Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Hello, good evening. I call this meeting of the South Portland City Council to order on Thursday, November 12. This is, in fact, a workshop, and we're going to get it started as we usually do. Please join me, if you wish to, for a Pledge of Allegiance to the United States of America.
[0:27] Speaker B (unidentified): I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you so much. Madam Clerk, can we have a roll call, please?
[0:49] Speaker C (unidentified): Counselor Scott? Here. Counselor Walker? Here. Counselor Coleman? Here. Counselor Matthews? Yes, ma'am. Counselor West? Here. Counselor Pride? Here. And Mayor Tipton.
[1:02] Speaker A (unidentified): We are going to have tonight a two-part meeting, the first being our mayoral caucus, and I think we need to do a few seat changes for that one. Looking for my official words, here are my official words. So I think the first thing is I need to call, or do we do our seat change so that I can, and call the caucus to order. Do we ask our councillor-elect to join us? Thank you, Mr. Scott Sr. Okay, excellent. Can we have councillor-elect Clancy join us? Voila. Scott has left a special seat for you. We don't want any misidentification to occur. So, welcome, councillor-elect Clancy. All right, now let us call the caucus to order. I don't think anything special is required other than my saying that, so let's commence with the business. A hand at hand, we're going to announce the nominations for mayor to serve us in the year 26, 27, and what we're doing tonight is voting on the council's nomination. And then when we seat our council for 26, 27, when we do that on December 7th at our inauguration, that begins at 4 p.m. We will then officially vote for that year's mayor. So without further ado, do we have any nominations for mayor for the year 26-27.
[2:54] Speaker D (unidentified): Councilor Walker. So, thank you. I want to be straight with this council and with the people of South Portland. I voted against Councilor Matthews the last time he ran for mayor. I'm not going to pretend otherwise, and I don't think he'd want me to. I'm nominating him tonight anyway, and I want to say why. I've spent the last two years serving alongside Councilor Matthews, and doing so has changed my mind. You'll learn a lot about someone in the two years of this work, and what I've seen and what I've come to know is that Councillor Matthews is a man dedicated to this city. He listens, he learns, and he can change his mind. Our city is growing and changing, and I believe he will be a mayor willing to grow and change with it. His agenda, with focus on air quality, facilities that best serve our city, and finding a balance for our property taxpayers, is one that I align with, and I'm eager to work on with him. We have a big year ahead. With air quality, six years of testing, 2,770 samples. Our October 27th meeting called it out plainly. Benzene is an issue. At Pearl Street, benzene ran nearly twice the state guideline, with homes sitting right up along the fence line. We need to be on the side of the people breathing this air. We need to take action, and we need to hold the operators to account. With facilities, the bond failed and the voters said no, but the need didn't go away. We need to come up with a solution that works for our public safety employees and our residents we can't lose sight of mahoney and taxes we need a local option tax we need a lodging tax we need the leaders in augusta to listen and counselor matthews has been working to build these relationships with those leaders for two years now budget season is coming and we have a cost problem not a spending problem and the tools to help are in augusta i trust that as mayor counselor matthews will work hard to engage, to listen, to learn, and to work, to lead with us on these and many more important issues. I nominate Councilor Matthews for Mayor, and I ask my colleagues to join me.
[4:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you for that nomination, Councilor Walker. Do we have a second of Councilor Walker's nomination?
[4:52] Speaker E (unidentified): Councilor Scott. I second the nomination. I don't have a speech prepared.
[4:57] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, well, then we'll take your second. At this time, I think we would like to hear from Councillor Matthews. Would you like to state your reasons for wanting to be mayor? Yes, Councillor West. Well, I was going to let Councillor Matthews make his case and then do that, but if somebody can, I'm free to be coached. Is it, if there's no other nomination, all right, do we have any other nominations? I do not. A Councillor West, I move the nominations be closed. All right, do we have a second for that? Councillor Scott. All right, so are we closing Nominations all in favor. Yes, we are closing nominations. And now Councillor Matthews, you have been nominated. Would you like to say a few words about whether and why you would like to be mayor next year? First of all, well, thank you, Jess.
[6:03] Speaker B (unidentified): Not often I get goosebumps, but thank you very much. Those were some very kind words, and I think that our relationship has certainly evolved, and I think that we have some great conversations. I will say that some things have changed over the year. It's been kind of a crazy year for us with ICE and the results of the air pollution quality of South Portland, and you know that's one of the things that people, you know, I would say do we have a problem, do we have a problem? Well, you know what, they proved me wrong, and I'm the first one to say that yeah, we have some certain problem areas in the city of South Portland, and that certainly moves to the forefront because I want the people of South Portland to be safe with the air quality, and you know there's a lot of people out there that claim to possibly have come down with cancer because of the oil tanks. And I am in no position to say whether or not my cancer was caused by air pollution, but it's certainly a possibility. And as a cancer survivor of South Portland and seeing the numbers that are quite staggering in a couple of areas, it certainly makes me more aware of the work that we have to do as a council, and that's one thing that I want everybody to know, that the mayor is just a ceremonial position. A council is only as good as everyone makes it together. You know, we may disagree on things, we you know not see eye to eye, but as long as you work good together and you communicate good together, that's what matters and the people of South Portland can see that, you know, they saw they disagreed on that, but it's okay because you know what, that's democracy. So I do appreciate the support, and I will be working hard with the experts. I'd like to build the relationship certainly with the terminal operators as far as the air quality of self-holding goes, but we also have to look at our facilities, we have to look at our tax problem, and you know Council West and myself have been working very hard over the last two years with the people of Augusta, and just the other day we had a meeting with the people of Augusta to come up with some ideas that could really help us. So we hope that moves forward. Correct? Yes, absolutely. So I do thank you. I'm not gonna ramble on, but I appreciate the support, and again, no I in
[8:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Team, thank you. Thank you very much, Counselor Matthews. Are there before we vote, are there, are there other councillors who would like to say anything?
[9:05] Speaker E (unidentified): Councillor Scott? I, again, didn't have a speech prepared, but I did want to reiterate, I think, Councillor Matthews' point that the mayor position is a ceremonial position. We each have a vote on the council, and I think to the extent that we can all work as a team is very important, and I appreciate your willingness to work with your councillors over the last year. And I think you, I know you, the current mayor is falling in your footsteps and you're falling in hers, and I 'm just looking forward to this next year.
[9:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you very much, councillor Scott. Any other councillors? Right. I will just say, councillor Matthews, I appreciate your willingness to serve us in our community in this way, and councillor Walker, you're right. We've got a lot to do next year here. Thank you. All right. All in favor?
[10:08] Speaker F (unidentified): Do I get to vote on this?
[10:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I think you...
[10:11] Speaker C (unidentified): Councillor Elect gets to vote.
[10:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Councillor Elect gets to vote. Sorry. We can both quack together as lame ducks.
[10:19] Speaker F (unidentified): I would vote for you.
[10:20] Speaker A (unidentified): That was a unanimous vote of the councillors and the councillor elect.
[10:27] Speaker C (unidentified): We just have to go over procedures for inauguration briefly.
[10:29] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, that's the second part of this discussion. Stay, hang in there, councillor-elect.
[10:37] Speaker C (unidentified): So just so that everyone on council is prepared for inauguration on December 7th. There are other actions that will follow once you have voted in the new mayor for 26, 27. The first being the traditional vote of councillor Walker for district 4 to spread the inauguration address on the record, which would require a second, so if anybody wanted to take that place now, that way everybody knows what they're doing on inauguration day, and then there'll be the motion to adjourn and second that as well, so there's three places for counselors to nominate themselves to fill in, so that way everybody has their place to be during inauguration day, and we're not wondering who's going to be second. I'd like counselor Clancy, council
[11:21] Speaker B (unidentified): elect Clancy to be part of the inauguration, so would
[11:26] Speaker C (unidentified): you like to second counselor Walker's motion, or would you like to motion for adjournment on December 7th? I would like to second it. Okay, I'm
[11:41] Speaker E (unidentified): having a motion for adjournment. If you're looking for volunteers, I'm
[11:46] Speaker C (unidentified): Surprised you want to second that. Sure. The only other thing that I did want to share with council for inauguration is that we do have a new photographer to do our council photo. They would like to have us do it earlier ahead of the inauguration. So if that's something that is okay, then I will preserve the space so you can do your photos before the inauguration. So that way you are welcome to depart after and go to any celebratory events. What time? I believe he is available as of 2 up until right before and it would only be about a minute and a half to do everybody's headshots so it's a quick
[12:28] Speaker A (unidentified): process. So maybe would it will he stay? He'll be there for the entire event but
[12:44] Speaker C (unidentified): including the school, correct? The photographer that we're going with is actually gonna do everybody individual and then put us all together so that we don't have poor lighting or issues that we've had in the past. Okay, so there won't be any group photo this time. So everybody will be individual and then he'll put us together as a council digitally just
[13:08] Speaker E (unidentified): because necessarily i would love for it to be as like 3 30 or closer to the four o'clock zone if that's perfect yeah i mean i 'll try as soon
[13:19] Speaker C (unidentified): as my meeting ends but and as I said he would be there the entire time so if we did need to catch
[13:23] Speaker B (unidentified): anybody after we could do that as well. Where is he taking the headshots at the at the up on the
[13:28] Speaker C (unidentified): stage or is he doing himself? We're gonna have a setup separate at the school. Okay so well
[13:33] Speaker B (unidentified): so during the if Misha didn't make it he had to pop out to do it during the start of
[13:41] Speaker C (unidentified): the school board inauguration, correct? Right, okay, if that works that works. Additionally we do have the school choir playing during the transition between city council and school board so there
[13:52] Speaker A (unidentified): will be some musical accompaniment and I know you've worked with our school partners to set that up so thank you. That sounds lovely. That is all that I had. All right, so we will plan all counselors who can to get there at 3 30. Got it, all right, and we've got you have everybody assigned in the roles that you need, Madam City Clerk? Yes ma'am. All right, well thank you so much. I think we'll move on to the next part of our meeting. I think we need to say goodbye to our counselor-elect at this point. Thank you. All right, well usually Scott kicks us off and says words like this: hey counselors, you've got a list of proposals you need to discuss and see if the counselor who is proposing this workshop will find another counselor Supporting the workshop, he says something like that anyway. So our first item is a workshop proposal for listing the main library on the inventory of archaeological and historical resources, and that is a request of the Historic Preservation Committee. And also just one more technical procedural item. Josh, you hadn't planned to come and sit here for this part, okay, just want to make sure.
[15:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you. All right, has that, yes, brought forward by HPC, and we do have someone here from HPC if you wanted to hear from them. I think we should think that makes
[15:26] Speaker G (unidentified): perfect sense. Good evening, mayor and members of the City Council. My name is Nicole Reagan. I'm here as the chair of HPC. As Mayor Tipton alluded to, we recently submitted a workshop request to explore adding the main branch of the South Portland Public Library to the city's inventory of historical and archeological resources. Built in 1965 and opened in December of 1966, the library represents an important chapter in South Portland's history. Its construction followed years of community efforts to establish a public library, and it has served residents continuously for nearly six years. Importantly, the building has a considerable architectural value. Designed by Maine architect John Leisure, it's an excellent example of the international style, a mid-century modern movement characterized by clean geometric forms, expansive glass walls, and an open interior. Leisure designed several notable buildings throughout Maine, including Franklin Towers, Cumberland County Jail, and Bramhall Fire Station. Interestingly, the South Portland Public Library was his first kind of big municipal project. Also, his son is a structural engineer who I believe lives but works here in South Portland, so still connected to that history. The library, the library building is remarkably unaltered, retaining much of its original design materials and architectural character, for better or worse. Its prominent location on Broadway and Cottage, alongside the Holy Cross Church, also creates a distinctive grouping of mid-century architecture, kind of right in the center of the east side of the city. Finally, the Maine Historic Preservation Commission determined in 2018 that the building is eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places. So the HBC believes the library is an important architectural landmark and a reflection of community's history. We believe that it deserves that consideration, and we hope the council will support scheduling a workshop to examine these aspects further.
[17:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you for being here. Councillors, I'm just going to note that we're going to need three councillors to support this workshop. But meanwhile, do we have any questions of our presenter? All right. all right well do we can do we have to move to support a workshop or just throw our hands up all right counselors all in favor of supporting the workshop i think we have more than three thank you very much in fact more than three equaled six counselors in support all right let us go to the next one this is a proposal from counselor scott can we hear from you counselor scott on this topic the review of council committees yes thank you i actually
[18:11] Speaker E (unidentified): hope that this might continue as sort of an annual or some sort of normally scheduled review, but I think it would be very helpful for the council to review the list of committees that we have, how they're structured, how they're supported, funded, etc. I know that we set up a new budgeting process last year, or I guess this year. And this is by no means to sort of check or try and kind of scrutinize the committee's work. It is because I think that we have so many committees, we have so many amazing volunteers and staff that support these committees. And I think it's really important for council to recognize that very formally. I know that we had a great event to kind of support the committee work that's gone on, but I think it's really helpful for council to understand the committee works that we have, you know, continue to support that, and sort of really understand what is working and not working in those committees, how it's structured. I think it should be something that the council is very much aware of. As a new counselor, I have tried very Hard to do that over the last year, but I think it should be something that's formally both recognized as a council and that we continue to think about that and improve on that process, you know, each year going forward. So not just in a single workshop, but I hope this might be the impetus for, you know, having a more formal review process and making, again, in the in the nature and spirit of supporting that committee work and all the volunteers that
[19:55] Speaker A (unidentified): are serving our community. So all right, well, thank you very much. Do we have another counselor in support of this workshop? Oh, it looks like we have two. I saw counselor Matthew's hand first and counselor West also supports. So and so does counselor Walker. Wow, I know that
[20:20] Speaker F (unidentified): there's some things pending out there ideas for example I saw a letter from the Historical Society asking that the South Portland Historical Society be removed from the historic preservation community and anything like that 's hanging out there it seems to be should be wrapped in this workshop and i also think it might be useful to ask all our committees if they have any suggested changes in their responsibilities charges memberships as part of the preparation for the workshop that it seems like we could include that if that would be acceptable to the count. Just at least three members of the council
[21:00] Speaker H (unidentified): So I think that's an excellent idea.
[21:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I'm just going to play out your idea a little bit. For example, if the clerk was in touch with each committee chair and asked them to plan to be part of the workshop and just sort of make comment.
[21:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, I don't know that we need to do that. But I know that we have the annual reports coming up soon and probably before the workshop. And it might be useful to ask as part of that annual. Because I periodically have members of these committees say, well, we should be doing this, we should be doing that, and I don't think there's a formal way for them to come forward with their suggestions of structural changes or changes and responsibilities. Madam Mayor? Yes. I'd like to ask that we do this as
[21:47] Speaker D (unidentified): Two separate things. One, the annual reports are important and they need to have kind of their own focus. And then second, I as a former committee member, it was intimidating to kind of feel called to come and stand before the dais and feel like you were having to defend your committee. And so I think it might be better if we do it on a more informal level where the clerk reaches out and if a committee wants to come forward and bring changes or suggestions for changes forward, then that would be the time for them to do it rather than say hey everyone needs to come and y'all need to come with ideas. It just might feel a little a little more
[22:28] Speaker H (unidentified): organic, a little less intimidating. For efficiency's sake, I would think that they could all give us written feedback first and then if during the workshop we decided any idea merited some discussion rather than just let's go ahead and do it, because half of these might be simple things that we're ready to say yes to after reading it in a paragraph and other things we might have questions about and we can always move to have another workshop on the same thing as the result of that workshop. That's great and call them and ask them to defend their idea if it needs defending or just answer a
[23:01] Speaker E (unidentified): question. Does that Oh councillor Scott, I just wanted to say very clearly that this is by no means a request for the committee's to kind of come forward with a report or a defense or anything by that means. I think it's, the idea is more about a little bit of a sort of council engagement and community engagement about what are the committees that are out there? How are they served? How do we as a council support those committees? Do they make sense? How are we sort of making sure that we're staying engaged and helping support the committee structure that we have set out? So I see it as much more and I'm happy to workshop some of the workshop ideas with folks about like what makes the most sense and I think maybe I'm happy to work with you Jessica about reaching out to committee chairs and members to see how they might like to engage in a workshop but it's it's really a matter of sort of making sure there is an education engagement from the Council and to the community to say, what are we, what do we have out there, who's serving on these community committees, what are they trying to do, and how do we best really support them? If that is the nature of my request, so I by no means, I'm asking for sort of reports or everyone to get up and give their five-minute speech or defense by me, so yeah, thank you so.
[24:34] Speaker A (unidentified): i usually at this point or actually during a real workshop but this is a workshop to discuss a workshop ask scott if he has what he needs in this case this is going to fall to you do you think you have what you need yes i have spoken with counselor west as
[24:51] Speaker C (unidentified): well as counselor scott about timing of this and i do believe it would be most fitting once we do have information from the committees and their annual reports to know what they are or have done this past year and then we also do have some ordinance updates and things that need to be addressed for our boards and committees that would coincide with this conversation and i've had informal conversations with most of our board and committee members so i do know that there's going to be a couple That are going to want to attend just to understand what the council is going to be discussing, so I can certainly extend that invitation as well. All right, as usual.
[25:22] Speaker A (unidentified): On top of it, thank you very much. All right, counselors, I think we can move to the third workshop request, which is, what is it? Oh, it's, it's actually more than just one third. Okay, I think all of this is an advisory, I don't think there's action here. Yes, it's just an advisory of what is ahead. All right, well we know that the agenda has been set and published for next week, the 17th. We know that on December 1st we already have a scheduled workshop which is a sort of part two on our tank emissions discussion. And so it will fall to the next mayor to schedule these two workshops that we have just discussed. Madam Mayor, I also.
[26:19] Speaker B (unidentified): You know, depending on the outcome come of the workshop on the first, you know, we may have to schedule another workshop there too on that one, so I just want to make sure that we're aware when we're scheduling these workshops that the workshop is more important than the other, but this particular one, depending on, you know, what our findings are on the workshop that you're bringing forward, we.
[26:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Could have another workshop relatively quickly to show, okay, just and for clarity I think it was the decision of council to have that workshop, but it will, I'll get to chair it and that will be my last meeting as mayor, so all right, anything else, I think we're good, sorry, do you
[27:11] Speaker E (unidentified): want to just clarify maybe for everybody like the december 1st workshop and what the subject that 's air if i'm correct that 's air quality the next air quality workshop i feel like there are a lot of like next workshop discussions december 1st but might be helpful for the public to clarify that is the workshop we're talking about it is the workshop we're
[27:32] Speaker A (unidentified): talking about, it has been described only as, hold on for one second, the topic, We will discuss different topics related to the city's ability to have an impact on tank emissions, to the state legislature's ability to do the same, ideas and actions that the council will recommend on December 1st. And yeah, I think that is all we can say about that, except to say that I did just talk with email with the city manager today to say that to the extent possible we will have a fuller description of that workshop available to the public, and that will be useful, anyway there's a profundity if I ever heard one, all right are we ready to adjourn, do we, do we don't, it's not on the agenda, we don't do a round robin as part of this, we simply say sayonara, so may we have a motion to adjourn from counselor Walker, seconded counselor Pride, all in favor, thank you very much counselors, we are adjourned and we've done it