← Back to MaineScanner

South Portland Council Approves Zoning Change and Food Waste Program

2026-11-05 · 3h 22m · Source: spcc_20261105 - South Portland City Council - November 5 2026 (City of South Portland (SPC-TV Vimeo))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Good evening. Let's call this meeting of the South Portland City Council to order on Thursday, November 5th. Please join me if you would like to for the Pledge of Allegiance to the Republic that is the United States of America. [0:23] Speaker B (unidentified): I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:39] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Madam Clerk, may we have a roll call? [0:43] Speaker C (unidentified): Councillor Scott? Yes. Councillor Walker? Here. Councillor Coleman? Here. Councillor Matthews? Yes, ma'am. Councillor West? Here. Councillor Pride? Here. [0:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Mayor Tipton? I am here. Here. If there are no additions or corrections to the minutes of our last meeting, I am going to accept those by unanimous consent. Oh, okay. That was a thumbs up. All right. So those are accepted. Thank you very much. Let's move to petitions and communications. [1:16] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you. This is just to share the city's results from the elections that have been posted on the website and then to share for Councillor-elect Scott Tipton and Clancy will be joining us at the mayoral caucus next week and then we will have our inauguration for those councillors on December 7th at 4 p.m. and my school for the overall election participation we had 71.4 7% of our enrollment and registered voters come out and vote in the state election and we dipped a little bit below that with I believe 65% of that farm municipal ballots but still [2:01] Speaker A (unidentified): A fantastic turnout for midterm. Yeah, I know there's no clapping but maybe we do little, we'll do jazz hands to the clerk, to the clerk and all of the election workers. Thank you so much. I don't know if people think about this when you come in to vote, not only was it a smooth process for our voters but those folks are up at dawn and they are there till quite late. Our city staff also has to set up machinery, has to come and take down machinery. It's it's a big deal so we're extremely grateful to you and i just wanted to personally offer congratulations to councilor-elect scott who i don't know if you call you elect you're elect for the next council but you are also counselor scott and also to official counselor elect clancy and i will say that i am very pleased that i'm going to be continuing on this council as well so thank you to everyone who ran we had quite a few candidates we had school board candidates we had other city council candidate and everyone who ran thank you so much, Everyone who voted. Thank you so much, Democracy in Action, yay. All right, I think we can move. We will, if we have no objection, we're gonna postpone the appointment calendar to our next meeting, which is coming up on the 16th of this month, thank you. Now we need to hear the rules for public comment. [3:39] Speaker C (unidentified): Members of the public will be given up to three minutes to speak on any topic on or off the agenda during citizen discussion part one. Members of the public who speak on an agenda item will not be able to speak on that item again during at the time. Members who spoke during citizen discussion part one will not be able to speak during citizen discussion part two, and we ask everyone to state their name [4:01] Speaker A (unidentified): and address for the record. Okay, thank you. Do we, I think you can definitely state your name and you can say your street, you don't actually have to state your whole address, so there we are with that. Can you please read us our consent calendar items [4:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Madam City, we have one item this evening and that's order 66 26 27 authorizing the city manager to accept 23 160 of highway safety grant funds to be used by the police department. Pass requires a majority vote. Any [4:36] Speaker A (unidentified): counselor want to remove that item from the consent calendar. [4:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Can I just ask why I'm seeing a proclamation on mine? Or did I log into the meeting wrong? Yeah, there are two items. I'm sorry, I didn't know that. I am seeing that. [4:57] Speaker C (unidentified): It's not on our print agenda, though. Well, that's what I was reading. [5:01] Speaker E (unidentified): I also have it on the website version. Okay. [5:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, yes, we do have that other item. [5:15] Speaker C (unidentified): That's what I was reading from the paper, so let me get to the computer. Thank you so much. You're welcome. The other item that we have on the consent calendar is a proclamation for the Extra Mile Day which was November 1st, but we did wanted to recognize that this evening. Okay [5:37] Speaker A (unidentified): so that is on the consent calendar, so would that anyone want to remove that item or remove the other item from the consent calendar? Okay, all right, well then I think we can open up our public comment at this point. Four items on the consent calendar. Anyone? It does, no, yep, yes. [6:08] Speaker F (unidentified): Is this the first one with the? [6:11] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not, it's the first one for those two items. Yes. 2627. You are correct, the Highway Safety Grant Fund. [6:28] Speaker F (unidentified): Jack Raposa, Walnut Street. The council's being asked to accept a grant from the Maine Bureau of Public Safety for $23,160. I'm all in with accepting the grant money for our city, but the subgrant contract requires the subgrantee, who is the city or the police department, to provide matching funds. I'd like to know where those matching funds are coming from. [6:57] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, hang on. Anyone else want to comment on either of these two items? Does it look that way? We're going to close public comment on the consent calendar. Mr. City Manager, can you answer that question? [7:12] Speaker G (unidentified): So the matching grants come from the existing budget? I don't know if, Chief, you want to add anything in addition to that? [7:22] Speaker B (unidentified): Dan Heron, Police Chief. Matching funds are no longer required for these grants. [7:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Aha. So that means that it's somewhere where Mr. Raposa would have read this. That's outdated information? [7:36] Speaker B (unidentified): They are no longer required. [7:38] Speaker H (unidentified): Oh, okay. I don't know where it's got that information. All right. [7:42] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I mean, it says in the document we're required to provide the matching contribution as provided in the application, but so I don't know if they're saying there's no match required, but there's... [7:56] Speaker F (unidentified): As of this year's ordinance. [8:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Well, it was a good question to ask. Doesn't sound like they maybe have updated their information as clearly as they could. Yep, so we'll [8:09] Speaker B (unidentified): have to make that change. It's just not updated, and this year we don't need to make that match. [8:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, we didn't have anything else. We closed public comment. Counselors, are we adopting the consent calendar by unanimous consent or...? All right, we're voting, and it looks like everyone is in favor. Let's have somebody actually move to adopt it. [8:37] Speaker D (unidentified): I move that we adopt the consent calendar. [8:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone want to second it? Counselor Scott. Yay. Did you want to say anything? We usually do not. Okay. Now, all in favor? We've got a unanimous vote for the consent calendar. Life is good. Let's move to citizen discussion part one. Thank you very much. Anyone on any topic, please come forward if you would like to make public comment. [9:10] Speaker I (unidentified): Good evening. Mary Ann Brown, Preble Street. I first of all want to start out with giving kudos to our library, who does amazing workshops. And I was at one last week about DIY beeswax wraps. I'm leading in, I'm leading in to a little bit about recycling and our pay to throw and composting and all of that. Eco Maine did this workshop, and it was amazing. I learned not only how to make a beeswax wrap, I went home and made a bread bag out of beeswax. Beeswax is amazing because it's antibacterial, it's antifungal, and it breathes. And if you put those famous little bagels in there, they're going to last you for more than one day. So that was really a big plus for me. But the other big plus for me was this nice little magnet that they gave us that says do recycle don't recycle. And I'm wondering why, and this is my question, why does not every household in this city have one of these to go on their refrigerator? I can't tell you how often I peek at it just because I just want to be sure that I'm recycling the right things. And years ago I got this little thing from garbage to garden. I love this little thing. It's been pinned to my bulletin board for 12 years, maybe 13 maybe even 14 and what I can chuck and what I can't chuck and that's what I really believe that the people of South Portland really need first of all you need to look at can I chuck it so if you can chuck it goes in your compost if you can't chuck it then can it be recycled, and if it can't be recycled, then it has to go into your trash. I think this is the biggest thing that we need to do is education,, and you can't do it just once. You got to kind of keep at it. You got to do it over and over again. I've taught school from seventh grade right up through adult ed and a little bit of college. And you know what? I had to repeat things many times. And so this is really what I'm saying, and I think I mentioned this before when I spoke a while back, is that it has to be about education. And so the other thing that I learned while I was there is that it costs about $35,000 to do that big lineup at the transfer station. [12:21] Speaker A (unidentified): One sentence? One sentence. [12:25] Speaker I (unidentified): Did you know that paint cans can go to any paint store? Yes. I did not. Okay. [12:34] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Thank you so much for your comment. And are there more? Any more public comments on any items? [12:43] Speaker J (unidentified): Come on down. [12:48] Speaker K (unidentified): Hello. Dave Hebert. Live on [street]. And this is prep for December 1st. This is a post I just made, and it's a thought, maybe get you thinking. And it came about because I've been monitoring out reviewing VOC site locations, and they're not good. So here's the title: is this a fear and measurable way to get oil tank companies to help us with SOPO's tax burden? The problem. The city would like to use any available land to create tax income for new homes and developments. However, many residents feel the DEP is doing a poor job of selecting sites that can fairly and accurately represent all the homes in the city. They feel there's only one sure way to do it, and it's to create distance between the tanks and people's homes. What about the homes that are there already that are closed? So here's my proposed solution. If we develop zoning that prohibited new buildings within 1,000 feet of bulk patrol storage tank, the city would lose potential tax revenue. However, wouldn't it be fair to place that financial burden, whether it be a tax or a fee, on the owners of the tanks rather than on the residents because you can't use that land because they're going over their boundary. We could also offer the terminal owners an alternative. If they choose, they could sign an agreement committing to modify their tanks using the best available controls with a good faith effort to achieve zero emissions. We could use the lower Massachusetts allowable ambient limit for benzene, which is one-tenth of what we have, as the standard for that terminal. If a terminal owner chooses this option, it could exempt them from the additional financial burden while allowing the city to pursue development in these currently problematic areas. It sounds like a win-win to me. So I asked between now and December 1st, please don't change any zoning within 1,000 feet of any emissions tanks because it's going to take out the potential to come up with creative solutions such as this. This is just a seed. The other thing was I sent all of you a photo. One of them shows why fence line testing can only show danger and not safety. The picture shows the monitor down here, 150 feet away, it shows the tank vent up there. Emissions can flow over the monitors. I talked to the EPA, I said they can easily flow, they never denied it. Talked to the DEP, they never denied it. Denied it. [16:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you very much. [16:03] Speaker L (unidentified): All right. Maybe just one more. Jeff Steinbrink, College Road. So I have a sublime and ridiculous of the sublime the mayor has already anticipated just to say thanks from all of us. I think I can speak for all of us for all of us for to the city clerk's office especially, and all the people who helped make this last election the standard that it was. I spent a certain amount of anxiety at this podium in anticipation of this election, and so it seems to me that I ought to be here to say, isn't that a relief and isn't that wonderful that it went the way that it did? I've also said before at this podium, we are all immigrants. And I realize, I think anyway, that one of the primary purposes of making people anxious about this election was to keep people from, and maybe people who are more recently immigrated than say I am, from feeling comfortable going to the polls. I think we should all, I hope we can all take from this experience some degree of confidence and security that our elections are indeed the way they ought to be. So again, thank you. The ridiculous thing has to do with something that may just apply to me, that I tried in doing my homework for tonight's evening. I tried to get behind the agenda. It was online through the diligent operation. And it required, for the first time as far as I'm aware, that I actually sign in with an email address and a password. And when I did that anyway, it just took me through a cycle of emailing and passwording that it wasn't satisfied with. And so I was never able to get to the meat of the order. So I may be extraordinary in that, and I just did something incompetent, but to the extent that other people's experience might be shared with mine, that's an unfortunate thing because you can't see behind the curtain. Okay, thank you. [18:10] Speaker M (unidentified): Hello, James Avalos, Maplewood Ave. So this afternoon, I was reading email sent by the Public Safety Building Committee, and it was commenting on the vote, successful 71% turnout, and the bond referendum was defeated pretty soundly, 60 to 30-something percent. So, reading that, I just wondered, why is there no talk about alternative funding, like state? I leave out federal, but I think it should be forthcoming from the state to be helping with emergency infrastructure for a major city like South Portland. And I'm just a little surprised that there hasn't been any discussion that I've seen about alternative funding. It's all tax to residents and that seems unusual. So I voted no for this referendum not because I'm against police officers and firefighters, but I'm against taxes being doubled and then raised and raised and raised. I was trying to make sense of budget, looking at the last year's budget, it's 152 pages. So there's a lot of questions and kind of like missing information as what work has been done getting state funding. So, yeah, honestly, I was thinking I would have been more likely to vote yes if I knew that $88 million was going to a one-time raise for all public workers, teachers, emergency workers. I would have voted yes for a one-time bonus, but not for buildings. You know, I think it would be more effective raising people's salaries rather than just building new buildings. I realize these buildings are out of code. I mean, they're out of date, but they've been neglected for a long time. And that makes it all the more unusual. It's been, I don't know how many years, 10 years. That's a lot of time to talk with state representatives. That's a lot of time to get action from the state. So that's I just wanted to bring that up and I'm hoping there will be more discussion about that and more talk about what's being done along those lines. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anyone else for public [20:58] Speaker A (unidentified): comment? All right, we're going to close public comment. We do answer questions. Generally I'm wondering if it would make more sense though on the questions of whether people can have magnets and for education about recycling, if we can just wrap that up with the presentation that will the discussion we're going to have. Sure. Okay. Did you did you did you hear other questions? What would you get I [21:32] Speaker N (unidentified): didn't hear another question. Well about the public safety had that been explored? Oh yeah there really [21:39] Speaker G (unidentified): aren't state funds for municipal building projects. They administer typically they're a pass-through for federal funding or they're said funding, but there's really not a state program that gives money for towns and cities to build police and fire stations. Unfortunately there's FEMA grants, there's rural development grants which we don't qualify because we're not a rural community, and again those are kind of through the federal government. We have looked at congressionally designated spending seds Funds for like our Pearl Street project, for example, ask for other federal grants through our federal delegation over the past three or four years for different projects. Unfortunately, you know, the dredge project in the harbor, we've never been successful, in part because we are a large community with a large tax base, large value. We're not a poorer community like you might have seen some of the federal grants that have gone to fire stations in, you know, Buxton or other places that just don't have the population bases us. So it's a, it's a, it's a great idea. Unfortunately, there's just not really programs out there where the state gives money to municipalities to build anything other than really schools. [22:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, thank you for that, Scott. Do you mind if we just acknowledge that things will be changing in Washington and potentially at some point congressionally directed funding might smile at South Portland? But what you were saying about us being a larger municipality with the perception that we don't need as much help is very true. [23:22] Speaker E (unidentified): Alright, any other questions? I heard one about getting into the agenda. Yes, Diligent platform for residents shouldn't require a sign-in, correct? Correct. And I can't get into it tonight, so I don't know if there's an issue with Diligent itself, maybe today. [23:41] Speaker N (unidentified): But I got in easily through Agenda, through the city website where it says Agenda, and then the calendar comes out, and you can choose all of the meetings, and that's how I got in. [23:54] Speaker C (unidentified): It is. If you do end up on the Diligent website, there is a sign-in option. So if the URL does have that defaulted, you will get prompted to enter an email and it will cycle because you're not an authorized user on it. So if you ever have any issues, you can always go back to the city's website and navigate to the agenda and then it'll bring you right to the public site. [24:15] Speaker B (unidentified): Can I just ask Jeff one quick question? You were going through the regular set that we would normally go through, correct? Yes, sir. Okay, that's what I just want to make sure, because I couldn't either. [24:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Sounds like there's some glitchiness out on the Diligent. They're not being diligent. [24:31] Speaker N (unidentified): Yeah, because Alice had posted it in Diligent, I couldn't get in. [24:35] Speaker C (unidentified): Alright, well. [24:37] Speaker A (unidentified): We've had a community discussion on how to break into the agenda this evening. I think though that we can, where are we, you answered questions, we're moving on to public hearings in action. Can we get a reading of the ordinance, please, so [24:58] Speaker C (unidentified): Ordinance number 9 26 27 amending chapter 27 zoning regarding a zone map amendment to extend the limited business LB zoning district first reading pass on October 27th passage requires five affirmative votes and [25:12] Speaker A (unidentified): this will be a roll call vote thank you very much Scott did you want to say anything [25:18] Speaker G (unidentified): Summation of where we're at so the council obviously as a clerk had read had approved the first reading of this last week and so is now in order for the second read I know there's been some comments questions concerns raised by the public so if there's a different route the council wants to go obviously our planning director is here can answer questions and discuss any sort of possible amendments otherwise the ordinance is in order for passage and happy to answer any questions Mom did you want to present [25:57] Speaker D (unidentified): something now okay [26:03] Speaker A (unidentified): I would just add the reminder that this started with trying to help a business owner who is in an unusual situation so the only thing I [26:22] Speaker H (unidentified): will add and it's it's actually not part of this agenda but it's related and council was asked when we presented the rollout the two-year rollout for the comprehensive plan whether you were comfortable with us coming in with a quick interim ordinance to remove some of the very obviously inconsistent land uses under our existing zoning districts that happen to sit squarely within areas that we want to do something different with so for example industrial uses that might sit within what we call today in our comp plan our downtown neighborhood area if we're allowing heavy industry there if they happen to come in over the course of the next two years they're there for a very long time and we've got this new vision so council gave us the go ahead to come to you with an updated ordinance just to clean up the very obvious inconsistencies you should be the easy ones and we're not going to get into stuff that's sort of you know fuzzy so we're trying to give you that ordinance that is due to go to the planning board on the 18th of this month and then would come to the council immediately after that I bring it up here because the LB zone is one of those zones that sits along all of our corridors and a comp plan asks for neighborhood mixed use walkable type environments there so there are some land uses in the LB zone which we are cleaning up as part of that ordinance a couple of those have been brought up as examples of why this might be a challenging thing to bring into the cottage zone so even though it's not part of this package i think it's important for you to know that there's an opportunity here to look at the lb zones list of uses and you'll have that opportunity to clean that up come december you know so it's pretty short order here i still you know stand by where we left with the memo that the proposal is consistent with the comprehensive plan as is even with the uses that are in there but you will be making it even more benign or have an opportunity to make it even more benign within about a month so there are kind of two components to this but tonight you are just looking at the lb zone as it is unaffected on an additional 12 parcels i thought it was 11. [28:25] Speaker A (unidentified): it's now 12. okay whatever all very well thank you i'm not all right i'm understanding are you [28:32] Speaker N (unidentified): talking about not including the after the curve addition i think it's a different difference different zone okay because ld is limited business right it's a different issue [28:47] Speaker A (unidentified): so if any so counselors i think i'd love to know if you have questions for milan at this point No question? Okay. I don't. All right. There seems to be a... You guys are good? All right. Questions over here? Because it's extended. Okay. Then let's open this up for public comment. Do we have public comment on this agenda item? [29:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Jack Raposo, Walnut Street. zoning map amended amendment to change 11 properties on the south side of Cottage Road from residential aid to limited business I didn't give this a lot of thought during the first reading then I got more information recently I do remember consulate Matthews making a comment that he liked coffee before the [Speaker O (unidentified): vote so] now I have a few questions number one where any of the residents in these homes consulted before counselor scott brought this forward to the council number two if this change is for a coffee shop and what in what address would it be located because it doesn't look to me that any of the homes we are talking about would entertain a coffee shop except the address at 535 Cottage Road where Starboard and Company is located, which if it is, it should already be designated as LB. And if it's not, then I'm just wondering what Starboard and Company, a business, is doing in that building. Number three, this building is directly next to Rosemont Market. And why can't it be designated as LB and leave the rest of the properties as Residential A. Rosemont Market is the first building in Cape Elizabeth. So those are my questions, and that's all I have right now. [31:15] Speaker J (unidentified): I just want to say something. Georgia, DeVaris, Victory Avenue. I think there are two different things being talked about here. isn't wasn't what Milan was discussing about the ordinance about setbacks or front yards no that's later that's later that's later I couldn't would you mind repeating I couldn't hear and I can't see so I don't know if I'm here to talk about the right thing the first item under [31:46] Speaker A (unidentified): public hearings in action ordinance number 9 26 27 that's the amendment or that's the zoning amendment ordinance and I know for a fact you're familiar with it because you have to address this council before about this one so we're [32:03] Speaker J (unidentified): commenting on the ordinance before yeah it so we hear what it's gonna be we [32:14] Speaker D (unidentified): already heard it last meeting there was no presentation this is just the lb the 11 properties [32:20] Speaker P (unidentified): on cottage road just that specific amendment the ones you're concerned with all right everybody [32:27] Speaker A (unidentified): stop i'm so confused okay so i'm just gonna i'm just gonna roll the tape back a little bit when last we spoke october 27 at the high school there was a presentation of what the changes are the council voted unanimously the first read of this ordinance now we're back it's the second read the council didn't really have questions so the next part in our process is you ask the public if the public has comments so that's where we're at [33:06] Speaker J (unidentified): i'm sorry i thought there were going to be changes to this and then we there [33:10] Speaker A (unidentified): could be mr barris we if we're going to do that 's when it gets to council discussion so we haven't quite gotten there we closed the public comment first so it if there's a [Speaker J (unidentified): two-sentence comment yes] yes because you did not exceed your time [33:33] Speaker J (unidentified): Georgia Tavares, Victory Avenue. It's my understanding that there is an amendment for zoning change that will just apply to the half of the building in South Portland that would then join the village commercial area of Cape Elizabeth and that the rest of the beloved residential neighborhood on Cottage Road would remain a protected residential zone. So I'm hoping that's what's happening, and I would thank you very much for that. [34:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have other members of the public commenting on this ordinance? And I will just say that at this point, the ordinance we're discussing is for 11 properties, and that's what is before you at this moment. [34:28] Speaker L (unidentified): Councilors, Jeff Steinbrink, Cottage Road, having heard and knowing only what I know from the public record and where we are right now, I would want fervently to reinforce what Mr. Raposa has said. Everything he said I would say too, and the questions he asked I would ask too. Okay. Anyone else? [34:52] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. It looks like we can close comment on this item, counselors questions. Oh, I'm sorry, there were [35:00] Speaker G (unidentified): questions three from Mr. Raposo. First one for Counselor Scott, did you talk to any residents [35:06] Speaker Q (unidentified): before you submitted this workshop request? I believe I submitted this workshop request in July [35:14] Speaker P (unidentified): of this year and I did not talk to residents beforehand. I have spoken with many residents [35:19] Speaker G (unidentified): since then and I don't know the exact address I'm on, I might need your help with this one. What's the address that of the proposed coffee shop? 535. Thank you. And why can't it just be converted to LB and keep the others as residential? I [35:40] Speaker P (unidentified): don't know if that's a Brandon. Yeah, I'm more than happy to know, you hold your [35:47] Speaker A (unidentified): thought for one second. So the city manager is asking Brandon to address it. Is that, I know there [35:54] Speaker G (unidentified): was initial talk of that could be considered spot zoning, so and I know you've looked into this a [35:59] Speaker R (unidentified): little further, so yeah. Thank you. So I'll do a high level and we, if there are additional questions during council. So this could be looked at as spot zoning, but I think it's important to note if it was just that lot, there's sort of two things, there's spot zoning and then there's illegal spot zoning. A spot zone is not necessarily illegal so long as it still meets the comprehensive plan and the uses and we, I think that is part of the discussion that needs to happen tonight if the recommendation from the planning board is amended that [36:45] Speaker A (unidentified): that's very brief but yes that's good you're here if there's further questions all right now is the time on our show that I say what is the will of the council councillor Scott I move for passage thank you is there a second councillor Matthews wait before we vote well we will have discussion so I'm gonna ask councillor Scott first to be first in our discussion as is our [37:17] Speaker P (unidentified): tradition since she moved for passage. I'm happy to discuss this, I also have a motion to amend. Okay, so I'm happy to discuss this. All right, move directly to [37:31] Speaker A (unidentified): to my amendment. Why don't you make your motion to amend and then if we need questions answered from Brandon or anyone else, that will happen. Okay. What is your motion to amend? [37:41] Speaker P (unidentified): I move to amend the recommended properties that the planning board has brought to us to just have the LB change to, I think, 535 and 531, one which are the two properties adjacent to the Cape Elizabeth line included in this zone amendment for the LB zone. Okay, so can we just say you are moving to remove [38:14] Speaker A (unidentified): any property but that property from this. Yes, eleven one and eleven two, eleven three through [38:22] Speaker P (unidentified): 11 42 would not be included in the lb zone amendment change okay and counselor matthews [38:29] Speaker A (unidentified): you're seconding the amendment to remove the other property correct okay do any counselors have questions for brandon as to whether we can do that yes sorry can i comment on my [38:49] Speaker P (unidentified): So I have looked into this a great deal. I've had many conversations since submitting my workshop. And I think that this is, I know there have been concerns about spot zoning. I think that there is not a concern about spot zoning with this parcel. Now I've included two parcels with conversations with the owners of these parcels, that these is congruent with adjacent land uses in Cape Elizabeth even though it's not in South Portland, and I think that it is not a substantial change. It is a change from what the planning board brought forward to the council, but it is a reduction and a small portion of what they have proposed that we are moving forward with. So I do not have concerns about either spot zoning or this being a substantial change that would need to go back to the planning board. I think that this is a hopefully thoughtful and surgical approach to a zoning change which allows a business owner to proceed with a business proposition in South Portland which we should all support, and I do hope that it supports some of the residents concern around changes so that is sort of why I am presenting that amendment to the motion this evening. [40:15] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you did you want to add anything counselor Matthew I just want to thank Council Scott for [40:20] Speaker B (unidentified): doing her due diligence homework and talking with the owners of 531 and 535, and she [40:29] Speaker A (unidentified): worked all week hard on it and good job. All right, thank you so much. We're about to vote on the amendment. Is there anything else we need to hear from our council? The only thing that [40:42] Speaker R (unidentified): I'm just thinking of now that I is because of the amendment, I just want to be clear that this would be the new first read. Yes, okay. [40:56] Speaker A (unidentified): counselor west yeah can i [41:04] Speaker S (unidentified): ask my colleague if she's discussed the time frame with the applicants and how they what their time [41:14] Speaker P (unidentified): I did and let me clarify that if this is a first read what would be the opportunity for a second [41:22] Speaker G (unidentified): read so this would go back to the planning board because council's made a substantive change [41:27] Speaker P (unidentified): Excuse me, this would go back to a first read as the city council, not back to the planning board. [41:38] Speaker G (unidentified): And then back to the no, tonight would be the, it would, it reverts to a new first read because if you amended, it's now considered a first read, so you're you're you're back to that, but because you amended it, the planning board has to still see the amendments and [41:57] Speaker Q (unidentified): so it goes back to them. A lot of head shaking over here. It doesn't, sorry, I, that is [42:02] Speaker P (unidentified): one of the biggest things that I want to clarify is that I've never not done that first. I [42:08] Speaker R (unidentified): So, I looked at the, and I know I'm probably taking a more narrow approach, but we have done it in a couple cases since I've been on where it has not had to go back to the planning board. [42:21] Speaker G (unidentified): The recommendation came. For substantive? [42:23] Speaker R (unidentified): There's no definition of substantive that I could find. So, what is substantive is up for debate. The point of having the planning board review a amendment is partly to let those property owners be heard and have a public notice. The council amendment tonight is not asking for 12 more parcels to be included. It's going from 11 or 12 down to two. So that public hearing has occurred, those property owners have had an opportunity at the planning boy public hearing. I am, if the will of the council is to send it back, that is fine, but I could not find any guidance in any of what was a substantive change to a recommendation as long as it's still presumably this council should find that it still meets the comprehensive plan, so if 11 parcels did do two, if you want, it's perfectly fine to send it back to the to the planning board for their recommendation if that's the will of the council, but I don't think it is necessary. What I was clarifying was because it's being amended after the first read has already occurred, it changed, that turns this into the first read, so it would have to come back for a second read at the next business meeting, the 16th, the 17th, oh the 17th, excuse me, oh it [43:57] Speaker G (unidentified): can come back a week, it doesn't have to be advertised for seven days, there's should be enough time. We've never approved a first and second rate, you've always said that we have to [44:08] Speaker C (unidentified): wait two weeks in between, we have veterans week in between, so we have the full week, we have a meeting [44:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Oh, I got you. Our business meeting is next week. [44:15] Speaker C (unidentified): Business meeting is the 17th, so we have a seven-day buffer. We're good. [44:18] Speaker G (unidentified): We're good. So the 17th, yeah. Okay. Councilor West. [44:23] Speaker S (unidentified): Councilor West. Since we're on this subject, and we might as well kind of air this and get all these things out in public, what is the authority that you cannot amend an ordinance at second read and proceed to adopt it? And if it's too hard to deal with that tonight, and I really would appreciate some kind of something in writing from the council at some later date. [44:43] Speaker R (unidentified): Let's do that. I think part of his past practice that was passed on to me, but I can look into the charter and the council rules. [44:50] Speaker S (unidentified): Well, I think we're very fortunate to have a corporate council who does a lot of analysis. And I have had a hard time following that position for quite a while. Understood. Any [45:04] Speaker P (unidentified): other councillors? I just wanted to explain my sort of thought and reason here is that we are moving forward with a smaller version of what is before us and I appreciate there are a lot of different opinions on this but I see this as a recommendation on a portion of what is before us not a change to what is before us and I think it is appropriate although I appreciate having an opinion and another kind of bite at the apple if we do we need to move this into another meeting that is my sort of understanding of what I'm trying to propose in this second read but wanting to move this forward that's helpful okay [45:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Understood other counselors with any comments on [46:00] Speaker S (unidentified): the amendment I don't yes I'll just say that I support council's counselor Scott on this it's we're leaving the status quo except for the one parcel so I don't see any need at all for it to go back to the planning board I don't even see any need for it to have a new first reading [46:22] Speaker P (unidentified): but that's a whole nother topic I would like to get some clarity on that if that's possible to like vote on this pending an opinion or what we do there okay so but our [46:38] Speaker A (unidentified): understanding this evening is if we vote for the amendment that turns this into the first read of this ordinance we can schedule the second read on the 17th this will not go back to the planning board review because it's not considered a substantive change so if we all understand that are we ready to vote on the amendment yes counselor West I mean it's counselor Matthew I just want to [47:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Make sure that we're sure because it could really throw a wrench. Correct is probably what I'm gathering. I want to make sure that we're okay with this being the first read, the next read on the 17th, that we're not gonna in the middle find out later on Milan's gonna come up with something or somebody's gonna come up with something and say oh, because then it sets it way back. So I just want to make sure that Brandon is clear that we're okay. You've told us we're okay and I don't, I don't want any curveballs thrown. Just to clarify, you're [47:50] Speaker R (unidentified): okay with it not, are you asking about the first read, this being the first year, you're asking does this have to go back to the planning board? It doesn't have to go back to the plan in my opinion. [47:59] Speaker B (unidentified): It does not have to go back to the planning board. I just want to make sure that we're 100 [48:02] Speaker P (unidentified): clear on that so this is putting it back to the first read and that's the piece that this would be a second read final i 'm i'm fine with that i had not considered that but i'm fine with [48:16] Speaker A (unidentified): all right. It feels like we're ready to vote on this amendment. All in favor, it's a unanimous vote of the council for the amendment. Do we have a motion for passage of the ordinance? Oh we did have, that's right. All right, did you have anything further to say about the ordinance itself? No thank you. I believe it was seconded. No, are any other counselors [48:45] Speaker R (unidentified): corporation council just quickly, I'm reading in the chart and just for this council to take up if they want to, so section 222 of the charter talks about the passage procedure for passage of ordinances, first reading, emergency ordinances. I don't think this would rise to the level of an emergency and this does not give me clarity on where this process came from. So I'm talking a little bit on the fly but you could try to, would need to do the preamble but if you felt as though it was because of a timing issue an emergency, I think that's a bigger stretch than the ice ordinance but there is that procedure there. I'm just trying
New Business
[49:31] Speaker A (unidentified): to make sure the council has all of its information. Thank you for your thoroughness. Okay yes, I think the opening of a coffee shop compared to the ice ordinance is probably not going to fly. All right counselors, all in favor, we're voting yes. Oh wait, did you have something? We're all in favor of this new first reading. Yes exactly, we are voting on the first read of an ordinance that's become increasingly familiar and examined to us. All in favor, a unanimous first read vote of the council. Thank you. Okay, I think we're moving to action on old and new business. Could you please read order number 56. [50:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Order 56 26 27 adopting a city curbside food waste collection section service postponed from October 13th, 26th. Passage will require a majority vote. [50:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Did you want to preamble or are we rolling straight into our sustainability director? We can roll to our sustainability director, Julie Rosenbach. [50:38] Speaker G (unidentified): May have seen her a few times on this topic. [51:31] Speaker P (unidentified): It needs pardon me it needs time how apropos [51:41] Speaker R (unidentified): can i yeah while they're trying to get set up raise a point of order when reading the charter you passed it you could take a reconsideration if you wanted section 224 of the charter you can just further consideration final passage after such public hearing and second reading the council may finally pass such ordinance in the same form as originally presented at the first reading that's where i think that's where that comes from comma or by motion amend the same and finally pass it in such amended form without the necessity of further hearings or readings so and I wasn't sort of ready for that question so I was trying to read it quickly I think if you wanted to you could potentially reconsider that a second read reconsider the vote you just and make it a final vote this evening yep okay sorry to throw that curve [52:40] Speaker A (unidentified): We're just having some council fun here let's just tell him he hit a home run yes somehow there was a there was a baseball analogy working but I think we messed it up long ago all right so and that was a curveball actually ha hang on your presentation is warming up for us okay so I'm not sure how at this point you go backwards do you suspend Ben, do you... Okay, move for reconsideration. [53:14] Speaker P (unidentified): I would move for passage of the amended zoning ordinance. [53:18] Speaker A (unidentified): No. I think we have to move to reconsidering. Oh, jeez. [53:22] Speaker S (unidentified): All right. Counselor West. I'll move for reconsideration. I'll second them off. [53:26] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Counselor, it's been moved and seconded. Counselor West. [53:31] Speaker S (unidentified): I have nothing further to add. [53:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Counselor Pryde. I'm happy to see we can do this. I think we're good. [53:42] Speaker D (unidentified): I have to have voted for the affirmative. Since I voted for it, I can second to amend it. Second to reconsider. [53:49] Speaker A (unidentified): We're good. All right, councillors, we have a motion to reconsider the... I've lost the numbers. [53:56] Speaker D (unidentified): Passage of the first read of... [53:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Passage of the first read of Ordinance Number 9, 26-27. All in favor of... [54:04] Speaker P (unidentified): Actually, I did want to make a comment. I'm sorry to delay the meeting. I just want to note that I really appreciate all the conversations that I have had with landowners and neighbors and people, and I just thank you, and this is how we make things work, so yeah, okay, that's all. [54:24] Speaker A (unidentified): I know we want to thank Mr. Roberts also for these nice rules. All right, all in favor of reconsideration, that's a unanimous vote of the council. We're now going to go back to ordinance 9-26-27, and yes, I move for passage of 9-27 as amended, because we don't, does the amendment still count right now, or do we have to read it? Okay, I move for adoption, yes, of this ordinance as amended as a second read, thank you. Do we have a second of that motion? Thank you, Councilor Pryde. Councilor West, would you like to make a brand speech right now? [55:09] Speaker S (unidentified): Probably not. No, I don't have a word to say. [55:11] Speaker A (unidentified): No, Councilor Pryde. Nope. [55:14] Speaker C (unidentified): All right, this is a roll call, [55:17] Speaker A (unidentified): because it's a second read. Oh, okay, thank you very much. Councilor Scott. Yes. Councilor Walker. Yes. Councilor Coleman. Yes. Councilor Matthews. Yes, ma'am. Councilor West. Yes. counselor pride and mayor tipton yes that is a unanimous vote of the second read of ordinance number nine 26 27. The work is done here, save you an agenda item. Thank you, Council. That will go into effect in 20 days, 20 days, it will go into effect in 20 days, thank you. Sure, all of us look forward to the coffee. All right, can we now go to action on old and new business? Is the presentation ready? [Speaker Q (unidentified): Thanks everybody.] Thank you all, may this be easier than that. [56:16] Speaker T (unidentified): That was pretty easy, great, good. So I just made a presentation even though this isn't extremely complicated because there are some numbers in it and maybe not everybody read the memo. Julie Rosenbach, Sustainability Director, and I am coming forward after a workshop on September 15th where Council talked about a lot of different options for waste management strategy and opted to have me come forward with two different orders for moving forward, and so there's two orders attached because you potentially might like one or the other, but it's adopting curbside food waste collection service and the question is should it be opt-in or opt-out if you adopt it, so Yeah. PDF? No. I made it in PowerPoint, but then I saved it for the drive-in. There we go. There we go. Thank you, Milan. Thank you so much. All right, so the first thing I just want to do is to remind you why adopting curbside food waste collection service is a good idea, whether it's opt-in or opt-out. And there's a couple of reasons. First of all, we know that food waste is roughly 70% water, which when you gets thrown in the trash and it gets burned in our eco main waste to energy facility, it's extremely inefficient. It's like if you poured a can of beans on a campfire, would still burn but it would take it would be more difficult to burn. Second thing is that when you burn it ends up as ash and it ends up in a landfill and all of the nutrients what could be used are just lost, permanently lost. Whereas if you do the opposite and you put it to compost, then it's really beneficial and it turns into nutrient rich soil. So there are a lot of good ideas, a lot of good reasons for pulling food waste out of our trash and using it for higher and better use. Okay, so how it would work is the service would be the same whether you choose to adopt an opt in or an opt out approach. The first thing that would happen would be an enormous outreach campaign to talk to people about why food waste and how to sign up for food waste or opt out of food waste. And so that would be the first thing participants would get, a five-gallon bucket along with a starter with compostable liners and an information booklet or a magnet that they could use. And then weekly pickup would be a five-gallon cart that would be put out along with your trash and recycling on the curb. And because it would be a citywide program, there is not an option to provide clean buckets. It would be just, the buckets would just be emptied. But of course, people could line their buckets with compostable liners if they wanna buy them or newspaper or anything. So in addition to if we moved over to citywide food waste pickup, then we would, right now we have five food waste drop-off sites and I would suggest that we would reduce it down to three food waste drop-off sites just for overflow for residents and for people who are not on city trash and recycling service. So the big question that council asked me to look at and provide numbers for is what is the difference between introducing a program that is an opt-in curbside food waste collection versus an opt-out food curbside food waste collection program. And here are the numbers. With opt-in it's a choice, you have to take a first step in order to sign up for the program. And so all of our data here is based on curbside food waste collections in other cities. And so we are estimating that about 40 percent of the city would opt in for this free service and the amount of food waste Would be diverted would be about 842 tons. The total diversion rate would be 35 percent, and the net annual cost increase, it's a net cost increase because we would have tipping fee savings and we would have savings from reducing our drop-off sites from five down to three, would be $185,000. So this would increase the average residential cost through the tax rate by roughly $13 a year. And the capital cost, the capital cost in both scenarios are for the starter kits, would be about $46,000. dollars. Under the opt-out service, because people are getting it and don't have to take that extra step, we are estimating about 75 percent of people would participate to some extent, and that about a little over 1,400 tons would be diverted, and the recycling or waste diversion rate would go up to 42 percent. It costs more because there's more trucks on the road, and so the net cost increase to the city would be about two hundred and twenty thousand dollars, and it would be roughly eighteen dollars a year for the average resident through the tax rate, and of course the capital one, that the year one capital cost would be higher because you would be buying starter kits for, we're guessing, the 75% of people who participate in the program who do not opt out. Obviously if fewer people opt out, then the capital cost goes up slightly but based again based on other cities this is what the numbers look like so there's trade-offs of both approaches and for the opt-in approach the costs are tied to use you know what you're paying for is what people have signed up and they are likely to use it 's going to engage fewer households but it is going to increase our waste diversion rate and the money will be directed for the kits that will be purposefully used. Right now people who pay for private curbside food waste collection pay about $228 a month for Garbage to Garden, which is the only people right now in South Portland who do curbside food waste collection, and so those people, there's roughly 1,700 people who either use curbside food waste collection or use the drop-off sites. But I think there's around 850 people that would save money immediately through this service. So through opt-out, the costs are tied to reach. Residents are enrolled automatically, and so it would engage many more households, people who might not be inclined to take that step and say, oh, I'll start composting my food waste, would potentially try it because we would be delivering them information and delivering them the bins in order to do this. So the city would pay for all the kits in the citywide collection, though, even if people dropped off and didn't participate. So both approaches have merit. Again, the diversion rate increases under both approaches. The opt-in one is more cost directed, and the diversion rate goes up to 35 percent, and under opt out it would go up, we estimate, to 42 percent. In both cases we're adding costs because it's not being offset by a pay-as-you-throw program, and so we'd be adding some operating cost, and it would be an average tax increase per year of about 13 or 18, which, just to compare the $13 or $18 per year to what people pay for private service now is $19 per month. So it's definitely more cost-effective for people, and it's definitely more accessible for people. And then you also have the capital costs. And then lastly, just again, reminding you that it is a good option. Introducing curbside food waste is a really good option for South Portland, even if it is not paired with pay-as-you-throw, because residents really are interested in composting. It's going to be cost-effective for more residents to participate. People who don't have the bandwidth to go to our free drop-off site but also can't afford to pay $19 a month for curbside service, and it will increase the city's waste diversion rate, and that's where I'm gonna leave it, and I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank [1:06:52] Speaker A (unidentified): you very much. Counselor Coleman has, I still [1:06:55] Speaker N (unidentified): I still really don't understand why the opt-out is more expensive. Because I know people who are already composting at home. I mean, I use the drop-off because avocado shells just, I have to make it into confetti in order for it to compost. It just turns to, like, this hard shell. And, but, I mean, I... [1:07:21] Speaker T (unidentified): Oh, like, why does the program cost more? Yeah, why? There's more trucks on the road, more transportation costs to pick up from 6,750 people versus picking up from 3,600 households. It's transportation costs. [1:07:41] Speaker N (unidentified): But, I mean, it's like I put my stuff, my avocado shells, in your drop-offs, you know, because you have five now and I've asked somebody which ones are going to be eliminated. I probably generate like three quarts a week if even that of food waste and it's mostly and other people I know. I use it more in the winter than I do in the summer. [1:08:11] Speaker T (unidentified): I'm not sure what your question is. [1:08:13] Speaker N (unidentified): I'm just saying it's like nobody's stopping at my house to pick up stuff and a lot of people I know people who are using I don't understand is there what don't you [1:08:23] Speaker A (unidentified): understand just phrase it as a question because that's what she's looking why [1:08:26] Speaker N (unidentified): for people who opt out in compost they're composting or dropping off why is it more expensive to opt out if a trucks not stopping at their house well [1:08:39] Speaker T (unidentified): because we would be funding this program through the tax rate and so whether you sign up or don't sign up, we would be paying overall for the trucks to be going across the city. [1:08:51] Speaker N (unidentified): So do you need a certain number for it to be cost-effective, opting in? Does it have to be a certain number? [1:09:00] Speaker T (unidentified): It depends on what cost-effective means. [1:09:03] Speaker N (unidentified): To get to the rate where it's $13 a month for taxpayers. A year, I mean. [1:09:11] Speaker T (unidentified): If it's an opt-in program, we are assuming that only 3,600 people would sign up and in that case the program would cost the city roughly a hundred and eighty five thousand dollars a year. Yeah I saw that and the opt-out was the opt-out would be that we are assuming that six thousand seven hundred and fifty people participate in the program. Okay so that's the difference. Okay thank you thank you do you have [1:09:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have questions there,, Councillor West? [1:09:47] Speaker S (unidentified): Did you do an analysis of what the estimated tipping fee savings will be in both of these? [1:09:53] Speaker T (unidentified): Yeah, the tipping, I didn't put it in the presentation, but we did estimate the tipping costs. And if you go to the memo, it's in the annual cost and savings for each one. So the tipping fees would be reduced by $48,000. The cost for food waste drop-off sites would be reduced by $19,300, and the cost of the actual service for opt-in is $247,500. So the net cost increase is $185,000, but we are already calculating in the tipping cost and the reduced cost from going from five to three drop-off sites. Okay [1:10:45] Speaker S (unidentified): so that you just said the tipping costs are estimated to be the same the savings for either alternative is that what you? Nope. I'm sorry if I'm not reading this right. [1:10:56] Speaker T (unidentified): No I see opt-in. So in the memo this is the opt-in numbers. Okay I got it. 110. Yep. Okay sorry. [1:11:08] Speaker S (unidentified): So at one point, when I saw the spreadsheet of the analysis of this, you were factoring in the anticipated revenue that the city would receive from the extended producer responsibility, refund or stipend that we might get. Is that still part of this calculation or not? [1:11:29] Speaker T (unidentified): No, that is not part of this calculation because the program is, at the very best, delayed by a couple of years. It might not come to fruition. Okay. Not only that, but we have no idea what the reimbursements might be, so I left that out of this equation. [1:11:52] Speaker S (unidentified): Okay, thanks. And then how much is it costing us for the drop-offs right now, the bucket, the large barrels that are in the five locations around town, around the city? [1:12:02] Speaker T (unidentified): That, I believe, is $36,000, I think, a year. [1:12:14] Speaker S (unidentified): I think from this observation, that seems extremely successful. I would say when we stop by the high school typically on Monday morning those all five of those are just overflowing. And I'm one of the things that we might explore is expanding that program, but okay. [1:12:32] Speaker T (unidentified): Those are my questions. I did I did ask for more money to add another drop-off say in last year's budget. But it didn't make it hurt. Yeah. [1:12:41] Speaker S (unidentified): Well, it's always hope. [1:12:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Counselor Scott, you're finished, Counselor West? [1:12:47] Speaker S (unidentified): Yes, thank you. Thank you for indulging everybody. [1:12:50] Speaker P (unidentified): With the opt-out program, my understanding is that you serve, everybody gets a barrel and they don't have to put their food in the barrel. Can you, and that is obviously expensive to provide the barrels and roll that out, can you help me understand if there is any kind of conversation about opt out and like whether or not you can say to a resident do you want this barrel or we can give it to the next person or [1:13:26] Speaker T (unidentified): you're just like rolling out 7600 or 6700. Well we would still do an outreach campaign in either their option. We would do an outreach campaign. If people are like no I just don't want to do it then we would say okay we encourage you. There would be a period I imagine there would be a period where we can say you can unless you opt out we are going to deliver this to your household and that we're guessing that about 25 of the people just opt out immediately and that the other people are like well I'll get it, I'll get it. Or I had no idea that this was even happening or whatever. I do a mac like we have, we have a DEP grant right now to do an 18-month recycling waste diversion campaign and it's going to involve, it's going to be a big project. It's going to involve hopefully getting some neighborhood champions to help spread the word and then doing a bin tagging program which we've done in the past and people have absolutely loved. And what if it all works out, we would, it would be impactful to pair this with that program. I imagine when we go out to RFP we would ask whatever contractor proposals we get to help us do outreach to people and I think I mostly wanted to confirm that [1:14:57] Speaker P (unidentified): the opt-out program is not just like dropping off a five gallon bucket and hoping but that is there is some outreach and education and if people don't decide to pursue that 's fine but you have some engagement and [1:15:16] Speaker T (unidentified): interaction with those residents. I would hope that they would opt out before the program starts but people could get the bucket and be like nope but then again they have to make the phone call to opt out or they just let the bucket sit so I don't think we get to every household in the city but it would definitely be trying to reach people. [1:15:36] Speaker Q (unidentified): do we have other questions just do you want her to answer the question from public comment about magnets and education yeah but are you here for that i'm sorry i can i ask a question [1:15:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Just but yes let's not forget that, thank you. So I understand on the private people who are paying for private one of their incentives is they actually want compost, they want the compost bag to be delivered back to them. Yeah is that how this would work for our residents? Would all residents who are part of this program get the compost back? No I don't think they would, I don't [1:16:20] Speaker T (unidentified): think that I don't think city-wide service would include you being delivered a bag on your curb but I think we could likely include in the RFP that sort of we get a number of yards of compost at a central location and like the sand buckets and other things people could go [1:16:40] Speaker A (unidentified): and get compost okay although i have another question but counselor scott i just wanted to [1:16:51] Speaker P (unidentified): clarify that I do currently pay for curbside compost and the ability to get compost back is actual an actual that's an extra fee so it is not a exchange of I disagree that it is [1:17:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, that's fine. I'm, I know that it's not automatic unless you've gone to the website and said yes, but it doesn't, I don't think it's an extra fee. But all right, I stand corrected, maybe it is, but I've never thought that it actually is. Okay, we'll have to, you want to go up to figure out what bills we're paying. All right, other counselors with questions. All right, just one other question. If we are signed up with a vendor and we are signed up for opt-in and so gradually maybe more people are, is the ven Do our vendors flexible enough to keep increasing the routes or do you think that will be solved by saying you can only sign up for the, you know, in January, February and March for the next year or something like that? How will we work that? I [1:18:04] Speaker T (unidentified): I think we would probably, because we are South Portland, estimate 40% of people would opt in, and that's how we would write our RFP. It's a pretty high rate to just start off the bat with opt in, but what we could do is for each year that we do a contract, have a cap and say, okay, well, if we go over this cap and it's going to cost us more that we haven't budgeted for, then people are on a waiting list, and we try to increase the budget for the next year. But what we've estimated here is a pretty high cap for, okay, hopped in. All right, thanks. Also, sorry, just to say, I don't know what the tranches are, but like if it's not 3600 but it's 3800, it's, it depends on when another truck has to be involved, so I'm not, so we'll have to [1:18:57] Speaker A (unidentified): We would have to find out with the capital. Okay, all right, thank you. You don't by any chance [1:19:02] Speaker T (unidentified): know if you pay extra for compost that is not, that is not the bill I pay in my house. I pay every other bill except for garbage to garden, Marianne. All right, a member of the audience [1:19:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Our audience seems to know. Can you just quickly, I'm just curious [1:19:21] Speaker I (unidentified): Been doing Garbage to Gardens for a very long time and I pay 19 a month. It doesn't go up on any month for me. I go into the website, I say I would like compost delivered to my house these five, six, seven weeks and they drop it off, the nice bag I have eight of them sitting there waiting to close down on my gardens now, and I have not paid an extra penny for that. I would like to know, though, if I'm off to stay in my home, where can I be? [1:19:57] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, all right, I suddenly a question occurs to me. If there is, if the city is offering this, are residents who say, I don't want the city to do it for me, I'd rather pay for my own private system, service. [1:20:16] Speaker T (unidentified): I think that would be a bit ridiculous because you don't need to go up to pay $19 a month. I think what we would try to do with Garbage Garden, just like what you can do is say, okay, I'm getting curbside service. I really don't want to clean out my bucket. I want compostable liners. I'm pretty sure, and this is with Garbage Garden,, but we don't know who the vendor is because we're going to do an RFP. But for the example of garbage garden, you can pay a little bit extra and they will drop off a roll of compostable bags. I am pretty sure we could write an RFP that says, I want this, but I also want bags of compost and negotiate a rate that people would pay a little bit more to get the compost dropped off at their yards. And I'm pretty sure it would still be cheaper than $19 a month. [1:21:06] Speaker A (unidentified): All right. Well, thank you very much for answering that because I do think that would provide incentive for gardeners. Is there anyone who has a question? Oops, we're still on questions. We strayed a bit. All right, no counselors have questions. We did have an existing question about how education would roll out, whether people, for example, would get refrigerator [1:21:30] Speaker T (unidentified): refrigerator magnets that's like we have given out magnets and cards and all sorts of stuff from eco main in the past and i am sure that as we do our recycling campaign over the next 18 months that we can give out magnets again does that answer the question okay all right and [1:21:56] Speaker A (unidentified): and that would somehow be figured into a budget, so nobody would be surprised. [1:22:00] Speaker T (unidentified): We often get stuff from EcoMain that we don't have to pay for, so I think we would probably talk with EcoMain, and I'm sure we could... I don't know if we can get, you know, 9,000, but we can certainly get an amount. [1:22:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. All right. Thank you, Julie. Yes. And we're going to open up for public comment about this. [1:22:31] Speaker F (unidentified): Jack Raposo, Walnut Street. After reading the order, and I've been at the meetings where this has come up a few times with our pay-as-you-throw, that no matter whether you opt in or opt out, we're still going to get hit with another tax of $13 or $18. Everyone, by the way I see it, because opt out means opt out. If you want opt-out, you don't pay. But this opt-out system is not the way opt-out really works. So everyone is going to pay the additional $13 or the additional $18, whatever it happens to be, especially if it goes to opt-out. And even though this increase seems to be minor, $13 or $18, dollars every dollar is important to someone on social security and on a fixed income. So this is just another addition of pay a little bit more, a nickel here, a dime there, keep on going up on our taxes or whatever the case may be. These costs, the capital cost or whatever, are they coming back on the taxpayers, these original $48,000 or $77,000, whatever they are? Again, it always comes back to the taxpayers. And I think some of this, with what goes on in the city, and these little nickels and dimes and all of that stuff, holds a lot of people back from voting for some of the things that we'd like to have, a fire station and a police station, because we're always turning around and the next time you turn around there's another tax coming at us. So I would think we really need to sit down and think about how we're going to move forward on this whole process. Thank you. Thank you. Do we [1:24:49] Speaker A (unidentified): have other public comment? Think you've already spoken on the topic, so I don't think we can have you come back. Anyone else? [1:25:06] Speaker L (unidentified): Jeff Steinbrink, Cottage Road. I haven't done my homework, so even more than usual, I may not know what I'm talking about. [Speaker I (unidentified): Great. Good.] But the good news, I'll talk either more quickly or for less time. Here's the thing that though sticks to me after a number of these meetings, and a thing that just rubs me the wrong way, the city is now giving away something. It's really giving away the only set of chips it has in this back and forth with we citizens. And something constitutionally in me has a problem with that. And so, for instance, I know that there was a time anyway when there was talk about going to a smaller trash barrel and how that would have economic and other kinds of benefits for the city. And I realize I may be one of the four or half-dozen people in the city who actually favors pay-to-throw, so that, too, makes me an outlier. So the thing that this seems to be building to a question in me is, isn't there some way that someone somewhere along the line might have at least considered bargaining this good that we have that is bargaining the giving away free compost service in return for maybe changing from the big barrel, what is that, the $65 one, to the smaller barrel, the $35 one. I'm afraid that horse may be out of the barn, though, because we've already made pretty clear that we're willing to give this away. But there is a world in which, wow, the chance to get free curbside compost service risk might be worth trading something for, especially if I don't always use that big bucket. Because that was a real gain economically, going to the small, the 35 gallon, I would just like to think somewhere along the line, we would consider the bargaining. If not now, maybe sometime in the future. That's [1:27:27] Speaker Q (unidentified): a question that we considered. [1:27:30] Speaker A (unidentified): OK, because I didn't understand it. So others for public comment. All right, close down public comment. Okay, Julie, do [1:27:48] Speaker G (unidentified): you have in response to the last questions why Mr. Steinbrink about has there been any thought about the bargaining trading the composting and bucket and anything like that you have any doing [1:28:05] Speaker T (unidentified): the bartering in the trading I'm not sure I understand. [1:28:07] Speaker P (unidentified): Yeah, I don't think that's like a, I appreciate it's a thought. [1:28:11] Speaker T (unidentified): You mean people willing to do the Pays You Throw program in order to get free curbside compost? In order to get food waste composting? That is what was being proposed at the September workshop. [1:28:27] Speaker G (unidentified): And, Ms. Raposa, could you clarify, you said, will this cost go back on the taxpayers? I didn't quite get something about $40,000. I wasn't sure what you were referring to. Cost 46 000 and 77 000. Oh, the startup cost. Yeah, right, that would be part of that's part of the overall cost of the project but that's been factored in it's not like a an additional thing that wasn't considered but yeah thank you for clarifying anything to add to that Julie [1:29:05] Speaker R (unidentified): No. Okay. [1:29:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Counselors we yes we don't have excuse me I have I need a little tutorial when we have two separate ordinances about essentially the same thing do we consider them separately to [1:29:22] Speaker C (unidentified): have a discussion no these are just two options and then you would move action on which one you [1:29:28] Speaker A (unidentified): would like to move forward with okay so we can put our discussion right now well I think someone [1:29:33] Speaker D (unidentified): has to make a motion to put something on the floor and then we need to reject it right we [1:29:38] Speaker A (unidentified): have to vote for one of them so do we have a counselor who's motioning for one of these [1:29:44] Speaker P (unidentified): Counselor Scott I move to move forward with the opt-out food waste program that has been [1:29:51] Speaker A (unidentified): presented tonight thank you Counselor Scott thank you Mayor any second here on that one well here then I will second just so we can hear Counselor Scott's rationale thank you [1:30:14] Speaker P (unidentified): Counselor Scott, I appreciate all the discussions that we have had about waste and food waste, etc. I think we have to make some step forward. I think the opt out program is better than the opt-in program. I appreciate I may not have gotten anybody's approval on even the motion to move that forward, but I do think that we need to make a step forward. I think many communities have a composting program as a part of their city budget. I appreciate that it is dollars, but this is very low dollars in the grand scheme of things. I pay I think 13 a month to have my compost picked up, and I just like we I think we need to move the ball forward, so I supported a motion. Thank [1:31:08] Speaker A (unidentified): you very much. I you just saw seconded because I wanted to hear what Councillor Scott had to say. We just heard that I still have a couple of questions, so that's all I have to say right now. Anyone else have anything to say? [1:31:28] Speaker E (unidentified): Councillor Walker, so this is a topic that as many of you know is near and dear to my heart, and I've become I feel like a solid waste and recycling and food waste kind of subject matter expert over the last year or so, but I do not support this, and I do not support this because I do not feel like it is a big enough change to solve the overall problem that we put forward, which was to reduce the overall city costs of our municipal solid waste, increase our recycling rates, and move the opportunity to conserve what residents spend on their solid waste based on their own consumption, so people would be in charge of their own trash costs, and this does not do that. This doesn't move the needle on our recycling rates, and it is a tax increase. It is something that our residents have made clear that they are not in support of, and it does not do enough for me to solve the problem. This is a topic that I would like to come back to at another time when we are legally able to do so, and I want to have more conversation about what we as a community can do to reduce our municipal solid waste, to increase our recycling, and at the time at that time come back to the curbside compost, because I think that it is an excellent tool. I definitely see the value. I am someone that does pay the 19 a month, so I'm really putting against my own self-interest, because it's safe that would save me money, but it doesn't solve the problem, so this is not something that I can support. Thank you. I [1:33:17] Speaker N (unidentified): Support either the opt-in or opt-out because a lot of the people who are opting out, like myself, are actually already removing their food waste from their trash. So anything that removes that, which is water, which is heavier, my understanding was that it would decrease our overall tipping fee and save money. And so, I mean, it's $13 a year. The opt-out is $18, and I'm still not quite certain why a truck not stopping at my house is going to cost more money. [1:33:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Hold that thought. Thank you. Any other councillors? All right. Councilor. Oh, I'm sorry. Do you have your... I didn't see your hand up. [1:34:06] Speaker S (unidentified): Well, I'd like to speak in support of what Jess said. I know this is a really hard problem. And we've been struggling with this ever since I got on the council. And I do support trying to get food waste out of the waste stream. And it would seem to me that we could add an extra barrel to every one of our existing sites without too much money. And I would hope maybe we could have another site next year. Here, because I think that's been very, positive. I thought Mr. Steinbrink's comment was a very good comment in terms of what we're giving up here, and not really addressing the full problem. And this is an area where Jess has a lot of knowledge. She's on our ecosystem. She's our rep to ecosystem. She's been on our waste reduction committee. I don't unlike some of our other problems and I know it's costing us money if we don't stop, we don't address this year, it's okay, let's spend, let's go back to the drawing board. I think we, I think I can speak, well, I'm speaking for myself, that I know I won't go forward with the plastic bags, and maybe we've made that clear. At the same time, I think I was not expecting it to come back like this, quite frankly, because I thought the way I ended it the last time, in my view, was to say, the community needs to give us some ideas. If you don't like plastic bags, help us figure out what we're going to do to reduce our waste stream. And I am at the stage of saying, I don't want to vote for either of these tonight. I'm grateful that we have someone on the council who cares enough about it. It, we've done this thing with subcommittees, and she can be the subcommittee of one and try to see if we can figure out a way to ask our community to help us figure out some approaches. If you don't like plastic bags, and we understand that you don't like plastic bags. I mean, we heard you loud and clear. And we're not going to push something down, but we've got to do something. So what should we do? And let's figure out a more holistic approach to the whole problem. And if we can't get it done this year, we can't get it done this year. But the trouble is, if we do this, we'll have done sort of a band-aid approach, and then the topic will be off the table for a couple of years, and the costs are just going to keep going up and up. So I support what Jess had to say. [1:36:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else? All right. I was going to ask Julie to make a clarification that Councillor Coleman had pointed out we needed to hear. Is that okay? Julie, can you come back and just clarify one more time for us? We heard you say, and there is a memo, that there is the cost of reducing the tipping fee by not putting wet food waste. The reduction that we're seeing is estimated to be 50,000. Correct? It's a [1:37:25] Speaker T (unidentified): different amount whether it's the opt-in or the opt-out program. All right. [1:37:30] Speaker A (unidentified): Now we're talking. It's already factored in. So yes, that is what we need to say is key, that is factored in. It's still the additional either $13 a year or $18 a full year for the average taxpayer. Yes. Okay. I don't know what the average taxpayer, what's the [1:37:51] Speaker T (unidentified): average taxpayer? That is a home value of five hundred and fourteen thousand dollars. Obviously [1:37:57] Speaker A (unidentified): a different base. Okay, so base basically a five hundred thousand dollar home or so. Okay. All right, thank you so much for that clarification. Counselor Scott, did you have a question? And the motion's still on the table for opt out. I [1:38:15] Speaker P (unidentified): I just want to say that this community has been very against pay-as-you-throw or any additional kind of per household per purchase cost. And I think that while we need to make a change, you have to do it incrementally. And I very much support us moving towards, regardless of anything else on the table, I think that it makes sense for South Portland to provide food waste service. So, totally appreciate everything. I very respectfully disagree with my dear council member. But, like, we, I just, I think we're never going to get to the perfect picture. And I very much hope that we can make some increment toward that. And I support opt-in or opt-out, but a program of this nature. Thank [1:39:24] Speaker A (unidentified): You, I said that I seconded it because I wanted to hear you say, but we seem to be discussing the whole concept right now. We're still on the opt-out option, which is not, I'm not sure I favor the opt-out. However, I do favor starting somewhere. It does, for me, to withdraw the motion. No, not at all, we have to vote on it up or down. So I've, I hear what Mr. Raposa is saying. Basically, I think what he's saying is if you nickel and dime it, taxpayers, it's eventually not a nickel or a dime, it could become a dollar. And I hear that. I still think that $13 for a full year or $18 for a full year is, in these times, not, that is justified by the fact that if we start this program, not only will we be starting a compost program that is earth-friendly, which I am a fan of, but that we will be opening up opportunities for education across the community. And that by having discussing why composting can work, and also by bringing in this new recycling program that has been popular, right, recycling education, it might help us to do what both Counselor West and Counselor Walker were talking about, get toward a point where people understand that these programs and doing things differently with our trash can eventually save a lot more of our resources, because our resources do include the earth that we live in. So I just, I think we have to start somewhere. Frankly, I was favoring opt-in only because I thought it might be easier to introduce to the community, and also choice is important. So may I make a suggestion? Yes, my suggestion is that we vote on this one. Well, if so, I also [1:41:29] Speaker D (unidentified): favor the opt-in of these two options, and what I would do is make an amend, a motion to amend by substituting the opt-in for the opt-out. That would get us to where we need to be without having to have, I mean, it is two votes, but it's how we traditionally done this in the past. It's just amended with the thing that we really wanted instead of having something be defeated. All right, positive that way. [1:41:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, okay, so we've had a general discussion. We thought we were talking about opt out. We now think we're going to hear, is it, I can make a motion? Yeah, I'll move to change my motion to [1:42:08] Speaker D (unidentified): and I will second that motion. All right. [1:42:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, we may, in fairness, should have voted for opt out, but I think we all saw what was gonna happen. So, there is a motion on the table to change this to opt-in. Opt-in. And is there support for that motion? All in favor? I would favor the opt-in. Are [1:42:42] Speaker N (unidentified): you? It's, I still really don't understand. [Speaker D (unidentified): So to clarify.] Yes, please. [1:42:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Why I support this, and this will clarify, so the cost, so opt-out means that everybody gets a bucket, and you have to opt out of the program in order not to get a bucket. Therefore, it costs more, because everybody gets a bucket under opt-out. Opt-in means you have to ask for the bucket. So that means that fewer people are going to use it, and therefore it costs less to the taxpayer. The reason I agree with opt-in and support this amendment is because we have a library, and not everybody uses the library but we all paid for the library. We have schools, not everybody uses the schools, thank you, some people choose to send their kids to private school, some people might choose to continue privately paying garbage to garden, but we all pay for the schools. I think that this is a step, I am for incremental change just like counselor, it's got, I think this will make a difference. I think that if we start thinking in this direction and we see how successful this is, this is an education piece as well, so I'm for it. But I prefer the opt-in version because I already see people getting a bucket, not really understanding why they have a bucket, and then just sort of wasting that money that the city spent on it. I'd rather have us educate people and give them the buckets because they're asking for them. It so that's why I prefer, thank you, opt-in program, I got it, and I feel, and another reason is because I think that I'm favoring it because I know Councillor Tipton prefers that. I want this to pass so I'm going to support the [1:44:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Amendment. Did anyone else want to speak to the amendment? Councillor West, so if [1:44:36] Speaker S (unidentified): This amendment passes, you'll, it would be for an opt-in food waste that would allocate $231,300 for the program. Is that correct? [1:44:51] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm not looking at the figures right this second. [1:44:54] Speaker S (unidentified): Well, that's what the order says. Yes. [1:44:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Sorry, I had, okay, here's opt-in. I'm, okay, this one doesn't have it. Yes. Wait, 2475, is that what you just said? To opt-in, I'm looking at opt-in. [1:45:15] Speaker N (unidentified): Seeing that, I thought opt-in was, yeah, this is just the opposite. No, it's because [1:45:21] Speaker S (unidentified): Read the order, it's because they're out, it's allocating the 185,300 plus 46,000. [1:45:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Have the memo open right now, not the order, I'm sorry. Okay, got it, so you had the question answered. [1:45:39] Speaker E (unidentified): yes counselor Walker so I think again I will not be supporting this and it's not because I don't believe in incremental change it's not because I don't believe in composting it doesn't solve the problem and I think coming into what is likely going to be several mean years in terms of budget I think we need every dollar that we possibly can to stretch as far as it can and because this does not solve the problem. I don't feel like this is where we should allocate that $231,000. [1:46:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, I just was thinking of everything else, [1:46:23] Speaker S (unidentified): but Councilor West. Well, I have to ask, I wonder how much, how many small bins you could buy for $231,000. If everybody had a small bin, if we took an approach that everyone had a small bin and then we had the big cans that collect food waste at the food waste drop-off locations that we have. I'm just saying, in terms of the big, [1:46:47] Speaker E (unidentified): yeah, the small trash bins. [1:46:50] Speaker S (unidentified): How many small trash bins can you buy for $231,000? And the other thing is that this $185,000 is gonna be every year, right? It's gonna be, whereas if you buy small trash bins, it's a one-time capital expense. [1:47:08] Speaker A (unidentified): Can you just, when you say small bin, do you mean the people who are already doing their compost and taking it to the food waste drop-off sites? [1:47:18] Speaker D (unidentified): No. That's where that is. [1:47:20] Speaker S (unidentified): I was just picking up on a conversation from last time, where we have in our ordinance right now an option that you can have the full-size bin, or you can have, I guess it's about half the size. Is that right? Jess, is it half the size? [1:47:34] Speaker E (unidentified): No, it's 35 and then 32. [1:47:38] Speaker S (unidentified): anyway it's smaller yeah it's quite a bit smaller yeah and we were and i kind of thought we were still talking about that but i'm just we're trying to get the numbers and to be analytical about this if the council majority wants to proceed with the food waste what you're looking at is an ongoing cost of at least 185 000 dollars a year and then the initial education is 46 $6,000 capital, and I can't help but wonder how many small bins you could get for $231,000. And then you would presumably reduce the tipping fee quite a bit and eliminate the ongoing $185,000. And so it's just a curious thing to think about in terms of what is the best way to proceed if we're going to be incremental about trying to reduce our waste stream. And the and then I was saying at the same time that the big I'm sorry bins is an ambiguous term, but the food waste drop-off points that the city has that as far as I can tell have been extremely successful. I use several different ones and there are always seem to be full, and I do think that some of our restaurants are using them too, which is another way of getting food waste out of the waste stream that could I don't think it would cost too much to expand that a little bit, so I'm just trying to say I'm just trying to say another version of what [1:49:14] Speaker A (unidentified): my other colleague was saying. I well I want to call on Councillor Matthews however council can you just does this mean Councillor West that somehow the large that we would replace the larger bins that we have with smaller bins. Therefore, there's less opportunity to put waste into the waste stream. [1:49:35] Speaker S (unidentified): Yes, that's one of the topics we were talking about last time. That there are many cities that have done that, and then you pay extra if you want to have more things than the small bin. You either can buy a bag, or you can do whatever. [1:49:52] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, I am a bear of dim green. [1:49:54] Speaker S (unidentified): In my opinion, we've had an unfinished conversation about all of this. So that's probably where I'm having some trouble tonight and why I won't be supporting either of these. Okay. [1:50:03] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, in fairness, I also will say, because you're talking about it, that this procedurally seems like it didn't come out where you thought it would. At the end of our last Pay As You Throw workshop, we did say to the staff, bring us back an opt-in and an opt-out. We really did. [1:50:19] Speaker P (unidentified): But the bin the bin size is a different way to adjust residents waste right but we did not say [1:50:31] Speaker A (unidentified): let's bring back the whole discussion we asked them to bring back compost opt-in compost opt-out we really did swear to god re-watch the tape okay counselor matthews so fellow [1:50:46] Speaker B (unidentified): counselors Listen to Councilor Walker, please. I'm telling you, she is spot on. And if I was allowed to clap, I would, but I don't know whatever you guys were doing earlier, whatever. But I know we need to stop, but watching the recycling program with the blue barrels that we have now and the green and everything else, people naturally went that way. You see more people back when they first came out there was this big amount of money that we had to put forward and people were freaking out and everything else. Now people love it, I mean they love being able to put in two different barrels and I'm not so sure that we haven't done our due diligent homework to find out what the people think about how we can make it better. I mean, I haven't seen any surveys from people in the community that said, well, maybe you could do this, or maybe you could do that. Or I don't know. I just know that we are in a very, bad time for money. And time after time, we get lambasted about spending money. And I'm not even going to say the word needlessly, because it's not needlessly. I recognize it, and there's a lot of people out there who recognize it, that we need to reduce these dumping fees and that we need to make things better. But it is putting a Band-Aid over this. And I think that Council Walker, who this is her baby, is voting against this, and she should tell other councilors that, hey, we need to do more homework. We need to figure out a better way. and I'm not saying put it off two years I'm not saying that but I do think that by doing this we're not going to be talking about this for three years because we have a lot on our plate as counselors right now and this can still be in the mix and the sustainability office can do more homework and I'm rambling and I get it but I'm telling you right now the citizens of South fortland are sick and tired of spending money and that i do not support either can [1:53:17] Speaker E (unidentified): i make one more point yes please and i know i'm speaking for a third time so i appreciate your grace on us. We as a community already do provide compost to our residents, it is not curbside but we do provide it so there is as we work through and i'm going to borrow your term that i love so much churn through this rather weighty topic no pun intended of how to how to reduce kind of the overall amount that we are disposing of. I think possibly expanding which is a sounds like a more economical version the free sites would be something we allow that education piece to move forward because the other thing I'm afraid that we're losing sight of is curbside compost was supposed to be something that we were able to offer because pay as you throw funded it pay as you throw funded it was it pay as you throw really was a win-win from in terms of being able to offer a powerful tool to our residents to help reduce the number of bags that they would use and because people were purchasing the bags it was saving the city money and paying for this powerful tool and so now we're not doing that at all for various reasons, but we're still, I understand, but we're still, we're still charging residents more to provide a basically door side version of something that we are already providing. So it doesn't solve the problem and we're already providing it and it costs more money. And again, I'm not saying that I don't support tax increases. I mean, when budget comes, especially with the school board, you're going to hear me be a champion if they need more money. I'm going to be a champion for that if our staff needs money to bring programs forward if we need money to pave the roads the library all of these things I'm I am a champion for that. I want to be mindful with how we spend our money though and this to me it's not that counselor [1:55:22] Speaker N (unidentified): Coleman I believe in incremental change and I now understand what opt-in means and the reason why pay-for-throw is because of the cost of the bags it is that is pretty cost prohibitive for a lot of people in our community whereas in opt-in recycling there are a lot of people who don't have cars a lot of our elderly people would truly participate at that level I think that would be most helpful I can personally tell you I would be I would not opt in because I'm already utilizing community bins in doing my own composting and as far as like the small smaller it's not a time even to introduce getting more small green buckets because that's an additional cost I have a large green bucket that has been in my garage for over two years because I generate this much trash that goes in, and I always find space in somebody in a neighbor, so the truck's not stopping at my house. One less stop. But it's got to be more education. This is where I truly believe, like Mary and Brown, that education,, we can do better, because we need to decrease our tipping, what we put into trash, because the tipping fees are only going to escalate, and money is really tight for a lot of people right now. It may get better in a few years I but I don't think it's going to get better by next year. And in buying plastic bags that's why paper swirl is just not an option right now for a lot of people. That would be what do I buy food or a plastic bag okay so I think we [1:57:14] Speaker A (unidentified): I think we need to finish up here. [1:57:16] Speaker P (unidentified): There is a motion on the table. [1:57:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, opt out, opt in, I mean. So, the first vote is there support for changing this to opt in? All in favor of that. That is four votes in favor. So, that is enough for the amendment. amendment so now what we are discussing on this is whether this opt-in well sorry i think i [1:57:54] Speaker P (unidentified): technically amended my motion which was originally opt out to be opt-in and that's just the vote [1:58:01] Speaker D (unidentified): yes so now we're back to the main motion which has become opted yeah okay all right [1:58:08] Speaker A (unidentified): all right are we doing more discussion at this point or not i don't think so all right in all in favor of the motion that is four all opposed that is three the motion carries it didn't need it's not zoning right all right so the motion to begin opt-in food waste collection carried. All right, are we moving on? I think we should. What are we going to? [1:58:53] Speaker C (unidentified): Ordinance number six, 2627, amending chapter five, buildings, regarding updates to the permit delay division and other miscellaneous clerical updates postponed from October 13th, 26th. First reading, passage requires majority vote. [1:59:09] Speaker G (unidentified): We turn it over to our planning director, Melinda Vida, to start. we also have representative from the store preservation commissioner all right do we need to go back and do a motion to reconsider to buy you some time or [1:59:28] Speaker H (unidentified): for the record julie started by saying hers was going to be simpler all right so belanavida planning director thank you mayor tipton and counselors this item coming to you is long-standing and you know all things considered we had some other priorities and assignments that were tackled in the interim the council had looked at what we're gonna be taking up tonight some time ago years in fact but it's taken that long for us to come together with the solution so there's a little bit of just some Reference points for the prior workshop guidance because this had been through workshop up, but it's not a fresh one. I'll touch on that very briefly, but I'm going to assume counselors you recall that, happy to dive in if we need to. So the ordinance before use chapter five, it's our building ordinance, which contains a section that says if older buildings come across for construction, demolition, amendments, that we would freeze those applications if the age of the building was certain vintage to allow us to do some preservation work. This is what that ordinance looks like in effect in terms of what we do, and the substance of it is really in five steps. Once a building is affected or a property is affected, we tell the applicant we can't process, the application sits for 90 days to allow this process to sort itself out. The process is that either goes to the Planning Board or it goes through first a consultation with the Historical Society, second a recommendation to the Historic Preservation Committee, third, the Historic Preservation Committee considers whether the property has historical significance. It makes a recommendation to the council to put it on our local inventory. Council acts, then it goes back to the HPC for them to weigh in on what the project is in the first place in light of it being listed or not. And then the applicant gets to decide whether they wanna pursue the listing, the incentives, or they can just say no. There are many problems in the way that ordinance was structured and the procedure in here, and staff flagged that up. We had a consultation with the HPC, actually think it was the Arts and Preservation Committee at the time. They provided input on what might be a good path forward. We met with council. Council provided a variety of guidance at workshop on how to deal with the thorny problems in there that we knew we needed resolution on. Some of them are procedural, some of them are cost related, others are more substance of how we wanna tackle preservation. A couple of key points are here, I'll come back to it. But one of them, which is just, I'm going to call out because I want to make sure we are aware we had this discussion, but the HPC would like to revisit this discussion of the static age of building being 1941 or earlier, and they have reasons for that. The chair of the committee, Nicole, is here, and she will speak to that, and I'll flag where that sort of sits in the ordinance that's before you. The ordinance that's before you does all of the things that council asked us to incorporate, and here the nuts and bolts are that we will receive an application for someone wanting to demolish a building older than 1941 or to otherwise affect a building that may be a resource. We will let the applicant know we can't process this until you tell us affirmatively that you do not want to participate in the preservation piece. Usually it's a pretty quick turnaround for applicants to say no, I want my permit processed, or tell me more, and we can give them the guidance on what this ordinance will allow as an incentive to try and keep them in the program. But it puts the decision point to the applicant up front early rather than at the end. If they weren't going to agree to the program in the current version of things, then we spend 90 days. Everybody does a lot of work in order for the applicant to say thanks but no thanks. If that's the way it's going to be, the guidance from council was we'll let the applicant say that up front and everyone can move on. And that's what this ordinance does. So we let them know it's on hold until they tell us that they do or don't want to be in the program. If they say they want to be in the program, they have to identify what the historic resource is. If the building's been so cobbled over the years that there's really no historical value anymore, then clearly there's nothing to do there. But if it's truly a genuine piece of historic resource, we would want to establish that, define its historical merit, and there's a process for that. The second piece is we have to look at what the project is. Great, they have a beautiful old house and it's emblematic of all the architecture of the period, etc., but the project is to totally demolish it because they want to do something different. So we have to understand the resource, we have to understand what work they want to do to the resource. So those are the two pieces that the applicant would be responsible for, and if they proceed through that and if they can put forward a project that maybe isn't total Demolition, but they want to respect the history of the building, but do an addition on the back or something else that doesn't affect the resource, then they can get into the series of incentives that council wanted us to provide. There are some new things in the incentives package, so that's the only thing I really want to kind of dive into. They get authorized for the incentives and then they go on with permitting, and one of the incentives is related to permitting, so just as a quick flag again. Nicole will speak to this in more detail, but the HPC would like you to consider not that static 1941 date but to do a rolling if the building's older than 50 years, so as we move forward in time we're just tracking 50 years from whenever the applications receive. All right, so the incentives, if we're going to move this to an applicant decision, we wanted to try and provide something meaningful so that the applicant decided to opt in for preservation, which usually comes at a cost, even if it's cost neutral in terms of dollars paid to architects and builders and whatnot, there's still the cost of time to reconsider the work, evaluate it, and then go ahead and do it. So there's always like a cost element of some form. So what's the incentives that's gonna encourage someone who's not already motivated to do historic preservation for their own reasons, encourage someone to do this. So the three that we can really bring forward is to take, and this is what council authorized us to do or guided us to do, is take the 50% permit fee reduction that's in ordinance today, move it to 100% permit fee reduction, and that's up to 100% because it allows the HPC to consider the scope of work that they're doing. This is the new piece that council wasn't talked to, introduced to at the workshop, and I just want to make sure you all understand what's in here. The problem with the permit fee reduction as an incentive is it's highly limited. If you look at a scenario where someone's coming in to apply to redo the windows on a beautiful Victorian building, the cost of the permit is a couple hundred bucks. The cost to redesign, procure, and install age specific authentic historic windows is thousands more than the conventional window that you can buy at a retailer today. So the thing we're up against to try and provide a compelling incentive is thousands of incurred cost for the benefit of historic preservation. So how could we possibly make the permit fee reduction compare at all? So the thing we've introduced into this ordinance is that if you go through this process, if you volunteer to subject yourself to requiring Victorian-style windows instead of the conventional, that's still your choice. But if you choose to do that, you not only get the up to 100 percent fee reduction on the window permit that you're applying for today, but you put the property into the program and five years later if you want to do a garage in the back that doesn't touch the building at all also comes with a couple hundred dollar permit fee application that would also be eligible because you've now put the entire site into the program. We know what the resource is, we can have intelligent conversations with you about it and you've now established sort of a legacy of potential permit fee reduction on that property and that's the community's commitment to try and keep the resource preserved. It's always the applicant or property owner's choice so in the future if they wanted to or needed to demolish the building or do an addition that isn't quite in keeping with preservation they just wouldn't be eligible for permit fee reduction on that proposal but so long as they continue to preserve the resource they continue to make themselves available without having to go through a process to get permit fee reductions so it's a little bit of a compounded permit fee reduction to try and give a little oomph to the incentive but at least it lets it start to become you know cost attractive as a motivator. The second piece is that when you enter into this program voluntarily applicants choose to start and subject themselves to this they get the permit fee reduction potential but also when they go through that process which takes time they have to do the evaluation of the resource then they have to do the does my project keep the resource intact that takes a little bit of time again they're choosing to do it but then they wouldn't be at the bottom of the application pile if they go through that process and we find they have a project that does respect the resource and they are then willing to do the cost that their permit is reviewed top of the line it's an expedited review so there's a time savings there so that decision point isn't painful. We have had for a long time the adaptive reuse program still an incentive still available. We would continue to make that offer that Up to applicants in your packets and Nicole will speak to this, the HPC mold, this sort of legacy permit fee reduction option that's available because it does, you know, stack permit fee reductions, which is the city foregoing potential revenue. It's not costing the city anything, but it's also not earning the city money that we would have otherwise earned. So they did ask the council to just consider, are you comfortable with that amount of incentive package? And I asked the same question, I think it's a really important question. I do want to provide the council an option here and that it's not included in our ordinance, but if you did have concern about sort of the long-term compounded incentive offered by continually providing fee for free permits on a historic preservation project, we can also establish a limit to that, such as the language on this page, and I'm happy to discuss it further, but basically it would mean the HPC and staff are not making any decisions that would be permit fee reducing a project in excess of some dollar amount. What's on the page here is 25,000 as a suggestion, but it would engage council at that point. So when the dollars become more significant, great, we're providing that incentive, but council's the one that gets to do that decision, not others. Council's always engaged in this process anyway, so it would be a pretty streamlined review because we have to come to Council for you to list it on the inventory in the first place, so it would be a tandem conversation. We would tell you, here's somebody who's wanting to add a large project on the back end of a property that has a beautiful Victorian in the front. They're going to leave the Victorian intact, even though it's more painful to do that, they've got to drive the driveway around, they have to meander, they have to protect it. They were initially going to demolish it, but if we can do a permit fee reduction on their 10 unit building at the back, they will find a way to keep the Victorian in the project. We get the preservation achieved, they are maybe motivated to do that because the permit fee cost on a 10 unit project can be pretty significant and 100 fee reduction could mean tens of thousands saved, so it's meaningful. And now I'm trying to say the Victorian, but that's also foregone revenue to the city. So that's when we would come to you and say, look, here's the Victorian, it's being preserved, they're interested in doing this because they can find another way to design a site to keep the building in the back, not touch the Victorian. But hey, they're doing this because they'd like to get the hundred percent permit fee reduction and that amounts to thirty thousand dollars. Let's say you at that time would have the ability to talk about what the incentive in the permit fee reduction is. You would also have time to evaluate whether you even want to list it on the inventory and make all that available in the first place. So there is an option here if you're concerned and HPC is flagging some attention on that issue. We can discuss that and then HPC also has another recommendation, they can speak to this as well, to look at defraying some of the costs as another form of an incentive. So one of the problems we flagged with the ordinance as it is, that the ordinance today is silent on who pays for the work to establish whether it's a resource is genuinely there and what the project is. And that problem is that it currently falls to staff, but we're not budgeted to do that. So one of the things we needed to procedurally fix in the ordinance is to make clear who pays for the work. And under this ordinance for council's guidance at workshop, if the applicant says yes I want to go through with this, then the applicant pays for the historic resource architect. They show that their resource is actually something of value, they show that their work is going to protect the resource. The city taxpayers are not paying for that, we are evaluating the proposal, so that's now clear in the ordinance. But from the HBC's perspective, as you'll hear, they would like to have a conversation about a grant program to help defray those costs and that could be a program that they oversee. Again it would be a budget decision presented to you at budget time. So that's the nuts and bolts of what's before you here, happy to dive into any of it further, and again we have the chair with a presentation from hpc or some [2:13:26] Speaker B (unidentified): More from HPC. Yes, yeah, clarifying is just, this is the same thing that we had where we had some community members that had applied and it was like a really long process and we were trying to speed it up. Is this the same type of thing that we had? You don't want to talk about, right? Yeah, that's people who don't know what I'm talking about, but go ahead and help me refresh my memory. [2:13:53] Speaker H (unidentified): We had a process that was almost taking 90 days, correct? It's obligated to take 90 days by the current ordinance, correct. And so when you come in and your building is built in 1940, we say thank you for your building permit, we're not touching this for 90 days. And the reason is it has to be going through a variety of consultations. The frustration is that, okay, it waits and goes through this whole process, maybe it's even a resource that the council seriously cares about, and then at the end of 90 days the applicant decides, I don't care, I need to move forward, I need to build this, or I want to do this, and I'm going. And the ordinance allows for that too. So it's a lot of pain and a lot of time and a lot of process for not having a formal obligation then to do anything with it. And so that was one of the issues we flagged is, if we want to make this a voluntary program, then why subject someone to it when they're going to say no at the end anyway? Let's figure out a way to make the incentives more powerful and try to get people to opt in. [2:14:55] Speaker B (unidentified): So what is the timeline now? [2:14:59] Speaker H (unidentified): The timeline now is they submit a permit, or even at the time of submission, our front counter staff would know to look for these dates. Is it a building of 1940 or earlier? And they would tell the person submitting, do you want to participate in the program? Here's the incentives. Here's what you get if you walk through with us. And if the person says, sure, let me learn more, give me the materials, wait on my permit, let's do some discussion, great, we keep going. I actually like this program. This is great. I want to build the 10 units. I was going to tear down the Victorian. If I can get a permit fee reduction, great. Let me retool. Let me rethink. And I'll try to do that and I'll come back with some different plans. That's preserving the property. Great. And the applicant is owning that process and participating willfully. But if they look at it and say, I'm changing out the windows, I don't have $50,000, I have $10,000, my windows are drafty, I understand, I'll work with the Historical Society, take some photos, document it, archive it, but I really need to move forward with this. That's my reality. Then they would just say, I don't want to participate in the program, we process the permit right away. Okay. [2:16:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Can I, before we, should we hear from Historic Preservation before we ask further questions? [2:16:12] Speaker E (unidentified): Questions. Well, can I ask my, I'm just afraid to get lost on the shovel. Does the waiver, permit waiver, does that apply to the property or to the owner? So the Victorian example, X person does decide to participate and then just after they've done their work they sell the building, next owner comes in, they want to make a change but it's still aligned. Does the waiver stay with [2:16:37] Speaker H (unidentified): the building? Yeah, I own the building, I work with the council, I work with the HBC, I get it on there, I get it listed, I waive my window installation fee and I do the, you know, whatever Victorian windows, and then I sell it to you and you come in and you want to do a detached garage in the back. It's with the property now. Okay, so that property recognizes the resources there. If you continue to protect and preserve that resource through subsequent work, then you continue to be eligible. You'd have to talk to the HPC, they'd have to evaluate, make sure you're not affecting the resource. So long as you're not, then it's a legacy benefit. So it does potentially make the property more marketable. It sort of bakes in this long-standing access to a permit fee reduction with minimal process. Okay, thank you. Thanks. Okay, can we hear from her? Thank you. Good [2:17:30] Speaker O (unidentified): evening, Mayor and I'm City Councillors. My name is Nicole Regan and I'm the current chair of the Historic Preservation Committee, or HPC. As per our memo, which hopefully you all had a chance to review, the HPC recently voted unanimously to recommend the Chapter 5 ordinance update in regards to permit reduction and historic preservation with one additional suggested edit. The committee proposes a further amendment to the ordinance update that would replace the fixed December 31st, 1940 cutoff for historic consideration with a rolling 50-year period based on the building's date of construction at the time of permit request. We believe that the current cutoff as drafted is arbitrary and risks excluding properties that are an important part of South Portland's history. A building does not need to date to before 1940 to have architectural or historic significance. I'm sure we can all think of some examples that would not be included if 1940 were continued to be the date. A rolling 50-year period would better align the city's approach with established historic preservation practices, as well as the guidance of the Secretary of Interior's National Register Criteria for Evaluation. So this is a 50-year period is very common in this area when kind of thinking about historical significance. I think most importantly, the administrative concerns that may have previously supported a fixed cutoff date have been substantially ameliorated or even eliminated under this new proposed process. The historical society is no longer responsible for individually reviewing each potential property for listing, thereby eliminating that burden for them and that potential bottleneck as well. And permit-related communications and notifications are often handled electronically, which allows for more easy notification for potentially eligible applicants. Especially, I think, because it's an opt-in process and things can be, like I said, handled electronically. Electronically, they can go out quicker, responses can get quicker, and so things can just be processed more quickly overall. And with it being upfront as well, that's really kind of front-loading that decision point, as Milan talked about, and so that would hopefully, we think, would make the whole process go a lot faster. The change would also give property, more property owners, if you changed it to a fifth-year period, more people would be able to take advantage and participate in the incentivized preservation process that would then help the city recognize and restore protect historically significant resources for more recent but still significant periods. Finally, a rolling 50-year standard would automatically evolve over time that reduces the need for future ordinance amendments as newer properties would become historically significant as time moves on so for these reasons the hbc recommends further amending the ordinance to adopt a rolling 50-year period of applicability and as Milan mentioned in our memo we also had two kind of considerations that we hoped you would just kind of think about in your discussions that were raised by committee members one was that I think he gave an excellent example of because these incentives are going to kind of run with the land there is kind of potential lost revenue from future fees really would apply more to kind of large parcels where you might have kind of one resource but be able to sort of develop the rest, but it would just be something for council to consider because as it runs in perpetuity, that could be kind of lost potential income there. And sort of conversely, for smaller properties, the amount, the permit incentive, even if it was 100%, might not outweigh the costs that the homeowner or the property owner would be expending for the experts for the Historic Resource Survey and the Historic Preservation Analysis, which are required. So we would just, maybe not now, but in the future, if you were to make this amendment, consider some sort of grant program or just kind of seed funding to assist smaller property, not that it doesn't have to be smaller, but property owners for whom that balance might, the incentive might still not be enough for them to go through the preservation process. And that could be something that is budgetary through HPC and something that they could oversee. But I think it would make a big difference for people doing smaller projects because in addition to having to pay for the experts, the actual materials that are used are often more expensive, as Milan said. So you're kind of getting two additional expenses if you're going through the historic present this process that the permit fee reduction might not account for or fully account for. So, thank you for your time your consideration on this and I'm happy to answer any questions about what the HPC recommends. Thank you. Thank you very much. [2:22:26] Speaker A (unidentified): All right counselors questions for Milan or our historic preservation committee leader. Do I see questions? Yes, Councilor Watt. [2:22:39] Speaker P (unidentified): I did not focus as much on this agenda item. Is this related to every planning application in every building in South Berlin, or are there sort of specific, like, can you? [2:22:55] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, this relates. This is in Chapter 5, Buildings, which is governing primarily the building permits. It's building permits and demolition permits. So when someone files for either one of those, we look for the age of the building. Okay, and if it's in that age category, then we would tell people, you're on hold if you're 19 older than 1941 until you tell us in or out. I do want to piggyback on one thing. It's important to know the ordinance is written that if you list the property on the local inventory, this or any other future council says this is a historic resource for us, then that also makes you eligible for the program. And that listing inventory, the criteria in your ordinance, has no age category whatsoever. So this governs when we get permit applications that we have to take the step of asking an applicant to say yes or no when they're 1940s or older. But if someone comes in with a building from the 70s, and it's super cool, it's got some architect that everybody knows, and everyone loves the building and they want to pursue this program, Council has every right to put that building on. You could put a building built last year on your historic resource inventory, if you so choose. So, what by the station? You could do it for a prospective building. But, anyway, my point here is that the program and the incentives are available at Council discretion because you have power over what's in your inventory, but this is governing a staff step to talk to an applicant about whether they want to be in or out, and that only kicks in when they're 1940 year old any [2:24:35] Speaker A (unidentified): Other questions? Milan, it seems pretty clear that you think this does establish the right balance in terms of protecting historic resource says while encouraging appropriate redevelopment and improved energy efficiency, but and we'll make it an and we're potentially, I mean, we will be looking at cutting off a revenue source. That's okay. We think that's okay. Any way to project how much? I just heard a whole discussion about taking care of our monies. [2:25:20] Speaker H (unidentified): We don't have projections for foregone revenue had this applied and had this been pursued in every case. And it's a little difficult to do that because the applicant has to choose. I still think this is going to be a cost regardless of this. We tried to be creative with as many incentives as we could provide, but the reality is doing bonafide historic preservation is expensive. There are things like federal programs and whatnot that can help. You know, people would do that if they really have a beautiful property, put it on the national register, it makes money available. Again, voluntarily you opt in for that program, but it needs to be a subsidized effort. If we're talking about, you know, let's say totally demolishing a building that really warrants or has merit under preservation, this math still doesn't work out. This incentive is not going to be powerful enough, frankly, but we've done as much as we can in here. But because the incentive is never going to keep up with the costs, it's really difficult to tell you that, you know, for example, everyone's going to say yes to the incentive and then we forego a revenue stream because I still think many people will have a hard time doing that unless they're already motivated and financially capable to do it. And that's why we didn't, we didn't get into that. The best way I can answer that question, it's really hard to predict. We don't have a lot of these permits filed for a lot of people doing, you know, total demolition on a building of this vintage that is also emblematic of an architecture and preserved in a good enough state. So one that you all may be familiar with, there's a project currently under construction on Broadway, 1337 Broadway, just as you approach the couch corner, that was half demolished and then got fully demolished, is now being built. That project paused in the demolition because the demolition kicked off before we had a chance to analyze the project, and it was an older building. It had some elements, in fact was photographed in and outside by the historical society because the program kicked in and allowed them to engage with the property owner. But that building had very mint limited original quality to it that wasn't compromised and evolved as people lived in the building. So it has to also be a resource, and that's, so it's very difficult, and also what people are proposing matters. They're not all total demolition projects. As I said, if it's a window thing, that's probably the hardest one. Windows are so darn expensive when you compare conventional versus period windows. I'm not sure if that fully answered it, but it's best we can do. [2:28:08] Speaker S (unidentified): Well, I guess my original question [2:28:10] Speaker A (unidentified): is, this the right balance? And you said best we can do. [2:28:13] Speaker H (unidentified): I will also just say, council can't intervene. Right, like we don't, as I said, we don't see a hundred of these every week, in which case, like, you pass it and all of a sudden there's this flood of foregone revenue. The reality is this is a trickle. It happens slowly over time, and you can see how this program evolves and revisit this. Right? Thank you. [2:28:41] Speaker B (unidentified): Counselor Matthews, just for the people at home, I think this is just more of a perk for a hope in a poll that we were able, that we're able to preserve some of the history of the city of Sao Paulo. And you know, I'm sitting here thinking about it's kind of like buying organic food fruit and just regular fruit, you know, you know it's going to be more expensive buying the organic. And so it's, and I get it, because I personally, as we went through the fire station process, every meeting I said I want to keep the front face of the fire department. It's historical, it's, it's a, it's a beautiful face, it's recognizable, and it's been around forever. And I get it, and you're probably right, I don't think that you're gonna get a whole lot of people jumping at it with construction costs and the cost of fuel and diesel, everything, and the cost of tar alone, you know? So I don't think that you're gonna get a whole lot, but I think it might be worth putting something in place just to see if we can save some face in the city of South Walton. That's my take. Am I, is that what you're looking at, kinda? [2:29:58] Speaker N (unidentified): You're supposed to be asking questions. I didn't like this. I didn't like this. You did. [2:30:01] Speaker H (unidentified): I think this is procedurally significantly better than the current ordinance for all parties involved, because it's a genuine process, where the other one is a little bit of a bait and switch. You know, we're doing all this, you put through the pain, and then you just decide at the end, and it's kind of, it's just frustrating, frankly. This one's procedurally significantly better, the incentives are significantly better, and then the preservation outcome, as with today, is a, is a partnership between a Property owner and the community to talk about and see what we can offer and do as much as we can with some limitations here. Let me ask, is the permit timeline any better if an applicant's primary need is to move fast because they've got drafty windows and winter's coming and they only have so much money? All that, they submit the permit today, they will be asked whether they want to participate. If they don't want to participate, we start processing permits and they get to work, so it will be faster. Because under the current ordinance we pause it for 90 days, no discussion, that's the council requirement under current ordinance, and then we go through a process because 90 days allows for the consultation with the Historical Society, then a recommendation to the historic preservation committee, then a recommendation to the council, then back to the preservation committee to see what the project is and evaluated against a resource that the council may have nominated, and then to the applicant to decide. That takes 90 days between everything we have to do in between, and in fact 90 days is not enough, but it's what's in the ordinance, so that's all we can pause it for. [2:31:52] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, counselors, any other questions? All right, the items open for public comment. Any public comment? Don't see any public comments closed. What is the will of the council? Councillor West, move for passage. Thank you. Second, Councillor Walker. All right, Councillor West. [2:32:13] Speaker S (unidentified): Yeah, I do have one, just one mechanical thing. I don't know the best part, place to put it, but so right now, they're going to get a permit. The permit fee waiver is for the entire project. What concerns me is if there's going to be a waiver of fee permits in perpetuity. I think there should be some sunset on it, whether it's 10 years or 20 years or something. But I understand about putting the property in the project, and that goes with the property. And that's a decision that's made at a certain point in time. The problem for me is that it's awfully hard for cities to keep track of permit fees and waivers. So I'd like to see a sunset on that. That's all I want to say to my fellow councillors in terms of how I would see the problem working. The reality of it is, as a local government, we don't have the authority to provide incentives that are going to, it's got to be some kind of state tax incentives that are going to be big enough or federal to really encourage somebody to do a historic preservation. But I think it's great that you're trying to do this. And I certainly support it. It's just trying to think about how to administer it over time. That's where I would like to see for the permit fee waiver some kind of a limit on how many years it would last. [2:33:45] Speaker H (unidentified): We, just for clarity, we would not be needing to track anything. Once the council lists it on the inventory, it's there until you take it off. So if the council puts it on there and a property owner comes forward and says, I want to do something with this property, we would know this is a listed property. You're eligible for permit fee reduction. If you can show me your project, show the HPC that your project doesn't affect the resource. There's no need for us to track it. The tracking would be if you wanted it from a budgetary standpoint to know no property has received, you know, X cumulative dollars or whatever, but that's, that's the budgetary side of it, not the program side of it. So it's more a question about council, do you want to set up some global limit? If you were to write an ordinance, for instance, that no one property can receive a cumulative lifetime benefit of X dollars, then yes, we have to track it on a permit by permit to track it towards that dollar amount. But if you're just interested in maybe using time as a proxy and say you get whatever benefit you get for the permits you submit between now and the next 10 years, there's no, still no tracking for the city. We don't really, the ordinance wouldn't require us to follow that dollar amount. However, you know, Mayor Tipton, to your point, if you wanted to do the check-in, you know, let's see how this has been going after two years, three years, have we foregone, you know, something of a dollar amount that's not comfortable, that's not too big of an ordeal for us to have a report back to you because you want to see where that program has been, and you get a cumulative, hey, in three years the council has not received X dollars. Those are reports we can run, but we're not tracking anything on a per property owner changes, it doesn't really matter. Just the administrative burden side of it is not that big. I just [2:35:36] Speaker S (unidentified): Don't, if we're worried about giving up revenue, I don't want to give up revenue in perpetuity because I don't think that's fair to a council in the, if we want these buildings to last for forever, you know, I think, yeah, I understand it's historic, it's always going to be historic, you'd like to preserve it, and I, and I understand the person makes a decision now to go on the registry. But if we're going to waive permit fees, it just seems appropriate to me to have some sunset on that, some duration. Because we're talking about 25 years, 50 years, whatever. Somebody comes in and wants to do something, and you say, oh, well, waive back then. And who knows what the scene is going to be financially. So I just wouldn't want to wait. I just don't want to tie the council's hands in perpetuity like that. [2:36:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I don't know we have the authority to do it in perpetuity to begin with, but what would it look like to you to make? [2:36:36] Speaker S (unidentified): Like a 25 year cap. Yeah, sometimes that 20, 10, 20, 15, 20 something. [2:36:43] Speaker D (unidentified): Council pride, does the dollar cap that was suggested during the presentation make sense as opposed to [2:36:52] Speaker S (unidentified): a time limit? I don't know, I personally like the time one because I like the flexibility for [2:36:58] Speaker H (unidentified): future councils to do what they need to do. The one thing to consider with the time element of it is as you go further in time, that's when the history starts to become further away and [2:37:11] Speaker S (unidentified): arguably more historic. Yeah, but they've already put it on the register, once they put it on, I'm, the only thing I'm talking about is the fees. [2:37:19] Speaker H (unidentified): I understand, but in year 21, a property who's now 21 years more historic than it was at the time that it got listed on the inventory is now not eligible for the permit reduction. [2:37:34] Speaker S (unidentified): No. In year 21, the council that's in power in 21 can decide what they want to do. They may, at that time, decide we're going to take, we're gonna, who knows what's going to happen, I just, I'm just concerned about tying the hands of future councils and fiscal matters, Council [2:37:53] Speaker N (unidentified): Coleman, when you were first talking about this, my understanding was like if it was a standalone garage and they wanted to build it, if not in [2:38:03] Speaker H (unidentified): Historic, it would not apply to the permit waiver. That's the scenario where the waiver would make sense, because they're proposing something on a property that's now been given this fee waiver eligibility, and they come forward with some project, and it does not touch the resource. Because this case, it's a detached garage in the back. We would charge, I don't know what the number is, 500 bucks for the permit to build that garage, and we could tell them because you took the step of protecting that other property and you've made sure not to compromise its historic merit, it your garage fee of 500 is now waivable. That's that's the compounding benefit to try and bring the incentive more close to something, even though it wasn't built in the, this new garage that's [2:38:55] Speaker N (unidentified): standing alone is not built in, looks like it belongs to this house. Yeah, they're protecting [2:39:03] Speaker H (unidentified): the resource and the thing that they're doing is not jeopardizing the resource. If they placed, If it was attached, for example, the Secretary of Interior standards for historic preservation is the standard everybody uses on how you do preservation properly. And they'll evaluate under those standards what the new project is. If the new project is an attached garage and it uses an entirely different architectural style and is not complementary to the old, in fact detracts from the old, blocks the view of the old, that's a problem. and that would not be eligible for the permit fee reduction because it's compromising the resource. But if it's benign and in the back, even though it doesn't look like it belongs there, yeah, what's interesting just to run on this example though is historic preservation does not support generally something that mimics the past, it's a false past. Yeah, so when doing preservation work, you have a beautiful Victorian, you want to attach a garage to it, you don't want to use a modern version of victorian architecture, you have to respect the past and do something that doesn't detract from it, but you 're not trying to replicate it. So but all that design consideration is part of the secretary of interior standards. Just going to remind the council this is [2:40:23] Speaker P (unidentified): a first read. Counselor Scott, sorry, this is based on a workshop from 2024. Yes, okay, I don't remember what I was wearing. I know, I guess I would just generally say that I am not really in favor of like a hundred percent fee waiver on anything. And yes, I appreciate that maybe it was 50 and the guidance from that workshop was to go to 100. I think I'd be somewhere more in the 50 to 75, but like I just don't think waiving a fee entirely makes sense for our city. And I will spend more time on this between now and the next one, apologies. [2:41:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, it sounds like people are suggesting tweakage or considering it, but. Meanwhile, we have this first read. So, I'm sort of, okay, what do we do? We brought you back, somebody motioned, blah,, it's on the table right now. all right well anybody object to an actual vote here you ready all right all in favor of the first read of the ordinance of passing the first read alright so it looks like with that last minute sure it is a unanimous first read vote no change I it sounds like more time is needed and that potentially you would expect to hear amendments in the second read that's my feeling no that's [2:42:24] Speaker S (unidentified): not what we should be doing. If somebody, I raised a point. Yeah, I didn't hear anyone else liking it, so I withdrew it. I didn't pursue it. Well, counselors, if I look at you, I've [2:42:33] Speaker A (unidentified): raised the point. All right, but if I look at you all and I say there's a motion on the table, are we ready to vote, and everybody sits there kind of, then how am I supposed to know you want to amend [2:42:45] Speaker S (unidentified): it? Ooh, nobody wants to. So we have the first read, but I think to encourage of amendments on the [2:42:52] Speaker A (unidentified): second read is not with what we decided. I'm not advocating for them. I just said I thought from what I was seeing that might happen. I don't know if it will happen. Sorry for an editorial remark. [2:43:08] Speaker C (unidentified): Can we move to the next ordinance, number eight, 26, 27, amending chapter 27 zoning regarding A and G district setbacks and miscellaneous amendments, postponed from October 27th, 2026, [2:43:21] Speaker P (unidentified): six, first reading, pastor will require a majority vote. Okay, I'm going to turn this back over to our [2:43:28] Speaker G (unidentified): planning director, Milan Davida. [2:43:37] Speaker S (unidentified): Okay. [2:43:43] Speaker H (unidentified): this one is again mending zoning now this is to do a couple of different things first is a couple of housekeeping items i won't spend too much time on that the bulk of this is the a and g zone setbacks this bullet at the bottom is from the prior presentation ignore that this is primarily we'll be talking about ang zone front setbacks the miscellaneous text amendment components that are included in here is something that we overlooked we had it actually in the red lines of the housing package that you already passed, but when we were drafting the red lines somehow the bottom of the page got deleted and one of the revisions was omitted. And that's the allow the planning board to review on consent landscape revisions up to 5,000; currently it's at 1,000. So we'd like to reinsert that. And then because that housing package allowed certain staff level reviews, that's a state requirement now. We have some provisions in our stormwater standards that read in the past that the planning board is the only one that can approve them, and that was true in the past, but now because we have a staff level review we just need to make sure it's the review authority, whoever it happens to be. So that's little cleanups. The A&G zone setback stemmed from conversation we had with council when we were doing a housing ordinance. You heard some public comments about can the ordinance go a little bit further. We were not supportive of amending that current package, but we did come back to you and say look we looked into this further. In fact I had a conversation with Councillor West that we've actually been tracking this issue for some time, going back to 2021 I believe is when it was kind of first on our radar, and we found that there's sort of a systemic issue. It's not a one off issue with that one speaker that you heard from. And so we presented that to council at your second reading. It looks like there's a thing here for us to consider as a community fix, and council was interested in hearing that so we bypass workshop. Fully expect potentially for us to be amending, modifying, diving deeper into this ordinance is the first time you're seeing it, but that's the background of where we're coming from on the changes. The at the time that we were talking to you it was in the context of the housing package being considered, and you had not passed that package just yet, and at the time the A and G zone front setback requirement was 20 feet, but the housing package you have already approved the G zone Going from 20 to 10 feet, that's now law, right? So what this ordinance is now amending, or asking to amend, is to take the front setback in the A zone from 20 feet to 10 feet, and the front setback from the G zone from the what you've already approved, 10 feet, down to 5, not 20 to 5 but 10 to 5. It also includes a 1 foot flexibility allowance on a side setback. Both A and G zones have a side setback, side yard setback, of six feet, and if a property owner has a neighbor who's comfortable with it and provides an affidavit saying they're comfortable with it, that they can work together and allow and at one foot grace on that six feet, making it a five foot setback, but the neighbor has to be engaged. We took the neighborhood engagement approach with the side setback because six foot side yard setbacks are fairly narrow. We didn't recommend going much deeper than that without more extensive analysis. So I'm not going to talk about that one so much because I think it's, you know, much more benign. I think I'm more straightforward, but the bulk of the presentation is on this front setback reduction. You saw this image when we were talking in the housing package when I expressed, look, we looked into what this public speaker was advising you on about possibly looking at these front back setbacks, where in the community do we have a situation where the properties in the A&G district do not actually meet the 20-foot required setback? And so what this map depicts with every little black dot is every property we're aware of that is closer to its front property line than the 20 feet that the ordinance requires. All the black dots are non-compliant, and can look a little bit deeper into the map so you can see the context here. So for example, right at the end of this red arrow, there's a little blob with no black dots, and the reason for that, if you look at the zoom in on what's happening there, just for example, these two properties, the red line and where the edge of that blue arrow is, that's the 20 foot from the front setback mark. That building is built to 20 feet, that's why it doesn't show up as black in the map, it's compliant with today's 20 foot setback. Another example where you see the black dot is a scenario like this one on Olive Road. The red edge here along the front is the 20 foot setback, the building's built closer, so that's where a property would come up as black on the map. That's why it's non-compliant, not that it's wrong or bad, it's just that we have a standard, the buildings That they were built over top of are not compliant. The stats in total, which I shared with you already, is in the existing AG zones, again, 20 foot setback. We're about half compliant, half not compliant. The message from a planning perspective is that 50% non-compliance is indicative that the neighborhoods are actually designed differently than what our current vision is for them. And so, is there reason to have that vision? What's the why? Do we have 20 feet if our community is not 20 feet? What's a healthier standpoint just in terms of respecting what the community is in ordinances to see a non-compliance rate in the sub 20 which is what we get to if we're moving the front setbacks to 10 or 5 feet in the context of what we're talking about is the residential a and residential g districts the g district is in our comp plan and in zoning and long-standing bin our infill zone it's the dense zone it's supposed to be the dense zone and so the proposal that you have before you is to allow the a zone to go to 10 feet and the G zone to drop to the 5 feet because it's supposed to do more on those smaller lots, again, that infill potential. So that's, that's the rationale of why we're giving you a one is 10 and one is five basis. They are zones with different purposes. One thing you did not see that I just wanted to share really quickly is you got sort of global statistics for the whole community, and that's that 50 split, but are there neighborhoods where it's like wildly off from that global average and so we started to carve up just certain areas just so we could see you know does that statistic hold if we're getting into individual neighborhoods that people are more familiar with so here's a snapshot of ferry village we have 393 homes in this particular catchment area with the pink outlined properties right now 215 of those so roughly 400 and roughly 200 are complying so still keeping with that 50 split it 's consistent in fairy village moving to a 10 and five front yard setback. This is all in the G zone. So the five was the recommendation. We'd get 31% of the properties more compliant. We'd still have 15% nonconforming. So there's 15% of those 400 properties are still closer to the property line, front property line, than even five feet. Looking at, this is getting closer to Mill Creek in the meeting house, ocean area, 576 properties in this snapshot, shot 324 are compliant today all right so roughly 50 still holding true to that global split if they move this is a zoning if they move to the 10 foot front setback recommended in the ordinance we get a 11 non-conformance rate so again 20 to 10 range but 32 of the properties are now conforming with our suggested setback over in pleasantdale statistic holds true about 200 properties about 100 are compliant 50-50 split this one sees a substantial jump in compliance if we go to five feet from the 20 feet that's there today 50% of the properties would be more compliant but still 14% would be even closer than five feet looking over this is the off Evans the Bonnie Bank Bonnie Breyers the Bonnie's we've got 300 homes in this snapshot 162 so a little bit more compliant with the 20 feet here most of the properties almost all just all but four percent would be closer than the 10 feet so we can dive into these further but we did want to test it and make sure that the global wasn't kind of out of sync with any individual enclave or any individual little neighborhood I did share with the counselors the map that this is a snapshot of I don't know if you've had an opportunity to dive in but we can in the course of discussion if it's helpful zoom in any areas we did try to visualize what that looks like so the yellow blob here is the g zone I'm just going to turn that off so it's easier to see and on any individual property you have the five foot from the front yard setback 10 feet from the front yard setback and then 20 feet which is the law in the a zone today and this random property that is zoomed in on is an example where again the property is edging forward into that 20 foot it's non-conforming today so here's why this is from a housing perspective I think important for us to talk about and wrestle with you have some properties that are compliant you have some properties that are not 50-50 what we're seeing with housing cost of construction is many homeowners are stressed and trying to grow inside their home the first thing they try to do the first thing any contractor architect trust encourage you to do is take your existing foundation and build on top of it. If you're building new foundation, if you're expanding horizontally, your cost of construction go up orders of magnitude. Small additions on the side of your house will grossly outweigh the cost of doubling your square footage if you were to go on top of your existing footprint. The foundation costs are significant and it's much more challenging. So what we've routinely seen and why we've been tracking this issue going back even to 2021 when people come into the building permit office their first question is I've got this hip roof like this property here this property has not come forward to us or maybe they have I didn't this isn't about their personal history this is just an example looking at the architecture here I've got a hip roof here and I've got a tiny little bedroom it's sloped ceilings I can't really do much in there it was an old attic that somebody finished out and I actually need to make a livable space here I need to put in a bedroom with a bathroom because my elderly parents want move in they want them on the ground floor I'm going to go up to the upstairs so I don't have to walk on the stairs or whatever this is what we have to tell them you can't do that because you can't lift the ceiling here because you're in the setback these are the most common scenarios that we have less common scenarios is someone wanting to do like a full tear down and then you know build as close to the tight side and front yards as they possibly can it's the adapting of the home that is difficult it was the example that you heard in that you know speaker that came to you is that they could expand into the interior of their parcel but the cost of that is so significant and when they're talking about adapting homes to new occupants whether growing families aging families or even just new families and buildings that are really small because that's all they could afford to buy these things are pretty significant cost implications so this is why we're raising it up together with a housing discussion. We are also talking about, again, 20 to a 10-foot adjustment. So that's a 10-foot change and a 10 to a 5-foot. So a 5-foot adjustment in the G-zone. That's the scale of addition. That's the scale of expansion on a building that people are being asked to look at. The other important thing, and this isn't necessarily intuitive, is that if you look at these images here, the color bands start from this white line that's the assessor's mapping of the parcel boundary. It's not a survey, but this one is emblematic of most people's scenario, where the property boundary, which is what we measure the 20 feet from, is not where people see the edge of road. And a lot of people make this misconception that my property goes out to the edge of road, or that's where you're measuring 20 feet from. And so if we shrink this down to 5 feet, well heck, someone could build to expansion on their home and go right up onto the street and cause all kinds of safety or other concerns. And that's, that's just not how this is measured. It's measured in from their property line. In our neighborhoods there are very few roads where the right-of-way, the edge-to-edge of properties, this white line to this white line, is less than 50 feet. And so we have quite good right-of-way consistency in through town, which allows us to put two lanes in both directions plus sidewalks like what you see here. This is a 50-foot right-of-way. So the changes that would be enabled with front setback reductions would be allowing, for example, this house to do a bay window that they currently cannot do. Even that would be an addition expanding into the front setback that we'd have to say no to. The biggest one that is, again,, this is anecdotal feedback to you from your code permitting development office. The biggest one that is just hard to tell people is when they want to pop up their roof. It happens frequently and it's because of that cost of trying to maintain the existing foundation and work up from the perimeter. Those are your structural walls. That's where you can do your new joists, open up walls, open up buildings, make the structure more usable. They want to be able to preserve and use that outside perimeter. perimeter. And so most architects will want to try and work with that. And you end up with some more challenging construction if you have to keep the roof where it is here, but you can do your pop-up back here. Those are the things that from a design perspective end up increasing cost of design and increasing cost of execution construction. Weird angles and that kind of thing. So anyway, that's That's the intersect that we see, those are the kind of conversations we see is why this is sort of relevant and why we wrote in the memo there's consistency with our housing policies in the comprehensive plan. And we've argued here because of the black dots here that this isn't incongruous with what we know South Portland to be, which is an older community, not sort of replicated suburban style new construction from 70s and 80s where every house is exactly compliant with the standard that was adopted in the 70s and 80s. Our community neighborhoods are older. It's a five foot setback to a zero foot setback to a 40 foot setback to a 30 foot setback to a 10 foot setback. It's dynamic. These are the New England villages. This is our reality. For at least 50% of the properties, it's not in that 20 foot zone. So it's where we felt there was a systemic issue, an opportunity to look at this as an ordinance fix, not as a one-off on an individual property case. I think some or all of you may be familiar, the Board of Appeals did grant a waiver, or a variance, excuse me, on that one case of those homeowners are moving forward. They have had their issue resolved. But we can maybe learn from that, right, if it was justified in that case maybe the ordinance can be examined so that's why this is before you. Again, the recommendation is that a drops to 10, G drops to 5 from 10, and we have some of those miscellaneous cleanups in there as well. Questions? [2:59:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Councilor Matthews, did you, yes, come on. Mine is okay, so I just want to make sure because of the five foot, so you're saying that it's how many, just give me a guesstimate how many feet in before the five feet starts on the edge of the road. And the reason I'm thinking is example my street doesn't have sidewalks, okay, last year we had a lot of snow, the paws come by, they're taking up the first three feet of the yard, a lot of people with the off-street parking and all that stuff, so where does the five feet actually start approximately on most yards with no sidewalks, so I'm just [3:00:38] Speaker H (unidentified): grabbing an area in fairy village because i know that there aren't sidewalks in a number of these areas so you can see the edge of the yellow there would be the start of the property line right the thickness of what the right-of-way is that distance right it's not necessarily set but it's generally 50 feet through some of these like the smaller local streets but the start of the yellow is the edge of right away to this right everything that's not in color in between here is right away city right away but just anecdotally give you an answer the thickness of the yellow and pink lines here is roughly i think we would say the thickness of this uncolored area between the edge of pavement and the start of the yellow pink and pink and yellow together is 10 feet so in most streets where they have one lane in one direction one the other no sidewalks and it's just lawn it looks like somebody's lawn is actually probably about 10 feet in from the edge of pavement is where their true property Starts, and then the front setback would be another five feet from that. So if you were to build, you'd be building 15 feet from the edge of pavement if you were to max it out. Thank you. [3:01:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Sorry, I thought Councillor Scott, I just had a question. [3:01:52] Speaker P (unidentified): About if you have, I know you went through some neighborhoods, but if you had a sense of the number of properties in the G zone that were maybe not less than five feet but between five and ten feet from the right-of-way, like they're essentially non-conforming to the ten-foot standard, or that they exist, that the front of the property is between 5 and 10 feet from the right-of-way. [3:02:24] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, I don't have a just for the G zone. So this 5,941 properties is A and G together. But you can see of those properties, if we set the setback to 10 feet, then 5,089 are compliant. If we drop it further, there's another 634 that are compliant. So the difference there is, well, let's just call this 5100 and 5600, so about 500 homes become compliant. So 500 homes exist between 10 and 5 feet between the two zones, though in the two zones the A zone is bigger than the G zone, but the G zone has smaller lots. Yeah, we could do some analysis to figure out exactly how. [3:03:07] Speaker P (unidentified): Many are in each, but okay, yeah, thank you. Councillor West, I just want to ask that. [3:03:13] Speaker S (unidentified): Photo of, first of all, I hope you could leave the photo up that shows the houses with the blue and the pink and all, and was that particular one in an A or G? [3:03:23] Speaker H (unidentified): This one is Fairy Village, which all of this is covered in G's. Don't you just go. [3:03:27] Speaker S (unidentified): Down a little bit closer, you know, go a little bit closer, so, and just leave it up there, because I think when we have questions it's just useful to see other [3:03:37] Speaker A (unidentified): questions. Okay, public comment on this, the a, the G setbacks. No, alrighty, it's closed, councillors. Councillor West, move for passage. Thank you very much, councillors. I think councillor Scott Walker, which was councillor Scott, okay [3:04:07] Speaker S (unidentified): Now I can explain why I don't like this, and the phone is useful for starts. If we are worried about existing houses not being able to put in a window or not being able to do something to their roof, the way to address that is through our non-conforming sections of our zoning ordinance. They're very clear, they have all these provisions, and it's certainly easy enough, and there's both horizontal Enlargements inside the required setback, and they have what we can do and what you can't do. And if you want to have to allow some windows, just go ahead and change it. My big concern, particularly the G, I'm really much more concerned about the G than the a. I'm a strong supporter of our off-street parking requirements during the winter months. I think it makes a very, it's huge for our community to have efficient snow removal, and if you spend time driving around Portland in the winter you can see the difference between our city and that city, and if you look at these photos you can see right now and this isn't a snowy time for these cars to pull off the street, they're in what we would consider to be the front right away. The real thing that's going to go on in our community isn't people remodeling, because we can address that through the non-conforming. It's what's going on in my neighborhood where people are tearing down houses and rebuilding houses. And right now, they're somewhat limited. But because of the changes, and I support walkable neighborhoods, and I support increased density. But because we can now have ADUs, if we go to a five-foot setback in the G zone, which is all of Ferry Village, quite a bit of the Lower Meeting Hill, it is going to be a financial incentive to tear down some of our smaller existing houses and put two units on and take advantage of that five-foot setback, and then that in turn is going to put more pressure on parking and streets, and I just don't think that's where we want to go as a community at this time. So for that reason, I would offer an amendment to leave the G-Zone at 10, delete that part of the ordinance, and go ahead and make the change in the A-Zone to 10 as proposed, but keep it. So I don't know if that's clear enough, but that's what I'm going to do. [3:06:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Are you making, did you make a formal amendment motion? [3:06:50] Speaker S (unidentified): Yes, and it was seconded. All right. I don't have exactly the part of the ordinance. I guess it's just the chart, the little chart that has a line through the 10 and has a 5. We just take that out. Yes, I'm sorry. [3:07:04] Speaker P (unidentified): I was going to make the same, but I think the motion that you were making was to basically remove the G change from 10 to 5. Correct. Which was the same motion that I was going to make, but you beat me to it. It. So that is what I understood you to be moving. And I second it. [3:07:23] Speaker H (unidentified): Page four, which is up here in the column of the G zone, we would not be introducing this change. We would leave it at 10 feet. And the A zone would continue to have the 20 dropping down to 10 feet under that amendment. [3:07:39] Speaker S (unidentified): Because if you look at the blue lines, that isn't as much of a problem. The yellow is really going to be a problem with cars pulling off and just moving houses too close to the street. And incentivizing, when the state law came up about the ADUs, I raised the issue and was told at that time the setbacks will stay the same. Anybody who wants to put an ADU will have to comply with the existing setback. And I went to the people who speak, talk to me and said you don't have to worry too much because they're still going to have to comply with the existing setbacks. So now if we reduce the setback this much, we've already reduced the G zone from 20 to 10 in the relatively recent future. We now go down to five. The amount of buildable area that's creating on the lot, it means that it's really going to be physically possible to tear down a lot of these small houses and build two units. And I, and that's not where our neighbor, existing neighborhoods wanted to go. And [3:08:50] Speaker A (unidentified): you meant the relatively recent past, is that what you meant? Yes. [3:08:53] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes. Okay. Who wants to answer question? Yes. So I hear what Councillor West is saying, the concern for her neighborhood, but you're saying that the, what you are seeing in the planning office across the board, a Angie, is not that people are looking to tear down and rebuild, but people are looking to modify the homes that [3:09:17] Speaker H (unidentified): They have to make those homes more livable. Correct, there's more of that than there are new construction, total demo new constructions. But people do total demo a new construction too. And if we remove the [3:09:30] Speaker E (unidentified): G zone from this, then we are essentially, I mean, like your map was great that you sent out, like I plugged in my house, I'm looking at right now, and from basically the, you know, that front part of my kitchen all the way forward is in the blue zone. So the pink zone and the yellow zone are all encompassed. And I'm in the A zone in Thornton Heights. But it sounds like if we remove the G zone that we are making life harder for people who live in that area that do want to stay in their homes and do want to modify it at the expense of maybe a smaller portion of people who are looking to tear down and build. [3:10:09] Speaker P (unidentified): Sorry, can I ask a clarifying question on that, though? [3:10:12] Speaker A (unidentified): But I don't, did she get an answer? Did you get an answer from the law? [3:10:16] Speaker P (unidentified): Sorry, I meant to try to help. [3:10:18] Speaker H (unidentified): We would be making life harder under the assumption that the law is five feet, but the status quo is that it's now ten feet. Right, that's what I mean. So we're not providing that additional five-foot incentive in removing it. [3:10:33] Speaker E (unidentified): If someone came in and wanted to raise their hip roof and do that in Ferry Village, and they were nine feet from the front feet, and we can't, we don't make this change, we've [3:10:41] Speaker H (unidentified): just made their life harder. We would say no, you cannot do it for that. [3:10:48] Speaker A (unidentified): I see, Counselor West. I know that Counselor Scott, Counselor Scott did, is this a follow-up [3:10:55] Speaker P (unidentified): to this question? Well, I think this gets back to what I think Counselor West was asking about and what I think Counselor Walker is concerned about, and what I wanted to clarify this entire conversation is that it seems to me that without a setback change there should be aspects of our ordinance that says if your footprint of your existing building is nine feet from the right-of-way and our ordinance change that we're making tonight is ten feet, that you should be able to do anything above that conform like non-conforming footprint, and I think we should figure out how to make that change to allow people to build up from that footprint regardless of the setback, because that is an existing non-conforming space. But that seems different to me than an ordinance change that is to five feet or whatnot. But I guess that's a little bit of my question, what I thought you were getting at is like, that is covered by other aspects of the ordinance, or could we [3:12:00] Speaker S (unidentified): Counselor West, yeah, that is what I was, I and sometimes probably I talk too fast and say, but I was talking about our non-conforming sections have specific sections that are called horizontal enlargements within the required setback and vertical enlargements within the required setback. And they allow certain things, and they don't allow other things. And if we're talking about existing houses and families that need more room for children or whatever, I think the sensible way to do it is to have the non-conforming sections apply. And then if you look and the reason why the photograph is important, if you look at these houses in Ferry Village, what we're talking about right now is the edge of the blue has already taken place, in other words, the edge of the, so go all those houses are conforming, see, they're they're conforming with the edge of the blue. There's no problem, and I don't, I might be fine if just go around it, I mean I'll be kind of one, as you know we own a property in Fairy Village, if you want to see ours I can assure you it conforms, there's a good, and you can see the three, the blue here, most of these are conforming, it's not important, so you don't need to go up to the orange or whatever you call that other one in order to have these houses be conforming, with a real concern is, and I will be glad to give you a tour, a walking tour of how many homes have been torn down, and there I know it's an infill zone, but there's not that much room for infill anymore because we've we've done a really good job in the last 15 years of infill, since ever since they changed the code back to [3:13:41] Speaker H (unidentified): allow the infill, we can certainly do the non-conforming as, and it does tackle different situations, right, so you have an existing property and you have an inherited structure that you're taking on, can we give you more relief to do more with that property irrespective of what the ordinance wants you to do, we can, that's the whole non-conforming section is to give them flexibility that wouldn't be available to someone who has an empty lot and wants to build, they have to comply with all the standards, correct, I don't know what council wants to provide as guidance, that would be a new ordinance, we can come back and we can look at all that, we did consider the non-conforming piece of that, the trade-off that you should be aware of. And I remember this, Scott, you may remember this, and perhaps Councilor Pride, you were on council at that time. When I first got to South Portland in 2020, very first ordinance we all took up was an issue because the community was concerned. When we establish a standard, there's meaning and reason to do that. And so the point of non-conformance is to get that issue fixed. And in that case, it was land uses that were not appropriate for that area or not consistent with that area. If we call them non-conforming land uses, why would we give an opportunity for them to continue and be re-established if we've made the determination that they're inappropriate? So that's why we started this by saying, what is the issue here? What is the concern that we're trying to achieve and protect with the 20 feet? Is there a health safety that's preeminent, right? And really this gets down to neighborhood aesthetics. It's fine to have a 20-foot standard, but if we end up working through the non-conforming ordinance, most of our community is built out. We don't have green fields where new construction is the defining nature of our construction. It is working with existing properties. And what we're going to say is we want everybody to be at 20, but virtually every property in South Portland is built upon, and we want to allow those people to continue to go at are we actually in fact comfortable with 5 or 7 or 10 or whatever that number is so why make the law inconsistent with what we're saying we're comfortable with if most properties or many properties or enough properties are already there and we want to be able to give them the pass through the non-conforming route That's that's the question that we started with, and that's why the statistics on just how many are considered conforming and non-conforming is, I think, informative, is what are we as a community? And what are we comfortable with as a community? And let's just put that into the law rather than say, we're comfortable with something that's not our norm, and then we'll give a back way entrance into that for existing properties. And I get the rationale, and we have the zoning tool to do it. But I just want to give some background, I guess, to why we took this approach rather than the non-performing approach. They're both very available. [3:16:39] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, and just reminding everybody we still have this motion for the amendment. [3:16:44] Speaker E (unidentified): On the floor, so yes, counselor, any risks to the city because almost 50 percent of our properties are considered non-conforming? Oh, that's good. Any [3:17:03] Speaker A (unidentified): other counselor want to speak to the amendment idea? Okay, I'm giving you all fair warning that I don't see anyone and then about to ask for a vote. Everybody ready? All right, who is in favor of the amendment? One, two, three, four, five. And who opposes? Two. So the amendment carries. Now we have to look at the whole thing, but are we ready to do that? I'm actually gonna make, well, I don't know if I need [3:17:41] Speaker D (unidentified): to make an amendment here, but I do want to make a short comment and possibly an amendment. The amendment is really a Scrivener's error from a while ago. You may notice that 27.303 refers at the very end of the paragraph to, or improvements as outlined in Section 27.303 and Section 37.303, 37 would be Chapter 37, which doesn't exist. So I'm guessing that 37 should just be another 27. I don't know, do I guess I'll make a motion to amend that to change that 37 to a 27 as long as we're amending the [3:18:20] Speaker H (unidentified): whole ordinance. This ordinance isn't amending that section and it may have been just a typo. I went and looked back at the published order. Yeah, and it's okay then, great. [3:18:32] Speaker S (unidentified): There actually is a code section that allows the manager to collect correct clerical errors [3:18:39] Speaker G (unidentified): in the code. Errors, I guess, yeah. [3:18:41] Speaker D (unidentified): Then I'm going to just point that out and hope that the manager corrects that error because it is in the published code. I did double check when I saw that. But in case anybody out there wonders if I actually read all of this stuff, please remember this moment. Bartleby. But you know I hear loud and clear what counselor West is saying and I appreciate the hard work that went into this and support the motion as amended. Okay, well, let's see if anyone [3:19:14] Speaker A (unidentified): else does. All in favor? All right, that is a unanimous vote for the first read of the ordinance. Thank you. We're now at citizen discussion part two. Does anyone want to make public comment? All right, public comments close. Communication from the city manager, please. I'll limit it to [3:19:39] Speaker G (unidentified): Two quick things I just wanted to remind everybody. Next week on Wednesday 11th is Veterans Day. The Veterans Day parade will begin at 10 30 starting at SMCC flowing down Broadway. Will be followed by speeches in the park at the Veterans War Monument. And then also on December 8th we are scheduled to have a resume workshop on city facilities. The P3 folks developers will be here seeking some clarity from council before they proceed with their next steps related to the Mahoney project. And also we'll be looking to have a follow-up discussion related to the failed public safety bond. So I just want to give council and heads up on that and public heads up on that as well. All right any [3:20:32] Speaker A (unidentified): counselors with a round robin item? Yes counselor what it's got. I just wanted to thank the city [3:20:40] Speaker P (unidentified): clerk and staff for a very well-run election. I think there was a lot of fear that was, yes, thank you for it running very smoothly and working late into the hours and greatly appreciate it. And America is better for you. [3:21:00] Speaker A (unidentified): And I just want to appreciate our police officers or firefighters, our emergency medical technicians. And I believe that I am speaking for the community in that appreciation. So all right counselors motion to adjourn [3:21:20] Speaker S (unidentified): excellent. I just want to remind the community that tomorrow a free concert seven o'clock at night at our high school auditorium. The Jazz Ambassadors of the U.S. Army Field Band will be giving a free concert seven to eight thirty tomorrow night if you're looking for something [3:21:37] Speaker A (unidentified): exciting to do in South Portland. Yeah, sounds good. All right, more chirpy little robins? No. Motion to adjourn. Seconded by Unanimous. Yay, thank you.