← Back to MaineScanner

York County Commissioners Hear Property Tax Abatement Request for Livingston Homeowners

2026-11-04 · 19m · Source: Commissioners Regular Meeting 11-04-2026 (York County Commissioners (Vimeo))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Welcome to the regular meeting for the County Commissioners meeting for in the County of York. I welcome everybody to stand and salute the flag. I'd like to make this by the way I think we're entering public. We'll start off with public comments. Do we have any public comments in the auditorium? Seeing none. I don't see anything on Zoom either. Let's move to approve the meetings, the minutes, rather, the following meetings. [0:55] Speaker B (unidentified): Move to approve the minutes of the meeting dated October 21st, 2026 as submitted. [1:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. We have a motion by Commissioner Clark, a second by Commissioner Shannette. Any discussions? All in favor? Unanimous. Next, we move on to the treasurer's warrants. [1:16] Speaker B (unidentified): I move we approve the warrants dated October 21st, 2026 in the amount of $964,230.89. [1:26] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. We have a motion by Commissioner Clark, a second by Commissioner Shinnett. Any discussion? All in favor? [1:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Unanimous. I move we approve the warrants dated October 28th, 2026 in the amount of $785,919.44. 44 cents. [1:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. We have a motion by commissioner Clark is second by commissioner Chinette. Any discussions on favor. Unanimous. Next to hear from any reports from the County commissioners. Do we have anything? [2:02] Speaker B (unidentified): I would just like to congratulate the commissioners who were reelected after a hard fort battles yesterday and a congratulation to both of you.
New Business
[2:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Any new business. [2:18] Speaker C (unidentified): Mr. Chair, first item of business tonight, you do have to hear a property tax abatement out of the town of Livington. It's here on denial out of the town. Here tonight is the McKenzie's, Robert and Nancy, as well as, I'm sorry, but I forget your name, from Greg Clifford. Okay. And that from McDonald and Associates. Okay. Very good. Thank you. So commissioners, typically what we do we swear them in as well turn it over we'll let the mckenzie's come up here i will swear you in because this is a an actual hearing and so we'll ask you to state your name swear you in and then allow you to proceed with your testimony if there are any additional documents that you need us to have please give those to me i'll hand them out and barring any questions from the commissioners. Are you ready to start with the hearing? Okay. So, again, I'll have you come up, Nancy, if you would, please. [3:32] Speaker D (unidentified): So, you know, nothing but God. Okay, thank you. [3:41] Speaker C (unidentified): And just start for the record that she's Yeah, just for the record, we do have the commissioners do have everything that you gave us and so that's what i used to yep and so they have all of the documentation so if there's something new please identify that for us. [4:16] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. Okay. So where do I start? [4:24] Speaker C (unidentified): You have, yeah, we have everything, take a deep breath and just state your case. [4:30] Speaker D (unidentified): kind of lengthy. I'm just going to start at the beginning. That's fine. Yeah. The floor is yours. Okay. About a year ago, we were sitting around talking with neighbors and the subject of property taxes came up. they asked us if we had ever seen our property tax card. We asked what that was because we are first-time homeowners and aren't very knowledgeable about taxes, assessments, etc. [Speaker B (unidentified): We trusted our] municipal authority for doing the right thing. So anyway, we were curious, decided to ask the town of Livington for our detailed tax card out of curiosity. In August of 2024, we received a copy of her tax card. The document was obviously not ours, or so we thought. The card was somewhat illegible, but looked like it stated that we had three bedrooms and two baths, plus other errors. I asked my husband if he ever talked to the person who would have filled this card out. He said no, one ever came out that he knew of. Along with receiving a tax card, the clerk mentioned that there would be a townwide reassessment in December of 2025. Not knowing if these errors were significant as far as our taxes go, we decided to wait for the reassessment in December to finally verify the incorrect tax card. We had no idea when assessors would be out to reassess our home. We didn't receive anything in the mail. Maybe it was posted at the town hall or something. I don't know, but I don't hang out at the town hall. I don't read town reports. I just don't care about other people's business. But anyway, luckily, I was at home when O'Donnell Associates came out to the house to assess. I saw him walking around my backyard, asked who he was, and invited him in and gave him a tour. He verified that the tax card that was on file was ours and that we were listed as having three bedrooms and two baths. He corrected all of the errors because we only have one bedroom, one bath. For those of you who didn't know that, less than a month later, I requested a copy of the town of our new tax card and was told they probably wouldn't be available until April of 2026. So April came and went, and I made another request, and I was told by the clerk that the assessors would be handling letters directly when they are finished. On May 4, again, I made a request for a copy since April had come and gone, and I was told they would be mailed out this week. Later that week, I received a new tax bill from Livington, which was $2,052.64 less than the previous year's tax bill, which was almost half of what last year's tax bill was. So, okay, I guess it did make a big difference. I never did receive a copy of my new tax card, but I did receive something from O'Donnell Associates and they told me I could go on their website and I went on their website and got my new tax card. This would be the burden of proof that I needed to file for debate. On the original tax card from the town, again very eligible for being such a powerful document, was missing the date of the assessment when it was made. At some point in the last 20 years, someone wrote at the top EST 6-23-2005. I'm assuming EST meant estimated. Because if you look at the bottom where there's the date, there was no date. So I'm assuming it meant estimated. Since 2005, the estimated date, I've been paying almost double what I should owe for taxes. I will later explain how I came up with the 49% over-assessed, which is that I just gave you. So 20 years. We're not talking $25 to $30 per year here. We are talking $1,700 to $1,800 a year for at least the last three years that we've been overcharged for taxes. taxes. Add 16 more years of that, it paid 49% more than what we should, and picture. After gathering my word of proof, I filed an application for abatement on August 12, 2026 for three years of payment. Three years out of 20. We knew certainly that the town would not want to pay us back 20 years of all our payments. We thought three years out of 20 would be more than fair, the town put it to me. A few weeks later, on September 3rd, the town wrote us a check for one year's abatement, one year, not a 20, with no explanation as to how they justified me. Apparently, I'm not without fault. I should have filed three separate applications for abatement, one for each year. However, all three of those would have been and exempt kids except for line five, the tax union for abatement. My mistake. Also, I have learned that there is a 185-day period after tax community in which to file for an abatement for each year. That would have been impossible in this case, as I wasn't even aware of the issue and didn't have the burden of proof that I needed until I received my new tax bill in May. my mistake not filing within the 185 days their mistake charging me double all my property taxes for 20 years if the state of Maine feels that abating three years out of 20 is not the right thing to do and that the 185 day non-compliance justifies the ten on keeping 20 years of my grossly overstated tax payables And all I can say is I hope the money that I donated to the town of Littleton for the last three years, unbeknownst to me, was used for something honorable like feeding the poor or feeding assistance for the elderly. That's my story. Any questions? No? No. I have a question for clarification purposes. They granted you an abatement for what year? year did they adjust 2025 which was also 185 over the 185 days but they made an exception okay so they did do 85 and 2026 was taken care of that's 2026 i got my new bill yes okay thanks to odong and did they indicate that if you had filed a separate form for the other two years, you would have gotten the abatement? No, they didn't say that I would have gotten it. Oh, okay. It's like you have 185 days for any year, from any tax commitment date. So the other two years, yeah, I would have been blown away. But they say. No, the statute is quite clear on 185 days and how far we can go back. So I didn't know if they had kind of made a somewhat commitment type, but I don't hear that. [12:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Mr. Chair, just a question. When were you notified or when did you discover the 185-day requirement in terms of filing and abatement? Because it seems like that has popped up in your testimony, that's popped up in the paperwork that we have as the rules and the parameters that we have to operate by. So at what point did you realize that was the rule and that was the expectation? [12:53] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, I did quite a bit of extensive research and went out to main.gov, got some documents, 841, 706, what was it, bulletin number 10. and somewhere in there i saw that because i wanted to make sure i was doing the right thing oh sure absolutely but it didn't it didn't phase me really because i didn't know how that would apply to this situation okay you know i mean sure let's do the right thing okay thank you so much [13:27] Speaker F (unidentified): you're welcome nothing else [13:35] Speaker C (unidentified): thank you thank you thank you greg come on up good greg if i could just have you raise your right hand and you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth so help you god i do okay thank you very much missioners i have just a side note i have other individuals that are entering the meeting room the waiting room here on zoom and you know from time to time what happens when i let individuals in so just be aware sometimes we get zoom bombed yeah so you know it's not nice yeah it's not a pleasant experience so but i'm going to let them in yeah let me just ask a side question ema are you expecting any additional folks here perhaps i can check yeah why don't you come up megan we'll let them in and just promptly exit them if we have to you don't know those people i'd [14:43] Speaker A (unidentified): watch out for that big trouble fellow yeah [14:48] Speaker C (unidentified): well we're all adults here good job thank you we just want to be a little extra cautious here so okay greg why don't you go ahead the floor is yours at this point in time [15:23] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. So, again, I'm Greg Clifford with O'Donnell & Associates. We do the assessing work for the town of Leamington, and we're just here defending their decision to only grant one of the three years of abatement requests by the McKenzie's. and we're citing title 36 section 841 which lays out the authority that the assessors have to grant abatements we've already discussed the 185 days after commitment and basically some municipal officers you know they can grant up to three years but they can't do so for an error in valuation, which is what this circumstance represents. So that's basically it. They don't have the authority. This didn't represent an illegality, an error, or an irregularity in the assessment. It was an error in valuation. [16:33] Speaker E (unidentified): I have a question. So Greg, help me to understand the difference between an error in valuation and an error in assessment? Because to me, if there's an error in valuation, then the assessment is going to be incorrect. So help me to understand the difference there. Right. So an illegality, examples of [16:56] Speaker F (unidentified): illegalities would be, you know, if you're being taxed for a building that wasn't on your property, where if a tax bill went to the incorrect owner those are illegal assessments but in terms of the error and valuation like that could come up in many different ways right if no one had been to the property for 20 years and you know depreciation hadn't been captured no one had been inside previously and they didn't know that you know So some aspects of the building were unfinished. These are all examples of errors in valuation. [17:39] Speaker E (unidentified): So when was the last time you visited the property and did an in-person assessment? [17:45] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, we started working with Livington in 2025, and we made the revaluation visit in either December, 2025. [17:57] Speaker E (unidentified): prior to that when was the last in-person visit just as she said there's no inspection date [18:04] Speaker F (unidentified): on the old property card and there's an estimated that somebody showed up in 2005 [18:11] Speaker E (unidentified): okay and i want to just kind of go back to the assessment versus valuation it's my understanding that it's an error or I'm trying to understand the error in the assessment piece of that isn't just necessarily that it's irregular, that there could be an error in the assessment itself that could stem from valuation, correct?