Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
Public Comment
[0:15] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, everyone. I call the Westbrook Planning Board meeting Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026 to order. This meeting will be offered as a hybrid meeting accommodating both in-person and remote participation. The link and phone number to join the meeting via Zoom is located on the Planning Board agenda, which can be found on the City of Westbrook website, westbrookmaine.com slash agenda center. Where public comment is permitted, members of the public attending remotely will have the opportunity to provide remote testimony. If you wish to speak during a public hearing or public comment use the raise hand function through zoom or dial star 9 on your phone when instructed by the planning board chair comments will only be accepted during the public hearing or public comment period and should remain specific to the application that is being discussed roll call orlando
[1:00] Speaker B (unidentified): lucas schrag orianna farnum and robin tannenbaum are all absent kevin price here. Nancy Litter Capes. Here. Jason Frazier. Here. Karen Axelson. Here. Vice Chair John Turcotte. Here. And Chair Larry McWilliams is also absent.
[1:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Alright, the first thing on the agenda is to have the minutes of October 6th, 2026 adopted. May I have a motion please? So moved. And second? I second. Alright, roll call vote please.
[1:36] Speaker B (unidentified): Kevin Price. Yes. Nancy Littrokapes. Yes. Jason Frazier. Yes. Karen Axelson.
[1:41] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. John Tarkoff. Yes. All in favor, none opposed. All right. So the next is our regular business. Orlando, can you read that item into the record?
[1:58] Speaker B (unidentified): Item number 22-000604, site plan approval extension request, 860 Spring Street, Bolas Asset Management. THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A FOURTH EXTENSION OF THE APPROVAL GRANTED ON NOVEMBER 1, 2022 FOR A 15,240 SQUARE FOOT BUILDING ADDITION LOCATED AT A60 SPRING STREET. THE REQUESTED EXTENSION WOULD EXTEND THE APPROVAL DATE BY ONE YEAR THROUGH NOVEMBER 1, 2027. TAX MAP 003, LOT 101A, ZONE INDUSTRIAL PARK DISTRICT. ALL
[2:32] Speaker A (unidentified): RIGHT. APPLICANT PRESENTATION, PLEASE. GOOD EVENING, BOARD.
[2:35] Speaker C (unidentified): My name is Jay Connell, it's Spago Technics, and as Alondo had mentioned, I'm seeking approval for a site plan approval extension of one year for 860 Spring Street. I guess any questions or comments?
[2:56] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, first, I guess it is a public hearing, so does anyone from the public have any comments on this extension request? Seeing none, are there any on Zoom?
[3:05] Speaker B (unidentified): if there's anyone participating via zoom and would like to speak please raise your hand
[3:11] Speaker A (unidentified): i'm seeing none all right so let's close the public hearing so well i'll just go to the everyone on the board first anyone else have any questions none all right so i do see that this is the fourth request correct all right and so is the specific one just an issue of cost this time around I'm sorry was that the specific reason is it because the costs yes
[3:37] Speaker C (unidentified): my understanding is that just due to interest rates and the current economic situation that they have not over the past three years been able to find somebody but that they're hopeful within the next year to get somebody in that space and get the develop development under construction prior to November next
[4:07] Speaker A (unidentified): year all right I mean just kind of an unwritten rule that you definitely get one you probably get two or on the fourth I understand that financial constraints are affecting everything but all right there is a motion on page what IS THIS? TWO OF THE PACKET?
[4:28] Speaker D (unidentified): MR. CHAIR. I MOVE TO APPROVE THE REQUEST FROM BULOS ASSET MANAGEMENT FOR AN ADDITIONAL ONE-YEAR EXTENSION ON THE SITE PLAN APPROVAL TO EXTEND THROUGH NOVEMBER 1, 2027 FOR A PLUS OR MINUS 15,240 SQUARE FOOT BUILDING ADDITION LOCATED AT 860 SPRING STREET, TAX MAP 003, LOT 101, ZONE INDUSTRIAL PARK DISTRICT, EXCEPT AS NOTICED IN THIS MEMO, ALL PREVIOUSLY APPROVED FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL ASSOCIATED WITH THE NOVEMBER 1, 2022 APPROVAL REMAIN APPLICABLE.
[5:09] Speaker A (unidentified): IS THERE A SECOND? SECOND. ROLL CALL VOTE, PLEASE.
[5:15] Speaker B (unidentified): KEVIN PRICE. YES. NANCY LITTER-KAPES. YES. JASON FRASER. YES. KAREN AXELSON.
[5:22] Speaker A (unidentified): YOU ARE ALL SET.
New Business
[5:25] Speaker E (unidentified): NOW ON TO NEW BUSINESS.
[5:33] Speaker B (unidentified): ITEM 26-000847, LAND USE ORDINANCE AMENDMENT, SECTION 335-7.1, VILLAGE REVIEW OVERLAY ZONE. THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS INCLUDE MODIFICATIONS TO THE VILLAGE REVIEW OVERLAY ZONE REVIEW PROCESS AS A PART OF A CITYWIDE INITIATIVE TO REVIEW THE structure and procedures of city boards, committees, and commissions for consistency with legal requirements and local practices.
[6:01] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, staff presentation, and that is you.
[6:04] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, so as was workshopped last month with the board, the city council is going through a process of looking at all of the city's boards, committees, and commissions for just modernization and consistency throughout the different boards. Two of those boards have items in the land use ordinance, AND SO THE VILLAGE REVIEW OVERLAY COMMITTEE AND THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS, THOSE AMENDMENTS ARE BEING BROUGHT TO THE PLANNING BOARD FOR REVIEW. BASED OFF OF LAST MONTH'S OR AS EXPRESSED DURING LAST MONTH'S WORKSHOP, THERE WERE SOME QUESTIONS AND CONCERNS REGARDING THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS AND SO WE'VE SORT OF SEPARATED THE TWO TO BRING TONIGHT JUST THE VILLAGE REVIEW ITEM AND THEN WE'LL BE COMING BACK AT A FUTURE MEETING WITH THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALED ITEMS WITH JUST SOME ADDITIONAL INFORMATION AND CONTEXT FOR THE SO THE VILLAGE REVIEW OVERLAY ZONE, THIS AFTER CONSIDERATION IN THE SEPTEMBER WORKSHOPS COMMITTEE MEETING, SORRY, AND COUNCIL MEETING, IT WAS DETERMINED THAT THE ACTUAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE WOULD BE SUNSET, BUT THE STANDARDS CURRENTLY REMAIN. THE INTENT OF THIS IS BEING THAT THOSE VILLAGE REVIEW MEETINGS WILL ACTUALLY OCCUR AT THE PLANNING BOARD LEVEL NOW, WHERE THEY'RE RECORDED, IT'S EASIER ACCESS FOR THE PUBLIC TO PARTICIPATE IN THEM, AND have that public conversation happen in this meeting. What we are interested in doing as part of this, we met with the Village Review Overlay Committee to discuss this with them, and there was a recommendation that there's a lot of development that's coming in that seems to be different than what the anticipated development was going to be when these standards were initially put in place. There's several waivers of the standards that often come forward when it comes to the board because the way that the buildings are being sized, some of the standards don't make sense. So what we'd like to do is we would like to have a holistic kind of look at those, and we're going to invite all current or previously current and past members of the Village Review Overlay Zone to come in and sort of participate in that to look at those standards and update them. So that will be coming to the board in the next couple months. But in the meantime, what we're doing tonight is updating or proposing to update the land use ordinance to be in line with the city council vote that already occurred in September. The only additional item that we're proposing is clarification on the demolition approval as the ordinance currently reads any demolition within the village review requires planning board approval and that's really intended to protect the buildings of historical significance and not necessarily somebody's garage or shed that's falling apart. part. So what we're doing is we're proposing that demolition approval be required for structures that are either listed in or eligible for the National Historic National Register of Historic Places, and that would exempt dangerous buildings or, you know, again, those garages or sheds or things that really weren't intended to be caught up under this ordinance.
[9:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have anyone from the public who wishes to speak on this item? Seeing none, do we have any on Zoom
[9:19] Speaker B (unidentified): who wish to speak on the side if there's anyone participating via zoom and would like to speak
[9:24] Speaker A (unidentified): please raise your hand i'm seeing none all right we'll close the public hearing staff you could respond to yourself but when we go to the board does anyone have any comments about this
[9:36] Speaker G (unidentified): proposed amendment mr chair one question i noticed that with the demolition approval it kind of has the planning board chair as one of the kind of not reviewers but involved the recommendation process prior to it but it may not need to come to the planning board is that does that process where the planning board chair is involved to that level exist anywhere else or is that kind of a new role for the chair it does not that would be a new role okay thank you any
[10:07] Speaker D (unidentified): others I DO HAVE SOME COMMENTS, QUESTIONS. I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS I FIND VALUABLE ABOUT V-RAWS IS THAT THEY ARE SPECIFICALLY FOCUSED ON THAT VERY SPECIFIC SET OF ORDINANCES. WHEN WE BRING THIS INTO THE PLANNING BOARD, WE ARE DEALING WITH THINGS THAT ARE ALL OVER THE NUMBER OF ZONES IN THE CITY. all kinds of different projects and different phases and different stages and i think that viras has given some really useful comments to us about downtown because they can really focus in and i don't know that we'd have the same luxury to focus in that deeply as a planning board because we get our materials what like the thursday or friday in advance of a meeting and if we're away for a weekend you know there goes that opportunity to review so in any case i think you know for the one or two times that they meet per year to look at these projects i still consider them quite valuable and also you know i know that there's at least one architect and historic preservationists and they kind of they volunteer their time right or they get a STIPEND OR SOMETHING. THAT'S QUITE A GIFT TO THE COMMUNITY THAT PEOPLE WILL STEP UP AND DO THAT AND REALLY FOCUS ON THOSE SPECIFIC PARTS OF OUR DOWNTOWN.
[11:47] Speaker F (unidentified): IS IT OKAY IF I RESPOND? YEAH, SURE. I AGREE AND I COMPLETELY UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'RE SAYING AND I THINK WHAT WE'RE LOOKING TO DO IS, BECAUSE A LOT OF TIMES WHEN THE APPLICATIONS ARE IN FRONT OF THIS BOARD, YOU ARE LOOKING AT THE SITE PLAN AND THE UTILITY PLANS AND EVERYTHING. FOR THESE VILLAGE REVIEW APPLICATIONS LOOKING TO HAVE A SPECIFIC VILLAGE REVIEW ITEM. SO IT WOULD NOT BE WHILE YOU'RE ALSO OR IT WOULD BE AT LEAST A PRESENTATION AND CONVERSATION SPECIFIC FOR ARCHITECTURE TO TRY TO REALLY BEEF UP THE FOCUS ON THAT AT THIS BOARD. AND WHAT WE ARE SEEING IS I THINK OF THE LAST GOOD WHILE, AS LONG AS I'VE BEEN INVOLVED WITH THE BOARD, THE FOCUS ON ARCHITECTURE AT THIS LEVEL IS MUCH HIGHER THAN IT WAS WHEN that advisory board originally came on and so that kind of all came into play as to the rationale for shifting that conversation to this board right
[12:45] Speaker D (unidentified): thank you and i did read that in the materials that were provided and i still think that if there was an adjustment in those one or two meetings a year where public could attend i still find value in that committee so that's
[13:02] Speaker A (unidentified): ANY OTHER COMMENT, QUESTIONS? THERE IS A PROPOSED MOTION ON PAGE FOUR OF THE PACKET. MR. CHAIR.
[13:11] Speaker G (unidentified): YES, SIR. A MOTION TO RECOMMEND AN AMENDMENT TO THE CITY OF WESTBROOK LAND USE ORDINANCE SECTION 335-7.1, VILLAGE REVIEW OVERLAY ZONE TO THE CITY COUNCIL TO CONDUCT THE VILLAGE REVIEW PROCESS DURING THE PLANNING BOARD PROCESS.
[13:28] Speaker A (unidentified): IS THERE A SECOND? SECOND. I'LL RELEASE IT. Roll call vote, please.
[13:40] Speaker B (unidentified): Kevin Price. Yes. Nancy Litter Capes. Yes. Jason Frazier. Yes. Karen Axelson.
[13:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. John Turcotte. Yes. All right. I would need a motion to go into workshop, please.
[13:57] Speaker D (unidentified): So moved, Mr. Chair. Do I have a second?
[14:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Roll call vote, please.
[14:02] Speaker B (unidentified): Kevin Price. Yes. Nancy Litter Capes. Yes. Jason Frazier. Yes. Karen Axelson. YES.
[14:10] Speaker A (unidentified): PLEASE READ THE WORKSHOP ITEM INTO THE RECORD.
[14:15] Speaker B (unidentified): ITEM 26-000913, SITE PLAN, SHORELAND ZONE, RIVER WALK NORTH, CITY OF WESTBROOK. THE PROPOSED PROJECT INCLUDES AN 8-FOOT WIDE RIVER WALK EXTENDING FROM BRIDGE STREET TO GARFIELD STREET. THE RIVER WALK WILL CONSIST OF A MULTI-MODAL PATH WITH PAVED SECTIONS AND AN ELEVATED boardwalk segments in areas where existing site constraints limit at-grade construction. Tax map 032 and 039, lots 223 and 031, zone, city center district, residential growth area 1.
[14:51] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, thank you. Applicant presentation, please.
[15:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Just trying to figure out how this...
[15:04] Speaker F (unidentified): If you control L, that'll put to full screen mode. Thank you. Good
[15:11] Speaker C (unidentified): evening. My name is Craig Burgess. I'm here tonight on behalf of the city of Westbrook. The project team is very excited to initiate this process with the planning board tonight. I'm here with Allie Druin with Crideria Associates, Alex Del Vecchio with Acorn and Robin Sanders in the back with the city of Westbrook. As the notes state, there was a conceptual plan that was originally developed for this river walk back in 2015. and 15. The plan that's in front of you tonight is vastly different than what was originally proposed. The environmental work on this site started back in 2018, and then Acorn Engineering was engaged in 2025. Since then, we've met with the public three times. The first two neighborhood meetings were in August and October of 2025, and then we again met with the public in September of 2026 as part of the DEP process. The team has also met with a variety of the regulatory agencies in an interagency meeting, including Inland Fisheries and Wildlife, Maine DEP, and Army Corps. Overall, we've received really good feedback of the project, and since then we have submitted the Maine DEP individual NERPA application in October of this year. Moving forward, we plan on submitting the major site plan application back to the for boards review next month so it'll be back in front of you in january 2027 and then beyond that in 2027 we plan on initiating the construction documents phase we hope to have permit approvals in march 2027 and then going into bid in construction we hope to have phase one of this project complete for the brownfield construction -eligible portion of the project in September 2028, and then again for the remainder of the project ending in October 2029. So with that said, I'm going to turn it back over to Allie to kind of talk through the environmental work that's been done to date. Thank you.
[17:25] Speaker H (unidentified): All right. So like Craig mentioned, the environmental assessment of this strip of land began in 2018 and we did do some phase two work which is the phase that includes environmental sampling of the soil itself in 2023 those results came back with some sporadic exceedances along the corridor for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and some metals above the main DEP remedial action guidelines. So we're talking about pretty marginal exceedances and conditions pretty typical of most urban settings and would not be unlike anywhere else that we would likely encounter throughout Westbrook. So in 2025, the city was awarded a $4 million EPA Brownfields cleanup grant. grant. And like Craig mentioned, that grant does have a sunset date in September of 2028. So given the current climate with the EPA, there is not likely to be any extensions. So we are sort of in the crunch time of getting that grant spent by that deadline of September SINCE THE GRANT WAS AWARDED, THROUGH THE PRESENT, WE HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH THIS DESIGN TEAM TOWARDS PREPARING A REMEDIAL ACTION PLAN AS WELL AS THE DESIGN THAT ALEX AND CRAIG ARE GOING TO SHARE. AND SOME OF THOSE PUBLIC MEETINGS THAT CRAIG ALSO MENTIONED, WE DID PRESENT THIS REMEDIAL ACTION PLAN, WHICH IS ALSO A REQUIREMENT OF THE EPA Brownfields grant process. So all things came together to create this remedial action plan, which is essentially an environmental media management plan is more commonly what you would likely see the term. And the main goal of how this has been designed is to prevent exposure. And as you can imagine, the typical remedial approach of excavating soil along the river is problematic and has a whole other set of challenges so the goal here is really to prevent exposure through engineering controls and that's going to be through maintaining the vegetation to avoid contact with the soil itself keeping people on this boardwalk surface so that they're not down in the soil they're up on this structure and to prevent disturbance of the soil and maintain that vegetated stability so that we're not losing soil to the river and erosion this plan is also going to establish the means and methods for handling soil and groundwater during the construction itself and then in order to ensure the protection of exposure into the future we're going to have an operation and maintenance plan that's going to require some inspections and maintenance of the vegetation to make sure that all of these provisions as they are constructed continue into the future and then for the very long term a declaration of environmental covenant will be filed against the property which is going to run with the land so that you know 20 50 years down the road when we're all long gone, these measures can still be maintained. And all of this is to ensure that we are complying with the no action assurance letter that the main DEP has issued for the property, which is essentially their approval of everything that we've put together and their agreement that if we implement things as we've stated, that the city won't be liable for the contaminants or future exposure that might occur at the property. Hello,
[21:31] Speaker I (unidentified): my name is Alex. I'm a landscape architect, as Craig mentioned, with Acron Engineering. I'm just going to walk you through the proposal. So the proposed Riverwalk North Trail is located in downtown Westbrook, along the northern side of the Presumpscot River. It essentially links together a number of publicly accessible open spaces in this downtown area, including Cornelia Warren Fields, Riverbank Park, and the forthcoming Sacrapah Park. So it really creates a really great loop for people to sort of access the river within the downtown area. The trail is currently consisting of two types of systems, as people have mentioned, the on-grade portion, which is sort of an asphalt trail system on-grade, as well as an elevated boardwalk structure. There's a number of access points across this system. We have one off of the pedestrian bridge that's somewhat parallel to Bridge Street, and that's sort of a stepped or stair condition. We have an alternative accessible entrance off of Dana Court, as well as an access from Revere Reserve, I'm sorry, and then further in Garfield. The city is also contemplating an additional emergency access point off of King, although this is sort of under development right now. So that's just a consideration at this point. As part of this trail system, the project proposes a small parklet in the portion of the trail that's somewhat expanded. I think it was mentioned that the trail really follows this former utility, Sapi Utility Corridor, and so it's fairly narrow for the majority of its length. However, a certain portion in the center of the site, it really expands in what we've been referring to as a peninsula condition. There's also a number of wetlands in this area. So this little parklet is really located both out of the 25-foot setback from the river's edge, as well as outside of wetlands that have been delineated on site. The intention here is to provide kind of an opportunity for people who are walking across this trail system to kind of engage with the river in a more meaningful or tangible way, really descend from the boardwalk and kind of be surrounded by vegetation and see the river without necessarily seeing other structures in their peripheral vision. The boardwalk system is utilized and proposed across this larger trail system for really two reasons or a number of reasons that are inherent to the constraints of this site. We have some significant slopes as you can see from this diagram in the center of the site and this boardwalk allows to kind of span over those slopes without creating additional disturbance as Allie had mentioned. In that sort peninsula area that we just referenced where the parklet is. We also have this large wetlands area, so utilizing a boardwalk here as well really minimizes disturbance of that wetland because we're kind of bridging over it. We also have throughout this corridor, due to the historic use of its parcel, a number of invasive species, including Japanese knotweed, multiflora rose, some Norway Naples excuse me in consultation with the city and the design team we're thinking of this as an opportunity to test out some invasive control management strategies looking at three different areas of the site to test out these strategies excuse me before they are utilized to really understand success rates as well as maintenance requirements, so it would be a way to really better understand how effective these are prior to implementing them across the site or to initiating construction. construction these really just represent two conceptual sketches that were trying to help us develop the boardwalk and on-trail condition as has been mentioned the trail itself is eight feet wide to allow the passage of pedestrians as well as cyclists we're currently working with the structural engineers as well as the larger design team lighting representatives from different from manufacturers to understand what the appropriate lighting is to implement across the trail system. We're showing something taller here. We're also considering something slightly lower, hoping to balance both safety across the corridor as well as reduced glare and sort of maintaining privacy for adjacent homeowners who are abutting this parcel. Similarly, we're we're investigating security or call boxes being incorporated to the trail so that people feel safe as they're utilizing this space. And then some additional site amenities such as seating or litter receptacles may be incorporated as well. We're also testing right now what the height of the guardrail or handrail might be, whether or not that could be incorporating some screening to sort of separate the trail system from adjacent properties. We'll similarly be investigating and we're currently designing various planting to help create some buffer or screening between the trail system and entry points onto the trail as well as again our adjacent honours. So this in somewhat and what represents the design as it is right now. We're happy to discuss any questions that you may have and hope to keep evolving the design with both the city and the team, as well as feedback from the public to find the sort of best design that really balances the variety of interests across the project.
[28:05] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you staff thank
[28:10] Speaker F (unidentified): you i don't think that there's much to add to the presentation at this point in time this is both a straightforward and incredibly complex project it is it is a trail along the river that has so much going into it there has already been a significant amount of coordination between the different departments in trying to balance the needs of fire and safety and engineering and public services so at this point we are still in a i would say well developed conceptual plan and looking for feedback from the board for the direction that we are at and are moving forward with thank you this is
[28:55] Speaker A (unidentified): open to public comment is there anyone present wishes to speak seeing none is there anyone on zoom
[29:03] Speaker B (unidentified): IF THERE IS ANYONE PARTICIPATING VIA ZOOM AND WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK, PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND. I'M SEEING NONE.
[29:11] Speaker A (unidentified): EVERYONE IS AT THE POLLS. OKAY. I'M GOING TO CLOSE PUBLIC COMMENT AND THEN OPEN IT UP TO THE BOARD. ANY THOUGHTS, DISCUSSION,
[29:18] Speaker F (unidentified): QUESTIONS? MR. CHAIR, IF I COULD JUST THIS WAS UPLOADED TO THE PACKET MATERIALS. WE JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE EVERYONE SAW THAT THERE WASN'T A BUTTER COMMENT THAT SUBMITTED THAT WAS INCLUDED.
[29:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I SAW IT. THERE'S AN EMAIL FROM AN ABUTTER REGARDING TITLE. I AM ASSUMING THAT WOULD BE THE CITY ATTORNEY HAS ALREADY LOOKED INTO THE TITLE ISSUE? YES. THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
[29:43] Speaker C (unidentified): I HAVE A QUESTION. IT'S PROBABLY MORE FOR STAFF.
[29:46] Speaker D (unidentified): YOU MENTIONED $4 MILLION FOR THE BROWNFIELDS. HOW MUCH OF THAT IS AVAILABLE FOR THIS PROJECT?
[30:05] Speaker J (unidentified): GOOD EVENING, ROBIN SAUNDERS, CITY PROJECT MANAGER. THE FULL $4 MILLION IS AVAILABLE FOR THIS PROJECT. The team is working on that. The seed money for that grant came from WIC, so we have $300,000. So if we have anything that's not brownfields eligible, we have $300,000 from WIC that we can also use. Something that might not be brownfields eligible might be, I don't know, I can't think of anything right now because we are in the conceptual design portion of this. So all of the design efforts going into it, everything from the specialty geotechnical engineers that we have to bring in, the helical pier investigations. We're using helical piers so that we minimize those wetland impacts that they talk about and minimize the shoreland impacts and also maximize the slope stability that you're talking about there. You're talking about a river bank that's been sitting there quite nicely for many, years, and we don't want to do anything to impact that. So we're using those $4 million judiciously, but studying it very carefully so that we choose the right construction techniques so that we leave as much of that $4 million on the table as possible. because we have estimated based on the 2015 you heard Craig Burgess talk about the preliminary designs that were done in 2015 they had estimated the full project to be I don't know five to seven million dollars but it wasn't permitted the project was much different this project is actually going through permitting so we're actually making it feasible and I've looked at those costs and subtracted what we're not doing and then applied a five percent annual escalator to the cost and we're probably looking at roughly eight million dollars to construct the whole thing but we do have an estimator on board now who will probably have a more clearer estimate for us by the end of the year by the end of the calendar year so we'll know what the full COST IS, AND MONIQUE CORNETT, THE ECONOMIC AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR WHO IS HERE WITH US TONIGHT, SHE AND I ARE WORKING SHOULDER TO SHOULDER TO CLOSE THAT GAP ON FUNDING. THANK YOU. YOU'RE VERY WELCOME.
[32:49] Speaker E (unidentified): THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. I HAVE QUESTIONS FOR THE DESIGN TEAM. SO WHERE ARE THE AREAS OF CONCERN FOR THE CONTAMINANTS?
[33:02] Speaker H (unidentified): So the, like I mentioned, they're very sporadic. So we collected soil samples probably every, you know, 50 to 100 feet along the corridor. So the assumption is that they're similar between those locations. But not every single location had elevated concentrations. So, but because there is not a real pattern, like it's not one end versus the other end, We do make the assumption that the whole area has some degree of contaminant that's present. So it's not like there's a specific hot spot that it needs to be addressed. We've made the assumption that the whole thing is pretty equivalent.
[33:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. And what kind of samples did you do? Was it soil samples? Yep. So soil samples.
[33:49] Speaker H (unidentified): And then just on the western end where some of the historical mills were, kind of where the current main med building is. There was some older investigations back in the early 2000s, in the 90s, that did have some groundwater investigation that found contaminants back then. So we didn't reassess groundwater just because of the nature of this project, but we do have that older information too. How deep did you go for the samples?
[34:20] Speaker E (unidentified): Are there monitoring wells, or is it just a...
[34:23] Speaker H (unidentified): So Maine DEP looks at the top two feet for a use for park exposure, so those soil samples would have focused on that top two feet. Gotcha.
[34:32] Speaker E (unidentified): And then a question about the boardwalk. Where is it in relation to the 100-year floodplain? So hopefully that's been designed.
[34:48] Speaker C (unidentified): so this is a close-up of the parklet that alex mentioned and the 100 year floodplain is represented with this darker dashed line here so the team is currently looking into that and that is one of the main reasons why we elevated the riverwalk to be above the floodplain So throughout the entire raised riverwalk area, it's actually elevated above the floodplain so that the actual bottom of the structure is completely above that. The only thing that will be below the floodplain would be the helical piers. So the project, yeah, a lot of the riverwalk is within the floodplain. We recognize that, and we're considering that with part of the design moving forward.
[35:36] Speaker E (unidentified): Great. And then, okay, thanks. Question for staff. Is this going to be considered right-of-way, or is this considered a park?
[35:48] Speaker F (unidentified): It is not considered right-of-way. It's a public parcel, so it would be part of the Riverwalk.
[35:54] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay. I'm just thinking, is there going to be curfew? I mean, is there going to be hours that people can or cannot go onto this?
[36:01] Speaker F (unidentified): Presumably, it would follow the dawn-to-dusk hours. Okay.
[36:04] Speaker E (unidentified): Yep. And that's how it is on the other side as well?
[36:07] Speaker F (unidentified): That's how it is in the Riverwalk Park.
[36:09] Speaker E (unidentified): I know the park has that.
[36:11] Speaker F (unidentified): The park has that, but I don't believe that applies to necessarily the entire river walk, boardwalk system, such as the areas that are, you know, behind the restaurants and whatnot, but where on the northerly side, it's going to be more, it's not fronting along businesses, so that it would follow more of the park rules as opposed to, like, the area that's along the businesses.
[36:32] Speaker E (unidentified): This is exciting. I've definitely been waiting for this for a number of years, so nice to see it in motion. So, thanks.
[36:44] Speaker D (unidentified): Nancy? Yeah, I do. you. Thank you for your presentation. Several things are coming to mind. I look at what you put up for what it could look like, and it doesn't match the Riverwalk South, you know, in terms of design. And so in my mind, I'm trying to figure out what is that all going to look like together? Is it going to look choppy? Or, you know, what is that whole design going to look like and i also know i don't know what kind of boardwalk design will be you know at the end of kidder street too if that'll be different or the same so that's part of it is it oh no
[37:28] Speaker J (unidentified): i'm i'm really sensitive to that sort of understanding of what you're saying there we the conditions i guess at this stretch of riverwalk north are very different than on the south side of the river kind of a thing so the south side of the river you know how the river sort of it 's called what we call a cut bank so on the south side the river is actually making a turn into the river kind of a thing so we need that what 's called like a headwall kind of a thing on the south side of the river and so it's like form it follows function right And so we may have a very different looking Riverwalk on the other side. So how we're trying to bring the flow in is going to be in, we're already talking about branding wayfinding signage, you know, on one side to the other. using sacrappa park is the hub to sort of say you know this way to riverwalk north riverwalk south educational or interpretive signage we'll have the same signage you know to tell the story of westbrook or the story of our geology the story of our indigenous history or whatever it is or maybe art installations along each of them but we're going to have or the idea is to have some type of branding, so that we'll pull common elements among each of them. But in this case, I think that the engineering form and function have to be integrated into what it looks like. I wish they could all look the same, Nancy. I really do. But unfortunately, because we have such different conditions on one side than the other and different soils, and a river that
[39:27] Speaker D (unidentified): it has to have its own way right well thank you for that robin i know that you know things don't always have to look the same but i'm glad to know there's an eye to paying attention to how it how it can all flow and that common element of signage and if you can think of other commonalities that
[39:45] Speaker J (unidentified): we could weave into the fabric of it we'd love to hear it you know those are the only ones that have come to mind so far like wayfinding interpretive signage art installations i have a list going i also have a list going of policy questions that will need to think about like
[40:02] Speaker D (unidentified): hours and things like that too so thank you okay great i have a few other things too so the i'm thinking of so i spend quite a bit of time on the river south walk i walk that a lot and i love that one of the things i really love about it is the view to the other side of the river how wild it is the beauty of the trees and the landscape and everything like that so i'm trying to imagine in my head what how much of that will be gone how much of that would be preserved and i don't know if there's a way to get a better visual sense of that for us here because that's something pretty special about Westbrook. I feel like it's right in the middle of our city. We've got the river, of course, and then we've got this green. We're so lucky to have it. And I like the idea of the Riverwalk to be able to take advantage of that, but I'm wondering what are we going to lose in terms of the viewshed and how to consider that in advance.
[41:21] Speaker I (unidentified): or yeah so I think our intention in terms of the city and the project team is really to preserve that wild quality of this space in some ways the northern side will have a slightly different experience you know you'll be sort of sort of under the canopy the intention is really not to remove or disturb this zone as much as possible, and in some places really to help restore it, to me slightly more representative of that natural ecology versus some of the species that have kind of colonized. But in areas where we have surveyed different tree species, made sure that the boardwalk really preserves those silver maples that are kind of dotting the shoreline, Those tend to be a lot closer to the edge of the river, the high water line, whereas we're trying to push this a little bit away from the high water line to try to stay further from that 25-foot setback so that natural quality would be preserved. Additionally, the vegetation is really important to maintain, as Alice mentioned, and where there would be disturbance, we would be revegetating that area. And similarly, part of this process is trying to come up with construction techniques that minimize disturbance in the construction of the boardwalk or the trail system so that there isn't sort of this vast change in that area. But it feels like you're in a natural place and can really see the river and kind of feel like you're there and part of that place.
[43:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay, thank you. Yeah, thank you for that. I'll look forward to see more in-depth plans and what that will look like. A few other things I'm thinking about is I saw in the staff comments about the importance of safety vehicles having access. And at the same time, I'm thinking trash bins and benches and things like that. And what size safety vehicles are we talking about? And would there be the opportunity for trash bins? and benches and safety vehicles? Or is it just really just a walking path?
[43:51] Speaker J (unidentified): All right. So again, some of this goes on the list of policy discussion issues. I'm also a huge proponent of being, I grew up in Maine and hiking most of my life. I'm a carry-in, carry-out kind of person, which I know is a little bit controversial. so but we are thinking about in the parklet what should be there and you know whether it's actual manufactured park benches or are they like for example in sakarapa park we're going to be putting some granite rocks for some seating so for some real organic seating We may do something like that there, because we actually have to deal with the flood, floodway and the floodplain. So putting, you know, something of a natural nature is natural nature. Something of nature back in there is,, is actually, you know, more favorable for the permits and things like that. that so we are thinking about adding you know the parklet some places to reflect some places to sit and we have to put trash on that policy that list of policy discussions about whether you know and so i'd almost turn it back to you all about do we carry in carry out are we a community where we're going to send a utv down there every other day to fill it up with trash i don't know I mean, that's a that's you know a hard question We are we have gathered all the UTV information from public works public safety so that we know what everyone has for UTVs and made sure that we have their the weight limits and the and the parameters for them to get in and out so that We have the weight limits associated and accounted for on the boardwalk off the boardwalk and for that sort of the public safety access the additional one that we're looking into what street it comes off we don't know yet which one it will come off it really depends on grade and what the cost will be kind of a thing did i hit every everything that you were asking about nancy seating trash yeah and
[46:20] Speaker D (unidentified): And then all of that working with the public safety vehicles, if those were going to be on the boardwalk itself. Yes, absolutely. And it sounds like the seating and things would not be on the boardwalk.
[46:30] Speaker J (unidentified): It would be in the parklets. Just the parklets. Probably the parklet. Or parklet. We don't necessarily have a lot of, like, pull over and sit down kind of places at this point. point, you know, and if we were talking about art installation or interpretive signage, I think we were thinking at the parklet, weren't we? Yeah.
[46:56] Speaker I (unidentified): We've designated a few additional areas where we would propose some interpretive signage in addition to the parklet. So the idea is that people walking along the corridor could learn about, as Robin mentioned, history natural history and other aspects of the project so that was the intention there's some areas of the boardwalk in particular where there's it connects up to those access points and there's a bit of a flare in the design so that gives us a little bit more space to situate some of these elements so that's kind of where we are considering concentrating additional site amenities so that there doesn't have to be sort of like a bump out necessarily
[47:38] Speaker F (unidentified): and if i could add on to that the issue with having the amenities along the boardwalk is a width issue where it is so limited to that eight foot and we need to maintain the access for the utvs for the emergency and public services access so that's why kind of i think when we're looking at locations for these waste receptacles or chairs or whatever benches it's the parklets it's like the beginning and the end point it's where can we put them but that isn't within that
[48:03] Speaker D (unidentified): that restricted boardwalk section. Right. Yeah, that's what I was trying to understand. Thank you for that. And my one last comment, and then I'll pass the mic, but I live in an area where I don't know the idea of carry in, carry out, is that there's no trash bin at the bus stop. And it's been like this for 16 years, that the belief is supposed to be that if you don't put a trash bin that trash bin there that people will carry out their trash, I can tell you it's not true. So I just want to state that, remark that, because it isn't true. There's trash constantly around the bus stop, and there's no trash bin. So that's my comment about that, and then I pass it week are you talking about a metro bus stop yes the one of the hubs right on mechanic
[49:04] Speaker J (unidentified): street okay all right because i thought metro was responsible for their trash but again let's i'm glad that you put it on the record so that becomes a discussion point nancy
[49:20] Speaker D (unidentified): thank you i know taking the bus that there's there's no place to put trash when you get on
[49:25] Speaker J (unidentified): on the bus yeah and it's again it's my understanding that's a metro service that they should provide so it's very different than metro bus stop versus going to river riverwalk north kind of thing i completely recognize what you're saying and i'm not invalidating it whatsoever so yeah no thanks let's talk about it let's have a community conversation about it thank you so
[49:51] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you for the presentation like it was great like everyone else i've been eagerly waiting to see what goes on the north side in terms of trash i 'm trying to visualize in my head i have also walked the south side a million times with my kids i don't know that there is trash on the walk outside of riverbank park and maybe behind the restaurants i can't think of one but if there were one probably unfortunately the parklet would be the place to put it and i love the parklet by the way i think that is fantastic over there because as you walk on the south side there are multiple parks as well including behind the restaurants where everyone just hangs out and looks out at the river below. So I think that's a great, idea. I am wondering if I was like an AI hallucinating this. I really thought that this trail was going to go to the bridge. And is it because Water Street's just too close to the water? Is that ultimately why we went up Garfield Street? People just walk a little ways to the bridge. Is that kind of the idea? I see nodding heads. That makes sense to me. Okay. And in terms of kind of ideas to put out there to make the two halves look alike. Just consider lighting, so the lighting on the north side is consonant to the lighting on the south side, and so we'll be looking across at each other. But aside from that and the comments made here tonight, I'm eagerly looking forward to the next iteration. Does anyone else have any more comments? Go ahead, please.
[51:16] Speaker J (unidentified): I just wanted to say thank you all so much for this opportunity to just workshop it and listen to you all directly and to the team, and this team has done a wonderful job. Thank you for the positive feedback. We really appreciate it.
[51:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. All right. With that, no motion.
[51:41] Speaker E (unidentified): Go ahead, please. One other question here. Just curious, what kind of wood is going to be used for the boardwalk? I know the wood on the south side is in bad shape. I mean, it would be great if it could be eBay. And, you know, just bulletproof lasts forever, but it's expensive. I know.
[52:00] Speaker I (unidentified): I understand. I think that's what we're trying to work through is understanding maintenance concerns. And we're working with the city's team to get their perspective, just because obviously they don't want to create this sort of headache for the future maintenance and operations of the – I know. But then also similarly the cost, the overall cost. So these are things we're working through right now, but we don't have a specific material selected yet.
[52:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. With that, I don't need a motion. This meeting is adjourned.