← Back to MaineScanner

Westbrook Council Approves Metro Budget, Data Center Rules, and New Fire Lawsuit

2026-11-02 · 1h 12m · Source: 11/2/26 City Council (City of Westbrook (Vimeo))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:14] Speaker A (unidentified): The regular City Council meeting for Monday, November 2nd. I would like to just remind everyone in the Council and in the public of our expectations, which includes raising your hand and waiting to be called on prior to speaking, and to confine your comments to the merits of the issue and avoid personal comments. Land acknowledgement, please. [0:33] Speaker B (unidentified): The Westbrook City Council understands, honors, and acknowledges that the City of Westbrook is located on the traditional and unceded homelands and waters of the indigenous people of the Presumscot River. We recognize that the Wabanaki people have been displaced by the advancement of colonization, yet have belonged to this land for countless generations and thousands of years, and their presence continues in Maine to this day. Roll call, please. Councilor McCambridge. Here. Vice President Shaughnessy is absent. Councilor Chau. Here. Councilor Turcotte. Here. Councilor Falcum. [1:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Here. Councilor Reardon. Here. And President Monroe. Here. Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I'm with God. There are no minutes to be approved tonight, so we'll be on to the mayor's message. [1:34] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you. I'd like to begin tonight by inviting Glenn Fenton from Metro to come to the podium. Glenn is going to give us an overview of Metro's budget for 2027. [1:49] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, so Glenn Fenton, Executive Director for Metro, thank you for having me tonight. I HAVE A PRETTY BRIEF PRESENTATION HERE, AND WE'LL START BY JUST REVIEWING WHAT'S BEEN GOING ON IN METRO OVER THE LAST 12 MONTHS SINCE OUR LAST UPDATE. FIRST OFF, AS A REMINDER, THE SERVICE THAT METRO PROVIDES IN WESTBROOK IS PROVIDED ON FOUR BUS ROUTES. OUR ROUTE TWO, WHICH SERVES THE PRIDES CORNER AREA OF WESTBROOK, THE ROUTE THREE, WHICH IS A CROSS TOWN ROUTE THAT SERVES EAST BRIDGE STREET, BROWN STREET NEIGHBORHOOD, SPRING STREET NEIGHBORHOOD. THE ROUTE FOUR, WHICH SERVES largely serves Main Street as well as Saco Street, the Hamlet, Eisenhower Drive, those areas. And then the Husky line which is a limited stop route that travels between Portland and Gorham and has two stops in Westbrook that is again a higher speed route that goes between the cities. Metro ridership for this year has been largely flat as compared to last year. WE DID HAVE A DIP IN JANUARY LARGELY RELATED TO ICE ENFORCEMENT REDUCING THE AMOUNT OF FOLKS RIDING THE BUS DURING THAT MONTH. OTHERWISE I THINK WE WOULD ACTUALLY BE ON THE POSITIVE SIDE OF THINGS THIS YEAR BUT WE WERE A LITTLE BIT LOW IN JANUARY AND OTHERWISE TRENDING MOSTLY FLAT WITH SOME SLIGHT INCREASES IN THE SUMMER MONTHS. BOARDINGS IN WESTBROOK REMAIN STRONG. YOUR BUSIEST BUS STOPS ARE ON MECHANIC STREET THAT'S THE MAJOR TRANSFER POINT SO THAT'S a place where we'd expect to see a lot of rides that's at the main street hub there where we have all the routes coming together and then your next largest busiest stop is at rock row and all three of those top busiest stops are showing improvements over last year so that's encouraging the westbrook high school pass program for students has been off to a great start not a lot of data here so i don't want to draw too many conclusions but we can see that the trend is moving in the right direction, positive trend there. And as recently as last week, we had some of our highest ridership on that program. So that's really encouraging. And we're hoping as we get into the colder winter months, that we're able to see that curb some of the truancy issues that I know the high school was encountering. We're in close contact with Principal Garrett on that. And so far, I think that program is really off to a strong start. Just wanted to mention THAT WE MADE SOME FAIR POLICY CHANGES OVER THE SUMMER, ESPECIALLY AS IT PERTAINS TO THE BUDGET, WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THE COUNCIL UNDERSTANDS THAT ALTHOUGH THERE IS AN INCREASE FOR WESTBROOK, WE ALSO ASKED MORE OF OUR RIDERS THIS YEAR. AFTER COMPLETING A PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT PROCESS, NEW FAIRS WERE STARTED ON AUGUST 1ST. THAT RAISED OUR FAIR FROM $2 TO $2.25 FOR YOUR BASE FAIR. FOR REDUCED FAIR RIDERS, FOLKS WITH DISABILITIES, SENIORS, veterans, they're eligible for a half fare or their fare went from $1 to $1.10. Our monthly fare cap, which is essentially the most a person could pay for riding the bus in any given month, for full fare riders went from $60 to $65. And for reduced fare riders, we didn't increase that to really recognize that those folks would be most impacted by any fare increase. So for them, it stayed the same. And we also, over the summer, introduced a new technology on bus to allow folks to use credit cards and Apple Pay and Google Pay and those types of electronic wallets to pay on bus. You're seeing this in a lot of the larger transit systems in the country. We're really happy to be one of the first agencies of our size to get this technology off the ground. And so far, we've seen steady growth in that area. And we think that's a real potential for us, an opportunity for us to grow ridership and get new riders who many times are afraid to ride the bus because that fair payment tends to be a barrier for people trying transit okay with that i'll jump into the budget metro's budget for 2027 so we're on a calendar year budget as a reminder about 23.4 million dollars that's a 14 increase over our 26 budget i'll get into the reasons why the increase or what's included in that increase in a second our budget is largely driven by wages and benefits That's our highest line. So about 72% of our expenses are related to wages and benefits. So our service rate this year, we're operating about 135,000 revenue hours. That's how many hours of service we're operating in our service area. Next year, we're programmed to operate about 160,000 revenue hours. That increase is largely being driven by a service that we launched in Scarborough about three weeks ago a new route and new micro transit network in Scarborough launched that we worked with the town of Scarborough on and got fully funded through the main Turnpike Association as well as through the main DOT I'm sorry the main Turnpike Authority so that program is fully funded and there's revenue to back the expenses for that but that is driving a large part of the increase that you're seeing in our budget additionally last month, we also had South Portland City Council vote for additional service and expansion there that will amount to about $335,000 in additional service. That's a half-year service improvement that we'll be working on launching around mid-year of 2027. So on our expenditure side, again, as I mentioned, wages and benefits largely driving our budget, 72%, and then fuel right behind it at another 7% of our budget so almost 80% of our budget is just wages benefits and fuel and tires and fluids so when we look at our budget you can see that 's really being what's driving the increase on the expense side so on the wage side our current collective bargaining agreement with our union will expire and June 30th of next year so we'll be negotiating with them in the spring. We have programmed an increase there. We already have an agreed upon increase of two percent at the first of the year and we'll be negotiating our increase for mid-year with them as I said in the spring. Additionally we have budgeted for benefit increases, budgeted a 10 percent increase on premiums and then the other increase there is related to the expansion of our staff related to those service improvements that I mentioned. So we did need to staff up for that. So there's more bus operators, and I'll get to that in one moment. And then lastly, fuel, about 35% increase on fuel. We're coming off of a really fortunate fuel contract where we were getting diesel for $2.37 a gallon. As we all know, those days are quite a ways behind us right now. And so we've, I think, aggressively budgeted for $4 a gallon in the coming year. Right now, we're not able to get that rate yet, so we're still working on our contract. But right there is a large increase and then in addition to that we came off again another favorable contract for our natural gas. We have 10 natural gas buses and our rates on natural gas went up about 65% on our last contract for that. So again these are our biggest lines and really are driving the increases in our budget. But I want to point out the service improvements and how they factor in here and what the increase IF THOSE SERVICE IMPROVEMENTS WEREN'T FULLY BAKED INTO OUR BUDGET, WHICH THEY ARE. SO THE INCREASE IN SERVICE JUST ON THE ACTUAL ADDITIONAL SERVICE, THE NEW SERVICE THAT WE'RE ADDING, IS ABOUT 1.6 MILLION FOR THE SCARBOROUGH SERVICE AND ABOUT 335,000 FOR THE SOUTH PORTLAND SERVICE. SO THOSE TWO AMOUNTS, WHEN REMOVED FROM OUR BUDGET AND YOU just look at just the expenses apples to apples we're at about 4.7 increase in budget from 26 to 27 or about 965 000 in increase and that again is largely driven by those lines that i mentioned as i said staffing there's increase a net increase of staff about 13 employees again to be clear all but one of those employees are specifically related to the service improvements, which are fully funded. I want to make that clear that all of the service improvements that I've mentioned are fully funded with outside funding. So more bus operators. We also had some rearranging in our departments. We moved our marketing department into our advocacy group and out of our planning and customer service group. So there's some ins and outs there, but the only actual net position that's not related to service this year is one customer service representative that we added to our budget our budget the assessment of course is what happens in when we look at our expenses and we look at our revenue what become what remains becomes the local assessment basically the municipalities fill the gap between our funding and our expenses on the funding side funding largely has been flat you do see an increase on the federal line That funding, again, is additional targeted funding to cover some of the expenses related to the service improvements. We budget for our federal FTA, what we call 5307 formula funding, we budget for a 2% increase there. So that increase really isn't a lot when you're looking at some of the rising expenses that we encounter. Our state funding is flat, so no increase in state funding. again you'll see an increase here but that is largely targeted funding to cover those new services it's not additional regular operating funding that necessarily helps offset assessments for communities so again very small increase on federal side flat state funding fair revenue you can see almost 10% increase on fair revenue that's related to the fair increase that I just mentioned so we did make a little bit of headway there but largely the other major lines for our revenue are flat. Fair revenue makes up about 16% of our revenue. On the capital side of things, we are, I think, in pretty good shape on our CIP. We were actually able to reduce the local assessment on that or the amount of local match we needed. And our debt service has improved slightly as some of our bonds, and we bond for when we purchase buses, we bond that. And so some of that debt service has gotten a little bit better over the coming years so all in all our increase on total increase on the capital side and our borrowing and we put those all together is about 3.6 percent so all in all not too bad on capital and on our reserves. So this leads to the municipal assessments so for Westbrook right now the I should say the overall the aggregate municipal increase in municipal assessment is 14.4% with the amounts differing from community to community. So the communities that had ARPA service improvements, so about two years ago, we had service improvements that were fully funded by ARPA. That funding source has run out in 2026. We had partial year funding for it. Next year, we won't have any ARPA funding remaining. So you're seeing some of the communities that have larger amounts of arpa funded service are starting to pick up the slack on that or pick up what's what was the arpa funding that is no longer there westbrook had a limited amount of arpa funded service improvements only i think on our on the husky line so the impact is lower than some of the other communities like falmouth who had a whole new micro transit route and increased in frequency so they're seeing a larger increase than some of the other communities. So that's why the increases by community are a little bit different. There's also changes in the amount of service that the communities have that make the increases differ from community to community. So just a history on where Westbrook's assessment has been historically over the last few years. You can see largely the increases were really in that kind of low single digit percentages. And even last year when it actually went down, that was largely a factor of South Portland merging with Metro and that's having an influx of federal funding so that kind of made all of the communities have a better year last year and you do see back in 2018 that was when Westbrook invested in some of the new services that you have now the Route 3 and the Husky line specifically that's what that service improvement was in 2018 and that's why there was a large increase there and then after that it's been largely, like I said, flat. I just wanted to touch on the eligibility for TIF funding to be used for this year's assessment and how much that could be. So of the increase, which again, going back, the total increase is, or I'm sorry, the total assessment is $988,210. Of that, $408,540 is eligible for TIF funding so that's that's important to keep in mind it's also important to note that of the increase amount 64,000 of the increase is TIF eligible and only 15,000 is would rely on the general fund so we were able to ensure that a large part of that is eligible so if there is capacity the city will be able to use that for their increase and I think that's all I have I'm sorry if I move through that kind of quickly [16:03] Speaker C (unidentified): See if we have some questions for your gladness. That's okay. I did [16:06] Speaker E (unidentified): Can you go back to the first slide? How much did the you said the ridership was flat? And it went from two dollars to two ten to twenty five to twenty five twenty five cents [16:20] Speaker D (unidentified): Yes, and typically when you raise fares We expect to see ridership go down. So flat is actually pretty encouraging Our projection was to have, I can look it up, but I think just between 2% and 3% depression in ridership related to that increase. And it's usually pretty reliable that you'll see a decrease when you raise fares. [16:45] Speaker E (unidentified): So who comes up with the $0.25 increase? Is that Metro? Yeah. You regulated how much you can go up? [16:57] Speaker D (unidentified): or so we have we have to go through a public involvement process where we present our proposal to the community we get feedback and then in this case we actually we presented it we got feedback and then we went back to the communities after that made some adjustments we were considering as much as 250 but there was there were some concerns both from the public and also from our board members that might be too high an increase 225 does put us at as the highest fair in the state and in closely close to the highest in the region or in New England. So we felt like that was a good place to be. We last changed fairs in 2020. So it'd been six years since we raised fairs. And so we thought this was the appropriate time. And I think we'll be looking at more lower increment fair increases as opposed to large jumps. In 2020, we went from $1.50 to $2. And that was a lot for folks to bear. And so we're trying to be more thoughtful about [18:00] Speaker E (unidentified): having them be in smaller increments. Well, and I think that when I go to the gas station, I don't ask for 25 cents more. I mean, it goes up. And I do think that the fares should reflect the price of gas and things like that. Because if I was going to get on the bus in Westbrook and go to portland it's only going to cost me 25 cents more my vehicle is going to cost a lot more than that and i know there's a burden you know everything's going up but for 25 cents but then the city will our increase is 14 so to me you know kind of weighing things out going six years without an increase seems like a long time and hopefully that you know the direction that you go in or your board members you know still that's that's cheaper than an uber you know depending on where you're going and i just think that 's a very small increase for six years and then it reduced one fair is 10 cents when you when you put things in perspective and you know ridership is low and you know vehicles and gas and you know i have to buy tires and i buy gas and you know that's figured in your budget but i do think that an increase at least they're increasing but i don't think it's i would have been and probably happier with the $250,000, but I'm not on the board, and I didn't vote, but I do get to vote on this, so thank you. [19:55] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, Mr. Fenton, thank you for coming to our meeting. I appreciate the presentation. Can you go over our budget numbers again? I don't think you went over it. The print's so small on the orange slide. Yeah, I'm sorry. So basically, could you tell us where we were and what the new price is? [20:12] Speaker D (unidentified): So, yes, this is really small. Well, so your 2026 assessment was $908,665, and your 2027 is $988,210. Yeah, and to be clear, that's an 8.8% increase, not 14. 14 was the aggregate average of the communities. Okay. Okay. [20:35] Speaker F (unidentified): Now, I was thinking that the more towns come in, they help pay the share, and the prices will go down. HOW COME THAT HASN'T HAPPENED? IT SOUNDS LIKE WITHOUT THE NEW SERVICES IN SCARBOROUGH AND SOUTH PORTLAND, WE WOULD HAVE ONLY GOT 4%. YOU SAID, RIGHT? [20:53] Speaker D (unidentified): 4% WOULD HAVE BEEN THE INCREASE IN EXPENSE. UNFORTUNATELY, THE REVENUE IS NOT RISING AS FAST AS THE EXPENSE. IT WOULD NOT HAVE CHANGED YOUR ASSESSMENT. THE SCARBOROUGH SERVICE IS FULLY funded. So there's no cost to the member communities for that service. On the point of more communities joining, there is a benefit on the fixed side of things, which if you noticed in our presentation, unfortunately, our fixed costs are low. So as a percentage of our budget fixed is less than 20% of our budget, maybe 25 on a good day, but it's probably closer to 20. That, more communities spreading the fixed cost across more communities, does have a benefit. On the variable side, communities pay for the service they get. So if you have more service, you pay more. If you have less service, you pay less. If another community has more service, it doesn't necessarily help or harm you because, again, they're paying the variable costs on that. And that's how our cost allocation model works. So it's really designed to focus on the amount of service that you get is what you're paying for. So I mentioned revenue hours, and the communities pay for their portion of the revenue service that we operate. [22:17] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. A lot of the new bus routes were subsidized. They weren't paying their full share of miles. I believe it was the Husky line. It was the new line to Freeport or something like that. Just to say, try us out. Are they still being subsidized, or are they paying their full share? [22:36] Speaker D (unidentified): No, they all pay their full share now, and that's where we're at with Scarborough right now. So Scarborough isn't paying – they are paying $145,000 next year, but they'll phase in over time, and then hopefully in two years they'll vote to become a member community and then have the full assessment that all the other member communities pay for their service, which in theory will help because, again, now you'll have another member community to spread the fixed cost over. [23:04] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. [23:09] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU FOR GOING OVER THE NUMBERS. I WAS SITTING HERE THINKING I CAN'T READ THAT. THERE'S NO WAY. ARE ALL THE OTHER COMMUNITIES ON THE SCREEN MEMBER COMMUNITIES? [23:19] Speaker D (unidentified): ALL EXCEPT FOR SCARBOROUGH. [23:22] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU FOR THIS. [23:25] Speaker G (unidentified): I'M NOT SURE IF THIS IS A QUESTION FOR MR. FENTON OR CITY ADMINISTRATION, BUT THE SLIDE REFERENCING THE TIF eligibility. I'd like some context on that. Does that mean it is going to get paid for out of TIF funds or is that it is just eligible if there's an excess? So every year part of our [23:45] Speaker C (unidentified): metro gets to be paid from TIF because the part that was newly expanded several years ago, the Route 3 line, essentially. 3 and the Husky line. And the Husky line, that gets to be paid for by TIF. So every year there has to be a calculation done to be like what percentage of the cost is attributable to that expansion and what's attributable to what we had before we started using the TIF to pay for it. And so I think the data, could you go back to the slide [24:11] Speaker D (unidentified): that showed what percentage of the increase? Yeah. So not sure. So the, yeah, the percentage, it's 18% of the increase or well, the increased amount on it, on the TIF is 18%. So from what your last year amount was to this year or to the upcoming year is 18 percent and then on the general fund size 2.7 percent those aren't the actual amounts of the increase of course the aggregate increase is 8.8 percent but comparing year over year so the bottom line is it's 408,000 [24:47] Speaker C (unidentified): is TIF eligible and the other tricky thing about the way so they you use a calendar year fiscal year and obviously we don't and so this will get factored into our budget in the spring and it's they always don't match exactly because we're kind of guessing what the other half of the year is going to be in the future and i just want to point out that so we're kind of returning to the year before last kind of spending levels it looks like because last year WE DID SEE A REDUCTION IN OUR CONTRIBUTION BECAUSE OF SOUTH PORTLAND ADDING. IS THAT RIGHT? [25:26] Speaker D (unidentified): THAT'S RIGHT. THERE WAS ARPA FUNDING STILL IN THE BUDGET LAST YEAR. THAT'S A BIG PART OF IT. I SHOULD ALSO MENTION LAST YEAR BECAUSE THE ARPA FUNDING WAS PHASING OUT, OUR BOARD VOTED TO PUT ANOTHER $300,000 IN CARRY FORWARD FUNDING IN WHICH IS ONE-TIME FUNDING THAT'S PHASED out to. So we had about $800,000, almost $850,000 come out of the budget in revenue that's not returning next year. That was, again, the ARPA was expiring and the carry forward was one-time funding. [26:02] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay, thank you. I have one other quick question for Mr. Fenton. I'm blanking on the name of it, but the express bus service that is planned, is there an update on the timeline for that? [26:13] Speaker D (unidentified): THE BUS RAPID TRANSIT. WE ARE STILL WORKING ON IT. I THINK IN THE SPRING WE WOULD LIKE TO COME BACK AFTER THE FIRST OF THE YEAR TO THE COUNCIL AND TALK TO THEM IN DETAIL ABOUT WHAT WE HAVE, THE PROGRESS WE HAVE MADE AND GET SOME FEEDBACK. THEN WE WOULD LIKE TO WRAP THE PROJECT IN THE SPRING WITH THE FINAL, NOT THE FINAL DESIGN, BUT THE PRELIMINARY DESIGN BEING COMPLETED BY EARLY SUMMER. THAT IS OUR GOAL. OKAY. THANK YOU. [26:39] Speaker C (unidentified): THANK YOU, MR. FRANTZ. thank you I want to announce that at our next City Council meeting on November 16th project manager Robin Saunders will provide an overview of the preliminary report from the presumptive River landslide vulnerability assessment project this presentation will highlight the preliminary findings from the University of Maine's field investigations and progress from the project team on what makes some land areas more vulnerable to landslides than others. Neighbors are encouraged to attend or listen in to gain a clear science-based understanding of community conditions, proactive measures to safeguard our community, and preview the upcoming public engagement opportunities for 2027. And we'll be updating the city's website with information about this project, public learning session dates, and additional educational resources, but tune in to our next meeting on November 16th for more information on the landslide vulnerability issue. I also wanted to encourage everyone to attend the upcoming public meeting on the Main Street Redesign and Pedestrian Improvements. Maine DOT and the city will hold that meeting on Thursday, November 12th from 6 to 7 p.m. at Westbrook Warren Congregational Church, 810 Main Street. I'm really looking forward to this. This meeting that we held a couple of years ago about public pedestrian safety was extremely well attended and residents gave us and DOT valuable feedback that has helped shaped the draft plan that we're looking at now. This next meeting is an opportunity to see what the future of Main Street could look like and offer more feedback before the design is finalized. The proposed improvements include wider sidewalks, landscaping, raised crosswalks, improved crossing signals, accessibility upgrades, and new pavement. Together these improvements offer an opportunity to refresh Main Street and make the corridor through the heart of our city safer and more welcoming for people who are walking and riding bicycles. Main Street is a part of our daily life and we all, most of us, either live or drive or work through it and I hope that we're gonna see another strong turnout like we did a couple of years ago. It was probably the most impressive kind of version of one of these public meetings I'd ever seen. If you can't attend, there are other opportunities, the presentation materials, and there'll be also an opportunity to provide comment through a website that will be live from November 9th through the 25th. And we'll be posting about that on our website this is really exciting to see this work moving forward it's still you know still over the horizon it's not happening tomorrow but it's getting closer and that's exciting to see finally tomorrow is election day you might have heard I wanted to recognize our election workers and thank them for everything that they do we're very fortunate here in Westbrook to have people who bring such care, patience, and professionalism to their work. Their attention to detail gives us confidence in the integrity of our elections, and their kindness makes voting very easy and pretty much pleasant experience for most of us. And that takes a lot of effort. Election days are long, and sometimes people arrive feeling stressed, frustrated, and a little bit grumpy. And our election workers handle those moments with exceptional professionalism while keeping the process moving and helping people exercise their right to vote. The modest compensation that they receive hardly reflects the time and responsibility involved. They do this because they care about serving the community and I'm very grateful to them. So if you're voting tomorrow, please be kind and patient and take a moment to thank the people helping you. They deserve our appreciation. And I'd like to turn it over to our city clerk, Alice Ledoux, to talk a little bit about our election tomorrow. [30:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Yes, thank you very much. Thank you very much. So again, election is tomorrow, November 3rd, at our polling location, 426 Bridge Street, the Westbrook Community Center, right in the gym. We will be open from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. And just a reminder for anyone still waiting to give us back your absentee ballot, that those will need to be returned to City Hall by 8 p.m. [31:04] Speaker C (unidentified): That's all from me. Thank you. [31:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. On to City Council messages. Councilor Reardon. [31:16] Speaker E (unidentified): earlier last week i received an email from the westbrook transportation director melissa foy last year in partnership with haniford brothers they had a bus a bus parked in our parking lot for one weekend to stuff a bus to help hunger in westbrook and we've We've agreed to do two weekends this year. So if you're near the Westbrook-Hannaford on Saturday the 7th and Sunday the 8th of November and November 14th, which is a sad day, and the 15th, there'll be a bus with some transportation people there. And Westbrook-Hannaford will be doing some announcements and letting them know what's going on out there. but it worked out really well last year and looking forward to Melissa and her team at the Westbrook Canterford on those two weekends so if you have any canned goods or different things like that you'd like to donate please come down to the Westbrook Canterford thank you [32:26] Speaker F (unidentified): you any other counselor messages counselor show yes I want to thank the Westbrook marching band This weekend, they went down to Harvard University and performed for the New England Scholastic Band Finals, and they did amazing. They got second place, gold medal, but they played their hearts out. They usually used to get in first place, but they moved up to a tougher division, but they performed excellent. Even the people commented how great we are from other teams. So it was a good time. The kids, the marching band kids, excellent. And we're all very proud of them. So thank you. [33:10] Speaker H (unidentified): Councilor Turcotte? Yes, I just wanted to add that we were there, too, and it was just amazing to see them perform against all Massachusetts schools, the only main school, and they placed second. And they were very down on themselves because they're so used to perfection. But to me, two points was perfection. They were pretty close to 100. And so congratulations to them, but also congratulations to the music department, the marching band staff, the color guard staff. I think there was about 20 adults who make that happen. And we constantly are placed in a division above our size because we're so good so if you get a chance to support our marching band even just by attending some of their performances here in the community please do thank you so much [34:05] Speaker A (unidentified): any other counselor messages all right on to student rep there is not one here present tonight onto our first public comment if you'd like to come up to the podium please state your name if you're a resident of westbrook and if you'd like to tell us what ward you're in we can follow -up afterwards. And you have three minutes. [34:32] Speaker I (unidentified): Hello there, Larry McWilliams. I do live in Westbrook. Yes, tomorrow is election day, and I hope to see everybody at the polls. I am running for House Seat 128, and I'd like to see everybody as much as I can. There's two things that I really want to bring to the council. One is pretty much about election day as far as meetings go, as far as planning board meetings. Being on the ballot, the meeting is scheduled for tomorrow as well and it was done the last time when I ran for mayor I think that on election night period the meeting should not be planned for any planning board meetings on that should be either the second Tuesday or maybe the third however you want to plan on it but I don't feel it's it's right to have a any type of meeting on election when people are already stressed on going to meetings and then try to get out the vote when they can on a short amount of time anyway so that's one. Another thing about the packets, unfortunately, there was a mishap this morning or Friday where they didn't get our packets out till this morning. And I didn't pay attention to it because I already knew I wasn't going to the meeting. But when I did look at it, Monday, sometimes our meetings are pretty extensive. We have a lot on our agendas. And trying to get what we get in on a Friday, and I know you guys the same way, you get your packets on Friday. day there's a lot to go over to try to get ready for a monthly meeting so we if we can increase those agendas because I read the agendas too I read with the increase on the bus and one of the questions I like to ask with that is the when I looked in the packet it was a 0.06 percent ridership that we got and are increased the one on the budget or on the fair ride it was increased to 7% on what they're projecting for next year, but what was the projection from 25 to 26? That number I would like to see because did it come close to what the projection was, or did it come fall short, way short with the amount? So other than that, thanks. I'd like to have more time on the meetings, maybe a week before our packets would be great. Thank you, [36:40] Speaker A (unidentified): administration thank you anyone else matthew [36:54] Speaker J (unidentified): brunner resident of westbrook i think it's no secret that i don't agree with the decision you all made last week all but one of you to repeal and replace the recreation and conservation commission good news is i've excitedly applied to the new committee i do look forward to serving on it as soon as it's convened I hope, as most of you said last week, you will support previous members on their placement on this new committee. Also, as I stated last week, I believe disagreement and dissent can be constructive. And as such, I would like to thank my three representatives that represent me, Councilor Falkingham from my ward, Councilor Raritan and Councilor Shaughnessy, who were at large for taking the time to meet with me in the past two weeks. We did not agree on your decision, but we agreed on a lot of things, and even our disagreements were, I think, good and healthy. I think honesty and conflict can live hand in hand, and if I'm lucky enough to serve on this new committee, I look forward to the collaboration you guys have talked about having with the new one. On a similar note, I'd like to thank Councilor Turcotte for her honesty and, quite honestly, the bravery that she displayed last meeting. When you put yourself in a position of dissent and then kind of get tried to be silenced, I think it's a clear indicator of how daunting such an act can be to dissent from what's the popular opinion. I would hope to kind of hear an apology publicly to her tonight. And if it's not going to come from someone on the council, I'd like to apologize to you. Because I talked to a lot of people in preparation for that meeting. And they all had the same feelings that you expressed that night. And in my effort to either get you guys to see my side of the story or to hopefully secure my position on the new committee, I softened that language and I didn't have the bravery to say what everybody was saying. I don't believe it's any one person. I believe it's a perception that can be had of the system as a whole when we don't follow what's very available in front of us. So I'm sorry. And thank you. That said, what's done is done. I truly do hope to be appointed to this new committee. And with the help of the council, as you said, I hope we can craft it to be even more helpful, if possible, than the previous commission. Thanks a lot for your time.
Unfinished Business
[39:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Anyone else? Okay. Okay. no unfinished business onto orders of the day. Second and final reading. what are the wishes that we still do? [39:53] Speaker B (unidentified): The first order is order 2026 dash one 18 found on page 46 of your packet, authorizing acceptance and expenditure of Bureau of highway safety grant funds. [40:04] Speaker E (unidentified): What are the wishes of the council reading? I move for the next two readings for OUR SECOND AND FINAL READING. ORDERS NUMBERS 2026118, AUTHORIZING ACCEPTANCE OF EXPENDITURES FOR BUREAU OF HIGHWAY SAFETY GRANT FUNDS. AND ORDER NUMBER 2026119, AUTHORIZING A DRAINAGE EASEMENT AT 41 BROWN STREET. THANK YOU. [40:29] Speaker A (unidentified): IS THERE A SECOND? COUNCILOR CHAO? ANY DISCUSSION? ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC? OKAY. ROLL CALL, PLEASE. [40:39] Speaker B (unidentified): Councillor McCambridge? Yes. Councillor Chow? Yes. Councillor Turcotte? Yes. Councillor Falkham? [40:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes. Councillor Reardon? Yes. And President Monroe? Yes. Six in favor, none opposed. On to Order 2026-120. [40:51] Speaker B (unidentified): This is Order 2026-120, found on page 57 of your packet, amending the land use ordinance regarding data centers. As a note, this does require public hearing tonight, November 2nd, 2026, and this was [41:09] Speaker A (unidentified): I WILL GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE PUBLIC COMMENT. PUBLIC HEARING. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO COME UP AND SPEAK, PLEASE SET YOUR NAME. I WILL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING. WHAT ARE THE WISHES OF THE COUNCIL? [41:29] Speaker E (unidentified): I MOVE FOR THE SECOND AND FINAL READING FOR ORDERS NUMBER 2026-120 AMENDING THE LAND USE ORDINANCE REGARDING DATA CENTERS. [41:47] Speaker C (unidentified): THANK YOU. I WANT TO REITERATE WHAT I SAID LAST WEEK. I STRONGLY SUPPORT THE PLANNING BOARD'S RECOMMENDATION. I BELIEVE THAT THE CONCERNS ABOUT STAND-ALONE DATA CENTERS ARE QUITE SUBSTANTIAL. THERE ARE DEMANDS ON ELECTRICITY AND WATER, THE POTENTIAL FOR CONSTANT NOISE, AND THE BURDENS THAT THEY CAN PLACE ON INFRASTRUCTURE AND SURROUNDING NEIGHBORHOODS. THOSE ARE CONCERNS THAT GO DIRECTLY TO STAND-ALONE to our responsibility to protect residents' quality of life, and plan responsibly for Westbrook's future. Westbrook welcomes investment from business interests that offer opportunities that benefit our community, but we must consider what a development requires of us and not just what it offers. First and foremost, our resources and infrastructure need to support the people who live here, our existing businesses, and the housing and economic opportunities that our community needs resource consuming data centers are simply not a good fit for westbrook the ordinance being implemented tonight makes a very sensible distinction it prohibits standalone data centers while allowing server rooms and similar facilities that support an on-site business i appreciate the planning board's careful consideration and unanimous recommendation and the work of our planning staff i agree with their conclusions and i hope that the council WILL ADOPT THE ORDINANCE TONIGHT. OKAY. ROLL CALL, PLEASE.
New Business
[43:11] Speaker A (unidentified): COUNCILOR MCCAMBRIDGE? YES. COUNCILOR TROY? YES. COUNCILOR TURKOT? YES. COUNCILOR FULCAM? YES. COUNCILOR VERDEN? YES. AND PRESIDENT MONROE? YES. SIX IN FAVOR, NONE OPPOSED. ON TO NEW BUSINESS. FIRST, WE ARE ON TO BUSINESS LICENSES. [43:24] Speaker B (unidentified): THIS IS A LIQUOR LICENSE FOR SWEET CAROLINE'S RETRO LOUNGE located at 1 Westbrook Common, Suite 5. This is located on page 60 of your packet. It does require a public hearing this evening, November 2nd, 2026. This was also posted in the Portland Press-Herald Friday, October 23rd. [43:41] Speaker A (unidentified): I'll go ahead and open the public hearing now. If you'd like to come up and speak, you can. Yeah, come on up. [43:54] Speaker K (unidentified): Hi, I'm Caroline. I am the owner of Suite Caroline's Retro Lounge. I'm really excited to be part of the Westbrook community and right in the heart of Westbrook at the Westbrook Common I think I'm gonna create a really wonderful space. I'm excited to kind of show you what I can do with my talent and integrating local art and local music and really kind of thriving in the heart of Westbrook and I'm excited to see everyone there and it's been a lot of hard work but you know thank you for viewing this and I'm I'M EXCITED. [44:33] Speaker A (unidentified): ANYONE ELSE FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING? I WILL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING. WHAT ARE THE WISHES OF THE COUNCIL? COUNCIL RUIDEN. [44:42] Speaker E (unidentified): I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE FORWARD THE LIQUOR LICENSE FOR SWEET CAROLINE'S RETRO LOUNGE AT ONE WESTFORD COMMON SWEET 5. [44:54] Speaker A (unidentified): IS THERE A SECOND? COUNCIL CHAO? Any discussion? I was there the other day, and I know it was still Westbrook on tap, but you can tell there's been some slight changes in movement of stuff. It's been great. Yeah, it was great. [45:16] Speaker E (unidentified): Council Member Rudin? I'm actually looking at the menu right now, and it looks very delicious. Not sure if I'm going to go with the huss radish mustard on my roast beef in Swiss, but maybe. BUT I THINK IT'S AN AWESOME SPOT AND I KNOW THAT I WAS ON WIC WHEN WE HAD TO REDO THAT AREA AND WE'VE ALSO HAD A LOT OF MUSIC OUT THERE AND IT'S REALLY AN INVITING AREA SO I WISH YOU LUCK AND YOU WILL SEE ME DOWN THERE. [45:53] Speaker A (unidentified): ANY OTHER DISCUSSION? [45:55] Speaker B (unidentified): ROLL CALL. Councillor McCambridge? Yes. Councillor Trout? Yes. Councillor Turcotte? Yes. [46:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Councillor Fulgham? Yes. Councillor Burden? Yes. And President Monroe? Yes. Six in favor, none opposed. There are no resolves. On to order of the day, one reading required, order 2026-121. [46:13] Speaker B (unidentified): This is order 2026-121, found on page 71 of your packet, authorizing retainer agreement for legal representation in fire apparatus antitrust litigation. What are the wishes of the council? council [46:32] Speaker G (unidentified): councilman cambridge i move for the first and final reading of order 2026 121 authorizing retainer agreement for legal representation in fire apparatus antitrust litigation that the westbrook city council hereby authorizes the mayor or designee to enter into an agreement with gustafson gluck pllc of minneapolis minnesota to represent the city of westbrook in class action litigation against several fire apparatus manufacturers, as outlined in the attached [47:02] Speaker A (unidentified): exhibit. Thank you. Is there a second? Councillor Reardon? Any discussion? Ms. Holmes? [47:10] Speaker L (unidentified): So this is a request to authorize us to enter into this retainer agreement with Gustafson Gluck of Minneapolis, Minnesota, to represent the City of Westbrook as part of the indirect purchaser class action lawsuit that is taking place nationwide against several fire apparatus manufacturers. There are four primary manufacturers of fire apparatus across the nation right now. And the city of Westbrook purchased a fire apparatus back in 2022 from one of these vendors through a distributor. There's actually two class action lawsuits that are taking place one for those that purchase directly from the manufacturers and one for the indirect purchaser class who went through a distributor and we are part are asking to be part of that second item both of those classes assert that the manufacturers artificially inflated the prices of those apparatus that there were forced production delays that there were retroactive price hikes and further alleged that the organization THE FIRE APPARATUS MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION FACILITATED THE SHARING OF ECONOMIC DATA BETWEEN THOSE FOUR PRIMARY ENTITIES. INCLOSED THIS EVENING IS A MEMO FROM FIRE CHIEF STEVE SLOAN AND WE DO HAVE OUR ASSISTANT CHIEF GARY WAGNER HERE THIS EVENING IF THERE'S ANY QUESTION ABOUT THIS ITEM. BUT AS THE CITY OF WESTBROOK DID PURCHASE OUR QUINT LADDER TRUCK FROM E1 ORIGINALLY IN 2021 21, delivery happened in 23, I believe, two years later. We experienced significant delays, adjustments to the final price. A performance guarantee was withheld from the city of Westbrook. Through this class action lawsuit, the city of Westbrook's primary objective, of course, is to make sure that there's accountability in the market concerning fire apparatus going forward because in the future, the city will be in a position where we will once again need to purchase fire apparatus in the future. And we'd like to make sure that there is accountability in that process as well. Interestingly, the direct purchaser class is being represented at the federal level by Pretty Flaherty amongst several other law firms. As we're part of the indirect purchaser class,. We are asking for your permission to enter into this retainer agreement with Gustafson Gluick is one of the co-lead firms for the indirect purchaser class. There's no upfront cost or out-of-pocket obligations for attorney fees. Those fees and expenses would be contingent upon and payable out of any recovery that takes place under the agreement through the court order. We do anticipate that this is probably a long-term case, and as far as our involvement would likely require some time from our fire chief during discovery and periodically over the course of coming years, but this is something that we would like to participate in because the city of Westbrook was impacted, and there may be a favorable outcome here if we can make sure that manufacturers are being held accountable. [50:33] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Any discussion from the council? Any discussion from the public? Okay. We'll call, please. [50:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Councilor McCambridge? Yes. Councilor Trout? Yes. Councilor Turcotte? Yes. Councilor Falkham? Yes. Councilor Reardon? Yes. And President Monroe? Yes. Six in favor, [50:55] Speaker A (unidentified): none opposed. On to orders of the day, two reading required. Order 2026-122. [51:01] Speaker B (unidentified): This is Order 2026-122, found on page 79 of your packet, authorizing sale of 12 Water Street. What are the wishes of the Council? [51:10] Speaker E (unidentified): Councillor Reardon? I move for first reading of Orders No. 2026-122, authorizing sale of 12 Water Street, that the Westbrook City Council hereby authorize the Mayor-designee to sell Westbrook-owned property located at 12 water street to dory schulenberger of westbrook maine for a price of not less than fifty thousand dollars and to negotiate and enter into a purchase sale agreement to the to execute the municipal quick claim deed and other documents or instruments SUCH AS PROPERTY ON SUCH TERMS AS SUBJECT TO SUCH CONDITIONS AS THE MAYOR OR DESIGNEE DETERMINES AT THE CITY'S BEST INTEREST. FUNDS WILL BE DEPOSITED IN THE REVENUE LINE. [52:13] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU. IS THERE A SECOND? COUNCILOR CHAO? ANY DISCUSSION? MS. HOLMES? [52:20] Speaker L (unidentified): So this item, as Councilor Reardon just read into the record, authorizes the mayor-designee to sell the city-owned property located at 12 Water Street to Ms. Dori Schulberger of Westbrook, Maine, for not less than $50,000. Ms. Schulberger is here in the audience this evening, along with her attorney, Mr. Broadus, if there are any questions for them specifically. specifically this authorizes the mayor or designee to enter into that purchase and sale agreement and to execute the deed in any other documents necessary to sell that property by way of history here the city of westbrook acquired this parcel along with several other parcels back in 2023 when we purchased acquired several pieces of land from sappy along the northern portion of the presumptive scott river following that acquisition ms schulberger reached out to the city of Westbrook, alerting us to her presence on that property and provided with us, provided to us the history of her and her mother's residence on that land. They had leased the property from Scott Paper Company back in 1980. And that was later acquired by sd warren sappy with rents payable at four hundred dollars per year sd warren assumed the lease and continued to honor that and following the passing of miss sharon schulberger dory's mother dory assumed that lease agreement with sappy and continued that agreement with the city of westbrook while she also asked for the city to sell her the parcel that she had been living on So we had an appraisal conducted of this parcel. It is a very unique piece of land, triangular-shaped land. And the appraisal valued the parcel at $50,000. Given the unique site conditions, there is limited actual buildable space within that parcel itself. And the city would want to place several easements upon the property, including construction easements and other conditions that we may wish to utilize at some piece, some part in the future. This land itself right now is not directly along the alignment of the Riverwalk North project that the city of Westbrook is pursuing right now. But the city would wish to retain the ability to expand in the future someday if that's something that we wanted to do. We'd want to retain the ability to purchase, to build in that area, even though that is not the plan right now for our project. SO THIS AGREEMENT WOULD AUTHORIZE OR THIS ORDER WOULD AUTHORIZE THE SALE OF THAT PROPERTY AT NOT LESS THAN $50,000. MICHELE BURGER IS OBTAINING A SURVEY OF THE PROPERTY RIGHT NOW. AND WOULD ALSO DESIGNATE THAT $50,000 TO BE APPLIED TOWARD THE RIVERWALK NORTH PROJECT ITSELF. AND I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT ARE HERE FROM YOU THIS EVENING. Councilor Reardon. [55:37] Speaker E (unidentified): This is one of the first discussions when I got reelected in January. And I'm happy that it ended the way it did. I know that Dory has always lived there as a child. and it is an outcome that I'm pleased that she has the opportunity to purchase it those type of agreements are very few and far between that she lived by for quite a while but that was between sappy and SD Warren and all those but I am glad that this is going to be finalized hopefully tonight with a vote and we can all move on. Thank you. Thank you. Any council discussion? [56:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion from the public? State your name if you're resident of Westbrook and you'll have three minutes. [56:46] Speaker M (unidentified): Andrew Broadus here for Dory Schulberger. As Angela's laid out, this is a kind of unique situation. One of the things to keep in mind on this is this property has been appraised. It does reserve rights to the city for easements and continuation of the Riverwalk if in the future they decide to do so. There's going to be a workshop tomorrow at the planning board about this Riverwalk north. It's going to end actually at Garfield Street. This property is a little bit beyond Garfield Street. and it won't be built on at the moment, but they're reserving that right. This is a win-win. It's a win for Dory. She gets to stay there. She becomes a taxpayer with the land. The city gets money for the Riverwalk North project. I think it's great that the city can sell her this property to allow her to continue to live there. She's been there since 1980. and i think it 's a win-win for both parties i think at the end of the day here this is a combination of a lot of negotiation with the city but we 've come around to realizing that it makes sense to keep residents here especially long-term residents and give them an opportunity to own the land that they're under it's hard to live on leased land and i think this is this is a good move for the city thank you any questions okay thank you yep three [58:24] Speaker A (unidentified): minutes state your name and if you're resident of westbrook right alice peterson garfield street [58:32] Speaker N (unidentified): and although my street's going to be much busier with the boardwalk i prefer that to having my neighbors having people look in their backyard as you know i've been here many times with other people supporting dory and it's a win also for the neighborhood so i hope that everything goes smoothly i know there are still details to be worked out but our neighborhood feels now like it can be intact and we appreciate that the discussion and decisions are going in this direction thank you thank you [59:12] Speaker I (unidentified): larry mcwilliams still live in westbrook i want to agree but this story is very nice to meet you. You had a lot of support with the city. And what happened when this came about, and I heard about it too, and it came through emails and so forth, and it was very challenging. But how this decision came and even to get to where this is, the citizens and the people of Westbrook stood up. And they asked questions, and they showed up, and they said, this isn't right what you're doing to this poor woman. She's been there forever. and I think with the pushback and with the help of the citizens and bringing it to the meetings and to the agendas and to the to the administration that this was allowed to happen and it is rare that it does but I am happy that the city made the right decision on this because it was it's a it was a it was something that it was circulating around and a lot of people heard about it and I know there was a lot of feedback that came back to the city on it so thanks for making that decision and hopefully we'll get to keep pushing back and keep fighting back with what things come up and need to be addressed and when we address them we need to make it our points come across to how we want to say it and we should be allowed to say it when we say it so thank you very much [1:00:32] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you anyone else roll call please do [1:00:40] Speaker B (unidentified): you want to do show of hands first oh yeah first [1:00:43] Speaker A (unidentified): ALL IN FAVOR, SHOW OF HANDS. ALL IN FAVOR, NONE OPPOSED. ON TO SECOND READER, ORDER 2026-123. [1:00:54] Speaker B (unidentified): THIS IS ORDER 2026-123, FOUND ON PAGE 89 OF YOUR PACKET, APPROVING THE 2026-2029 COLLECTIVE PARTNERING AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY, WITH THE WESTBROOK ESSENTIAL SERVICES UNIT. THANK YOU. WHAT ARE THE WISHES OF THE COUNCIL? [1:01:09] Speaker E (unidentified): I MOVE FOR FIRST READING FOR ORDERS NUMBER 2026-123, approving the 2026 through 2029 collective bargaining agreement for the Westbrook Essentials Service Unit that the Westbrook City Council hereby author approves the attached 2026-2029 collective bargaining agreement with the Teamsters Union No. 340 Westbrook Essentials Service Units, It's a copy of what shall be placed on file in the Department of Human Services. [1:01:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Is there a second? Is there a second? Councilman Cambridge, thank you. Any discussion? Ms. Holmes? [1:01:57] Speaker L (unidentified): So this approves a three-year contract with a brand-new unit here for the city of Westbrook. The essential services unit was established through the beginning of our negotiations, separating 12 positions from the general unit. These 12 positions were separated as they had a unique set of circumstances addressing the working conditions for these employees. And I just wanted to read this definition here, that essential services employees are those whose primary duties are necessary to maintain the continuity of critical municipal operations, public infrastructure, including but not limited to maintenance, operational facilities, wastewater grounds, and administrative support functions essential to city services. This excludes certain positions such as our public safety personnel, but there are a number of employees here who are required to work to maintain our operations, even in the midst of snowstorms and other emergencies that we have. And so this unit was established to cover those individuals as a unique bargaining unit. So that was established back in March of 26. And as a starting point for this collective bargaining agreement, CBA, we use the general unit collective bargaining agreement as just a template for that. A significant component of this agreement that you see this evening is the establishment of a new wage scale. So the individuals covered by this unit, as we conducted our market salary data study, as we have done for other bargaining units, you may recall me saying at the last CBA that we brought forward to city council for consideration that we generally look to market data to see are we within 10% of what the average is for these positions across the region. And we found that we were off from 2% to 11% outside of that variance. And so that is a significant change by establishing the new pay scale for these 12 individuals here. And that's what happens in year one of this contract is establishing that new scale. year two would see a three percent cost of living adjustment and year three would also see a three percent cost of living adjustment a couple of other significant items that are included in here is a one-time 500 signing bonus for all 12 members of this following settlement and ratification and there are some updates to the clothing allowances and other updates more of an administrative nature that we have been making to all cbas along the way addressing main paid Family Leave Act, and some other items that we've been trying to be more consistent in across our CBAs. So the projected costs for this contract agreement cumulatively for the three-year period is $107,837.46, $107,837.46. That's across the three years of this contract, EXCLUDING OUR SCHEDULED STEP INCREASES OR ANY OTHER ADDITIONAL COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH SOME OF THE UNIQUE PROVISIONS OF THIS CONTRACT ITSELF. IT TOOK US A WHILE TO GET HERE TO COME TO AN AGREEMENT AND IT HAS BEEN VOTED UPON AND RATIFIED BY THE UNION MEMBERSHIP. THE NEXT STEP HERE IS, OF COURSE, TO ASK FOR CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZATION AND APPROVAL OF THIS CONTRACT. AND WE'RE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE. WE ALSO HAVE OUR HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR, JOANNE, THIS EVENING. IF THERE'S ANY PARTICULAR QUESTIONS. [1:05:54] Speaker A (unidentified): THANK YOU. ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE COUNCIL? I DON'T SEE ANY. ANY DISCUSSION FROM THE PUBLIC? OKAY. SHOW OF HANDS, ALL IN FAVOR? ALL IN FAVOR, NONE OPPOSED? ON TO OUR SECOND AND FINAL PUBLIC COMMENT OF THE NIGHT. IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK, COME UP AND STATE YOUR NAME, WHETHER YOU'RE A RESIDENT OF WESTBROOK AND IF YOU WANT TO TELL US WHAT WARD YOU'RE IN AND YOU'LL HAVE THREE MINUTES. [1:06:35] Speaker O (unidentified): GOOD EVENING. Ken Fawson. I live in Frenchtown here in Westbrook. I'm here tonight to speak to one specific aspect of the changes to the Recreation and Conservation Commission, which is now a committee. Let me preface my comments by explaining a little bit of my background. I lived in Germany for 10 months, shortly after the Berlin Wall came down. I spent weeks at a time in countries like India. I've been to India 20 many times. Malaysia, Taiwan, China, Japan, many other Asian countries, and nearly every European country, at least once. Okay, last year, my wife and I visited Norway, where my grandfather immigrated from, before he settled in North Dakota as a wheat farmer, and why anybody would go to North Dakota from that, I don't understand. As a result of my travels, I've made friends all over the world of nearly every race, many religions, sexual orientations. I have friends that are Hindu, Jain, Buddhist, Shinto, Sunni, Shia, and Sufi Muslims, Mormon, Jehovah's Witness, Humanist, Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, and many of the myriads of Protestant denominations. I've grown to appreciate Mark Twain's quote, that travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness. I believe immigration is what made this country great because immigrants bring a diversity of culture, and there are things that I have seen overseas that I think should be brought here, many things I've seen over there. I believe it will be a great benefit from having non-citizens on that committee. I absolutely do. I don't think you need to be a U.S. citizen for that. however during that public hearing it sounded as though somebody could be on that committee who was in this country illegally I think that's a grave mistake as elected figures each of you should have sworn an oath to support and defend the US Constitution that means under the supremacy clause you must support and defend help enforce immigration law even if you personally or collectively disagree with that this is what your oath means if you're thwarting or impeding those efforts you're no different than the racist public officials in the south that violated federal laws protecting newly recognized rights of slaves. Please make it clear that persons in this country illegally are not allowed to serve in any capacity in our municipal government, and that you will work with law enforcement to remove people in the community that are not legally supposed to be here. That's [1:09:37] Speaker A (unidentified): your oath. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? [1:09:45] Speaker B (unidentified): Mr. Ledoux? I do have one hand on Zoom. Okay. [1:09:49] Speaker A (unidentified): Please state your name, and if you're a resident of Westbrook, and you have three minutes. [1:09:57] Speaker P (unidentified): Hi, Mark Fournier, 75 Warker Street, Westbrook resident. Just wanted to touch base on tomorrow, November 3rd, it's a voting day. And like you guys talked about earlier, there's a lot of stuff that goes into making this vote happen and happen smoothly and correctly. And Ellis does a great job. So just wanted to remind everybody that it's your duty to get out there and vote. So come out and vote tomorrow, November 3rd. and it doesn't matter who you're voting for just do your job come out and vote and second thing I just wanted to say really quick is I want to thank Anna for the way she spoke up at the meeting the first time I came and spoke in front of the city council I was really nervous because you hear about how unwelcoming city council meetings can be. And so she really encouraged me when she said that to me that first time to come out and speak. And there's a lot of people in our community who have opinions but will not come out because they're afraid to be judged. And what Anna did last week took a lot of courage. I wouldn't say we agree on everything. But I just wanted to thank you for doing that for the city, the citizens, and the people you represent in Westbrook. And don't forget, get out and vote. Vote Larry. [1:11:29] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other public comment? Okay. No referrals or committees. We are going into executive session. I request to enter into executive session pursuant to 1 MRSA section 403 6e for consultation with say solicitor concerning the legal rights and duties of the city inviting the following individuals to attend the city solicitor so moved second okay all in favor more executive session