← Back to MaineScanner

Rockland Planning Board approves boat storage site plan and discusses vacant building fees

2026-11-03 · 1h 28m · Source: 2026-11-03 PLANNING BOARD MEETING (City of Rockland (Vimeo))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Let's do a roll call first. Irene Flynn. Pat Brooke, I'm the acting chair tonight because Claire's dad is not feeling well. Dan Kelly. Okay. Our business tonight basically we're reviewing an application and site plan submitted by Landmark on behalf of SHM Rockland for a boat maintenance and storage facility. located at 56 New County Road. Then we have the review of an ordinance amendment submitted by the city that pertains to the approval and fees, et cetera, for vacant buildings. We then have time for public comment, and we have two sets of minutes. minutes. We have a question for, actually, as regards to the minutes. Am I allowed to vote on minutes that I was not present for? Yes. Okay. And that's it. So let's get started. I skipped over new communications. We don't have any new communications, do we, now? Would the applicant please come to the table? Oh, we on that map. We're City Hall on that map. Because it's close, isn't it? It's off the map. [1:55] Speaker B (unidentified): It's on Pleasant Street right here. Yeah. [1:58] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, so we're very close. I wasn't able to go out to the site visit, but my two colleagues did. So let's start with your testimony. Sure. [2:10] Speaker B (unidentified): So my name is Mike Sabatini. I'm with Landmark. And this is... [2:14] Speaker C (unidentified): Ian Buba. actually was safe harbor the client owner of the property yes safe harbor Rockland is essentially [2:23] Speaker B (unidentified): buildings that the original building was that old there's been an expansion at all over the years with the latest around 2019 ish safe harbor purchased the property in 2021 when they purchased the property This is the existing conditions that it looked like there was the gravel yard the temporary building was there Yeah And look like and the project is proposing to place a large building 130 by 230 for 29 000 square feet yeah where that gravel yard is and it'll be used for its boat storage and maintenance just like they do in their existing building and it's not really an expansion of the of the use per se because a lot of the built the boats that are stored outside will now get stored inside it's gonna allow them to do a lot more work on boats on in and out of the weather they're not planning to expand their employees per se same amount of employees just to go over the site a little bit for employees to get back and forth and go over utilities there the water will be extended in okay the water will be extended internally okay and the power there'll be a new service coming from pleasant street there'll be a pole set just on the other side on their side of pleasant street and then underground power to the building there's going to be a new sewer connection there's just employee bathrooms in the back corner of the building that will drain to a pump station at the front corner of the building and utilizing the existing sewer connection in Pleasant Street that's all shown on the plan There will be a new LP gas tank added and a line going to the new building. That's about it for utilities. The biggest other improvement is the stormwater management. This project is subject to stormwater law and DP review, and there will be two soil filters on the project. [5:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Could you talk more into the mic? Yeah, because I'm having trouble hearing you. [5:06] Speaker B (unidentified): There'll be two soil filters, excuse me, and they're shown in green on the plan. And there will be drip edge filters capturing roof runoff from the proposed building and part of the existing building. Since we last talked at our pre-application meeting, we have added landscaping to the plan, which include 28 dark green arborvitaes in two different locations. One is to screen a residential property on this corner, and the other is, I guess that's to the west, where there is some residential uses in that direction, and kind of a view from Belvedere Street. Some other information that we provided was lighting. we have a photometric plan included in the application package and there's a max of seven point three foot candles all building mounted lights all down downward facing there's an average of point four foot candles but more importantly it's less than one foot candle you know at the property line in all locations yeah that about does it I guess on site we talked about the dumpster locations and another container that has some hazardous material and location of that happy to discuss that further yeah happy to [6:42] Speaker A (unidentified): answer any questions. Okay, so before we get into anything substantive, does anyone on the board have an additional material submission that they would need in order to find the application complete? No? No? Okay, then I move that we find the application complete. I need a second. Second. I move that we find the application complete. [7:12] Speaker D (unidentified): I've seconded. I can't. Yes. Okay. [7:17] Speaker A (unidentified): Vote. Yes. Three. So, we find your application complete. Now, I need to open a public hearing. [7:26] Speaker E (unidentified): Pat, could I clarify something? You had a site walk today, and who attended? You two. [7:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Okay. Thank you. Okay. I'm opening a public hearing for any public comments on this application. No. In that case, I'm closing the public hearing. so now basically I'll ask Elias to present the staff report. [8:05] Speaker F (unidentified): Report so late to you guys. I, we're a little short staffed and it takes a little time to put these things together, but I'll present it here and then we can go over any questions so the proposed structures for existing activities on the property there's no additional activities that are going to be taking place on the property according to the applicant required reviews are the site development standards there's a question of whether performance guarantees shall be required for several different elements and then a review of technical standards in that same chapter so the properties in the rockland thomaston upper pleasant street neighborhood for those of you who attended the site visit you see that it connects pleasant and new county roads there's curb openings on both sides which makes it a corner lot under the definition of rockland's ordinances meaning that there is no rear setback we have side setbacks and front setbacks and there's different setbacks for residential and for commercial and you can see those in your zoning table in the staff report on the second page So the existing parcel includes approximately a 58,000-square-foot warehouse and boat repair facility as well as an 8,000-square-foot temporary fabric structure, and the fabric structure will be replaced by the proposed structure. That structure was previously permitted by the planning board. And the new structure falls into a major site plan review because it meets the square footage requirement, meaning that it comes before the planning board, and the approximate square footage is $29,900. square feet. For the purposes of stormwater management, the impervious surface area will be reduced by about 5,000 square feet. The applicant has adequate financial and technical capacity to complete the project and is the current owner of the property. All the zoning standards are met, which you can see in the table. If there's any questions about those, we can go over those. So I'll briefly go over what I wrote in the site development and technical standards and then we can go through each one from the board's perspective to see if there are any questions for each of those elements so for traffic and circulation as I mentioned before there's no anticipated increase in the volume of traffic or activity because again this is predominantly existing activities which are being moved inside with limited additional volume and roughly the same number of employees as well as there is adequate space for circulation maneuvering of vehicles and the fire chief did review for adequate emergency services access the applicant has proposed indoor bicycle storage bicycle storage is a requirement of the ordinance and snow storage is indicated on the site plan one question the board will have to address is that within the growth area sidewalks are required where no sidewalks currently exist that has not been a requirement that has been previously exercised for this lot during previous planning board reviews but the board will have to consider the applicant has requested a waiver and the board will have to consider whether to grant that parking and ada there's no change to existing parking arrangement there's no significant national natural features on the wetland on the parcel there are several wetland areas only one of which appears to be really a functional wetland we saw it on the site and they were impacted by previous development activities and are being reviewed as part of an MDP permit review process the applicants proposing buffering and screening abutting residential properties with our baby one of which we discussed modifying to extend a little bit further on the eastern boundary of the site. Yeah, I'd say that's the eastern corner. Yeah. [12:23] Speaker A (unidentified): And the applicant accepted that request? [12:27] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, I think the same amount of arborvitae, but just shifting them all. Okay. Yeah. [12:34] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah, and for those who don't know, arborvitae grow up to roughly like 25, 30 feet. They're somewhere between trees and shrubs, but grow up to the height of a tree. Is that accurate characterization? And the overall parking lot drive area will be reduced through some reduction in impervious surface and also because the large building is going to be taking up a bigger portion of the lot. Stormwater management. Management the applicant requested a waiver from the requirement that a full drainage study and calculations be provided due to the net decrease in the In the impervious surface the applicants also proposing several stormwater infrastructure improvements, which do not currently exist the public services department and the weight and the stormwater department have both indicated that they will require a line upgrade for the easterly most line towards Park Street that ties into city stormwater infrastructure and we discussed that a little bit on-site and it seemed like did you say towards Park Street it's like the one the [13:53] Speaker B (unidentified): one that's [13:58] Speaker G (unidentified): closest to Park Street I understand now thank you sediment [14:07] Speaker F (unidentified): and erosion control the majority of the site is you know on a is stabilized gravel soil the only area of concern is there's a steep slope again on that sort of easterly boundary where some of those Arbor V day are going to be going applicant has proposed riprap stabilization for that area which is an improvement over the current condition there's no real significant increase in demand for utility a no new water connection and we already discussed the stormwater line community safety so the proposed development was reviewed by fire and police and we got department head sign offs for those which should be on your desk there are fire hydrants in close proximity and adequate space for circulation the fire chief indicated that sprinkler and fire alarm systems will be required due to the size of the structure and one thing that we did come up over on site is that there's a hazardous waste container for products from boat repair that should be adequately marked for emergency services and cannot be relocated within the setback I'd probably just add it on to the onto the actual finding because you're allowed to say it has to be compliant with the setbacks and must be must be adequately marked yeah that's fair exterior lighting as the applicant noted the all exterior lights are full cut off downward facing fixtures there is very little light trespass on abutting properties the only there is a 0.4 foot candle 0.3 point yeah 0.3 foot candles on the abutting property at 173 Pleasant Street but that's a mixed-use property which can have up to one foot candle noise and vibration currently all the activities out are outside they're being moved inside there's not necessarily a reason to think that would do anything but improve the noise and vibration from the activities on the site architectural visual appearance substantially similar to existing buildings on the site the last piece, performance guarantee, when we talk about performance guarantees, we're talking about upfront costs to guarantee that the project is completed, and we talk about those specifically for soil stabilization, for erosion control, for sidewalk construction, or any other public- [16:53] Speaker A (unidentified): So basically, infrastructure that the applicant is responsible for putting in. Yeah, they have to do a performance guarantee. [17:00] Speaker F (unidentified): well yeah so the board would consider whether their performance guarantee is required I did discuss this with the other city departments stormwater and public services neither of which felt that a stormwater that a performance guarantee is necessary to complete the project and the board has not received any public comments at this time I'm also in this fight in this findings I'm proposing two conditions one is that the applicant should obtain all the required mdep permits and provide proof of approval to the city it's typos in that sentence apologies the applicant and that the applicant shall provide adequate stormwater infrastructure improvements in coordination and subject to the approval of the public services and stormwater departments in reference to that stormwater line in new county road yeah is there a timeline for providing that? For our purposes, a certificate of occupancy will not be issued until the [18:00] Speaker A (unidentified): conditions are satisfied. All right. That was fast. [18:04] Speaker B (unidentified): You wouldn't issue a building permit until we have a DEP permit, right? Right. Yeah. [18:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Let me look to see if I can't remember if I had any questions on this. I don't think I did. Irene, any questions on the submission? [18:21] Speaker G (unidentified): Are we going to go over the highlighted questions? [18:26] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that comes next, at least on my agenda. [18:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think it probably makes the most sense. We can go over the highlighted portions on here. I think it probably makes the most sense to go back through the standards and just make sure that nobody has any questions about each element before we move on. So starting at section- Page three, yeah, of your notes. starting at site development and technical standards proceeding down yeah [18:53] Speaker A (unidentified): so the first is the board should consider whether to grant this sidewalk waiver request the reason being that there's a sidewalk there now there is no [19:06] Speaker F (unidentified): sidewalk there's no sidewalk you talk so fast there is no sidewalk however this site has undergone several other planning board reviews at none of which, at no point was the sidewalk required. [19:25] Speaker A (unidentified): And you don't expect a lot of pedestrian traffic, no? No. People don't come to watch while you're building or repairing roads. [19:34] Speaker G (unidentified): I would think this is more for the people using Pleasant Street than just the business themselves And just looking at the grade change and the curve, I actually think this is a good candidate for a sidewalk for safety. [19:55] Speaker D (unidentified): I would agree with that, just anecdotally. And it is an anecdote, but still. There's quite a bit of pedestrian traffic on this street, school kids and such. It is a... On New County? On Pleasant. On Pleasant Street. Excuse me, yes. Yes. Yeah, kids walking home from school, going to a neighborhood. [20:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, how much of your site is on Pleasant? [20:17] Speaker G (unidentified): That's the side getting the development is more on the Pleasant Street side. [20:24] Speaker A (unidentified): Then on the new county, yeah. [20:26] Speaker G (unidentified): Which is a pretty busy street for ‑‑ 400 feet or so, something like that, looking [20:32] Speaker B (unidentified): at the map. On Pleasant Street? Yeah. Yeah. How many feet is that? [20:47] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, 300 or 400 feet, somewhere in that neighborhood. Okay. [20:52] Speaker A (unidentified): Elias, is there sidewalk on the rest of Pleasant Street? No. I drive Pleasant all the time, and I've never seen a pedestrian, to be honest. [21:00] Speaker F (unidentified): I mean, it's a terrible street to walk on, but there's no sidewalk anywhere else on Pleasant Street. [21:06] Speaker A (unidentified): And people do, pedestrians do use it. Yes. Because I guess I'm coming, I use it to come to Planning Board and leave it sometimes 8 o'clock at night, so no one's out there. [21:17] Speaker G (unidentified): I think one of the reasons people don't use it is because the hill portion with the curve is rather dangerous, especially if you're coming towards ‑‑ if you're driving this way and the sun is in your eyes, it's really hard to see people. I biked Pleasant Street a number of times to get to Planning Board and I could see it being useful to have a sidewalk to go on to. [21:50] Speaker A (unidentified): But you mean along the whole of Pleasant Street. [21:54] Speaker G (unidentified): We're just talking about the portion that... [21:56] Speaker A (unidentified): So, Elias, does the city have any plans to put a sidewalk on any other parts of Pleasant Street? [22:03] Speaker F (unidentified): Not as far as I know. [22:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah, there'd be a couple really nice trees that would have to get removed if we had to put a sidewalk there. If you're going to do sidewalk, then you're going to do curb, and there's no public storm drain system in Pleasant Street. I know I was involved in the Lowe's Hardware, which is a bigger project, and there was no sidewalk required there during that review, which is also in Pleasant Street. Yeah. I don't know. Isn't Lowe's in Thomaston? [22:41] Speaker G (unidentified): Huh? Isn't Lowe's in Thomaston? [22:43] Speaker B (unidentified): no that's not he means the project they have on pleasant it's low what's it's low it's called low yeah it's called but it's it's like very fancy oh okay they make like brass i see what you're saying yeah so it's right up it's right it's literally it's only one property up across the street and gotcha and there were you know it was discussed at the time and the board then this was several years ago but the board then was like you would need a full sidewalk in order to be safely on Pleasant Street there was talk about well you know the City Hall is on Pleasant Street you should be able to walk to City Hall which is a very good point but until the city comes forward with a project I don't know it just doesn't it doesn't seem to make sense on [23:29] Speaker G (unidentified): Pleasant Street to me yeah it's just you know looking at our comprehensive plans of plan. We have the complete streets language in there about trying to make Rockland more pedestrian and biker friendly and especially where City Hall is unpleasant. I think it makes sense to start trending that direction. [23:55] Speaker D (unidentified): I would second that and just say, no, I understand that removing trees, I'm not for that, generally speaking. But I think the argument that you're putting forward is basically we don't need a sidewalk in front of Safe Harbor because there's not sidewalk on the rest of the street. There should be sidewalk on all of the street, in my opinion. and that is in line with the comprehensive plan and this would be a step in that direction yeah [24:31] Speaker B (unidentified): it's a shame because there's mature landscaping beds there that are providing buffering is there if you're if you're dead set on it is there is there a way to have like a fee in lieu where it could you could come you could contribute to a sidewalk on pleasant street that the city [24:51] Speaker D (unidentified): undertakes a bigger project or I don't know that wouldn't really be a question for me I just on a personal note I'd rather see a sidewalk than money but I understand what you're saying how [25:14] Speaker A (unidentified): old are the trees that you would have [25:17] Speaker B (unidentified): to remove I'm [25:28] Speaker C (unidentified): also wondering how would we do that we essentially have to do to two ADA-compliant ramps on either side. [25:33] Speaker B (unidentified): And how do we go to know where they're going? Yeah, they go to know where. [25:36] Speaker C (unidentified): There's no way to cross across the street safely, so it's just opening up. Again, I'm just speculating how the scope. We keep elaborating to make sure that, to your point, you want to add this to Pleasant Street, but how do we make it so essentially no one's just kind of walking back [25:50] Speaker A (unidentified): into the street? Did you guys look at this today at the site plan and kind of in your head pencil out where the sidewalk would go? [25:58] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm just familiar with it from hiking it. [26:00] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, I'm very familiar with the, I'm a pedestrian, familiar with this area. [26:05] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I'm a pedestrian. Well, Elias, you might have to help me because I wouldn't agree I don't. I think unless the city has plans to put in the rest of the sidewalk, it's like a road to nowhere. I mean, it is, there's something nice about going in the right direction. The city wants sidewalks, but that part of Rockland, Route 1, Pleasant Street, doesn't seem to me to be a heavily pedestrian street and to require them to put their little portion, you know, where it's going to end. And I wish the city did have some funds and plans to sidewalk the entirety of Pleasant Street, but have we talked to whoever that would be, public works guy, or do they have any such intent? [27:07] Speaker F (unidentified): There's no intent that I know of to fund sidewalk improvements along this section of outer Pleasant Street. I didn't ask Todd. I should have asked Todd about what he thought about the sidewalk here. Todd, the Todd Philbrook, the director of public services. I think that the board should balance the potential benefit of what was it? 350 feet of sidewalk, right? Like, I mean, you've, we've talked about all the things that we're weighing here, right? Like one, is the potential to add a stretch of sidewalk where there is none. Another is that there is no other stretch of sidewalk to connect to anywhere along Outer Pleasant. We have trees that we're talking about being cut down. And then we're talking about what's the long-term goal? Does this contribute to the long-term goal of complete streets in a way that is substantially impactful? So, I mean, it's the board's decision. I think in the past, the board's looked at, in different situations, at Old County Road, a recent project, the board decided not to require sidewalks because the lack of connecting infrastructure made things more dangerous, potentially. Different street, different place. I think there's two competing considerations. Like, one is the city plans call for complete streets, and to get complete streets, we kind of have to stitch them together. And another is that you don't want a sidewalk to nowhere, right? It's not a – it doesn't increase safety. It decreases safety, and maybe it's wasteful. [29:00] Speaker A (unidentified): And loses a couple of really nice trees. Being a tree hugger myself, that really bothers me. [29:06] Speaker G (unidentified): Sure, but if we were to look at long-term sidewalks on Pleasant Street, it sounds like those trees would have to go. Yeah. [29:16] Speaker B (unidentified): You could choose the other side of the street. You would pick one side of the street, and that would be a bigger study. Sure. Like, okay, where is the sidewalk? What are the impacts on the south side? [29:27] Speaker A (unidentified): I mean, the comprehensive plan has been in effect for a while, hasn't it? Yes. Three, four, I don't mean ten years. I know it was three or four years ago. revised, but four years, five years? [29:40] Speaker D (unidentified): Four years, I believe. I think [29:45] Speaker F (unidentified): proximity to downtown and the imminent opportunities to connect to other sidewalks are also a factor. It could be ten years or longer or never by the time the city is able to fund sidewalks out of Pleasant Street. If it was a quarter mile from or whatever you know a thousand feet from the sidewalk then that increases the chances that the city is now going to say okay look we can connect the city has put [30:15] Speaker A (unidentified): a number of sidewalks in my neighborhood which is the south end yeah but that's less than half a mile into town right and there's a lot of pedestrian traffic actually in the south end Anyway, what do I do at this point? We have two people who want to, or I'll just make the motion and see how people vote, I [30:42] Speaker F (unidentified): guess. So anybody can make a motion. The motion would be to accept the waiver or to not accept the waiver request. I think, in addition, the other thing that has to be considered is the development's more on Pleasant Street, but the parcel front's on two sides of the street, or on two different streets. [31:12] Speaker A (unidentified): One is New County, right? Right. Well, Route 1, what I call Route 1. [31:17] Speaker B (unidentified): It's New County, yeah. [31:19] Speaker G (unidentified): It's not Route 1. [31:20] Speaker A (unidentified): It's not Route 1. Yeah. [31:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, it's New County Road. Oh. Well, a side street off Route 1, essentially. Also a pedestrian. [31:33] Speaker A (unidentified): So do we want to require sidewalks on New County, or are there sidewalks on New County? [31:38] Speaker F (unidentified): I would recommend that... My recommendation would be that the motion would include... The motion would be a condition that would... If you wanted to see the sidewalk, that the sidewalk be constructed or not constructed according to the public services director. Because mandating a sidewalk that hasn't been reviewed by the public services director when we don't know which side of the street, to Mike's point. [32:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Can you explain that a little bit more? [32:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, you could construct a motion along the lines of that the applicant would construct a sidewalk along the frontage, along Pleasant Street, if acceptable to the public services director. Something like that. It doesn't have to be that exact language. [32:42] Speaker D (unidentified): And if it wasn't acceptable to the public services director, Safe Harbor would not have to construct the sidewalk? [32:51] Speaker F (unidentified): Under that language, yes, but some, you're welcome to. [32:58] Speaker A (unidentified): But again, if we're doing this to comply with the comprehensive plan, the public services director usually engages someone to make a plan, you know, for where they want sidewalks and which side of the street and all that. so you wouldn't want to build a sidewalk that he or she had disapproved. [33:19] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, you would not want to have a sidewalk in a place where the public services director does not want it. [33:24] Speaker A (unidentified): He said, no, we don't want a sidewalk there. That's the counterproductive. [33:28] Speaker C (unidentified): And if I may bring up just one thing, there also isn't any structures on Pleasant. There's no drainage, so essentially now all that runoff, that would typically run off onto our property, would not go easily and continue downward, so now you're risking that runoff going farther down the road so unless the drainage structure would have to figure out how to capture that so just again just add it to the scope of like how this would yeah I hear what you're [33:54] Speaker G (unidentified): saying is there some way that we can look more into this before having you 're making good points, and talking to the public works folks seems like a prudent idea. I just want to make sure that Rockland's trending in the direction that the comprehensive plan would like us to go towards. And I just have concerns about this hill in general because of how unsafe I feel on it. so i think it would be worthwhile to look into whether or not a sidewalk there is a viable option or a bad option but do we have to hold up the approval the side plan on that unless you [34:48] Speaker A (unidentified): constructed a condition as a condition yeah would you be okay with constructing it as a condition [34:53] Speaker F (unidentified): i don't really know how the so the person i mean to be honest like i get that was kind of why i was suggesting the public services like Todd Phil Burke is the person who would have the expertise to evaluate whether a sidewalk was desirable or not in that area yeah in terms of both stormwater runoff in terms of you know [35:14] Speaker A (unidentified): practicality in terms of in plain English your motion is saying the applicant has to construct a sidewalk have such time as the public services Public Services Director, does his view make, or her view make the finding that the city wants a sidewalk on that particular area? Exactly. Exactly. [35:34] Speaker D (unidentified): In situations where we've required a sidewalk to be constructed, have we, have we had this sort of thing before where the Public Services Director has to okay it? Is that typical? Yes. [35:49] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I wouldn't require, I would not require an applicant to construct a sidewalk without [35:54] Speaker E (unidentified): consulting public you did it okay that's what i thought i think it's elm street where there was a new building yes right and it's all up to the public services director the design [36:07] Speaker F (unidentified): the installation time and approval yep yeah and yeah and that one had some other wrinkles as well but certainly we needed we can't we can't people cannot build anything in the public look way without the public services directors, you know, okay. So in the interest of not holding up approval, deferring to the expertise of the public services director may be the best option to move forward. [36:39] Speaker A (unidentified): So I move that we require the applicant to build a sidewalk at such time as the public services director has done a review and approves the building of the sidewalk [36:54] Speaker F (unidentified): at their location or requires yeah can i can i state it back to you to make sure [37:02] Speaker G (unidentified): we're on the same page and then we can it also looks like there's a question oh well i just i [37:07] Speaker B (unidentified): just wanted to before you guys make a vote on this i wanted to state that or reiterate i guess that this site has been before the board multiple times and it has gone through this waiver because this is not a new part of the ordinance. The sidewalk requirement has been there and they've said, ah, it's probably not a good idea. Nearby projects like low hardware, similarly we're saying, well, we're too far out from downtown. If we're gonna put a piece of sidewalk here, it's gonna be years before we got any kind of sidewalk. So those are all justifications of why it was not seen as necessary to build a sidewalk I totally understand your sentiment that says oh well if we if we always do that then they'll never be any sidewalk built but if you're further in town if in the sidewalk is a little bit more in reach it makes sense to go ahead and build that but this far out of town in my opinion it doesn't make sense and in precedent of other planning board other projects before the planet I've seen similar decisions made that it wouldn't be required so i just wanted to yeah reiterate that i understand your position i get your sentiment absolutely i just i wasn't expecting this i figured it would [38:23] Speaker G (unidentified): be like a no-brainer that it would be waived so rockland does currently we have a working group working on bike and pedestrian infrastructure especially around south school which is just off of Broadway, and many people drive or walk on Pleasant Street to Broadway to the school. So it's quite close to the school, further away from the downtown area. [38:50] Speaker D (unidentified): And how close are we to the nearest sidewalk? I think it's about a block away, city block away. Oh, my gosh. It's on the corner. [39:01] Speaker B (unidentified): You'd have to cross Broadway to add some sidewalk. [39:03] Speaker D (unidentified): It's on the other side of Broadway. [39:06] Speaker G (unidentified): yeah which is probably like a quarter mile but broadway has got a city block yeah i mean broadway [39:12] Speaker D (unidentified): has a big block but yeah okay so [39:19] Speaker F (unidentified): the motion as i understand it as you presented was that the [39:22] Speaker A (unidentified): no one seconded it except just that means table well or void or whatever the word is so the motion [39:32] Speaker F (unidentified): let's just i just want to clarify the motion that you tried to make so the motion was that the applicant be required to construct a sidewalk along the frontage of the lot along Pleasant Street should it be required by the public services director. Yes. Or deemed necessary by the public services director. Is that? [39:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, that was the motion, but no one seconded it. So I'm not an expert of parliamentary procedures. [40:08] Speaker F (unidentified): you know yeah so if you don't have a second then that motion would fail right so do we have a [40:14] Speaker D (unidentified): different motion dan do you have a motion i don't right now i'm not necessarily opposed to that it sort of suggests that i mean public services director will probably say we don't need a sidewalk there and i would like to see a sidewalk there so i'm that's my reasoning for not seconding that motion but [40:42] Speaker A (unidentified): i well should we just vote well you can't vote without a second but sure no not vote on the motion vote on considering whether to grant the sidewalk waiver you [40:58] Speaker F (unidentified): can do that but you just to be clear just to be clear like requiring a sidewalk that is not recommended or desired by the public services director is not going to be a functional way to proceed right like that is not going to be that's not really in accordance with the comprehensive plan I mean it is in theory but the public services director is responsible for everything in the right of way and if he doesn't want it there he cannot allow the applicant to [41:26] Speaker A (unidentified): construct it and I believe there was the last sidewalk we required was the one on Elm Street which is in the downtown area and the public service the whole department was heavily involved that was paid for by the city yeah it was the housing right yeah this is way I'm willing to second that's I said I'm willing to second motion sure so then we vote yes all those in favor of requiring considering the construction of a sidewalk by the applicant at such time as it is required by the public services director? Vote yes. [42:12] Speaker F (unidentified): As deemed necessary by the public services director. [42:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, required by the public services director. That was one of your words. Anyway, I vote yes. Okay. [42:27] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, and so that is a condition of approval, so that avoids the need to consider whether [42:38] Speaker A (unidentified): to grant, we're not granting the sidewalk waiver request, do we need to vote on that too? [42:43] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, you would grant, the proper way to proceed would be to grant the waiver request subject to the condition of approval that you just passed. [42:50] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, so I move that we grant the sidewalk waiver request subject to a condition of approval that we just passed all those in favor Okay, the sign [43:07] Speaker E (unidentified): Pardon me. I missed the second. I'll second it. Oh, okay. Thanks. So yeah, you're gonna have to read that. Okay, [43:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Pardon me. So you have to hold the vote again because you didn't have a second. Okay, so [43:19] Speaker A (unidentified): So, okay. Just go through the whole motion thing again? [43:27] Speaker F (unidentified): Just say all those in favor of the... [43:29] Speaker A (unidentified): All those in favor of granting the sidewalk waiver on the condition we just approved. Yeah. Raise your hand. [43:36] Speaker F (unidentified): And Irene's seconded. Yeah. Okay. The [43:44] Speaker A (unidentified): next highlighted area is the board should consider whether a waiver should be granted for stormwater management. Does Planning Code have a viewpoint on this? Sorry? Do you have a viewpoint on whether we should grant a waiver for stormwater management study, [44:11] Speaker F (unidentified): I guess? Yeah. Typically, or at least in every other application that I've been a part of, when there's a net decrease in impervious surface, the applicant generally does not have to provide a fully engineered stormwater study. [44:23] Speaker G (unidentified): and they also gave us the main DEP and there's and it's subject to DEP [44:30] Speaker F (unidentified): processes which presumably are more robust okay so let's try this again I [44:40] Speaker A (unidentified): move that we whether we will grant a waiver to the requirement that a full drainage study and engineering calculation be provided as part of this application? [44:57] Speaker F (unidentified): You should move to accept or to deny the waiver. Okay. [45:02] Speaker A (unidentified): You need to give me the language next time I lie. [45:05] Speaker F (unidentified): This is not working. I put some language on there. [45:10] Speaker G (unidentified): This makes perfect, right? Anybody [45:13] Speaker F (unidentified): can make a motion. It doesn't have to be Pat every time. Okay, [45:17] Speaker A (unidentified): so now I need a second? I second. all those in favor so that motion passes three to zero the next is sediment and erosion control the applicant is asking us to waive the requirement that the performance guarantee for stabilization be required and that's basically because the proposed development because our parcel that's already developed with the majority of surfaces composed of stabilized gravel and erosion control measures are part of the Maryland Department of Environmental Protection. [46:02] Speaker F (unidentified): Do I have that right? You said Maryland. [46:06] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm Maryland, Maine. I used to live in Washington, D.C., so Maine Department of Environmental Protection process. any discussion on this any [46:19] Speaker G (unidentified): opinion I move that we accept the waiver I second [46:25] Speaker A (unidentified): all those in favor okay three zero anything else highlighted a lot of that should be it. That's it. So at this point, do we vote on acceptance of the site plan at this point? [47:03] Speaker F (unidentified): I will read each finding of fact into the record, and if there's any further discussion, we won't have to vote on each one. No. You can vote at the end, but that way if there's any further discussion, and you can stop me and then you'll have the motion at the end of the finding document and we'll add the conditions as well at the end so the first finding in fact is based on the submitted application materials the project's description of components related to traffic access and circulation the board finds that the applicant is that this standard is determined to be met pursuant to condition number three which will be the sidewalk condition based on the submitted application materials and the project's descriptions to components related to significant natural features protection the standard is determined to be met based on the subject so based on the submitted application materials and the project's description of components related to landscaping buffering and screening the board finds that the standard is determined to be met based and vibration this standard is determined to be met based on the submitted application materials and the project's description of components related to architectural and visual appearance this standard is determined to be met and then lastly based on the submitted application materials and the project's description of components related to public improvements landscaping erosion and sedimentation control or and other elements of the project the board will not require a performance guarantee any [49:22] Speaker A (unidentified): questions so the board discussion so [49:28] Speaker F (unidentified): the next step and we still have not received any public comment but the next step will be to read the or one of you will make a motion it could be the motion that i have proposed on the findings if you so wish and then we will go through the and you'll also include the conditions condition number three being the one that was just approved So, [49:52] Speaker A (unidentified): say that we are about to approve your reading of the findings of fact into the record? [50:01] Speaker F (unidentified): So the next step is to make a motion to approve or deny or postpone the project. The proposed motion I have on page six is a motion that could be made by a member of the Board and should include the conditions of approval, including the one that was just added. Okay. [50:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Then I move that on the basis of the application plans, reports, and other information submitted by the applicant, findings and recommendations contained in the Planning board report for the public hearing on November 3rd 2026 relevant to the site plan standards of chapter 16 of the Rockland City Code and the testimony presented at the planning board hearing the planning board find that the plan is in conformance with site plan standards of chapter 16 subject to the condition We just approved which is that the applet repeat the condition [51:12] Speaker F (unidentified): You can read so you can say subject to the conditions contained in this report as well as okay [51:19] Speaker A (unidentified): subject to the conditions contained in this report yep, and including the [51:24] Speaker F (unidentified): Requirement that the applicant work with the public services [51:27] Speaker A (unidentified): And including the requirement that they must work with the public services director to see whether... [51:34] Speaker F (unidentified): To determine whether a sidewalk shall be required. [51:37] Speaker A (unidentified): A sidewalk construction will be necessary. [51:41] Speaker F (unidentified): And then you need a second. I need a second. [51:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Second. Okay. All those in favor? All right. Excellent. So the site plan is approved 3-0. [51:57] Speaker F (unidentified): We will get... Yeah, we can, why don't we sign them after the meeting and you can come pick them up, is that okay? That's fine. [52:05] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you need, you have plans? [52:07] Speaker F (unidentified): We have plans, yep, all set. Okay, yeah. [52:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Will you just scan that and send a signed version? You don't need the physical. [52:16] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, that too? Yeah, I'll figure it out. Sounds good. Thank you, everybody. [52:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, moving along. We have, I think, next is the review of the vacant building ordinance amendment to chapter ordinance amendment number 27, chapter 4, article 5, vacant buildings. Are we all familiar with the latest rendition of the ordinance amendment? I have [53:02] Speaker G (unidentified): one question just on it says guidelines to regular vacant commercial industrial is it supposed to say regular or regulate which one of it so there's [53:17] Speaker F (unidentified): two there's two ordinances one was the original one that was on your desk last time that was proposed and then the other one is the proposed amendment [53:25] Speaker A (unidentified): But no, we're looking at the agenda, 5A, number one, I, little I, second line. [53:36] Speaker G (unidentified): Should say regulate. Regulate, yes. Very good. [53:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Discussion on this? I think I'll start out with, if I can find the right thing here. I still don't think the fee structure is adequate, but I don't know whether we have any input on that or whether that's simply done by... I mean, they did increase it to say it's $500 for every six months that you are vacant and you have not obtained this certificate of approval. approval. I think that's really de minimis for most. [54:32] Speaker G (unidentified): It's up to $5,000. [54:34] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, the total, if you go on for ten six-month periods, which is five years, then you will pay $5,000. In other words, it's $500 every six months, forever and ever, up to $5,000. I want to— But that means that they've been vacant without approval for five years. [54:55] Speaker F (unidentified): I want to flag that the proposed amendment has a year-long Certification periods rather than six months and that was mostly because we don't have the capacity to Chase sick every six months. Yeah So we have two we have no I'm looking at the new one I didn't bother [Speaker A (unidentified): Again so] the new one has it [55:29] Speaker A (unidentified): So the new one, number eight, fees, A, initial six-month period, B, second six-month period. [55:42] Speaker F (unidentified): I think that may be the old one. The one that I'm looking at says proposed amendment at the top on the first page. Well, it was first. [55:58] Speaker G (unidentified): And that one's different than the one that was on top of it? Yes. Okay. [56:03] Speaker F (unidentified): okay so there's two versions there the reason that there are two included in your packet is because the one with the red line edits which is the original version is the only one that was has been officially submitted okay this other one will potentially as of Monday and I'd probably say likely replace the [56:31] Speaker G (unidentified): old amendment so I probably not as familiar was this one the proposed amendment one sent out in our was it in my packet yes it was but normally one [56:50] Speaker A (unidentified): files the most recent document on top and documents underneath it so I took the one on top taking that to be the proposal but fair enough anyway okay yeah did [57:07] Speaker G (unidentified): so i'm not as familiar as this one but i did have a question on or did we answer your question no [57:13] Speaker A (unidentified): because now eliza say that the 500 fee carries them for a year yeah if you go to that same [57:21] Speaker F (unidentified): section in the other document to the number yes yep so [57:35] Speaker G (unidentified): it would be ten years before it's at the $5,000 correct exactly so if you're vacant and not in conformance for ten years yeah it seems like perhaps they should have doubled the 500 to a thousand so then they would have been the same college is going to [57:58] Speaker A (unidentified): go for the full year and then if you are you know scoff law for the five full years you will pay $5,000 which seems to still be pretty low to me so [58:15] Speaker F (unidentified): the that's certainly feedback that can be provided to counsel right like you asked if you haven't you have input on whatever you want to have input on because you're writing a memo and it's it's the opinion of the board so you can include whatever feedback you wish to I think one thing is that the feet all fees have to be tied to services that are provided they have to be one tied to services that are provided like we cannot arbitrarily decide to make our building permit ten thousand dollars it has to be tied to the amount of staff time that is the amount of costs that you're off sitting to the city so in order to law yes, so in order to charge higher fees, you would have to make a case that vacant buildings You know that if you're gonna charge them a thousand dollars a year that the city is spending that much in [59:12] Speaker A (unidentified): Code police fire. Well, where'd they get the 500 then? Yeah, that's my question, too [59:19] Speaker F (unidentified): I'm not saying it's I'm not saying you can't do it I'm saying that 's a context for the for the way that you fees have to be calculated [59:26] Speaker A (unidentified): But I mean was this some Expert calculation to come up with the $500 fee. I [59:33] Speaker F (unidentified): Think it was in line. It was developed by the city attorney by what the city attorney, okay? [59:41] Speaker D (unidentified): It feels arbitrary [59:44] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I'm not against it. I just I just don't think it's high enough. Do you think it's high enough? [59:51] Speaker D (unidentified): I Don't know enough about the research I know these sort of proposals are controversial in other cities so I don't know it seems low I mean speaking candidly it seems like well if we're gonna do it why not charge [1:00:13] Speaker A (unidentified): more well I'm thinking of Burger King for example that's been vacant since I moved here five years ago and they've never been charged anything and the fire [1:00:25] Speaker G (unidentified): department's been there multiple times oh yes and you could absolutely make the argument that [1:00:31] Speaker F (unidentified): the city spends x amount more in costs for vacant buildings right like that's part of the foundation for where the fee is and those numbers aren't hard and fast because every building might be different just like every building permit is different sure so there's wiggle there's definitely wiggle room there i'm just giving that context the conversation i'm not saying you couldn't charge You couldn't justify a higher fee. I'm just saying that there are some parameters to how you set your fees [1:01:02] Speaker D (unidentified): Allies could I ask you kind of an outside question? You went to school for urban planning something like that What's your understanding of the research about these sort of ordinances? [1:01:14] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, I think We've done well, we've done some own our own outreach with other cities and I think it's still pretty early to tell a lot and every word the biggest problem is that every ordinance is different sure so we've worked really hard to get this ordinance to be as like practical to implement as possible because that's really where things start to fall apart like we talked to cities that have very complex ordinances that are very strict very hard to comply with and It's really hard to get anywhere when you're just all you have is you must do this or else Like there needs to be enough sort of incentives to do the right things to actually help people get off the vacant building certification list. Other cities we talked to just have continuously added buildings and not taken them off, and then other cities have had a lot of success reducing them. So it's really mixed results, and it really depends on the local economy and the way the ordinance is structured, which I know is not a super clear answer, but I think it is a little bit uncharted territory. Sure. [1:02:24] Speaker D (unidentified): What are the potential downfalls of this sort of thing? And I ask because instinctually I kind of agree with it. So what's the other side say? [1:02:38] Speaker F (unidentified): Potential downsides. I mean, I think about it a lot in terms of kind of like what I was just saying, like complexity of administration, like it's a capacity. We spend time enforcing it, right? and so the city itself has limited resources right we're always resource confined and so things that we spend more time on take away from time that we're spending other things so if we're spending time on it and it doesn't work then right that's a net loss if it does work then maybe it's worth it so I think the potential downfall or the potential downside of it is that it's an additional cost that can be imposed that doesn't achieve its intended end but the potential upside is that it's a cost that effectively promotes the revitalization of vacant buildings okay I don't so I don't I don't know if that answers your question no it [1:03:42] Speaker D (unidentified): doesn't but I didn't expect you to I understand that these questions don't have answers I'm just yeah what do you think the [1:03:52] Speaker F (unidentified): potential downsides are i [1:03:56] Speaker D (unidentified): agree with you that it's essentially a waste of time not to be too blunt but i mean honestly it seems like a good idea seems worth trying yeah i [1:04:13] Speaker G (unidentified): have a question which is why use both license and certificate to talk about it because i ended up feeling very confused as to if those were different things or the same thing so five is license required and then six is certificate application and under license required it talks about the vacant the first thing it says a vacant property certificate what is it yeah I think that's a good comment okay great [1:04:53] Speaker A (unidentified): Great, because using two different words for the same thing is a big no-no. [1:04:58] Speaker G (unidentified): It's very confusing. Everything you write. [1:05:01] Speaker A (unidentified): So what do we like, a license or a certificate? [1:05:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, they use certificate more, so I feel like it's a certificate. [1:05:09] Speaker A (unidentified): So just make number five, license certificate required. Yeah, because the next sentence after license required says a vacant property certificate is required. board. [1:05:39] Speaker G (unidentified): I also, for the memo that we give the board, it looks like they, maybe they expanded it, but in the one I spent the most time with, there were not, I don't think there were an adequate amount of reasons why someone should be able to forego having a certificate for a period of time like there's there's nothing there was nothing on if there's like legal proceedings going on the property because if something's tied up in title like it's hard to tell someone to do work on a building if the tight they find out the title is not clean and well [1:06:40] Speaker A (unidentified): could we use language like the reasons include but are not limited to but you [1:06:48] Speaker G (unidentified): You know, then it gets very gray. I understand why I'm having this. They still need approval. [1:06:59] Speaker F (unidentified): The reasons in the current ordinance, the newer version, are so it's located in the definition of the vacant building, which is in Section 2B, and it reads, a commercial industrial residential building which has not been used or occupied for its intended purpose for a period of at least 90 consecutive days and is not undergoing construction rehabilitation renovation or repair pursuant to a valid building permit so that's one reason you wouldn't have to get it construction or repair to damage by fire or extreme weather so requiring demolition or significant rehab or three listed for sale or lease at a or below the fair market value of the property so those are the three main reasons that you would be able to avoid. [1:07:48] Speaker A (unidentified): But Irene is absolutely right because it could have said something like the owner must have clean title. I don't know how you would have. [1:07:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Or like something about if the. If there's litigation. Yeah, if there's some sort of litigation. Right. [1:08:07] Speaker A (unidentified): Which would make action by the owner. [1:08:10] Speaker E (unidentified): Like an estate. [1:08:12] Speaker D (unidentified): Could we just. Sure. Sorry. Inheritance. question could we just say something as simple as the owner is legally unable to [1:08:22] Speaker G (unidentified): occupy or work like can provide that they're working on the legal side [1:08:29] Speaker F (unidentified): to be clear to you don't have to come up with the exact language because it's just going to go in a memo which will be reviewed by counsel and the city attorney so that way you present the idea i mean i think the language you just suggested was pretty that would be pretty good clear [1:08:43] Speaker D (unidentified): Clear enough, not too vague, just say legally unable, okay. [1:08:46] Speaker F (unidentified): Yeah, and I mean, at least from there, they know what you're talking about, and then they can adapt it as necessary. [1:08:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Guys, anything else on this? [1:08:58] Speaker G (unidentified): I think, yeah, this is another very nitpicky thing, but for Section 4-508, vacant properties, it goes one purpose, two definitions, and then there's no three. [1:09:12] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes, I know, yes. There's a few typos. There's also a hanging lettered subsection at the east section. [1:09:23] Speaker D (unidentified): Hanging chads? Just a little election night joke. [1:09:28] Speaker G (unidentified): Yes, thank you. Very good. [1:09:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Are we ever going to hear election news? [1:09:39] Speaker G (unidentified): Did anyone? Any other? I would I guess in that same memo where we talk about the legal things is just ask the council to really think about what other or maybe like consult with the city attorney on like what other reasons someone may be unable to because that's just one that I [1:10:20] Speaker A (unidentified): I guess my issue with this whole thing is, what was the city's purpose in amending this ordinance? Was it to simply get some money into city coffers to reimburse it for money spent on vacant buildings? or was it somehow to incentivize or I guess with property rights you can't really force, but to really incentivize the owner of the building to do something with that building, either sell it, occupy it, or tear it down. And I don't think if you look at incentivize, the only incentive really is the fee. So it comes back to, is that big enough to incentivize any owner to change this building from being a vacant Burger King for five, ten, I don't know how many years it's been vacant, into an occupied building, you know, something that would enhance the city of Rockland downtown rather than just be an eyesore. I'm not sure what the city was trying to get by doing this yeah I think I mean as far as I can [1:11:43] Speaker F (unidentified): tell from the meetings I've gone to and the stated purpose is basically that there are associated costs with vacant buildings that are above those of non-vacant buildings right after building is vacant for three months or you know there are potentially additional visits from police or fire that may be necessary or code enforcement as well. So some of it is to compensate for that cost and I think that but I do think the real purpose or one of the major purposes of it is to try to spur some sort of economic revitalization in the areas that are vacant. [1:12:22] Speaker A (unidentified): And see to do that you really need a bigger fee. It comes back to the fees. Because we're not saying we'll put you in jail if you don't do something with this building the only the only stick we have you know is a decent fee that would induce them to say oh it's better to just sell this building because simply collecting $500 a year seems like nothing to me at least it's something [1:12:55] Speaker G (unidentified): thing though towards the it's the ems and code enforcement it's something it's it's something but [1:13:05] Speaker D (unidentified): it just feels like if the council i mean there's a lot of work that goes into this and you know they care about it presumably so it ought to be a stick that yeah really kind of hurts you know elias you may know this does it have to be a flat rate can it be increasing every year for instance or could it be a percentage of their property tax or it could be a lot of things are there more are there more creative ways to do this that i don't know if they'd be better [1:13:40] Speaker F (unidentified): do you have any thoughts about that i think so it doesn't have to be a flat rate the current scheme does increase every year by five it doubles or yeah so it goes up by $500 each year the you can tie it to things that are reasonably related to the cost of service that you're providing so you could maybe do it by square footage [1:14:11] Speaker D (unidentified): But that wouldn't be directly tied to the city's burden of having to collect these fees. You couldn't do it by property taxes. Yeah, you couldn't really make a case for that. So kind of a flat but increasing fee is kind of the way to go because square footage. But that might be arbitrary if you have a building that's right down the street. downtown but really small but a huge eyesore versus a huge building but on the edge of town [1:14:47] Speaker F (unidentified): it's not really causing much problem i will say that my that our goal in our department with our fees is to streamline them as much as possible where they're one easy to figure out currently our fees are not that easy to figure out because you over the years people have tried to capture so many different situations that you're some of them you're calculating by cost of or by cost of the project, some of them are calculated by square footage. I've seen other cities that calculate building permits by cost of the project, square footage, and then have different multipliers for different type of structure and different multipliers for different types of story because they're trying to assign the appropriate amount of fee for each different situation. In general, the way that I believe fees work is that there are always going to be some people who pay less than the amount of work that is being done on their project, and there's always going to be people who pay more, you're trying to get that middle while keeping the fees reasonable and easy to administer. [1:15:50] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, the speeding ticket conundrum. Yes. Porsche versus Honda Civic, who pays more. [1:16:00] Speaker A (unidentified): So where are we, ladies and gentlemen? [1:16:05] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, I don't know how to write a memo. [1:16:07] Speaker F (unidentified): I think, so I think one of you or multiple of you would volunteer to do it. It can be bullet points, right? The planning board supports or doesn't support or neither supports nor... [1:16:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Don't you and Claire kind of have a format? Because I've written a couple of these memos, several, and then I noticed Claire had like her own. She changed the format. [1:16:30] Speaker F (unidentified): Claire may have a format, but it can be... There's no strict, fast rule about it. I think a good memo is probably going to have a few... I mean, you talked about how much... Generally, it sounded like you thought the fee should be more, right? It sounded like there was the confusion about the license versus certificate. And then what else? [1:16:57] Speaker G (unidentified): That they should, if they cannot legally sell the property. [1:17:08] Speaker F (unidentified): Or legally sell or legally occupy. well either if they can't so I mean a memo could be as simple as you know dear City Council the Planning Board supports the passage of this ordinance with the following comments any of your three bullets that's or it could be more expensive than that it's really up to you but it doesn't have to be a comprehensive policy memo. It can be just reflective of the discussion. So you're volunteering for this, Irene? [1:17:45] Speaker G (unidentified): Sure. Wonderful. And who do I send it to? [1:17:48] Speaker F (unidentified): So you'll send it to myself, to Claire, and to Stuart. And Stuart, do you have Stuart's email? I can give it to you. In [1:18:09] Speaker A (unidentified): terms of discussion on this, where's my agenda? And I think this means we can go on two minutes because we already did our public comment. So we have minutes to approve from two days, June 18th and July 7th. [1:18:38] Speaker E (unidentified): Is that the one you're going to do first, July 7th? [1:18:42] Speaker A (unidentified): July 7th. The first one in the package is July 7th, yeah. Okay. So I had a comment on line 30, the word plants. I think you meant plants. Oh, thank you. And then on line 32, this is really nitpicky, but instead of before, if you say they will, I tend to ask who's they. say, you mean the museum, I gather. [1:19:25] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm sorry, Pat, where are you? Line 32 [1:19:28] Speaker A (unidentified): on July 7th. [1:19:36] Speaker G (unidentified): So two years before the museum. Two years before they will need to [1:19:41] Speaker E (unidentified): relocate. Oh, the museum? [1:19:45] Speaker A (unidentified): The Lighthouse Museum will remain in place and open for two years. I would say it, referring to a museum instead of they you wanted to say right the museum okay line 39 at the very end you say there will be a staging area including ukraine i would say located out back of the building they're not building anything in [1:20:24] Speaker G (unidentified): bed aren't they building the staging area i don't [1:20:26] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't think you've built a building. I just think it's less, whatever you just say, located because we're really not sure. And of course, I wasn't there and that, I think that was it for me on the set of anybody else? No. No. So, can we have a motion that includes both of these units? Mm-hmm. All right. so June 16th on line 25 it says agent is that acorn without the H or is that really the company's name? A-C-H-O-R-N? I believe that's how you spell it. That is [1:21:16] Speaker D (unidentified): how you spell it. I think yeah I've seen their trucks. [1:21:20] Speaker E (unidentified): I had to find Finn Bondeson's name, so that's, I searched it with acorn spelled that way to find it. [1:21:32] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody else on page one? No. On page two line 19, it says the proposed fence for the eastern edge of the property where there is no landscaping will also be addressed by mr. town that's yes that's but it's [1:22:02] Speaker G (unidentified): spelled K a and then is that isn't it HN no okay sorry I didn't know what that [1:22:10] Speaker A (unidentified): meant exactly how do you address the proposed fence was that all there was to that discussion? [1:22:20] Speaker F (unidentified): Which, sorry, which line are you on, Pat? [1:22:21] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, line 90 on page two of June 16. [1:22:38] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm not sure. That verb does seem like it could be a little clearer. [1:22:41] Speaker E (unidentified): I'm not sure what Amanda said. [1:22:44] Speaker F (unidentified): I can't address the fence. [1:22:46] Speaker E (unidentified): It's not, you're right. Well, you could say, hey, fence. Hey, fence. Yeah, that's true, I could do that. Except that they were gonna, [1:22:53] Speaker A (unidentified): do you mean the location of the proposed fence [Speaker B (unidentified): will] be addressed by Mr. And you're going to be looking at where they're putting it. Is that the idea or how high it is? [1:23:05] Speaker G (unidentified): Was this the additional fence that they wanted? [1:23:13] Speaker F (unidentified): This was the final meeting, so we must have approved all approved. [1:23:24] Speaker E (unidentified): I know what it was. were going to, the language, that's what this has to do with. Okay. In the findings of fact, you were going to address that fence that's what this means so we'll be [1:23:42] Speaker G (unidentified): dressed in findings of fact yes okay we can yeah we could clarify that in the findings of that okay line 98 it says mr. Elias [1:24:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Is it a flat A? Are you Khan or Khan? Yeah, what's the pronunciation? [1:24:10] Speaker F (unidentified): Khan. It sounds like an H. Okay. Maybe it was an H at one point. Yeah. [1:24:15] Speaker G (unidentified): Or maybe it was always two Ns. [1:24:17] Speaker A (unidentified): My only other, does anyone else have anything on page two? On page three, way down at line 141, it says it's about shared lateral rolled by the owners of 10 Ingram Lane, 14 Ingram Lane, 65 Main Street, and 65 [1:24:41] Speaker E (unidentified): Main Street. Oh, shoot. I listened to that tape to get this right, and I got it wrong. [1:24:49] Speaker A (unidentified): So it can't be the same. There's another [1:24:54] Speaker E (unidentified): 63, maybe, or 67. I'll listen to 63. So you'll just check that. [1:25:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay. Anyone have anything else on page three or on page four? Oh, this was the artist studios. Here's a comment on page five, the first line 200. You say the acting chair recommends, but Claire was present at this meeting according to the page one. [1:25:55] Speaker F (unidentified): And you were absent. I was absent. [1:25:58] Speaker E (unidentified): Yes. Okay, then it must be the chair. [1:26:00] Speaker A (unidentified): You just mean the chair. Claire was the chair, not the acting chair. Right. Okay, so just take out acting. Okay. I must say that whole paragraph did not make a lot of sense to me. If I'm the only one, I'll forget it. well I'm sorry the planner and CEO discussed the ambiguity in applying the definition of studio and the resulting ability to address the intent of the ordinance right it was it's because studios it's hard to oh I know I the whole thing made no sense to me because it was sort of an academic discussion. [1:27:03] Speaker D (unidentified): Okay. Yeah, kind of on my part. [1:27:08] Speaker E (unidentified): Shall I just take it out? [1:27:10] Speaker D (unidentified): No, the paragraph makes sense to me. I think what we were talking about didn't make a lot of sense. [1:27:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I wasn't there. [1:27:18] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah, that's what I'm getting at. [1:27:21] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, so there were no typos or anything in this. so I move that we approve the minutes of June 16th and July 7th, 2026. As edited. All those in favor? Second. Yeah, as amended. Okay. Our business having been conducted, I move that we adjourn. Okay. Great. Excellent. The meeting is adjourned. Praise the Lord. Yeah. Okay. Are [1:28:00] Speaker G (unidentified): we offline now? Check. I love your minutes. Is there...