Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Hi everyone, my name is Eli Rubin with the Planning Division here at the City, and thank you for being here. It's great to see you. I recognize many of you. There's also many new faces, and I see kind of a mix of people in the building industry, homeowners, a few committee members who helped with the formulation of a lot of the policies we're going to talk about. our mayor elise tipton is here who also of course had a hand in enacting some of the legislation we're going to talk about and so our goal tonight is to give a review of what some of these new changes are to the city's zoning ordinance there's a lot there i don't anticipate everyone will be an expert by the end of the night but at least people have an idea of how to ask the next question that's kind of the overall goal for the night we've kind of geared the presentation generally towards people who are mostly interested in one two three or four unit housing development and ad use are there people that doesn't that doesn't fit that you are doing something else commercial development larger multifamily development okay so that's a pretty good a pretty good match then maybe here's our agenda for tonight we have three speakers I'm gonna start talking about the zoning impacts then we're gonna have members of our code enforcement team talking about the building code and how this interplays and what you need to understand about that and we've been joined also by Tim Doolin of Kennebec savings to give a perspective on finance this is a very important component of all of this how does the finance play into the construction project that you're anticipating. So, at the very beginning, what is zoning? Zoning is local laws, local laws that more or less determine what and how things can be built in different parts of the community. They can very basically be broken down into land uses, sizing, and performance standards. So we'll get into that in more detail, but land uses is basically houses can be built here or not here schools can be built here movie theaters can be built here but not here right that's land uses what we call space and bulk or dimensional standards that governs the size the placement the orientation and then performance standards that would be how many parking spaces are needed what is the traffic impact things like this so cities had zoning since about the 1950s and how is zoning changed right zoning is changed through the legislative body so in South Portland that's your elected leaders your city councillors and smaller towns that's town meeting so since the 1950s we've had a zoning ordinance it's been changed through acts of City Council incrementally over the years and why is it changing why are we here today to talk about those changes a few really big reasons one reason is the city has recently adopted in April of this year a new comprehensive plan comprehensive plan is the city's kind of general plan it's a 10 to 15 year plan and it's the foundation for the zoning ordinance so every decade, the city looks at its existing zoning ordinance, it looks at what do we want the future to look like, and it suggests policies to change. So a lot of the things we're talking about tonight are because the comprehensive plan directed some new policies that impact zoning. The other big thing was state law. So many of you probably are aware of a few state laws that passed in the last two and three years that requires local zoning ordinance changes. so everything we're gonna hear tonight is also a result of that where can you find the zoning ordinance there's a link here and this presentation will be posted on the city's website there's a link here and I'll explain a few other ways that you can reach it 's about a 500 page document it's not user-friendly it's something we're working on but it's also partly why we're here at it we do events like this and we're here to kind of answer your questions and help you through the process so here's the really basic rundown of what these zoning changes mean to you one of the biggest changes is that almost everywhere in the city and almost all of our residential zones the minimum lot size have shrunk to 5,000 square feet this is a result of state law this some zoning districts had much more like 20,000 square feet or 12,000 square feet and now almost everywhere in the city is 5,000 square feet that allows for that smaller incremental development what we call infill housing type of development the other really big change before I move to the next change just to just to clarify a minimum lot size is only describing the smallest permissible lot that is created it doesn't affect anyone's lot today you have an existing lot doesn't doesn't change anything about it if you are creating a new lot it can be any size larger than 5000 square feet it just means that the smallest lot you can create today is 5000 square feet so on those 5000 square foot lots generally around the city you can now build in theory two three or four units of housing depending on where in the city so we're going to talk about growth areas and other areas in a moment but generally almost everywhere in the city you can have two housing units on your 5,000 square foot lot and you can have four housing units on your 5,000 square foot lot if you're in these certain growth areas that's a theoretical right still need to be able to accommodate parking still need to meet the height limit still need to have the landscaping requirement right so it isn't always possible to get four units just because you have a 5,000 square foot lot but the land use permissions are going to try to allow that and so it really depends on your site design we'll get into that too another big change is setbacks the city as you know it was developed and built with very different setbacks than are the rules today that have been for the last 50 years so what we see is the setbacks have a lot and a lot of the city have been reduced to get closer to the historical norms right has anyone had the experience where like they don't have a garage and they're kind of rear yard that's kind of like crooked you want to like rebuild it you come in and you've got to try to get a permit and say no you can't spend the setback well but the garage is already there right so this has been this perennial issue and that one of the changes trying to help and seek to address this is to bring these setbacks back to the historical norms what people are used to lastly ad use I think how many people here are interested in ad to use specifically great oh great so ad use are basically allowed everywhere it's one per lot but they're allowed everywhere a really big change that people should know is that for a long time it was required to be owner occupied that requirement no longer exists state law preempted the municipalities rule and so that law no longer exists however as a reminder short-term rentals are prohibited if you have a short if you have an ad you no dwelling unit on the property can be short-term rental. So you get an ADU, no short-term rental. There are benefits to ADUs, which we'll talk about a little bit tonight. And so it's a trade-off, is kind of the best way to say it. So what's a growth area? What's another area? I don't know if you can, hopefully you can see, this is an outline of the city. The gold areas are the growth areas, right? These are our growth areas that allow residential units. Perhaps it's a little hard to see the outline of the actual city, but as you can see, it's a minority of the city, but it's kind of where the comprehensive plan said, this is where we want to invest growth-related capital improvements, in these areas, because we understand that the city is expected to grow. That's what the state economist model shows. and so that growth we want to focus that in these areas that's where we want to support the infrastructure so these are the growth areas in those growth areas if your property is within these growth areas there's a good chance you can have four dwelling units there on your 5,000 square foot lot maybe more if it's a larger lot maybe less if you have some site complications right you can't really fit it all in and everywhere else in the city is about two sorry that the contrast is not great I looks better my computer screen so okay so that's changes to zoning other changes that have happened also are how you get approval to build what you're trying to build so permit review for a long time I'm not actually sure how long maybe since the 50s if you wanted to build anything besides a single-family house you have to go to the planning board to a public hearing, full-blown, it was treated the same way as a large strip mall, as a water amusement park, as an Olympic-sized stadium. So these things have changed, right? So one of the changes is now one- and two-unit houses, so duplex, single-family homes, and ADUs. You don't need a site plan, you don't need planning board approval. It's treated just like a single-family home has always been. One- and two-family homes, basically synonymous now. Now, that doesn't mean you just fill out one piece of paper, there still are requirements you need all your trade permits your plumbing hvac your building your electrical utilities you need to manage your storm water right so you're creating new impervious area how prove that it's not just running onto your neighbor's property right so what's your drainage plan you're going to interface with the city's right-of-way so what's your curb cut plan and how are you tying into the utilities and the road and like i said 80s before these no longer require public hearings they no longer require site plans it's a much more streamlined process how many people are interested in building three or more housing units okay great couple so everything we just talked about plus a site plan what is a site plan a site plan is like just another level of review it's a finer detail it's asking a lot more questions and has more standards right it's a larger development so there's more standard supply now we're going to ask what's the impact to traffic how are you calculating your parking what is your exterior lighting going to do is it going to shine onto your neighbor's property lots more lots of more questions however our new regulations actually separated these into two categories so we have a new category called the minor development which are three and four unit housing developments and they no longer need a planning board public hearing that's administratively reviewed still has to meet those standards which can be rigorous but it is administratively reviewed we don't have that public hearing anymore anything more than that we're back to the planning board public hearing treated the same way we always happen we just call that a major development now many towns many of our peer towns have been doing this for years and so we're we now have a model like that the last type of permit i'll mention are non-conforming lots of records how many people might have a property that when they bought it they kind of vaguely understood like it has a side lot or it has like a rear lot yeah like how it's like I like my lot has two lots how does that work right so a lot of the city was subdivided in the 20s and 30s and the teens but the lots weren't all built so over time the property that you own might actually be two lots two lots of record so because that lot was already created you can build on it right even though it's too small even though it's less than 5,000 square feet so if you have a lot of record which you can you find out by looking at your deed if it says conveys unto thee parcel a meets and bounds parcel B meets and bounds you probably have a lot of record this is something that still requires planning board approval it's really streamlined though it's it's not that complicated but you still need to meet these standards because it's a very small lot you're really close to the neighbors so there's a higher sensitivity of impact all right the biggest thing i want to call out on this if you have lots of record you cannot sell it before you get your planning board approval to develop it right so you might have that side lot you need a little cash you're going to sell that lot that has disrupted the chain the custody chains if you will and now that lot can't be built so it has to be approved in conjunction with the parent lot before it's separated that makes any sense there wasn't too many of you with lots of records so I can come back to that and answer more questions but that's a careful one to make sure that you don't accidentally sell your lot before your approvals all non-conforming lots of records allow ADUs but ADUs everywhere all right so we just talked about some of the allowances now that zoning allows but it's not always a clear-cut path to your construction project one thing that i think is worth calling out because we see this kind of again and again is someone gets very far in their construction planning they have already outlaid a lot of money and only then do they discover i don't have access to the sewer or the sewer ladder i thought I was going to use is TARA newspaper, and it's crumbling. I can't use it. Sewer at southportland.gov, or you can call. The WRP is Water Resources Protection Department. That's our sewer department. The collection of sewage protects our water resources, so the Water Resources Protection Department. You can call them, email them. They're very busy people, but they will get back to you. They can likely tell you the age that your sewer lateral was installed the material and the size right this is really good information for you in your beginning kind of scoping of your project that being said they can't tell you the current condition so for a relatively small amount of money you can hire a private scoping or you can buy or rent a scope and assess the condition and it's really worth it because it can be so it can lead to some big surprises and you don't want unexpected costs lateral sizing this is a general rule of thumb one in two units four inch pipe four inch pipe is the kind of standard if you have a home that's existing in the city you probably have a four inch pipe you probably have a cast iron or clay or tar and newspaper pipe but it's probably four inches and it could prop if it's in good condition accommodate one to two units if it's more than that it really should be a six inch pipe that's the next step up but it depends there's exceptions it depends on the pitch it depends on the length it depends on a lot of things so that's a conversation you can have with the sewer department about what's appropriate and i'm going to just pull up an example of like why this is so complicated and why it's really pays to plan early for example this is a part of the city this red box if you could imagine someone wanted to build a house in this red box and then turns out there's no sewer in street how can they connect to the sewer so this happens throughout the city there are portions of the city where the road is built on ledge there's no utilities in that and it's not uncommon to ask your neighbor for easements right so partly what I think what I just want to convey is right this person very likely may try to get an easement from a rear neighbor or a side neighbor and that is that is not abnormal it's a part of construction in an urban environment so if you find yourself in the situation find out that soon start talking your neighbors see if an easement can really lighten your load and make for a clean clear path through utilities this is just sewer but same with water storm water collection gas whatever your utility all of our utilities are electric is over ground but really kind of pays to find out so cool map right shows you the whole sewer now how do I how do you get the access to this map well I'll show you we'll spend a couple minutes on that so it's accessible in the city's website so our beautiful home page at the bottom of the home page actually the bottom of every page on the city's website is this footer and on that footer you'll see the web GIS viewer the web GIS viewer and it looks like this I'm going to show you three little tools that will help and I really encourage you to spend some time on this because it's a tremendous tool and it can get you a far away in your site design so three things up in the upper left is where you type your address on the mid left is where you have a variety of layers that you can interlay your sewer your zoning your water your bus line or whatever you want and then on the right we have these tools like a tape measure and drawing tools things like this so for example, I typed in 25 Cottage, it's the address to City Hall. It locates it right there on the map. And right off the bat, I have some really good information. So the arrow here, laser, don't have a laser. The middle arrow, that's the property card, that's your property record card. That's your tax assessment information, really good information. It also has the age of the house, the condition, some details about the house, and it has the square footage of all of the units. right that can be really helpful as you start to pencil things out we also see the at the towards the bottom here these blue arrows you'll see land area and acres of the lot right there it tells you your lot size and the book and page number of your deed whenever you submit an application to the city you have to submit right title and interest which is a copier deed sometimes you don't know where that's located you can always get a copy that's the book and page number at the Cumberland County register of deeds it's all online go online print it out you're good to go okay over on the other side we have some cool tools so if you open this up you might want to look at an actual aerial image and so you click on base map up at the top you have a lot of different options you can see through the years there's different base maps i really like the 2022 because it was taken in the fall so there's no tree foliage we'll be getting an even more recent one 2025 or 2026 sometime in the next year but for right now this is the one that i like to use so you click on that now you have a really nice look at your property and you can open up over here click on all your variety of layers this is the zoning district so now i can figure out what zone i'm in lots of other information i can come back to this in the q a section if we want to explore this more but mostly you kind of have to just play around with it and see what see what you like lastly tape measure tools is great if you think that you want to put in a olympic sized swimming pool right in the parking lot there and you know the general dimensions and the zoning allows for it 5 000 square feet perfect it'll fit right there go and get your building permit and you're good to go and lastly the street view is incorporated right into it which can be really handy it just gives you a real sense especially if you don't live on the property you can just like see it see that what the foliage is and the vegetation around it this is an example of a lovely three-story home and you can kind of see oh maybe there's some opportunity here that I hadn't thought of on this side of the yard and it's it's right there right at the top and it shows you a few years as well okay and I'm gonna end on this is just an example of kind of how far you can get so this is a lot the property owner wanted to make a lot division so this is two new Lots measured out the setbacks measured out the buildings with the actual square footage measured out the cars measured out the parking area measured out all this was done just I don't know a little bit of time on the computer didn't cost anything so this tool can really get you a far away in your basic site design okay I'm gonna talk about a few other requirements just to make sure people are generally familiar with what the requirements are we do still have parking requirements in the city in your growth areas it's one space per dwelling unit generally people are providing more than that but that is the minimum everywhere else it's two for a single family and one and a half for a multifamily per unit for multifamily we have changes to the EV charging ordinance are people familiar that the city has an EV charging ordinance it's requirements for providing EV charging infrastructure so I think for most people in this room it's the first column on the left the blue is going to be what's more relevant if you have a newly constructed residential unit with dedicated parking that means like unit one park here unit to park here as opposed to just free-for-all what we call shared parking if you have newly constructed residential units with dedicated parking and the parking is located within 25 feet that's the that's the length of a charging cable within 25 feet of the building you are required to put one ev ready stall per unit that basically just means that's a 240 50 amp that's a dryer circuit you don't need to put a charger you don't need to put a pedestal you just need to run the circuit if it's newly constructed you just have to add that circuit so that in the future if it's a renter very easy for them to install a charger if it's a new property owner very easy for them to install all it is a little cost but it's pretty marginal on the cost of a new home so this is the this is the requirement if it's more you're talking about more than 25 parking spaces which i didn't i don't know if anyone in this room is but if you're looking at a larger development there are more requirements for actual installed chargers actual ev install chargers but we can talk about that if there's more questions okay the second to last requirement coastal resilience overlay zone does anyone here live like kind of near the water generally yeah okay this map in light blue shows the city's new coastal resilience overlay zone it is showing the 8.8 foot of sea level rise plus the 100-year storm potential level or exposure to flood water this is anticipated to occur potentially between the years 2120 and 2170 lots of variables in there right but when you're doing construction if you are in this zone this ordinance will apply and what does the ordinance actually require first of all it's only the new construction an existing house not nothing happens to but for new construction based off of the use and today we're really just talking about low sensitivity or we're talking about moderate sensitivity uses so one to ten dwelling units the first floor and the critical elements of the house the hot water heater the electric panel that stuff has to be above 14 foot navd 88 that's a specific metric that's not 14 feet above the ground right most great in south portland is like between 9 and 15 feet so what that means in practice right how many people live in a house that has a little walk up few steps most people live already a foot and a half three feet above grade so for the most part the new requirements are going to require that people's housing looks similar to the existing vernacular of the neighborhood it does frustrate you if you're trying to build slab on grade right if you're in this zone you want to slab on grade you really can't you have to be a little bit higher if you're at 11 foot elevation and you need to get to 14 you got to add a couple feet all right for larger developments which does not many of you will see higher sensitivity is 11 plus dwelling units you're probably gonna have a different use on the first floor so parking is common with these are both in Knightville or storefronts are common and lastly just a reminder your critical uses so you're heating your hot water your electrical it has to be above that flood potential flood because even though this is not a flood we anticipate anytime soon the house will still be there in 2100 2120 2170 hopefully and if the whole plumbing is connected to a sewer in the basement is you have to replumb the whole house right so they're trying to future-proof to a little extent okay and again that's the map the last standard I'm going to talk about tonight is the heat island mitigation requirements this is not going to apply to most people in this room, because one, two, three families are exempt. So this really only applies when you get to larger than a three family, so four units or more. So I'm not going to really get into the details, because I don't think it applies to that many people. But we can talk about this in Q&A. But it basically says, if you're going to have a roof, you're going to have a roof. If you're going to have more than four units, that roof's got to be a lighter color. Why? Why because we know that dark roofs as dark shingles Contribute to a lot higher cooling cost for the building Energy costs and not just cost but just carbon emissions And so just having a gray shingle and that's really what like that's what we're talking about is the difference between gray shingle and a black Shingle the requirements are not that stringent, but it makes a really big difference. It really it really makes a big difference there's different requirements for flat roofs and there's requirements for if you have a large parking lot and I don't think that really anyone in this room is contemplating that but we can talk about that in questions so here's my last slide that was a lot we covered a lot right there's gonna be more zoning changes over the next two years the bulk of the zoning that's in the comprehensive plan is going to be implemented right so over the next two years, we're gonna continue to see more changes. We'll have more meetings like this. After two years, the comp plan is still gonna be rolling for another 10 to 15 years. There'll be more changes, but it's gonna be a lot less, more nuanced, more things that are emerging, or things that aren't zoning specific. But I'll leave you with this map. This kind of shows the future of the zoning districts in South Portland, right? So this is the general map of our, it's kind of our workflow of how we're gonna work through the city and rezone to meet be consistent with a comprehensive plan and so you'll see in 2027 and 2028 is when we're aiming to kind of hit these targets so if you have property you're thinking about a project one of the first questions to ask is where is it is the zoning going to be different in six months or in a year and a half and ask that question first because that may impact your timing and what your site design and what you're thinking about for your project so more information as always on the planning division section of the city website and we'll answer questions after the rest of us finish up so with that I'm gonna invite Nick Richard as the director of code enforcement to give a presentation on the permitting aspect and already
[28:31] Speaker B (unidentified): thank you everybody for coming out as he said my name is Nick Richard I'm the director of code enforcement and jen leeman is over here with me she's the deputy director and i'm just going to kind of go over adu's state law and our local requirements these are what are in place as of october 5th of this year we had some recent changes that came through and this is what you need to know so this is basically only one adu is allowed per property properties with a single family two -family, and three-family, allow them. Four families do not allow an ADU. Anything above that, you cannot have an ADU, as it says right there. Now, to basically discuss the sizing on a square footage of an ADU, you're talking about the modified floor area. That's the term we use in our ordinance. That means the gross floor area with deductions for areas in the building that are not conditioned space and attics and garages, so long as the attic space is not classified as a story as defined in the then current building code. So it's very wordy, but if you ever have any questions, you can always call me and I will answer that. Does this count as a story? I'll get to the bottom of that. But anyway, so for the modified floor area for an ADU, it depends on your parcel size. So if you have a parcel size under 10,890 square feet, your ADU cannot exceed 800 square feet or 90% of the primary dwelling's modified floor area, whichever is smaller. So we're always taking the smaller of any of these measurements in these situations. For a parcel larger than that size, you're not going to exceed 10% of the parcel area, 1200 square feet, or 90% of the primary dwelling unit, whichever is smaller, again. again. And no ADU shall have less than 190 square feet of floor area. And on properties with two or three dwelling units, the ADU must be no larger than 90% of the largest legal unit existing on the property at the time of that application. And ground floor ADU cannot exceed 800 square feet as a footprint. And as Eli mentioned, owner occupancy for ADUs is no longer required. You can rent both the primary and the ADU. You cannot use it as a short-term vacation rental. Either of the units cannot be used in that manner. They must be at least 30 consecutive days or more for rentals. And all units must be held in common ownership, so you cannot condoize these and sell a unit or, you know, any other type of situation. Fire and building code requirements. These are things to consider. We have the international residential code versus the international building code so the international residential code and I was at a training all day for continuing education credits so bear with me my brain's a little mushy but the international residential code is for one and two family dwellings townhouses that are three stories and below and basically we do require plans for all permitting but those are not required to be stamped there are exceptions if for some reason you supply plans and it's not conventional framing or conventional construction and we can't verify that your plans meet code where we might ask for stamp plans if your foundation is you know I have no idea if your foundation is gonna meet code I'll say get a stamp plan for your foundation if your framing shows that it does then we can move forward but you can go from the whole building requiring stamp or just sections that we're just confused we can't locate it in the code the building code the IBC is three or more dwellings in one structure so if you have a duplex existing currently then and you want to add an ADU to that existing structure at that point that triggers the IBC and that requires a stamped plan and what that means you have to have a an architect or an engineer evaluate the building for the code and there's there's numerous other codes that are involved the existing building code energy code and they have to look at it and design that at ADU to meet the new code and there's other triggers on the next slides that I'll talk about mainly sprinklers but if you're unsure what will be required please reach out to us and we will walk you through all that so here we go with existing construction renovations alterations and additions there are egress requirements to consider window requirements in bedrooms every bedroom requires at least one, emergency escape and rescue opening. That means a window of minimum size. It's usually 5.7 square feet. Number of egresses depending on the number of units and many other number of occupants as well. For stairs, newer replaced stairs, they must meet today's code. There are a few exceptions. Existing stairs that are not being touched can remain. Platforms for stairs, many people don't realize that you need a three-by-three minimum platform before a door on the top of stairs. They think you just get stairs right up to the door, open the door, and go in. You need a platform on either side of an exterior door. Fire separation between units, so you want to make sure that if you do have adjacent units in the same building, there has to be some kind of a fire separation, a fire wall, a one-hour wall to separate the two units. Adjacent to garages in a single family, you do need 5-H sheetrock on the walls and ceiling between the garage and any living space in that unit. Smoke and CO detectors, basement attic dwelling units, the egress and ceiling height for those areas if you have existing houses that you want to convert to ADUs, you need to make sure that your ceiling heights will meet the minimum requirement of 6-8. for egress as well for basements you want to make sure that you have a full egress path to get out not just a central stairway that goes into the other unit utility considerations other ones are you know plumbing hvac location i know eli touched on it with the cross separate facilities for adus the goal is to have separate facilities for every adu on a property but there are exceptions that would allow you to run the ad use facilities through the existing unit if there's really no other alternative but that's the goal and you want to check with Portland Water District for your water connection because sometimes they do have their own requirements that's above ours we don't we don't get involved with that electrical meters you're gonna want separate metering for that as well and then energy code compliance so the city of south portland we enforce the stretch code and what that means is the 2021 international energy conservation code is the base code but the stretch code is 15 above the main that base code and that means any new construction has to meet this code there are exceptions for renovations and alterations additions must meet the new code and then what you're doing to show us that you're meeting the code is a res check or a calm check res check it's for residential anything that's two units like as the irc stated two units or townhouses calm check is for the commercial side ibc and those are online tools that you would basically plug in all your parameters for insulation your r values your window fenestration r values and u factors and then your it even talks about the orientation of the building i mean it can get really technical if you have any questions on that you can reach out to us we can guide you we can't tell you how to do it but there are people out there are professionals that actually work in this field that you know you got insulation contractors that do know what they're doing when it comes to that and then as far as sprinklers go currently right now a single-family dwelling with an ADU either attached or detached does not require sprinklers where they are required is if the construction of an adu results in it being the third unit in a building then you're going to trigger sprinklers for every unit in that building the entire building would then need sprinklers and then if you're constructing a new duplex whether it's involved with an adu or not that does require sprinklers in south portland and addressing so i am also the addressing officer for the city single families with an adu the primary dwelling is going to retain the original property address the ADU is going to get a unit two designation and as you go through like a two family the first obviously is unit two one and two and then the ADU gets three so the ADU is kind of like that little brother that just gets the little number and then for permitting these are what you're going to be looking for an ADU the first one is your zoning permit you're gonna have drainage plan requirements in most cases unless it's an existing building that you're converting you won't sewer connection fee setback requirements building permit plumbing electrical and other considerations are if you're in the shoreline zone flood hazard the craws as eli explained soil quality might come into play if you disturb more than a certain amount of soil after the product is completed tree removal excavation that's That's through, if you're working in the public right-of-way, and then curb cuts. And I believe this is my last slide, but it's pretty fitting. He has a permit, and it says he can do what he wants. That does not happen. Not on my watch. Yeah, that is my last slide. So I will hand it over to Tim Doolin.
[38:41] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, yeah, my name is Tim Doolin, residential lending officer with Kennebunk Savings, here to talk all things financing of ADUs. I'm going to talk a little bit about different loan programs, well, I'll get into what we're talking about in just a second, but I think the one overarching point I want to, if there's one takeaway to take from what I say today, everyone's financing situation is different, so we're going to talk kind of like very high-level type stuff, 10,000-foot view, but everyone has different needs, different requirements, different qualifications, so it's important that if you are considering an ADU build that you have that financial conversation sooner rather than later. It's never too early to have that conversation, even if it's just a thought bubble in your head and you want to see what's doable, what's possible. I think it's a worthwhile time to connect and have that conversation. It sounds simple, but it's very surprising how often I might get a conversation of someone saying I have the perfect plan, I know exactly what I'm going to build, and then I have to crush some dreams, which I don't love doing. So it's best to have those conversations sooner rather than later to know, and I don't mean me to say it in a negative way, but also you could be qualified to build more or do a bigger or larger project than you might otherwise thought. So just in general, that's kind of the overarching point I want to get across is having those conversations sooner rather than later is generally recommended. Other than that, just other basic topic overview, we're going to talk about financing, loan types and their pros and cons. That's probably what we'll spend most of the time talking about. Appraisals, opportunities and challenges with ADUs being still relatively new. there are some challenges there with appraising those types of properties finding comparable sales and whatnot construction monitoring basically what the bank what the bank's role is in the construction phase because a lot of what you might talk about is just sort of like the application requirements and what you know what you can qualify for what payments are it's also important to understand like what actually happens after the loan closes in the bank's involvement and then also just sort of a just a very brief sort of construction process from a lenders perspective just kind of giving you an idea of what those steps are that you might be looking at during you know from beginning to end so starting with financing types this I started with the home equity loan or line of credit just because frankly I find it to be one of the more simple solutions for most folks you may or may have me have heard of a home equity loan or line of credit it can be used for just about anything we do ask for the purpose, but what I'd like to call it is it's borrowed cash after it's closed, so you can use it for what you want. But it's a loan partly approved based on the existing loan-to-value, generally up to 80% of the appraised value of the house. So the example I give is if you have a mortgage balance of $200,000 and the home appraised at $500,000, you could then lend up to a total of $400,000 combined between both your primary mortgage and the home equity loan or line of credit. it that would give you an extra two hundred thousand that'll give you two hundred thousand dollars that you have available that you can borrow okay it can be in second lien position and this is probably the biggest benefit of this program if you got your mortgage you know during covet times you have a great two three percent rate you want to keep good for you this allows you to keep that nice low rate and get your financing without having that be disturbed often lower closing costs and probably could have included in there no closing costs depending on the lender it's a very you know mortgage applicator typical mortgage refinance is going to be you know these days these are going up across the board it's usually going to be like four thousand dollars or so give or take for your tangible closing costs a line of credit significantly less to none depending on the lender and their programs it gives you flexible access to funds during construction this is also a nice feature too and when we When you talk about the ADU loan, construction loan program specifically, as I kind of touched on construction monitoring, part of that is when you do a construction loan, the bank is the one that sort of – the way I would kind of phrase it is we are the financial manager of the project, if you will. So we hold all those finances. The builder will come to us for disbursements when things are – when funds are necessary to be disbursed. You don't have to worry about that with the line of credit. That's your own money. you pay it you speak you connect with the builder you do or the contractor you disperse funds to them as you so choose so there's a less of a less of a middleman involved if you will you don't have to have lender approval for the project I say this is a pro because it's not that having the lender approve the project is a problem necessarily but we all like to make our lives easier sometimes unless paperwork is makes your life easier so not having to get involved in the project or getting involved in the approval of the project rather can at times just make for a more streamlined application process. Cons and the biggest con for this is it's limited to the current value. So in that example I gave $500,000 purchase price with allowing you to get $200,000, $200,000 may not be enough, probably more than likely not enough for building an ADU these days. You know, you might be looking at needing to get financing in other places, using your own funds or what have you. Other loan programs that we'll talk about, the AD loan specific loan program, does allow you to use future value based on the finished project that you're working on. So that's certainly a limitation. Interest rates generally variable. Now I put that in the cons, but that can be a pro. Lately that is definitely a con, as rates have been going, usually it's going to be tied to the prime interest rate, which right now is at 7.5%. So you're probably going to be either at that, a little below that, a little above that, depending on what the margin is that bank has for that interest rate. But that can go up or down with the market changes. Federal Reserve just met today, not changing rates as of right now. They changed it in September, and they said they're likely to change it again, possibly November, December. So more to come there and then also another con is a higher qualifying payment since it's a variable rate program so if we when i first started in this business the prime rate was at 3.25 percent and i worked for a bank that gave prime minus one it was 2.25 percent for a line of credit which is pretty wild you could qualify for that all day that's great fast forward 10 years you still have a balance on that rate is now six and a half percent can you qualify for that to protect against that, we qualify based on a higher interest rate. So although your payment is an interest-only payment and is most often, although your payment might be relatively low, we build in and assume it might be higher, which can limit your ability of how much you can borrow. So there's a couple limits between that and the value of the home being the current value. There's a few limitations there. So this is a good option if it fits. because again it's a bit more streamlined and frankly more ease of you know ease of use for the consumer but it does not certainly does not fit all budgets you have buckets you have to have strong income and significant equity in the property to make that to make that work next option i have here is a cash out refinance you notice there's fewer pros and cons here just because this one as we talk about interest rates if you have your three to four or 2% or 3% interest rate, you might want to ignore this slide altogether. But one of the pros is it can give you better cash flow by combining two loans into one. So regardless of what the interest rate is, taking your primary mortgage and taking the new funds that you're going to be getting and putting them into one loan, usually like let's say you had a 30-year mortgage five years ago, you're now going to go back to another 30-year mortgage. It might give you a better cash flow and have a lower overall monthly payment than any of the other options. However, it might cost you more in the long term. So even though it is a pro, there is a potential con there in the long term, which again goes back to talk to your lender, have those conversations to see what makes sense. And it can be a lower interest rate than construction loans, home equity loans, and lines of credit. Mortgage rate right now is at 7.25% for a 30-year fixed, roughly. So that would be a better interest rate than the variable rate on the line of credit. so that can be a better option for someone who wants that fixed stable payment as low as possible the cons as I just mentioned replaces that first mortgage you don't want to wave goodbye to that two three percent this is not probably the program for you and at times higher closing costs I say a time you already mentioned usually a refinance you're looking at like four thousand dollars or so in closing costs typically which again will vary from situation to situation, but certainly a con there for that loan program type. And this is the fun one. So this is an ADU construction loan. These are, you know, as ADUs are, we have new guidance from the state. These programs are also new, also evolving as well. So there's a lot of uniqueness to these programs, and I'll also warn you that, you know, if you're thinking about financing and thinking you might need a loan type like this, if you call ten banks you might get one that offers it because it is relatively new it is relatively kind of a niche product so just be advised that you're not you might not see it everywhere the there's pros here in the two biggest pros of the first two bullets and I already mentioned use the future value after the projects completed so when we start an ADU loan application or a construction loan application we're collecting building plans budget and a spec sheet from the builder so we have a pretty good idea of what's going to be there so we give that information to the appraiser they go out to the property they take a look at the current status of the property and then pretend you know what they're looking at on paper is there and they find comparable sales based on that generally speaking if you're putting money into your house increasing square footage you know do something that's going to be generating revenue for you it's going to increase the value of the property so we can use that increased value so that same example of that person who their house appraises today at $500,000, but they need $300,000 for their project, the ADU loan might be a more suitable program for them because it depends on what the appraisal comes back at, but more than likely in that scenario you'd be able to have enough equity there where you could potentially lend up to that number. The other benefit is use projected rental income to help qualify. This applies to whether or not you plan to use the EDU for profit, like if you wanted to rent it out to individuals in the community, or if you plan to use it for housing family. The reason that we decided that makes sense is that if you are going to be, obviously if you're going to be renting it out, you're going to be getting income, that's pretty straightforward. But if you're renting it to family, the idea is that there's going to be another income that's going to be helped supporting the household. so in either case we're able to use projected rental income to help qualify so you know in those cases where if like you're having like this comes up a lot on like family scenarios where like you have you know mom and dad might want to have provide housing for or grandma and grandpa want to provide housing for son and daughter granddaughter grandson they're in they may be retired fixed income we can help you use that projected rental income to boost up what we could qualify for on the mortgage it's also generally a fixed rate I've not seen any that are variable yet so I could probably say usually it's gonna be a fixed rate again can be in second lien position so you can keep your first mortgage as is and you're really sweet two to three percent interest rate and have this be in the second lien position behind that it's an interest only payment during the construction based on the drawn balance so we'll get into what the drawn balance means a little bit more in depth in the next slide but basically you when we when we set up a home an adu loan it's really should be more titled an edu line of credit because you get approved for a limit that the borrow the builder can draw on for the construction let's say you're closing today but the builder is not going to start for two months you have zero dollars of payments assuming you have no nothing we didn't pay anything off as part of the as part of closing on the edu loan but you have zero dollars of payments until you actually start using funds the first draw for site work lumber windows whatever you know it is the builder's ordering let's call that a hundred thousand dollars you're now paying interest only on just that hundred thousand dollars until the builder comes and draws more funds so it keeps your payments relatively low during the construction phase and you're only borrowing based on what you need generally it converts to a permanent loan after construction ends so as I mentioned in that first initial period it's going to be that interest-only payment after that construction period ends which we give anywhere from six to twelve months for construction it then reverts to a fixed principal and interest payment loan based on whatever that balance was so in that example of a $300,000 build you know things go really great for you it comes in at 275 for the total builder cost awesome you are only charged interest based on that 275 000 that you that ends up being a part of the project the cons and i touched this before again i put this in the con section but it's not a problem it's just an extra step in the process requires approval of your construction project so we are reviewing building plans spec sheet budget we are going to look at the contract we're going to require the permit be obtained prior to closing on the loan so basically everything is like the builder is like waiting, ready to go when we're closing on the loan. Everything's in place to get started. Again, it's part of our process. We've been doing construction, or most lenders have been doing construction for a period of time. It's something we do. We have whole departments that are dedicated to processing construction loans, whether it be residential or commercial. So it's not a problem. It's just an extra step in the process. The other con, it can be a higher interest rate. Construction, the average 30-year mortgage right now, as I said, is right around $7.25, $7.3, $7.5. five percent. Construction loan rates are generally going to be a half percent higher than market is sort of like the basic rule of thumb. So somewhere in like the high seven percent range is likely what you might see. But because it's also potentially a second lien position loan, some lenders might have a higher rate charge because it's in a second lien position behind a primary mortgage, which is a less advantageous position for the bank, carries more risk. So the risk gets passed on in higher interest rates so that can be a con it depends on how what your look how much you're looking for what your equity position is so there's a lot of variability there again talk to your lender to kind of find out what that all looks like and it can have higher closing costs construction is expensive like i mentioned we have a whole department that's that or i say we lenders have whole departments that are there for to review construction documents and you know process things and you know as we'll get to you in a second monitor the project that cost money so there are higher closing costs potentially for any type of construction or you appraisals opportunities and challenges this I want to talk about just because it's it's big it definitely is a it can be a hot-button issue with an edu loan mostly and I'll start off with a you know before I get into the negative start with the good again you can use a higher value to get a better borrowing capacity which is ultimately a good thing that you're able to use that. However, ADUs are still relatively new, and finding comparable sales can be challenging. And the way appraisers work when there's properties that are not directly comparable, they make adjustments to have the properties match, which causes variability. So what that means is like an appraiser in a perfect world, let's say you're buying a three-bedroom, two-and-a-half bath, 2,000-square-foot house, kind of like just your typical single family. There's going to be comparable sales like that everywhere you know there's you know there's going to be plenty of comparable sales they're going to be looking for within half a mile to a mile within the sold within the last six months to a year and kind of having those similar characteristics they're also doing that for your property with an edu which there are definitely more adus and they're they're becoming more and more popular but they're specifically looking for houses with an edu that have changed ownership and been sold within a reasonable period of time so what is required to do with the appraiser you know we had an appraise an edu appraisal where one of the properties was 30 miles away so there's going to be a lot of difference between south portland and like you know wherever 30 miles away is pennybuck or something like that so there can be a lot of differences there so the and also you're looking at maybe not necessarily comparable properties. Square footage of the main house at the ADU aren't exactly comparable, number of rooms aren't exactly comparable, so the appraiser has to make adjustments based on that to have that property sort of match from a value perspective, which brings into a more subjective view of the value as opposed to an objective view where if you have that cookie cutter typical single-family house. So what we've seen is massive fluctuations in what we get for appraisals i had a an adu in portland they tried with a different lender not that appraisals you know as a lender we don't choose the appraiser so it's not their fault but if one appraiser came back with a value of like 850 000 but they needed to appraise that around like 1.1 million to do what they need to do we did an appraisal no less than three months later and it came in at $1.2 million. So you're talking a $250,000 swing in value in a couple of months just because you're, I'm sure there's different comparable sales, I didn't see the other report, but nonetheless, massive fluctuation. So that's an important thing just to be aware of, that the appraisal can be, there can be some variance there, for sure. But that was a very, high budget build, so that was a unique situation. And also too, build budget does not always match value gain very simply we always as a bank and lender when we were thinking about what the house might appraise at we start by looking at the current value plus the build cost it's a very imperfect way to look at it you know we're not an appraiser we're just giving like a ballpark that's where that's our starting point ultimately though it does not necessarily translate that way and that's not just for a to use that's just for construction in general or home improvement projects in general so that's just something to keep in mind that if like you're looking at the numbers and you're thinking well I'm doing this $300,000 project I need my house to appraise $300,000 higher for it to work this should all work out just fine not to put not to scare you but it may not you know you don't make sure you're careful and that's part of the process that's not something you need to obtain we would do or the lender would do an application or an appraisal as part of the application process then construction monitoring so what is construction monitoring so if you do if you go the ADU loan route, we're going to be approving the project, and then we're going to be, like I said, acting as that financial manager of the project. As part of that, we're basically ensuring the project is completing according to the approved plans, which there can be tweaks to and change orders and things. That's all fine as long as it fits within budget. Funds are being used for intended purposes, and the construction is progressing on schedule. So we're basically there to make sure that from a financial perspective, and also working on behalf of the consumer making sure that the contractor builder is doing all the things that they are supposed to be doing saying they're doing and staying on track with doing so construction draws we hold the we hold all funds used for construction so back to that example of a fight of a $200,000 loan with a $300,000 build cost let's say you have financial means to do to contribute that extra $100,000 to bridge that gap and make that difference. If today is the closing date, you provide that $100,000 today. We hold those funds for the duration of the project and we disperse funds to the builder. Because basically, what we don't wanna see happening is that you have who is responsible for paying what. We wanna have that all be coming from one source. Logistically, it just works way simpler to do it that way. so we hold all the funds for construction as the builder is progressing in the project they'll submit requests for work completed and material orders and you know like they'll say like you know the first example of site they complete some site work they order windows they order lumber for framing they would give us a draw request for that including paid invoices This is, not to get too technical, but lien waivers for any subcontractors used and things like that. A lot of that's done with the builder. That's not something you necessarily need to worry yourself with. Usually if all is going to plan, all you need to do is sign a document authorizing that you approve that we can send those funds out to the builder or contractor. And then a draw schedule. And this is actually an important question to ask because some, depending on the lender, They're going to have different requirements to how many draws that they will accept. As I mentioned, lenders have a team of construction people who work in the construction team. Costs money to have due reviews. We do site visits and inspections, as I'll get to in a second. Costs money to do so. So some lenders will limit the number of draws that you're allowed to do. Some will have higher numbers, or some will have unlimited draw requests allowed. It varies from lender to lender. The benefit of having higher number of draws allowed is that the builder can ask us for funds more often, which helps in a couple ways. One, keeps them moving faster. If they're being replenished with their funds that they're spending up front in costs, we're replenishing those at a more timely basis. Then they're able to keep that project going in a more timely manner. And also the builders need to be as specific and worry like, oh, no, I left out this one thing, and now I've run out of my draw request. It's going to cost the customer extra money to do another one. Those are things you just want to ask and to make sure that you understand what the lender does there. And then inspections. Lender will have periodic inspections prior to draw approvals. When we do an inspection, when you hear the word inspection, don't think that it's anything too technical. Sometimes I'm going out there and I have no idea what I'm looking at. Like they say rough plumbing and electrical has been done. We go out there and we take a couple pictures. generally speaking like yes anyone can see that there is electrical wires there's plumbing running around seems like they're doing what they're supposed to do the real inspection will be done by you guys you right here Nick over here those are the real inspections but we do those just to make sure things are moving and trust but verify is sort of the idea or a thought process there so construction process from a lenders perspective this is from beginning to end just like really quick just to kind of go through it and remember initial consultation which again initial consultation with the lender I can't stress enough just have that as soon as possible like it's just it just it's you it's a free conversation it doesn't hurt it takes 30 minutes to get a general idea of roughly what you could potentially qualify for and what loan makes most sense most the most sense for you so having that sooner rather than later is always a good idea however if you have that cross conversation well in advance of that conversation interest rates can change or sorry well in advance of the project being done rates can change so make sure you're staying up to date on where those might be once you get that number of what you can finance you review you review that budget and come up with a plan with the contractor or builder when you have the budget plans and spec sheet you can start a formal application that is the point where we can officially start our process the reason being as i mentioned before we can't we need that information to order the appraisal so if we start an application we don't have that info we just have stuff kind of sitting until that comes in logistically that doesn't really make sense from a timeline perspective so once you get those all those pieces in place then we can start the process very broadly there's much more to this line but we can skip all that or a lot of that lender reviews income assets credit and projects obviously there's a lot that would go into that and then you get to approval and closing once you get to closing that's where we are now in the construction phase where we can start dispersing funds and all that and then we do a final inspection to confirm the project's completed. All being told, you'll be very friendly with the bank or the lender that you use because you'll be in touch with them a lot for the duration from the initial consultation to closing. That can sometimes be a multi-year endeavor. So get comfortable and friendly with your lender because they'll be your best bud for a little while. And then in closing, again, I don't mean to say it again, but again, talk to a lender early. Keep in the loop on progress and changes, and everyone's finances are different. Make sure you understand the options that best suits you. And then, really importantly, ADUs are still new and evolving. When we talked previously before this, you brought up a couple things about ADUs I didn't know. That's now new. So I learned something new last week about ADUs. So that's always changing. And with that, again, being in constant communication with your lender of what your plans are. don't assume that because the town approves it that the lender will approve it so if plans are changing make sure you're talking with the with the lender so yeah that's it for me okay so
[1:04:51] Speaker A (unidentified): everyone's a pro understand your project go home pencil it out submit your plan so we wanted to reserve the rest of the evening for questions the last time we did this that seemed like two or three years ago we did a similar type of event it seemed like it was a fruitful use of time so we're gonna open it up to questions I'm gonna try to MC it and we'll each kind of take our turn to respond and so when you ask your question you or I 'm gonna try to generalize it so ask about your project but I'm gonna try to generalize it so that's applicable to more people and if you have a really specific question then we'll invite you to come in the office we could talk more so yeah sure so the question was that do the zoning changes that are contemplated in the comprehensive plan are they essentially a foregone conclusion or are they like up for debate and discussion the answer is there's no foregone conclusion a comprehensive plan is a plan it is not a law it's not rules it is not a requirement it's just a plan the laws the zoning need to be consistent with the comprehensive plan but there is a lot of artistry who could say right most communities in the state their zoning does not match the conference playing completely right because it is the zoning is the decision of the City Council right and so that is the decision of your elected officials over the next decade piggyback on that so I
[1:06:36] Speaker D (unidentified): heard from code compliance that for example G zone was going to change all their setbacks around the November time frame but then I looked at what you saw set put up there and honestly I could not read that map but it looked like it was more all over the town and there were lots of different things so is
[1:06:55] Speaker A (unidentified): there someplace we can go to see what's gonna happen when yes that there is the question is where can I find out kind of generally the timeline that zoning changes are anticipated to happen so I'm gonna put up I'm gonna put up a website we're here at our friendly city website here on the home page the department or planning this lives in the planning division and we're gonna go to the comprehensive plan page so current programs and comprehensive plan and if you scroll down here this is a tentative schedule right okay things always change right things were slated to go to council last night meeting went a little long and so things changed schedules change meeting went till past midnight night yeah right so this will give you a sense but the biggest thing the biggest takeaway from the schedule is to understand that every one of there's going to be we're scheduling is to be kind of like four big zoning packages and each time this happens there's going to be two comprehensive plan committee meetings then a planning board meeting then two city council meetings over the span of two months right so in the spring in the fall and then in 2028 in the spring and the fall so you will get you'll have these out for a few months you'll have kind of the drafts public and you'll get to see what people are talking about engaged in the debate in the dialogue and so there is not a better way to know until that time frame comes what exactly and what the timing will be because there's there's just so there's a lot I mean I don't I'd otherwise say we can read the comprehensive plan that's 300 pages and that's not really an expectation either, right? And so there's just, there's too much at play. There's all the time there's emergent needs that come from a variety of places and they might supersede this list or they might rearrange things. The other thing too is that any one of you, anyone in the city who has right title and interest can apply to change the zoning code, right? Any resident can do that. And so a lot of times our zoning changes is based on applicant and applicant desire right so they still need to find that their proposed change is consistent with the comprehensive plan can't propose anything it has to still be consistent with the plan but a lot of the changes actually come from real life from I'm trying to do this thing the zoning doesn't allow the comprehensive plan says it should be allowed and so I'm going to propose this so I don't know if that kind of answers your question but there's at the moment this is the place so it's not going to be done like a zone or g zone it's now going to be done by these different areas so the challenge with that is that there are new zoning districts okay right i wish that i could tell you that but right now there are what is today in a zone might be a zone tomorrow but it also might be downtown Mill Creek core zone right might be a new zoning district and so that's why we made the map and we kind of showed it graphically on the map to see these things are in flux but we're doing this over time where you know the goal is to try to keep everyone as apprised of what's happening as we develop it but there's just a lot of variables right now yeah okay yep go back to that okay, any other questions? More questions? Thanks for doing this, first of all. Yeah. It's really helpful.
[1:10:49] Speaker C (unidentified): So you've got a piece of land, it's 5,000 square feet,
[1:10:51] Speaker E (unidentified): and you can maybe do one to three or something on it,
[1:10:54] Speaker F (unidentified): but you've got some mature trees that are not invasive,
[1:11:00] Speaker C (unidentified): but they're in good health.
[1:11:01] Speaker D (unidentified): Is there a room in the ordinance to remove those trees
[1:11:04] Speaker A (unidentified): and do something so that you can then go ahead with any of this? Yeah. Yeah, so the question was about tree protection. The city has a tree protection ordinance and removing trees and kind of how does this work, right? So the zoning allows all this new infill housing, but you have trees, you have mature trees, which are a good thing, you know, in your neighborhood, on your lot. So the short answer is yes, you can remove trees. The longer answer is it may require approval. and the purpose of the approval is to evaluate how many trees are you're proposing to remove is there an alternative to removing those trees so the ordinance has a few stipulations it says if you've proposed more parking than that's required you have to try reducing the amount of parking if that will save a tree if you are proposing more I think it actually has a number of dwelling units I there's like a certain percentage and if you can save a tree by reducing that then you need to do that and it's not always possible sometimes it's like oh the tree removal is gonna happen because I have to put my sewer line in has nothing to do with the parking right so you will get approval to remove the tree but you are now required to plant two trees right to mitigate for that loss it's it's an imperfect kind of solution but it's one way to try to keep the cycle of trees going there are some exemptions and there are some kind of special cases the biggest thing the biggest takeaway is just this city of South Portland has a tree protection ordinance before you cut down trees call the code office find out do I need approval can I just go ahead and do this right that's it just fine just make sure that you're not after the fact oh wow I cut down all these trees I didn't know I needed it well you know now you need you need to find out if you need approval first and in many cases you don't need approval especially with small projects if they're invasive all those Norway maples if it's a sick diseased or damaged tree if it's an ash tree a lot of them are coming out to be preventative yeah every tree in
[1:13:20] Speaker B (unidentified): the shoreland is considered a protected tree so there are requirements for re-vegetation depending on if the tree is not dead not hazard or anything like that but anytime you do have a tree removal in the shoreland it's always best to check with us because you're going to need to have a report prepared by an arborist or some qualified tree professional that says that the tree is dead actually devil went today it was an emerald an ash tree that was affected by emerald ash borer that was dead and i said you have to big the arborist needs to provide me a report that says it's dead and then you can remove it without having to replant that 's in the zoning ordinance that's not even part of the tree protection so there's the zoning side which you know talks about shoreline zoning and then the tree protection is everywhere else and including shoreline so that's something to consider if you have any question about trees always call and ask this i'm just pulling up the
[1:14:18] Speaker A (unidentified): the shoreland zone is, it's areas near water, near the ocean, near a lake, near a river, near a stream, so a tributary, if you're in that area, there's a lot higher sensitivity to protect that ecosystem, protect the resource, so definitely call the office if you're in around that area, but now that you know how to use this map, you will know. You can zoom
[1:14:42] Speaker B (unidentified): right into your property say oh yeah look at that from large bodies of water the ocean or lakes and streams and rivers those are usually about 100 feet down to about 75 feet from that high water line so we're here at the library
[1:14:59] Speaker A (unidentified): we're just a little outside the zone but yeah there it is does that kind of answer your question so there is a path there's a path forward but if you're gonna remove a tree you might be required to plant a new one or two so any other questions yeah sure let's let's just go to this let's just go to the zoning code so I'm gonna show you how to get there and then we'll answer the question so city's website right it's right here when you go up to the government page here we could learn about the city learn about your boards and committees your City Council budgets and right here the city charter and the code of ordinances so you find zoning which happens to be chapter 27 it's right here and this is a really nice bedtime read 474 pages and so what you're looking for is the space and bulk standards for zoning districts section 27 403 and you go here and it's it's all listed in a series of tables like this so I'll give you a little orientation to kind of understand what we're looking at our zoning districts out laid up here do you have a zoning district that you do you know the zone of your property it's probably a or G right it might be double a so let's let's look at these three these three zones together make up 90% percent of the land area of the city, so chances are. Okay, so here you have your minimum lot size. We talked about 5,000 square feet. Your minimum lot area per dwelling unit. You gotta see some footnotes. Street frontage, we were talking about this before. The 75 feet in the AA, 40 feet in the A and G. That's how wide is the lot where it abuts the street the right of way. Okay, so now we're here. minimum front yard setback maximum front yard setback so maximum front yard setbacks not applicable in almost any district I think it's only one district yeah the RC so for your question like so what's the setback right now so in the g-zone that this recently dropped to 10 feet I think this used to be 15 maybe 20 feet it used to be 20 yeah so it's this is dropped to 10 feet the a and double layer still 20 feet one way to understand the zoning districts double a and G in this order this is low density middle density higher density housing all right so low density housing more space all around middle densities kind of the middle there and then the G density that's our highest density residential district so you so it's fit more a little bit tighter side yard setback six feet and we are 15 there is a there is an ordinance that had a public hearing at the Planning Board a few weeks ago it was scheduled for City Council last night but it got postponed in it seeking to or it's proposing to amend the a and G to reduce these again by another five or ten feet so I think it was to drop the a zone to ten feet and the G zone to five feet
[1:18:46] Speaker B (unidentified): again allowance from six down to five if your neighbor agreed to it we can tell
[1:18:57] Speaker A (unidentified): you more background on that if people want but let's does that kind of answer your question right off yeah so accessory great question the ordinance often has different setback requirements for principal structures and for accessory structures so accessory dwelling units are accessory structures even if it's an accessory dwelling unit there's a portion of your house that portion that use is the accessory structure setback so a lot of times you'll see these footnotes sometimes these footnotes are saying it's ten feet but then you go down on the footnote it says except accessory structures or six feet right so your garage your ad you your garden shed so a lesser restriction. So the footnotes are a very important component of the table. Is there one? I saw another hand in the back there. No? Any other questions?
[1:20:08] Speaker F (unidentified): It's not really a question, but it is that I was just finding my note on it. Earlier, Eli, you were talking about when we're dealing with setback changes, that it will harken back to more of historically how South Portland was developed. So I think the figure that I saw most recently is when we make the change, if the council votes to make the changes that you just described in A and G, that already they're about 40% of the residential homes in South Portland already will be what we are now turning it into. So I guess the reason I feel that it's important for people to think about that is if the council does this, I don't think it's going to shock anyone. It's something that we see every day.
[1:21:10] Speaker A (unidentified): And thank you, Mary Tipton. That's part of the way that these ordinances get developed is, you know, the comprehensive plan has a kind of overarching policy goal. It says revive historic neighborhoods, have infill density. But what does that mean? So the planning division does analysis. We look at what does the actual build-out look like on the face of the earth today. And so the proposals that come forth, just like you were saying, were from that analysis that found, okay, making this 10 feet and making that five feet I think were the numbers will render 95% of the lots conforming right because a lot of most of our houses right now are non conforming because they were built a lot closer so one of the metrics that we kind of use is all right bringing this back down returning to historic norms it makes most of those lots conforming with respect to setback and it's different in different zones so that analysis can kind of happen all throughout
[1:22:39] Speaker G (unidentified): has always been good about making amendments. So right there on the chart, since you have it up, AA, 75 feet for minimum street frontage, okay?
[1:22:50] Speaker A (unidentified): You want me to select this? Yes, right here is what Mr. Notice is talking about.
[1:22:56] Speaker G (unidentified): Now, that's just an arbitrary. When that was done, they went through and just picked the size. It didn't fit all the lots, but it fit, you know, I don't even know how many it fit. I know down by the Willard Beach area it doesn't hardly fit any of them, okay? They're not 75 feet. That's not double A.
[1:23:15] Speaker D (unidentified): Pardon me? That's not double A. Willard is A.
[1:23:19] Speaker G (unidentified): I'm talking about some of the lots down in Willard that are double A.
[1:23:22] Speaker D (unidentified): Right, but there aren't any in Willard that are double A?
[1:23:26] Speaker G (unidentified): There are. It's the Lovett's Field side.
[1:23:28] Speaker D (unidentified): It's Lovett's Field, right. Right, Lovett's Field. Lovett's Deak Street.
[1:23:32] Speaker G (unidentified): There's Deak Street. Okay. That's kind of cradle spoke. You've got one foot in the coveted Lovett's Field there. And then you have one foot in the Willard Beach neighborhood, okay? I don't know if I'm using the right terminology, but in any event, you know, so let's say you've got a lot that's not 75 feet, it's 67 feet, okay? Can you put an ADU in that existing house? Just because, you know, the frontage is there. I've read the memo, and it seems like the memo, space in bulk, you've got to meet that, setbacks, but do you have to meet the, and I know for a fact that there's an ABU that was approved next to the property I have in question that has virtually no street frontage, which is a right of way.
[1:24:28] Speaker E (unidentified): So just for clarification, that minimum street frontage is more for when you're creating a new lot, not necessarily existing lots creating an ADU. That's not a new lot. Not a new lot. Nope. So that's perfectly normal that they were allowed to build that. Now,
[1:24:45] Speaker G (unidentified): I don't want to take up too much time here, but I know I am. I'm sorry. I'd like to see that 75 feet, 40 feet, you know. With ADU, it doesn't even matter if it's a previous lot. That's what you're saying.
[1:25:00] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, so the ADU has to meet bulk and space requirements, but that's more for the setbacks and the building coverage percentages. Yeah, but not the street frontage, not the minimum lot size.
[1:25:19] Speaker B (unidentified): Perfect. I can expand a little bit on that too because Eli talked about non-conforming lots of record, and there are a lot of lots that are conforming non-conforming lots of record that are only 30 feet wide in the city that are residential and so basically even though this says you need to have 40 feet of frontage for a and G or 75 for the double-a non-conforming lot of record with 30 feet of road frontage can be built upon to be split and then built upon the latest example is one on withburn that i know of and withburn is basically a bunch of old 30-foot wide lots from the subdivision in like 1920. so that's basically this like we said this is if any new law was to be created this is what you have to meet these are the requirements thank you yes
[1:26:15] Speaker E (unidentified): or
[1:26:23] Speaker A (unidentified): or 90% of the primary dwelling whichever is smaller right yeah right
[1:26:37] Speaker B (unidentified): right so that's a first floor adu so if your adu is on the first floor it can't be larger than 800 square feet for that first floor area but if you had if you were able to build a larger adu because you have a larger lot so you can get 1200 square foot adu you'd have to build it 800 on the first floor and have a second floor with 400 square feet even if it's attached yeah unless it's yeah if it's detached especially the only other instance is if it's a garage you're
[1:27:12] Speaker E (unidentified): building the garage as the ground floor and the upstairs is the adu itself that can be larger than the 800 if your property permits
[1:27:21] Speaker B (unidentified): yeah because you also have to take into account the building maximum building coverage in the a and g zones are 25 and 33 percent respectively there is no maximum in the AA zone. And that's 24% of your lot area for A and 33 for the G.
[1:27:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, yeah, good. Any other questions? I have a question for Tim. Sure. If I might. So the ADU construction loan is really, was really fascinating for me to learn about and I'm interested to know how you classify it as an ADU versus just another small house on a property in a city like South Portland a person may have the opportunity to build a second or third small house they might call it an ADU we might call it right there's like a few things at play we might not call it right it's like it depends and so where is the kind of how do you define that so
[1:28:39] Speaker C (unidentified): the answer is pretty simple yeah it's whatever the town says okay so we don't get okay splitting hairs on that yeah town calls a new to you yes that's an
[1:28:47] Speaker A (unidentified): ADU okay that's that's kind of time make sense okay interesting so that's like another perk to having going the EDU path even if you could develop it as a regular principal additional dwelling unit. Interesting. All right. Well, if there's no further questions, I'm going to just share with you one last resource. Here back, we go to Departments, and we go to Code Enforcement here.
[1:29:23] Speaker B (unidentified): While he's bringing this up, Jen will be the point of contact for any ADU zoning permitting. So you'll be working with her if you do
[1:29:30] Speaker A (unidentified): you want to start an ADU process and speaking of which so right here we have a whole page for accessory dwelling units and you'll see here quick links here's a digital copy of the guidebook that you took or there's more
[1:29:45] Speaker E (unidentified): copies in the back okay well we'll get that a little bit construction in
[1:29:57] Speaker A (unidentified): In process, but this slide deck that we just looked at today and the recording, this has been filmed, will also go up here so you'll be able to come back and reference this material if you need. Otherwise, we can be contacted in the Code Enforcement and Planning Division and we look forward to having another conversation.
[1:30:15] Speaker F (unidentified): Oh, another question. I do, no, it's an accolade. I just wanted to thank you guys for doing this and to also say that when I see things like bullet points on a slide for some of them I think about the hours and hours of work behind all that simple bullet point and it's work by the planning department and planning and codes and also by volunteers who are residents like us who've served on comprehensive planning committee who serve on the planning board so I'm just I'm very grateful to all of you and I'm particularly grateful when we see how much progress there has been made on streamlining which was something that I think lots of people in South Portland and builders who wanted to build in South Portland had been calling for years so thank you very much
[1:31:15] Speaker A (unidentified): right thanks all