← Back to MaineScanner

South Portland Council to vote on ICE ordinance, tank farm emissions

2026-10-27 · 5h 41m · Source: spcc_20261027 - South Portland City Council - October 27 2027 (City of South Portland (SPC-TV Vimeo))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Mayor Tipton: Hello, everyone. It's good to see you. I call this meeting of the South Portland City Council to order on Tuesday, October 27. I want to note that we are a family affair council meeting and I'm proud to see it. If you will join me on this day that is one week before For our electoral process is concluded a foundational tool of democracy. We can show respect to the ideals of the Republic of the United States of America. [0:38] Speaker B (unidentified): I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:56] Mayor Tipton: Thank you so much. Madam Clerk, may we have a roll call, please? [1:04] Madam Clerk: Councilor Matthews? Yes, ma'am. Councilor West? Yes. Councilor Pride? Here. Councilor Coleman? Here. Councilor Walker? Here. Councilor Scott? And Mayor Tipton? I am here. [1:17] Mayor Tipton: Here, Councillor Scott is slightly delayed. She'll join us as quickly as she can. Madam Mayor? [1:23] Councilor Scott: Yes, ma'am. Before we start, because we have such a crowded agenda tonight, I'd like to make a motion to put over item G1 and G2 until our next meeting. Those are two zoning matters. And I think particularly item G1 requires some discussion from by the council and I just hate to do that tonight when we've got a couple of really important Workshops to that. I'd like to spend our time on [1:56] Councilor Pryde: I'll second that motion [1:58] Mayor Tipton: All right. Thank you very much Counselors any questions or did you want to hear from the city manager about that? I just had a quick question [2:06] Councilor Walker: is there a bit on g2 was there a Sense of urgency around that matter [2:15] Councilor Matthews: yes this was the workshop that counselor Scott had requested and counsel agreed to move it directly to a first read in October so there was some urgency with this business which is why we kept it on this agenda but obviously it's up to the council if you want to move it to it would be Thursday of next week for a [2:34] Councilor Pryde: first read that's that's your I'll withdraw my second I'll submit an [2:42] Councilor Scott: amended motion that we just put over item g1 and i think g2 we can do really quickly and i'll second [2:47] Mayor Tipton: that okay counselors any further discussion questions all in favor the unanimous vote of the counselors present thank you very much now let's go back to those minutes if there are no additions or corrections to the minutes of our October 13 meeting. We'll pass those by unanimous consent. I don't see any. The minutes are accepted. I'm getting used to being able to see my counselors like this and it's like this. Now I know what the school board chair deals with. We're now gonna move on to petitions and communications. You so [3:35] Madam Clerk: This is just a reminder, as the mayor has said, we are waiting election on next Tuesday, November 3rd. There is still time if you are not able to go on Election Day to come get your absentee ballot this week. We'll be open until 6 p.m. again tomorrow night, and then we were open until 5 p.m. on Thursday, and that is the last opportunity to obtain an absentee ballot or to vote an absentee in person. Thank [4:00] Mayor Tipton: You counselors, any questions about the petitions and communications announcements? Again, we just thank everyone who is working so hard on our elections. We really appreciate the work everyone. Get out there and vote. Thank you. All right, can you please read the items on the consent calendar, Madam Clerk? Order [4:26] Madam Clerk: 228 2526 Affordable Housing Committee, Jessica Rosenberg for private sector housing developer for District 1 for an unexpired term, expiring on December 30th, 27. Order number 33, 26, 27, Comprehensive Planning Committee, Emily Hamm, Advisory Member, a mayoral appointment for an unexpired term expiring September 30th, 27. Order number 59, 26, 27, appointing Ruth Graves for Ward Clerk for District 3 for an unexpired term ending in November of 28. Order number 60, 26, 27, appointing Gerald Murray for Ward Clerk for District 1 for an unexpired term ending in 28. Order 61, 26, 27, granting temporary street closure from Broadway, of Broadway, between Breakwater Drive and Ocean Street for the Veterans Day Parade on Wednesday, November 11th from 8 and 10 a.m. till 1230. Order 62, 26, 27, appointing Rebecca Barr for Ward Clerk Pro Tem for District 2 for an unexpired term until November of 2028. And the last item on the Consent Calendar is Order number 63 26 27 authorizing the main dot for construction over limit permit for an existing project. All items read on the consent calendar require a majority vote. All [5:39] Mayor Tipton: Right counselors, any item that any of you want to remove from the consent calendar? I don't see anyone raising a hand for that, so let's go and read the rules for public comment. [5:54] Madam Clerk: Which is coming right up. Members of the public are invited to comment on any topic, on or off the agenda, during citizen discussion part one or part two, for up to three minutes. If you are here to speak on an item appearing on tonight's agenda, you are encouraged to wait until this item comes up on the agenda, where you will have three minutes to speak. If you are unable to wait, you may speak on the matter during citizen discussion part one; however, you will not be permitted to speak on the topic again. Similarly, members of the people, members of the public who speak on the topic when it comes up on the agenda may not speak on the topic again when it comes up during citizen discussion part two. We ask all speakers to state their name and address for the record.
Public Comment
[6:34] Mayor Tipton: Thank you very much. I'm just going to underscore a couple of things that our clerk just read, which is that we have a few different public comment periods. The first one we have coming up is for items on the consent calendar that you just heard read. The second one we have coming up is the first open public comment. That means you can make a comment about anything. If you speak in the first open public comment, you cannot speak again in the second open public comment, which is basically toward the very end of the meeting. You can always speak on an agenda item as it comes up, with only one exception. If you've already spoken in the public comment on that same topic, don't expect to speak on it again when it's an agenda item. All right, everybody, we're having a test. Who can, I think that we've made those clear. I think some of you know this from having done it before, but it's very nice to see so many faces, and I want to make sure that everyone understands how this works. Okay, we're now going to open up the comments on the consent agenda, only for the consent calendar, excuse me. I don't see anyone approaching the microphone. I see, okay, I do not, so it looks like we do not have comments for the consent calendar. All right, we're gonna close those comments. Thank you. Now we can move into, oh wait, I think we better vote on the consent calendar. Move for passage of the consent calendar. Thank you. We have both second counselors. All in favor, thank you. And can we note that counselor Scott is with us? Good to see you, thank you so much. All right, now we can move to our first open public comment. Thank [8:43] Madam Clerk: Do we need to postpone the appointment calendar? [8:46] Mayor Tipton: Oh, did we not postpone it? I'm so excited for public comment. I seem to be skipping things tonight. All right, councilors, without objection, we can postpone our appointment calendar to our next public meeting. Yes, I don't see objection. That is done. All right, I see a lot of you and who wants to be our first person to make public comment because there's the microphone we'd love to hear from you. [9:54] Speaker H (unidentified): I don't know if this fits in with the order of things all right. [10:05] Mayor Tipton: Ms. Berger, can you move the microphone to make sure it's as underneath you as possible? How's that? If I remember, this microphone can be a little tricky, although maybe it's a new one. [10:16] Speaker H (unidentified): Tell me if this is good. [10:18] Mayor Tipton: Yes, you sort of have to lean really into this one. Really into it. Okay. How about that? [10:25] Madam Clerk: Sounds good. Thank you so much. That sounds better. Yes. Do we have the clock? [10:30] Speaker H (unidentified): No, this isn't going to take very long. Good evening, councillors. Thank you for the opportunity to speak this evening. I'm Rachel Berger, resident at 17 Churchill Road. For a number of years, working with Protect South Portland, we were concerned with tank pollution affecting residents' health in our town. There is scientific research showing a strong established connection between benzene and leukemia, as well as emerging links between benzene and bladder cancer. Fence line monitoring has revealed that benzene levels are way above the state limit at two locations, one of which I live only seven minutes' drive from. When I heard these emissions could cause bladder cancer and leukemia, I felt I should speak out since I had bladder cancer requiring major surgery and are currently dealing with leukemia. The issue of these emissions should be taken seriously and dealt with in ways that protect the residents of South Portland. Thank you for your attention. You're welcome. Good [12:10] Public commenters (Melinda Hull, Skeek Frazee): evening. My name is Melinda Hull and I live on [street]. There are two topics on the agenda tonight that particularly speak to the public health and safety of members in this community. One involves the necessity of clean air for all members of this community and how that's not happening right now. And the other supports the idea that immigrants and black and brown community members can move safely through our city. I'm speaking tonight as a Protect South Portland coordinator and a resident, asking the city council to act now to protect public health and safety. I support the ICE ordinance that is before you tonight, and I'm grateful that the school board voted for inclusion last night. But I will focus my comments on tank fume mitigation. I became involved in the toxic tank fumes issue in 2019. I came before the city council then and shared the story of my daughter's daycare and the persistent choking fumes that caused the children to be kept indoors, teachers to develop chronic respiratory conditions and headaches, and horror when it dawned on me that this wasn't an accident, that it was knowingly being allowed to happen to our kids and our neighbors. I showed my then almost three-year-old daughter how to cover her face with a scarf when she smelled the fumes, because it was all I could do. The fence line data that will be presented tonight adds to years of documentation at all levels of our government of the dangers posed by the tanks, further corroborating personal stories like mine. There is a problem with the air here. The tank farms are responsible for a significant portion of it, and it is time to act. Hundreds of homes, thousands of people are experiencing long-term exposure to toxins. The DEP's own data confirms the population's persistent exposure to sickening and deadly benzene. And the tank farms report that they aren't operating anywhere near their level of permitted emissions. Can you imagine, Councillors, how much more toxic and poisonous the air will be when they are? And despite all this, the proposal on the table from the City and DEP is more testing. We need to do better than that. On behalf of Protect South Portland and many of my neighbors here tonight, I call on the City Council and DEP to stop these tank farms from polluting our neighborhoods. The DEP has many tools, including the power to lower permitted emissions amounts and require the measurement and mitigation of the toxins coming from the tanks. 30 seconds. The city has its own arsenal of tools, including the creation of local emissions control ordinances, so let's use them. After all, the DEP has said many times publicly it's just following the city's lead regarding this problem. So, leaders in this room, what are you going to do to stop the tanks from dumping pollutants into the air we breathe now? [15:06] Mayor Tipton: Thank you. Thank you very much. [15:14] Public commenters (Hartley Bion, Nathan Trapp): Hi, my name is Hartley Bion. I am 11 years old and I live in South Portland. I went to daycare near the tanks and my family likes going to Bug Light Park. I think it's crazy that tanks with hazardous fumes are allowed to be near houses, parks, and schools and I think the City Council should do everything they can to make sure the air around the tank farms is safe to breathe. No kid should have to live in fear of having to breathe toxic air. Benzene can cause serious problems for kids like leukemia and asthma. Please act now and protect kids across the city. [15:59] Public commenters (Chelsea Bien, Anna): Good evening. My name is Chelsea Bien. I live on [street]. Street. I support passage of an ICE ordinance that covers all city employees, including school employees, and tonight I want to talk about the tanks. Over and over, this community has seen our concerns about the tank farms minimized or dismissed by state regulators. Years ago, the DEP refused to act when it learned from the federal EPA that Global and Sprague had been violating the Clean Air Act for years. years. The EPA had to act on its own, suing those operators. In 2019, when residents turned out in force to share their stories in public testimony and comments to the court, and in all the years since then, the DEP has said they saw no reason to act urgently, that the data didn't support it. There are good people working at DEP, some of whom I think are here tonight. And we have a regulatory system that time and time again favors cooperation with corporations over accountability to the people. It was residents, not regulators, who pushed for fence line testing. I'm grateful to the many people in this room who worked diligently to get that bill passed. Some of you on the council and Manager Morelli were part of that effort, testifying before the legislature. Now, thanks to you, we have data that tell a crystal clear story. The air near the tanks is dirty. It exceeds the state's own health standards, not by a little and not every so often, but dramatically and consistently in places where houses and businesses and recreational facilities are pressed right up against the fence line. The city just built a playground within sight of Sitco tanks, where readings show high benzene, a well-studied carcinogen that's particularly toxic to children, one block away from the fence. As you listen to the experts tonight and discuss the options, please ask yourself, how does this help the people of South Portland, who have been waiting years for action, to breathe easier? I have two requests of the council. Number one, demand that the DEP provide real accountability by making the tanks clean up their operations. Say it in the strongest possible language. Number two, take direct action. The city can impose its own requirements on tank operations through a local licensing process or an ordinance that piggybacks on the DEP process. process. There is precedent for this in Maine as a means to control polluters that have an outsized local impact but are overseen by state regulators unwilling to act. You can do this. You are the body that can act to protect local interests. Please do. Thank you very much. Hello everybody. My name is Alex Golchenski and I live on [street]. I'm here today about two connected issues about the health and safety and collective well-being of our neighbors. First, I'd like to briefly voice my support for the passage of an ICE ordinance that covers all city employees, including school employees, but I'm here primarily to talk about the tanks and the results of the fence line monitoring report. As you've already heard today, and I'm sure we'll hear more later, many of these air pollutants are concerning for human health, but benzene in particular is of concern. Benzene is officially known carcinogen and long-term exposure damages bone marrow and is linked to leukemia and other blood disorders. But it's not just long-term exposure. Acute exposure can cause fatigue, dizziness, irregular heartbeat, and headaches. We also know children, older adults, and immunocompromised people are especially vulnerable. The World Health Organization does not recommend there is any safe level of benzene exposure. You'll hear a lot in today's report about Maine's ambient air guidelines, lines, which are used extensively as a health-based benchmark, not regulatory limits of a definitive or the definitive line between safe and unsafe air. Additionally, I was concerned to find out that Maine's benchmark for benzene is less protective than Massachusetts. We have a 1 in 100,000 cancer risk compared to 1 in 1 million. So my question is, why does Maine DEP accept a higher level of cancer risk than Massachusetts, and why should we as residents of South Portland except our lives is any less valuable. However, as you've already heard, even measured against Maine's ambient air guideline, the fence line monitor's data shows benzene levels at almost every tank consistently exceeding guidelines, both in short-term and long-term averages. And we are seeing these elevated levels while many of these tank farms are not actually even operating at their full capacity. So this exposure for benzene and other harmful VSCs are legally permitted to be much higher than what we're seeing at the fence line today. Day tonight the city is going to consider more monitoring and a 1,000 foot setback for future development. I believe both have a role, but neither is enough for our neighbors who already live, learn, and work near these tank farms. So the question I'd like asked tonight is, how many people currently live within 1,000 feet of these fence line of these teen farm fence lines? I'd like an official answer, but I've already counted at least 75 residential buildings, some of the multifamily units within a tenth of a mile, which is just 500 feet from the sicko fence line alone. And so my question for the council is this: are we doing everything we can protect we can do to protect the health and the people who live here right now? Current residents and our neighbors should not be an afterthought in the conversation about future development or another round of monitoring. I urge the city to pursue every available pathway to reduce emissions and residents exposure to benzines right now, to press CDP for strong protection and hold tank farms accountable, and make it clear that additional testing cannot not substitute for meaningful mitigation. Thank you so much Mr. [22:07] Mayor Tipton: Redfield, if you could just let him set up. Great, thanks. [22:22] Public commenter (Alex Redfield): My name is Alex Redfield. I live on [street]. It's my daughter Harriet. Three of the biggest topics that I hear folks around town talking about these days are the ice ordinance and the tanks, and we're talking about those tonight. I want to add a third one just to frame it in a different context, which is the police and fire station bond. And I bring that into the discussion not to talk about the police and fire station bond, but to mention it as another public safety item that we're all considering. They're very different issues with different origins, different solutions, and they're being treated differently, though they're all related to public safety and keeping us safe and making South Portland a place where we can live and learn and work and interact with each other. So on one of these public safety questions we're mobilizing city resources and asking all of us to share the burden. We're borrowing millions of dollars and paying it back with interest to improve the infrastructure that ostensibly continues contributes to one element of public safety. On the other two well we're talking about it today. I want to frame it that way to put it into context what feels like an appropriate response and what doesn't feel like an appropriate response. What feels appropriate to me personally is to use every tool available to solve the problems and it's okay that we don't have all of the tools we need to get ice out of our community. It's okay that we in this room don't have those tools that's just how it is. It's also understandable that we in this room can't immediately close the tanks and clean our air. What's not okay is leaving anything on the table or using our tools towards a purported solution that doesn't actually solve the problems. When it comes to the ice ordinance. I'm appreciative of the discussions that indicate that the city is ready to make the ordinance broad, expansive, enforceable, and transparent, and I encourage you to use all of your tools to support neighbors that are feeling unsafe because of ICE's continued destabilizing presence. When it comes to the tanks, the best metaphor I could come up with is that it feels like our smoke detector has been going off for somewhere between 10 and 15 years, and it's It's beeping again and we now know that the battery isn't the issue. When my smoke detector or carbon monoxide is maybe an even better metaphor, I should have thought of that. When that goes off in my house, I don't think the appropriate solution is to go out and buy more smoke detectors. The appropriate solution is to put out the fire and get rid of the source. I think it's time to put out the fire and clean the air. [24:56] Mayor Tipton: Thank you very much. Hello, [25:02] Public commenters (Hartley Bion, Nathan Trapp): my name is Nathan Trapp and I am a South Portland resident of [address]. I'm here not only to talk to the people of the council but also to anyone here who is from the tank farms. I would like to say I do not want cancer and my mom who has lung problems, I do not want her to become sicker because she has to deal with a problem that isn't being dealt with. So please do whatever you can to deal with these tank farms. Thank you. [25:38] Mayor Tipton: Thank you, Nathan. [25:43] Public commenters (Leslie Gatcombe Hines, Kathy Chopman): Hello. Thank you for having this workshop. My name is Leslie Gatcombe Hines and I live on [street] and previously lived on [street]. Street. My adult child attended school at Dyer Elementary and South Portland High School. I worked with Protect South Portland for the Clear Skies Ordinance. As a long-time resident, a registered nurse and healthcare professional, I am concerned about the exposure of residents, particularly children and the elderly, to volatile organic compounds in the air surrounding the petroleum tank farms in our neighborhoods. I know that a good portion of the state is reliant on the products stored in the tank farms that were part of the Strategic Petroleum reserve, and although I have reduced my consumption of petroleum products, I still do rely on them. However, I feel that as a city, we need to partner with the EPA, DEP, CDC, and companies that store their products on city property. As residents, we need to be responsible stewards of the environment and advocates for public safety. In 2019, I opened a vacuum canister on my deck, which is downwind of the tanks between Highland Avenue and Broadway. In the brief moment that the air was sampled, it tested positive for volatile organic compounds. My deck becomes quite dirty with deposits that can be black. Last week, I cleaned my little table and chair, and six days later, this is how much I got off of it. I don't know what might be part of that, but I live on a dead-end street, so there's not a lot of traffic. I'm a recent cancer survivor and know that benzene and other chemicals or known carcinogens. I do not know if we have epidemiological data for our city regarding rates of types of cancer, neurological conditions, and respiratory or other diseases which may be caused or enhanced by exposure to these chemicals. We know that there are certain times when these chemicals are more likely to be released and that there are some sites which are more problematic than others. Do we know when these releases occur? Do we have a way to warn daycares or schools to keep the children indoors if these compounds are being released? Better yet, are there hoods or other devices that can be used to contain or mitigate these releases? Do empty tanks provide any exposure risk? Is there a date by which tanks need to be replaced? Do they need to be removed? Is there contamination of the soil outside of the fence lines? In 2020, the state was asked to place monitoring devices around residential areas but did not do this, but the city's Clean Air Advisory Committee recommended fence line monitoring, and the bill was passed in 2023. The fence line monitoring has provided some of the data we needed showing that benzene has been released in excessive standards for long-term exposure. However, there's not a safe level of benzene. We need to have this issue more actively addressed, both with monitoring and some proactive action to mitigate exposure. There are at least seven children's centers and elementary schools, summer rec camp, high school, college, three residential centers, along with many homes and rental units in the areas surrounding these tank farms. We need the state regulating agencies and the corporations that own these tanks to work with us on this issue to ensure residents so their public safety is being addressed. And I support what you're going to do tonight. [28:57] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Good evening. My name is Victoria Libby. I live on [street] with my husband and our young children. I'm honestly surprised that I need to be up here. I assumed that in this country, particularly in this state, clean air was a given. I thought my city and my state would not let residents breathe in cancer-causing chemicals. I've learned that I can't just expect that. Maine's Department of Environmental Protection's own air monitoring found benzene, a known carcinogen, near Sitco Terminal on Mechanic Street and South Portland Terminal on Lincoln Street. The levels were far above normal, up to 12 times higher near South Portland Terminal. Families live right next to these tanks and breathe that air every day. The World Health Organization says that there is no safe level of benzene exposure. Even on Preble Street, at a little distance from the supposed safer levels of admissions, my family notices strong chemical smells, especially in late summer. That fits how these tanks work. As temperatures rise, pressure builds and fixed roof tanks, and they release more vapor. Since we moved here, my husband uses his inhaler more and I get headaches I never used to have. I can't prove the tanks cause that, but I shouldn't have to wonder. Other states have faced this problem and acted. I'm asking this council to formally press Maine DEP to require these measures for every tank in South Portland. Domes on all floating roof tanks and all crude oil tanks to capture vapors. Vapor capture systems on all fixed roof tanks, continuous leak detection using infrared cameras, independent state monitoring not company self-reporting, a plan to keep these tanks from contaminating our waters during severe floods. I'm also asking that allowable mission limits be lowered significantly. When the health effects are this uncertain, the burden should fall on the companies, not on us residents and our children. I love this city. Please don't ask its families to trade their health for the convenience of oil companies. Thank you for your time and consideration. [31:08] Mayor Tipton: Thank you very much. [31:17] Public commenter (Ed Rowe): Ed Rowe, Deke Street and Meetinghouse Hill Park Project. I'm here tonight to discuss the progress we've made on Neal Street and the public benefit we've already provided to the city. We've done this in the three years since we got planning board approval on August 26, 2022. Can the city manager, please confirm this is the date we got formal signed planning board approval. The most significant public benefit is the satisfaction of DEP regarding hazardous materials. The entire neighborhood is much safer environmentally by the work we did. We abated significant asbestos. We satisfied DEP. We did this at my expense and eliminated significant city liability going forward. This alone saved the city $400,000. Over the winter of 22, 23, and 9 months, we built a 750-foot DOT quality road. Underground utilities, this is the longest road built in the city in at least 20 years as far as I can determine. The city benefits from this million dollar road. I talk to people all the time walking through and they love what we've done there. I would like to turn it over to the city now, however I am prevented from doing so by restrictive language in the approval notes. We also built the longest privately funded separated stormwater line in the history of South Portland, 1,000 feet long through bedrock and places along the Walnut Street side of the project. This is entirely for the benefit of the Butters on Walnut Street and it's worth over a hundred thousand dollars. These are benefits the city has already accrued and there's more to come. But I'm here to discuss buildings. Not only have we already provided incredible site work benefits, we have built four seal housing and it's more successfully than any other project in South Portland since the plenty ward approval in the fall of 2022. There are four other residential projects that have been in discussion, zone change, or started construction here in South Portland since 2022 or earlier. We've built more units in the same time and have more occupants than these four projects combined. Surf Site, 12-unit condo project, mothball. Summit Terrace, 20-unit project, six built, one occupied, the project seems stalled. Stable Oaks, 100 plus units, mothball. Bug Light, 100 plus units, mothball. And not only have we built more units, mine are 100 occupied, our site looks better. We've built roads, set aside open space, abated hazardous waste, and built separated stormwater systems. Other projects have done none of this. The idea that we are somehow delinquent as far as progress on site is not supported by the facts or in comparison to the other projects. If we widen out to the county level, you find multiple suburban condo projects are either bankrupt or vacant. The market for condos has spoken. I don't make the market, but I listen to it and I'm open to pivoting. That is what is required here. We need to think anew and act anew. Question for the City Manager. Has any of the other South Portland projects mentioned been subjected to specific time to complete deadlines in their rezoning language? Thank you. [34:08] Public commenter (Walter Kimball): Walter Kimball, [address]. I want to speak in favor of Ordinance 10, ICE restrictions, ICE enforcement restrictions, and specifically extending those restrictions to municipal employees in South Portland schools. I think having schools be part of the team that keeps our citizens safe, particularly our children, is especially important. [34:56] Public commenter (Tim Johnston): Yes, you may go ahead. Okay, thanks. Hi, my name is Tim Johnston. I'm at [address]. First of all, thank you to the council for everything that you've done here and the DEP and all the diligent research that's been done around fence line testing. My apologies, I'm not as well versed as some of the other people who have spoken about this issue. But I moved to South Portland five years ago. This is an amazing city with an incredible waterfront, great community, and I think if all these fields were open right now without oil tanks on them, I don't think there's a single person that would choose to put oil tanks on these properties and be living with these emissions. I moved here with the hopes of raising a young family and now I'm very hesitant to do so with the sort of unknowns. Yes, we know the harms of benzene, but there's plenty of other chemicals and we don't necessarily have all the research. When I moved here five years ago, there was some kind of app, I think it was called Smell My City, that they were encouraging people to go on and see how bad things smelled. That data seemed to go nowhere. There seems to be not have been a lot of progress in that time and I'm very surprised by that. So I just want to encourage the council to do as much as possible to move in the direction of the city we want, which is not having these smells here. Nonetheless my specific question is more about the revenues that we do gain from these things being here. I mean obviously, we all use petroleum products, even though many of us are moving away from them. It would be nice to know what the direct benefits to the city are. If we can use some of that revenue to do some things like real-time monitoring, not just on the fence lines but within neighborhoods, to know when things are unsafe, when we shouldn't send our kids outside, and what other benefits we might be able to... Maybe there's some kind of trust where the citizens of South Portland could be paid out. My understanding is there's no shortage of profits in the oil industry. I could be wrong on that. So anyway that's my comment and thank you very much for opening up the Florida public comment [36:51] Mayor Tipton: thanks thank you good [36:56] Public commenters (Matthew Beck, Tom Okolka): evening thanks for the opportunity to speak with you this evening. I'm state representative Matthew Beck, house district 122, the portion of South Portland that includes Willard Beach and some of the oil storage facilities that you'll be discussing this evening. It was a pleasure to have the opportunity to partner with Council a couple of years ago and try to get a community notification bill passed in the state legislature. The bill ultimately was opposed by the Mills administration and then amended to simply put up warning signs on the fence line of the petroleum storage facilities. That bill failed in the House when a majority of my colleagues voted against it and I guess the point I'm making is you have an opportunity to take action here tonight. We can certainly partner again in the 133rd legislature that starts in January but once things get to Augusta there's really no way of knowing how things are to turn out. You have within your own power the ability to do things without going to the state legislature and I encourage you to take the most effective and decisive action You can on this issue and in another matter I want to congratulate you on the great work you've done on the ICE ordinance that's before you tonight, I encourage you to pass it, and I wanted to make sure that as you discuss that, you remember the name of the young father in Biddeford who was killed by ICE on July 13th. I thought it was important to say his name, Johan Sebastian Duran Guerrero. Thank you. [39:04] Mayor Tipton: Thank you, Representative. Sorry, taking my notes and getting a little distracted from my politeness duties [39:13] Public commenter (Craig Piper): Counselor Craig Piper love its field as a resident taxpayer and architect leading the design team for the proposed central fire station police station I would like to briefly address the cost of both waiting and the value of investing in these facilities the proposed bond represents a significant investment and taxpayers are right to carefully examine both the need and the cost. Throughout the process, the team has continually evaluated space needs, provided building systems, materials, and durability to ensure these projects are appropriately sized, responsibly designed, and fiscally prudent. An important consideration is the cost of delays. Postponing actions does not eliminate the challenges facing our existing facilities. While repairs can extend the life of these buildings, they do not resolve the underlying infrastructure issues. Band-aids don't fix broken arms and our facilities are broken. The need does not go away with time, only the cost of addressing it changes. Now is the time to provide safer working conditions for our first responders, enhance public accessibility, and reliable emergency services for the entire community. As a taxpayer, I understand the financial impact of this decision. Supporting the referendum does not mean overlooking the cost. It means recognizing that the need is real, that delay action carries consequences, and that investing now provides long-term value for all the citizens of South Portland. These projects are ultimately about public service, emergency preparedness, fairness, safe working conditions, and responsible stewardship of community resources. For these reasons, I respectfully encourage support of the Public Safety Referendum. Thank you for the opportunity to speak and thank you for your service on the committee our community or service to our community and then there's also some public information Saturday morning at the library for anyone who wants more information on the project. Good [41:29] Public commenters (Barbara Dow Nucci, PJ Craigan): Evening. My name is Barbara Dow Nucci. I now live at [address], but I grew up in South Portland at [address], Dow's Woods, which overlooks Nutter Road and the Hill Street tank farm. Thank you for holding this very important hearing. I'm here to speak on behalf of Toss the Tanks Campaign. Campaign. Toss the Tanks wants to express strong support for the work done and the recommendations being set forward by Protect South Portland. Their oil tank campaign is receiving overwhelming community support. However, we must be concerned not only about what is in the air, but we must also know what may be beneath the ground. For decades, millions of gallons of petroleum products have moved through South Portland's oil terminals. We do not know what their operations have left behind embedded in our soil and groundwater. Nowhere is this question more urgent than at the Hill Street tank farm. This tank farm is becoming a stranded industrial landscape, an emerging urban wasteland in the heart of our community. This must not be allowed to happen in South Portland. At the present time the environmental consequences of decades of petroleum storage and handling remain inadequately understood. The City Council should now ask the Maine DEP to take five specific actions. Embrace the air quality recommendations being put forward by Protect South Portland. Require comprehensive soil and groundwater testing in and around the Hill Street Tank Farm. Require Suncor and Portland Pipeline to pay for these independent environmental assessments conducted under DEP oversight. Establish ongoing monitoring and public reporting requirements for both air and land monitoring. These requirements should be considered not only for Hill Street, but for all other South Portland tank farms where decades of petroleum operations may have affected the soil and the ground water. 30 seconds. The city's responsibility to protect health, to protect public health, cannot just stop and enforcing air quality standards. It must extend to protecting the land and water beneath our feet. Thank you. [44:17] Mayor Tipton: Thank you very much. [44:25] Public commenters (Edward Reiner, Peter Stanton): Good evening. My name is Edward Reiner. I live at [address]. I've been a resident there raising my family for 28 years. [address] is on the Four River. It's at the end of Elm Street and it winds around between Mechanic Street and Ballard and Palmer Street and our house is about 700 feet from the global tanks and about 400 feet from the Citgo tanks. And I'm wondering now calling into question whether I should have moved to this neighborhood because I recently had bladder cancer surgery at Christmas time and immunotherapy treatments after that and I think I'm doing all right. But the big question is was my exposure to ongoing heavy over-the-limit air pollution petroleum fumes did that contribute or caused my situation. Anyways I've been an activist in the city for a long time. I love this city. I've been part of Protect South Portland and I'm very proud of how the Clear Skies Ordinance played out over time, and South Portland should be proud of how that litigation finally happened. I'm thinking of a timeline of how these things can progress. I think that was 2013 when that was passed, but I'd like to go forward to other meetings we're moving up towards 2019. I spoke to the head of the Air Bureau asking him in a meeting like this, so is self-monitoring in order to relicense, is that best practice? And he said, he paused and he said, it's the industry standard. So we've been dealing with a state DEP that has been dragging their feet and actually was resisting the EPA for a long time. And I made note of this comment on the news, Jeff Crawford became the Air Bureau manager and top of that department and in 2019 on television he apologized for the DEP stance and had what's like a 180 reversal on what we might expect now from the DEP. So we've been dragging our feet a long time and I've heard the schools mentioned as they've never had an air quality grade better than a C. So this needs to happen sooner rather than later. And so that 2019 stands now as seven years since Jeff Crawford made a dramatic turnaround and said the DEP would now be on board. In the past, they were basically siding with the industry and letting them re-license with just setting their own declaration of what their emissions were. And I think it's time to move forward. And I think we can now be in better partners with the DEP, But we need to keep pushing them forward. Thank you. Thank you [47:28] Speaker H (unidentified): Hi Susan Henderson, I'm a street. I'm a retired nurse. I was on the council when the complaint came from the EPA and on the DEP came to the council and We started the CAC and all that was going on. I read the recent report. I think We're doing better at looking at data, gathering data, analyzing data. I noticed that the report talks about incidence of cancer related to benzyne at numbers of people per 100,000, and I think that's all fine and good, but there's a lot of bad stuff that happens at levels a lot lower than that. We know, I think as fact, that these chemicals are not good for living things and we can't always prove that this causes that. We don't have the data of how the chemicals mix together, the petrochemicals together, and we don't have the data of how the chemicals from the tank farms mix with the trains and planes and boats and cars and we're not out to blame anybody we're not out to say liability your level caused this and that we're our prime goal is to keep our residents safe and we have a really strong database that our residents live in a toxic environment now my understanding is that all the tank farms are low are licensed as low-level polluters they seem to be meeting those requirements and under those requirements the levels aren't adequate they're not up to the high level polluters apparently there's up to my understanding there's much more stringent regulations if you're a high level polluter which leads me to believe that hey there's more that we can do to stop slow up the pollution so my suggestion is let's forget about the regulations and assume that these companies in really highly populated areas are emitting too much pollutions and they have to meet the standards of high level polluters because they're making people sick and we can i also think that there's a rationale that our tanks are in a highly populated area different from tank farms probably around the country when you go down the jersey turnpike and places like that you don't see developments where i could throw a snowball and hit a tank from a yard so I think as I think Alex said you I hope that you will take action we need to stop the pollution time thank you thank you hi [50:46] Public commenter (John Romer): John Romer O'Neill Street I'm here to talk about the Meeting House Hill contract zone and our concerns about what's called the third amendment that has been proposed by mr. Rowe, in this document, it the ultimate completion is tied to sales of earlier phases of the project, and given what's happened so far, we've lived there two years, we were the second house, nothing has happened on the site for over a year, so that seems to just keep this open ended, and that's a big concern for us. We believe it should be a big concern for the city, and it seems in essence to shift the risk to the city and to the community. Looking at the new plans, we're concerned because the proposal seems to build now build right up against the ridge, which is hillside on that side, and we're wondering has there been or will there be, if that's gonna happen, new reviews for erosion and environmental concerns. It's also not clear from the new document if the number of units is changing significantly, how does that affect traffic? Will new reviews be needed for that? It also appears, and I could be wrong, that the height of the buildings is significantly taller on the pit side, potentially blocking the views of all the trees, which actually looks stunning at the moment, and that's a big concern. We're also very concerned about the reduced size of the park. It was initially going to be one acre, it has now been reduced. I believe it might be two-thirds or closer to five-eighths. All of us that bought homes and all nine single-family homes have been sold, even though we didn't sign a contract with Mr. Rowe, we're affected by this. We're affected in day-to-day life, we're affected by the time it takes for the road to be turned over to the city. And part and parcel with that, now that this new plan has been shared with the city, we are wondering what the next steps and timeline for review and for community input are. Thank you. Thank you. Hi. [53:22] Public commenter (Kelly): I'm Kelly, my family lives on [street] near the Coast Guard, and thank you for having this important meeting. I'm from South Portland, born and raised, grew up in the fairy village area. I've smelled the oil many times, I remember as a kid, and I felt sick because of it in the house, because I've smelt it. Ironically, a lot of times it's, I'm a night owl, it seems to fill my family's house overnight when maybe nobody's smelling it in the day where we live, and I remember missing a Thanksgiving gathering because I felt sick in the morning after breathing it overnight in the house, so which is just crazy, it's affecting protecting our lives. I'm currently going through chemo. I'm being treated for cancer right now, and I don't wish this upon anybody. So I know what it means to face uncertainty about your health. I'm asking that us South Portland residents not be left with uncertainty about what our leaders intend to do to protect us. When we hear that long-term benzene levels over near South Portland's petroleum terminals have exceeded Maine's health guidelines, I have to ask how much more evidence do we need before protecting people becomes a priority for all of us? We need your help. We've seen the articles that have just come out about exposure to tank emissions increases cancer and illness risk. We know these things. We've been seeing them over the years. Benzene is a known carcinogen. There's no safe level for exposure. We can't say what could cause any one person's illness, but we shouldn't have to wait for illness to be traced to a specific source before pursuing reasonable protections. When we advocated for fence line monitoring, the purpose was to gather data that could inform action and we were told that information was needed. Well, we have lots of data, we've heard about it, we're gonna hear about it tonight. So what's gonna change? I'm asking DEP, based on these findings, what specific steps can be taken to reduce emissions, what additional protections are possible under existing regulation, what findings would trigger further investigation or corrective action. I also want to know how we'll identify short-term emission spikes that periodic sampling might miss and how we assess what we are actually breathing in our neighborhoods. We should not have to wait to address these risks that are already identified and protect the residents from ongoing exposure and I'm I'm asking the City Council to please establish a public action plan with clear guidelines, measurable pollution reduction goals, and including an assessment of what is the combined impact of emissions from multiple facilities in our neighborhoods, not just assessing each facility in isolation. As you've heard the kids talk, there's kids near the tanks, the schools, the daycares. We live near there. We hang out at Bug Light. We use the green belt. We all deserve to know what the health impacts are on us and to protect us. Thank you so much. Thank you [56:40] Public commenters (Amy Piscopo, Shelby Layton): Good evening. My name is Amy Piscopo. I'm a resident of Portland at [address]. I appreciate everyone being here tonight to discuss these important issues. I'm gonna give my professional background briefly only because it's relevant to this tank farm subject. I Began my career working as an environmental engineer sampling environmental contaminants including VOCs like benzene at toxic superfund sites. I went on to earn my doctorate in environmental engineering with a focus on the fate and transport of environmental contaminants and I currently work at a non-profit that monitors air emissions and pollutants. That said I'm well acquainted with studies like the fence line monitoring report that we that we're discussing tonight and I'd like to draw attention to one of the assumptions that underpins the short-term exposure finding, which was as paraphrased on the city website, Maine CDC concluded that the results indicate minimal health risk from short-term exposure to the daily variations measured during the study. The sampling window in the fence line monitoring study is 24 hours. This means the concentrations measured reflect an average over a one day period. However, tank operations such as filling or draining fuel oil can happen on smaller timescales than a day. This means that peak concentrations are likely much higher than the concentrations in the report, which for many locations are already in exceedance of ambient air guidelines as we know tonight. While the health models referenced in the study do take 24-hour average concentrations as inputs, these health models are limited in that they assume that a shorter exposure at a higher concentration can be translated into an equivalent continuous exposure at a lower concentration. I'll give a quick analogy in case this is helpful. So say in scenario A we have someone that consumes seven beers over the course of an hour with no subsequent beers for the rest of the week. In scenario B, someone else consumes one beer per day each day for a week. In both scenarios, seven beers were consumed in a week, but do you think the acute impact on the body is the same in both cases? Following this analogy for the acute health models in the fence line monitoring study, they assume both scenarios are the same. So my point is that this is just one reason of many reasons why impacts to public health may be understated by this report, meaning that we need to take action and make changes now. The data here is already compelling enough. Thank [59:34] Mayor Tipton: you. Thank you very much. Hello, [59:43] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): my name is Mark Johnson. I live at [address] here in South Portland. I've been living in South Portland for nearly 40 years. I wanted to thank the City Council for listening to the citizens. For a number of years, over many important issues, the City Council has been very accessible and provided us with a voice, which I'm very grateful. Thank you for your action on removing flock cameras. I think we were ahead of the country on that. There are stories almost every week in other communities that haven't been listening, and I give you lots of credit for standing up for us. I also want to give you credit for considering this emergency ordinance to enact restrictions on ice. Again, you're very proactive, and I appreciate your actions. Also, similarly, I hope that we can come to some further movement here to protect our citizens from these important air pollution issues. I have friends that live on [street]. I don't live too far from there myself. I'm very concerned about them. When they moved to South Portland, they were not aware of these issues. Now everyone is, so I encourage you to do whatever you can. Work with DEP if they're willing to push them if you need to. So many more comments are so more informed and eloquent than I am, especially some of our youngest citizens, which I'm very happy to hear that they're concerned about their future, and I am too. Thank you for your time. Keep us informed. Thank you. [1:01:33] Public commenter (Lauren Shapiro): Lauren Shapiro, Deak Street. Every South Portland resident deserves clean air and the right to know whether the air we breathe is safe. Now that we have monitoring data that raises serious concern, it is time for action. But there is another issue we must confront, the long-standing inequity in how we value and tax the land occupied by these tank farms. Based on 2021 assessor's data, even before the recent revaluation that further widens the gap, tank farm revenue per acre was one-seventh of residential and industrial warehouse one-fifth of residential. Residential. These tank farms, which sprawl across our city and infiltrate our neighborhoods, have been systematically undervalued for decades. While residents have faced continual and substantial increases in property values and the rising tax burdens that come with them, the tank farms have failed to contribute their fair share toward the growing costs of our city, all while their emissions continue to threaten the health of our residents. Why do we continue We will continue to subsidize these parcels at the expense of our community's well-being when our city is so desperately in need of revenue. We are struggling to fund schools, retain educators, maintain aging infrastructure, and provide essential services. Yet these tank farms occupy a significant share of our city's land while generating only a fraction of the tax revenue per acre that residential properties contribute. tribute. Their fiscal contribution falls short, while the environmental and public health burdens remain with our community. This arrangement is neither equitable or sustainable. I have raised the need for fair assessments of these tank farms time and time again in front of this Council. Tonight I ask the Council to take two concrete steps. First, do whatever you can to protect the health and safety of our residents. Call on Maine DEP, state legislatures, create our own air quality standards demand tech is used to reduce exposure monitor the hell out of them second undertake a thorough review of current take farm tank farm valuations and tax contributions evaluate the potential revenue that alternative uses of these land parcels could generate and then incentivize these alternatives or make them pay up we cannot continue asking residents to pay more to sustain our city services while the tank farms contribute so little relative to the land they occupy and the burdens their presence imposes nor should our community be expected to accept their hazards as the price of doing business in our neighborhoods the time for meaningful action is now thank you thank you [1:04:24] Rosemary DeAngelis: Rosemary DeAngelis, Pleasantdale. I live across Fort River from the Sitco tanks. I live around the corner from Ted, who spoke earlier and who recently underwent treatment for bladder cancer. I, too, am concerned. I have lived in that location for 32 years, 32 years of ongoing exposure. This has been an ongoing topic for many years, and yet still we're asking for safety measures that should have been in place in this community over two decades ago. My property was recently taxed as ocean front. Shouldn't that be benzene front? I wonder how that would affect my tax bill if that's what it said, but that's real. I wonder. I wonder the impact of the effects, the consequences, and as I age, I wonder about the health impact. It concerns me. For me, yes, but for all of our residents. And I ask you to support change what is affecting our neighbors. Thank you. Thank you. [1:05:39] Councilor Scott: Good evening, everyone. My name is Anne Carney. I actually live in Cape Elizabeth, but I serve as the state senator for Senate District 29, which includes South Portland, Cape Elizabeth, and some of Scarborough. And I was going to wait until the agenda item came up, but I was so moved by what Sue Henderson said, and it reminded me of the long series of conversations that the city and the legislature and members of this community have had regarding these emissions. And the point that Sue was making, which I think is really important, is that if you have a major emitter that best available control technology is required, so there are technological ways to address these emissions. And I would urge the City Council to work with the state and with our legislators to require best available control technology on any oil terminal facility that is within a certain distance of a residential area. I think if you all can, if you look at the materials for this meeting tonight, you'll see the planning divisions illustration of the thousand foot buffer around all of these oil terminal facilities. When I looked at that, what instantly struck me was we're putting a burden on all of these private homeowners to either withstand the emissions or take a hit on their property values simply because of the danger posed by these oil terminal facilities. And that's really upside down what we should be doing is asking those facilities to use best available control technology. And then, and I do strongly support the continued testing and monitoring that is proposed, but it would be wonderful to couple that with the best available control technology. And then we could use those that monitoring to measure how much cleaner our air is and how much safer our community is. Thank you. Thank you very much, senator. Good [1:07:53] Jason Shedlock: Evening, my name is Jason Shedlock. I live on [street]. I can't agree more with the senator's comments. I hope to be one of those individuals to work with the city council and the state legislature as well as the DEP and others to make sure that best available technology is being used. You I grew up in a place nicknamed cancer valley. I've lost family members due to atmospheric conditions, radon, factories that didn't have controls and things of that nature. I think it's really important to understand the responsibility that polluters have, especially in a situation like this. I would advocate that we go even further and we create a community benefit agreement and a community benefit fund that these polluters as a requirement to renew their license as a requirement to continue to do business here. No amount of money is going to reverse someone who has bladder cancer or lung cancer or leukemia or we should talk about a health fund as well to defray some of those costs. But from my perspective this is absolutely a public health issue, it's an environmental issue, you know. I represent workers for a living as well with the Laborers International Union of North America as well as the Main Building Trades and others. I'm concerned about the individuals who work in that area and concerned about in those seven beers in a day as we talked about the plumes that the former speaker talked about and how that impacts workers, as well as the people within who knows what a radius those plumes reach. So I urge the council to continue to hold accountable and step it up with us. I know that you will, and I look forward to being a part of the solution and standing with the neighbors in that area. [1:10:05] Dave Ebert: Hello. Dave Ebert, Edwards Street. Where is the CDC? [1:10:11] Mayor Tipton: They are here, right? Dave, you have to address your comments to us. Thank you. [1:10:18] Dave Ebert: Where are the CDC? Okay, this goes to the CDC. Since the meeting's agenda seems to have left out the following in the dark, I'd like to bring it to the forefront. Did you know that according to new comprehensive plan that your evaluation must incorporate the maximum potential to emit. I don't know if you knew that. Let me explain. At Sunoco during 2023 and 2024, the emitted, they emitted calculated emissions were 30% of what they were allowed of their PTE and what this is saying is the same well if you if you released 30 percent and your PTE is a hundred percent then really whatever you measure you're going to multiply times three point three and that's that's what you what you're telling people that 's your where you have to evaluate whether it's safe or not that's where you have to evaluate whether or whether it's safe or not thank you does everybody understand that 's huge that's really huge that means everything that the cdc has in that report will have multiples all of it does it make sense yes, Sunoco just last week had federal reserves taken out. That means those reserves, 200,000 barrels worth, were just sitting there. Trucks were not coming up being filled. Ships were coming up filling those tanks. They were just sitting there. So the emissions were much less than future contracts might be where they use it for gas stations. And the gas stations fill up the trucks and the ships come in and there will be a lot more emissions. So all this testing we're doing is actually measuring trends of contracts, sample size of maybe just one. Maybe that federal contract's been six years. So we're measuring how well that contract is doing. It's not like a random thing where you're flipping the coin. There's intelligence behind the data. agenda. We're treating it like it's random, like the flip of the coin or just weather, but it's not. [1:13:11] Mayor Tipton: Thank you. All right. I don't see anyone who is in line to make public comment now. I remind you that you may make public comment when we get to the agenda items. So seeing no one else, this public comment period is closed. We're going to move to public hearings and action Oh, oops, we're going to answer questions. [1:13:33] Councilor Matthews: I would just say I've got a list of the questions if we could have DEP and CDC present. There may be other comments and questions. They may answer some of them during their presentation. If not, I'll do my best after to answer those. There was a question about Mr. Rowe asking to confirm the August 22 date of when the planning board signed, and I can confirm that. He asked about if there were any timelines for other projects that he mentioned, including the one at the Liberty Shipyard. I'm not aware of any agreement the city had for any sort of timeline with that. That didn't even make it to the planning board. So no agreements there. There were no agreements with anyone at the former golf course, Sable Oak. So there wouldn't have been any sort of agreement in her timelines there, and as far as I know the one by the piggery had met its conditions of the sale, so I'm not aware of any misses there. Planning board director confirms shaking his head, so that's the answer on that. And then there were some questions about the O'Neill Street project and the new proposal and whether that would be new reviews, etc. Planning Director Navida, if you don't mind answering those. Hi, [1:15:10] Milan Navida: I'm Milan Navida, the Planning Director. So what I heard from the question was whether or not there'd be continued erosion control monitoring to make sure that the site's stable. I think that was the specific one, and yes, they're obligated to do monthly erosion controls. Once we see that it's stabilized and if the area is not being worked, then we don't monitor that area because it's stable and not being touched. But any area that continues to be affected, if they're gonna keep working through the winter, then we'd be doing monthly monitoring. And if there's rain events or a failure to upkeep them, then we move to weekly monitoring. It can escalate from there. And so the process as it works its way [1:15:43] Councilor Matthews: through the planning board would eventually make its way to the council, and so people that want to [1:15:47] Milan Navida: learn more can do both of those. Correct. Yeah, what the planning office holds is a zoning text amendment proposal which requires a public hearing at the planning board. It would be advertised in the paper, and after that planning board public hearing go to council. If it was to pass, it would have to be read twice by the city council. All public hearings with public comment. Appreciate it. [1:16:15] Mayor Tipton: All right, so again, questions that some of you asked may be answered by the DEP's presentation. And then some other questions I noted were a little bit more rhetorical, like asking counsel, "Will you do X?" I think it's fair for us to be able to hear the presentation and have our discussion, and it would then be clear whether we will do X. Thank you. All right. Now we'll move to public hearings and action. [1:16:47] Madam Clerk: Emergency ordinance number 10 26 27, an emergency ordinance to enact immigration enforcement restrictions in the city of South Portland. Passage requires a unanimous vote of all members of the city council present and voting, with at least six members present and voting. Thank you, Mr. City [1:17:05] Mayor Tipton: Manager. Did you want to say some words? Do you want me to say some words? Do you want our council [1:17:12] Councilor Matthews: to say some more? Briefly, I just wanted to provide a couple updates. Well, this is, I think, still warming up, maybe needs to be turned on again. So since the last council meeting, you had asked for a little bit more information about whether or not this could, should apply to school employees, school board. Our legal counsel Brandon Mazur met with school officials, including the school attorney, to talk through that matter. And since that time, as of last night, the school board voted that they would like the council to include school employees, board members in the ordinance, which again our legal counsel has opined that we can do. I also just wanted to call quick attention to there was a couple questions about sort of a training and what training on the ordinance would look like. So I just want to call attention to in the packet I had put together a one page [1:18:14] Speaker B (unidentified): overview. Yeah, I don't know why it's not warming up. It's trying, it's trying. Yeah, okay, thank you. [1:18:20] Councilor Matthews: So there's a one-page overview of what a potential training scenario could look like. There would be basic information shared about the ordinance with all employees, and then there would be scenarios tailored to specific departments, like city hall, because they're going to deal with different things than police, who may deal with different things than the rec center. And so there would also be some tailored scenarios to folks in those departments to help them understand. So this isn't a finished product, it's something that we'll have to continuously work on, but then we'll be able to log and make sure all the employees have taken this training, and then it would be part of just a general new hire orientation. So as soon as someone's hired, when they're getting their training on the different policies and procedures in the city, this would also be one of them, along with any sort of needed refreshers. So I just want to update the council and the public on those two items. And again, you have the two versions of the ordinance tonight, the one that excludes specifically school employees and the one that includes it. Brandon, is there anything [1:19:30] Mayor Tipton: you wanted to add on that excuse me just once it either from you brandon or scott i don't think we [1:19:37] Speaker B (unidentified): stated an overview of what this ordinance is. Oh, I was just assuming from the last meeting, sorry. [1:19:43] Councilor Matthews: Yes, this would prohibit city personnel from cooperating with federal immigration enforcement, and one thing that this ordinance also did change, based on the requirement or the request from council, was it renamed ICE as or as the entity with whom we will not cooperate, although that definition in the ordinance covers all federal immigration enforcement agencies. Thank you. [1:20:12] City Manager (Brandon): Brandon, just one minor clarification, assume it so. You do have two versions. The one that includes the school department also incorporates the school board. It's not just school employees, so just minor, and then happy to answer any questions of any of the changes or any of the process. All right, thank you so much. [1:20:39] Mayor Tipton: Councillors and members of the public, that council did have quite a rigorous discussion of this ordinance at our last meeting on October 13th, but there may still be questions that the council has. I don't, councillors, any questions? Councilor Scott. [1:20:59] Councilor Pryde: Could you clarify if there was any communication with the school department administrative attorneys and confirm that the school board has sort of the governing authority to kind of make this statement in their meeting? No offense to the school board, but I just want clarify the difference between the administration sort of attorneys and the school board's position and clarifying if we have received kind of blessings from both of those or lack of opposition. [1:21:35] City Manager (Brandon): I don't, I don't know what was provided. I provided a memo to the school board cc'ing the mayor and the city manager at the request of the school board on my position. I don't know what the school's attorney said to the school board last evening. I was not providing any sort of memo ahead of time. The conversations I had with him, there was some differing of opinions, but there was no final determination made. With that said, I think last night's vote, in my opinion, is guidance to this council, not necessarily if you guys decide to exclude them, I think that is perfectly within your realm. They have vocalized wanting to be a part of it. And my opinion sitting here advising this council is, as long as nothing in this policy frustrates stay longer 20 a, which is sort of the school world, any sort of personnel policies or collective bargaining policies, which none of that was raised as an issue in their review, I think it's perfectly reasonable to pass this. There are a number of other ordinances in the city. The conflict of interest policy includes the superintendent, school board, school employees that have purchasing power of more than 200 dollars. There's the procurement, I think, also includes the school department, so it's not completely abnormal to have ordinances affect the school department in this in the city. [1:23:12] Councilor Pryde: either i just have one yes there was a lot of discussion about training and i think a lot of conversations and comments that we received scott i wanted to ask your opinion i think i appreciate that there is a greater detail on the training and i think that 's an important aspect of this work and supports the ordinance and i was not in favor of having that specific training language within an ordinance and I wanted to check in about the ability for the council to review and be aware of the training materials, major changes to those training materials, and kind of get sort of an update on a somewhat regular basis. And I procedurally I'm not sure how to do that, but I would like to request that be a part of our sort of ongoing review of this ordinance so that we know that it's happening and we can be transparent and have some council review over the materials. [1:24:12] Councilor Matthews: I'm happy to share when we finalize the training documents, they're happy to share what those end up being. So you can all see the course curriculum, I guess, as you could maybe refer to it, that we'll be sharing with staff and new hires as they come on board. It wouldn't be anything that the council approves per se, because that's not what the ordinance says as the city manager shall, so it wouldn't be, hey, council, come, you know, bless this, it would be more [1:24:41] City Manager (Brandon): informational, but I'm, you know, absolutely happy to share that. And one clarification on that, if we're looking at the ordinance that includes city and school, the superintendent would be doing the training. It may not be this. No, so Scott will be doing providing the training and that policy to [1:25:01] Mayor Tipton: To the city side of the city side of things, thank you, that's helpful. And my recall is that this did come up in our discussion two weeks ago, and that Scott, you had said that as part of your city manager's report, you would occasionally be able to talk about this and update us. Yeah, so the other [1:25:19] Councilor Matthews: part of this is the is the notification requirement, and that's done at least annually to let council know whether or not there were any reported issues of staff cooperating or being asked to cooperate with ICE within the limits of personnel policy laws and things of that nature, or if there was such an incident that it would be reported within a I can't remember within a certain timeline, so it wouldn't wait for that year update, but the year update was more just to confirm like hey we haven't forgotten about this, there were no reports this past year, just wanted to let council know. So at a minimum that would happen, but then if any incidents did happen, those would be reported to the council presumably at you know the [1:26:05] Speaker B (unidentified): next meeting or shortly thereafter. Okay, if there are no other counselor [1:26:12] Mayor Tipton: excuse me, questions, we're gonna go to public comment. All right, let's go to a public comment. As a courtesy, I'd like to invite the chair of the school board to be the first person to make a public comment. [1:26:26] Rosemary DeAngelis: Rosemary DeAngelis, Pleasant Dale, chair of the school board. I wanted to answer a couple questions that were asked. One of them was from your corporation counsel, Mazer. What was provided to the school board was the memo from Attorney Mazur, the recommendation from our attorney, which was to not, I mean, our attorney recommended, but just like your attorney, it is a recommendation. The board does have the authority, just like the council does, to override what the attorney may or may not recommend, as long as it's not in violation of any law. We were not in violation of any law. Our attorney did recommend that we not be included in the ordinance, and it was a unanimous vote by the school board to ask the council to include us in the ordinance. I believe this is a time when we all need to band together to be a team and show strong unity. The members of the school board spoke directly to these conditions. It was a unanimous vote, and with this unanimity came a strong sentiment that school employees are city employees and take great pride in that role. And our children deserve safety, their families deserve safety, and our community deserves safety from ICE. And I know this ordinance does not change what ICE will do on the streets, but it speaks a strong message. It says we are one and we stand together. And that's what the school board spoke very strongly to last night, was the sentiment that we are unified. And we met in open session. Our attorney gave us – he was not there, but he gave us the opportunity to go into executive session. We would only go into executive session if we had questions about our roles and responsibilities as it pertains to MRSA 20A, and there was no action by the school board to have any questions for the attorney. They felt very strongly about their vote and voted unanimously to request of the council that we be included in the ordinance. So if you don't have any other questions for me, I had some other comments I was going to make, but you know, I thought you were going to call me up here to ask me first what, because you had – do you want to take an additional minute? Thank you. I just wanted to say, because one of our representatives, Matt Beck, did speak the name, and I wanted to say it as well, Johann Sebastian Duran-Guerrera was killed by ICE, specifically by David Brouillette. And that happened on July 13th, 2026. And I have attended Biddeford City Council meetings, Scarborough Town Council meetings, and speaking at both to encourage action similar to what is before this council tonight. I drive my friend to work, and I say this every time I come here at 6 a.m., and I have apologized that he came here for safety, and we are not keeping him safe. He lives in South Portland, and if you can call it that, because he spends his time either driving with me to work and driving home with somebody else, or he's in his apartment with his shades drawn and blinds pulled and just not going out of his building at all. So I understand and I appreciate what the city manager has said, that we are not going to affect what ICE is doing on the street, but I think the more communities who pass ordinances like this and make a statement and stand together as a Community the better that is, and so I thank you for asking school employees if we would like to be part of this, and the answer to that is without question, yes. Thank you. [1:30:57] Mayor Tipton: Thank you very much. [1:31:04] Councilor Pryde: Good evening. I'm Eliza Rule and I live on [street]. Thank you for considering this ordinance tonight. I appreciate the urgency with which you took this on. At the October 13th meeting, I advocated for the inclusion of general training topics in the ordinance language. I acknowledge training information is not typically part of the public conversation. I think this case is different because I believe the training is a key aspect of this ordinance. The actions that the city staff take directly impact the public. If general training guidelines cannot be explicitly be included in this ordinance, I suggest including language similar to this: the city manager or the superintendent or their designee shall create and make available on the city's publicly accessible website an outline of the items in this section. This language is similar to language included in the city ordinance on housing related to tenant and landlord rights and responsibilities, which directs the city manager to make relevant materials available on the city website. A question I don't believe we have previously been addressed is this. Will employees be trained on how to report suspected violations, and will they be trained on their rights under the state employment laws that prohibit retaliation against employees who have reported suspected legal violations? I have one additional question for the council by way of a scenario. An immigration enforcement agent seeks to enter a South Portland fire station to use the restroom. Can that request ever be considered incidental or allowed under this ordinance if agents are only in our city to conduct federal immigration enforcement? This scenario is relevant because it is clear, based on the draft training, that this ordinance can be interpreted narrowly or it can provide more protection. Further, if a resident sees an ICE agent enter a South Portland fire station, how might this be interpreted? The training provided to city employees directs them in potential interactions with federal immigration enforcement agents. Training policy transparency will help the public understand what we can expect. [1:33:17] Jason Shedlock: Good evening again, Council. My name is still Jason Shedlock, and I'm still living on [street]. Street. I'm very aware of the privilege that I have just by the way I look. And I'm very aware that I can walk in my community and be treated very differently than many of our friends and neighbors. And I feel strongly that if we aren't using that privilege, the privilege that we all have, to help those without it in every single way and pushing the envelope when necessary, then we're no better than the people that are trying to take those rights away. I'm proud of the council for what you're doing right now. I urge you to follow the lead of your corporation council as well as chair DeAngelis and the entire school board and include those workers and those school board members. One question that I do have, and I did bring it up last time, and I hope it will be a source of some discussion at the very least, is the way I read the proposed ordinance, contractors working for and on behalf of the city aren't necessarily included. If they are, to me, it's not very clear. I see that as a potential loophole, and I also see it as protecting those contractors too, to give them the guidance on what they're supposed to say, where they're supposed to report it. I appreciate your looking into that. I appreciate all the work that's been going into this. It's time to move forward on this, and I do agree that we can be an example, and the more jurisdictions and localities and states that pass these types of things. Collective action to me is very important, and I appreciate your part of it right now. Thank you. [1:35:25] Public commenters (Amy Piscopo, Shelby Layton): Hello, I'm Shelby Layton. I live on [street]. First of all, I really want to thank you all for all the work that's been done on this ordinance. I know a lot has gone into it, and I appreciate you being responsive and passing this on an emergency basis, or hopefully passing this on an emergency basis. I have faith in you, and I also appreciate the effort to get input from the school board and the school board's unanimous vote last night to have this ordinance be as strong as possible and cover both city employees and school employees. And I, you know, I think it's really great to see everyone in this room here because we care about making our community safer, and I think this ordinance is an important step towards taking back our power from federal law enforcement and keeping our community safe. One piece that is still missing from for me and that I have questions about for the ordinance is how it's going to be enforced. I think we need a clear mechanism for the public and for employees to report violations of the ordinance. And I want to tell you a recent story about why I think that's particularly important. Just this week, a number of community members saw Portland police officers interacting with ICE in what appeared to be a very friendly way, and perhaps even working with ICE to prevent legal observers from observing what ICE was doing. The Portland ordinance doesn't have a complaint mechanism and it was really unclear what to do in that situation, who to report that to, who had authority to take action, what community members could do about it. And when community members have reported it, 's not necessarily clear what's going to happen after that or what action is going to be taken as a result. I really don't want to see that happening in South Portland. I think that if someone sees something like that happening We want to be able to know exactly who to report it to what information to provide And what action is going to be taken as a result of our report? And you know, I know that disciplinary action Might be confidential. But when I say what action I mean that they are going to investigate it Who's going to investigate it and that some action is going to be taken as a result of the investigation? and I so I have some questions tonight that I'm hoping the city manager can answer one will the city manager commit to creating a public complaint process to will the city manager commit to putting a complaint form online on the city's website three will the city manager commit to creating a publicly available policy regarding how complaints will be investigated and reported on and I already lost track of the numbers but will the city manager commit to reporting to the council any complaints as they occur rather than waiting for the annual report thank you thank [1:38:32] Mayor Tipton: you very much sorry [1:38:37] Councilor Pryde: hi my name is Julia Edwards I live on [street] over on the west side and I raced over here because I thought maybe I'd miss the ability to comment so I'm glad I made it. Everything that Shelby said, thousand percent. Like would really love to have actual answers to those on the record publicly. I also admittedly have scanned the document and don't know, and forgive me if this is a very easy question to answer, and I probably should know this, but I work six jobs and I'm in school and I have kids, so I'm going to take a pass on like having read it at this moment. Is there express language in this recommending that we look at our planning rules and laws and ordinances to make sure that we have very specific language to not allow ice access to properties in South Portland for ice activities? I would like, I know you can't dictate that there's a process for planning language and planning land use policies, but it'd be important to have that in there or at least recommended that become a priority for our planning board. Would love to hear thoughts on that. If that's already in there, great. And I apologize for taking a valuable time, but just wanted to make sure that everyone is aware in this room, since there's so many people in here for like the first time in a very long time, ice has not gone away. The destruction that it is causing to our friends and neighbors and community members is even more so than what we saw in January. January, we just weren't ready for it. January, we had no idea what to expect, but it is even worse. They are more, they're able to do things quicker. They are doing things under cover. They are doing things without a lot of public awareness. And largely the city seems to have gone back to quote unquote normal. And I get that the world is on fire, but like this is still happening for our community members even more so than it was. And the impacts are even more severe because there is less visual like attention on this. So I really thank the council for keeping this in the forefront. I think all of you here that are either hearing this or have spoken to this, but please make sure that it does not fall off the table and make sure this ordinance please is as strong and stringent as humanly possible. Cities all over the country have been doing really good work on this, so let's not just stick to what the state is doing and what the cities in our state are doing, but let's look outside to our friends and neighbors that have really done their due diligence on being as like draw the line in the sand as deeply and as strongly as you possibly can. Anything less is just not worth anyone's time, so thank you for your work so far, but there's more to do. [1:41:35] Mayor Tipton: I'm sure. Thank you. Thank you very much. Good. [1:41:44] Public commenters (Melinda Hull, Skeek Frazee): Evening. My name is Skeek Frazee and I live on [street]. I'm here in support of the proposed ICE ordinance, enforcement ordinance, and I want to thank you all for grappling with this very, significant and important topic. I think many would agree that of late life, ICE's behavior is not only inhumane, it's been immoral and it's been an irresponsible use of our tax dollars. ICE hasn't targeted the worst of the worst and rather here in South Portland they've terrorized families and individuals and the vast majority of whom are lawfully present in pursuing appropriate federal immigration processes. We've all heard that the only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good people to do nothing. We took a pledge of liberty and justice for all. I'd be most proud to say that the community where I've lived for 45 years has the courage to proactively and publicly support and protect the rights and honor the humanity of all who live here. So thank you [1:42:51] Mayor Tipton: again. Thank you very much. Anyone else? I don't see anyone. We're going to close public comment. I think there are questions we need to answer. [1:43:02] Councilor Matthews: So there was a couple of questions about employee training. Will employees be trained on how to report complaints and that they're protected, essentially whistleblower protection from reporting violations? So say absolutely. How employees can report concerns will be part of the training session. And it can be part of this too about a whistleblower protection. So that can be added to it. As of right now, Brandon, feel free to weigh in on this. If a federal enforcement officer stops by a fire department and asked to use a non-public bathroom, I don't think that's considered assisting with an enforcement operation. So it wouldn't be prohibited under this ordinance, but I want to confirm that with you before we go away from that topic. [1:44:02] City Manager (Brandon): Yeah, so in the proposed section 34-3, no city employee shall grant and no city employee has authority to grant ICE or any federal agent permission to use city-owned or city-controlled property as a staging area, processing location, operations base, or similar facility for immigration enforcement or to provide any special enhanced or non-public access to city property for that purpose except where required by applicable law judicial warrant court order so if somebody came in and asked to use the restroom if it's not being used as a staging area processing or any special or enhanced access I think it would be allowed under this [1:44:44] Councilor Matthews: Ordinance, and then there were the questions about complaint processes. So section 34 9 of the ordinance deals with how to file complaints. They'll be handled by the city manager for essentially complaints. We're going to have to get a little bit nuanced when it comes to complaints about if they're city boards or committees, because that's not really a role for the city's myself or the HR office to investigate. Those would probably have to be referred over to the City Council for some sort of reviewer action, so we would have to work on specifics of that. But yes, we can put that on the website. I don't know if it would be a form or at least information of, hey, if you think you've seen a city staff person, here's who you can contact. And I, and I do believe the ordinance already does contemplate reports being made annually saying, hey, this is a aggregate summary, but also as they come in. So yes, this would be reported to the council as they occur. And then there's nothing in here about planning or ordinance amendments for zoning about ICE looking to, I don't know if the question was acquire properties or not. And we haven't really looked in the legal ability to restrict the federal government for from purchasing lots if that was the question but that 's not in the current ordinance okay [1:46:20] Mayor Tipton: I think I did. You hear more questions? Just one. [1:46:24] City Manager (Brandon): From Mr. Shedlock, so we did discuss this at the workshop in terms of third-party contractors, and I think our, there's nothing specific here. This is affecting city employees, city properties, and we did have that conversation about procurement and RFPs and a little bit of an enforceability issue. If after the fact we've granted a contract and they do it, I think it adds a level of complication to this that I wasn't comfortable going down at this point. I'm not sure we can really affect a third-party contractor. There's some limitations to what we would be able to do. [1:47:11] Mayor Tipton: Okay. I think I saw Council Russ had a question. I think I might have a question, but I think we can hold our questions to be part of our council discussion. Does that work for everybody? All right. What is the wish of the council? Yes, [1:47:30] Councilor Pryde: Council Pryde. I move for passage of the version of this ordinance that includes school employees. [1:47:36] Mayor Tipton: All right. Can you be heard, Councilor Pride? I don't know. Does it work? Yeah, it seems [1:47:42] Councilor Pryde: to be working. Okay. Excellent. Does anyone hear me? Yes. I'll say it again. I move for passage of the version of this ordinance that includes school employees. [1:47:51] Mayor Tipton: Thank you. Are you seconding, Councilor West? I'll second. Thank you. Councilor Pride? [1:47:56] Councilor Pryde: I think we had a lot of discussion of this at the last meeting. I do agree with our Corporation Council about third-party vendors. It's difficult because I think they also have some constitutional protections about who they speak to, and the government can't limit that. And so I think that weakens the ordinance to add that we can get to constitutional attack. I think that I appreciate the city managers willingness to share, and I think that's going to be hopefully, you know, for what we know there hasn't been any cooperation thus far, and hopefully that continues. I said last time that no matter what we do with this ordinance, it's not going to stop ICE from rounding up folks, and we want to stop that, and we appreciate those people providing witness. We also want to make sure that there's never a point at which people think that the city is actively protecting ice. So I think it's it's it is because of the situation we're in, I firmly believe it is an emergency, and that we should pass this ordinance. But I do think that a change is warranted. I don't want them using our restrooms. So I move that we amend section 34.3 to change any federal permission to use it as a all right, so change as a staging area processing location operations base or similar facility for immigration enforcement change, delete that and write for any purpose. I'll [1:49:42] Councilor Scott: second that all [1:49:45] Mayor Tipton: right counselors we have a proposed amendment. Any questions on the proposed amendment? All right, well then I think we can vote on the amendment. All in favor, councillor Scott? Yes. So that is a unanimous vote in favor of that amendment. I think I think it was unanimous. Councillor Matthews, sorry again, I'm not used to looking up and down the way here. Yes. Are there any opposed? All right, thank you. That is a unanimous vote for that amendment change. All right, counselor [1:50:27] Councilor Pryde: pride, are you finished with your remarks? Yeah, I mean, I think hopefully those who are curious about more detail for me can look at the video from last time, but I was pretty firmly for this [1:50:40] Councilor Scott: then, so and I remain so. Thank you very much, counselor West. I just said I support it, and I appreciate the work that the staff has done, and they're really good emergency findings too, right? Excellent [1:50:55] Councilor Pryde: Thank You councillor Matthews, so I just want to make sure because this has to be a unanimous vote tonight In order to make this an ordinance We're not voting on we're just voting on Scott has a plan for training correct that we're kind of not going on what he has listed now correct there's going to be tweaks to it so we're we're voting on the ordinance not the training correct okay i just want to make sure [1:51:27] Councilor Matthews: training is required under the ordinance but it doesn't get into you know like the level of specificity like i provided as a as a potential for what we would train on right yes because [1:51:39] Mayor Tipton: at the last meeting we did hear from several members of the community that they wanted to understand that there would be an effective training for the employees the city manager brought forward some proof that there will be and i think that will be from what i understand scott will be able to see more of that online correct thank you all right yes counselor walker [1:52:06] Councilor Walker: for an amendment to amend section 34-9 to add whistle whistleblower protection i'm not quite sure the specific language i'd leave it to our attorney to craft that but i'd like to offer something to the extent of after the paragraph no complainant or witness shall be compelled by the city to disclose their immigration status in the course of such an investigation after that add the language about whistleblower protection and [1:52:37] Mayor Tipton: do you suggestions for the specific language you're asking that from our council brandon let [1:52:46] City Manager (Brandon): me try to i'm hoping you can give me a few i'm hedging just because i don't want to infringe on anything in personnel policies and that's the only hesitation i have but i can try to work up some language that any whistleblower protection shall be applied i think it's under all of our policies here that all city employees and school including the school have whistleblower but let me let me try to craft some stuff before you take a vote and maybe there can be just a few [1:53:16] Mayor Tipton: seconds to let me hold that together we'll tell jokes in the meantime okay other counselors suggestions for amendments discussion etc what counselor scott thank you i just wanted to voice [1:53:33] Councilor Pryde: My support for passing this amendment and making sure that there is an amendment that we can pass this evening, given that election day is on Tuesday. I am not opposed necessarily to specific amendments that are or motions for amendments that are able to be made, but I do want to make sure that we have a clear ordinance that we can move forward with. And I do think that a lot of this relates to other aspects of our personnel policies and HR, including whistleblowers, and I do think that there are those protections, if they are not elsewhere, they need to be elsewhere, and may not be appropriate for a specific ordinance. It should always refer back to, I think, the basic protections that any employee should have at the city or the school board where there are protections needed for whistle blower activities. So again, just want to voice my, you know, support for the ordinance with the with the school department, and I really would like to make sure that this gets on the books this evening so that is my top priority. I will note, Scott, this is a promise not a threat, that I will follow up with you on some of the aspects of this ordinance that are within your purview to make sure that there is a good amount of transparency on the city website for training materials, your reports, and that happens well. And if we need to sort of codify that in some sort of order resolution, I'm happy to pursue that if needed, but I appreciate your work so far in the transparency that you do have, and I will hold you to that and promise to follow up with you as we continue on this journey. Thank you. Thank you [1:55:13] Councilor Walker: very much, Counselor Scott. Counselor Walker, I'm happy to rescind my request for an amendment. I wasn't sure after the prior amendment in terms of specifying Use of buildings if we needed to be as specific as to include whistleblower language in this ordinance, But if this ordinance Calls back to other employee language, employee protection language. I'm happy to rescind [1:55:41] Councilor Scott: Hold that thought [1:55:43] Mayor Tipton: Any more to add to that? [1:55:45] City Manager (Brandon): Just, I think, I think it does, because it 's the complaints are going to be investigated pursuant to alcohol city personnel policies, collective bargaining agreements, and law, and there's the main collective, the main whistleblower protection act, which is under Title 26. It's, I, it's there, it's not explicit, but it's there in my opinion. Yep, and that works [1:56:07] Councilor Walker: For me, I echo Counselor Scott. I want to make sure that we do get this as buttoned up as much as we can and enacted tonight, so I'm happy to receive. Okay, so the amendment is withdrawn that [1:56:21] Mayor Tipton: and we didn't have a second anyway, I don't believe. All right, other counselors. All right, I think we're close to our vote. I would just want to say what I said two weeks ago, which is I feel personally very grateful to residents who cared enough to bring this forward for us, who care deeply about their neighbors, who are watching the situation in Maine and across the country, and are saying that it is important that South Portland do anything and everything that we can to protect the people who live here. And so I am grateful to them, and thank you. And I think we—I hope that we will join our other neighbors, our city neighbors, Portland, Biddeford, Lewiston, Waterville, and I apologize if I've left anyone off the list. I hope South Portland will be an example to other cities. Councillors, all in favor of the ordinance? That is a unanimous vote of the South Portland City Council. Thank you. I am required to tell you that we are not supposed to clap. All right, moving right along. Madam City Clerk, would you please read order 64? I can't read it through my blurry little eyes. Order 64, 26, 27, thank [1:58:01] Madam Clerk: you. Authorizing a condemnation order to be filed in the office of the municipal clerk to condemn an interest in into the property for the Pearl Street pump station force main. Past requires majority vote. I'm [1:58:15] Councilor Matthews: going to ask our water resource protection director, Fred Dillon, to come to the podium and give this a little explanation because I know counselors got some email traffic back and forth on this, and I want to make sure Fred gives a little bit of an explanation. Thank you, manager. [1:58:30] Fred Dillon: The—Fred Dillon, the director of the water resource protection department, just to give a little bit of summary on what we're proposing to do with the force main installation, and I think you all have heard more than you want to about the Pearl Street pump station. We just had a groundbreaking ceremony there a couple of weeks ago, but this piece of it is really critical. It's an important link between the pump station and the wastewater treatment plant, and it traverses the mud flats, and in order to do that, we have an existing force main that we're going to leave in place, and we're going to install two new force mains off to the side of that. And we have to take that section of property in order to install that force main. And in order to do that, we have to do what's called a taking. And through our corporation council, we've tried to establish ownership for that. It's unclear at this point. There's some question about that, and some residents have some idea that there may be some other information that they could bring to us that might prove otherwise, and we're open to seeing that. But suffice to say that this has to happen. We have a critical construction window between mid-November and mid-March due to wildlife habitat protections, and we can't do construction outside that window. So yeah, I mean, if there are any legal questions about the ownership, I'm sorry Brandon, I'll defer to Brandon, but suffice to say that this is a very critical piece and the construction really needs to happen in this window. So and if you have any questions, I'll I'll either answer them or I'll defer to Brandon. [1:59:55] Mayor Tipton: Thanks, Fred. Thank you Brandon, did you want to give us some information or not yet? [2:00:02] City Manager (Brandon): I think there's been quite a bit of information provided in your in your packet. There was the title folks in my office did quite an extensive search. The mud flats are murky at best. Some of it's been filled in, some of it's been changed over the last 120, 150 years. So what's being proposed tonight is a taking of unknown ownership. What that means though is we're not clouding anyone's title, we're not alleging. If somebody comes forward and says we've taken something, they can come forward and certainly grant us an easement if we need, and we can we can address that. Sabego Techniques was also involved in helping create the meets and bounds that was created, and the opinion letter from my office as well is very specific to one notation that we found for a property and is not about the entire length of the easement. And the only other clarification that I want to point out is we're actually doing two things. We're taking a permanent easement for the force main, but we're also taking a temporary construction easement to install the force main, which will expire once that is complete. And like I said, it was it's there's very unique situation, and it would have been great if it was a little bit more cut and dry so we could have gone not gone to the folks, but there's no reference to the water in any of these. [2:01:45] Mayor Tipton: Deeds that we looked at, all right. Thank you very much, counselors. Do you have questions? I don't see questions. Public comment on this item, order 64, is open. Anyone for public comment? [2:02:05] Rosemary DeAngelis: Thank you, Rosemary D'Angelis, Pleasant Deal. I have to laugh when Brandon says the mudflats are murky because they are in fact very murky. And so I am one of two property owners along that area. And my deed does say to the high water mark, and we're in my, and my neighbor who is far more knowledgeable about this and he's done a lot more work and he's at a dental conference so he can't be here, so this is up to me, but we're not, we're not trying to make this any more difficult than it is, and I think as attorney, as Attorney Mazur has said, I'm happy to provide my deed as he is with his. We understand this is taking a permanent easement and a temporary easement. If we share something else that puts this in question, this just kind of threw us off. The biggest thing I guess that I would want to say is that there wasn't any communication with us as property owners, and that I think is really a shortfall of the city. I mean, we're only two property owners who come along that side of the water, and we, I mean, we only knew about this because we saw it on the agenda, and then Jeff Wallowender who's my neighbor started to do more research about it. So my point to the city is just that communicating with people and keeping them in the loop and having them be part of the process would be really preferential, and if there's further information that we need to provide, we're happy to do that. But thank you. [2:04:10] Mayor Tipton: Anyone else on this item? Item. If there's really only two of you, I guess probably not. All right, public comment is closed on this item. What is the wish of the council? Hello? Are we moving for passage, Councillor Pryde? Second. Seconded by Councillor Matthews. Councillor Pryde? [2:04:33] Councilor Pryde: Just a question for Corporation Council Mazer before I, do support this, but I hear what the residents are saying, and it's in my district. If their deed does refer to the ocean or the high-water mark, would that give them certain rights under this? Would they have a right to just compensation? What are, what is the impact of that, and do we need to make a change now if that's correct? I don't think there would need [2:05:01] City Manager (Brandon): To be any change now, they would be, would need to get appraisal and have just compensation for the, for the taking. The thing with those two properties is that it wasn't actually, I don't think they're actually implicated either in the actual area that's being contemplated with the review of the parcels that both my office and Sebago Technics, there were a handful of parcels that we were looking at very old deeds and I'm trying to remember the name of the heirs of whoever the subdivision, the old subdivision that Miss D'Angelis and her neighbor are part of was not even contemplated as part of the review area. So I'm, it would need further, this came in I think 6 30 Friday night and we scramble at my office to do our best. So if there's, I think as Water Resources said and my office said, if there's more there we can review it and re, reconsider, but they weren't really even contemplated as part of our discussion with Tobago Techniques. And then [2:06:07] Councilor Pryde: I just a follow-up where we are declaring in the order that the city has conducted a thorough search and has determined that there are no known owners of record that can reasonably be determined. If that phrase were just eliminated from this order so that we can move on and do more research, because if we're making that determination now and then we reverse course, I mean, I guess the, my question is, are there implications to making that determination now and then reversing course, or are there implications to us removing that from this order? I don't think you can remove it [2:06:43] City Manager (Brandon): from the order. The only thing for a taking that can be amended is the compensation line, the amount. You can increase that, which to be fair we put as that number, but I believe, and I'll look it up, I believe the statute only allows the order to be amended on that. One's a very specific thing. So we could always bring it back. I think I 'll have to look to see if we can bring it back without having to do the re-noticing of it all, but I talked to my, cannot remove that line from the order. I believe I believe the statute limits any edits to the order to only while [2:07:42] Mayor Tipton: you're checking, do you mind if I ask Counselor Matthews, who was our second, if you have comments? I yield my time to Counselor, where she has a question. Well, and also Counselor Walker's been wanting to ask a question too. I think Counselor Walker had her hand up first, so hang on, Counselor Walker [2:07:59] Councilor Walker: Can you just clarify, so it looks like from the memo that we're talking about, it says council advises treating the title flats north of lot 9 on the Hathaway plan, blah, below its high water mark as unknown or uncertain ownership. And I believe the property owner was talking about [2:08:17] City Manager (Brandon): how her deed goes to the high water mark is are we so again that memo is very specific parcel that was discovered by a reference in a deed it's not about all of the parcels none of that reference that is in that memo is in anybody else's deed that we looked at i may not be answering your question directly but i just want to clarify that memo that was provided to sabego technics is very narrow and it's not a pie it's not a title opinion on anybody else's title or rights it's very specific to that one parcel that had a little bit of an odd reference in it that Sebago Technics and our title folks felt like they needed to clarify for the record, so [2:09:03] Councilor Walker: asked answer the over kind of overarching question about what's the difference between property that goes to the high watermark and property that is below the high watermark because the title flats it looked like from the main statue information that was in there was referencing the [2:09:19] City Manager (Brandon): low the low tide line yeah so under so there's a what's known as the main colonial ordinance of 1641 47 so an upland owner whose land abuts tidal water presumptively owns the flats to the low water subject to the public's fishing fouling navigation easement but the state law court has made clear that a grantee gets that presumption only where the grant expressly calls out the water whether it's through ocean sea cove river and a description bounded at a landward monument or by the shore it does not reach the flats based on our research. So we did not look at Missy Angeles, we did go back and review, and I'm gonna butcher his name, Wallowender, his property, and the land that he, his deed is bounded by land references, not the shore, so the presumption of ownership of the flats doesn't apply here. [2:10:23] Councilor Pryde: So the reference to water at all is what's significant. That's what implies the flats. [2:10:31] City Manager (Brandon): And then there's, as we mentioned, as we're going through the history, some of this, there are streams that no longer exist that were referenced. We tried to do historical maps just in terms of the old original deeds. It looks like these heirs gave out the land but never anything to do with the flats. There was some state land way back in the day from the war. So again I'm gonna use the word murky. It was a interesting project which I don't think Fred or Lacy expected when they reached out [2:11:05] Councilor Pryde: for this. And let me just, and just so, just to clarify, you basically, you don't believe that actually the season goes over Miss D'Angelis's property, is that, is that what you're saying? [2:11:18] City Manager (Brandon): I don't believe so. Okay, but again we can, we can do a deeper dive. And yeah, my one concern is that [2:11:26] Councilor Pryde: that I trust that 's probably true, but we're gonna pass an ordinance saying this doesn't implicate any property owner or an order rather. And then, if we have to reverse that, if we can, that would be fine. I don't mind correcting things that are wrong if we have a reasonable degree of confidence that we're right this time. But the question is, can we correct that or what kind of implications does that have beyond what we're doing here? I doubt it has too many implications because we can't really declare other people's property rights per se as a council. So I, you know, I'm getting more comfortable with going ahead and passing this. [2:12:10] Mayor Tipton: All right, councillor West. Thank you [2:12:12] Councilor Scott: I'm getting more comfortable with passing it because I'm looking at Google Maps and I just want to say this comes up periodically. That if the staff could provide a map, a visual of what they're doing, it will solve a lot of problems. If you look at Google Maps and you see where our Pearl Street pump station is, you see where our station is, our treatment station is, and if the pipes are going to go straight, they're not going to go anywhere near the high water mark of Ms. DeAngelis property. So I think that could have solved the, would it, could have saved some problems. And I just want to ask again as I've asked before for maps are a tremendous help to the council and to the community. So please staff, when you give us something that where a visual would help, include a visual. [2:13:00] Mayor Tipton: Thank you, Councilor West. Any other councilors? We have a motion on the table. We're getting close to voting unless any other councilors have comments, questions. All right, we're good, ready to vote. [2:13:16] Speaker B (unidentified): Are we ready to vote?
New Business
[2:13:18] Mayor Tipton: I think we are all in favor. All right, that is a unanimous vote of the council. Thank you very much. I have been advised by our city manager that the staff members who are involved with item 3 of public hearings in action and item 2 on action and old new and new business and for any of you who missed it where we already decided we're not doing action or item 1 under action on old and new business that the staff members are planning to stay through the end of this meeting and that if we wish to we could vote to move our workshop discussion to now. Does anyone want to make a motion to do that? All right, I'm it's we're not saying we're tabling these items, we're saying we're changing the order of how they will be discussed. All right, I don't see anyone jumping at that opportunity so I would ask that the clerk move us to ordinance number seven and oops I was going to do the same thing she's doing [2:14:33] Madam Clerk: I'll wait ordinance number seven please. Sure ordinance number 7 26 27 amending chapter 27 zoning regarding a zoning text amendment to amend building coverage allowance in the light industrial zoning district 200 John Roberts Road first reading passed on October 13th 2026 passed requires five affirmative votes and this will be a roll call vote. Thank you very much [2:14:59] Councilor Matthews: As a reminder, this was a request from Elevate Sciences to change the building coverage allowance from 30% to 40%. As the clerk noted, you approved a first reading of this, so it's now in order for a second final approval and will become effective in 20 days per the charter if council [2:15:18] Mayor Tipton: approves it tonight. Questions, counselors? I don't see any. This item is open for public comment? Do we have public comment on this item? I don't see any. Public comment is closed. Councillors? Move for passage. Thank you, Councillor Matthews. Second, Councillor [2:15:39] Councilor Pryde: Pride. Councillor Matthews? No, all good. We went over this and again, we have [2:15:45] Councilor Scott: already done the first passage. Thank you. Councillor Pride? Ditto. [2:15:52] Mayor Tipton: Thank you. Any other councillors with comments? I will just say that the owners of this business do operate their business in District 5. I've been in touch with them. They appreciate the council taking action. And that's all I have to say. Councillors, all in favor? Oh, it's a roll call. All right, well, do we need to wait for Councillor West to return then? Or do we just need to be very slow? Let's try going slow. [2:16:23] Madam Clerk: As you get five, you're good. Yeah. Counselor Scott? Yes. Counselor Walker? Yes. Counselor Coleman? Yes. Counselor Matthews? Yes, ma'am. Counselor Pride? Yes. Counselor West? [2:16:40] Mayor Tipton: Mayor Tipton? Yes. So that means six. So let's say that the ordinance has passed. Thank you. Okay, we're now on action on old and new business, item number two, ordinance number nine. Could you [2:16:57] Madam Clerk: please read that? Thank you. Ordinance number nine, 2627, amending chapter 27, zoning, regarding a zone map amendment to extend the limited business zoning district. First reading passed, requires [2:17:09] Councilor Matthews: majority vote. So counselors, this was a request for a workshop request from counselor Scott that was council agreed to move directly to a first reading. It would extend the LB Limited Business Owning District on the south side of Cottage Road from Edgewood Road all the way to the Cape Elizabethtown line, and it converts 11 properties from the Residential A District to the LB District in the process. Planning Board has recommended approval of the amendments, and I'm gonna turn it over to the Planning Director, Melinda Vida, for a few comments. If you have something to show, I'm going to have to unfold myself. Do you have to show something? [2:17:50] Milan Navida: I don't. Milan invited the planning director. This was an exhibit that's available in your packets. It's just the map so we'd have a visual of the area that we're talking about. The one thing I do have here, but I can just speak to it, is this is amending the zoning map that exists today to bring that LB zone down Cottage to the Cape line on the south side, affecting the properties on the south side of the street, not the north side. And the only thing that's related to that here is that the south side really has more of mixed-use commercial development, and that's why we continued it along the south side. The north side has predominantly single-family homes, whereas the south side has some two families, three families, and then, again, commercial developments. We also took a look at Cape Elizabeth, and again, it continues that pattern. I think you're all probably familiar or personally with the area, so I don't think we need to belabor it here, but we see a consistency with what's there and consistency with the comp plan policies. You have those in the memo. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have about it. Yeah. [2:18:57] Mayor Tipton: Counselors, questions? Counselor? [2:18:59] Councilor Pryde: Scott, thank you. Surprise one, I think it would be very helpful if you could very succinctly clarify why this is coming forward as a zoning change and a map amendment as opposed to being able to single out a specific property for a change of land use. I think it'd be [2:19:18] Milan Navida: very helpful to clarify that. Sure, so under state law we have what's recognized as spot zoning, and the whole premise of spot zone zoning is that we wouldn't give one individual property owner more rights to their property or fewer rights would be punitive to a property owner compared to their neighbors when the plan for the city, which is our comprehensive plan, has a guide for what should be happening there, and either one person gets to benefit from it or one person doesn't get to benefit from that policy. So in order to prevent spot zoning, we have to try and achieve a holistic plan for the way that land is used in the area, and the guide again is the comprehensive plan, and the comprehensive plan here says that the corridor is intended to be mixed-use and allow a little bit more even residential activity if that was the case than the surrounding area. So we could not just single out one property and sort of hopscotch and cherry pick because then we're really making decisions based on individuals and not based on how land should be used and how to plan for a community, not plan for an individual, which is what zoning is supposed to do. So that's why we took this approach. I'll emphasize again, this is an interim ordinance approach, if you if you will. It is consistent, we think, with the comprehensive plan, but it's not fully implementing all of the policies of the comprehensive plan. We're going to be taking a closer look at this. I shared with you that two year work plan, so we will be coming back to this area as an example in the planning board discussion. Some of the planning board members recognize that there's aspects of the LB zone which we may want to tinker with and adjust in this area, and we will be doing that, but the LB zone still is compatible with the comprehensive plan policy guidance. So we'll be back to this area, but what we're putting on the table right now is still consistent, and I think it's really important in zoning we talk about policies of what people can do but you have to also think about what the physical context is these are very small parcels so there was some concern for instance about LB allows more commercial type activity so we're gonna have a proliferation of heavy-duty strip malls and commercial activity tons of traffic it's just not physically possible with the properties here that are affected we're talking about less than a dozen properties and most of them are under 13 000 square feet so they can't really carry that kind of land use impact, and it's not a large area that we're rezoning. So all those things considered, we think there's consistency here, and it achieves the goal but also maintains more of a balanced holistic approach to how we zone the area, counselor [2:22:00] Councilor Pryde: Scott, could you also, as reading in your memo, you have a very clear list of potential activities in the LB zone, and I understand as part of the comprehensive plan those activities may be reviewed. I was reading those trying to square that list with the more extensive table and explanation in chapter 27 of our of our ordinances on zoning. Could you briefly describe how there are certain restrictions on those uses and clarifications on those uses? It is not sort of a blanket it list of uses that are automatically permitted, but some have sort of special exceptions if you [2:22:38] Milan Navida: could just totally explain that concept briefly? Yes, so the zoning ordinance has bulk and space standards, things people are familiar with, like how tall buildings can be in setbacks, all everybody has to physically conform to those restrictions, so no one gets to just, you know, put a commercial business right next to someone else's property line as an example. And then there's also things called performance standards that apply to some of these businesses where we can anticipate that there may be impacts on neighbors. The obvious one on this list is the shelter ordinance, which the council took a lot of time with to carefully craft, so we developed very specific and heavy duty standards on how shelters could operate in the LV district. It makes it virtually impossible for them to exist in these particular properties, again, because they're small and all the things that would be involved in setting up something like that. Every one of the businesses would have to respond to traffic, parking, noise, nuisances generally, stormwater impacts, and land use in general. So things like paving the entire property and then sending all your runoff to the neighbors so their basement floods, that's not gonna happen. And everyone has to demonstrate that clearly. If they propose anything more than 1,000 feet of construction, it goes to the planning board and gets vetted at a public hearing. Otherwise it's a smaller scale review and staff level review, so the those standards apply across the board. And then you mentioned permitted or special exception uses, some of these uses may also be classified as special exception, which just means we also have to evaluate if that particular use on that property compared to other properties also in that zone is somehow inappropriate. You can think of an example where we have a highly sensitive resource and a particular land use that very clearly would impact that resource. Okay, you can do it in the zone but not this particular property, it's circumstantial to that lot. So there's also those protections as well. Thank you very much. Thank you. Other counselors with [2:24:37] Mayor Tipton: questions? All right, this I think, yeah, I didn't do it, sorry, I totally lost it for a second. Okay, hello. Public comment is open on this item. I [2:25:00] Ann Mello: am Ann Mello. I live on [street] in Portland. Thanks for keeping this on the agenda tonight. My sister and I are interested in potentially opening a coffee shop on 535 Cottage Road. That space, as far as we know, has been retail for a long time. We really want to kind of create like a community place where people can go walk in the morning, meet their friend, read the paper, have their book club. We did spend Saturday and Sunday door knocking on Cottage Road, Woodbury, and Woodlawn, so the surrounding streets. Obviously not everyone was home, but we met with 10 people and had honestly 10 really great conversations. Only one person, I would say, had some concerns and questions, but I think hopefully we eased them a little bit, and that was the next door neighbor, the rest on Woodbury and Woodlawn and Cottage Road, all were really excited, honestly, at the potential possibility of having a coffee shop they could walk to. We didn't know what we were going to expect when we were door knocking in October, but it was honestly like very positive and a good response. We don't want to open something that neighbors don't want, so we were excited by that response overall. And again, appreciate you guys keeping it on the agenda tonight. Thanks. Thank you very much. Hi. [2:26:22] Georgia Daveris: I did bring a map, but my printer broke. If you could pass it along, I circled the good evening. My name is Georgia Daveris, and I live on [street], a stone's throw from this new zone. I only found out about this planned zoning change while reading tonight's agenda on the important issues of protecting city residents from ice and protecting our health from dangerous tank emissions. The current limited business zone along Cottage Road, heading east, ends at the Rattleshake Grill. At this border, the zone becomes a residential A zone until the Cape Elizabeth town line. In between Rattleshake Grill and the Cape line are about a dozen modest-sized properties, mostly single-family homes and two or three two-family homes. Across Cottage Road from this proposed zone are all single-family homes, with the exception of a church. This section of Cottage Road is narrow enough that even in a small car, you can't open a car door if you've parked along the edge if there is an oncoming car. The door would be sheared off. Referring to this section of Cottage Road as a major corridor is a stretch. There is a building at the end of tonight's new proposed business zone that sits half in South Portland and half in Cape Elizabeth. Rosemont Market is its immediate neighbor. This zone change request, as it has been explained to me, is to fulfill a desire to sell coffee from this building, half of which is in South Portland in a residential zone, half in Cape Elizabeth in a small business zone. It's a tiny neighborhood, mixed-use area, and with the exception of the half a building that wants to serve coffee, it's in Cape Elizabeth. I have no issue with a small coffee shop moving into the neighborhood, but I do have a problem them with rezoning a dozen additional properties when main state law has an appropriate and proportional remedy rather than rezoning the entire residential section of cottage road to standard limited business as proposed. The city council can instead institute a conditional or contract rezoning under main state law 30-a mrs 43528. In other words, you can rezone the south portland half of the building to be in sync with the cape elizabeth side. Both sides of the building would then allow for a coffee shop without rezoning an additional dozen properties on a street that is currently a parking and exiting your vehicle challenge. I am asking you to reconsider the zone change and amend it to include only the half building. 30 seconds that precipitated this request. I'd be happy to walk to a coffee shop a few blocks from my home. I'm not against growth or progress or change. A coffee shop That is an organic response to the desires of the community that which fits seamlessly into the tiny business district Across the Cape line is growth that I would welcome. The impact of rezoning half a building far outweighs the reasons and potential consequences of inviting through zoning a Dozen residential homes to be turned into who knows what. Please reconsider and amend this ordinance. Thank you [2:29:32] Mayor Tipton: Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else with comment on this? I don't see any. We're closing public comment. Counselors, what [2:29:46] Councilor Scott: are you thinking? Counselor? I'm going to go ahead and let Counselor Scott and I'll second it. Go ahead. Counselor Scott, you're moving for passage, [2:29:53] Mayor Tipton: seconded by Counselor Matthews. Second. Thank you. Counselor Scott. Thank you. Very much [2:29:58] Councilor Pryde: appreciate the comments and the work. I also spoke with several residents in this area and I think there were some reservations some neutrality and some positivity around this. Obviously you know some concerns the way you know this is my district and have had some great conversations with lauren and ann mellow and others. I think looking back to the a comprehensive plan from 2012. Was it 2012 or 15 that we passed? This corridor and building out some of these corridors in our city for mixed use and additional both business and housing opportunities was part of that plan and that goal. It was sort of re-discussed in the current comprehensive plan, and the kind of goal of these areas being additional mixed use and housing is sort of continued in that current plan. The ridge of the 2012 plan actually has a much sort of larger corridor, basically from the intersection of Broadway and Cottage out to the Cape Elizabeth line. So I think that this is sort of in spirit of the comprehensive plan. We have an opportunity to build additional businesses here in South Portland, and I think that this is all in the nature of building additional business opportunities, growing our business valuation, and building additional housing opportunities. This is not taking homes away. This is allowing for more valuation and more businesses to be built in some of these corridors. I love being able to walk to a restaurant, you know, maybe not a gas station, but a convenience store at a gas station, and I think that's what a lot of the residents that I spoke with were really excited about, sort of more opportunities to walk, to converse, to commune. And my hope would be that as we continue to build out these corridors in this mixed use development, we do address things like pedestrian crossings, traffic issues, parking, etc. But most of the residents that I talked to had no issues with parking. They were actually upset that they couldn't park on half their street and didn't feel that it was an issue. So I think these are all things that we can discuss and work on as a community, and I think we need to make sure that we are building the kind of valuation and opportunities across our city which will ultimately help lower our tax burden on single-family homes, especially in my district, who complain about that every day. So thank you [2:32:28] Councilor Scott: very much. Thank you, Councillor Scott. Councillor Matthews. Thank you. First of all, sorry to take [2:32:34] Councilor Pryde: away your bubble but anybody that knows me knows coffee's my thing I got excited I heard that word and my hand went up so but i want to say thank you to you for taking the lead on this and really bringing this to us i think it's exciting to be able to bring this to south portland cape elizabeth and i think it's a great opportunity for both of you are you guys twins or just sisters good twins okay good so i think i think it's great and i understand the explanation that counselor scott has given and as far as allowing more opportunity for walk-through businesses in the area so i definitely support this and i look forward to being a patron thank you counselor matthews other [2:33:32] Mayor Tipton: Other counselors with comments. All right. Yeah, I don't think I have a comment. Thoughts, but not a comment. All right, on this first read vote, first read all in favor. Thank you, that's a unanimous first read vote of the council. All right, that brings us to our workshop discussion. I'm going to take a quick little break myself and I'm gonna ask counselor Matthews if he would sit in the seat for me and give a break everybody's got to go well all right then maybe we do need a floor break okay 39 let's all be back in our seats by 44 thank you gosh I said 44 and then I broke my own rule. All right, we've reached our workshop discussion and I are we going straight to the [2:41:42] Speaker B (unidentified): DEP or do you want to preface it a little bit Scott? I have the very briefest of preface. [2:41:46] Councilor Matthews: Council, as you know, the city has been working with Maine DEP and to some extent CDC since 2019 in response to long-standing community concerns about odors and air emissions, and in particular as they relate to emissions from petroleum tank facilities. And please tonight that we have presentations from both the EP and CDC on the kind of final analysis of the six years worth of monitoring from different air monitoring locations throughout the city that have evolved a bit over time in some cases as well as a presentation on data from the first year plus of the fence line monitoring. And so both CDC and DEP are gonna be talking about those topics. And then we're gonna talk about next steps and ultimately seek guidance from council as to those next steps. So our first presenter is Thomas Simmons. He is the acting state toxicologist for the Maine CDC. And I'll turn it over to him. And after that, we'll have a presentation from Maine DEP's Director of Air Quality Assessment, Stacey Knapp. [2:43:06] Mayor Tipton: Thank you, and thank you. [2:43:10] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): Wonderful. Thank you for having me, and good evening, city councillors, and thank you for the introduction, Scott. And just again, my name is Tom Simmons. I'm the acting state toxicologist for the Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention. I've been with the Maine CDC as toxicologist since 2013. I also have with me tonight our staff toxicologist who's a lead on a lot of the data analysis that you'll see and figures generated tonight. Thank you. So Scott gave a nice overview of the talks this evening. I will be giving an overview of our health assessment of the volatile organic compound, or VOC, and six years' worth of monitoring data for that, followed by Stacey Knapp at DEP. They'll talk about next steps on naphthalene levels, measuring naphthalene, and then a summary of the fence line monitoring results. A little bit of background, as Scott alluded to, The study began in response to community concerns about odors in the area as well as releases from the petroleum storage facilities. In 2019, Maine DEP initiated a community ambient air study, and that was set up to collect 24-hour ambient air samples every six days at multiple stations across South Portland and Portland. Portland, and those are canisters that pull in a volume of air over 24 hours. Those canisters are collected by DEP staff, they go back up to DEP's lab, they measure for 47 individual volatile organic compounds, or VOCs, they QC that data, they put all of that data on the website, and then they also provide that data to us staff at Maine CDC. CDC. We look at that data, compare it to health-based guidelines, see if there's any issues, higher levels to note, and then we've written reports on health assessments in 2020, 2023, and now [2:45:27] Mayor Tipton: in 2026. May I just ask one quick question? Are these slides also available to the public on your website? [2:45:37] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): They are not right now, but they will be after the presentation. Okay. Thank you so much. I believe the previous presentations we have given our, the slides are available. For the locations of the monitoring sites, this is a map of the South Portland, area. The black dots with the black labels are the current locations for the active monitor stations in both Portland and South Portland. The gray dots with gray labels are the previous stations or offline stations now. and the shaded polygons that you see here are the outlines for the petroleum storage facilities in addition to Rigby Yard Railway, the kind of the green long polygon towards the bottom of this figure here. And the initial design of this study was to place monitors at each of the five voting districts within South Portland. Over time, due to input from the Clean Air Advisory Committee as well as the community input and City Council, stations have been moved closer to petroleum storage facilities as well as needing to move for construction and access and issues here. And then shown on the map, or other, the small squares, and mostly in the Portland area, some in the South Portland area, are other VOCs licensed facilities that can emit some VOCs into the area. This is a figure showing how long the each monitoring station has been online. The black bars here are again the current active monitor stations that are collecting the 24-hour samples. The gray bars are the offline or historic stations here. The top three, Portland Ocean Gateway, West commercial street, Deering Oaks, are all Portland stations. The remaining stations are in South Portland here. And over time, what we like to see when we think about exposures, population exposures, longer term exposures, is the longer a station is online, the more data we have, the more confidence we have that we're capturing, you know, ups and downs, highs and lows over that longer period of time, year-to-year variation. So some of these stations have been online for six plus years now, and others like central receivings just under a year and a half of data. And also something to note here as I go through the presentation, we'll compare stations across stations. It's important to note that when you're looking across stations, you want to think about same time periods or equivalent time periods. Not all the stations collected over the same time period, although we do see overlap for some of these black bars and gray bars. So we can think about it that way. And now I want to take a few minutes and just talk about our health assessment. And here we're breaking this down into a short-term exposure health assessment and a long-term exposure health assessment. For the short-term exposure health assessment. This considers a 1 to 14 day exposure time, and this uses health-based guidelines called acute minimal risk levels. These are guidelines that are developed by the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, which is part of the federal CDC, and they're designed specifically, or developed specifically, from acute exposure studies. So these are studies of shorter-term exposures to much higher levels either in animals or human worker exposure populations where there's a much higher level for a shorter period of time. That can be you know six hours a day for six days. Looking at that data then you can extrapolate out for my you know 24 hour exposure and the acute MRLs are all non-cancer based and they're designed to meet or really be at levels where we'd expect minimal or no appreciable health risk. So they're fairly conservative in that sense. And if you're above an MRL for a chemical or VOC, it doesn't mean that there'll be an immediate health risk. What it does mean is we need to think harder about that exposure and ways to reduce that potential exposure. For long-term health assessment or long-term exposure health assessment, we're interested in exposures or we're focused on exposures that are greater than a year. So now we're talking about average exposures all of these 24-hour samples averaging then over time to give us a longer term exposure estimate. Here we're using health guidelines called the ambient air guidelines which are developed using EPA methodology and EPA calculator. The AAGs can be both cancer and non-cancer based. If a chemical or VOC has both a non-cancer and cancer endpoint, the lower of those two values is used and set as the AAG. And these are designed to be representative or protective of exposures that occur for 24 hours a day, seven days a week, for 70 years. And for cancer estimates they're set at one in 100,000 additional cancer risk. So what that means, if you have a population of 100,000 exposed for 70 years to a constant concentration, 24 hours a day, seven days a week, one of those persons would likely have a cancer associated with that exposure. So that's what we talk about when we say one in 100,000 cancer risk for the AAGs, where we have a cancer-based values. Where we don't have a cancer-based value, It's a non-cancer based value similar to the MRL. If you're above that, we don't expect to see a health effect, a non-cancer health effect. Again, what it does mean is we need to think through that exposure and ways to reduce that exposure. And then one way to look at the impact of multiple chemicals is to look at chemicals that have a cancer-based toxicity value and actually sum up their risks. So we call that a cumulative cancer risk, and that's a way for us to see not only the individual cancer causing chemicals but the impact of all of those chemicals that you may be exposed to. So I'll talk about that towards the end of the presentation. Jumping right into the short-term exposure health assessment, this is an example figure for benzene, and here I'm showing the benzene concentration on the horizontal axis, and each one of these dots is kind of hard to see all of them as they're squished in here, but our individual 24-hour sample results for all of the stations in Portland and South Portland for benzene, and we're comparing it to the acute MRL, that short-term health-based guideline of 9 ppb, and what we can see is all of the individual values for the acute MRL are below or sorry for the 24 samples are below the acute MRL. So from this point of view, we're not concerned about short-term exposures, acute exposures from that one to 14-day window for any concentration of benzene measured at any station over this period of time. We do know there are multiple VOCs that have MRLs associated with them. To be able to do this quickly and look at it all in one figure and do an assessment, what we do is calculate a ratio, a concentration to acute MRL ratio. This is just the concentration that's measured in that 24-hour sample, again those individual 24-hour samples, divided by the acute MRL. That gives us a ratio, and here I'm showing this for benzene. The ratio of one would mean that it meets or is at the same concentration as the MRL. If you're below one, that's lower than the MRL. If it's above 1, that's higher than the MRL. And this is a figure showing for those VOCs that have acute minimal risk levels, those ratios that I just talked about, pointing to this line here of 1 to the right side here. If you're above that, means the concentration in that 24-hour sample is above that MRL. Below 1, it would be below that. And we can see here that although we do see some detections, some measurable levels of acrolein, benzene, some chloroform, tetrachloroethylene, all of these levels are below their acute MRLs. And this is showing all of the, I think it's roughly now 2,770 individual samples are actually shown on this figure. It's hard to see with all of the overlap between all of the stations in both South Portland and Portland. But a takeaway here year is no 24-hour monitoring result was above a short-term health guideline over the six-year sampling period. Whether it was close to a fence line or further away, we didn't see any impacts that we would be concerned of for shorter-term exposures. Switching to longer-term exposures and our long-term health assessment, moving away from the individual 24-hour samples I had mentioned previously we want to look at the average exposure here and really what we're interested in is taking all of the individual 24-hour samples. So this is an example for benzene levels at Mechanic Street. Each one of these circles here is the individual 24-hour sample, and then this box up here is the average of all of those samples over the time that this station has been collecting samples. And we see generally the range of concentrations for the 24-hour samples are from about 0.02 all the way up to 0.9. Most of the samples are falling in within the range of 0.1 to 0.3. And that's where we find the average of about 0.2 ppb for benzene at Mechanic Street. So this is what we would look at and compare to the ambient be an error guidelines which are designed to be longer term exposure metrics. These lines next to the box are the 95th percent confidence intervals. The longer those lines extend from the box that means there's more variability in all of those 24 hour individual measurements and we would have less certainty that we're capturing the measurements with that average. The shorter the line the closer to the box that means the more we have or the more confidence we have in that average. And just to mention the first couple figures I'm going to show without the lines and just look at the average concentrations at each individual station in South Portland and Portland. Similar to the short-term health assessment, we can look at the individual concentrations of the chemical. This is showing benzene. Here are the average concentrations over the time that the station's been collecting samples, and you can see here that all but one station have average levels, long-term average levels below the benzene AAG set at 0.4 part per billion. There is one station, Pearl Street, which is on the fence line of a petroleum storage facility, that does have a concentration that is above the current AAG. Again, similar to the short-term health assessment, we know there are multiple chemicals with AAGs and they've been measured. And one way to look at that is to do a ratio. So again, this is just the concentration, the long-term average concentration divided by the AAG to give us a ratio. And this is all of the chemicals that are measured in the samples, the long-term averages at each station minus acrolein. I'll talk about that in a minute. It. But we can see here that really what jumps out at us is benzene has the highest levels and that we only have one station that has a concentration or ratio in this case that's above the AAG. And I'll note here these, it's kind of hard to see in this figure, trying to squish a lot of chemicals in, but this asterisk next to the VOCs listed here are VOCs that have cancer-based toxicity values. Some of those that are measured at higher levels are 1,3-butadiene, carbon tetrachloride, chloroform, ethylbenzene. Those we can look at from a cumulative cancer risk estimate, which I'll talk about here in a minute. What I mentioned for acrolein as a separate figure, so we've actually seen much higher levels compared to the AAG. So this is the ratio figure for acrolein. And you can see they're much higher than one in all stations, both in South Portland and Portland, ranging from 10 to greater than 22 for a ratio there. So at each station, the levels are above the AAG for acrolein. And that, at a high level, is what we focus on in the report, and our findings are for a long-term exposure health assessment. There were two VOCs that were above the AAGs. Acralyn was above the AAG at all monitoring stations, and then Benzene was above the AAG at one monitoring station, Pearl Street on the fence line. So I just want to spend a few minutes talking about each of these in a little bit more detail, tail, and then go through some figures on their averages by station and compare them to statewide averages here. For acrolein, sources include burning fossil fuels, smoke from fires and tobacco, indoor air can be higher if there's cooking fats in oils at higher temperature. We know from studies in rodents that short-term exposure to acrolein can cause nose and throat irritation also in humans from occupational exposure. Long-term exposure to lower levels can increase nasal lesions in studies in laboratory rats. Again, I want to point out that the toxicity values that are developed based on the short-term and long-term exposures are designed to be protective, so at those toxicity values, at the acute MRLs or the long-term AAGs, we don't expect there to be health effects right at those levels. And this is a figure showing the average concentration in the circles here and other stations in the state. So DEP has a hazardous air pollutant monitoring program that they've been running in addition to this study. Those include other stations in the state in Rumford, Press Isle, Lewiston and Bangor. Those are shown at the top here in these brown circles. These are the crowling measurements over the six-year period that those stations have been running and they've been running for a longer time than this but just comparing the six-year period to the study here in South Portland. If we look down looking at the Portland stations and they're similar to the average levels for crowling ranging from about 0.1 to 0.15 in the statewide stations. So not much of a difference here in Portland. Similar in most of the South Portland stations the averages range from about 0.1 to a little over 0.15 and with the exception of Red Bank just under 0.2 and then Pearl Street which is on the fence line of a petroleum storage facility actually had the lowest average accroling level here. And our takeaway is even though all of the stations are above AAG, at least for accroling, it doesn't seem to be an issue that's isolated to South Portland or Portland. It seems to be a statewide issue for higher levels of accroling. I'll also mention that these levels are similar to nationwide levels. This isn't a Maine-only problem. Unfortunately, you know, these concentrations of acrolein are worth investigation, but it's not a South Portland-specific issue from what we're finding. Switching over to benzene, its sources can include gasoline up to 1% by volume, and it can also be found in vehicle exhaust, burning wood, gas stoves, in a large portion of cigarette smoke. Short-term exposure to benzene can cause an increased risk in effects to white blood cells and impact the immune system. Long-term exposure we know can increase the risk of certain types of cancer. It is a known human carcinogen primarily for cancers of the blood and it impacts cells in the bone marrow. And this is a figure similar to the acrolein for the long-term averages at the statewide stations as well as the stations in Portland and South Portland. Concentration here on the horizontal axis, the AAG at 0.4, and similar to the ratio figures that I've shown here, there's only one station that has a benzene level, average benzene level above the AAG, that's at Pearl Street on the fence line. Looking at the Portland stations, they're similar to the statewide stations in this 0.1 to 0.2 range. Stepping into South Portland, setting Pearl Street aside, we see long-term benzene average concentrations range anywhere from about 0.15 to just under 0.13. Slightly higher than what we see statewide, but not dramatically, and everything's below the AAG here. So I want to point out, at least from a risk assessment perspective, these data, based on these data, for the most part, the general population of South Portland and Portland, we don't have any concerns about long-term exposure to benzene here, given that it's below the AAG. Where we do have some concern is the concentrations at the fence line at Pearl Street are above the AAG and we know there are homes that are very close to the fence line. We think it's worth an area of investigation of what the levels are once you start to step away from the fence line but you're still in very close proximity to the fence line. We don't have data to really look out and assess that risk. We do have some indication that stations that are within 500 feet of the fence line, so Mechanic Street, Front Street, and I believe Bug Light, are all within 500 feet of the petroleum storage facilities, or some petroleum storage facilities. Those levels, average levels, are below the AEG, but what we don't know is the levels between those, and that's, we think, an area worth further investigating. Lastly, I want to talk about the cumulative cancer risk piece. So this is a way for us to think about, although not perfect, think about the combination of exposure to multiple chemicals. And this is an example figure showing how we calculate a cumulative cancer risk. So on the horizontal axis here we have cumulative cancer risk cases per 100,000. And then in this bar we have the individual chemicals that make up that sum. So here this teal box below is benzene at Mechanic Street; this average level equates to a 0.6 in 100,000 cancer risk. Carbon tetrachloride has a 0.3 in 100,000 cancer risk, and chloroform has a 0.2. Ethylene dichloride has a 0.2, and then all other cancers that we have a cancer, or all other chemicals that we have a cancer-based value for but contribute less than 0.1 per 100,000, we sum up all together into another category. So that's what you're seeing here is this 0.3. We sum that all up to give us a cumulative cancer risk of just under 1.6 cases per 100,000, and again that is assuming that exposure occurs for 70 years, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. We would see from all of those chemicals an increased cancer rate of 1.6 out of 100,000 people. This is the cumulative cancer rate figure for all of the stations in South Portland and Portland, starting with the South Portland on the left side and moving to Portland at the end here. And a couple of things I'll point out: again this is the access for cancer cases per 100,000. This teal bar is benzene. We can see at most stations that benzene is the largest contributor to the cumulative cancer risk. Some other chemicals include the 1,3 butadiene, similar across stations, with the exception of Central Receiving, although Central Receiving was only online for a shorter period of time; that may be impactful then. Carbon tetrachloride, which is a legacy pollutant, and we see similar contributions across stations. And in South Portland and Portland area, the cumulative cancer risks, setting Pearl Street aside, range from about 1.3 to just under 2, 1.8, 1.9 at some of these stations. Pearl Street, due to the elevated benzene concentration, has a total cumulative cancer risk that's just under 3 at 2.8 and per 100,000. Comparing this to the four other hazardous air pollutant stations in the state where we can also calculate the cumulative cancer risk, so it's shown in this panel in the right, and we see a similar pattern. Benzene is a large contributor to overall cumulative cancer risk estimates, as well as carbon tetrachloride, chloroform, and then ethylene dichloride here. And comparing the statewide cumulative cancer risk, which is actually above 1 in 100,000, it's, you know, 1.3 to 1.4 per 100,000. You know, Portland area is slightly above that with the South Portland area, again, setting Pearl Street aside, you know, slightly higher there as well. Pearl Street with the 2.8 in 100,000 is higher than the statewide stations there. And what I want to point out here are these, again these estimates of cumulative cancer risk are estimates. One way to think about this or step back slightly is to look at cancer rates from cancers reported to the state. So the main cancer registry actually does take all of the cancers in the state that's a reportable disease to the state. They compile those data and then look at rates by county to see if there's anything jumping out at them of is there increased cancer rate in this county or this county. When we look at Cumberland County for all cancers, there isn't an increased rate compared to the rest of the state. On their metrics for age-adjusted rates that go up to 2023, it's about 480 for Cumberland County. The state's about 490 for cumulative of cancer cases there, age-adjusted, out of 100,000 people. We've looked as well for acute myeloid leukemia, which is associated with benzene exposure in that, and we don't see a difference in Cumberland County to the rest of the state for that particular cancer. So that tells us at least that we don't expect these cancer rates, even though they're above 1 in 100,000, to really result in increased cancer rates just from a risk assessment point of view. When we look at the actual cancer data we see something similar nothing's jumping out at us at least from the data that we have we've looked at to suggest there's an increased cancer rate in Cumberland County that geographic unit. [Mayor Tipton: Large geographic unit.] And so just to quickly go over the summary of our health assessment, looking at short-term and long-term findings. No monitoring stations again had 24-hour sample results that exceeded a short-term health guideline, and all the monitoring locations for ambient air and of acrolein had substantially higher levels than the AEG, although these levels were similar to other stations in the state. With the exception of Pearl Street, all the monitoring locations had long-term average concentrations of benzene that fell below the AAG. Pearl Street is the one station on the fence line where there was an exceedance, and there are nearby homes, and I mentioned that's, you know, of concern and worth further study. And then for our cumulative cancer risk estimate piece in Portland, South Portland, those range from about 1.5 to 2, with the exception of Pearl Street, which was slightly higher at 2.8 per 100,000. And I do want to mention here that this cumulative cancer risk estimates are likely underestimating due to the exclusion of naphthalene data. So in the report we mentioned that we've seen some changes of naphthalene over the years that we've been monitoring, that also happened at other stations in the state. So DEP will talk about their next steps of measuring naphthalene, but that is an impact that we're looking at, and it will probably increase those cancer rates. Again, stepping back, we don't necessarily think, based on the cancer data that's reported to the state, that will result in increased cancer cases. Just to take a quick look at that in a relative sense, so this is a figure showing naphthalene levels, not showing the concentration here, but just to look at a relative sense to kind of give you a comparison of how much they may increase cancer rates, and it will likely be similar at other stations in the state. And then just to point out here that some of the stations where we've seen higher levels relative to other stations, those include West Commercial Street and Cash Corner, so naphthalene is a Combustion product and West Commercial Street during the summer of 2023 had some construction activities that's largely probably contributing to this higher level, this larger variability. Cash Corner is next to a fire station as well as some industrial movement of commercial traffic that's probably contributing to the higher levels there. So we don't necessarily think there are going to be higher levels right next to the fence line and that would be contributing or adding to the benzene levels that we saw at Pearl Street. But we do want to look further into naphthalene to see what those levels are and if we can get data and to look at that. And I think with that I will hand it over to Stacy. Thank you. [3:15:17] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Excuse me, just one second. I did have this up and when I just opened my computer it disappeared and now it's saying that it's updating Microsoft here we go, it opened. I was about to say, I don't really know what to do here. Okay. My port's on the wrong side of the computer, evidently. [3:16:53] Public commenters (Barbara Dow Nucci, PJ Craigan): That's rather ominous. [3:17:00] Councilor Matthews: It's referring to your SharePoint, so you can probably trust it, but if that's wrong, don't worry. I don't know. [3:17:06] Mayor Tipton: Oh, here we go. Can I? I think you want to enable it. Just. There we go. [3:17:12] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Beautiful. Okay. And now I'm not going to touch anything. Okay. Okay. Sorry about that delay, guys. So, as Scott mentioned earlier, I'm Stacey Knapp. I am the Director of the Division of Air Quality Assessment in the Air Bureau at Maine DEP. [3:17:29] Rosemary DeAngelis: She's talking to the microphone, so... [3:17:32] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): I like to look at my audience. We'll look at you. [3:17:38] Mayor Tipton: And that microphone is questionable, so you sort of need to almost eat it. You have to hold it, bring it as close to you as possible. Okay. Sorry, Stacey. We actually planned every detail of these excruciating moments for you. [3:17:56] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Sorry. Is that better? Okay. Yeah? Okay. All right. So as Dr. Simmons mentioned, we did not include naphthalene in the recent health risk assessment because we have some data quality issues with naphthalene. And we were here about a year ago talking about this because that's when we discovered this. So we discovered the data quality issue with naphthalene when we were reviewing the South Portland data. We had at that point five years of data and the first four years of data looked relatively similar. In the fifth year of data, suddenly those concentrations dropped. Now while that might sound good, we didn't know why they dropped. There wasn't anything that happened that would suggest those concentrations should have dropped, so we started questioning the quality of those data. And our chemists in the lab did a deep dive into all of the laboratory data, all of the laboratory records, all of the maintenance logs, to try to determine what was going on. Because this was not just happening in South Portland, this was happening statewide at all of our hazardous air pollutant monitoring locations, and we didn't know exactly what was happening. So our chemists figured out that it was a hardware issue, and that routine maintenance in April of 2023 resolved that issue. So as a result, all of the data prior to April 2023 were biased high due to that laboratory issue. And that fifth year of data, after April 2023, those data were valid. Now because we questioned the data, we continued to question the data and essentially wanted to prove the quality of our data. So we started some inter laboratory comparisons where we reached out to partners in Rhode Island, in Ohio, at US EPA, and even a commercial lab where they could analyze our samples as well. So we analyzed samples, they analyzed samples, we compared those results. So I won't read this whole slide, but just to show you, this wasn't just one or two samples, right? So from early 2025 through summer of 2026, we sent samples to Rhode Island, we sent samples to Ohio, EPA sent us standards, we sent samples to commercial laboratories some of those samples when we analyzed them and our partners analyzed them those matches were great and then they weren't sometimes we were high they were low sometimes we were low they were high and so we've continued to question the data now to15 is used for the measurement of vocs and ambient and indoor air nap billion is technically an SVOC, it's a semi-volatile organic compound. And there is a method that's specific for semi-volatile organic compounds, which is TO17. So while we use TO15 in the lab for VOCs, all of the data that Dr. Simmons shared with you, those data were analyzed using TO15 in the laboratory. We now have concerns about using TO15 with very low concentrations of naphthalene. And that's what we see in our ambient air is very low concentrations of naphthalene. So TO17 is better suited to look at those concentrations of naphthalene. And so we have recently collected samples at both Mechanic Street and West Commercial Street. And it's a different method. It's a tube method. It pulls air through a tube instead of a 24-hour canister. But we did collect those samples over that same 24-hour period. And we've sent those samples to EPA for analysis. So we are still awaiting those results, but we're hoping that will give us more information. We also collected canister samples on those days for comparison. So going forward, our plan is to continue to analyze our samples. We analyze them for a long list of VOCs. We'll continue to analyze them for naphthalene, but when we report naphthalene, we are going to flag it as informational only. And this is not unusual. Massachusetts does the same thing with their data. They flag it as an estimate. Okay, and I should also add that this wouldn't be an issue if our reporting limit were higher. So our reporting limit is very, low. We like to be as transparent as possible and share all the data we have, even when it is a very,, very low concentration. Our reporting limit for naphthalene is 0.05 ppb. Ohio's is one. The highest annual average we found in South Portland was at West Commercial years ago, and it was 0.3. The current highest is Cash Corner. It's 0.1 to 0.2. So it's because our reporting limit is so low and we try to be as transparent as possible that this has become an issue. But we want to let you know that we are questioning those data, which is why we have sought out an alternative method, and we hope to have those results soon, but we don't have them yet. So that's all I have to say about naphthalene. So Dr. Simmons gave you a rundown of our six-year health assessment. So we have been doing that canister sampling for almost seven years now, and I want to differentiate between these two types of sampling, right? So we have the 24-hour HAPS canister. That's lab, that's analyzed in our laboratory for a number of VOC compounds. That's 24 hours every six days. Now we have the fence line monitoring. The fence line monitoring is a full two-week sample, so it's less of a snapshot, it's a full two weeks, and then those samples are sent off to commercial laboratories for assessment. And it doesn't look at the full list of hazardous air pollutants. It only looks at bore. And we'll talk about that a little bit more. So going forward, since we now have six years of data to analyze for the HAPS canisters, we don't feel that we will learn any new information by continuing that monitoring. So we do plan to discontinue those HAPS canister locations for the most part. We plan to retain three. We're going to keep Portland Ocean Gateway because that is part of our statewide hazardous air pollutant network. We have five locations; Portland Ocean Gateway is one of them, so we'll continue that location. We're going to continue Mechanic Street because, as Dr. Simmons kind of hinted at, there are a couple of areas in the South Portland area where we think we should, we're recommending some additional study, and we want to keep Mechanic Street during that additional study, and then we want to maintain a fence line location so as Dr. Simmons mentioned, the only location where there was a HAPS canister where we saw benzene concentrations above the ambient air guideline was at the Pearl Street location, which was on a fence line. Now, we've actually used that canister as a quality check for the fence line monitoring data because it is right next to a fence line monitor. And so that was really useful to have those two methods right next to each other for comparison, and we want to maintain that. Now, we can't stay at Pearl Street because there's construction going on. We learned about that earlier with the pump station, so we're trying to find, we're working with the city to try to find another location that is right next to a fence line monitor. We'll move that canister location there and maintain that essentially indefinitely as a check on the fence line monitoring. So we're discontinuing some of those HAPS canister locations, and we are shifting to fence line monitoring. Fence line monitoring has already started; it began in July of 2024, and that's why I am here is to talk about the first year and a half of results of that fence line monitoring. So where did this, how did this come about, right? So the 130th Maine Legislature enacted public law in 2021, Chapter 294. The governor signed that into law in the summer of 2021, and that statute required certain petroleum storage tank facilities to begin fence line monitoring programs. Now, in accordance with that statutory requirement, Maine DEP adopted Chapter 171, which was control of petroleum storage facilities, and that rule includes other requirements, but one of those requirements is fence line monitoring, and it required facilities to submit a fence line monitoring plan. It requires facilities to use EPA methods 325a and 325b, and it requires facilities to submit their data on a quarterly basis to the department, and the department, for full transparency, provides those quarterly reports on our website for public access as well. So the method 325A, 325B, those are EPA methods. Essentially, 325A is the field part. It's the sampling, deployment, and collection piece. And then 325B is the lab piece. That is how they analyze that sample in the laboratory. In summary, this method looks at four VOCs. We refer to them as BTEX compounds. That's benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylenes. For our purposes, we are combining MP xylenes and O xylene into one called xylenes, but they are technically two separate compounds there. Chapter 171 does require independent third party conduct this monitoring. So the facilities cannot do it themselves. EPA does not do this. They have contracted out third party entities to conduct the monitoring as well as analyze the samples. The method includes a passive tube. It's this little metal tube with a sorbent material inside, and air is kind of passively passed through there. There is no pump. It's over a two week period, and that material absorbs ambient air and whatever VOCs might be in that ambient air. Those samples are analyzed in the lab. When those samples are placed, when they're deployed in the field, there is a height requirement. It's 4.9 to 9 point feet above ground level, and that's roughly the height of your average first or second story window. As I mentioned before, it is a two-week sample. This is what they look like. Here are a couple of examples. On the top you can see that little metal tube. On the bottom they're roughly the size of a coffee cup like that housing up there on the top right. It looks shockingly like a coffee cup except inside can hold four different tubes, and you can see just kind of the mesh on the bottom is to protect those samples. This is an example of what a fence line plan might look like with locations around each facility. Those facilities are given a number for data records, and within Maine there are one, excuse me, 11 facilities who are subject to chapter 171. Six of those facilities are here in South Portland, and the number of fence line monitoring locations around each facility just depends on the distance around their fence line and the shape of that fence line. In South Portland, we're looking at between 12 and 18 sampling locations by facility. We're going to jump right into the results. The first set of results I'm going to share with you are the long-term average concentrations. This is a year and a half of fence line monitoring averaged together. Now we're averaging each individual monitoring location. We are not averaging across the entire facility, so each of those locations around that fence line that I showed you, that is what we're averaging, each individual location, but all of those two-week samples over that full year and a half time frame. Now we're going to use ambient air guidelines that Dr. Simmons already explained as a reference, as a comparison, but this is fence line data. This isn't technically ambient air, but we also know that there are houses very close to some of these fence lines, so we feel this isn't a good example, a good reference to compare it to, but do keep in mind that ambient air guidelines are intended for ambient air, not fence line perimeters. So let me add this disclaimer that these comparisons are intended to provide context for the monitoring results and do not by themselves constitute a health risk assessment or indicate the level of exposure experienced by individuals living or working near the facility. So here's the first one. We'll start with benzene. So let me orient you to this figure because we're going to look at a few of these. Along the x-axis you see all of the facilities in Maine, those 11 facilities that are subject to Chapter 171. The first six are here in South Portland. The others are throughout the state. On the, on the Y-axis, you're going to see concentration in parts per billion. And then along that 0.4 dotted line, that's the ambient air guideline for benzene. Each of these little circles is the 1.5-year long-term average of that benzene concentration at each individual monitoring location, so 12 to 18 per facility, depending on how many locations they had around their facility. So, when you look at this, you can see that there is one facility, Portland Pipeline, where all of those circles, all of the concentrations, the long-term average concentrations of benzene at each of the monitoring locations around that facility, all of them were below the ambient air guideline. For every other facility across the state, there was at least one location around that fence line where the long-term average benzene concentration exceeded the ambient air guideline. At some facilities, there are more than one. At some facilities there's only one or two. For example, we have Global and Sprague here in the South Portland area where they each only had one monitoring location that exceeded the ambient air guideline. Also in South Portland we had Sunoco where there are three monitoring locations around their facility that exceeded the ambient air guideline. Now Sitco in South Portland, there are more, right? So looking across the state, for the most part, where a facility had a location that exceeded the ambient air guideline that exceedance was less than 2.5 times the ambient air guideline. The one exception here is South Portland Terminal. That highest concentration there, that 1.8, is about 4.5 times the ambient air guideline. So we're going to come back to benzene, but let's move on to the other compounds, those other BTEX compounds. So first looking at toluene, every single long-term average at every single monitoring location at every single one of the 11 facilities was well below the ambient air guideline. So not too concerned about toluene here. Ethyl benzene, we only had one location at one facility that had a long-term average above the ambient air guideline. That was at Sicko. It's relatively close to the ambient air guideline, but still above. And we had two other facilities in the state, both South Portland Terminal and Buckeye, that had one monitoring location where that long-term average concentration was close to the ambient air guideline but not over. For xylenes, similar to toluene, every long-term average at every monitoring location around every facility was well below the ambient air guideline. Okay, so let's dig a little bit more into benzene. So I'll orient you to this as well. We're gonna look at some maps. So we know that there are monitoring locations around all but one of these facilities where the long-term average concentration of each individual of at least one of those monitoring locations was above the ambient air guideline. So where around the facility was that concentration high? Where was it low? So in these figures, there are circles that indicate the fence line monitoring locations around each facility. We're just starting with Sitco. ago. The color, whether it's orange or green, indicates whether that concentration is above or below the ambient air guideline. Orange indicates that long-term average concentration of benzene over that 1.5-year period was above the ambient air guideline. The diameter of the circle represents the concentration. So bigger circle, bigger diameter, bigger concentration,, smaller circle, smaller diameter, lower concentration, okay? So here at Sitco, as we saw in the previous figure, we can see that all of the fence line monitors were above the ambient air guideline for benzene, that long-term average. But we can also see that some of these locations are higher than others, and we can see that the highest concentration locations are actually along the water, and there are some higher concentration areas at the northwest edge of Sitco. What I do want to point out here though is that we have homes. We have homes relatively close to that fence line on the northwest side of the facility as well as at the southern edge of this facility. Global was one of the facilities where we only had one location above the ambient air guideline for that long-term benzene concentration and that location is not near residential homes. That location is along the water. Portland Pipeline, this was the facility that had no locations that had long-term average benzene concentrations above the ambient air guideline. South Portland Terminal was the other facility where all locations were above the ambient air guideline for that long-term benzene concentration. So again, bigger circle, higher concentration. We can see those higher concentration areas are mostly along the water or along the cemetery edge. But there are some homes along the southern edge of that facility, and those monitoring locations were indeed above the ambient air guideline. Sprague, only one location above the ambient air guideline, and there are no homes near that location. And Sunoco, this location, this facility had four locations above the ambient air guideline, line but those locations again are not near homes. Okay so those are the long-term average concentrations. We're going to talk about them a little bit more with our recommendations but let me then jump into the 14-day sample results. So each of those metal tubes is set out for a two-week period and analyzed individually. So as Dr. Simmons already mentioned, for short term, for an acute exposure, just as a general reference, we are going to look at the MRLs, the same MRLs that Dr. Simmons explained, for the 24 hours to two week period. So this is each individual 14-day sample. These aren't averaged at all. And again, these comparisons are intended to provide context for monitoring results and do not by themselves constitute a health risk assessment or indicate the level of exposure experienced by individuals living or working near a facility. We do recognize there are homes very close to these fence lines though. Okay, we'll start with benzene again. You can see that acute MRL of nine, everything is below. So every single sample collected at every single location at every single facility across the entire state was below that acute MRL for benzene. Same with toluene, same with ethylbenzene, and same with xylenes. So in summary, all of those 14-day sample results at every sampling location, at every facility, they were all below that acute MRL. Long-term average concentrations are a little trickier. For toluene and xylenes, all of those long-term average concentrations were well below the ambient air guidelines at all facilities. For ethyl benzene, there's a mix. There were a few facilities that had concentrations either slightly above or very close to the ambient air guideline, but each of those facilities only had one location that was approaching that ethyl benzene AAG. One was slightly over. Benzene is a different story. Benzene had variable results, right, and had the most locations with concentrations above the ambient air guideline. We know we had one facility, Portland Pipeline, where every monitoring location was below the ambient air guideline. We had two facilities where there was only one location above that ambient air guideline. We had Sunoco where there were a handful, three, but they were not in your homes. And then we had Sitco and we had South Portland and Terminal where all of their locations were above the ambient air guideline, and there were homes close to those fence lines. So our next steps, our first recommendation is for the city to look into conducting a fence line step out study. Now this is similar to what Dr. Simmons recommended, and we've talked about this. We have canister sampling results at Pearl Street, and we see that those concentrations are above the ambient air guideline. Now that is on a fence line that is not out in the community like all of the other canister samples, but we recognize that there are homes very close to that. Now the fence line monitoring as a follow up, again, we see concentrations of benzene above the ambient air guideline near residential homes near Sitco and South Portland Terminal. And so those are the two areas where we have questions, and we're interested to see how those concentrations change as you move away from the fence line. So as Dr. Simmons pointed out, we do have canister sampling data from Mechanic Street, from Bug Light, from [street] that is further away from a fence line, and those concentrations were below the ambient air guideline. Those are within 500 feet. So how quickly do those concentrations change from the fence line to that 500 foot canister? We don't know. We don't have an answer to that question. So we would like to see the same passive samplers that are used for the fence line monitoring set at intervals moving away from the fence line, specifically at the southern edge of Sitco, where there were homes, to the southern edge of South Portland Terminal, where there were homes, and then at that northwest area between the fence line and the Mechanic Street canister of the Sitco facility because again there are homes up there. So those are the two locations that we are looking to investigate a bit further and so we can determine the actual health risk in the communities. The other thing we have actually already started. So when we started seeing these fence line concentrations above the ambient air guideline we wanted more information as others have pointed out today those are a two-week interval. A lot happens in a two-week period. So we reached out to our partners at EPA because they have what's called a Sensit S-Pod. It is a low-cost sensor and it looks at total VOCs. So fence line monitoring, remember, looks at four VOCs. It looks at BTEX compounds, right? Benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylenes. Total VOC sensors look at all the VOCs. So including all of the VOCs that we look at using TO15 in the laboratory and also more and it doesn't split them out these are not regulatory grade monitors I really want to stress that these are low cost sensors but they are continuous so we look at hourly data in the five locations where we've deployed these instruments we were able to borrow these instruments from EPA and we started deploying them last November we have them at Front Street we had one at Pearl Street before we had to move Mechanic Street we have one near South Portland Terminal now and we have one out on Western Ave kind of near Red Bank and so they give us continuous data and we're using them in a qualitative sense looking at how those VOC concentrations go up and go down when is that happening and then we reach out to the facilities when we see an increase in those VOC concentrations a short-term increase in those concentrations and say what is going on what is it that you guys might be doing that might be contributing to those increased VOC and mixed results those activities don't always match up with what we're seeing but we also know that there are a lot of other sources of VOCs in the area and we also know that wind plays a huge role in that so we plan to leave each of these spots out for a full year duration and then we'll be doing an analysis looking at wind looking at petroleum product deliveries and trying to see if we can find a pattern there linking activities to those concentrations The other thing that we're working on the department and the city and the facilities are all collectively working on an MOU for tank headspace monitoring I understand the protocol for that monitoring is included in this MOU and that is still being worked on and finally the department recently purchased an optical gas imaging camera an OGI camera can visually detect VOCs. It can look at VOC emissions as well as leaks. And so our staff are currently being trained to use this instrument with the idea that we can go out to facilities and further evaluate VOC emissions and potential leaks at the petroleum storage terminals. And that is all I have to share with you tonight. And I will stop there and we'll talk about questions. [3:43:06] Mayor Tipton: Thank you, Stacy. Thank you, Mr. Simmons. Should I be calling either one of you doctor? Well, we really appreciate you sharing all of this information, and I suspect that our counselors have questions for you. I have about a million, but I will... [3:43:27] Councilor Matthews: Do you mind if I just make sure I get the right, what we're looking for feedback on tonight? Sure. Okay. So council, you heard some of the next steps proposed by DEP and I've outlined them in the position paper that includes the step out VOC study and how I think of this is kind of like a funnel almost how the studies have gone over the past seven years. We started out with a big catchment area of, as someone said earlier, monitoring locations in all of the five voting districts in South Portland and we begin narrowing those down as we got results in and we felt we could move on to other areas because there wasn't you know any results there that were either concerning or we found some areas that we wanted to learn more about with the help of the Clean Air Advisory Committee and now we have this six years worth of data we feel like we can continue to move down that funnel and focus on the couple of areas outside of SP terminal on the sitco facility that warrant further investigation as to whether the amounts at the fence line how far out those are getting into the neighborhoods as Stacy had mentioned because some of those monitors that are 500 feet out are not picking up the same levels above a AG that they are at the fence line but we need to know whether or not that's holding true for those areas the other is obviously continuing the fence line monitoring see what that has the s-pod monitoring we are still working for over two years now and trying to get a as some have termed it burst emissions study so what are the short-term burst emissions and how can we best measure those so we've been working with the terminals and main dep to come up with an agreed-upon framework as to how we can measure those we're still kind of doing some details with DEP but we hope to have that finalized soon and then obviously the Transition of the 24-hour canister network will be moving away from some of those areas where you know DP hasn't or CDC hasn't felt there needs to be further study. So we're really looking for guidance from Council on whether you are supportive of those steps, if there's anything you want to take off that, anything you want to add on to it, and go from there. There is also in your materials some residential land use implementation feedback that planning is looking for in terms of buffers within certain areas on development. And I'm just gonna ask Milan for a brief second to just talk about what they're looking for feedback there. And then we'll turn it back over to counselors [3:46:12] Speaker B (unidentified): for questions and feedback. Thank you Milan for being as concise as possible. [3:46:21] Milan Navida: So in your packet that memo details why we're asking the question. We've spent three years talking about how do we mitigate for some of these risks in the comp plan. The comp plan is a very clear policy which I know you're all familiar with, that we need to fully understand the potential health impacts before we change zoning regulations to allow somebody to take a property that couldn't currently house housing or has a limit on how much housing it can provide and then increase their ability to apply to build housing. Some of the areas in all those policy discussions seemed pretty comfortable for people to talk about housing, like Sable Oaks at the golf course, main mall area, people seem pretty excited about that. Those are generally speaking, not often thought about when we think about air quality issues. issues. Other areas, obviously, we're very sensitive, the eastern waterfront, obviously, and then some of these industrial areas. The question here for me as we go through this two-year process of rezoning is that where is that line at which we think we're comfortable saying additional housing through zoning is something that we want to enable? We've had lot of discussions about this. In the memo I gave some reference points on how people have looked at you know separations and buffers. We can look further into that if council wants for us to do that. We've also heard sort of anecdotal feedback from folks of you know 500 feet of separation is a sort of minimum or a thousand feet of separations, and some people talk about, some people talk about 300. Those are anecdotal at best. We have not analyzed those numbers, but I understand the point of providing some kind of buffer, some kind of peace of mind, if you will. So what we're looking for is just whether or not the city council at this point has any guidance for us on we want to uphold the do not up zone for residential, and we want to make sure that is happening within this distance. If you're prepared to do that tonight, if you're not, that's okay. We also would like to know if you want to set up a council workshop at whatever point we can for us to give you any additional information that we might be able to research and find out about what might be a sensible number, if you're not prepared to go to the thousand or the 500 or something else. So really I just need to know, is this up zoning for additional residential city-wide something we don't want to be talking about because we still have some stuff to study, or is there some point here distance from these facilities that we're continuing to track where we've got a certain or a reasonable amount of comfort, you're okay entertaining zoning proposals that allow additional residential. So whatever that guidance might be is what we'll take tonight, or guidance to go to workshop. Thank [3:49:16] Mayor Tipton: you Scott. Are you doing something I should know about, or are we ready for council questions? Okay, always good to know, counselors. Counselor Walker, so I have a bunch, but I'll start with just a [3:49:37] Councilor Walker: couple and then I'll seek my time and ask that maybe you come back to me. But my first one was, where did it go when you, this is for a main DP, when would you expect to report out on data on that last piece that you just went over with the, I'm paraphrasing, that yes and the fancy cameras and the optical things, all of that, it [3:50:08] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): it totally depends. So with the fence line step out study, we are recommending a one-year study so that data can be averaged over a year, which is the minimum required to compare it to an ambient air guideline. So we're suggesting a one-year study for the fence line. For the tank headspace space monitoring, I don't know what the timeframe plan is on that one. And then for OGI camera assessments, again, we don't know what we're going to find. So it's going to be learning how to use that instrument, going out, checking it out, seeing what we find, seeing how useful it is, seeing where it's useful, and kind of going from there. So I don't have specific timeframes for that. I mean, we could, you know, maybe I shouldn't volunteer this, but we could give you updates periodically as we work through these things, but I don't, I don't know at this point. We don't have a set time frame that I'm aware of. All right, thank you. [3:51:04] Councilor Pryde: Sorry, can I just clarify, did you answer the question about the S-Pod analysis? I know that was November and you'd like to do a year. Yeah, so those don't, didn't get [3:51:12] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): all deployed in November. The first one was deployed in November of last year, so they're starting to come down. We actually co-locate them for four weeks all together at the beginning and at the end just for quality checks. The last one, I believe, was deployed in March of this year, and that's the one over by South Portland Terminal. It's in the Forest Cemetery, and we actually plan to leave that one through the step-out study. We're hoping that one of the fence line passive monitors could be placed at that S-Pod for comparison as well, so we'll leave that one a little bit longer. But the others, they should start coming down. The South Portland Terminal one, we'll have a year data set in March, but this winter we're going to start analyzing those data, and the facilities have been fantastic in providing us with the fuel delivery schedules and that sort of thing, so we'll be able to compare MET and fuel deliveries with the VOC concentrations that we've been seeing. But again, this is total VOC, it's not specific to the BTEC compounds. I can add, though, that when we've seen higher concentrations, we did collect a grab sample once, and we did indeed see the VOCs that we would expect to be associated with [3:52:21] Councilor Walker: petroleum products, but we just have that one sample. And then my other two questions that I'm not quite sure who would answer them, I'll just say them both and we can decide. My first one is, where is the disconnect between, you know, the data that you were giving us tonight, you know, kind of the long-term exposure, the one in 100,000 cancer risk for benzene, versus the WHO guidelines of no safe exposure? So I was curious about that. And then also, and this might be a staff question, so Portland Pipeline That's the only, as far as I know, and I could be speculating, but is that the only tank farm that's basically empty? I mean, I know that we were saying that it was the only one that was where the ambient air guidelines were consistently below the levels of ambient air. That was the one that was kind of below on all studies for benzene, but that one's pretty [3:53:18] Councilor Matthews: much empty. Correct? I think you, they report to you when there's empty tanks, right? And how long are you aware of others other than Portland Pipeline or maybe Air? Yeah, Eric Kennedy from DP. [3:53:41] Eric Kennedy: Good evening, Eric Kennedy, acting director of the Bureau of Air Quality, Scott. In terms of the, your question about, you know, certainly throughput through Portland Pipeline has been reduced significantly. I'd have to look at, you know, emission inventory reports to see exactly how much they've decreased over the past several years. I don't have that off the top of my head. [3:54:09] Councilor Matthews: But do you know if other, others have essentially empty tanks or reduced capacity, reduced capacity? [3:54:18] Eric Kennedy: Well, they're certainly all operating at, you know, certainly not their potentials as, you know, as they can operate in terms of their license. But I will say, you know, gasoline, petroleum product throughputs in Maine throughout the years really doesn't change much. It's based on consumer demand primarily, and we haven't really seen much change and throughput through the years. I was just curious because you know for [3:54:54] Councilor Walker: pointing out Portland Pipeline as, you know, kind of this is for lack of a, this is an oversimplification, but this is the good one because it's below all of the levels, and I just, I was curious about what it would look like if it was operating at more full capacity, so that's why I asked that question. And then the question about the WHO. [3:55:17] Eric Kennedy: I don't know if you can answer that. Can you repeat that question? [3:55:24] Councilor Walker: Where's the disconnect, or is there a disconnect between the data that was pointed out tonight about long-term exposure and cancer rates, you know, 1 in 100,000 for benzene, versus WHO guidelines that were referenced earlier this evening where there's no safe exposure? [3:55:41] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): Yes. So the WHO guideline of no safe exposure is a guideline of for any chemical that causes cancer, whether it's a VOC or another type of chemical, both the WHO and the EPA and other agencies have that guideline for chemicals. We'd like to see no cancer risk or there's really no safe level when we think of cancer risk. We're extrapolating down to zero. So that's the overall goal for chemical policy is to get to that zero. There's really no safe risk. Unfortunately, that's not the reality we live in. There are lots of chemicals that are well above zero that carry some sort of cancer risk. So while that's the goal, we have to have policies around those to deal with the elevations that we see in the environment. There are arsenic levels in private wells that carry cancer risk even in public water systems there's some cancer risk for arsenic even below the MCLs. If you look at public water systems that maximum contaminant level goal for cancers is zero so you'll often see that as you know a standard or a guideline to get to of zero, but the actual regulatory limit is higher than that based on feasibility to meet that. If you can meet that, great. That's the goal. You can get there. If you can't, we have to have a policy that allows for some cancer risk, unfortunately, and that's where the one in 100,000 comes into play. And that can vary for over decades of chemical policy. It's been either one in 10,000 or one in a million, and that's a policy decision [3:57:16] Councilor Scott: on where you want to land for that thank you counselors question I have a [3:57:23] Speaker AM (unidentified): question for this toxicologist when you're talking about like the cancer risk and you're mentioning each individual chem chemical is that taking into account a synergistic effect with these chemicals when we look [3:57:40] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): look at the cumulative cancer risk, the assumption there is equal potency and additive risk. So we're not thinking synergism, but they are just a summing effect of each of those individual compounds, their cancer risk, adding that up based on the measured concentrations. [3:57:59] Speaker AM (unidentified): And you talked about, like, Cumberland County is now greater than the others. But, I mean, we had people here. We don't have a hundred thousand people in South Portland, neither does Rumford, but there are many more people here than just 1.5 that have cancers that are related to these chemicals. So there's definitely a risk with the emissions. And if we were to talk about mitigating effects for the emissions, would that affect your study? And that it would probably, and I would hope after a year show that there were decreased toxins in our ear. Would that, would that affect your study negatively? Because I mean, it's like we know that this is a problem, and there are, there is technology to mitigate emissions to decrease these risk factors. And you know they're asking us to recommend housing when we know that this is in our ear presently, and that there are means to decrease that which would make it safer for people to live near these tanks. Yes. [3:59:22] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): I think we would look at that and the fence line data if there were actions taken to reduce emissions, and we would likely see that in the fence line monitoring data over a longer period of [3:59:33] Speaker AM (unidentified): time. So it would support actually that these, the technology is effective. We [3:59:41] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): would have to look at that over time. Yes, over time. Thank you. Questions. Thank you. [3:59:49] Councilor Pryde: Sure. I guess, I guess, you know, we heard a lot tonight from different residents about wanting to see some emissions containment technology. What kind of technologies are they already using typically? Is there a lot of that? Are they using the best available standards already? I mean, if we, if we impose that [4:00:13] Eric Kennedy: rule on them, would we be making an impact? So under our authority, the regulations that we have in place. We look at several different levels of control technology when we license a facility. For existing facilities, we use what's called best practical treatment, which is looking at control technologies that similar age, similar size, similar type sources use around the country. And that's what we use to determine and what is best practical treatment for existing sources. For new sources we use what's called best available control technology analysis for new sources or modified sources that looks at control technologies that are in use throughout the country, throughout the world actually, and it looks at environmental, energy, and economic impacts associated with all those control technologies. It's like a top-down analysis of various control technologies that can reduce emissions that you're looking at. There's also what's called reasonably available control technology, and that's applied to major sources of VOCs, for instance, in an ozone non-attainment area. We don't have any ozone non-attainment areas. However, the coast of Maine is part of the ozone transport region. So those requirements do apply to major sources of VOCs. And then there's a further level for, again, new sources, major modifications. That's called lowest achievable emission rate, and that looks at control technologies again throughout the country, throughout the world. And what's the lowest achievable emission rate? That can be achieved with the best control technology, and that's again applied to new, so major new sources or major modifications. [4:02:28] Councilor Pryde: Do you know, I mean, I guess I understand there's different regulations that you have that you apply to various sources, and I know that the sources in South Portland are typically on the older side, so I imagine most of them are probably held to the best practical treatment standard. But the question I really have is, do we know what they're actually doing? I mean, I imagine they're all meeting the minimum standard, but are any of these sources already, you know, using better treatment standards, better treatment technology, and is that something factored into any of the data? [4:03:02] Eric Kennedy: So best practical treatment, for instance, for gasoline storage tanks is, and this is throughout the country, that, you know, for similar size, age, type facilities, is generally internal floating roofs with, you know, seals around the outside of the internal floating roof that scraped the internals parts of the wall to keep the gasoline below the internal floating roof. But there are also domes, I'm told, that could you [4:03:40] Councilor Pryde: know increase the potential capture, and I note that there aren't really any domes that I can see around South Portland, Canada. So I'm, I'm just curious. So what I'm getting is that you probably, you actually, as much as you may know or believe that they're all using the what they're required to under the regs, you don't have any information about anybody using anything greater [4:04:02] Eric Kennedy: than what's required. I do, there are some facilities in California, there are some facilities in Texas. I met in South Portland. No. Okay, that was my question. Yeah, other counselors. [4:04:17] Mayor Tipton: Questions. All right, well I have a couple of questions. Is it so DEP does the licensing for the facilities, and part of the licensing is saying how much can be emitted. So is it true that right now the total is 550 tons of VOCs can be admitted in South Portland? [4:04:51] Eric Kennedy: That sounds about right for potential to emit based on the licensed facilities somewhere. [4:04:58] Mayor Tipton: I think we were seeing it. Well, I can only ask you questions, so all right, that sounds right. So did you know, here's a question, that is approximately equal to and the weight of an eight to ten car fully loaded Amtrak passenger train with the diesel engine. I looked that up because I wanted to have some idea of mass. So that was a question. You're you're not saying yes or no, and so I guess what I my question is of that massive amount of allowed through the licenses that DEP grants, of that massive amount of VOCs allowed. How much has been released that the testing is picking up? Do you think it was the testing is picking up from the full 550 tons, or do you think it was considerably less, or what ideas do we have about that? So the [4:06:07] Eric Kennedy: monitoring that we've done picks up measures whatever's in the air, so whatever is being released from not only petroleum facilities but every other voc source or source of benzene emissions, the measurements that we've done over the past six years pick up picks up all of those [4:06:28] Mayor Tipton: measurements. All right, thank you for that answer, but it sounds like we don't know if it's based on the full 550 that basically it sounds like, and just tell me if I'm correct, because that's my question, that it could be worse if it was as much as 550 that what we're seeing monitor could be less. Certainly if all the facilities [4:06:55] Eric Kennedy: were operating at maximum capacity emitting the most emissions that they could emit under their license, certainly you would have increased emissions that would be measured [4:07:08] Mayor Tipton: by the ambient monitoring stations that we have. Well, thank you for answering that. It certainly gets my attention. I had one other question just to be clear. I've heard you know the testing that you're recommending, but are you recommending testing in the absence of any other action, and by that I mean action to reduce the harmful emissions, so we look at as I [4:07:40] Eric Kennedy: Said we look at emission controls when we relicense a facility. We look at what we're authorized to look at in terms of what controls those facilities are subject to. That being said, in order to these next steps that we're recommending, in order to really pinpoint what's causing those increased levels or those higher levels at the fence line monitoring stations we're seeing, these next steps is really helping us to narrow down where those emissions are coming from. Are they coming from the tanks? Are they coming from the loading racks? Are they coming from the ships that are in port there? You know, we just we don't know exactly what activities are resulting in those higher levels of [4:08:35] Mayor Tipton: emissions. That's the next step. Mm-hmm. So all of that relates to further testing it, am I correct? It's not preventative. We yeah, we can't we can't [4:08:50] Eric Kennedy: prevent something unless we know exactly what's resulting in those higher emissions. [4:08:59] Mayor Tipton: I have one other question because it relates to what has been raised by some of the members of our community, the spikes question. We had a very creative analogy about drinking a whole lot of beer at once versus spacing it out. What are the health harms that potentially people are suffering when the not from an averaged amount but an averaged amount records it's part when those spikes are high? I'm gonna let Tom answer that question. Thank you. Well, [4:09:37] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): the data we have right now to compare to the acute MRLs are the 24-hour samplers, so again, that's pulling in air for 24 hours. That's not necessarily capturing the highest spike that could be there. We think over the longer periods of time, especially for the stations that have been on for longer periods of time, given that where you do that every six days, which is intended to capture over a longer period of time all the days of the week, that probably does capture some of those higher emissions during those times. It's not perfect system. It won't capture those really high if there are really high emissions, but probably some. And that 24-hour sample is, again, best compared to that acute MRL, which are based on studies in either mice, rats, or humans looking at very short-term exposures to very high levels. So that's our apples-to-apples comparison there. I don't think right now we have a great way of saying are there levels that are really high, a spike level, other than the 24-hour measurements, which is an average over that period of time. [4:10:49] Mayor Tipton: Thank you. I am. All right. I think it would be best. Well, [4:10:56] Councilor Pryde: I just, I didn't get my hand up quickly enough. Do you mind if I ask a few questions? [4:11:01] Mayor Tipton: If I thought you had more, but go ahead, please. [4:11:04] Councilor Pryde: in the, in the, fence line sort of extension test that you mentioned, is there not a Labrador,, just a cute little puppy, a laboratory based analysis that can look at dispersal rates of benzene from one point to another? I mean, it's, it seems like that could be very easily created and determined in a lab setting. No, maybe that's the answer. [4:11:32] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Unfortunately, it's not that easy. And it's not that easy because we don't have a single source in the South Portland area. We have a lot of sources of VOCs, as we saw on the map that Dr. Simmons put up. So we have to consider all of the sources of benzene, and then you have to consider the meteorology, which gets really messy. So we don't know. You can model it. We don't have the ability to do that, but there are human exposure models that can model sources and use meteorology and they can estimate what those risks would be further away from a source and they can include lots of sources. Again, we don't have the ability to do that, but a contractor could do that for you, but that's just a model that's not really what's happening. And so this fence on step out study is going to, if it's our recommendation, because it will show us what's actually happening at each of those locations, so we'll have actual concentrations, not modeled concentrations. Okay, thank you. And then on the S-POD analysis, [4:12:35] Councilor Pryde: I think you mentioned that's a total VOC. There's not a specific amount. Right. Does it still model or evaluate those VOCs in the same metric of the parts per billion? Yes, but it's different, [4:12:50] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): which is why I was trying to stress, like, we're using these data in a qualitative way because it is a low-cost sensor. It is not a regulatory grade monitor, so this is a much less rigorous type of observation and it is total VOC. It's, it's what's called a PID, a photo ionization detector, and so this type of technology actually reacts differently to different VOCs. It's called a response factor, so it's not that when this detector detects a one that benzene is a one. All the different VOCs have different response factors and they add up. It's, it's a little more complicated, so it only looks at total VOC. There's no way to break down what contributes to that total VOC without canister sampling, and we can't do canister sampling every, you know, minute. [4:13:42] Councilor Pryde: Or hour, okay. Yeah, I wish. And then I just wanted, if you can, my understanding is that if you were to build a tank farm in South Portland in 1950 and then the United States enacted a Clean Air Act and made many amendments thereto and Maine enacted their version of a Clean Air Act and that license, that facility was licensed and has operated in the same fashion without any modifications or new facilities, etc., that there's not the ability to go for, you know, federal government or the state of Maine, but maybe the South, city of South Portland to go back and change the requirements of that existing facility. I'm not asking for a full legal opinion, but if you could help me clarify, that's sort of my understanding of how some of these, whether it's backed or reasonable or all these different technology standards, how they apply and how they can be built into the licensing of these facilities over time. And I think that's what we're trying to sort of figure out how we get to. I know that's not really a question, but if you [4:14:45] Eric Kennedy: could confirm my understanding, I'll make it a question, but confirm your understanding in terms of there's no changes that can be made to, I'm paraphrasing here, to emission standards, emission limits, control technology at a existing facility, is that what you're saying? [4:15:05] Councilor Pryde: Maybe not, no, but it's a, it's a limited set of tools that you have, or it's, it's more limited [4:15:10] Eric Kennedy: in terms of those changes. Yeah, that's true. I mean, certainly we take our regulations are, they're all based on federal and state legislation. So if federal rules change, our rules change. If state legislation changes, our rules change. So those are the methods that things can change in terms of emission limits, emission standards, control technologies. [4:15:42] Mayor Tipton: All right, I really mean it this time, counselors. Any other questions before we go to public comment? I have one more. Yes, Council Walker. [4:15:50] Councilor Walker: Thanks, made me think of it. So current administration guidelines in terms of clean air and licensing and all that, I know it's a bit looser than what we've seen from other recent administrations, are those being factored into current licensing guidelines for these [4:16:06] Ann Mello: facilities are [4:16:13] Eric Kennedy: you talking about at the federal level? There really haven't been much change in the terms of federal regulations that apply to petroleum storage terminals. There have been certainly changes in other areas. Okay, [4:16:35] Speaker H (unidentified): yes [4:16:40] Mayor Tipton: Yes, we're done. Public comment on this item is now open. [4:16:57] Robert Selin: Robert Selin Deke Street Mayor Tipton, Councilors, City staff, and these representatives from CDC and our main Department of Environmental Protection, we thank you for being here. This is a very sobering evening for me and I think for our community in that we have aging facilities that by law cannot be brought up to the highest standards. And how do we deal with that? I hope that we get that imaging camera as soon as possible. We know who the two worst polluters are in our community. Go into those facilities, use that camera to detect the leaks because all petroleum products give off EOCs. They can escape through leaks, they can be captured and reconstituted into liquid, put back into the tanks, or they can be burned off and go into our air. So basically, during last week's northerly winds, there were complaints from the Pleasantdale neighborhood about very strong VOC fumes in their neighborhood and I personally went walked the Greenbelt and noticed that indeed there were and they were coming from Sitco the north wind and Sitco reported to the city that there were no malfunctions but I think those winds may have been strong enough to put out their vapor combustion unit. We all drive the bridge, we can see their vapor combustion unit on their property. It's that tall stack near the water white painted white with a black band around the top and it burns off toxics 24 7 day and night unless perhaps there's a wind that would extinguish it or they would turn it off. So I think that with those tactics being burned off and not what should I say that so I guess I'll just present some questions to our representatives here from the state for the Department of Environmental Protection direction, will you inform the city manager of the number of permitted VCUs, vapor combustion units in South Portland? Can you give us the location of each VCU, give us the names and contact information for the permit holders of each VCU, vapor combustion unit, and give us the permitted pollution limits for each VCU and when can you provide this information? I'm confident that as a community if we use that camera and if we can stop the incineration of toxic VOCs in South Portland time finish your sentence please I hope we can do better and thank you all for participating. [4:20:21] John Pawnee: John Pawnee, Beach Street. I just came to listen tonight, so I don't have prepared remarks, but there was so much fascinating discussion that I do have three brief things I want to say, but one of which I want to stress and I think is a very practical suggestion here tonight, but as long as I have, what do I have, three minutes? So I'll add my other two items too. So first of all, I wanna thank Rob for his comments. I agree with Rob and all I can do is, as I often do, pat Rob on the back and say, thank you. I'm a little shocked that we can measure pollutants above a suggested guideline up to a level where we all think it's a problem we all think it's a health risk and yet we appear to be powerless to go to the sources and have those levels reduced so i'm i'm a little shocked that we're in that situation and i think all of us here tonight feel that 's a situation we should try to fix over the long term. If we think the levels are too high, for example, at Sitco, and we say, you know, that place is emitting too much, you know, harmful chemicals, and we all agree on it, then we ought to be able to demand that they be reduced. And I get it that legally we seem constrained, but it seems like we shouldn't be. So that's something we all should work on. I do want to say that I'm very heartened by what I heard from Maine CDC and Maine DEP, the kinds of measurements they're doing and the statistics they're doing and the analyses. How am I doing on time? You still have one minute. You know, are very impressive, spot on. And, you know, I know I have to talk to you, not to them. So please tell them to keep going, you know, they're they're they're they're doing a great job and this idea of, you know, going to the specific areas, you know, around a storage facility and finding which ones are the problem, that's that's great. So I would like to, so here's the part that I think is practical and really important, I would like to see the specific analyses carried over to the Sunoco area because we don't have housing there but we do have a lot of discussions about changing zoning there. And so there's a discussion of building housing there, so I would ask you to go to what we call the eastern waterfront and is mostly the Sunoco area. I'm almost done, and work there, and the other thing is, and this is the really done, John, okay, the step, the step back measurements, it's a long night, the step back measurements have to be done at the Sunoco area. [4:23:43] Mayor Tipton: The step back has to be done and you're not supposed to talk to Milan either, boy. You are break in every rule you could find, but he's cute. Hi, I'm Dave Flatko, Reynolds Street. I wanted to [4:23:59] Speaker AP (unidentified): point out before i read my letter the cdc is using a benzene acute short-term m r l from the a t s d r that is a draft standard it's not final yet and they're using a they're ignoring the final acrolein standard from the same guidance that is way above everything in Maine. So it seems like they're making a big deal of acrolein and dismissing benzene with a draft standard. Anyway, the DEP has long maintained that the facilities in South Portland follow their air permits and the emission limits are protective of human health, but air modeling of the permit limits shows ambient air concentrations could be significantly above guidelines. The data to support this, benzene emissions are only about 1% of what's permitted, yet benzene averages at some locations already exceed ambient air guidelines. Benzene emissions could significantly increase, yet still be under permit limits. There is no regulatory limit on benzene increases in ambient air caused by industrial activities. There are only limits on total mass discharges per year. It is not just benzene that is present. By the facility's own estimates, for each part of benzene emitted, there are 265 parts of other petroleum VOCs that are not measured by the fence line monitoring nor fully captured with the ambient air monitoring. The CDC health assessment did not consider the synergistic effects of benzene combined with the other petroleum VOCs as they have done in other work. The DEP is in the uncomfortable position of issuing the permits saying they are protective of human health and then having data that doesn't support this. The residential canister grab samples from 2019 and the air modeling show that the highest benzene-naphthalene levels were in the Pearl and Chapel Street area and Cache Corner. These are still the highest areas for benzene and naphthalene. Seven years later, the DEP still says more data is needed and proposes the same study that was proposed last year and never started. Main air regulations should be revised to be protective of human health instead of using standard VOC mass discharge limits per year. In the Cache Corner area, the industrial wastewater treatment facility can discharge up to 2,000 pounds of naphthalene per year without an air permit, but this level This level could raise ambient air naphthalene concentrations significantly above guidelines. Naphthalene in cash corners is about three times higher than the guidelines. The air quality standards listed in Chapter 110 of the Maine DEP air regulations should be updated to include benzene and other VOCs with limits based on ambient air guidelines. And the fence line should be the regulatory compliance point. Fence line concentrations above guidelines would require corrective measures at the facility, which could include operational changes, containment and dispersion, or containment and full treatment. This is a particularly South Portland issue, as 80% of all petroleum entering Maine comes through South Portland, with 1.1 trillion gallons processed in 2024. The city needs to push this forward with strong support of legislation at the state level and be willing to pursue it as a city ordinance if state support is not there. [4:27:07] Public commenters (Matthew Beck, Tom Okolka): Hi, my name's Tom Okolka, former industrial hygienist with a specialty in indoor air quality, and Dave Folatko's a hard act to follow. I used to have to follow him on the Clean Air Advisory Committee. Couple of comments. A big to-do was made about the fact that the Portland Pipeline Company did not have any exceedances on any of the sampling sites. Happens to be, and I hope somebody would say it, of the 19 tanks my information says only one tank has any fuel in it any fuel and I have looked at the data that shows the highest levels and the one spot that almost exceeded its average is nears the tank okay and I just want to point out that for years those tanks were in full operation and the people complained about it, teachers complained about it. Nobody from DEP ever thought to measure the air levels and on those playgrounds. And I suspect just from the information from that one tank that they were exceeding the AAG for benzene on those playgrounds. Next, Sunoco, yes, nothing on Front Street. A fairy village doesn't seem to have anything to worry about but the proposed developments on the other side towards bug light two of those sites monitoring sites consistently exceeded the AAG so I support a really a thousand foot for those who are planning nobody should be building anywhere near that fence line because data suggests consistently above the AAG for benzene. Finally, we're here today not because of the DEP, although I have total respect for them, but because of the EPA and the fact that they took Global and Sprague to court. And we found out that they were putting out levels of VLCs that apparently DEP said asphalt tanks never had any VLCs. When all along, people in the industry knew to get asphalt to flow, you had to dilute it with something like old gasoline. And we found out through the DEP, or excuse me, the EPA, that they were exceeding their limits. And guess what? We have technology on those tanks now, the heated tanks, that captures those emissions. So nobody thought about that before. And I'm suggesting on those gasoline tanks, those Citgo tanks, we could insist that they capture those emissions. And I find it hard to explain, okay, to anybody in those neighborhoods right now, knowing the levels along the fence lines, how long we're going to wait to correct the problem. Good [4:30:33] Chris Kessler: evening. Good morning. I'm Chris Kessler. I live at [address]. I am outgoing state representative for District 121. I represent part of South Portland and part of Cape Elizabeth. Elizabeth. I have a couple of questions and a comment. The questions are the first one for the DEP. In the notes, it stated that they would seek funding from the terminals for some of this new testing, and I wanted to know when you say you're going to seek funding, is it that you already have the authorization to require that the terminals fund that or are you needing authorization from somebody else and when it comes to the headspace monitoring why has it been two years and we've not been able to come to any kind of understanding and are we needing to have greater authority to be given to get this moving along? Which leads me to my comments, which is that it seems to me that this is becoming less of a matter of the science and the data and more a political decision that we must make not just at the municipal stage but at the state level as well and we have the authority under the Clean Air Act for the state to require stricter standards and under Maine law we have the home rule authority to have even stricter standards and it is time for us to exercise our power to do this we've been waiting too long Years and years, and the fact that there is even an increased chance that somebody in our community can get cancer from breathing these fumes in the mix of all the other fumes that we breathe in from vehicles and everything else. 30 seconds. I know people who have lived across from the tanks for 70 years. We have to act now, and so I encourage the council and also all of the of us who serve at the state house, you know, we are partners in this, and we want to have rules in place that are fair, but we need to do this now. [4:33:36] Councilor Scott: Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thank you. Good [4:33:44] Public commenters (Leslie Gatcombe Hines, Kathy Chopman): evening, Kathy Chopman, Billboard Street. Good evening to the council and our guests, the DEP. I would reiterate what just Chris Kessler, a friend of mine, just said. It's been a long time. I'm tired of coming up here and talking about air, and you're probably tired of hearing me. From tar sands when we talked about and found out just how much the emissions were in the city. I developed asthma,, as I've said before, from living here. I don't have a family history. None of my family has it. But after living here for about 15 years or more, I developed asthma. We have the highest rate and one of the highest rates in the country, one of the highest rates of childhood asthma. That's another lung disease. There's another issue that happens with our bad air here. It's about time we did something. As we learned during tar sands, the Clean Air Act allows cities to do that. Cities can make their own emission standards, can make their own enforcement, et cetera. And back then, the city of Lincoln, which had a mill, and doesn't anymore, but a paper mill, they had their own emissions. They had their own enforcement, et cetera. So they had actually done that. They worked with the paper company. However, you don't have to do that. But it's time that we actually did something. We keep hearing these studies. We keep hearing how and we know that the rates are higher and 2019 as Chris and others mentioned we had the EPA. Again with Global and Sprague because what they had been admitting more than they were supposed to for years and the DP knew about it. That was a reminder in the Portland Press-Herald today about that. And so I'm concerned. We haven't gotten any data. I haven't seen any anyway today about what are the admissions now. Are they still high like they were then? And what happens when they admit at the time? Even the EPA just slapped, gave him a slap on the wrist and a little tiny fee. But we need to do something because people are sick, people do have cancer. We need to do something about our zoning. Are we going to be building where we know that there's high admission standards? We definitely need to put the special fence line and what you're going to do in other places in those areas where we know that the comprehensive plan and you've already approved as a council having high building there, then we need to make sure that it's safe for the people. If it isn't, then we need to look at what the buffers are. We need to investigate that and we need to make these companies accountable to provide the technology that is available right now, but they don't want to do it. Why? Because it's extra money. Why would they do it if they don't have to? So it's up to us to do something. If we don't, then it's on us. I know for a fact that a lot of the people that live around Bug Light neighbors have had cancer. They've died from it. So it's time to act. Stop talking. Stop getting data. We know it's just time to do it. Thanks. Thank you. [4:37:04] Councilor Pryde: Hi, Julia Edwards, Dawson Street. I came down here initially because there were questions after the first public comment that some of my neighbors and friends didn't get to ask. And so I want to make sure to get those out because I'm about to burst into tears after everything I have heard. Big one, with all the power that we as a city have, you have, we put you there, you have this power to make the restrictions more restrictive. Who is advising you on that? Because we want to make sure that you have the best environmental land use attorney on the planet. If we can't get them, at least in the state of Maine. So make sure that we have the best on this particular issue. Not a whole lot of confidence that is the case at the moment. So that's number one. And we want to have a very public accounting of who that's going to be and what their credentials are. So I worked at the Dairy Queen for 10 years in Cache Corner in high school and college. It's how I paid for college. I spent probably like 9, 10 hours a day there. Turns out that's the worst area in the city. Not surprised that the west side, Cache Corner, is the worst resulting area in all of that. There are some things that I want. I want my kids to be at a preschool where they're not looking at the tanks and smelling them almost daily. The remark was made that there are not tanks near those fence lines. You don't have to be on the fence line to smell what's going on. My kids have been there every day for three years now. The home we live in after the Catholic Church allowed for clear cutting and collusion with the airport and whoever else it was, can't even remember. We smell it now multiple times a week, smelled it maybe one or two times a month prior to that. I can't even see the tanks and we can't go outside anymore when it is that bad. So I would invite anyone doing testing on the fence line to actually come to my home and try and sit outside when we are trying to just be in our home we all get headaches we all feel nauseous dizziness like yeah you name it we've got it and we do not live on the tanks on the on the line can't even see them so I'd love to have a coffee shop where I can walk to it but for now I'll settle for not having my children be poisoned weekly. I would love to not have a police station in lieu of a coffee shop, but like I'll settle for not having my children poisoned. The things that you prioritize in your positions of power speak volumes. So please think very hard about the choices you make and the experience of people that aren't directly on the fence line, thank you. you. Eliza Rule, I live on [street]. Growing up, I would drive past the tanks on Nutter Road on my way to my grandparents' house. These monstrous structures always felt ominous to me, but there was always the assumption that they were safe enough, though I always felt an underlying uncertainty. Fast forward to 2015 when I moved to South Portland. One morning, I stepped outside and was confronted with the overwhelming smell of petroleum. I felt deep worry that what that meant for us in our new home as well as everyone else in South Portland. I felt unsafe. Since then fumes have disrupted our ability to enjoy summer night air when we open the windows at night. Too many mornings I have awoken to the heavy scent of petroleum. I always jump out of bed to close the house up, but then I'm left wondering if doing so is trapping the bad air inside the house. In recent years the smell seemed to decrease and often I only note faint sense on the breeze. Even so the odors are a constant reminder of the harmful chemicals in our air. Just yesterday morning I again noticed stronger smells outside my back door. This is all to say that if this is impacting me a mile away the impacts are much farther reaching than the neighborhoods in which these tanks occupy. I acknowledge that the main CDC reports that it found no acute impacts to our health. This information has been repeated by the media and the city, but when we continue to hear about residents experiencing physical symptoms there is something missing. And I'm not suggesting we need further testing. Rather, I believe the truth we seek remains obscured by the way the data has been presented. Because when we only consider every measured chemical in isolation, I believe we are missing a critical piece of the puzzle. What happens when many chemicals below a predetermined threshold of risk add up to a whole stew of dangerous gases? Furthermore, while I understand the departments are following standard practices for calculating risk, focusing on averages obscures some of the most important data that could explain people's symptoms. While the average benzene level at the South Portland terminal last year was 2.86 micrograms per cubic meter, there was a 14-day period when benzene reached an average of 14.8 micrograms per cubic meter. The main guideline is 1.28. Imagine what levels our community experienced during those two weeks if 14.8 was the average. Over the last several weeks I've learned a lot from the folks who have organized on this issue for years. In the past I felt like this was too big of an issue for me to wrap my head around and now it feels like too big of an issue not to. Please stay curious about what so many people or why so many people are feeling well. Stay concerned about the increased cancer risk to our community but don't delay mitigation insisting on more testing. We know the air is bad. Thank you. Hi. [4:43:26] Public commenters (Chelsea Bien, Anna): My name is Anna. I live on [street] in South Portland. I'm one of those people who lives in the fence line area. I guess I'm like, I don't know, tanks are like where the back wall is from my house. So it just like breaks my heart when I hear like, oh, the step out study, we're gonna find out how shitty it is in that area. It's like, I know how bad it is. I live there. I got involved in this in 2019. My kid was born in 2018, and I learned about all the, I could smell it obviously. It's like everyone know who lives there knows, but I lost my train of thought. Oh, yeah, so my kid was born, and I was like, oh, my God, I have to move out of this awful city. Like, it's poison. And then I, so I got involved with Protect South Portland people, sent messages. I got all these, like, vanilla responses about how it's fine. And, like, these companies are allowed to dump 500 fucking tons of VOCs into the air, and it's crazy to me. It's crazy that there's any like acceptable amount that we're just like, oh well, it's not that poisonous. It's like, it is, it's, if it's poisonous, it's poisonous. Watching this like tiny little kid, you know, breathing in poison air, I could come in my windows. I did the same thing the last person said. I would like close down the house, and then I'm like, oh no, I trapped it all in. I got a bunch of plants because it was like, oh, plants can emit it. 's like it's so crazy. We don't need more data, we need to do something about it, and we can do something about it from what all these smart people tell me. So it's just time to do something about it. I don't want to have more numbers to look at so that my anxiety about like, oh, how bad is it actually, like, can I open my windows, do I need to move, will anyone buy my house because it's like in a poison area, like, oh, we can't build new homes close to the fence line. What is anyone who lives in the fence, like, near the fence line supposed to do? It's crazy. Thank you. Can [4:45:59] Mayor Tipton: I talk again? No, not if on the same. Is there anyone else who would like to? Okay, wellest [4:46:20] Speaker AR (unidentified): of all, Ocean View Avenue. I just want to start by saying we're not stupid, and we know, you know, that we're not stupid, and we don't think you're stupid either. And so it's a very bitter pill to hear state officials come up here, one of whom didn't answer a single question, you all know that one, of whom talked down to us the entire time. Any other, I guess, was fine. We pay their salaries, we breathe the air that they allowed to get dirty, they, we raise our kids in the air that they're ruining, or at least Permitting others to ruin the folks over there. I'm still looking at you, mayor. The folks over there are paid a lot of money to make sure that we keep breathing it, and we are told that these acute guidelines are what matter, or that these extremely isolated samples are what matter. We're not stupid. You didn't need an extra study about flock. You didn't need an extra study about ice. You did the right thing. You can do the right thing again. We trust you. We believe in you, and we don't think you're stupid. I wouldn't have mentioned this except someone else mentioned it, at least one other person. I love this place tremendously. I specifically chose this place because I love it. And I think all the time about if I can stay here, not for myself, but because I'm responsible for two people who will live with the consequences of my choices and the actions of those folks and the inactions of these, and hopefully not the inaction of all of you. So, I really, hate being the cheap pathos guy here, but I would encourage you to do the right thing again because we know that you can do it, and you've proven it, and we elect you to do that. And you all live here. Unlike those folks, you live here. You know. We all know. It's so obvious. And the idea that someone can come from out of town and tell us that it's no big deal is the most insulting poultry excrement I've ever heard in my life. So I guess ultimately I don't have that much else to say except please remember that these guidelines that we are supposedly although I would say dubiously under still value our lives at an order of magnitude less than the Massachusetts governor or government values theirs, and the same goes for New York State, and the same goes for Michigan, the same goes for a number of other states. I'm picking states that are relatively comparable. My life's not worth one-tenth of some guy in Massachusetts, no offense, but come on. All right, thanks again. Just remember, like, you've got concerned citizens against paid stooges. Thank you. Thank you. [4:49:24] Councilor Pryde: Hi, Lucy Perkins. I live in South Portland. I'm reading this on behalf of someone who can speak. I asked AI, and is there any level of benzene that is safe to breathe? The response, No level of benzene is considered safe to breathe. I worried the question a little differently, and again, AI generated, "No, there's no completely safe level of benzene exposure." Even though agencies set legal or recommended limits, these numbers are management thresholds, not guaranteed so safety. Regulars, regulators establish these cutoffs to lower severe disease rates in industrial settings, not because breathing benzene at those levels is risk-free. I'll admit I'm surprised that AI would generate something like that. When comparing South Portland tanks farms to those statewide, are there others abutting neighborhoods like us? If not, the cancer risk cannot be compared nor carry the same weight to share space on a graph. The gravity of our situation here in South Portland is heavy, and we are tired of hearing that nothing can be done. Since the monitoring was intermittent, we all know the data is underreported and did not capture all the petroleum deliveries when levels spike. Like, it is really laughable to hear that we need more testing to dig down further or do the step-out testing. Like, how have we even gotten to a point of action yet? Have we not gotten to a point of action yet? These tank farms are yet again operating as usual, and the residents sit and wait and continue to be harmed. Can the state enact the tanks to have the safest, highest safety standards? Chris Kessler, yes to making that change on a state level. Can the city require modifications to the tanks? Yes to drafting the ordinance that Dave mentioned. Can there be an uprising and the residents of South Portland start a class action lawsuit? Not sure, but perhaps we need to do it all to make a statement because this has gone on long enough. Stop the buffer discussion, redirect the change to be made by the tank farms. Residents have put up with their hazards for long enough. It's time for them to become an active participant and responsible neighbor in our community. I just want to add that people have been organizing around this for years, many of whom are in the room and have an incredible amount of knowledge and data that they probably wish they didn't have to have. People are still organizing around this, come join us, we're working with Protect South Portland, other community members, and we really hope to continue this conversation and push for what community members want. Thank you all so much, thank you. [4:51:41] Public commenters (Barbara Dow Nucci, PJ Craigan): PJ Craigan, 1300 feet away from Sunoco tank farm. The things that strike me is if you take this entire data set and you put it in a vehicle and you drive it 70 miles down the road, pretty much all of it is concerning and would raise alarms in nearby states. I think, and as I mentioned before, more than just Massachusetts, other states just have simply better safety regulations around air. The second thing is really problematic with this particular presentation, and I respect, I respect all the DEP and everybody involved here, but we're here to critique and we want better air, is that this whole presentation went on without the DEP telling us whether or not these facilities were operating at their potential to admit. Many of them haven't been, although I did send emails to the DEP to find out their potential to admit versus how much they admitted in 2025, and that's not available yet. But 2024, 2023, a number of years prior, most of these facilities didn't emit at their full potential. But yet we see these data sets without that background information. Like that's problematic, very problematic, because you all are decision makers trying to make the best safe community for the rest of us without that essential information. Information, and it's not like you weren't asked by the community to please provide that information during this presentation, that's problematic. The other problematic issues are, I'm seven years into this battle, okay, I was one of those people who went to the state legislature and worked with Senator Carney and others to pass the fence line monitoring bills, Councillor Pride also participated in that, also our city manager wrote testimony in favor of our bill. But the problem, no problem there. But now what we have is these data sets we always find out after. When we had three lawsuits, we found out after. After we had been exposed for years. When we get a bad data set, we find out after. It's always after. And the solution is always the same. The solution is we need more testing. It's always the same. We need more testing. We're seven years into more testing, and we still have bad air. So the solution that I hope that all of you focus incredibly hard on is how to make us get less emissions. We don't want these exposures. Can DEP come to us next time with actual solutions that mitigate this problem, reduce the emissions? That's what we want. We want you to come back again and give us 10 options to reduce the emissions clinicians, so we don't have to show up like this anymore. We've had cancer survivors show up tonight. We don't want that anymore. Thank you. [4:54:47] Mayor Tipton: Thank you very much. Hi, [4:54:53] Public commenters (Amy Piscopo, Shelby Layton): I'm Shelby Layton, Stanley Street. I'm fairly new to this fight, and I appreciate all the organizing that has gone on for years to get us to the point where we are having this monitoring. But respectfully, I don't need this data. We are all here in this room because we know something is wrong. We know that our air smells bad a lot of the time. We know that people are getting sick. You've heard all these stories from individuals. We all know, you all live in South Portland, you know that certain times of night, certain times of day, you walk outside side and the air just doesn't feel right. And we don't need to wait for more data and more data and more data to listen to our eyes and our ears and our noses and what they are telling us. And I just want to sort of tell a story about a city council that actually has done something because they were worried about the environment. In the city of Boulder, Colorado, and the county that Boulder is in, the city looked around and said these oil companies are causing climate change, they're harming our residents because they're causing climate change, the same oil companies that are right here in South Portland polluting our air and also, by the way, causing climate change right here. And the city of Boulder looked at that and said we want to do something, and they filed a public nuisance suit against the oil companies for causing climate change that was harming their communities. And they've brought the oil companies all the way up to the Supreme Court and made them defend their role in climate change, have gotten reams and reams of documents about those companies' role in climate change. And they are probably going to win at the U.S. Supreme Court. And they won at the Colorado Supreme Court. And so I just want to encourage you for a minute to think outside the box a little bit about what the city could be doing about this and not just look at how can we regulate this? How can we allow these companies to continue operating in South Portland? How can we allow these companies to keep polluting our air but just at lower levels? Let's think big. Let's think, how do we get these companies out of South Portland? How do we get these companies to pay the residents that they've harmed for the harm that they've caused? And, you know, look at ideas, get creative, ask other cities, just do more than simply say, you know, you can pollute but just a little bit less, or we're going to be watching you a little bit more this time. I really, you know, I think it could be either all of us against you guys trying to get you to do stuff, or it could be all of us together, us and you against these oil corporations, and I really hope that it's the latter. Thank you. Hi, [4:58:02] James LaPlante: James LaPlante. I'm at 1490 Broadway. So I've lived in South Portland for about 25 years. I've bought three properties in the city. I love South Portland. I love being a South Portland resident. I live in the Bermuda Triangle of bad air. Cash Corner is awful. We get hit with the oil tanks. We have diesel trains that sit out on the overpass all day and rev their engines at maximum throttle, and I have to close my windows because my house fills up with diesel fumes. I bought a personal air monitor a while ago that gives me like data on what's going on, and it is constantly telling me that my air quality is terrible. That's just so much fun to watch those charts constantly letting me know about that. When these tanks were built, cigarette companies were telling us that cigarettes were healthy. And then we discovered the cigarettes were not healthy. And the cigarette companies knew the cigarettes weren't healthy. And it took forever to get that information out to the public. And when we got that information, we changed the laws. We regulated the companies. And then we also thought about the fact that secondhand smoke was dangerous. So you can't smoke in buildings. You can't smoke in the school. You cannot smoke in areas where people are going to be hit with these chemicals. These oil companies are no different. They do not care. They know damn well how their chemicals impact us and what health impacts that has. Their motivation is to make profit. Their motivation is not to be a good neighbor. We want not just the individuals in South Portland, but we want these corporations to behave like good neighbors. And a good neighbor doesn't poison you. A good neighbor looks at the emissions that are coming out of their tanks, and they apply the best possible technology to capture and remediate that chemical so that it is not leaching into the air and into our neighborhood and poisoning people. These companies make a lot of money. If putting capture technology on here is gonna break the bank and put them out of business, I, you know, they, that can't be. We need to apply pressure on them, financial pressure, regulatory pressure, so that they change their habits. Because right now it's just the cost of doing business. They violate, they get a little fine slapped on them, that's much less expensive than putting on this equipment. Seconds, we need to make it so painful that putting on this equipment makes financial sense for them. That's how you work with corporations. It has to make financial sense. All right, thank you. Thank you very much. [5:00:51] Public commenters (Edward Reiner, Peter Stanton): Peter Stanton, Deke Street. There's a lot of emotion in the room, and I think it's important to recognize it, but I also, I guess I'm more of a science person, and I want to respect that we did get some interesting information tonight, and the studies that are proposed are useful, but we know already, I think, that there's two real hot spots, and I guess it is incumbent on you guys to think about what this city can do, and we have to advocate at the level of the state. What can we do to make some progress? When we heard tonight that newness gets better emissions control technology than nearness to people, that's kind of sick. So we should be thinking about nearness, and we have a lot of it, especially down on Elm Street, and thinking about how we can ask for, demand, frankly, better technology to control emissions that we know are there. I can't even bother to look at my nose, I guess. I also want to agree with the folks that talked about the eastern waterfront, where we do have development opportunities and we have some data. We need more. And if there's going to be a secondary study that's looking at distance, we need to do it there as well as at the places where we already have hotspots. I mean, it feels to me like there's three key areas that we should be looking at. Anyway, I think that's everything I've got. Oh, the other point I wanted to make was that the companies that got brought to court, Sprague and Global, you look at them, they're surrounded by green dots on the map. I think that tells you that making these companies uncomfortable 30 seconds is an important way to get some change, and taking them to court is it one way to make them uncomfortable. We have people who are pretty good at public protests in this city that might make companies uncomfortable. Setting up our own infrastructure at the city level to set us a higher standard can make them uncomfortable, but we need to really be looking at that. Thank you. Thanks very much. Is there anyone [5:04:02] Mayor Tipton: else? All right, we're going to close down public comment with appreciation for everyone's comments. 1109. All right, one thing that had Milan had mentioned is whether the council would want to say that we would talk about the potential setbacks idea in a workshop. I don't know if there's any appetite for that. Yes, first I think there might have been questions [5:04:35] Councilor Pryde: asked by the people. Okay, and also I'm going to make a motion that we continue this meeting because under our rules since after 11 we do have to make that motion to continue the meeting. I'll make the motion. All right, okay. [5:04:52] Mayor Tipton: I have more questions. Please answer the questions that [5:04:56] Councilor Pryde: we have from. Can we dispose of the motion to continue the meeting first [5:05:00] Speaker B (unidentified): because otherwise we can't? Oh, I thought I'm going to make this motion now to [5:05:06] Mayor Tipton: continue the meeting before after some of these folks who are here tonight and might not be able to attend another meeting get. I thought that I heard you saying it more like continue and yes. No, thank you for that motion. Who seconds [5:05:29] Councilor Scott: it? I just like to plant the rule actually says I don't sound me be [5:05:34] Mayor Tipton: introduced. I'll withdraw my motion. That's fine, and I and I will attempt to reinstall my own brain. All right, we have questions to answer. Yes, and as I [5:05:48] Councilor Matthews: start it's gonna answer one of the questions. Our legal counsel Adrienne Kendall, special legal counsel for air quality matters, is here tonight in case the council also does have questions for him. So probably a lot of these are going to be for DEP CDC, so I'm going to throw it out there and I'll let you all point fingers as to who gets to go. The first question and there were some answer there were some questions asked during the first public comment period, some of those got answered during Presentations or otherwise, and so I'm just going to ask the ones that, to me, still seem to be outstanding. One of the first ones was, why does DEP use a lower threshold than, for example, Massachusetts DEP or CDC? [5:06:51] Public commenters (Mark Johnson, Tom Simmons): I can start from just a point of view of the higher level kind of policy. What I mentioned earlier is the, you know, decades of chemical risk assessment policy in the United States coming from EPA is cancer risk is set at typically one in ten thousand to one in a million, and it's up to policymakers such as yourself, state legislators, the federal government, to decide on what policy they want to adopt for those cancer risks. Other states may adopt one in a million, other states may adopt one in ten thousand, other states may adopt one in a hundred thousand, we happen to have a policy for DEP that they've adopted one in a hundred thousand here. [5:07:36] Councilor Matthews: There were questions about how many homes are when within a thousand feet, we'll have to get that information, that's not information we have readily available. I also don't have information right now on how much revenue and property taxes that the tank farms pay, so we'll we'll try to track that down or we will. Is there, I don't remember the specific question, it was something around it, can there be a notification system for emissions for when people need to know to take cover or close their windows or something, is that anything DEP gets involved in or CDC? [5:08:19] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Sometimes not in not in this particular case, so sometimes when there is an event and we go out and monitor related to an event, then where we're kind of watching every second to see what those concentrations look like. But in South Portland, we're looking at, you know, with the HAPs canisters, we're looking at 24-hour averages with the cans, and then those aren't analyzed for a while, and with the fence line monitoring it's a two-week period, and then we don't actually see those results until the next quarter, and with the S pods we are actually keeping a very close eye on those, and when we see high concentrations, by the time we see them they've dropped down, so they're they're kind of spiky, there's a lot of noise in those data. We do reach out to the facilities to try to determine what sort of activity has been going on, but again, by the time we see those data, those concentrations have already dropped, so there wouldn't be any sort of action we could take there, so [5:09:22] Councilor Matthews: We've talked obviously almost exclusively about air quality. Does the DEP has the DEP ever done any soil quality testing or groundwater or contamination from tank operations? I don't know, Eric, do you [5:09:39] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): happen to know? Yeah. [5:09:52] Eric Kennedy: Sorry for the long pause for my answer is we don't. We're not involved in that from the Bureau of Air Quality standpoint. That would be something we'd have to ask our Bureau of Remediation folks there. [5:10:13] Councilor Matthews: Was a question about can the city be informed about the number of permitted VCUs, the location, contact information, permitted pollution limits for all of those? [5:10:27] Eric Kennedy: so all of that information is available in the air mission licenses for the facilities which are on our website you can search by town you can search by facility but all that information should be on in the air mission licenses there [5:10:49] Councilor Matthews: Was a question about for the step out study seeking money from terminals to help fund that. I think I can answer that one. That's that's not a requirement DEP can impose. That's something that actually the city would have to and will be seeking if that's something that the council wants to move forward with funding from the terminal, those two terminal operators to conduct that study, because it's not anything DEP has funding for or can compel, is my understanding. Is that correct? And then headspace there's a question for headspace monitoring, why a two-year wait on that? It's [5:11:35] Eric Kennedy: been a long process to try and coordinate between the DEP, the city, and the terminals. I think Scott, you probably know how many times we've met, but I remember at least two meetings we've had [5:11:52] Councilor Matthews: jointly. And I'm sorry, Adrian, anything you want dad on that? I don't want to put you on the spot, but I know we've had, I am putting on the spot, thank [5:12:19] Adrian Kendall Norman: you Scott. Good evening members of council. Adrian Kendall Norman, answer Troy, special counsel on these air matters. With respect to the MOU, it has been a long and drawn-out path, and significant aspects of the delay have been part partially due to the number of terminals and getting them all together to coordinate, coordinating with their responses, drafts that we have been circulating, and there have been multiple drafts circulated, get all of their input, and so that's been part of the part of the Issue part of the issue related to technical issues, and we had members of the CAAC participate in the meetings, participating in the review. Mr. Flacco was here, has also been part of those, and the probably the biggest part of the delay has been related to the very technical aspects of elements of the review, in particular in the protocol, the enactment of a protocol for the review and the analysis of the headspace, and that is presently with Main DP. We've had, we've gone through several rounds of That part of it too has been the methodology has been to have the city and meaning CAC members with their commentary going back and forth with Main DEP to have alignment on that side before going to the terminals to limit the amount of back and forth and I guess disparate opinions in terms of what's being presented to the terminals, so that's That's that's the process and that's the cost for the delay. [5:13:56] Councilor Matthews: What are the emissions near Global and Sprague, and is there anything DEP wants to add about the EPA lawsuit and anything in that regard? Are they still in exceedance from when the [5:14:15] Eric Kennedy: 2019 lawsuit? So I do want to clarify something on that is that the loss the wasn't a lawsuit, but the case that the enforcement case that EPA brought against Sprague and Global were based on their potential emissions being higher than what was in their license, so they had recommendations as part of the consent decree that they had with both those facilities to amend for us to amend their licenses to put throughput limits on those facilities to better match what their potential emissions will be. Any [5:15:03] Councilor Matthews: and have the missions been that they've been reported, have they been within? Yes, Scott, can I just address that one point? Sorry, [5:15:15] Adrian Kendall Norman: the EPA in the lawsuits, because a couple of statements were made by the public relating to the EPA lawsuits, and the throughput limits that were attached exceeded any throughput that had been going through those terminals in the first place. The EPA was not there to limit emissions from those terminals. Those lawsuits were related to ozone, and the money, the funding that came from that went to wood stove improvement programs, which so that people would have wood stoves with improved combustion. Scott Morelli and I had protracted negotiations with EPA to try to get them to focus on our issues, and they would not. The point about, I also want to address one additional point while you're, well, I have the microphone, and that relates to the odor control VOC controls that were falsely characterized as VOC controls at Global and Sprague. Those were there, they were in the consent agreements with EPA, not because EPA wanted them, because the city insisted, and we negotiated those specifically with those terminals. They were deliberately not characterized as VOC reduction technology, but because one, because we had, if you remember some of those meetings, they the odors were the primary concern at the initial set of meetings, so that was the focus for that. The other reason that we didn't is because we didn't want the terminals to get credit for voc reductions, it really so that potentially if they had voc reductions they could potentially increase throughput because they would be offset, and so they were specifically not to get credit for that, and so it was it was stated here that those of voc reduction concessions, that's not the case. Thanks. [5:17:14] Councilor Matthews: Adrian, there's a question about other parts of the state, the like Bangor or Searsport, are there cases there where there are tank facilities in dense neighborhoods or near dense neighborhoods like in South Portland? Yeah. [5:17:35] Public commenters (Victoria Libby, Unidentified): Not as many, so as we saw on the maps today. I didn't show you the maps in other parts of the state, but those maps in other parts of the state are in the report, and so you can see where those locations are where a monitor exceeded the ambient air guideline, and you can see on the map whether or not there are homes around there, and the answer is not as many. There is, I think, one home closer to Buckeye Bangor, but it's it's it's really not that close. Did you say one? What's that, I'm sorry, did you say one? No, there aren't really, there aren't neighborhoods near those facilities like there are here. It's you know like, make sure I heard, along the main road there's you know like literally [5:18:17] Councilor Matthews: a house. Yeah, thank you, and I think the last question I have are any of the facilities operating at their full potential to emit, believe [5:18:32] Eric Kennedy: any of the facilities are operating at their full potential to admit? No, and it hasn't been for years. Okay. [5:18:45] Mayor Tipton: It's it's not I was calling attention to what Milan had said to the counselors in case we wanted to say we're not going to discuss the buffer idea tonight, but if we're if people think that's a terrible idea and they'd like to discuss that, let's just leave it on the table. [5:19:09] Councilor Scott: Yeah, if I'm in a workshop? [5:19:11] Mayor Tipton: Yeah, I mean, we could do both. We can go at it now and then say, we also need to have a workshop. I just was wanting to get a little feedback on that. [5:19:20] Councilor Scott: Well, one thing we could do is just say, we're gonna have a workshop. But if we do that, can we add other topics that relate to this to the workshop in addition to the buffer? Because I have a few other ideas that I would. [5:19:34] Mayor Tipton: Sure. Sure. I'm not at all looking to cut off council conversation right now. And in fact, I would, my feeling is that members of the public expect us to have a conversation right now and hear some of what we would like to say. Harder, Scott. Counselor Scott. [5:19:52] Councilor Pryde: I just have a thought that I think there's probably a lot that we could discuss tonight and a lot that would need to be discussed at a future workshop regarding maybe buffers zoning and Steps that might be taken past this. We're not gonna solve all these problems tonight. So I do think that having another workshop does make sense to cover several of the issues that were brought up. I do think it'd be helpful and I'm happy to just knock out some of my comments and have other counselors kind of go through some thoughts and reactions and see where we can get to maybe by the close of this portion. [5:20:26] Mayor Tipton: I completely agree. Go for the knockout, please, if you're ready. Okay. [5:20:31] Councilor Pryde: Well, first of all, thank you so much for the presenters and the information that was provided. I do hope that we can all be respectful and realize that we're all trying to be humans and do the best that we can, as I believe my colleagues are here this evening. So what I would like to understand and what I think might be the topic of a future action is to understand what the city can do, this may be your expertise, but what the city could do in terms of an ordinance to further regulate require backed or best available control technology and how what that might look like. I'm a little bit cautious of Boulder going up against the Supreme Court and maybe a little less optimistic. I don't really think that we want to take this before the current Supreme Court. So I think I'd like to better understand what are some of the confines of a city action and ordinance if we were to do this as the city of South Portland. I'd also like to better understand if there is complimentary legislation that we can work with the legislature on to support that and make sure that there's some state activity there and that we're not just acting as an individual city in the state of Maine. So that's point one in terms of where the council goes and what I would like to sort of better understand and can flesh out at a further workshop. I appreciate all the analysis that was done to date. I do think that it is important to have all of the data that we can and I do appreciate that there is additional testing that we can continue to do and I don't want to stop that process going forward. I actually took, I think, a lot of comfort from the testing that we are not sort of living in, you know, a forest fire, a toxic cesspool. I do think that there's some comfort that we do not need to move out of our homes, that you know there is an issue here and we need to solve that problem, but I don't believe that we're living in benzene city. So I appreciate the data. Happy to keep doing more testing, but it doesn't really matter to me because I think we all know that we need to actually do something, and whether or not the testing continues is somewhat immaterial. Regarding the buffer, I appreciate that there's this sort of idea that we need to create a buffer in our in our zoning laws coming out of the comprehensive plan. This comprehensive plan is for the next 15 plus years in our city, and if we don't solve this problem in the next two three four years, then forget the next 15, we've failed. So I don't think that buffers are worth it or rational or reasonable. I think that if we don't solve this problem, then again, we've failed. And I think when you apply the logic of a buffer to the fact that there are existing homes within 1,000 feet of these tank farms, it just begs the question of like, well, what do you do with those homes? And are you protecting the future potential residents of this area more than you are the existing homeowners? Do you ask them to evacuate? Do you not allow them to sell their homes to new residents? Do not allow them to build ADUs or expand on their footprint. There's so many issues around the idea of restricting home building and home buying and all of that. I think it is just a little bit of a sort of fool's errand. So that's what I feel about buffers. And then I also just want to say that like we are all consumers and a part of this machine. That is the reason that these tanks are here and that they're still here and that they're still operating. We drive gasoline cars, we heat our homes with oil, wood, natural gas, like these are all benzene causing and we're just we're part of this machine. So please vote on Tuesday if you haven't already. Please think about your environmental impact and please think about ways that systematically we can build a cleaner world for all of us to live in the future. But we're all a part of it. So this is not an us versus them, this is all of us need to figure this out together. And I hope that we can sit down at the table put some pressure on all the parties and make sure that we are all coming to this to figure out the right solutions thank you thank you very much counselor Councilor Scott. Councilor Pride. Sure. I think probably by virtue of my length on the council, I'm a little farther down the road than Councilor Scott is, only to the point where I think that I already know that we can do stuff, and we should. I do want to hear it in a legal opinion. I mean, one of the reasons we're here now is because legal opinions up to this point have said that, you know, if we don't have data and we make laws that they can be challenged based on the lack of data. Well now we have data and I'm very thankful for that data. So thank you for coming and presenting that. I think to me that data is enough. I think that data is enough to support an ordinance that requires greater technology. What technology is actually gonna work? Well I'm not an expert, I don't want to figure that out on my own I'm not gonna do that I we have other people we can employ to do that i think we should do that 's where i am i also agree with counselor scott about the buffer i don't think that's a priority for me because i want to actually protect those people who are already living there within a thousand feet of these terminals from the fumes so let's actually protect them and i think we're going to really harm their property values if we institute this buffer without Protecting them first. I understand it's part of the comp plan, and not everything in the comp plan gets intervention. Some things are prioritized to do, you know, first and second and third. I think that's kind of a back burner part for me. There's other things that are more important, and one of them, you know, as a city, just full priorities, is to protect those residents who live close to the tank farms. I see them from my front yard, and I'm less concerned because Hill Street's not used as much, but still very concerned if ever they started using it all the time. I'm within that zone of heightened benzene, or where it probably would be based on all the pictures I saw. So yeah, I do want to see us require as a municipality best available or best whatever the technology that makes sense is, because I, you know, I've been told by some people that best available won't work for these, and another thing I saw said, well, you can require best available retrofitted technology to older tanks. So I just would like more information there from experts to understand what the best thing to implement. But I think, you know, one thing that's been sort of on the back of my mind about all of this is the cost of the city. But when we do licensing, which I think is the way we need to do this, we can charge fees that pay for the process of licensing. That is the one other source of money we can have in the city. Everything else is property taxes, but licensing, we can charge licensing fees that pay the administrative cost of what we implement. And so if we implementate, if we implement this, and we need experts to go in there and examine the technology to make sure it really is what it purports to be, then we can charge fees to the companies for those experts who go in and inspect the technology. So I think, like I said, I think I'm a little farther down the road on this. I think licensing, creating a new class of license for emitters, our new license for, from a municipal license for emitters in South Portland, that requires them to have certain technology. I also would like a legal opinion to confirm that, but everything I've looked into so far says we can do that. So, and if we can, I'd like [5:28:43] Councilor Scott: to. That's my position. Thank you. Thank you very much, Council Pride. Next, I think we're, I think We're just throwing out some topics that we want to talk about at our next workshop. I want that, I, yeah, I want to say I'm pro, I, we clearly have two terminals where we have significant benzene problems. We need to face up to that. We need to do something about it. I think that we should figure out some strategy, which could possibly be legislation, that if a terminal is within so many feet of homes, and probably 500 because they said today that 500 feet away, the numbers were below the standard, that the terminals have got to use either best available technology or lowest achievable emission rate. I mean, we have got to push to have, we can't say that these terminals have been around forever and therefore they can still have these vapor combustion units that are spewing out pollutants 24 hours a day. And so that for me is really important to try to figure out the best strategy for getting some kind of a better standard applicable to the terminals for their emission control. But in the meantime, I think that within those two terminals, we need to have a development moratorium on any ADUs or any infill. I'm concerned the language that came before us was significant new residential development, but I want to make sure that we don't allow any more residential development in close most proximity to the two tanks that are significantly over the standards until we see if we can get better controls in place. I think we have to do that for public health. I'm just throwing this out for the topics I want to discuss at the workshop. I think that we should, I thought the state had the authority to have licensing fees that would cover the costs of administering the program, and I want to pursue that because I think that the level of expertise, air pollution is complicated. I never shared with you guys that when I first got out of law school, I worked for the state of Connecticut enforcing its air pollution laws, so, and that was ancient history compared to the technology now, but it's very complicated, and I, taking on as a city the requirement to determine whether somebody has best available technology or lowest emission rate and all that is a complex thing to chew. I would prefer to work with the state, have them try to use, and I was impressed tonight with the presentation, by the way, thank you very much. So those are the kinds of things I'm concerned about. I'm also very concerned about the potential to emit. We've got to deal with that because the fact, as has been brought out by people, if these if these things if these sorry tank farms facilities emit what they're licensed to emit, we'll be in much worse shape than we are now. At the same time, we've got a face I'd like to acknowledge that Portland Pipeline is out of business. Every a bit of information we can get is that property will not be used for crude oil storage in the future. So what we have to do, because it's effectively we can't allow any kind of development anywhere near those tanks when they still have their licenses. I'm going on too long. I'll hold it for the workshop. Stay tuned. These are the kinds of thank you what a cliffhanger council. I think we've got I think everybody's just getting some ideas out and then we'll try to focus them on another workshop right yes I it's [5:32:48] Mayor Tipton: It's not time for me to talk yet, I don't think, but what I am sketching is something called the Workshop to Determine Strategies for the Substantial Reduction of Emissions and the Prevention of Health Harm to Residents. Yes. Okay. Yes. Yes. Councillor Matthews? Just real quick. [5:33:11] Councilor Pryde: You know, I've lived here probably longer than most in this room, 60 years next to the tanks. I grew up next to the tanks and you know Portland Pipeline was a big part of my life with all my family my relatives doing making a living off all that and you know I know that there was some concerns I see them I accept them I accept change. I think that Counselor Scott was spot on with everything that she said and I mean everything and I wish I had said it first but yes but I'm also a believer that no good decisions are made after 10 p.m. and for us to make any type of decisions or anything like that right now is absolutely absurd. So that's my thought process but I do look forward to [5:34:03] Mayor Tipton: the workshop. Thank You Councillor Matthews Councillor Walker [5:34:08] Councilor Walker: First I want to thank our presentation our presenters tonight. That was great information and thank you for your thoughtful answers to all of the questions. I want to thank everybody who came out. It was a long night there was as was mentioned a lot of emotion and I continue to be impressed by the amount of knowledge that we have in our community. So thank you for coming here and sharing it with all of us. I with that and knowledge I do I agree with all of my counselors. I really want to see a Workshop, I want to talk about what solutions are. That was all I could think about when I was preparing for this workshop is what can we do, like what can we do, what do we know, what can we do. But I do think that back to the knowledge piece, I think that it is not going to harm us at all to do a both and. So to move forward with specific actions that provide immediate relief really to the residents in terms of feeling safe about the air that we breathe, and also continuing with the step out testing so that we know specifically, especially for neighborhoods like Pearl Street, Pleasantdale, specifically what the harm is, where it stops, and really can that data lead towards, I think it was our hopefully future legislator for my district, the community benefit agreement and the community benefit fund you know, things like that are there, and will that data help inform our citizens in terms of actions that they may want to take as well. So I think it's a both and. Thank [5:35:51] Mayor Tipton: you, counselor. Thank you. Excuse me. [5:35:53] Speaker AM (unidentified): Cancer Walker, one of the W counselors, and I really do think we should also do have monitoring next to where, what they would call the shipyard district, because that is a potential for growth that people really want to see, but until we can mitigate the admissions, and it's not just that the high admitters, it's all of this air moves, it doesn't just stay in one place. It sometimes drops heavier in some, but to say that these, it needs mitigation for every tank that is storing oil, and even tanks that are empty, because you had talked about, I don't know if it was the Hill Street, there's still some oil in one of the tanks. So in fact it was like a great big farm, but it was only one with it, and that was creating that much of a problem or a reading of concern. All of these admissions need to be mitigated. We need it to get it to, as Natalie said, to the lowest achievable amount that each tank can have. It's, it's not just the problem ones, they're all a problem. And to not recognize that is, I mean we all, it moves, it moves. And I grew up in the Rumford area, and the incidence of cancer was unbelievable. And it seemed lower on the charts that you were showing, and since it is owned by a Chinese company, it smells again, it is belching again, they're having that low cloud again. I, yeah, that's all I have to say. Yes, we need another workshop. We need to have experts tell us what is the best technology for the different tanks that, but we need to mitigate all of them, all their admissions. Thank you. I [5:38:00] Mayor Tipton: Also want to thank you for coming here and bringing us this data, and to recognize that we sit in different seats. We sit in the seats charged with the direct protection of our neighbors and our community, and your data will help us do that. I will say that when I heard the description of potentially doing the step testing, step up, step down, step around, it was described we're interested in learning how the concentrations change when you move away from the fence line, and what I instantly thought about was all of our neighbors who live there and cannot move away from the fence line. So I began to wonder, well, for them, you know, why would we pursue this testing? So I think that we'll talk about that further. In addition to the people who live at fence line, we have nearly 13,000 people in South Portland who live within a mile of Sitco. That's nearly half the residents of our city, so everyone is paying attention to this, and we heard that everyone is counting on this council to take real action. So I am, I am really grateful to my fellow counselors for getting us to the point of saying we need a workshop to talk about what our plan is, what teeth we have in terms of city policy, city ordinance, state statute, and I would also add to that DEP licensing. You're licensing them for a lot of pollution of our community, and I wish that could become different. So I look forward to our workshop. All right. Are we done here? Do we want to say that the rest of our meeting is not really—did you, Mr. City Manager, usually the most important part of the rest of the meeting is if you have more to tell us. I do not. All right. Well, I think then if no one minds, I think our residents are talked out. Let's have a motion to adjourn. Not having—sorry, are you closing? Second. Move by Counselor Pride. Do we have a second on a motion to adjourn? I don't—yes. Adjourn the meeting and put over the rest. Yeah, yes. All in favor? Well, do we have a second? I thought we had a second down here. Yes. [5:40:41] Georgia Daveris: Yes. Are we [5:40:43] Councilor Pryde: adjourning? No worries. No,. Okay. You want to take them home? I will have enough candy in my house after this weekend.