Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Council of Davis. Here. Council of Kellogg. Council of York. Present. Council of Callahan. Here.
[0:07] Speaker B (unidentified): Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag.
[0:11] Speaker C (unidentified): I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.
Public Comment
[0:28] Speaker B (unidentified): The first 15 minutes of any special meeting are set aside as a public forum for the public to address counsel on matters pertaining to city business. Anyone wishing to address the council I ask you rise Go to the podium and state your name and address for the record Please remember that speakers are allowed up to five minutes to comment as a reminder from city code persons present at council Meetings are cautioned to refrain from applause or other expressions of approval or disapproval of any statements made or actions taken persons speaking at such public forums shall strive to be accurate in their statements, avoid personal attacks and in your endos, and conduct themselves in a respectful manner expected of all meeting participants. And for public comment, we're happy to take public comment on any matters pertaining to city business. We will have a robust public discussion after the presentation as well, so if there are questions about stormwater the utility any of those topics the public comment period right now is not your only time to engage and to ask questions or to provide comment public forum is now open does anyone wish to address council any correspondence anyone received the public forum is now closed and the purpose of this special meeting is to hear an update from right Pierce regarding the stormwater management in the City of Rockland. I will defer to my City Manager in terms of an introduction and any opening remarks. Sure, as we know
[2:18] Speaker A (unidentified): we've been working on the stormwater utility well over a year, probably close to two years now, and I think we're coming down to the final end of it. tonight we have a presentation on ordinance and policies that give Council some time to look at it over and before we put it on the November or December agenda but tonight we have Owen, Jess, and Ryan here from Wright-Pierce and I'll let you guys take it over excellent thank you 're gonna share
[3:29] Speaker D (unidentified): I'm going to start things off for us here. My name is Ryan Wingard. I'm a vice president over at Wright-Pierce and here to support Owen and Jess in this effort. So we're here once again to talk about the stormwater utility for the City of Rockland and specifically getting into and digging into the details on ordinances and policies. So this is really getting into the meat of the matter and what you all are going to be thinking about as we move this forward. So we have a little bit of an agenda here that you can see on the screen, so we're going to go through some introductions and look at some of the draft ordinance language and some of the draft ordinance concepts as well as the credit policy and abatement policies and again to get into a discussion about the differences between those two and then talk through next steps where do we where do we go from here and then we'll open it up for questions so who you have before you right now we've been in front of the council on a few different occasions through workshops and other meetings but like I said Ryan wind guard I cut my teeth doing stormwater work and so this is kind of near and dear to my heart and looking forward to bringing this to fruition at some point for the city if that's the way we go here I'll let Owen introduce
[4:59] Speaker E (unidentified): himself or own chaplains on the project manager on this study and worked on a number of different Rockland projects including the stormwater master plan a few years ago in some stormwater sewer separation projects, culvert projects, that were kind of a result of that master plan.
[5:19] Speaker C (unidentified): Can I just ask that you speak in the mic to make sure? Sure, yeah. How's that?
[5:23] Speaker E (unidentified): Better. All right. So, yeah, I'm the project manager for this project. I worked on a number of different Rockland stormwater projects over the last few years.
[5:32] Speaker F (unidentified): Sorry, I need to push the button. Nope. I'm Jess. Hi, I'm Jess Richard. I'm a strategic funding manager at Ray Pierce. I have been doing stormwater, water, and sewer rate studies since 2007, and I've been doing some of the background work on this project.
[5:47] Speaker D (unidentified): And when she says some of it, she's been doing a lot of it. All right. So what I wanted to do is give everyone an update on where we are with the timeline of the project. As Tom mentioned, it feels like we've been doing this for quite a bit of time, and we actually have. have. So we did original outreach and planning and scheduling for the study back in 2024 and stretching into 2025. We refined some budget and projections in 2025 and 2026, which ultimately led to the recommendation to move forward with the stormwater utility in the feasibility study so we're in October 26 right now and what we're doing today is presenting the bylaws regulations and credit policy to you I think you've received some draft versions of those and looking forward to receiving comments and questions about those draft policies so we have been asked to give a quick overview of what a stormwater utility is I think it's worth noting that not everyone may have attended the meetings in the past and are wondering what a stormwater utility is so felt it worthwhile to revisit that so a stormwater utility essentially is a way to create a funding source to fund stormwater improvement projects with the city it helps out with administration and project management assists with regulatory compliance and engineering and planning there's always operation and maintenance activities that need to occur with a stormwater utility so the stormwater utility provides that funding source for the operation and maintenance and then PROBABLY THE BIGGEST THING IS THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS THAT ARE REQUIRED. OWEN MENTIONED THAT HE HAD BEEN INVOLVED IN THE STONEWATER MASTER PLANNING. WELL, THAT STONEWATER MASTER PLAN IDENTIFIED SEVERAL PROJECTS, SEVERAL MILLION DOLLARS WORTH OF STONEWATER IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS THAT WE FELT ARE NEEDED IN ORDER TO IMPROVE THE CITY'S STONEWATER SYSTEM. SO THOSE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS NEED TO BE FUNDED SOMEHOW. in a stormwater utility is a good way to fund those types of projects it provides a stable funding source as well doesn't rely on grants or you know bonds or anything like that it's a stable funding source that the city can rely on year after year and then repairing and replacement of infrastructure that's already there our observations are that there's quite a few stormwater infrastructure components that are out there that are in disrepair or maybe even undersized that should be increased in capacity so those are the types of projects that stormwater utility would fund so we're going to get into this a little bit more but in essence the stormwater utility is a charge imposed on property owners for stormwater runoff generation and we determine how much stormwater is generated from a property by looking at impervious area and so when I say impervious area is talking about roofs it's talking about driveways is talking about paved areas on your property so anything that increases the amount of stormwater and doesn't allow the stormwater to infiltrate into the ground is what we're trying to measure here. The interesting thing about a stormwater utility is that it offers a little bit of flexibility for the users in the form of credits. So if you are a user that generates a lot of stormwater at your site, there's an opportunity to achieve some credits against that stormwater fee if you were to install some best management practices or stormwater best management practices on your on your site but the biggest thing is we want this to be fair and equitable the stormwater utility sees past you know properties that are taxed non-taxed nonprofits whatnot it looks at the science it looks at the amount of runoff that is occurring on each property whether or not you're a tax exempt property or not so that 's where the equitable and fair piece comes in here so I think with that I'm turning it over to Jess
[10:48] Speaker F (unidentified): so that we drafted an ordinance for your review basically the governance is the city council that they administer the rules and adopt the fee schedule may delegate the duties in writing the city manager and the utility director designate they designate a utility director and recommend any annual budget and then the system responsibility this is for all city controlled facilities public rights away and facilities covered by city owes ownership easements and agreements and then other private facilities owners retain responsibility where the city lacks lawful access subject to applicable law so the draft ordinance fee and billing framework it's a dedicated utility fund the only thing that can be funded through this stormwater utility enterprise fund is stormwater work that includes maintenance that includes street sweeping anything that's done even large capital projects as Ryan said there's There's an ERU-based fee schedule, as Ryan also indicated, and the ERUs are based on the median. We looked at all of Rockland's parcels, and it's based on the median lot size. That creates one ERU, and then as you go above that, it creates additional ERUs. The difference between this is this bill goes directly to the property owner. so it doesn't go to if you're renting a property it goes right to the property owner so what's the difference between Oh draft so for the residential credit right now we've proposed a maximum 10% credit and for non-residents the maximum credit is 25% if you have less than 25 there's no credit on either side and 25 to 49 is 5% and 10% on the non-residential side do
[13:01] Speaker C (unidentified): you want to talk about those numbers now or later in the presentation we can discuss them
[13:05] Speaker F (unidentified): later in the presentation if that works for you whatever it no I didn't know if
[13:09] Speaker C (unidentified): you later is fine yeah thank you so
[13:15] Speaker F (unidentified): what's the difference between a credit and abatement and abatement is if we're using GIS to do this data gathering if you think or you believe that your property was not sized correctly, that's an abatement. You submit an abatement application for that. A credit is, if you do, as Ryan said, a best management practice on the property. So let's say you put in a rain garden or some other stormwater BMP. You can receive a credit for that. So, yeah, they serve different purposes, and there's an application for that as well. So there's an application for the stormwater credit and there's an application for the abatement the stormwater credit application you just have to put in your parcel information on parcel identification information what the BMP is for a Large non-residential credit. That's something that the tower the city would have to go out and validate You would need some documentation on that. So let's say you put in like a large cistern or something like that
[14:28] Speaker D (unidentified): and those draft policies the credit applications for the application for the credit and the application for the abatement those are included in the information that we had provided to you as well as the draft stormwater ordinance and some of the application instructions so I just let me just add
[14:48] Speaker A (unidentified): everybody in the audience those applications and policies are on the table up there for your review so
[15:00] Speaker E (unidentified): as far as the application for a credit you know Sorry, got to talk a little closer here. So on the actual application, so we do have kind of that draft application form, and what's going to be provided on that in general is going to be the basic stuff like who the owner is, the ERU amount that Jess mentioned, classification, account number, parcel, all those kind of basic things. You're also going to have to list kind of what BMP you're using, and you're going to have to provide some kind of backup documentation on that. so what is the area that BMP is going to be treating so what area of your parcel is tributary to this best management practice the BMP so whether that's a pond or some other type of treatment system what how much of your property is actually going to this and treating it so you got to provide some kind of backup on that and then some of that backup supporting evidence is going to have to be either plans or drainage plans a design perhaps and maybe a lot of times this is going to be for the larger commercial properties which they may already have kind of engineered plans for anyways but in any event you're going to have to provide some kind of verification that the treatment you're providing is actually treating the area that you're saying it's going to treat so you know this could be through permits maybe you've already applied for sizing information it could be as built information so record drawings of what was installed previously and then also condition and maintenance documentation so some photos this could be inspection or maintenance documentation you know are you going to be you know maintaining the vegetation that's out there you're not just going to let this thing grow in because a lot of these systems you can't just construct it and leave it you got to you got to maintain it over time so it's actually treating the storm water or you know detaining the storm water which is the whole purpose of the stormwater utility so that's some basic information that's included in that credit application so what we're proposing here and this could change i think a lot of times we see this as three or five years of renewal so every three and the way we're proposing it right now it's every three years anyone with a credit would have to reapply for a credit so it doesn't automatically roll over to the next the next phase so you know you'd have to reapply for that and if you've already gone through the process it's going to be pretty easy for you but you do have to provide some of that documentation that we just talked about and it's going to basically be the effective days starting after the latest billing cycle so once you submit your application for credit and you get approval your credit would kind of kick in at the next billing cycle ongoing duties by the owner so it's maintaining performance i talked about maintenance you have to allow inspections by the city so if the city does want to come and kind of verify things then you would have to provide access and then you'd have to report any changes so if you did maybe you widen your driveway and paved an extra parking space you would have to report things like that because that is going to impact your credit or if you replace your stormwater treatment with a different type of stormwater treatment you have to you have to report those type of things but it's just mentioned the city's gonna look at probably more of the commercial side of things and look at the bigger properties to kind of verify those at least once over that three-year period but the city also has the right to inspect some of the smaller residential properties too if
[18:44] Speaker D (unidentified): there's if there's credits in place and the reason for the three-year time frame is that we often find that sometimes the BMP measures kind of aren't maintained so if they're not maintained then they're not providing the appropriate amount of stormwater treatment that the credit was based on right so that three-year recertification process or reapplication process allows the city to verify that the BMP is, in fact, operating correctly and gets the owner's commitment that it's operating properly.
[19:19] Speaker F (unidentified): I also just want to add that the credit and the abatement, not the abatement, but the credit does, when the property is sold, the new owner would have to reapply for that under their own name.
[19:30] Speaker E (unidentified): Good point, Jess. Yeah, and I think, thinking again about large commercial properties where it's a substantial credit they're applying for, Or a lot of times, because they have other permits through DEP, they may already have kind of a maintenance log that they're able to kind of supplement for this. So it's not kind of starting from scratch, you know, in a lot of cases. So on the abatement side of things, what's required to be considered for an abatement? So you need to have verifiable material error. And so that could be a number of different things. So we listed out a few of the important ones here. or so it could be a mapping error maybe the impervious area that was calculated is incorrect and if you can prove that then you can qualify for an abatement or maybe it's the wrong classification maybe it was classified as a gravel driveway which is still impervious but maybe in reality it's it's a vegetated lawn area so another example is maybe it's the wrong parcel maybe you receive duplicate charges for the same parcel so those are obviously abatement situations condominiums where maybe you share access or eligibility maybe it's a contiguous area that could be considered for an abatement and then documented site change so maybe you removed a good portion of your paved parking lot or paved driveway and now you actually have less impervious surface so that's another you know reasonable abatement situation so what's excluded so we listed out a few of the exclusions so hardship disagreements with the rate drainage claims temporary conditions and requests for stormwater management credits so these are all things that you know that last one being more of a you're actually instead of applying for a credit you apply for an abatement you really need to apply for a credit if that's what you're looking for. On the timeline side of things, so kind of switching back to a credit application. So it's going to be 30 days to file the application. The city has 30 days to consider it complete or not. And then the city has 60 days to make a decision on that. And then once a decision has been made, the property owner has 30 days to file an appeal. Similarly with the abatement the abatement request can come within 30 days and the city again has 60 days to make a decision on that there is a hearing request period of 30 days if the property owner appeals and then additional 60 days beyond that for the city to make a decision on that so kind of next steps so we're here presenting kind of these I know that these were really high level a really high level summary of the bylaws the ordinance the policy for credits and abatements but kind of the next steps would be to kind of finalize some of these things so we've provided those documents to Tom which I believe have been shared with Council so at this point we're kind of looking for comments from Council on what we've kind of drafted up but the next steps would be to kind of finalize those bylaws the credit policy the abatement policy you'll notice we have finalized er you amount so we didn't really talk about the er you amount tonight and the reason for that is until we really finalize the credit policy we can't finalize that year you amount because until we understand how much credit is being given that's going to impact the amount of each er you so that's going to be kind of the last step once we finalize some of this other stuff so after finalizing the ordinance the bylaws the er use we can kind of go into adopting the utility itself and the rates would be kind of that next step after that, and then the final step would be implementing the utility and start the program. So a little shorter presentation than we've given in the past, but we felt like we've presented a lot on kind of the what is a stormwater utility, so Ryan gave a little summary. But we're happy to answer any questions on the stormwater utility itself as well, but we were kind of more focused on bylaws, policies tonight. Thank
[23:54] Speaker B (unidentified): you. I just want to stress to everyone the sort of broader context here of stormwater management being a real infrastructure challenge for the city. I think it goes without saying, anytime we open up a road, we see the extent of our infrastructure, its need for ongoing maintenance, and the significant cost associated with it. That's in large part why the voters backed a stormwater bond that the city has been working through. But I think tonight's discussion is really to try to understand how do we address those costs in an effective, equitable, and financially responsible way. But I also want to be clear with the public that no decision has been made one way or another. and we literally just got the draft ordinance so there's a lot of ample time I've heard from a number of residents concerned citizens both here and public comment but also just in the community with questions so there's definitely more public discussion that's needed around this and public input and that's part of what tonight is I have a few questions but I'm going to open it up to counsel first and then we can address some of counsel's questions and then open up for public discussion.
[25:26] Speaker C (unidentified): Counselor Davis. Thank you, pardon me. And thank you for that presentation and for your work on this. I'd like to start with maybe the most maybe a thing that maybe well for me at least sort of most difficult to figure out what an appropriate direction is, and that is the credit system. Can you start by just talking about how you came up with those numbers?
[25:56] Speaker F (unidentified): So we came up with those with some input from the city that the maximum residential credit would be 10%. We're open to looking at anything else as well and that the maximum non-residential credit would be 25%, and then we backed into those other numbers. numbers. But we see ranges for non-residential credits from 10 to 25. It really depends on the community. And for residential and for non-residential, between 25 to 50%, depending
[26:28] Speaker C (unidentified): on the BMP. All right. Thank you. Can you flesh out exactly what impervious area treated
[26:34] Speaker E (unidentified): means in this context? Do you want to take that one? Yeah. So what we're looking for Or is, you know, the focus is impervious area because that's what's generating runoff. So we're really focused on treating that area. So, again, it's the roof, it's the driveway. So when we're talking about generated impervious treatment, we're talking about how much of the driveway are you treating or the roof, not necessarily the vegetated area in the meadow or in your woods. Those BMPs should be focused on kind of the impervious area that's kind of generating the runoff.
[27:09] Speaker C (unidentified): So does that mean something like, just as an example, a cistern or something like that? Would you calculate then, according to the capacity of the cistern, how much of the impervious area that mitigates, essentially?
[27:21] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, I mean, you could build a really big cistern, but if only a small percentage of your driveway is going to it, that's all you're going to get credit for. So you have to make sure that you're actually building something that your driveway is going to drain to or your roof is going to drain to.
[27:37] Speaker C (unidentified): So conceptually, then, if I understand right, the idea is to try to figure out how much of the impervious area your mitigations have led to not contributing to the general public cost of stormwater runoff. That was a very convoluted way of saying what I'm trying to express. But you're trying to figure out basically what portion of the impervious area no longer is a public burden from these mitigations. Is that right? Yeah. Yeah.
[28:05] Speaker D (unidentified): So if you have a sample lot size that's one acre, and let's say that half of that is impervious area, if you treat half of that one half of an acre, so you're treating a quarter of an acre, that qualifies for the 50% impervious area treated and qualifies you for that 7.5% residential credit.
[28:31] Speaker C (unidentified): So, in that case, though, why would, just conceptually, with regard to these numbers, why would the percentages not be the same? If you were mitigating half of your impervious area, why wouldn't you get a half credit?
[28:42] Speaker D (unidentified): Very good question. And I think it lies in the fact that we still need the program to be funded. And so if we're offering credits to everyone and everyone's taking those credits, that may take too much away from the stormwater utility fund. so there's a there's a baseline revenue amount that needs to be generated by the fund in order to propagate the program right and just you could probably speak to this better than I could but we want to make sure that the program is sustainable and if we're handing out credits in that fashion then the amount of money that's available for the program significantly decreases all right
[29:26] Speaker B (unidentified): all right that's a follow-up oh yeah go ahead yeah well because it's it's it's kind of the foundational assumption is on the budget that's created and i understand there is a cost to stormwater treatment currently the city is the taxpayers are paying a cost right now that is not equitable some people are contributing that aren't paying some people are paying too little Some people are paying too much. But is the budget derived from what the current cost is, or is it a budget that is assumed to create an expectation of some other cost that's being carried?
[30:09] Speaker F (unidentified): No, the stormwater budget currently is all of the infrastructure projects. It's the bond, the stormwater bond. It's some debt service that we're anticipating for those projects that were in the stormwater report. port and it also includes some labor and maintenance and things of that nature
[30:28] Speaker B (unidentified): but it's currently it's a it's a cost of this city would be currently correct
[30:34] Speaker F (unidentified): it's currently on the mill rate yeah but it would be put into a stormwater so
[30:39] Speaker B (unidentified): it's not an essentially an increase in spending from know what the baseline would be for managing stormwater well I think it is an
[30:48] Speaker D (unidentified): increase because you haven't yet embarked on those capital improvement projects that are programmed for two years from now five years from now ten years from now right so it's definitely above what you are spending right now for operation and maintenance of your existing system definitely more I
[31:10] Speaker C (unidentified): appreciate your answer and it makes sense in terms of having a sort of baseline minimum just to operate the mechanism my gut feeling I'm only on council for two more weeks so this is my last round of questions to you so take this do what you want with this feedback but it seems fairer to me to try to make the credit scale more sharply or more directly with mitigation I need to I would need to think through the mechanics of that more before offering any more detailed feedback and again you won't get it from me but that is my gut feeling I think the mechanism sounds appropriate and clear but I'd be inclined to offer more of a credit for more mitigation thank you we appreciate the feedback you got penny council york
[31:58] Speaker G (unidentified): thank you very much counselor davis i am in complete agreement with you i would like to see more of an opportunity for people to offset that cost i just also just an ask for the team and thank you again for all of the times that you've met with us and tolerated all of our questions my feedback would be if we could provide a slide or a reference guide that could be accessed to our taxpayers through the city website on how much, like over the course of a 12 month period, what the anticipated amount that could be taken in by the city through this charge, and then the type of project that could offset set and how that will impact the mill rate in the future just so that people can really see very clearly that the whole point of this is really to avoid having to go back to the voters for a large bond item in the future this would really help us to mitigate ongoing infrastructure needs that we have around stormwater maintenance so to just be able to provide people with one central location where they could get some facts on that, I think that would be incredibly helpful.
[33:23] Speaker D (unidentified): All right, thank you. We'll work with Tom on what that might look like. Yeah, thank you.
[33:29] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm just curious, when we're talking about credits, do you see municipalities, after they get their utility up and running, increase that credit over time?
[33:41] Speaker F (unidentified): Sometimes, yes. I see a lot of revisions to the credit policy just because going out and checking on those credits and they get inundated that's why we have the 60 days because we do see a lot of communities where they get just inundated with credits and abatements and it's just too much for
[33:59] Speaker A (unidentified): us you know it's small city to turn around yeah now not only credit but you did mention a hard hardship abatement type of thing do you have any municipalities that have criteria on hardship yes we do I can give you some
[34:15] Speaker F (unidentified): some examples but usually it's I'm trying to think of what it is but it's usually an application to apply for and just verify so just to clarify that's outside of the abatement process yes financial or age-related yeah
[34:39] Speaker B (unidentified): I would agree I would like to see that I would also second my colleagues in terms of the, I really question whether those incentives are large enough to have, I mean, especially on the residential side, but also non-residential, is that enough where it sparks action taken to mitigate stormwater practices? I don't know what you've, like, what is the range of those percentage and credits in other utilities in Maine? I think there's six other stormwater utilities in the state. Do they range in terms of the percentage of credits?
[35:22] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes. They're all very different, yes. But, again, we typically see residential credits between 10% and 25% and then non-residential up to 50% depending on the BMP.
[35:35] Speaker D (unidentified): So Jess ran through a financial model for the stormwater utility, and it has to make assumptions for how many credits are going to be applied for right it has to make assumptions for you know just things like that so if we're thinking about increasing the amount of credit that can be given for more properties then my guess is that the ERU is going to increase right so if the eru increases that's going to impact everyone right so just keep that in mind as we're thinking about the number of credits because we had to assume a certain percentage of properties would request the credit and if those credits are much higher yeah i mean one of my concerns
[36:26] Speaker B (unidentified): would be that the there's a disconnect between even if you offer a credit doesn't mean people know about the credit or will take the credit and that is a really important piece because then you're kind of only rewarding people who may have the knowledge or the capacity to understand how the system works, and then you're essentially creating... So I don't know how you address that or how that's taken into account in the implementation, but I think it goes back to the question of modeling and being very transparent about, even before this goes into effect, what are the associated costs. I would also agree on the back end I think the you know so the revenue goes into a dedicated enterprise fund is that the that 's the how it would work that's the end goal yes yeah and so understanding having like the requirement for the municipality to be very clear about what it is funding out of that account and you know some transparency like the money is actually going to stormwater work I think is another piece of this that has to be
[37:38] Speaker D (unidentified): well established the ordinance I think does a decent job of explaining what the monies can be can be used for but happy to explore you show us an
[37:52] Speaker B (unidentified): example of another utilities annual like how do they account for the fund and how that on an annual basis like you know what did the funds that were collected and then what did what did those funds offset it kind of picks up on council york's question
[38:14] Speaker F (unidentified): yes definitely counselor
[38:18] Speaker C (unidentified): davis another credit question i know all these things are making life more difficult for you so i'm sorry no worries i think i understand conceptually based on what you said why you would want to make the first year you outside of the creditable fee base. That means though that someone with a small house doesn't have any chance to do something good and save money. Good for the world, good for the environment. I would love to be able to see someone with a small house achieve some small savings through some good action. Maybe not at the same level we were talking about before in terms of scaling rapidly with mitigation, but at least something, at least a token. That seems appropriate to me. Okay, definitely.
[38:58] Speaker F (unidentified): I have some examples that I can share too.
[39:02] Speaker A (unidentified): Councilor Callahan. Councilor Callahan.
[39:06] Speaker H (unidentified): Thank you, Mayor Laufman. I just want to second, third everything my colleagues have said already, but I'm also interested in us discussing what it would look like if we were to pass an ordinance amendment for utility and phasing it in stages. and phasing it in for commercial properties first because I am very concerned about the impact of another cost for our residents. So like if we phased it in for the first year for commercial properties that have larger impervious services before we added in residential properties, like what that would look like.
[40:08] Speaker D (unidentified): So I think the model that you have, Jess, makes that pretty easy to take a look at what a phased approach would look like. So it's essentially looking at the revenue that would be generated from the commercial properties, let's say in the first year or two, and I think the important thing is comparing that amount of revenue to the planned projects in the master plan to see if any of those projects would fall off the list because we don't have enough funding in the utility
[40:35] Speaker A (unidentified): to cover those projects wouldn't that also have to be gone through the legal department to make sure it's fair and equitable for all yes correct but
[40:50] Speaker F (unidentified): it's very easy for me to calculate that and
[40:55] Speaker A (unidentified): I think I was just gonna say when we're looking at the first year's budget I think we looked at what two hundred and thirty thousand dollars or more in debt service that would be coming off the general and does
[41:14] Speaker B (unidentified): that would we have a equivalent sort of impact to the
[41:19] Speaker A (unidentified): mill rate for that reduction yeah that would take the bill right down I believe
[41:27] Speaker F (unidentified): currently on the city's website there is a document that shows if we were to do this without a stormwater utility what the impact of the two on the tax the mill rate would be and then what it is on the eru yeah well i would i would want to look at it from
[41:43] Speaker B (unidentified): the other from the other perspective you know what is the cost of doing nothing in terms of
[41:51] Speaker C (unidentified): associating the cost to those who are not paying into the tax base i think there's a slide on that one too as well on the city's website yeah i think i think the last couple or at least the last
[42:04] Speaker E (unidentified): presentation we gave we gave some property examples and I think some of them were for the taxes yeah the tax exempt properties so I know the ER your
[42:13] Speaker B (unidentified): number is not finalized and you've mentioned that 's because of the we have to resolve this credit question but after that's resolved are you then able to provide like what a typical residential bill would look like and definitely so people are not just hearing about a fee structure without a dollar figure because i think there's you have to have something to compare to
[42:41] Speaker F (unidentified): no we definitely can there just aren't very many variables built into the current stormwater budget it's strictly just operations and maintenance and debt service and capital projects so we need to lock that down and then lock down how much we're going to be giving out as credits in order to build that final eru any
[43:03] Speaker B (unidentified): other questions i do want to recognize we have our wastewater treatment director here and staff as well if they want to share any comments or we can just open it up for public discussion do you want to come to the mic yeah can you come to a microphone please so
[43:33] Speaker I (unidentified): let the public speak first and then there may be comments that i could make after hearing what they
[43:38] Speaker B (unidentified): have this great so we'll open it up for public comment or questions and this is pretty flexible so don't feel that if you've asked a question you can't come back and ask another question or another point but welcome anyone who would like to comment or provide any input or questions to come to the to the podium and address the workshop good
[44:18] Speaker J (unidentified): evening I'm Rick Rockwell and I am a longtime property owner in Rockland and I've come tonight to learn get information and understand what is put in front of us here today, what the problem is, what the particular urgency of this moment is, what other communities are doing with regard to addressing this issue, the roots of the resolve to address this issue and how it will be funded and what the actual hard cost will be to people so they understand exactly what it is can budget accordingly whether it's a residence or a business both have costs and budgets and needs and you can't address what you don't understand so I'm here partly and to understand it but on first blush it seems that it is a cost that will be that is apparently a new cost that is to be distributed and absorbed and whether you call it a fee or you call it a tax or you call it whatever it's a cost that is going to be borne by a group of individuals businesses and residential and how that all happens and what the formulas are what the actual numbers are all certainly part of what the legitimate curiosity and interest and intent to learn is about. I also have concerns about the macro environment you know just came from meeting with economic development about you know how does a city address additional cost in a world where costs keep going up and it has to do with sharing burden the more people that share a burden the less burden on any individual simple math so how that you know burden is going to be distributed what it actually is but the general objection objective of having costs be shared would suggest that the way in which burdens are reduced is by increasing the number of people who participate in absorbing that cost and that suggests growth and is it a good idea to do that which may create friction or imposition on growth in an environment where growth is a necessary solution to a cost problem and so that is another basic question. So I have no answers, I come with questions, and hope that those questions are framed in a way that people can understand them, to understand if and what those alternatives might be, to understand what best practices are and how other communities have addressed all this. but and that the net of it all is that it is an increase in cost in an environment of you know ever increasing costs be it business or residential it all contributes to the health of a community the tax base of a community the ability to fund the needs of a community and if you erode that base you will distribute the burden in a way that has to be absorbed by fewer components. And I have concerns about inhibiting, restricting, constricting the opportunity for this community to grow so that the burden is less on any individual business and or homeowner.
[49:00] Speaker C (unidentified): you. May I say something in response to that? One thing, Rick, in response to your concern, one thing that I think Ryan or maybe Owen alluded to, but we didn't really emphasize it at this meeting, is that this will actually distribute the costs to non-profits in a way that we don't currently have the ability to. So it does actually add more participants to the pool of people who share the costs, and that's an important benefit of this, I think, for most of the, well, for all of the taxpayers in the city. More generally, in terms of not inhibiting growth, I think that, I haven't really thought through this, but my intuition is that if you're developing a new property in the city, the cost of, not really compliance, but the cost of mitigation strategies is probably less with new construction than with trying to modify existing construction,, I would guess, in general. And I think that's important in the sense that is an aspect of this that hopefully would not inhibit growth. You're right, it's a cost, but that's why, in part, we have the credit system to try to mitigate that. And the non-profit piece is an important thing, too, both in response to your concerns but also in terms of having the general public understand that this does result in a broader – not tax base – a broader fee base, I guess. Hi.
[50:20] Speaker K (unidentified): My name is Bill Allen. I have a handful of questions. Cut me out if you need to. What are the next steps set? There's no time on it. There's no date on it for setting the rates and assigning the ERUs. Do you have any sense of when that would happen?
[50:42] Speaker A (unidentified): no real guideline yet now but we're hoping internally that we'll have this all set up before our next budget which starts in July so several people have
[50:54] Speaker K (unidentified): said things about whether this is an additional cost and I can't tell from the paperwork that I read whether this is a different mechanism for accounting for costs that the city already is facing or is looking at in the future. I understand the attempt to make it equitable, to make it fair, but I can't tell whether this is an additional burden or perhaps the money that is coming out of property taxes would be reduced by the amount that is going to
[51:30] Speaker B (unidentified): the stormwater utility can you speak to that at all can i just add a flavor to your question is you mentioned regulatory compliance and part of this as my understanding is there's work that is required by the city to do because of dep regulations so that cost is part of the cost that needs to be addressed but if you can address the question in terms
[52:00] Speaker K (unidentified): Let me try to ask the question in a slightly different way, then. If the city is going to be burdened by regulatory costs, those are going to have to come from somewhere. This is one mechanism to say, if it's going to come from everybody, let's try to do it in a fair way. And I get that, but I can't tell whether we're talking about new costs or costs that we're already incurring because it's been raining for years here, there's been stormwater for years here, there's been problems, there have been fixes to those problems, and the city's been paying for that. Is this a new way of paying for that stuff, or possibly and, are there additional costs of regulatory compliance that will add to the burden, the cost burden that this is trying to at least make fair?
[52:52] Speaker A (unidentified): So the new costs going forward will be covered out of this utility. So we have identified $30 million, I think, in stormwater work that needs to be addressed in the city. So those projects will be funded out of this utility. But we currently have, I can't remember how many millions of dollars on the general fund budget that are for previous projects that will be transferred over to this utility. So in theory, basically I think one of the slides we showed maybe a couple meetings ago took households and compared what they would be paying in their taxes for projects as opposed to the utility fee. And I believe most of the residential properties went down. So the fee would be less than what your taxes were paying. But I believe some of the commercial properties were paying more. So it all depends on how big their impervious service was.
[53:47] Speaker C (unidentified): Can I maybe address that just more directly? It's a mix. it's stuff we've already bonded out and we're paying for right that you're paying for now in taxes but there's also future process projects that are necessary necessitated by both regulatory compliance but just also by the fact that we need to do them just to keep the city running last couple of
[54:08] Speaker K (unidentified): questions I think you addressed this earlier say I live in a small property and I want to build a rain garden like you've never seen before I don't get credit for that if I'm at one ERU well under the paperwork yeah and then we
[54:27] Speaker C (unidentified): talked about possibly addressing that yeah and my question though is would
[54:32] Speaker K (unidentified): most homes end up in Iraq and getting assigned a one ERU status I think we're
[54:38] Speaker C (unidentified): trending in that direction is that right it's a mix yeah I guess I don't have the
[54:45] Speaker K (unidentified): ERUs in front of me but it is a mix so my following comment to yours is if most people have one ERU and most people decide they want to do something to mitigate the stormwater on their property they should get some kind of credit for it and right now the paperwork says no you only you only get credit if you're more than one ERU. I agree yeah. Okay thank you.
[55:13] Speaker B (unidentified): Just to follow up on that is the rationale behind that essentially to create a floor like a capacity floor like you see in utility other utility rates where whether you whether you're using it or not you there's a minimum fee exact but I think the point is well taken that if people take action to address the problem that they're contributing to that there should be some method of some credit provided.
[55:50] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah, that's the challenge is trying to establish a base budget while also you don't want to discourage people from implementing BMPs because at the end of the day, that's going to help improve water quality. It's going to help with some of the flooding issues if everyone kind of contributes in that way. Can
[56:15] Speaker J (unidentified): somebody explain exactly what's going to be built with the money and what it's going to cost?
[56:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Yep. I think most of those are in the stormwater master plan, most of the projects listed that we're looking at through this utility.
[56:34] Speaker J (unidentified): So referring to a plan, but what – can you narrow – can you create a description? Is that – what is actually being built, a separate stormwater infrastructure? Is that what's happening, independent? I'm just trying to understand exactly how these dollars have been determined in the aggregate, where this budget has come from. Budgets are derivative of specific materials, time, costs, which suggest a very specific work plan. So I'm asking, what is the specific work plan that's associated with the formulas, the costs, the whole thing? what is going you know what needs to be done so the stormwater master plan
[57:19] Speaker E (unidentified): came up with a list of projects and it was a mix of culvert projects we're kind of focused on Lindsay Brook because a few years ago we had the storms that flooded Lindsay Brook so capacity was the biggest concern with Lindsay Brook so it's it's a culvert projects to improve capacity it's sewer separation projects to reduce CSO it's flood mitigation projects those are kind of
[57:49] Speaker D (unidentified): the big ones some green infrastructure projects in some of the park areas yep but if so the master plan is can be found on the on the city's website and there are lists there's a list of 23 projects that make up the $30 million that Tom was talking about in capital improvement projects. So those capital improvement projects are only one piece of the puzzle that goes into the stormwater utility budget, right? So Jess had mentioned operation and maintenance costs of the existing systems. There's going to be a cost associated with actually running the stormwater utility. There's the debt service that's going to be brought on to the stormwater utility.
[58:33] Speaker J (unidentified): And the date, is there a deadline or a timeline or a date in which this has to be set in place?
[58:44] Speaker D (unidentified): So we have provided some phasing opinions on when the projects could be completed.
[58:52] Speaker J (unidentified): But the impetus for the regulation, which is it state or federal regulation?
[58:59] Speaker D (unidentified): So the sewer separation projects, and Terry could probably speak to this, Because the sewer separation projects, I don't know if you have a date that you need to hit, but the sewer separation projects help to reduce the amount of water that you have to treat at the facility, right?
[59:19] Speaker I (unidentified): Correct. It's interesting. There are two different ways to look at this. One is the budget of what work has to be done and what the cost of maintaining it is. And then there's how are you going to distribute the cost. Totally two different things. [Speaker J (unidentified): Why now, Terry?] Well, because you're already doing it. And you have such a large amount of money that we already have a $10 million bond for stormwater and a $10 million bond for sewer separation. Those things are ongoing. So every year, just like you would if you didn't have this utility, forget the utility for a second, you're going to have a budget every year to do the things that we're talking about doing. There's not a question whether you're going to do them or not.
[1:00:18] Speaker J (unidentified): You have to. Well, you see that you're already doing it, so I'm trying to understand why there's a differential between that which was done and that which is intended which was done which
[1:00:30] Speaker I (unidentified): was done you have a debt service for you borrowed money to do it when we pass a bond the bond has to be paid back so all of those costs exist or the or they will be in the future based on the budget to take care of stormwater now the question comes that we know we're going to have all of this cost or we have all this cost what's the fairest way to distribute the cost that's why you're looking at a utility you only have two ways are we going to charge it in your taxes or we're going to charge it in a utility you're going to have to pay it
[1:01:14] Speaker J (unidentified): either way so just I just want to understand where we are at this point in your answer. So what you're saying is that we've committed at some point, I don't know when that all started, to be in compliance with a state mandate or is it a federal mandate? There's a
[1:01:35] Speaker I (unidentified): state mandate which is the state of Maine also enforces the federal mandate. They've been given that responsibility. There's that to separate stormwater from sewer. You have two choices. Separate it or build a 30 million gallon a day treatment plant to treat it all. They don't want to, they don't want you mixing it and not treating it. It's remove it or treat it all. That's a mandate. Now along with that you have flooding conditions that have taken place throughout the city over the last ten years serious ones that's a responsibility of the community to take care of that no one's telling you that you have to not deal with the or you have to deal with the flooding conditions they're not telling that no one's giving you a mandate except the community so the community voted on a $10 million bond to the first phase of that. That's an obligation that the community wants to do that. Now the dilemma that we look with that we're having at the same time is to do sewer separation means that you've got to take the stormwater out of the sewer system but then you have to have some place to put the stormwater, and that tends, you already have an overloaded stormwater system, so therefore you're gonna have to make mitigation to allow for more stormwater to go into that system.
[1:03:21] Speaker J (unidentified): All of these things. So I just want you to understand the original design. So if something started with a project to deal with stormwater, which is a constant in life, stormwater's in a new concept, And so now that you know, there's a there's an effort to take we're going to mitigate separate stormwater and the city goes and borrows Ten million dollars, right which is now due Interest or principal or is getting rolled over we're spending it
[1:03:50] Speaker I (unidentified): We're spending it down all of that comes all of those projects Which is available to you comes from a master plan, right a master plan What do we need to do in the city to correct the stormwater problem and also the source separation problem? So we did a master plan That gives you all the projects and it gives you target dates of when you would want to do those projects One of the parts that kind of pushes us along a little faster is part of our wastewater permit with the state is setting dates that target dates where they want the stormwater out of the sewer system so that's also a big part that pushes us the way we're going to go I think that what has to be clearly understood though is there are two there are two different things those budgets are going to happen every year regardless of what do you have a stormwater utility or not those things have to be decided by the council as, yes, we're going to do these projects. The only thing the stormwater utility does is give you an alternative to distribute the cost. And the reason why a lot of communities favor the alternative is because everybody in the community, the community, the post office, the county building, all of the nonprofits have to participate in it. If they're not paying taxes, it makes no difference. But if you go the tax route, then people get accepted out of the cost. That's the difference between the two. And it makes no difference. It makes absolutely no difference whether you're doing it through a utility or you're doing it through a tax Whether it's going to be done or not. I think I just would
[1:05:52] Speaker J (unidentified): Just throw a thought in the description to what I saw was some commentary that doing this can overwhelm a small town with the administrative and the paperwork and phase in. And that basically implies and suggests that there's an administrative, some administrative lift that's involved in all this. It was also evident through a certain number of years and you have to reapply and just essentially what looks to me like a embedded requirement for recurring administrative engagements that you're creating in and of itself an administrative burden which has nothing to do with stormwater but managing the paperwork associated with this whole program here's the answer to that if you
[1:06:52] Speaker I (unidentified): don't do the utility you don't get any credit you don't get anything it's just whatever it is it is the utility gives an opportunity to get some credit the credit thing if you want to look at it simply but who's the credit it is the
[1:07:12] Speaker J (unidentified): credit coming from here's the way you have to look at it you set up if you set
[1:07:17] Speaker I (unidentified): up a utility and you come and you derive this er you this unit right there are fixed costs and there are variable costs. The fixed cost has to be the minimum charge that everybody pays. If there's not one drop of rain, that cost still exists. Your debt service doesn't go away if it doesn't rain. That's the cost of
[1:07:44] Speaker J (unidentified): building this infrastructure. That's the building the infrastructure. There's
[1:07:47] Speaker I (unidentified): still operating costs. There are employees that you don't lay them off if it doesn't rain. No, there's all fixed costs. Just like the sewer utility, the exact same setup. So there's fixed costs. You have to make sure you get all those fixed costs. And then there are variable costs. Now the thing in the variable costs that I think should be understood that the water coming from private properties is not the majority of the water going into the stormwater system. Most of it comes from your roads and your culverts. So that has to be paid for. Do you want it paid for in a utility or do you want it paid for in the taxes? The only difference, the amounts of money are exactly the same. The only difference, do you want everybody to pay for it or do you 'd only want taxpayers to pay for it. The other difference being, if you're paying through taxes, it's based on the value of your home, which has no correlation at all to stormwater. There are a lot of people, if you live in a large house and you're paying large taxes, it doesn't mean that you're rich. There are a lot of people who are just barely making it in this town that have a big house, including me, have a big house and because of depreciation of the house are getting charged a higher percentage of the stormwater cost only because my house is worth more money now. So, that's the argument that we have to make with ourselves, is the stormwater utility method of collecting money better for the citizens of the community, or is it to put it in taxes? It's that simple.
[1:09:57] Speaker J (unidentified): You know, just one man's opinion, you know, as soon as you build an infrastructure that requires administrative burden and just you know administrative costs that doesn't address stormwater it dresses the management of the paperwork and I would also suggest that you know taxes correlate to square footage and to uses and you know all things in the tax and the appraisal and evaluation accounts counts for exactly those discrepancies in size, of lots, and dimensions, and so on and so forth. I would argue that they correlate very much in similar fashion. And I would, you know, to me it's a math equation as to, you know, is the juice worth the squeeze in terms of, you know, another layer of bureaucracy, burden distributed both internally and distributed externally and what is the cost of that and where does that all go and how does that all so here's it
[1:11:09] Speaker I (unidentified): here's an answer to that you can take a lot of that administrative burden out of the utility don't give any credits just like it is in taxes you do not get any credits in taxes the only reason you have that burden what you're talking about is try to give people an opportunity to get some money back for improvements that they make. If you want to do away with that, do away with it.
[1:11:36] Speaker J (unidentified): Question about the notion of, you know, mitigation and what are the mechanisms of mitigation and what are the triggers that would define a surface as impervious? Is it, you know, if you had a bunch of tiles that were, you know, two by two, are they in the aggregate, you know, two inches by two inches that were all together? Does, you know, is that an impervious service? Is that a, you know, what happens if somebody has, you know, rocks on their property? Is that an impervious surface? I just, you know, just curious about these definitions and what they mean in real life.
[1:12:19] Speaker D (unidentified): life? So there are standards in the industry and the state actually defines impervious area pretty well. Essentially, if you have a dirt driveway, but it's packed, it's impervious. You're not going to get a lot of runoff in there. But if you have pervious pavers or if you have some blocks that are in your backyard that are leading to your patio, that patio may be impervious, but I doubt we're going to count the little block stepping stones to get up there as impervious. They're they're in the yard. So there are some pretty standard definitions in the engineering community for imperviousness.
[1:12:54] Speaker J (unidentified): So if somebody built a house underground and there was nothing but a meadow on that parcel,
[1:13:02] Speaker D (unidentified): what happens? There's no impervious area.
[1:13:06] Speaker J (unidentified): There's no impervious area.
[1:13:08] Speaker C (unidentified): I bet you've never gotten that question before. I have not.
[1:13:11] Speaker J (unidentified): I'm just trying to understand what the objectives are, what the means and mechanisms for mitigating the exposures are and I will
[1:13:26] Speaker B (unidentified): just I'll just add this was a part of prior presentations there were a whole list of mitigation strategies and approved methods of what one could do I think we could recirculate those because it kind of goes hand-in-hand with the
[1:13:45] Speaker E (unidentified): credit question yeah so there's there's slides that I think are on the city website because we have a stormwater utility web page that provides different information so I think those previous presentations are on there but I guess
[1:14:00] Speaker I (unidentified): we can we can check that and there's something else that you have to understand too with credits I mean credits it sounds great credits it's It's like a waterbed. You push down here, it goes up over there. The only thing you're doing is changing the distribution of cost. That's all. So the more credits you get, the higher the EORU cost goes. So you have to be very careful that the credits sound good, but it's going to cost you more in the EORU anyway. So credits have to be realistic. And again, if I'm putting this system together, what I would look at is how much water actually comes from private property, and how much water actually comes from public use property. And then the credit cannot exceed, by any means exceed, the amount of water that you're going to get or not get from private property. You're gonna find that the major part of the cost is dealing with water coming from common use public property.
[1:15:16] Speaker J (unidentified): Let me ask you, Terry, you're so seasoned and you've got so much experience. Is this a real problem? Is this, I mean, what exactly is this really fixing? Is it really a threat or something that could hurt?
[1:15:41] Speaker I (unidentified): Well, I'll give you a perfect example. The building that you're redoing on Lime Rock. If this is not done, the next hundred year storm we do, the first floor be flooded. It was. So is it a problem? Tell me. The people that the people in the town that got their basements filled up and their oil tank floated out the door, is it a problem? Why do you think the population of the community voted on a 10 million dollar bond? They wouldn't have done it if it wasn't a problem. We dump millions of gallons in a two-inch rain, we can go up to 30 million gallons of mixed sewage going into the harbor. If it's separated, that
[1:16:38] Speaker B (unidentified): That won't happen. I want to just see if there are other questions in the audience.
[1:16:43] Speaker J (unidentified): I took enough time.
[1:16:46] Speaker A (unidentified): You have Counselor Callahan. Counselor Callahan.
[1:16:50] Speaker H (unidentified): First of all, for the people watching at home, I would just like to remind them that I think this is a fourth or fifth workshop we've had with Wright Piers and Mr. Pinto, who have gone over this in great detail with us. they're all available the recordings are all available we've talked about this in great detail I want to thank Terry for bringing up what he just brought up we brought home our creamy daughter seven years ago our house had flooded to within an inch of our first floor took out our oil barrel our furnace our hot water tank we weren't the only house on the Lindsay Brook that had happened to and something else mr pinto brought up we're going to pay for this one way or another and we're either going to pay for it in our taxes and that's only people that pay property taxes or we're all going to pay for it and that includes people that non-profits that don't pay property taxes and the utility can be you know renters however so it's either going to be five people paying for the pie or everybody who's getting a piece of the pie paying for the pie it's how we're splitting up the cost is what he's getting at and I think that 's a really important piece this is a really important thing that we're doing we do have a problem and we do have to do something about it and if you are fortunate enough to live in a house in Rockland that does not flood this might not be an experience you've had but a lot of people do thank
[1:18:32] Speaker B (unidentified): you hi
[1:18:35] Speaker L (unidentified): my name is Eddie I'm from Warren this is very important to me I own property in Rockland I've had a business in Rockland for 40 years I have a lot of impervious service on that business or at that business and I had the job that mr. Pinto has from in over in Warren for 33 three years of conducted meetings like this myself I wanted to start by saying that tip of the cap to the council Wright Pierce's is the number one engineering firm in the state of Maine as far as I'm concerned and I've done business with Wright Pierce in the past but not a lot of it so I have some questions and this is going to affect me quite a bit so I have some tough questions and none of this is personal or anything like that so pardon me but I believe there are five stormwater utility districts in the state of Maine am I correct six Long Creek Portland Lewiston Auburn Bangor and South
[1:19:53] Speaker B (unidentified): South Portland, Westbrook. Okay.
[1:19:58] Speaker L (unidentified): One of the things I want to point out is that some, or at least one that I'm aware of, looking at their policies and procedures, offers a credit up to 100% if you don't contribute to the treatment of the stormwater. If you have nothing to do with it whatsoever, then they give you 100% credit, and you're not charged this. The problem that I see for you guys is that from the Rockland Bog west, the water doesn't come into Rockland. It goes into Thomaston. It's not treated at the treatment plant. It's not a cost to the city whatsoever. And yet you're going to charge all of those people residents, and businesses for a problem that they neither contribute to nor cause. And I've been interested to hear you say how you're trying to make this fair and equitable. I would like to ask you how it's going to be fair and equitable to the people on the other side of Dodgers Mountain. so
[1:21:18] Speaker E (unidentified): I would say that they still benefit from driving on the roads that have
[1:21:25] Speaker L (unidentified): culverts and bridges that need to be upgraded okay does a city in the state use porous pavement very little very little yep does Rockland use porous pavement when we pave no why not maintenance because it doesn't last as long and it's more expensive am I wrong yeah you're gonna
[1:21:55] Speaker D (unidentified): have to buy vacuums for your roads to get all the organics out of right but I
[1:22:02] Speaker L (unidentified): will get a credit if I go to that expense in some of the districts I've I've read some of the policies and procedures from the other districts. I don't think that it's fair. Now, I agree with most of what Mr. Pinto has said, that the O&M costs are made up of variable and fixed costs. And the fixed costs, they are what they are. You have no choice. You've got to pay them. You have to do it. But the reason for credit is that if I mitigate my property so that I am not dumping as much water off the edge of it, which my personal property beyond what I own is 600 feet of woods before it gets to the river that's out behind us. So it's slowed right down before it gets anywhere. So if I'm not contributing to the problem, and a lot of the other businesses, and everything coming off of Dodgers Mountain, which is a lot of the bog, is the exact same way. So I have several questions for you. One would be, of those six or seven utility districts, how many did Wright Pierce work with?
[1:23:36] Speaker F (unidentified): under a former employer I worked with one
[1:23:41] Speaker L (unidentified): I'm asking about the company itself
[1:23:44] Speaker D (unidentified): so we've worked adjacent to the city of Portland in their setup of the storm or utility but we were not the prime consultant on that work so I don't think you'd even see our name associated with the city of Portland we tried to do Bangor but that didn't go through at the time and so essentially none except for
[1:24:12] Speaker L (unidentified): experience that Jess brings from her previous employment. Okay the reason I ask is that there are fewer and fewer wastewater treatment plants being built in large engineering companies need large projects to remain in business and this stormwater utility thing is a very advantageous situation for engineering firms. Some of the stuff that I passed out to you at the last meeting that I attended had to do with the contingency fee of 40%. The highest I've ever seen has been between 15 and 20. A 40% contingency fee on a culvert replacement seems absorbent to me. There's very little chance of running into a lot of ledge when you're replacing a culvert. I can see it on a wastewater treatment line. You're going down to a new area. Yes, I can see a larger contingency fee. But I see that you have a 40% right across all ten projects. That seems quite high to me.
[1:25:38] Speaker D (unidentified): It would be high if we were, you know, through final design on the project. I definitely agree. But we're in planning stages for a lot of these projects. So these are projects that we haven't put plans or specs together for yet. So the 40% is not necessarily to account for ledge that you might or might not encounter. or it's to account for the kind of the unknowns for what the project is actually going to entail. So as the concept moves from the concept stage to a preliminary design stage, then we drop that 40% down to, let's say, 20%. And when we get from preliminary stage to final stage, we might drop the contingency down to 10% or even 5%. So as the design progresses, the contingency definitely gets lower.
[1:26:31] Speaker L (unidentified): At that 40%, you've got $3.8 million set aside for contingency for problems that you might run into.
[1:26:40] Speaker D (unidentified): I don't think it's necessarily problems that we might run into. It's the scope of the project and not necessarily understanding the scope of the project that's at hand during a concept stage.
[1:26:57] Speaker L (unidentified): Let's get back to the equity question. How is it equitable for the people on the western side of Dodge Mountain to pay for this? And the other word was fair, and equitable. How does that work?
[1:27:15] Speaker D (unidentified): I definitely understand your concern. Owen brought up the point about that you're still benefiting from the other stormwater fixed infrastructure that's out there. there. Honestly, it's a discussion that we had as a group. I remember talking about it with you, Tom, and that's the direction that we decided to go. It's not set in stone, and we'll certainly take your comments into consideration and revisit with Tom and Terry. But yeah, it's a question that has come up before.
[1:27:49] Speaker L (unidentified): Earlier, when it came to the credits, I'm paraphrasing, but what they said was that it came from the city was it the City Council or who came up with the maximum on the credits that'll be allowed into this that was city staff
[1:28:11] Speaker A (unidentified): just to get a point of where we were starting but it will be the council's
[1:28:17] Speaker B (unidentified): final decision in the policy I'll just add that it's that I mean this is part of the discussion. Feedback, those credit numbers are not at all final. I think we've heard some concerns about whether it's enough of an incentive and the balance between the credit and whether it actually creates the behavior that you want people to do to mitigate the issue so it's a it's a it's a germane point that we're we're looking at I think there's a certainly a range where the credit itself becomes like mr. Pinto said you don't want the credit to be greater than the than the aggregate because otherwise then you're essentially defeating the whole
[1:29:10] Speaker L (unidentified): defeating the whole purpose yeah well that's that's what's going on yeah but where you have such a rural area, I don't know that there's places in Bangor and Portland that are similar to Rockland that has a lot of people that aren't contributing to it. I think you need to take that into consideration. And I could stand here talking all night, and I don't want any of us to do that.
[1:29:36] Speaker B (unidentified): I appreciate you coming forward again. Any other questions or comments from the audience? please.
[1:29:50] Speaker M (unidentified): So my name's Matt Mazzeo and I own Mazzeo Stills and Fireplaces on 21 Farwell Drive in Rockland on Route 90. I'm a neighbor to Mr. LaFleur. Before I get started, I wonder if I could just get your name so I know who I'm talking to.
[1:30:04] Speaker B (unidentified): The names are in the presentation.
[1:30:09] Speaker M (unidentified): Just go around them if you don't mind. Just say them real quick. It'll take about 10 seconds.
[1:30:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Sure. I'm Tom Luttrell. Nate Davis.
[1:30:17] Speaker C (unidentified): Adam Lachman. Terry Pittone. Ryan Wingard. Okay. Jess Richard. Okay. Owen Chaplin.
[1:30:25] Speaker M (unidentified): As I said, you guys are all with the firm that did the study? The three of us. You three are, and then you are who? I work for the city. You work for the city, and what's your capacity? Director of the Police and Control Department. Okay. So I don't want to take up a lot of time either, but you know I've talked to Ed about this and stuff and you know I heard you say that you heard his concern but the fact of the matter is there's a lot of people who just are not contributing to the problem so you've drafted this whole thing where you know you're trying to you know frame it as something that's very fair and equitable but it's not at all fair and equitable because we on the bog we don't get any services from Rockland really anyway as it is I mean you want to talk about water let's talk about the fact that we don't get any water we don't get town water we don't get town sewer you want me to pay because I'm putting water in a parking lot that I paid to upgrade because it's going into a bunch of grass and trees out behind my shop really you want me to pay for that are you kidding me give me a break it's ridiculous we are not that water doesn't even go into the Rockland town harbor it goes into the Oyster River which flows into to Thomaston. So we don't at all contribute to it. So why are we going to pay? So the fact that you guys are framing this as equitable is clearly just an effort to put this towards the taxpayers so that they don't have to pay for it because they don't have large impermeable areas and businesses due. So this is clearly just an attack on businesses here in Rockland and you're going to drive businesses out. We're already stretched as it is. You want You want the Hannaford parking lot to pay some $20,000 a year? What do you think is going to happen to food prices? What do you think is going to happen when grocery stores start leaving? You think little shops like Planet Fitness and stuff like that are going to stick around when they have to pay additional fees because of some bogus rainwater? Give me a break. It's a joke. It's a joke. So that's one thing. I thought it was kind of interesting that, you know, it didn't make the papers. I mean, there was some story about it in the paper, but nobody mentions that, like, all these people in the bog, some of the most impoverished, vulnerable residents. And I know because my mother grew up in the bog with, like, no heat or running water or electricity. And you're going to have those people pay as well. You want to talk about fair and equitable? That's not fair and equitable. That's not fair and equitable to have your most impoverished, vulnerable populations paid to have some water so that some large company can line its pockets doing this big thing. How about the impact study of the fact that we are not contributing to this problem? How about that? Let's do that. Because if I see a bill for some rainwater that supposedly is making its way into Rockland Harbor, The first thing I'm going to do is get a lawyer, and I'm going to have you guys prove that my water is going into Rockland Harbor, which it's not. You'll never be able to do it. And then you're going to have to pay for an impact study for that. And then you're going to have to pay for all of the legal fees when I inundate all of you guys with questions and everything. And then I'll finally lawyer up, and then he'll do it. And you guys can pay tens, hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees because you guys are attacking small businesses and driving us out with these bogus, fees. Give me a break. I mean, get a clue, guys. Get a frigging clue. We're not putting water into Rockland Harbor. There's a bog there. There's a bunch of grass. It's not going in the harbor. How come you didn't put that into your study? You guys had this big study, publish it. How much did we pay for your study? You didn't even raise that in your study, that the water's not going into Rockland Harbor? Gee, not at all sketchy. Give me a break, come on. So there's that. And that's about all I have to say. But we will see each other in court if I get a bill for that because I shouldn't have to pay for water. that ain't going into Rothland Harbor and I don't think anybody should and I don't think the people in the bog who are poor should have to do it I don't think people who have large big warehouses some of these you know like mechanics and these warehouse places bike shops things like that these aren't huge rich businesses but they do have large parking lots and they do have large metal buildings and you're gonna ask them to pay because you don't want to you don't want to piss off your tax base you don't want to piss off your taxpayers because they all have small little dirt parking lots so they're gonna pay like 80 bucks a year but we're gonna have to pay four or five thousand A year because we have a parking lot the water goes into the bog doesn't even make it to the bog I guarantee you I mean, it's really ridiculous that you guys I mean like hire this firm To think this hyperactive near genius stuff up. Give me a friggin break It's ridiculous Pay all that money to these guys Use a modicum of common sense. How about that? It's a bog it's a bog folks water is supposed to go into the bog that's where it goes but you know what after that then it drains into Thomaston so we're not contributing to the problem so we're not going to pay and then if I have to go to court and everybody in the bog wants to go to court we can make it into a big class action lawsuit and the city of Rockland can pay for it and we'll get another engineering firm to do a counter study because we don't trust this one obviously. Is that where we want to go? Because that's where we're going to go and I don't have to ask anybody's permission to do that. I'm the sole owner of the business. If I want to do it, I can do it and I will because I'll be damned if I'm going to be paying thousands of dollars for rainwater going into a bunch of grass out behind my shop on Route 90. I mean, you think it's funny. It's not funny at all. I mean, you're stealing from us. I just got done installing a stove. I don't want to be here tonight, but I have to come talk to you yahoos about this stuff [Speaker L (unidentified): because apparently] we think that water coming off of a shop on Route 90 going into a bog is overwhelming storm drains in downtown Rockland and we don't get water so I'm gonna be asking I'd like some public water how about you guys dig a ditch and bring us some public water on Route 90 and do it all for all the people in the bog as well as well as sewer you guys are worrying about this these storm drains how about you worry about getting some people some drinking water. I don't even have drinkable water on Route 90. I had to pay $2,000 this year to put in a water treatment system just so that it wouldn't rot my pipes out. I don't see any help from you guys from the City of Rockland. I see the tax bills but I don't see any help and I have to pump my own sewer and so does everybody else on Route 90. We feel like second-class citizens out there paying Rockland taxes, we can't even get mail delivered. They drive right by if we have the flag up on our mailboxes. Anything larger than a mailbox we have to go downtown to go pick it up.
[1:39:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Thank you. You're welcome. Any other comments or questions? I just wanted to return to one point and I think, Terry, you alluded to this, and it seems implied with the budget itself. So assume that the city does not do anything relative to a utility. There's still decisions that have to be made on an annual basis of what projects that we fund and how we pay for those projects.
[1:39:54] Speaker I (unidentified): It's not going to be any different. No.
[1:39:56] Speaker B (unidentified): And so I guess my question is, in terms of the budget that is set for, that derives the sort of what the utility would capture, is that essentially equivalent to what annual cost that the city anticipates to endure in terms of project expenses that it has to pay for?
[1:40:24] Speaker I (unidentified): You're not going to be adding staff or employees because of the utility that you're not going to need if you said the Public Works Department's going to do it all and it's going to be a matter of taxes. The budget comes here, you approve the amount of projects to be done, they're done, they're just paid for through taxes. As far as the work that's going to be done, they don't care where the money comes from. The work has to be done, and the council has to figure out, along with the public, which method do you want to use to distribute the cost? The cost is not... We're not going to say, because we have a utility, all of a sudden the cost is going to be higher to build the amount of infrastructure needed. The amount of infrastructure is already set in a master plan. This is what you need.
[1:41:26] Speaker B (unidentified): I'm talking about the size of the budget that's set. How do we get to that level? Because at some point the size of the budget has to be measured based on what the costs that can be. You can't just it's not made in abstract, it's made what can the residents and the property owners bear, whether it's through a tax that's embedded in your taxes or more equitably distributed through a utility.
[1:41:58] Speaker I (unidentified): The process of budgeting is exactly the same. Whether it's a utility or not makes no difference. The budget's submitted through the city manager, to the council, and the council approves the budget, regardless of whether it's a utility or not. The utility is only a mechanism to distribute costs.
[1:42:23] Speaker B (unidentified): I understand that. That's all. What I'm saying is that there's a variable there by what budget is set on an annual basis, with which whether it's through the taxes or through the utility the city determines what size of budget they want to correct yes so I think the budgets
[1:42:41] Speaker D (unidentified): are essentially the same for the utility though you have the added cost of the administration of the utility so I don't recall what that cost is just our
[1:42:54] Speaker A (unidentified): current cost that's in the general yeah just for the first two years and then I think as the utility gets underway, we'll be looking at maybe a director at that point in time.
[1:43:03] Speaker I (unidentified): Again, that's not because of the utility. It's because of the amount of work. Absolutely. So you'll do the exact same thing whether you have a utility or not.
[1:43:13] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, yeah. If it stays in the general fund, it'll be added.
[1:43:16] Speaker I (unidentified): The big administrative cost here is when you get into the credit thing and you have to go through giving credits and taking a close look. That's the administrative part. it's worthwhile and I think you should do it but you can't do it through taxes
[1:43:32] Speaker B (unidentified): are there administrative costs that are covered by the utility that would have otherwise been covered by paying for staff at the treatment plant are there costs that are administrative in nature that are that exist regardless of whether there's a utility or not?
[1:43:58] Speaker I (unidentified): If you don't, I suppose the one major difference or something you have to consider in cost would be the billing process of it. That you're sending out a separate bill. Other than that, it's going to be basically the same cost. If you if you need ten people to take care of the sewer or the storm sewer you're going to need ten people Whether it's whether you're doing it through utility or you're doing it through the taxes. That's that's the difference
[1:44:34] Speaker C (unidentified): and I just add that the amount we're going to get from the nonprofits dwarfs the Billing the cost of administering the billing
[1:44:41] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, I don't what? Why should the taxpayers of this city pay for the county building? building when it services the entire county? Why shouldn't we be getting funds from the other parts of this county to take care of the infrastructure here? Look at the infrastructure around that county building. And it goes with spread right through the nonprofits. Why in Why in the world should the taxpayers be carrying the burden of stormwater that it's not getting any benefit from, the people aren't getting any benefit from a tax-free entity here? Not with that. They pay for their sewer. They pay for their water. They pay for their electricity. electricity, why shouldn't they pay for their portion of the stormwater?
[1:45:45] Speaker H (unidentified): And we have multiple county buildings, we have the courthouse, we have the jail, we have the emergency management building where the sheriff's office is, we have numerous county buildings in the city.
[1:46:03] Speaker I (unidentified): It doesn't make any, in the long run to the staff or the workers or the ability to get these things done doesn't make any difference whether it's a utility or not you can if you fund it through taxes if you fund it through utility makes absolutely no difference to the amount of work that has to be done not yes
[1:46:29] Speaker N (unidentified): we get kind of further into the weeds on this I kind of wanted to ask for clarification and to kind of bring it back right the can you just state your name for the oh yeah dan flynn i live on maverick street the we have been federally mandated correct to stop the mix of sewage and storm water yeah right that is a mandate they gave us a choice they gave us a choice new facility new massive facility 30 million
[1:47:00] Speaker I (unidentified): gallon a day treatment plant so all that waste gets second stage treatment or
[1:47:08] Speaker N (unidentified): take it out of this right and so just to totally clarify the choices are we pay for it or we pay for it we don't have an option to get away from this is not something that we can just say well this was a bad trip everybody's mad about it we can just ignore it and just let stormwater be what it is we don't have an option correct thank you have you have an option when you're looking at
[1:47:38] Speaker I (unidentified): the type of facilities that you're building and the engineering and it's always looked at
[1:47:44] Speaker N (unidentified): what's the most cost effective way to do it right we are going to pay for this one way or another it's a matter of how we would like to distribute said cost thank you yeah i just want
[1:47:55] Speaker B (unidentified): want to build on Dan's point, I think that one of the other variables is how much the city, how quickly do we want to move forward through that project list is going to determine the budget per year coupled with what we've already committed to in terms of those infrastructure costs that we're already paying for. Because that is a variable. We could decide to be more proactive or we could decide to, it really depends on an annual basis, correct? Yeah. Some of it.
[1:48:31] Speaker I (unidentified): The separation part will actually be written into the wastewater permit and you'll be required to do it. And if you don't, they'll do what they did years ago when they voted down whether they wanted the bill to revise the treatment plan or not. they'll shut down your additional growth of your community and say no more connections until it's done so and that's that's there we're negotiating that right now that when and how fast it has to be done because it takes it also there's some changes at the treatment plant that we've made at the same time it
[1:49:20] Speaker B (unidentified): would be helpful if I mean I know that master parent is out on the website but it would be helpful to revisit that and look at what aspects of the 30 million are need to happen over what period of time I think that would help us understand how do we you know what 's more media and what can take place over a longer time period.
[1:49:46] Speaker I (unidentified): You're pretty realistic at it when you look at it. You can only build so much at one time. You can only tear so many streets up at one time. So even if you said, OK, we want to do it all, and we want to do it all now, it's still a 10 or 20-year process to get it to the level where it has to be. And then on top of that, and we have to do it now with the grant that we just received for stormwater and sewer separation, we have to do an impact study on sea rise and see how that's going to affect the stormwater system, which it will. bill. Most of it's regulation. Do away with the regulation and things will get a lot less.
[1:50:44] Speaker J (unidentified): Terry, I've got a question about the tributaries. The Lindsay Brook is, you know, you and I have talked and so many people are so familiar with it. Seventeen homes and properties that are impacted by rise in the Lindsay Brook. The Lindsay Brook dumps right near, you know, into the harbor directly how can you just how do you sort through you know the Lindsay Brook which is some hybrid between a brook and a I don't know we don't know exactly what it really is but it's called a brook that is that water gonna be diverted and processed that 's in the Lindsay Brook how do How does this all become segregated as a practical matter?
[1:51:34] Speaker I (unidentified): In the sewer system, you have to disconnect every culvert that's connected to the sanitary sewer system and send it somewhere else. Maybe you could even say, maybe fortunately, the Lindsay Brook system runs through the community to give you somewhere to send that stormwater. But at the same time, then you have to accommodate it to make sure the Lindsay Brook can handle all of that flow.
[1:52:07] Speaker J (unidentified): But does it still dump unprocessed into the harbor?
[1:52:12] Speaker I (unidentified): Stormwater, yes. Because the stormwater, according to this state at this time, the stormwater doesn't need treatment as long as it doesn't have sewage in it.
[1:52:24] Speaker J (unidentified): Because there's still particulates and road salts and other, you know, insecticides and so on.
[1:52:31] Speaker I (unidentified): It's common that stormwater goes as quick as it can, which I don't agree with, as quick as it can to the nearest body of water. That always gets us in trouble sooner or later. There are some states now that are saying that stormwater has to be treated. we're going to do some treatment there's some things being built that take sediment out of it but most of the time is get it out of here and get it out of here fast what we end up doing is through the sewer system and through the storm sewer system is rob all the aquifers of water we don't have enough percolation that's taking place because we want to get rid of the storm water we don't want storm water in the streets so we built culverts all over it's it's it's the necessary evil of development of population growing it's a problem everywhere not heat not just here this utility I've been through this four or five times in other states utilities they set up now utilities for garbage, for stormwater, for sewer, for water, you know, it's only a method to try to distribute the cost more fairly, that's all it is.
[1:53:55] Speaker J (unidentified): Is it, and I'm asking you, this is an individual opinion, is there a problem with sewage being dumped into the harbor? Sewer? You said you've got to separate sewage from this runoff, and the objective is, that a condition that's happening, that sewage is going into the harbor?
[1:54:15] Speaker I (unidentified): The problem is when the stormwater and sanitary sewer are mixed in a rainfall, you go beyond the secondary treatment capacity of the treatment plant. So it gets diverted, and it only gets what they call primary treatment. So there's a less degree of treatment, and it's dumped directly into the harbor. There's no way to get around it. At the time that they designed that treatment plant, that was acceptable. The federal government made the city do that, made the city put a separate system in so you could divert flow. And it dumps into Lerman's Cove and right under the Landings Marina.
[1:55:05] Speaker J (unidentified): But, like, if you remove snow, you can't dump snow into the harbor.
[1:55:08] Speaker I (unidentified): Exactly. Well, that's what we're saying. That's what we're saying. You can't dump snow, and you're not going to be able to dump mixed storage.
[1:55:18] Speaker J (unidentified): So I'm just trying to get to, you know, the consistency of it all.
[1:55:22] Speaker I (unidentified): There's no consistency in it. Yeah, there is none. It's nothing.
[1:55:27] Speaker J (unidentified): As far as, you know, what is the practical impact on the environment? What is the practical impact? It seems, and I could be wrong, but it seems that the real driver of this has to do with not overwhelming the current facilities. Is that what the objective is, to control the amount of velocity into the existing resources?
[1:55:55] Speaker I (unidentified): The community flooding that you have in Upland.
[1:55:59] Speaker J (unidentified): Those are the goals.
[1:56:01] Speaker B (unidentified): Wouldn't you also add the cost of treating water that you don't? Like right now we're treating water that is...
[1:56:08] Speaker I (unidentified): You don't need to be treated. You don't need to be treated.
[1:56:11] Speaker B (unidentified): And that's a cost.
[1:56:12] Speaker I (unidentified): The state starting next year will require us, right now we chlorinate seasonally. We stop chlorinating at the end of October and we don't have to chlorinate all winter there now the mandate is that you have to you have to chlorinate twelve months a year that's going to cost us probably a hundred and twenty five thousand dollars more a year plus at least at least two hundred thousand dollars in the treatment plant to accommodate how we're going to add that chemical during the winter months because of the freezing requirements. That's a requirement. We don't have any choice. They said, no, that's it. You don't have any choice. It's, to me, in the business, the gentleman said he was in the business for 33 years. I've been in into business for 55 years. I know I look young. 55 years. Why? It's because some other communities and they're discharged. The receiving water is having problems. So what's the federal government do? Everybody has to do it.
[1:57:33] Speaker J (unidentified): It's reality. There's a number of $30 million. It's either this or are you going to pay $30 million for a new?
[1:57:40] Speaker I (unidentified): You can't. The idea that you're going to build.
[1:57:43] Speaker J (unidentified): What I'm trying to get to is where does that reference come from?
[1:57:46] Speaker I (unidentified): The idea that when I say that you have that alternative to increase the treatment plant to a 30 million gallon a day treatment plant, that's hundreds of million dollars, not 30 million gallons. But you can't do it anyway. We don't have the land. can't. It's an impossible thing to do. So we have no choice but to separate.
[1:58:11] Speaker B (unidentified): And they know that. I just wanted to check is there any other questions on Zoom? No. Do you have any more questions?
[1:58:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, just apropos consistency, I can't resist trotting out the old Emerson quote, the foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds. Not talking about you, Rick. I only had one other question. There was a reference earlier to Bangor that Bangor did not
[1:58:35] Speaker D (unidentified): move forward with the stormwater utility do you know why i do and it was the way that it was presented to the public it was presented as and i shudder to say this as a rain tax instead of a stormwater fee and as soon as that verbiage got out there it was it was all over so we're We're trying to be consistent with our messaging and we're trying to keep things factual to what they are. So this is a stormwater utility fee that is paid by people who are benefiting from the use of the stormwater system and the other stormwater infrastructure in town, in the city.
[1:59:19] Speaker I (unidentified): Okay. Good lesson there. I want to make it clear also. I'm not arguing for a utility. utility. I'm saying that these are the reasons why that it may be something good for the community to distribute the cost, but to get all projects done and do what we have to do, it makes no difference whether it comes out of taxes or utility.
[1:59:44] Speaker C (unidentified): Well, I am very much in favor of utility. I think that's certainly the mood of the Council, though obviously there remain to be issues to resolve and discuss. Thank you all very much for this presentation and for the work you've put into this so far and i just want to well
[2:00:01] Speaker B (unidentified): echo thank you for coming to us again with some updated info i think would be helpful there's a lot of people in the public that are that are still learning about this there's a great website anyone who's watching this can go to the city's website and look up stormwater and there's a whole page of past meetings but I do think it would be helpful to have a general-purpose overview document and a list of these frequently asked questions that keep coming up be a good way to for us to want to answer questions but also there are new questions that are going to occur as people start looking more into this, how it applies to them. In terms of a couple of next steps, I did hear, and this is by no means a summary of all the points, but we did have a question about whether a phased-in approach could happen. What would that look like? What would be the pros and cons? the geographical question about the concerns from property owners who are not contributing directly to the to the sewer system then we had questions around the credit levels whether they're sufficient or not and then the minimum credit for individual homeowner what would that look like or the maximum
[2:01:37] Speaker C (unidentified): Oh, maximum credit, yeah.
[2:01:39] Speaker B (unidentified): And then the other point, which I think is probably the most important, is the economic modeling on, like, what an actual, once you determine the EDU, what is the bill going to look like for an average resident? And just provide some examples. I know you looked at that during the study, but as we get closer to a real number, I think that would be very helpful for us to see.
[2:02:09] Speaker D (unidentified): That there's a really good pamphlet that's on your website that describes a lot of what you're talking about Relative to the examples the property examples we go through an example of a single-family home with different levels of impervious area a commercial facility tax-exempt facility County owned and commercial a larger commercial So there are some of those pieces of information that are that are out there.
[2:02:35] Speaker I (unidentified): You know, I think be interesting to do is come up with, say, no credits at all. Say no credits. This is the unit charge. And then go 10% credit, 20% credit, 30% credit, and see what it does to the base charge. Because there's somewhere where the lines will converge and say, well, you can't go any more than this. And that's what you do.
[2:03:08] Speaker B (unidentified): But there's also got to be an assumption of what the city is going to spend on an annual basis. And if it spends it out of the tax base, it's going to be one cost to the mill rate. And then if we do it out of a utility, it's going to have a different impact on the mill rate. I think seeing those two numbers gets to the point of what Counselor Callahan mentioned and others about who shares the burden of that cost.
[2:03:44] Speaker D (unidentified): So that table I mentioned has the estimated stormwater annual fee for all of those properties, but then it also shows the tax annual amount. The annual increase. Yeah, the annual increase. Okay.
[2:03:59] Speaker E (unidentified): Great. I think that brochure also has some Q&A responses, so we can look at that.
[2:04:07] Speaker B (unidentified): If it can just be updated to reflect October 2026, just so people are looking at something that doesn't feel a couple meetings past, that would be really helpful for us. Any other? Well, thank you again for being here.
[2:04:30] Speaker D (unidentified): Thank you for having us. Wait in motion.
[2:04:34] Speaker C (unidentified): Move to adjourn.
[2:04:36] Speaker B (unidentified): We'll adjourn at 735.
[2:04:42] Speaker D (unidentified): So you weren't going to do it? No.