← Back to MaineScanner

Waterville Planning Board reviews parking expansion and hospital rezoning requests

2026-11-10 · 2h 22m · Source: Waterville Planning Board 11/10/2026 (Crossroads TV - Waterville Planning Board (Vimeo user))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:04] Speaker A (unidentified): Welcome to the City of Waterville Planning Board meeting, everyone. The first item is approval of minutes of the September 22nd meeting. [0:15] Speaker B (unidentified): I'll make a motion to approve. I'll second. [0:18] Speaker A (unidentified): Any discussion? All those in favor? Next, disclosure of conflict of interest. Anyone have any conflict that they need to disclose for the items that we're going to be discussing tonight? Okay, not hearing any. I would like to move item number five which is the Colby College item to be the first item that we discussed tonight. Is there any opposition to that? No? Okay, then we'll just go ahead and do that. So up next is Colby College. They're requesting informal pre-application review for the construction of a 206 six space parking lot to be built as an extension to the north end of the alumni parking lot. Good [1:38] Speaker C (unidentified): evening everyone. I'm Holly McKenzie, project manager at Colby College, and yes, we are seeking a informal pre-application review of a proposed 206 space extension to the alumni parking lot. I assume you're all set with your adobe free trial? [1:59] Speaker D (unidentified): I think so. As I [2:08] Speaker C (unidentified): said, it's a 206 space extension of the alumni parking lot, which as we look, we have a total campus map here. This is our alumni parking lot which is located behind the share Swenson and Watson Alumni Center and the Davis Science Building, and it is located on the east side of campus, and that is our proposed project that we're bringing for informal review this evening. Do you [2:36] Speaker A (unidentified): mind zooming in? Yeah, maybe. Yeah, bottom right. So [2:48] Speaker C (unidentified): the proposed location is where four previous tennis courts were located that we removed in 2024. Now we're driving without, how's that, does that work? Yeah, thank you very much. I do have a plan view plan sheet to a landscape plan on the next page, so again extending this lot here to be behind these existing tennis courts. Okay, and then the next sheet, and then there's a more detailed view of the proposed parking lot. So again these are the existing tennis courts. Down here is that existing parking tray as shown on the previous aerial photo, and here is the 206 space extension, okay. [4:10] Speaker A (unidentified): Questions from the board? [4:15] Speaker B (unidentified): Does the proposed parking area, does that extend into the Arboretum or into the forested area that currently exists? [4:22] Speaker C (unidentified): There is a forested area. It is not considered part of the Arboretum, but there is a forested area. Yes. [4:28] Speaker B (unidentified): And are those storm water retention ponds on the right hand side? Yes they are. And where do those drain into? So those are the ponds themselves. [4:37] Speaker C (unidentified): So the surface water from the parking lot will drain and be treated in those ponds similarly as we've done adjacently to baseball softball. There is an [4:48] Speaker B (unidentified): existing or pre-existing pond on the overhead view? Yes. I assume that the existing pond is at a lower elevation. It is, I am not sure of the elevation, but [5:01] Speaker C (unidentified): unfortunately it does not have the capacity to treat these, but these [5:06] Speaker B (unidentified): proposed ponds would theoretically drain downhill into a lower area. Like where do they drain after they retain the runoff? Where does it go? It would go [5:19] Speaker C (unidentified): into groundwater system and they would, yes, drain into nearest. And [5:27] Speaker B (unidentified): how close are the new ponds from the existing pond is it 's hard to tell from the yeah I [5:34] Speaker C (unidentified): would, I'm not scaling off the drawings, but just by visual, so one of the ponds would be located on kind of the edge of the trees here, and then this is the adjacent, closest adjacent pond. When [5:50] Speaker B (unidentified): you come back, could you come back with an overlay with the schematic drawing overlaid over the existing topography? [5:57] Speaker C (unidentified): Absolutely, we can do that. [6:03] Speaker A (unidentified): What's the intended use for these parking spaces? [6:06] Speaker C (unidentified): The intended use is to relocate spaces from the Roberts parking lot as we look forward to the science complex. So it's a reallocation of spaces that will be [6:16] Speaker A (unidentified): taken up with the new science complex. And what are the existing uses of the [6:20] Speaker C (unidentified): Roberts lot? The existing uses of the Roberts lot is for staff, faculty, and student parking. Okay, perfect. Any [6:32] Speaker A (unidentified): other questions from the board? Okay, are there any questions from the public on this? My only question. Okay, great. Do you know when you intend to come back for [6:53] Speaker C (unidentified): final approval? We are looking to come back for final approval when the next planning board groups, whether that's in two or four weeks. I know we're getting into the holiday season, so whether it's two weeks or four weeks, we'll be prepared for final approval. Okay. [7:09] Speaker A (unidentified): And do we have a meeting confirmed for two weeks from now? Hang on a second. [7:14] Speaker E (unidentified): You were going to ask to make a notification. Yes, thank you. If you vote to waive the notification requirement, because they've already notified for the DEP site location, I still have to put a link. Yep, absolutely. So that will require 14 days. Okay. [7:36] Speaker A (unidentified): So you wouldn't be able to make two weeks from now anyway? [7:39] Speaker C (unidentified): So I believe that pushes us to maybe the 8th of December is four weeks from now. I [7:54] Speaker A (unidentified): did say that I'm not available on the 8th. Yeah, I'm not available on the. Okay. [8:05] Speaker C (unidentified): We're looking at a springtime construction, so we're not in any sure immediate hurry, but we're ready for approval when the board is ready to [8:13] Speaker E (unidentified): Me, okay, will there [8:44] Speaker F (unidentified): be only one means of entrance to that parking lot? Yes, there will be. And it would, that be the road that goes down to what was, there was a [8:56] Speaker C (unidentified): house down there or a home down there at one time? Yes, the Hill House. Yes, the entrance will be off of Alumni Drive, which is the current entrance, one of the current entrances to this existing Alumni parking lot, and then here's your Hill House right here on this plan. Yes, yep, you can go either direction as you [9:25] Speaker A (unidentified): come out of the parking lot. I just thought of another question. So this is gonna be 206 spaces. Correct. How many spaces are in the existing lot that this is replacing? 324. Okay, so that's a kind of a substantial loss of parking spaces. [9:43] Speaker C (unidentified): It is. We have done multiple parking studies across campus, and even with only the addition of the 206 versus the 324, there will be some parking spaces left at Science, not as many, but there still will be ample parking across campus with the parking studies that we've done. Okay, well [10:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I guess we can entertain a motion to waive the notification requirement. I'll make the motion to waive the notification requirement. I'll second. All those in favor. Okay, well, we look forward to seeing you at the next meeting. Great, thank you so much. Okay, next is Inland Commercial Center is requesting informal pre-application review for the creation of 36 apartments in the former Inland Hospital building at 200 Kenny Memorial Drive. Yes, yeah, and we don't often get a lot of people here from the public, so the item after this one is the request for rezoning. This is simply a pre-application review for the creation of the 36 apartments in the former hospital building, so this [11:59] Speaker G (unidentified): basically is the enlarged God, why is it upside down? You guys gonna have to bear with me, I'm not a techno whiz. [Speaker H (unidentified): ] This is obviously the site for the former hospital, and I have gone through the parking calculations with the parking that is here and determined that there is adequate parking for the residential that we're looking to put in here and still leave adequate parking for the remainder of the building if it, assuming it's going to be office space. He's still trying to determine what he can get in there, but right now we're just looking to try to you get approval for change of views for some residential units. And I do have the floor plans of what we're looking at doing. They can do that to me every time. The second floor of, [Speaker I (unidentified): let] me get the overall so you can understand where we really are. [13:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. Thank you. Yeah, this [14:11] Speaker G (unidentified): Is this is the medical arts building? Mm-hmm. Now see this is the main portion of the hospital and I'm not sure what the name of this of this wing is, but the second floor of this wing is where we're looking to get residential units in this area right here. The medical arts building is still undetermined. It's gonna be office space more than likely and the same with over here. He's been talking to multiple people, he's been talking to some medical people who have been thinking about coming in here but nothing is set in stone, so that's why we're just looking for site plan approval for change of use for this portion of the second floor and also the third floor, which was the former maternity ward. We're looking at putting residential units up there as well. So is what you're seeking [15:50] Speaker A (unidentified): approval for is both the second and the third floor? Yes. So how many units on each of those floors and what size would the units be? The size of the units vary [16:03] Speaker G (unidentified): depending on the size of the rooms that are there. [16:09] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, third floor is 13. I don't [16:17] Speaker G (unidentified): remember off the top of my head, so I have to go back and look. No, that's, I believe there's a total [16:22] Speaker J (unidentified): of 44 they turned into, which was basically what they've done is going to do is take the patient rooms, yep, and the maternity ward, which maternity ward is all third floor. [16:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Is he, I was going to say, yeah, if you don't mind coming up. Yeah, okay. [16:49] Speaker J (unidentified): I'm the property manager of the property as of right now, okay, and like I said, the third floor it was all maternity ward. They're going to take those rooms and turn them into residential and then where the patient room was on the second floor they're going to do that. Typically they're going to be a one bedroom studio type apartment. I don't know of any two bedrooms that I know of yet, okay. So it's all one bedroom or studio apartments? [17:23] Speaker G (unidentified): So there's 23 units on the second floor. [17:27] Speaker J (unidentified): Okay. And 13 is, yeah, okay, 36. Yep. [17:31] Speaker A (unidentified): So, I mean, kinda, like what's the range of unit sizes? [17:43] Speaker J (unidentified): You're gonna talk about probably 600 to 1,000 square feet, right? [17:47] Speaker A (unidentified): No, he's the architect. Yeah, I spent many nights on the third floor 18, 19 years ago, so I'm very familiar with those rooms. They definitely weren't 600 square feet, yep, and if [18:18] Speaker G (unidentified): you give me just a moment I can tell you how big they're [18:34] Speaker A (unidentified): so around 320 on the third floor and 250 on the second and [18:54] Speaker E (unidentified): Is your mic on? I believe we will have to revise the zoning ordinance. I'm sorry, I think we require 300 square feet in the commercialism. An individual apartment must contain not less than 600 square feet of habitable space unless we call that an accessory. Doing yeah, I don't know how many, you can't have that many accessories, so we would have to revise. [19:42] Speaker A (unidentified): Who's who's the who's the target demographic for these actually? [19:51] Speaker J (unidentified): Looking at more of a college students since you have two colleges and I know that one of the colleges they've been renting hotels for a couple years so that's basically where we're where we're shooting for. [20:04] Speaker H (unidentified): Okay are. [20:07] Speaker K (unidentified): There kitchenettes in there? Yes there will be. Okay I just want to say I have an edu attached to my house that's just over 250 square feet including the bathroom and it's sizable. I mean it's great for, I have there's a couple living in there right now they love it so it's you know. [20:25] Speaker A (unidentified): For the right demographic that's not crazy. Yeah sure is there going to be some shared you know laundry space and stuff like that will that be will that be on site is the plan for that to be on site that has been discussed. Okay yeah you know most of the people who went. [20:48] Speaker G (unidentified): Through the code office and all the other guys were there they was like oh god this would make a great room you should put a kitchenette here and yeah okay oops do all the units have windows? Yes that's why there's probably one less unit than what Wally was saying because I realized there was a unit in the corner that had a window originally, but when they added on, that window went away. So that unit become a double unit. Okay. And I think code-wise, you can have a unit without a window, but I would not want one. [21:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I mean, it sounds like there may be some further discussions with maybe Ann and Code Enforcement on unit sizes and stuff. [21:48] Speaker E (unidentified): No it's in the zoning ordinance so we can't waive it we have to revise the zoning ordinance and when I say we technically the council has to refer to the planning board so that would be your next step. Yeah it seems like a waste real waste of time since you're right here right now maybe you could at least offer an opinion as to whether you'd like to recommend that this isn't a real vote. [22:21] Speaker C (unidentified): Sure,, sure. [22:22] Speaker A (unidentified): No, this is informal pre-application review, right? So we're just having a conversation. [22:28] Speaker E (unidentified): We're sliding back and forth between informal pre-application review. [22:31] Speaker A (unidentified): Anybody on the board have any opinions about? [22:34] Speaker D (unidentified): I have an opinion. [22:35] Speaker K (unidentified): As somebody who's on the housing committee at the state level, we need 80,000 new housing units in Maine in order to keep up with our growth over the next five years. The likelihood of us hitting that target is very slim I think at 250, especially if we're talking about college students who don't take up year-round housing. It's a shame to see permanent housing going to college students because it really reduces the availability for the average citizen to obtain affordable and accessible housing. So, you know, this is one of those solutions that seems pretty good to me. But I also did not love the 600 square foot minimum space in a commercial A, just because I think that 600... Oh, I thought you said 600. [23:29] Speaker E (unidentified): In commercial A? In commercial A, the apartments have to be 300 square feet. [23:34] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay, great. I swear you said 600. [23:36] Speaker E (unidentified): So you're saying the smallest... [23:38] Speaker A (unidentified): you definitely said 600 about something yeah i remember hearing that term all right but that's [23:43] Speaker K (unidentified): okay i don't know if it's 300 that's that's great yeah i mean he doesn't have 300 yeah [23:49] Speaker D (unidentified): we would be talking about reducing it by 50 feet right i will say from my tenants experience [23:57] Speaker K (unidentified): and from my own personally my plan is to someday move out of my house and rent that and move into to my ADU where I will live very happily and comfortably at 250 square feet, just saying. [24:08] Speaker G (unidentified): So that's my opinion. Well, it's funny, you know, as you get older, you know, the smaller space [24:12] Speaker K (unidentified): is better. A lot less to clean. I'll say that. [24:16] Speaker F (unidentified): To support Cassie's position, clearly there is a shortage of houses in Maine. And what she had intimated was that college students can live in a smaller unit and they can live in a larger apartment unit. A family can live in a larger apartment unit but cannot live in a smaller unit. Right. So i'm up with the opinion that this is something that is needed anywhere but here in waterville is special i guess yep so yeah i'm in favor of that at this point [25:06] Speaker K (unidentified): good point yeah thank you i will also add that there is also a shortage of housing that's easy for retired people to live in seasonal people all sorts of people who prefer a smaller space that just needs someplace to live that don't need you know a giant apartment and don't want to spend 1800 to 2500 a month on a three-bedroom apartment you know so yeah i think [25:33] Speaker G (unidentified): it's a great solution and you have what but you know what they call the work for workforce housing [25:38] Speaker A (unidentified): Where you have people come in for a period of time and yeah, so if I remember the process correctly, so hopefully that can get on the city council agenda for a week from [25:56] Speaker E (unidentified): now. They've already closed the agenda they have next meeting, okay, so that [26:03] Speaker A (unidentified): would mean it wouldn't get to them until December 1st would be the earliest it could get to them, and then they would vote on sending it to us for having a public hearing to make a recommendation back to them, and then they have to vote on it twice. Yep, so sorry we have to jump through. Yeah, so and I'm assuming that you wouldn't be coming back for final approval until the rezoning happened as well, right? Well it wouldn't make sense to come back for final [26:57] Speaker E (unidentified): approval before the zoning, right, because it's not permitted. Yeah, our solicitor had just advised us not to approve, correct, a final plan until the zoning is finalized, right, okay. [27:14] Speaker A (unidentified): Any other discussion then on the on this agenda item from the board on [27:26] Speaker B (unidentified): the other buildings on this property, what proposed uses are [27:30] Speaker J (unidentified): going to be? It's a big property. Well the like I said, 180 the medical arts centers, they're looking at office space or medical people because it's still got the medical equipment in it. 174 which is the down one below the hill is it could be either or. I've had people looking at it as an office space, I've had people looking at it as a medical building, and the Buxton building which is in the back, we're actually going to be talking about that tonight, and then what 246 which is across the road, that's basically all going to be either office space or might be sold that you know it's it's either with or either or, but that most people looking at that is office space. I could, I didn't catch your name when you, I'm Wally Williams. Yeah, [28:29] Speaker H (unidentified): I do have, you put any thought into how all these different uses are all going to interact, you know, if there's office spaces and people living in apartments and stuff like that, there's going to be a mixture of uses. Have you thought about like how if there's any problems that could be brought up because of that? We have thought about [28:58] Speaker J (unidentified): That yes, okay, and that's why the typically on the first floor is going to be the offices, second floor, third floor that will be the apartments. If the emergency room wing or whatever gets used as a different thing, we've already figured out what doors we're going to close that the tenants cannot get to it. So yes, we have put a lot of thought in that. You have all these different people in there and they can't interact or get the tenants in the middle of the night get to where [29:32] Speaker G (unidentified): they don't need to be. Obviously there will be some egress that they will share, but they'll be locked off so that if I'm, if I'm a tenant I can't just go wandering through the whole [29:44] Speaker J (unidentified): whole building. Yeah, we have thought about that. Yes, I [29:52] Speaker I (unidentified): mean so to the flip side of that also, I mean if I lived on the second or third floor, how are you keeping other people from accessing the apartments? Well it's, it's any other [30:03] Speaker J (unidentified): apartment. You have an elevator, it was just gonna have to make sure that they lock the doors or yeah, I mean I don't know what else to say. My gut feeling [30:12] Speaker G (unidentified): is that there'll be a walk-off so that you can't get to the third floor unless [30:17] Speaker J (unidentified): you have some sort of right. You'd be like the penthouse third floor, but the [30:22] Speaker G (unidentified): second floor could be different. It's like any hotel you go to, you can't go [30:28] Speaker H (unidentified): up the elevator unless you have. Yeah, I'm in favor obviously of adding housing. I just, yeah, I think I'd like to see like a full plan of exactly what's gonna be happening, what your plan is for everything. Sure, for make a final [30:46] Speaker G (unidentified): decision or recommendation. Sure, yeah, I mean I can show you some on the, on the plan right now if you, if you want, if you want to take the time. Yeah, absolutely, okay. If I go back to the first floor, we right now, you know, they can come in here, both residential and commercial can come in here. The residential won't be able to go through this door because we're putting a door there, and residential people won't be able to go through these doors to get into this space, and that's obviously the first floor at the ground floor. Yes, yeah, so both commercial and residential can come in here, you know, and I shouldn't say they can't go through there if the business is open during the day. Sure, obviously they're not going to have, they could be customers of those businesses. Exactly, yeah, but when this business is closed at the end of the day, the people that come in here won't be able to get in there. Yep, so that and again the stair back here, when you, once you go into the stairwell you won't be able to come Back in doing your only option is to go out unless you have a key to get on in on the second floor. Yep, so yes, you know we have thought about this and if I go back to the second floor we are putting a closure right here so that if you're on in this section of the of the building you obviously you won't be able you won't even be able to get over there and if you're over here you won't be able to get over here and that's totally separated. Yeah, the means of egress basically works with the stair here and the stair there this dead-end corridor is not doesn't exceed what's permitted so this floor here will be all residential and this over here will be business of some kind. Yep, and obviously when we come back for final approval I'll have these plans and probably be a step or two farther than they are right now [33:45] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, that's helpful. Any comments from the public give you guys an opportunity how far are you along? Oh sorry if you could come up to the podium and just give your name and it's for [34:08] Speaker L (unidentified): the minutes and name is Paul De Rosby and I just wondered we're talking final approvals and whatnot where are you in the process do you think you're looking at six months out a year out? Okay well the owner thought several months ago that it just seems it's it's a bigger thing than I think that he may have originally [34:38] Speaker G (unidentified): expected. Well as soon as we get all the approvals which is still gonna take some time right I think they probably will start construction and modification what modifications [34:52] Speaker L (unidentified): need to be done very shortly thereafter. Yeah and the only other question was everything seems to be working with the existing wondered if there was going to be any significant structural renovations. No thank you we're [35:13] Speaker G (unidentified): trying to stay with as much existing as possible. Sure [35:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah I didn't see anybody else's hands go up so no okay one last call from the board no okay well thank you very much and obviously we look forward to you coming back for that final approval. Yep so the next item is you guys again requesting these I didn't go anywhere requesting rezoning from institutional to commercial A for a portion of the property and from institutional and commercial B to commercial A for another portion of the property and that should encompass the entire property and so in summary you're looking for everything to be commercial A yes [36:14] Speaker G (unidentified): Okay but we have they have a tenant who was looking at the Buxton building who would need to be in commercial B okay [36:27] Speaker A (unidentified): And is that a separate parcel, and if so, do you happen to know which one? Because we have listed here, we have map 37 parcels 128 1, 132 1 through 11, and 131. That's the [36:53] Speaker J (unidentified): Buxton building right there. Sure, but I'll go back to do we know what [37:09] Speaker G (unidentified): parcel that is? But it's on the same parcel, it's not a separate piece of [37:12] Speaker A (unidentified): property. So do we know which parcel? We don't want to switch it to a to find out that you then want to switch it back, right? So if we make a recommendation to City Council, we need to be, we need to be specific. If you're asking us to make the recommendation to make a certain parcel commercial B, then we would need [37:37] Speaker E (unidentified): to know the parcel, well, the boundaries, in other words, to rezone it. We need to have boundaries. [37:44] Speaker G (unidentified): Right. So I mean, the folks who want to do this, I hear as well, and my [38:00] Speaker J (unidentified): question only because I'm, you know, if you get all those numbers, do you have a map that where those numbers would be, because I could, if I had a map, I could take, because I haven't been told of. [38:14] Speaker A (unidentified): It's on the city's website. I can look it up real quick. But [38:28] Speaker E (unidentified): the point is, whatever parcel number it is, the parcel needs to be divided, because you don't want the hospital building and the Buxton building are the same as this parcel. Right, yes. Excuse me. So we need to know what the boundaries would be of the Buxton building. Because I have to give that to people who make the map, right? They can't rezone just a squiggly [38:55] Speaker M (unidentified): little one. We need, right, needs some balance. So yeah, that falls into [39:08] Speaker A (unidentified): parcel 132, which is basically the whole thing, right? So yeah, so basically, and we would need to have that parcel split up, you [39:37] Speaker E (unidentified): know. And we don't know, you don't have to split the parcel, you just have to, you have to have a description of the line. Got it, okay. [39:48] Speaker J (unidentified): So you basically get a surveyor out there to give us the meat [39:53] Speaker N (unidentified): to balance. You use WGS 84 coordinates to map it out. I'm sorry, can we just [39:59] Speaker O (unidentified): issues like, you know, WGS 84 coordinates. Sorry. Yep. John York, owner of Full Metal Fab Performance. We're the ones looking to lease the building and eventually own it. Would it be permissible to give you a description based on just general GIS coordinates that build a polygon around it? As opposed to? I don't know. I wouldn't be the one doing the mapping. Is it CAI that does it? [40:31] Speaker E (unidentified): If you can talk with them. [40:32] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, I'm sure they're using, like, ArcGIS Pro or one of those programs. Yep, they're using ArcGIS. Yeah, I formerly was a GIS analyst, so I can certainly provide you guys a polygon and lines. Make them happy, yeah. So, yeah, and it would be commercial B is what we're looking for to permit what we're looking to use it for. Okay. [40:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. You'll probably come back up. Yeah. Yeah, so, okay, so we're looking at commercial A, you know, and a small portion of it be commercial. Yes. Okay, what's the overall vision for the entirety of everything for that one building? [41:21] Speaker G (unidentified): No, he had for an entire site. [41:26] Speaker J (unidentified): The, like I said, you've got the biggest part of it in the hospital as offices and residential. The only thing that's changing that would be a puppy would be that one building, and where's that little? Might that? It used to be the biohazard building. On the next to it. It's just the garage is what it is. [41:48] Speaker G (unidentified): But if you're asking what's going to happen back here? [41:51] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I don't have a good answer for that. No. Okay, so there's no concrete plans that you guys wouldn't be coming to us anytime soon for site plan review for any new construction or anything like that? You're really just wanting to get the rezoning so that you can reuse the existing buildings? That's correct. As they are today, that's correct. Okay, I [42:20] Speaker G (unidentified): mean, I know at some point he would like to do something back here. Yeah, but it's not anything that's on the plate right now. Yeah, go ahead, earlier you had said something [42:34] Speaker I (unidentified): about the building across the street. Is that the one that you were talking about? [42:37] Speaker J (unidentified): No. Okay, so that one is [42:47] Speaker I (unidentified): one that you would look to split off and know that [42:50] Speaker G (unidentified): that one already currently is split off, right? Yeah, it's not, it's not on that property at all. [42:55] Speaker J (unidentified): This is the KMD Condominium Association as it's in. You've got a doctor's office over here, somebody just bought 222 that they're remodeling, and 246 is sitting right over here in the corner [43:10] Speaker G (unidentified): of this, Ted. I thought, I thought Wally was talking about these buildings right here. Yes, that's what [43:16] Speaker A (unidentified): I am. Yeah, right, I was gonna say that's, yeah, so is part of this what's asking to be rezone? Yes, those are already in the commercial zone. Yes. Okay. [43:39] Speaker G (unidentified): I think those are commercial see and that's very concerned you [43:49] Speaker E (unidentified): all have that map in your shared space to get out so it's commercial see yes and then all of [44:14] Speaker J (unidentified): the other properties and then yes actually over in here commercial safe this is the answer this is probably the road that goes down through here's KMD I'm talking about their little private road that goes into the hospital [44:31] Speaker G (unidentified): Which is right here? Yeah, those buildings are right here. Yeah, they're right on the [44:37] Speaker J (unidentified): main drive. [44:49] Speaker E (unidentified): That's Lakewood and these are the office buildings up here in that commercial season, right? But we're only talking, so he's talking about the Buxton building, which is right around, if you knew where the walking [45:05] Speaker J (unidentified): trail is, pretty close, that walk. Yeah, this is the sewer easement here. Yeah. [45:10] Speaker H (unidentified): Yeah, sorry, [45:15] Speaker A (unidentified): I'm just trying to find these. I see one of them is listed as Parcel 128, and I'm having a hard time finding that on this map. Oh, sorry, 128, yep, 128, and then 132. And then 131, okay. [45:39] Speaker J (unidentified): okay so that 's going to be the one that's 128 it's going to actually probably where the buxton building is yeah because [45:49] Speaker A (unidentified): that's that, you know, I think this is the wooded area, but okay, if anybody else wants to look at that, okay. And you know, we've already kind of discussed what the, what the intended use of, you know, the old hospital and the medical arts, it's building there is the walk-in clinic that's listed here. That's right, that's 174, that's down over the hill, that's this one right here. So what's, what's the plan for that again? That's going [46:25] Speaker J (unidentified): to be either basically offices and, like I said, that's up for sale. More, I'll get more people looking to buy that than to rent it or get it remodel it, and it's basically offices and then [46:41] Speaker A (unidentified): there's also 224 KMD, which is just described as a medical office building. 224 don't belong to us. [46:52] Speaker J (unidentified): That is the medical office building and it doesn't belong to you? Nope, we had what would come with the complex was 222, okay, 246, 200, 180 and 174, and the Buxton building really don't have an address. [47:09] Speaker A (unidentified): that's why they call it a bucket to build well sure it's just what's was sent to us was 224 yeah Kennedy Memorial Drive so 24 it does not belong to this [47:23] Speaker E (unidentified): inland according to the assessor record. I got that from the assessor. Yes, I know [47:30] Speaker J (unidentified): because the assessor called me the other day and was talking about that and I said, 224 does not belong to us. [47:39] Speaker E (unidentified): So he hasn't been paying the taxes on it. [47:42] Speaker J (unidentified): So, like I said, he's actually coming up next week. Who's he? This guy from Boston and the city assessor. [47:56] Speaker G (unidentified): So which one's 224? [47:58] Speaker J (unidentified): 224 is the double two-story. That's it, you got 222, 224 is right next to it, and then 246 is what we owe, 180, the medical arts building is 180, it's one that's attached to the hospital. [48:17] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, so 224 is one of these up here. Yes, okay, gotcha, okay, so then whatever [48:29] Speaker A (unidentified): whatever recommendation we make, it will not include 224-KMD. [48:34] Speaker J (unidentified): Nope. Right, because that's all up in the commercial. Yes. [48:40] Speaker H (unidentified): I think there needs to be more research done on this, and more work needs to be done before we're able to make an accurate recommendation. There's a lot of what-ifs and everything. We need to have something a little more concrete before we can make a recommendation. [48:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I think it would be very helpful to get a map. Well, one, we're really going to need to know the boundaries of the Buxton building, and if it's, and I would, I would definitely talk, and I don't know if you can help facilitate that conversation, but it may need an address. I think the reason it doesn't have an [49:25] Speaker E (unidentified): an address is because it was hard to find an address because it's way back at the back of the [49:31] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, it took three months to get to where the meter was, the electrical meter. Yeah, sure, I'm [49:38] Speaker A (unidentified): just thinking for emergency services purposes. Yeah, I, it's going to need an address, and we'll need those boundaries, but it would be really nice to have a map that clearly shows which properties and which parcels are being asked? [49:58] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, personally, I have hatched the area that we're talking about. This area up here is not included in my plan. [50:11] Speaker I (unidentified): Yeah, but the Buxton building is. Right. [50:14] Speaker G (unidentified): I,, we just wound up about 224. Yeah. Yeah. And so the lot that we're talking about, I have hatched. there is the issue unfortunately they come up with changing part of this to commercial b i originally almost said i just don't even want to talk about it let's just get a commercial a and come back later and do that yeah because this is going to delay our approval for the residential just a little bit farther believe me i understand the situation you're in i'm not trying to be had to get along with you'd like to come up and talk yeah just [51:07] Speaker A (unidentified): just one second, thank you. So yeah, I'm, I'm, and I don't even, and I don't even know how we get that fixed, because I'm assuming the request that came from city council included 224. [51:29] Speaker E (unidentified): Let me see the agenda. All right, okay, the agenda, right, hang on a second. Yes, 224, that is from the assessor. I ask which parcels do they, sure, so I will just back that out. [51:55] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, and I have no problem doing that. 's to me that's easy is we just say, well, we obviously can't recommend changes to that because they don't own that property requesting it, right? So the parcels and buildings in question, the buildings are all highlighted in gray, correct? Yes, and I understand where the Buxton building is. Yeah, and you said that building to the left of it was the bio, biohazard [52:30] Speaker J (unidentified): building. Yeah, it's just an old, it's just a garage, it's just a garage, and is [52:34] Speaker A (unidentified): That being so close to the Buxton building is the request for that to be it part of that commercial B zone. I would probably put that as I would have [52:45] Speaker G (unidentified): made that assumption, yes. Okay. [52:50] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, let's, I guess, let's hear what the plan is for the Buxton building if [53:06] Speaker J (unidentified): you want to know who's coming on with the Assessor on the 17th. Guy's name is Glenn Sadian. He's the director of property tax, CBRE Validation and Advisory Service, and he's out of Boston. I just, like I said, he called and made an appointment with the Assessor and him for the 17th. So when he comes, I'll ask him those, these questions, yeah, to see what, if there's an assessment coming out to look at all these buildings on the 17th at 1 o'clock. [53:40] Speaker E (unidentified): But he's looking at the building. He's not the owner of the building. [53:43] Speaker J (unidentified): No, he's not the owner of the building. [53:44] Speaker E (unidentified): Who is the owner of 224 KMD? [53:49] Speaker J (unidentified): 224, I do know. [53:50] Speaker A (unidentified): The owner is Inland Commercial Center. [53:53] Speaker E (unidentified): But they just said Inland Commercial Center, which is Mr. Weinstein, doesn't own it. [53:59] Speaker J (unidentified): Right, he does not own that one. [54:01] Speaker A (unidentified): The tax assessor's records are incorrect. [54:04] Speaker J (unidentified): Like I said, they do not own that one. I do know that 246, which is right next to 224, is the elevator, says on it, is the KBM Condominium Association. Next, a condominium that 222, 24, 224 and 246 was a part of, and when they sold the Inland complex, two four, 224 was not part of that. It's unfortunate. I'm not sure how it happened [54:46] Speaker G (unidentified): but these, it's unfortunate these buildings are even talked about being part of this 224 [55:04] Speaker A (unidentified): can you all see that's 222, this is 224 and this is 246. So 224, no, that's 244. What you, what you just pointed to is 244, right, all the way over to the right [55:27] Speaker J (unidentified): is when you come across, you go up here, this was 222, which has been sold. As you go through the parking lot. This is a two-story right on KMD. That's 244. And then this one back, if that sits back a little bit, is 246. This one, we own. This one was sold after he bought it. Okay, so you're looking at over here, somewhere, is where you talk about the church. These are smaller buildings. This is a single story. And if you go drive up there now, you'll see all the construction built it, the vehicles around it, because they sold it and they were fixing it. This is 244, which is the dentist office. And this is 246, which is vacant, which has a sign [56:14] Speaker M (unidentified): in front of it. So what was it talking about? 224. Where's 224? This is, the assessor's [56:19] Speaker A (unidentified): map shows this is 224. Right. Well, so, and, just so everyone knows, the assessor's map shows 224 as behind Lakeview towards the woods, Lakewood, sorry, Lakewood, yep, it's behind Lakewood towards Evergreen Drive, I believe that is undeveloped. Oh, it's a parcel, it's not a building. Correct, it has an, no, we didn't say it was a building, we said it was an address and a parcel map. Okay, and it is listed as B, but it does say that it lists it in this paragraph as a medical office building, but 224, there is no medical office building. [57:33] Speaker E (unidentified): The assessor typically does not assign an address to vacant land. Yeah, so there's something wrong. [57:42] Speaker A (unidentified): I don't know what it is. Correct, I unfortunately believe that this needs to get cleaned up before we can make a real recommendation. I don't wanna just say, we're done talking about it. [58:00] Speaker K (unidentified): I do wanna- Make a recommendation anyway, right? Because it has to go, like it would be any recommendation we're making, right? Is this about making an informal recommendation? [58:11] Speaker A (unidentified): No, we're making the recommendation. We would be making a recommendation to city council on what parcels to rezone. [58:20] Speaker E (unidentified): To specific commercial zones, so okay, but the potential tenants are in a, are in a big hurry, so sure, we could theoretically just recommend that the council back out to 24 and let the people, whoever it is, determine who owns it and what it is, we just back it out, and if Mr. Weinstein discovers that he does actually own it, then maybe at the second, or you could say we recommend rezoning it if it belongs to Mr. Weinstein. I don't know. But then the question was what exactly do they want to do with the Buxton building, because that needs rezoning too. [59:08] Speaker A (unidentified): So that's what I would like to hear next. Next. [59:13] Speaker O (unidentified): Again, John York, owner of Full Metal Fab Performance. And Zach Walter, owner of Full Metal Fab Automotive Services. And just one thing, we did provide a map. It's a rough map, you know, Google imagery marking out the area that we proposed. They have that. [59:29] Speaker E (unidentified): I sent that to you. But it's not a line that... We can turn that into, you know, some sort. [59:36] Speaker O (unidentified): Of grid coordinates for you guys to map it out. But that's our proposed area to use for the retrofit of the building to do our automotive servicing. We also do some light manufacturing, PCB assembly for some of our custom products we build, and we do performance dyno testing as well. [59:58] Speaker F (unidentified): Is there any one of the four that came in on this project prepared to specifically tell us what it is that you want us to recommend to the council? I have absolutely no idea. [1:00:12] Speaker O (unidentified): From our end, the full metal that performance, and it would be to the area that we identified to rezone that is [1:00:18] Speaker P (unidentified): commercial be the Buxton building and The small garage that they speak of next to it From what I from what I gather is they would like the rest of the property to be commercial a and then this the area that encampuses the Buxton building the small garage there behind it there were some parking spaces that i drew out in the map that i provided to be commercial b because that would permit you know automotive service and repair the [1:00:53] Speaker A (unidentified): trying to get my, the east side of that building, which is kind of the lower part of it. Yeah, thank you. So the east side of that Buxton building is that where you would be, I guess, are there garage doors there today? Sure. So assuming, you know, the V, any vehicles that are going in there for any work or any testing or anything like that, they'd be in those bays inside, in the base. Any work that [1:01:38] Speaker O (unidentified): happens is we'll be inside, other than like maybe some incidental where you check trouble code or sure for wipers, you know, the incidental items. But yeah, all the testing and all the actual repairs we've done in suicide. In fact, I'm not sure if you guys, if it got to you folks, but we did develop a use proposal as well, which talked about our mitigation for sound. Yeah, I'm, you know, I've grown up in Maine. I've been out through the world for the Army, but I recognize that peace and quiet is one of the great things about Maine. So our intent is to put most of our efforts into mitigating any noise or any incidental community impact. Yeah, to just be the positives of bringing a manufacturing site and automotive services capacity to the... all [1:02:40] Speaker A (unidentified): right, I mean, I know the information that you put together was sent to us. I got a chance to read through it. I don't know if other members of the board got a chance to read through it before this meeting. Are there any questions about this specific use from members of the board for these [1:03:01] Speaker E (unidentified): gentlemen yeah go ahead in yeah I 'm not trying to be obstructionist I just need to the commercial a zone isn't a Mac manufacturing zone and so what I want to know is what you're manufacturing is and that's what we [1:03:22] Speaker O (unidentified): looked at be manufacturing our manufacturing capabilities are limited to a fiber laser which just be cutting steel and there'll be some welding of steel fixtures or you know automotive racing part components small automotive parts and small batches we're not it's not like a you know production runs we also do some CNC milling but it's all small single phase equipment so the manufacturing is very small batches and okay so that you're asking for [1:03:57] Speaker E (unidentified): for commercial B zone, which allows the automotive service, but it's not a manufacturing zone. So the planning board would need to decide whether... [1:04:08] Speaker P (unidentified): It's very light manufacturing. [1:04:10] Speaker O (unidentified): I thought it had included it in B. That's why I looked through it. I could be wrong, but... Because B was everything that you can do in A plus the automotive services. [1:04:23] Speaker E (unidentified): Right, and commercial A doesn't allow manufacturing either. If you need any kind of financing, you know, the banks always look at this. And, you know, I can't write a letter saying it's allowed unless you all say it's allowed. [1:04:48] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, 100%. And I come through it, and I felt pretty confident that B was allowed for light industrial use. [1:04:58] Speaker A (unidentified): There is automotive sales service, wash and repairs. it's it's anything in a plus a few things the [1:05:16] Speaker E (unidentified): only thing remotely what possibility and the commercial life so as David said commercial B allows everything in the commercial a plus additional uses and the commercial a zone it says warehousing and light manufacturing uses that's subordinate to retail establishments so you know it's not either so sorry again taking them my hearings are terrible sorry so what your manufacturing isn't subordinate to retail you have people coming in to buy [1:05:57] Speaker O (unidentified): those parts there yeah we will have a storefront that'll it's our racing equipment. It will be both online and storefront racing equipment. So the stuff we design and manufacture is sold right out of there. It's sold out of there as well [1:06:15] Speaker A (unidentified): as online as well as online. Yeah, but you are it says the manufacturer will be his own prime retailer. Yeah, prime retailer. So you're not creating wholesale. You're not manufacturing Parts for Wholesale So that actually falls under the commercial a use and commercial B Is ads on for the automotive sales service washer and repairs [1:06:48] Speaker F (unidentified): So can I, if I may ask, please go through? Yeah. Do you folks consider yourselves a company or a business enterprise that transforms raw materials, components, or parts into finished physical goods on a large scale using machinery, labor, or chemical or biological processing? [1:07:10] Speaker O (unidentified): Not on a large scale, but we do take raw materials, you know, aluminum billets, convert them to enclosures for our electronic devices that we build. Yeah, so we do small batches, everything we do, there isn't millions of people looking for a racing dash for very specific pieces of racing style, so it's all small batch, [1:07:36] Speaker K (unidentified): we're talking. Is this more custom equipment? [1:07:39] Speaker O (unidentified): It's custom equipment as well as some, I've developed some electronic devices that allow to, you know, they talk over a can network so you can add data, a racing dash that provides the user with a high resolution GPS and gives them full read out of everything that's going on, lap timers all built into a, you know, a 10 [1:08:01] Speaker K (unidentified): inch screen. So you won't be testing these in vehicles in the parking lot? No. [1:08:06] Speaker O (unidentified): No, the, and we like to keep our stuff on the racetrack so, you know, that's, that's where it's safe and we don't put any risk to the public. I was a former state trooper as well so I take, you know, that driving pretty seriously. You [1:08:25] Speaker B (unidentified): mentioned you're gonna have a dyno. Yes. How loud is a full throttle? Yeah, [1:08:30] Speaker O (unidentified): it's like three to three seven seconds there'll be full throttle runs. Our plan is it'll be in an interior room, dedicated room, so it'll be decoupled walls as well as we'll be using heavy materials, multiple layers of gypsum board, sound deadening Rockwell to eliminate the noise vibration coming out, and then the extraction for the exhaust we'll go through some s-bend events and then have some louvers that are treated for sound deadening. Are there any other [1:09:05] Speaker B (unidentified): processes that you're proposing that would make a lot of noise? No, I mean, you [1:09:10] Speaker O (unidentified): got like normal garage right here, impact, you know, impact wrenches going and, you know, hammering from time to time, but nothing that would be louder than a big rig starting, you know, at the stoplight on KMD. What type of racing are we talking about? What are we, all of it? Yeah, I like road racing. Yeah, most of the, lot of them like drag racing. We've, we tuned one of the fastest Porsche 944 stock dock block in the world doing, you know, high speed runs at Loring. You know, we've, we've done, you know, drag, like I said, drag racing, road racing. We currently have our dyno set [1:09:45] Speaker P (unidentified): Up in Winslow across the river and we've never had a complaint. We haven't had a noise complaint yet. And that, has less, way less sound ending. We have way less room. The rush to get this ball rolling is we've outgrown our space very fast. We, currently have two lifts, three to four bays, depending on where we can put stuff, and, you know, we've just grown so fast that we need a bigger space as soon as possible. [1:10:13] Speaker O (unidentified): Yeah, and we also, it's a little bit unique in that, you know, a lot of automotive service places, yeah, you'll get a good tech who can, you know, do the replacing parts, but we teach them, you know, well beyond into that, where they're learning about performance tuning, learning about CAN bus communications, some fabrication of, you know, not fabrication of PCBs, but assembly. We buy our PCBs commercially, so we don't have to do any etching, none of that, it's just pick and place machine, so it just picks up the components, puts them on and then we solder them through a reflow. So we have that advantage of, you know, we can bring some interesting talent and provide some unique training opportunities for the [1:10:54] Speaker B (unidentified): community as well. I have to say I have some reservation about people starting up a racing engine. I've had neighbors who had Porsche turbos and they're loud starting up and revving and I get a little bit concerned the location of this facility in relation to the butters or the residential neighborhood fairly close. I've driven up there the abutting residential Street, which is no longer a through Street and it's really close. You can see the garages from the residential neighborhood. Yeah [1:11:23] Speaker P (unidentified): I mean, it would be no different than a Harley going down KMD and I mean we're not revving engines in the driveway most engines would be you know started if like he said if they do our rev to any point it would be in on the dyno in a sound dead environment and what are your proposed hours of operation eight to five money through Friday Saturday our current hours are Saturday eight to five by appointment only and they would be similar hours at [1:11:53] Speaker O (unidentified): this and the dyno tuning we would move to strictly between those hours the daytime hours and when [1:11:59] Speaker P (unidentified): wouldn't move on to the evenings like I said we don't it's not like it's the only thing we do we do maybe one or two every yeah one or two a month you know one or two every two weeks and it's [1:12:10] Speaker O (unidentified): it's three to three to seven seconds that they're they're at full load and then it's a lot of [1:12:16] Speaker P (unidentified): Looking at numbers entering information. Yeah, I think so. We haven't, we haven't had complaints. [1:12:22] Speaker O (unidentified): And I've, I've called, we've have had some that went late in the night over in Winslow, and I've called the Waterville comms just to see if they'd had any complaints, and we haven't had any. We're in Winslow. Are you, we're on [1:12:34] Speaker B (unidentified): Lathgow Street, so clear. You definitely haven't any noise complaints or any [1:12:39] Speaker P (unidentified): nothing? No. And we actually have residential right really close to us in the neighborhood up the hill, and actually most of them are our customers that, you know, like us having, like having us in the neighborhood. I really like [1:12:54] Speaker B (unidentified): your concept. I just wish we had some kind of physical boundary or something on paper where we could actually delineate what would be the proposed rezoning, the exact area tonight. It's just I feel like we're lacking with, we don't have an actual address and I don't have actual coordinates, and I'm reluctant to recommend a rezoning to council without knowing exactly what we're rezoning. [1:13:20] Speaker I (unidentified): Exactly. The plans that they gave us are not appropriate, is that right? [1:13:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Well, it's a squiggly red line and I, you know, that's not what is going to be. [1:13:34] Speaker P (unidentified): i mean that was just the generalized because we're not we're not actually mr weinstein isn't we're leasing to own the property you know at the end of that time period when it comes for us to purchase it I'm sure then it would be you know assessed and you know that's break up the parcel we have to break out the parcel and all that 's why we were thinking that if we could zone this and use you know kind of a generalized you know I can kind of point on the screen I don't know if you [1:14:02] Speaker O (unidentified): guys have all seen the, yeah, they got the, they got the imagery, and I guess the question would be we've identified the area, I think, I think we've identified it pretty, you know, pretty well as to where it will be. If it's you just need coordinates for like the vertices of it, you know, that can be provided very quickly if your guys is, you know, zoning team doesn't, you know, doesn't have the, I'm assuming they have some sort of GIS capability. We decide do we need to be a [1:14:31] Speaker I (unidentified): A or B or? B. We need to be B. [1:14:34] Speaker P (unidentified): They need to be in A for the rest. [1:14:37] Speaker O (unidentified): Because I think B also does bump the size [1:14:40] Speaker B (unidentified): up to 600 foot. I have to say I've been on the planning board for six years and this is the first rezoning that we've ever done where we don't have exact lines of the parcel or it's. [1:14:51] Speaker O (unidentified): But it won't be the parcel because the parcel encompasses the entire project for Mr. King's group as well. [1:14:59] Speaker B (unidentified): So he's asking for a different zone than you're asking for. So yes, right, yeah. [1:15:05] Speaker O (unidentified): So we'd be looking at a breaking out a portion of the parcel to be zoned. I [1:15:18] Speaker A (unidentified): apologize, we come up to the curtain and real quick. And if this were to be, if this were to be rezoned, they would not need to come back for any site plan [1:15:33] Speaker E (unidentified): review, correct? No, because the site plan automotive business requires by ordinance that requires site plan review. Okay, so we've got two different sites [1:15:45] Speaker A (unidentified): that have to be reviewed. So we, if it got rezoned, I just want to make sure I understood that, sir, for everybody. If we made the recommendation for that portion of the parcel to be rezoned commercial B, they would still need to come back for site plan review before they could actually open their business in that [1:16:10] Speaker E (unidentified): building because it's automotive. We also really should be looking at whatever kind of buffering you want, because we don't want to draw the line and not correct any kind of, any space left for buffering. Correct, then that's what [1:16:26] Speaker A (unidentified): well, that's why I was asking that question, because it would be buffering from an automotive business to anything else. So they wouldn't be abutting the [1:16:45] Speaker E (unidentified): residential area, they would be abutting a commercial. Sure, but there's still the [1:16:51] Speaker L (unidentified): site plan review. So I was just going to say regarding Mr. Dupree, yes, without, knowing exactly how large a parcel we have, several people here that are just east of the Buxton building and noise would definitely be a concern. Also the end of Wilk Street goes up to the lower parking lot of the hospital, what used to be the hospital, and we would be very upset if that were to be opened. There is a gate, yes, that is [1:17:33] Speaker A (unidentified): closed off per a previously approved site plan. Correct. Well, excuse me, actually it's been [1:17:40] Speaker E (unidentified): discontinued as well. So there technically, there is no street there. I know it exists on the land. [1:17:48] Speaker L (unidentified): That being said, is there something that can be done to put up some kind of a buffer or plant a row of hedges or something to, you know, because it's still, you have a road that goes up there with a small steel gate. So it certainly doesn't give the impression that it's been, you know, closed down. [1:18:12] Speaker G (unidentified): Well, and it has utilities to it, so it can't totally go away. [1:18:18] Speaker A (unidentified): So the owner has no desire to open that up, right? So to answer your question, that is something that the planning board can make as a condition for site plan review for the agenda item that was before the one that we're on right now. Okay, that has to come back for final approval, which is site plan review, and we're allowed to make conditions, right? So to answer your question, yes, something can be done. And then back to what I was trying to get at [1:18:51] Speaker L (unidentified): is there's a large lower parking lot just east of the Buxton building. How much of that parking lot would be used by this automotive manufacturing [1:19:03] Speaker A (unidentified): business? The lower, that lower parking lot is not in the proposed commercial B [1:19:17] Speaker O (unidentified): Correct. I think there's like two right on the [1:19:21] Speaker E (unidentified): Large parking lot. Counted, that parking is counted for the hospital. Correct. So they can't take that away or else they have to build parking somewhere else. I don't know where you. Okay, so we have a pretty good idea of where the boundaries are if you can provide them quickly, and then we still need Mr. Weinstein to agree to it. They don't have a lease [1:19:52] Speaker O (unidentified): yet, right? And so you guys want to do it until it's been zoned so we, so we can actually do the [1:19:58] Speaker B (unidentified): operations. We're looking at, has this property been completely surveyed? Do we know all these boundaries where these, has this been surveyed, stamped, not just recently? I mean, I get the information from the hospital. Okay, but you're also not clear about who owns certain buildings like the 224 or, well, I'm clear. Okay, this house arranger is not proud of what I came [1:20:25] Speaker G (unidentified): here for. Okay. Yeah, this, he may own some of these buildings, but it's not patterned. Okay, [1:20:30] Speaker L (unidentified): got it. Okay, so my last point, just so we're clear, what is currently the lower parking lot? Right to the east of Buxton, there is no plan at this time to develop anything there. Okay, [1:20:48] Speaker O (unidentified): yeah. Just want to address the noise complaint as well as well. Like I said, I'm, I live on a dead-end road along the river because I enjoy peace and quiet. And what I would propose is during the site plan review, prior to us doing any dyno testing, is have show that we were in compliance with noise requirements before we do any of that. So I don't, we don't want to hold anything up for something we do twice a [1:21:17] Speaker P (unidentified): month at this point. Yeah, right, like if it's not permitted, then we'll address that down the road. Our main focus is, you know, automotive repair, programming, Diagnostics, you know, we do dealer level programming and Diagnostics that other [1:21:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Other shops around here just don't do, yeah, or can't do. I mean, and I'll be honest, when I first saw this, my very first concern was, is all of that noise being funneled right down into that residential neighborhood coming out of those garage bays? Yeah, and that's why if you look [1:21:53] Speaker O (unidentified): I mean, I think I dedicated about two pages of, you know, mitigation strategies that we, yep, we plan to use. And it's very much appreciated. Yeah, because like I said, I grew up in Maine and recognize that quiet is one of our, you know, best assets. So, yep, and there are also decibel [1:22:12] Speaker K (unidentified): limits in neighborhoods, residential neighborhoods, that are way stricter than in any commercial zone. [1:22:18] Speaker N (unidentified): So it would apply, correct? Yeah, I believe it was like a four foot height, 43 decibels at, I [1:22:26] Speaker O (unidentified): can't remember the exact distance, but I can, I can verify that or at least fall up to an ASTM [1:22:33] Speaker N (unidentified): standard or, you know, as well just make sure we're meeting the requirements. And can I ask what [1:22:41] Speaker K (unidentified): I just want to make sure what I'm looking at here, the current zoning allows for things like schools in any institution at social civic activities, like, so there's no guarantee that if there is no rezoning that what replaces the hospital will be something that's quiet and neighborhood, residential neighborhood friendly, correct? He's [1:23:11] Speaker E (unidentified): asking for commercial a zoning, so if we know, I'm asking the current zoning [1:23:17] Speaker K (unidentified): institutional, yep, if we don't allow this to be rezoned and it stays institutional zoning and then it has to be repurposed within those parameters, are there any guarantees for the residential neighborhood that there wouldn't be something that moved in that would have be loud or somehow inconvenient for the residents? I [1:23:42] Speaker A (unidentified): can, I think I cannot give you it. I mean, there would be nothing stopping an educational institution from moving in there and having an automotive program out of that building doing the exact same things that these guys are [1:23:56] Speaker K (unidentified): right or like a talking about doing, right? We decided to expand the Waterville techs, not we but the state decided to expand the Waterville Tech Center, they could move in and school buses and kids and 100 banned. Okay, just making sure that so that we're clear about the sound, like there are no guarantees, I think, I guess is what I'm saying, no matter what zone it is, there's never a guarantee on sound and in its relation to neighborhoods, is that aside from our decibel-like limits that we have, the ordinance that we have. [1:24:34] Speaker A (unidentified): I would agree with that statement. I do wanna give anybody else from the public an opportunity to speak if anybody has any comments from the public, anybody? [1:24:49] Speaker P (unidentified): To be fair, sometimes I feel like a teacher with my employees and they're like, you know, kindergarten students, just, so we could maybe be institutional. Some days more than others, okay. [1:25:05] Speaker O (unidentified): thank you for you know agreeing to meet with us and getting us on your agenda and let us talk about what we can bring to waterville so thank you yeah thank [1:25:15] Speaker A (unidentified): you very much so have you heard from all the neighbors yeah i asked again if anybody if anybody from the public wanted to come up and speak and nobody did so well i mean i know we certainly there's been a couple of comments about wanting to get a little bit i just keep thinking of bill lee saying you know there can't be any ambiguity about stuff he doesn't like that so I 'm getting the feeling from the members of the board that we would like a little bit more of a concrete you know the actual lines drawn for what the [1:26:22] Speaker G (unidentified): commercial B would be yeah I was afraid this is what was going to happen was this was going to throw a monkey wrench and getting the rezoning before yeah I [1:26:31] Speaker K (unidentified): know there's a delay anyway so right we would have to we have to refer there's so many back-and-forths that it does give you some time correct and well [1:26:48] Speaker A (unidentified): because the other thing is on the apartments there's already a delay because City Council has to send to us to change the zoning ordinance yes I get [1:26:59] Speaker G (unidentified): get that but you're not going back to that now because you want to wait for us to come back again before you send it to them so there isn't there's an extra delay here so [1:27:13] Speaker A (unidentified): if you would not be able to come for final plan a site plan review on the first agenda item that we talked about until the zoning ordinance was rewritten from 300 square feet to 250 square feet. And that's not going to happen. It can't get on their next meeting's agenda. So it's not going to get on their agenda until December 1. And then do you need to do a two week notice for something like that a public notice for ordinance change? So we probably wouldn't even be meeting to make a recommendation on that until potentially our first meeting in January I [1:28:10] Speaker G (unidentified): mean I'm not trying to be had to get along no [1:28:12] Speaker M (unidentified): I understand exactly he can build the larger units he just can't well that's [1:28:21] Speaker A (unidentified): That's very true. So I guess we do have an option where we could make a recommendation to zone everything commercial A as a start, and then they could come back and with the actual lines drawn and request that to be commercial B. So I'm a great lover of maps, but [1:28:50] Speaker E (unidentified): it's such a small area where that line could move because they have to have that whole big parking lot for Inland, so they're only gonna have 14 spaces, right, 14 spaces and two buildings there. So it's not as if we don't know exactly where the line is, but maybe we could all agree to, if you recommended that rezoning that fuzzy parcel, we could pull that off the agenda if we don't have a proper description before. How fast can you do that [1:29:36] Speaker A (unidentified): and is there a precedence for doing that, for saying you know hey we recommend city council that you rezone a portion of this land, we're not really [1:29:53] Speaker E (unidentified): sure what it is, but I think you're, you're pretty sure, we're pretty sure [1:29:58] Speaker M (unidentified): it's gonna get, but we're not exactly sure. I'm just saying they still have [1:30:14] Speaker I (unidentified): to come back anyway, correct? I mean, so we still have the opportunity to say no when they come back to us, but rather than slowing down the process, can we say something along the lines of assuming that this is drawn out appropriately. [1:30:28] Speaker E (unidentified): Do you have a computer here? Can you actually do this? Because we have another item on the agenda. [1:30:40] Speaker A (unidentified): I am definitely all for not getting in the way of development. I don't think there's anybody here that wants to see this building rot. [1:30:50] Speaker K (unidentified): Ought right, we don't want it to be Seton. As somebody who lives across the street from Seton, I can promise anybody who lives nearby Inland that they do not want what happened to Seton to happen to Inland, correct? Unless you would like to come to my house any day of the week and see the kind of traffic that wanders by. Trust me, you want this to be a developed happy building that generates tax dollars. Yes, that's what I would do that too. There's one, two, three [1:31:23] Speaker D (unidentified): of us that live pretty close to Seton, so yeah, I would like to add to on the idea [1:31:29] Speaker P (unidentified): that to make it all commercial A, we are gonna need you know some time to get in there, you know, inside the building to install this and make it appropriate for our uses, and like I said, I think Mr. Weinstein's thing is he doesn't want to sign a lease to us until we at least have a plan moving forward that there is a possibility that we can, you know, be in there. So you know if it can be something that we, it does get, you know, recommended to be A and down the road we can portion it off to be that Would that would work for us? Okay, so we just don't want to see it not be able to start getting that ball rolling until January, and then like I said, I have four or five employees and two lifts and three bays, and yeah, we've been working, you know, right very diligently to do the best we can, but I think [1:32:31] Speaker K (unidentified): the fact that we're running into the holidays, that's what really is sticking for me, is that really does extend. It's beyond a reasonable expectation. So for me, that is also a consideration. [1:32:45] Speaker A (unidentified): So then I'll ask the board. I mean, this gentleman in the back, he's putting together coordinates based on the red drawn outline of the building and some trees next to it and the parking lot. I'm looking at it right now. It's the Buxton building, that old by a waste building, the parking lot, again, some trees, yeah, so assuming that, you know, he's going to put together those coordinates, and, you know, is anybody feeling comfortable making a motion that would include a recommendation to City Council at this time? [1:33:38] Speaker B (unidentified): I feel comfortable recommending a rezoning to commercial. I feel more comfortable recommending a rezoning to commercial A for the entire parcel and then actually having clear delineated lines, a clear parcel for this rezoning to commercial B in the future. I'm thinking about the moral hazard here of rezoning something in light of past rezonings that were controversial or didn't work out exactly as intended, going down the road to rezone a piece of land that we don't exactly know where the boundaries are at this, well, and then that's why I said [1:34:13] Speaker A (unidentified): assuming he's gonna be putting the coordinates together right now based on [1:34:18] Speaker D (unidentified): based on, okay, you know, what was sent to us, my other question, my question is that [1:34:26] Speaker K (unidentified): how, I mean, the one thing that sticks out for me is how often do we rezone something on the, for a business that is a rent to own, like it seems very [1:34:43] Speaker A (unidentified): tentative, transient owner, the owner of the property has to be the one to make the request, and the representative for the owner is here making this request, correct, so understood, sounds like commercial A would mostly work for [1:35:13] Speaker D (unidentified): your business, yes, for your, for them, for the automotive, yeah, the only thing [1:35:22] Speaker A (unidentified): they'd be able to do would be the light manufacturing, the automotive is not committed [1:35:26] Speaker D (unidentified): oh, it's not, correct, which is why we would, yeah, okay, well, I would finish that, which was why we [1:35:34] Speaker F (unidentified): Would like to be B. Sorry, and on that point, if I may, yeah, and we're spending quite a bit of time on this, and I need maybe a preparation on that side. It's just I'm speaking here just how I feel about where we are tonight. Cassie has made two very important fields that I would support both of these projects. One is the size of the units has a limited market. That limited market, if it's full, helps the other market, which there is a great demand for families. So if you folks see that here in your mind, do what it is that you need to do to get us to that point to saying you're done on the other point about it being be and I know we're looking for some coordinates or whatever but again on Cassie's point is if we choose not to go to be because of what it is that you are planning on doing. If it's left in commercial A, what we would be preventing you from doing can be done already under A by some other institution, a school, a vocational shop or whatever. So, I mean, I'm in favor if we can get these figures together to move it to B and to support the position with this larger scale and let's get moving on with creating some revenue for the city of Waterville here. It's very simple in my mind, yep, the technical stuff that's being raised to my left is not something that's preventing the support that I believe you're going to have here, right, but it's something that our planner says we've got to have done. We get it done, and we know what in the world we're gonna be recommending. Let's move on with business, please. [1:37:53] Speaker H (unidentified): David, can I make the motion? [1:37:57] Speaker A (unidentified): Yes, it's open, floor's open for motions. [1:38:01] Speaker H (unidentified): I think we make a motion that we lower the commercial A residency requirements down from was it 300, no, we can't do that, can't do that, no, doesn't that all have [1:38:17] Speaker A (unidentified): to be in one motion for recommendation? This is rezoning a parcel and that would be a change to a zoning ordinance which City Council has to send at you. Sorry, [1:38:26] Speaker H (unidentified): no, thank you, I'm new to this. I wish we could, I was trying to put it all into one. I wish we could, but I recommend rezoning the whole parcel the commercial A and based on the coordinates that were given to rezone the Buxton building parcel to commercial B and if I'm forgetting anything else someone can add it on. [1:38:57] Speaker A (unidentified): No, there's a motion on the floor. Is there a second? I'll second. Heath seconded. Okay, any discussion on the motion that's on the floor? Okay, all those in favor and no opposed. So that's our recommendation and the gentleman in the back is going to be providing those boundary lines to go along with our recommendation to City [1:39:32] Speaker E (unidentified): Council. Good, could I digress just for a moment please? Did with your what's your informal recommendation the council unanimous that you would support decreasing the size of the apartments in the CA zone if they send it to you? [1:39:54] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, I mean, we can certainly, just a very informal show of hands of people that would be in favor of lowering the minimum apartment size in commercial A from 300 square feet to 250 square feet. Just an informal show of hands. [1:40:17] Speaker E (unidentified): Okay, so it is unanimous. Thank you very much. You probably don't have to worry too much [1:40:23] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you for asking that question [1:40:26] Speaker H (unidentified): I would also like to add on that if once the coordinates and stuff are done if you could share that with the council electronically so if there's any issues or anything that we see we could bring it up and [1:40:42] Speaker A (unidentified): you know obviously the expectation is those lines are going to be very similar to what was shared with us, the informal red line in the aerial satellite view, so. [1:40:58] Speaker P (unidentified): I squiggle the Google line. [1:40:59] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah,, so. [1:41:01] Speaker K (unidentified): It is very much involved. [1:41:03] Speaker L (unidentified): It is. It is, so. [1:41:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, well, thank you very much. So again, that recommendation's going to City Council. They have to vote on it twice. They won't be able to vote on it in the next meeting so hopefully then meeting that will be in three weeks with City Council they'll be voting making the first vote on this and sending to us yep the change to the zoning ordinance yep good luck thank you very much thank you very much thank you all for [1:41:40] Speaker G (unidentified): your time yeah okay I used to be a planning board member myself so yeah I [1:41:47] Speaker E (unidentified): understand yeah just for the benefit of the neighborhood both of these projects have to come back to the Planning Board for site plan review yes [1:41:59] Speaker A (unidentified): and during that site plan review process the Planning Board is allowed to attach conditions all the site plans will be reviewed by the city engineer by the fire department water and sewer water and sewer that's it right yeah so thanks everyone. I don't know if anyone's planning on just sticking around for our we have one more item it's discussion only of discussion only so we're not making any having any votes but revisions to a number of zoning ordinances to comply with a number of state Statutes, thanks Cassie, that were passed, what, during the last legislative session? For the record, those are LD 1829, LD 2173, LD 997, LD 427, [1:43:01] Speaker H (unidentified): 7 LD 1428 and LD 1143 I think Cassie can go down through these one by one yes please [1:43:19] Speaker A (unidentified): So and you've you've I'm assuming you've gone through these with Mr. Bradstreet [1:43:28] Speaker E (unidentified): No not yet so what I sent you today was yeah we can we can pause and just wait for a minute [1:43:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Till they're yeah hey guys on to the next if you don't mind moving out into the lobby thank you [1:43:47] Speaker E (unidentified): Yeah my email okay and I'll forward it to you as soon as I get great thank you so can you take maybe take that out and [1:44:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Then I know that you did send us some stuff now this afternoon and I'll tell you why I didn't get a chance to read any of it I don't know anybody else yes [1:44:27] Speaker E (unidentified): It's 20 some pages of changes there's really not a lot on every page so it won't take you long to read it when you have a chance okay the reason I held I've been working on this for months but the reason that I held it up was because I hadn't looked at what the state provided they hired a consultant to create some charts and I sent those to you also the problem was fitting what the statutes say into our existing ordinance so it's it's different from the way we've dealt with dimensional Requirements in the past so well if I could just run through I made a list of a few points I wanted to make to you first of all do you all know these statutes differentiate between the growth area and the rural area and that and that was established in the comprehensive plan. I had that on my thumb drive there, but if you, most of the city is in the growth area, which is green on this map. The brown is the rural area, pardon me, it's the area zoned rural residential. So under our comprehensive plan, the rural area is everything zoned rural residential, everything in the shoreland zone, and everything in the natural resource protection district. So essentially, everything else is in the growth area. So I wrote the changes for those two different areas, growth versus rural. So starting with LD 1829, which is an act to build housing for Maine families and attract workers to Maine businesses by amending the laws governing housing density. So went through that and revised our zoning ordinance and then the legislature revised LD 1829 became LD 2173. And so the office, the main office of community affairs, which is called MOCA for short, MOCA has a sub area called the Housing Opportunity Program, HOP. So HOP, I think it's HOP versus just MOCA, whatever. Anyway, they're writing a rule to try to explain the meaning of LD 2173, and it's not ready yet. But I don't expect huge changes from—if you read the state statute, you can understand it pretty well, so you probably don't need MOCA to tell you what it means, except there are a few exceptions. For example, the state says that we no longer can review projects that are less than five units, but we have site plan review that is triggered by impervious area. So I contacted MOCA and asked, well, if it's only three units, but it's a certain amount of impervious area can we improve it pardon me can we review it as impervious area and the lady said well we're working on that so there are few things that are not very clear and the another one is the so sorry and what types of projects [1:48:43] Speaker A (unidentified): would that impact so you said a three-unit is that a three-unit apartment building or a multifamily development where there are three individual no it's three units okay so you were [1:49:02] Speaker E (unidentified): able for sure to review anything with three units now the statute says five units but again can we review it based on the impervious area and not the number of so that's the chart that i sent you that mocha had oh i have more questions sorry so [1:49:28] Speaker A (unidentified): if i'm just i'm just trying to think of okay if it were a parcel that was zoned commercial say commercial a and somebody wanted to build a four unit three unit four unit who cares multifamily and it abutted a residential zoned property there's a potential that we would not be able to review it and do things like say oh this is the type of screening that you need on the residential property and stuff like that right that's my it's not five units yep okay [Speaker H (unidentified): okay but] if there was enough impervious area then it maybe we could review it and then be able to tell them dictate the screening right yeah okay and so we're waiting on that got it [1:50:22] Speaker E (unidentified): so there 's an example of an impact on the number of square feet in of per unit and commercial a zone if you allow smaller apartments then you're going to get more units yep and but if it's not five and it's an existing building you can't review it so right well it's it's possible though the code enforcement officer can say oh well here's a screening requirement and you need to re you need to comply with the screening requirement so sure it's not as if there aren't any controls but it's just so We could update the zoning ordinances [1:51:06] Speaker A (unidentified): To instead of saying you know oh the planning board will you know you whatever the planning board approves for screening we can say if it's less than five units these are the screening requirements and make it very strict in our zoning. Oh you can change the screening requirement yes [1:51:27] Speaker E (unidentified): Yep okay yep so the charts that I sent you from Mocha say, each one of them says on it, sorry, let me get the exact, these apply to all areas that permit residential uses. Well, that sounds simple, except that another statute says we have to allow apartments in commercial zones. So does this apply to commercial zones? I don't know so there's things that we still need to determine but I'm hoping that will happen pretty quickly and so the process would be Mocha will prepare the rule and then I'll look over what I sent you today the 20-some pages of changes and I'll ask Billy to review them and Dan Bradstreet to review them and then I'll ask the council to refer the changes to the planning board then you'll get them and hold the public hearing because the council doesn't really have any choice they really have To send this because it's state law so you'll hold the public hearing and then I think what will happen is the council will vote one time and then they have to vote to send this to Mocha for review because I applied it's not clear to me whether if I didn't apply for grant money whether I'd have to send it to them but it's not a bad idea send it to them anyway sure so presumably the council will send the draft that they voted on once to Mocha for review we'll get it back we'll see what Mocha Says make what changes they want if they require any and then it will go to the accounts over the second reading so it's kind of a process but is there a potential I and [1:53:35] Speaker A (unidentified): It's just because I was looking at the commercial A zoning and commercial B zoning earlier, but I noticed that there was in one of those, the zoning ordinances that we have, it said something about and apartments can't be on the first floor of Kennedy Memorial Drive. Yes, so is any of these statutes potentially requiring us to change that [1:54:03] Speaker E (unidentified): language? No, they allow that. So that's one instance, that's one of the LDs that we already dealt with before. We had to, I think that's LD 997 allows us to, yep, it requires us to allow housing and commercial zones, and so we did that earlier. I've made some of you what we're allowed to respect if you were on the board, second floor you were on the board. Yeah, vaguely familiar. Yeah, so the most shocking thing to me was that we have to allow four units on 5,000 square feet of land in the growth area with that has water and sewer, public water and sewer. Five, pardon me, four units on five thousand square feet. Right now five thousand square feet is the size of a mobile home park lot, but we want more housing and that's the way they're choosing to do it. So I will say though, so when we revised the zoning ordinance to allow ADUs, accessory dwelling units, the state allowed us to use language that said if covenants apply, you can't have an ADU. So you have an ADU unless the covenants in your subdivision say no, you're not allowed to do that. So I added that language, covenants apply, into this language that I sent you. So the multifamily housing, unless Bill Lee says I can't do it, isn't allowed if covenants apply. So if that stands, then this four units on 5,000 square feet would be for raw land as opposed to someone coming into your neighborhood and turning up, you know, adding three more units to a house. Can I just say [1:56:13] Speaker K (unidentified): something about this, please, that I'm there, this, the question, whatever questions you're asking in here, I asked in committee at the state level and I'm still not sure we ever got straight answers. That's what I am is just explaining, is that so we're currently, there are recommendations you have for me to take back to Augusta about this. Please feel free because I have a feeling that a lot of, in fact I know based on all the classes I'm taking with South Portland people like this is a problem for a lot of people. So if you have any recommendations or if we don't feel, come make things less ambiguous. Yeah, it was a very interesting, it was a very eye-opening experience for my first [1:56:56] Speaker H (unidentified): Year at the legislature, and just because they can have four units on 5,000 square feet doesn't really mean that they will. Well, there was a [1:57:08] Speaker E (unidentified): neighbor, there was a house in my neighborhood that was foreclosed on, and somebody who's a developer came in and bought it, and fortunately, in my opinion fortunately, he just renovated it and made it nicer. But he could have, his motivation, if his motivation were simply to provide more units or more income for him, he could have added three units to it, and it would be the, my neighborhood is entirely single [1:57:37] Speaker A (unidentified): family homes, and the properties that, oh, what's the, what's the name of the little street there in front of Mount Maresi? Is that, is it Sister's, Sister's Way or [1:57:57] Speaker E (unidentified): but a new house just got built. Oh yeah, okay. No, but that's the land across the street, drive [1:58:04] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah, okay, Mount Maurice, you drive, the land across the street, I think there's two or three lots [1:58:09] Speaker K (unidentified): that are technically for sale. Yeah, so that's like infill we want, I mean, you kind of want [1:58:16] Speaker A (unidentified): sure, like that, right? But do we necessarily want like four units, four units on each of those lots? [1:58:22] Speaker K (unidentified): No, we don't. The real, the real reason, and let me just tell you, the original version of this bill was originally you could have four units on your property, and then you could turn them into condo units and sell the condo rights for the four different ADUs on your property. Wow. So this is the negotiated, agreed upon version of this bill. I do think that there's, I mean, I really wish you guys could see the original so that you could have some perspective. Sure. I will say that the number of people, we had a similar conversation to the one we're having now when we talked about ADUs originally in Waterville, and I will tell you that I built one on my house, but it's not something most people are doing or can afford to do. Just if you have four, if okay, so one unit can be attached to your home, and then up to three can be detached from your home if I remember correctly. Hooking up sewer and water to three different is prohibitively expensive. Yeah, so the Likelihood of this ever happening. Part of me and I am again saying this on mic and not afraid to do so, okay, at the risk of losing my committee assignment, that sometimes some of these things are done for optics and our goal is to expand accessibility to housing. Not everybody has the opportunity of refurbishing an old hospital into like you know studio apartments, yeah, so some towns do need options. I do think that there was a lot of pressure from some groups that want to be able to originally you would were able to do this anywhere including waterfront property so that got negotiated out firmly and so there are things here that i think oh now it could be on any land now it has to be somewhere in a [2:00:28] Speaker E (unidentified): growth zone correct is this growth zone yeah and talked about that so you can have four units in the growth area with water and sewer, three units in the rural area with water and sewer. [2:00:41] Speaker K (unidentified): The three units includes your primary residents, right? [2:00:43] Speaker E (unidentified): Includes the ADU and two other units. [2:00:47] Speaker K (unidentified): Okay, so ultimately, I feel like the biggest argument against this and maybe not being in compliance is whether or not a city infrastructure can support that kind of growth. And so what I would recommend is going into compliance while we're also acutely aware of the number of permits that are being pulled for this and if it looks like it's going to become a problem then we should definitely revisit you know it's hard to not go into compliance with state law correct so ultimately we don't have a lot of options but you do have somebody at your disposal thank you isn't a very lucky position to bring the message back to augusta and i do think that like arguing that this is a strain on a on a city infrastructure like the one that we have in waterville that's aging and a lot of other communities have so one of the things that [2:01:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Ann mentioned was that it 2173 that any development that is less than five units would not require site plan review from the planning board now of course part of that site plan review is the fire department looking at it making sure that the development is going to be safe and that the fire department can actually get in there and do what they need to do? Well, we have laws. [2:02:23] Speaker K (unidentified): There's still laws, right? [2:02:25] Speaker A (unidentified): The laws still exist. But if there's no site plan review, who's making sure that it's being built to the specifications? Like, where would the oversight be? [2:02:38] Speaker K (unidentified): I mean, even with site plan review, you have that same, I mean, I appreciate your argument. [2:02:42] Speaker A (unidentified): The fire department signs off on it. [2:02:44] Speaker K (unidentified): Let's put it this way. The fire department has many let's I was just on a commission a stormwater pollution commission where there were dozens of instances that were approved by the EPA and by all the site plan processes that are relevant and still were issues. Sure, so because absolutely right, so like you can make that it's like the ambulance argument, like you can always make an argument for one more ambulance. Sorry, sure, you know what I mean, like you can always say well what about this, what about right now it's three units right and we're going up to five and I don't I actually don't have a problem with that because three unit you don't require site plan review. Correct, we do now, we do [2:03:34] Speaker A (unidentified): now yeah, so where I was going with this Cassie is knowing that something like this is happening, you know we may just need to adjust the ordinance to say that the developer still needs to get approval on their plan right, like they don't need to come to the Planning Board but they need to get approval from the [2:04:01] Speaker D (unidentified): fire, you know the fire department, same steps that you would right, but not have to jump through [2:04:06] Speaker E (unidentified): the multiple. Well the fire department would review the building anyway, it would be sure. Well where is your dumpster, correct, they probably would look at that too, but circulation around if you had multiple buildings the fire department would want to be able to get through there [2:04:26] Speaker A (unidentified): exactly right and so I'm just trying to think of things that we need to think of when we're making the changes to these zoning ordinances. I'm not worried about water and sewer, I've never heard right, because this is only where there's water and sewer right, the five thousand square feet, the five thousand square feet. Yeah but I mean I've never heard the water or sewer come back and say yeah no we don't have the capacity [2:04:58] Speaker K (unidentified): right, they always have the capacity. Well sewer is we are yeah, you might want to check out the sewer district but yeah, so [2:05:09] Speaker A (unidentified): but I do think it would be good for us to put in there, you know hey you still need you know approval on the site plan, you know at least from the fire department's perspective, the city engineer, the fire department, something, you know somebody needs to sign off it on it to say this is safe. I'm not opposed to that, how do [2:05:35] Speaker E (unidentified): you feel about that. So I heard from so many players so busy right now well [2:05:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Right, I mean I'm assuming they would have to file a building, they still have to get a building permit. Well, I think, and then code enforcement would have to say, okay, where's your site plan? Great, hey, fire deputy fire chief, what do you think? Yeah, there's a difference between [2:06:02] Speaker E (unidentified): creating more units within one building, which the fire department would look at anyway, and creating a new set of buildings. So maybe we would revise the ordinance around that language, or we would leave in the language that we still can review it based on the impervious area and wait for the state to come get us. I don't, I don't, I mean, I'm not gonna say [2:06:28] Speaker K (unidentified): how, if I agree with you or not, but I definitely don't disagree with you. So I also do think that as we just saw, there are an unlimited number of obstacles to development. One of the largest just problems that we have, of course, is housing, access to housing, and access to affordable housing, right? And it's been determined over and over again that one of the reasons for that are situations like we just experienced, where somebody has to come and then we make a recommendation, but we can't make the recommendation yet, and then we can't have a meeting for four weeks actually, because it's Thanksgiving, and then they actually have to go to City Council, come back here, go to city council twice more, time like that. We're trying to reduce those types of situations at the state level as much as possible without totally hurting municipalities. What I do think is that it was very lucky to have somebody with planning board experience on the housing committee this year, because the original version of 1829 was very different than what we ended up with, and you all would have just been really impressed by, you should all go read the original version, it's, it's interesting, it's very interesting. And I think that you even reached out before that I came to my table to make me aware of it, but we are trying to reduce obstacles, so the goal of the bill is to make, help dissipate problems that might be, might be made easier, right? So what we don't want to do at the municipal level is create more obstacles. To make it harder again, so we just want to be conscious of whatever ordinances we recommend, that we're not being counterproductive. Like, we do care about safety, it's still important, right, obviously, but we also don't want to quadruple the workload of the city engineer and then also put ourselves in a worse position than we were before this bill was passed, where the intent was to make things easier and more streamlined, I guess, less, not so much easier but more streamlined. Okay. Oh. [2:09:00] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, public meeting. [2:09:24] Speaker F (unidentified): I have in Waterville. When someone says, you know, Tom, what is affordable housing? Let me tell you. One building went from $18,000, $19,000 every six months for fuel. Three times that. And I'm going to have to sit back and listen to somebody in Acosta saying you're going to have to swallow that, my friend. I'm not gonna, that's not gonna happen, you know, cost of electricity, maintenance. I don't know what affordable housing is. No, yeah, I'm glad I'm not down here because I probably would make a few enemies. I guess that's okay. We'd be a great team for housing. I truly am. What a great idea, you know, had with this hospital complex, but to ask a developer to build something five or six units and then rent them out for whatever they determined to be affordable, which is Waterville housing, they consider affordable, 850, 900, 1100. I don't know a landlord that can [2:10:46] Speaker K (unidentified): Well, right. I think a lot of the times Waterville, when Waterville Housing and Maine Housing are involved, there's a subsidy, a state subsidy that comes in that helps subsidize the development. [2:10:58] Speaker F (unidentified): But that comes from somewhere. It comes from somebody. [2:11:01] Speaker K (unidentified): Well, Maine Housing is, yes, they're basically a bank, you know, they generate a lot of their own money. But there are grants and federal grants that come in. But the affordable housing, so for example, I mean, I don't know if this is the venue to do this, but down at the Lockwood, is that what it's called, the old Martin's Fabric store, okay, so yes, those that has a certain percentage of affordable units, but overall the majority are market rate units. During COVID, the cost of, they were halfway through developing that place, the cost of everything went through the roof. Those developers were no longer able to make it pencil, right, they couldn't finish the Development so they ran into a spot, they turned to Main Housing for subsidy to help them. Main Housing offered them basically alone and a grant. The grant part came with a guarantee that a certain number of units would be provided for a certain below market rate. So if you think about it, the below low market made, if there are people who live there that have vouchers, those vouchers are only for 900 instead of whatever, because that developer got access to some grants and some certain rates that made it possible for him to continue like complete the development. So yes, that money does come from places, but I think that if you looked into where it came from, you'd be surprised. [2:12:34] Speaker D (unidentified): It's not just tax dollars, okay? Tom over here is probably the only one that [2:12:45] Speaker A (unidentified): might remember. I think him and I were the only ones on the planning board at the time. I had brought up some municipalities in the state have an adaptive reuse ordinance, for, their municipalities. And, I couldn't drum up the support for it years ago. But if that would have, if that would have passed, Inland wouldn't have had to come to us to ask for the apartments. It would have, it would have fallen under that's an acceptable reuse of any building of a building of housing or just you know light office space type stuff. Yeah, something that would be allowed [2:13:35] Speaker K (unidentified): in any except for maybe residential a and b or something or right i mean i love it's just [2:13:41] Speaker A (unidentified): coming up with that list of these are the accepted uses for anywhere, right? Anyway, I, yeah, I agree. I would love to, I'm gonna, I'm gonna go searching through my old emails. Well, feel [2:13:58] Speaker K (unidentified): free to, Pat, we can sit down and talk like cloture hasn't happened yet, so if you want me to put some bills in, let me know. But I will say one of the things, for example, we tried to like, there are certain towns in the state that are making sprinkler installation mandatory that adds like a 30 to 60 thousand dollar cost to a house build. And so one of the things that came across our committee was like banning that. And so we had to like really weigh the way the, like, you know, you mean for like a single Family home for a single family home. Wow, yep. And so we were this close to a ban until the fire chief up in Kingfield, Carabasset was like, look, there's one road up to the mountain. If that washes out and there's lightning, you know, blah, so in that one specific instance we're like, okay, there is a place where you should mandate you have million dollar homes. The likelihood of getting fire rescue up there quickly is very slim, especially in certain conditions. So, you know, things like that, but you know, there are solutions to problems, we just have to find them. And so there are developers here, there are people who work for EMS or have family that works for EMS, so like this is the best way to come to reasonable solutions. Otherwise you just have people from Augusta who are throwing out the best ideas possible and it gets whittled down to like something that everybody can agree to. But I think if you have an area of expertise or good ideas that reaching out to your legislature is not a bad idea. Legislator and [2:15:37] Speaker A (unidentified): do we have a meeting in two weeks and do we have items on [2:15:44] Speaker E (unidentified): that agenda? Colby just asked to come the [Speaker A (unidentified): 24th. No,] we don't have a meeting in two. We do not have a meeting in two weeks. Okay, so the next meeting is December 8. [2:16:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Thank you. Okay. December 8th. December 8th. Yep. All right. Well, thank you, Ann, for [2:16:16] Speaker E (unidentified): your hard work on coordinating all of that. Well, thank you for listening. What I would suggest that you do is sit down with the zoning ordinance and the changes that are proposed and all of the LDs and how many try to read them all together. What's the limit [2:16:38] Speaker K (unidentified): of we can only have up to three planning board members in one place at one time? [2:16:43] Speaker A (unidentified): Correct, yeah. So where's it, I've spoken with the city solicitor about this. It's frowned upon to have three in one place talking to each other about like, we could be in the same building, but I mean there's nothing stopping, like there's no like hard, it's just it could [2:17:08] Speaker D (unidentified): it could give the wrong impression. All right, just curious. So when Ben and I are at the state house and then you guys can come visit us. Yeah, so all right, well then thanks [2:17:23] Speaker A (unidentified): everyone and I'll just say meeting adjourned. Sure. Yeah, sorry. [2:17:37] Speaker Q (unidentified): I'm asking if that we can have the street of Reddington in Waterville, half of it from Summer Street down to the Water Street road, made into a one-way roadway. I have, I have friends there that I pick up and I take them for whatever they need, and so had some close calls, close calls, so [2:18:06] Speaker A (unidentified): Unfortunately, that is not something that the Planning Board is able to do, but you can go, that would need to go to city council, correct, Ann? [2:18:21] Speaker E (unidentified): Or start with public works? I think they would be looking for a recommendation from the police chief. Police chief? Have you spoken with the police chief? [2:18:29] Speaker Q (unidentified): No, but I can. Yeah. Bill Bonney. Yeah, because I'm really worried about it. And there's a number of children that are on there. And the number of children, there's another thing to throw out here, is that so many of them on I live on [street] and so many of the children are on motorized vehicles without lights and they're out at night and I'm just worried that we're going to have some tragedies. Yeah, I don't want to see that. And on Reddington there's a lot of families going down Reddington from Summer Street to Water Street that have small children. Yep, and when I go down there I creep, sure I creep because I don't want to hurt anybody. [2:19:16] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah, I don't step on ants, every life has value, so I don't believe that. I'm almost positive that is not a state maintained road, that there's a city maintained road, so I believe speaking with the police chief and then they would probably speak with public works and the fire department and stuff. They may be able to make that adjustment on their own, they may need to go to City Council, but certainly starting with the police [2:19:44] Speaker Q (unidentified): chief would be a good. I'll go visit him tomorrow. Okay, because I just scooters [2:19:54] Speaker K (unidentified): are like the number of kids that are friends with my 14, 15 year old son, he's going to kill me for calling him 14. It's shocking to me, they all have, they all have motorized vehicles and it's crazy, they are out at night and they don't have nights on the sidewalks. [2:20:12] Speaker Q (unidentified): No, they're on, they're in the roadway. Yep, and there was one child in front of me right in the middle of the road, so I stopped, I'm not, I don't want to hurt anybody there, but we need to do something to make it safer for the children. I mean, when we were kids, how smart were we looking for problems, you know, it's as we got older and we experienced some things, then we caught on that there might be a better way to do things, and I'm, that's why I came to you tonight to see if we could do something about this before there's tragedies. [2:20:50] Speaker K (unidentified): Thank you for your piece. Yeah. You're amazing. Right? [2:20:53] Speaker Q (unidentified): Oh, I helped raise 13 kids, so I'm somewhat, I know how to nag, too. I know how to nag. [2:21:01] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, thank you very much for coming up and speaking. I wish we could help you. [2:21:07] Speaker Q (unidentified): Yeah, well, I thought this would be a good place to start because you do have so much impact in all areas in this town. [2:21:15] Speaker A (unidentified): Well, I'm glad we were able to point you [2:21:17] Speaker Q (unidentified): in the right direction yeah so just so that we are safer that our children are safer grandchildren in my case great-grandchildren in december i start my 79th year here somebody want to help me out the door well my kids tell me i'm in better physical condition than they are but you what i 'm a retired iron let me tell you if you don't use it you'll lose it yeah so you have to keep moving and so well thank you all for the jobs that you do and I wish you a very wonderful Thanksgiving thanks buddy Eat lots of [2:22:00] Speaker A (unidentified): turkey and pie. All right, then again, meeting adjourned. Thanks, everyone.