← Back to MaineScanner

Lewiston Planning Board Welcomes New Member and Discusses Zoning Standards

2026-10-27 · 1h 7m · Source: Planning Board Meeting 10/27/26 (City of Lewiston, ME YouTube)
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[0:07] Speaker A (unidentified): GOOD EVENING AND WELCOME. MY NAME IS SHANNA COX. I'M GOING TO CALL THIS EVENING MONDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2026 PLANNING BOARD MEETING TO ORDER. WE START WITH ROLL CALL, [0:20] Speaker B (unidentified): PLEASE. SURE. MICHAEL MARCOTT. PRESENT. DARREN DELANT. PRESENT. LUCY BISSON. PRESENT. SHANNA COX. PRESENT. AMY SMITH. PRESENT. ALEXANDER PINE. PRESENT. HEIDI BERTHELS. PRESENT. AND I'D LIKE TO WELCOME OUR NEW MEMBER, ASSOCIATION OF member Kevin Reddy present welcome for staff we have Shelly Norton deputy [0:42] Speaker A (unidentified): director and Craig Tebow land-use planner please let the record reflect that this evening we're missing Penthea Burns she's excused with advance notice and thus we are going to welcome one of our associate members to be a full voting member and we thought that might be a great way to welcome Kevin this evening Kevin you'll be able to vote along with us on any motion Welcome. This evening, our agenda is going to start with election of secretary. Just a little bit of background here. Our secretary position came vacant when Zoe moved a couple of months ago. Zoe also had a spot on the forestry board. You'll see that reflected down in item 6b. And we have been waiting for a meeting when we were all going to be here to be able to elect secretary, though we will acknowledge that as illness does happen to do. and Penthea is sick tonight. We're gonna forge ahead, though. And while we're tempted to elect Penthea in her absence, we know that's not a good process, so we won't. [1:43] Speaker B (unidentified): I'd like to nominate Amy Smith for secretary. [1:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Amy, do you accept the nomination? Sure. Is there anyone else who would like to be nominated or who would like to nominate another member? [2:06] Speaker C (unidentified): you have done your duty i just resigned as secretary yeah i can't say that [2:12] Speaker D (unidentified): i'll be a very good secretary but i'll nominate myself okay excellent amy with another nomination [2:17] Speaker A (unidentified): on the floor i would like to withdraw my acceptance but i would give you that opportunity thank you so much and you accept your own nomination any other nominations great then i would love to make a motion to adopt alex pine as the secretary of the board can i get a second for that motion second thank you rush too much did you catch that was amy who was rather ecstatic to cast that second i don't know is you need to actually [2:51] Speaker E (unidentified): have a second for that great but isn't it nice if we do but it won't hurt no [2:58] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah shall we vote on it as well please or is that something else that you feel is any discussion before we do Great. [3:11] Speaker B (unidentified): Michael Marcotte. Yes. Darren Gallant. Yes. Lucy Bisson, yes. Shanna Cox. Yes. Amy Smith. Yes. Alexander Pine. [3:21] Speaker F (unidentified): Yes. Heidi Bertels. Oh no, you're not voting tonight. Kevin Redding. Yes. Okay. [3:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Welcome, congratulations. Yes. So for the rest of our roll calls this evening. [3:33] Speaker D (unidentified): Yeah. That would be you. Is there a cheat sheet that I could steal? [3:36] Speaker A (unidentified): you could borrow potentially if you ask very nice to lucy asking very nicely to borrow your can you borrow your roll call sheet for the votes for the evening yes thank you make sure you give it back that's fine i can otherwise i don't have anyone to cheat off of i have i have it on the computer i can email it to you thank you thank you are there any adjustments to the agenda this evening no there are not great is there correspondence that you'd like to put on the record [4:07] Speaker E (unidentified): just wanted to state that staff provided a memorandum on the 21st related to the amendment procedure for ordinances and policies as requested by the board it's not on the agenda for discussion but of course you could if you want to so we don't have additional words to say about it i guess [4:27] Speaker A (unidentified): Great. Thank you very much Let our record reflect that there are no public hearings this evening, which allows us to move into other business item a Discussion on the standards for a frontage right-of-way at 209 Webster Street [4:46] Speaker G (unidentified): Mr. Tebow Bear with me one minute All right, I will direct you to your screens so staff, we were contacted by a representative for the property owner at 209 Webster Street, shown on the maps behind you, for the purpose of looking into more or less looking at the feasibility of a subdivision back there. [5:36] Speaker A (unidentified): Just because of the way the screen is, this Webster? Webster. [5:40] Speaker G (unidentified): sorry no Webster is like is top screen and east have would be left screen and then I'm actually not sure what that other street is okay so representative for the property owner reached out wondering about the feasibility of doing some sort of subdivision at that lot in that lot the whole thing is currently 209 Webster Street it's about 2.1 acres it's a single-family home which you can see fronting on Webster Street and they've you know drawn a sketch up including that single-family home remaining as a lot adding three additional Lots behind that with a you know a sketch of a street or a frontage right-of-way with a T-shaped turnaround and some rough dimensions for everything. Something like this, at the point that it does come to you with an official application for frontage right-of-way, this would be a subdivision, it would go to you for planning board. board, they wanted to have the discussion first because there are some issues with the ordinance that they're running into that may require some, you know, in other words, like a waiver from the board on a certain ordinance item. them and for further context the frontage that is required for a for a frontage right-of-way so they need essentially and I'll go back even further just to start from the basics one they have 112 feet of frontage at 209 Webster Street as it exists currently that is a conforming lot but to put in the street or in other words the actual right-of-way that itself needs 40 feet which would be subtracted from the hundred and twelve so we would be down to 72 feet of frontage and creating a in which would create a non-conforming lot the road itself we can get past that initial hurdle because the road itself creates frontage so we have 72 feet that would remain on Webster Street and then the remaining three feet needed would be on the new road so that seems to be okay as far as staff you know as far as the ordinance is concerned the issues that we're running into are actually in and I've laid them out in the memo they are in article 5 and there are two specific sections of article 5 that they sort of bump into from the ad ordinance itself the first is so we're gonna article 5 administration enforcement section 3 general provisions subsection a point to no undersized lots subsections a and a through D so those are shown on page on page two yep so those are shown on page two C and D and SO JUST STARTING FROM C, THE REQUIREMENT FOR LOT WIDTH. SO FOR ALL PROPOSED LOTS, THE LOT WIDTH SHALL BE AT LEAST EQUAL TO THE MINIMUM FRONTAGE REQUIREMENT, WHICH IS THE LOT WIDTH IS MEASURED AT THE POINT OF THE FRONT SETBACK, IN THIS CASE 15 FEET FROM WEBSTER STREET. and at that point the lot would need to be fifth would need to be 75 feet wide and so that's a separate requirement from the frontage requirement and the lot itself as it's sort of proposed is only 72 feet wide so that's sort of our first our first question then we go to subsection D, which is required lot proportions. That reads, all proposed lots must be able to completely contain within its boundaries an area as would be defined by a circle with a minimum diameter equal to the required minimum frontage for the district. And that's a long way of saying that any proposed lot should have a circle with a 75 foot diameter in it and so if the lot at no point is wider than 75 feet is in this case is wider than 72 feet then it's it's impossible for it to fit the circle with a 75 foot diameter so those are the two issues that we're running into and they really seem to only be a concern WITH THAT VERY FRONT LOT THAT WOULD BE DIVIDED OFF. FURTHER ON IN THE MEMO AND ALSO STATED IN THE ORDINANCE, THOSE TWO REQUIREMENTS, AND THIS IS THE VERY LAST PARAGRAPH OF THE MEMO, WHILE THE CRITERIA DISCUSSED ABOVE APPLY TO THE CREATION OF ALL LOTS, THE REVIEWING AUTHORITY CAN WAVE OR modify these requirements if it can be demonstrated adequately that the application of one or more of the criteria is not practical so that would you know in the future if this were to come to you for a frontage right-of-way review and a subdivision review that question would come your way as to whether or not requiring these standards to be met whether that is practical and whether you can you know choose not to you know to waver to modify that requirement you know this is still all sort of a preliminary discussion you're not looking at a you know clearly you're not looking at an application put together by a professional you know professionally drawn with you know accurate or you know concrete dimensions added so I don't think we're asking you to make any formal motion but we are looking for some input as to how you might view this in the future essentially this would be a future application would request some sort of modification of essentially three feet [12:57] Speaker B (unidentified): and so that's that's kind of what we are Lucy this is why we are told by developers that we are hard to work with mm-hmm three expletive feet I think that yeah [13:22] Speaker A (unidentified): I think Willie I think Lucy's willing to waive the three feet. Okay. You think? Yeah, that's what I got from that. Mr. Marquardt. [13:31] Speaker H (unidentified): We have looked at this property before for different developments and we're a little frustrated. I've grown up in this neighborhood. I know what the area looks like. It's very wet back there to begin with. And because of the trials and tribulations we went through when it was proposed to be multi-unit senior housing, Looking at a street that it's only two lots in from I'm not mistaken. Melo Street and maybe Is the one moody? Correct? Melo, I think is the next one up so Moody Street on one side East Avenue on the other More traffic pattern in and out of that area from Webster Street and out to Webster Street i'm not inclined to waive our ordinances or make exceptions it's a slippery slope we do it here we'll have to do it across the city for other people this will become precedent i'm concerned with a lot having an access point to east avenue [14:35] Speaker A (unidentified): does it 's a point of clarification i don't know that it does that's not how i read the map [14:40] Speaker G (unidentified): not as a lot one doesn't go out to East Avenue so the existing lot does have about 32 feet on East Avenue that the road that is you know the sketch road does have that tea turnaround that stops and that road [14:58] Speaker H (unidentified): would not go to yeah as design there it doesn't go to you stabbing but at some future point somebody may say I want a driveway not off of East Avenue yeah [15:09] Speaker G (unidentified): yeah driveway i mean today a driveway could be yeah 32 feet you're right today [15:16] Speaker H (unidentified): they could they could petition lot one to be the entire project without consideration for lots two and three in the existing 209 webster street which was once owned by i believe the owners of the vacuum shack vacuum shack the bazinets and that's how well i my history goes back in this area i 'm not willing to jump through hoops to make something work for somebody who is desperate because this will impact this will make precedent and impact other projects across the city because some of you be able to point to this one and say well you did it here and then we have a hodgepodge of what good is ordinances we can just drop all ordinances which is a pretty good argument to make in terms of I think it's either Houston or Austin Texas that basically everything is situational there's no strict guidelines but no I disagree with fellow board [16:28] Speaker D (unidentified): member thank you others mr pine and then amy what's the minimum frontage requirement for ncb [16:39] Speaker G (unidentified): ncb is 50 feet 50 feet okay and while we're there ncaa is 75 and this is in the ncaa zone and ncb crosses the road ncb oh i don't know i know on the left i 'd have to look at that map [17:02] Speaker H (unidentified): to the left you get to east avenue it's possible i don't quote me but i think ncb might be if you're coming if you're going towards savannah street on east avenue take a right onto webster nca that's what we're looking at take a left that could be ncb because you're going [17:21] Speaker B (unidentified): into town at that point can you pull it up on the gis because i don't think i can get it [17:29] Speaker D (unidentified): just to provide clarity for why I was asking that question looking at the map it seems there are some other lots sort of within you know a block radius that I have a smaller frontage so like in terms of sticking with the character I agree with Michael though that doing a bunch of exceptions all the time sort of makes your rules useless so why bother so I'm just I'm just curious if there is any zoning that sort of gives us a little precedent here if [17:58] Speaker A (unidentified): we did want to. I'd like to come back to that because that's my point that I'd like to make, but I'd like to respect the order. Neighborhood business. Amy? [18:05] Speaker B (unidentified): Neighborhood business. What's the... Yeah, that's... Can you go out a little? Yeah. So we can see. So it's NCA all around... Yeah. This... [18:18] Speaker A (unidentified): This area here. Can you point to it again for me? Where is it? It's 209 on here. It's... [18:22] Speaker H (unidentified): with a big green spot yes that one right there so i'm mistaken that's it now you can see ncaa [18:29] Speaker B (unidentified): towards the center top towards the left yeah it's all it's all ncaa except for that neighborhood business along this avenue this block here is the same yeah it's all non-conforming across the [18:43] Speaker A (unidentified): street and everything i want to make sure ms smith gets her chance to ask a question too [18:50] Speaker B (unidentified): highlight this one to see how big this one is let me zoom in on the Apple not [19:00] Speaker A (unidentified): application that you were using it was 50 feet and 213 which is essentially [19:08] Speaker B (unidentified): adjacent was 40 right well that's what I'm yeah I'm trying to say not on Moody Street I'm looking on Webster but if you're if you're putting it on Webster 213 Webster and then the other one on the other side of Moody Street on Webster yeah that one yeah 213 is 40 feet okay and then what's 211 is 60 feet yeah but [19:33] Speaker A (unidentified): this one here it's on the handwritten map that we were provided originally we were just looking for ordinance do you want to go back to the original materials that you had up it will answer these questions here [19:48] Speaker B (unidentified): you go okay yeah so that's 45 yeah we've got 45 down here yeah but that's on moody streets and i was yeah so you know it isn't an [20:00] Speaker C (unidentified): unheard of precedent miss smith yes thank you i was just trying to understand the orientation of the map so it says conveyed to 153 East Ave is that part of this subdivision and what is 153 East Ave can you can you invite her up so that her [20:21] Speaker A (unidentified): name can be said on the record welcome you're gonna grab a seat sickness to Craig and into the microphone you'll speak and say your name for the record Oh, okay. [20:31] Speaker I (unidentified): Renee Roy. Welcome. Thank you. So 153 East Avenue is currently elderly housing. I believe it's a four unit. Yeah. Yeah. It's on East Avenue. Yeah, right there. And he has, my client isn't here because he had plans to be out of town. he had believe it's four units there and it is and they sit above yeah and it's all like older people and they love the backyard they feel like they're still like in their original homes and you know so he wanted to preserve the back of that property because right now it's like right [21:23] Speaker A (unidentified): on the edge of the woods you know so can I just ask a follow-up question in the original PDF again has it already been conveyed to 153 no or is part of these changes kind of comprehensive redrawing all the lines including the big exactly [21:42] Speaker I (unidentified): exactly yeah it's part of 209 it's all part of 209. yeah okay thanks others [21:52] Speaker F (unidentified): heidi my only comment would be that whether or not i would vote on this would also be if any of the abutting properties came to an open meeting about this waiver and if they had any comments so i wouldn't want to make a commitment now without hearing because i can just imagine myself being in that situation and maybe buying a property and saying oh they're never going to be able to buy build back there because there's not enough frontage and then finding out that they got a waiver and so you know i have a similar situation so if any of the neighboring lots they were noticed notified in advance I would be interested in hearing how they [22:37] Speaker A (unidentified): felt about this so I 'd like to point out that mr. Marcotte's point is well taken I do despise the fact when we're regularly making up rules as we go along in a one-by-one contract rezone case-by-case manner that said it would be easy for me to vote yes on this given the amount of housing that would be created seeing a full application having an honest hearing and being able to hear the hearing those are all key pieces of what would make me feel confident in hearing that and lean towards it particularly because of the road frontage on the same within the same zone that's within a very close proximity to there I think that's very different than if this was in an area where every other lot was 150 feet 150 feet 150 feet but we have a number that are smaller so I would I would be very willing to hear that 's not a commitment to vote a particular way it does make me and I think to the question that was raised earlier we do have precedent of looking at dealing with issues like this in a form-based way the way that we do in our design district where essentially you're taking the averages of the parcels on both sides or within a defined area to get to what would be reasonable given the character and makeup of what's around it so I'd love to see us start to use so that fundamentally and like yes I'd be interested in hearing this and godspeed on your timing but second to that I would be as or if not more interested in us being able to review kind of a fix for these issues in general that does lead to our kind of jigsaw pattern of how we make decisions from a process perspective and i just fully like lucy's point is so well taken it is a lot to do for three feet and the diameter of a circle language for a layperson to apply like this is the beer this is the bureaucracy that makes us challenging to work with and so what I would just love from staff and I know that's like great job so far right this is this isn't feedback this is more like looking forward as you all bring forward things to the board for us to consider I'd love to see us if we're gonna make a change to like fundamentally make a change and not to do it in a one-off way and that might include language around circles as one example. Mr. Murcott, thanks for your patience. [25:19] Speaker H (unidentified): I'm sure the neighbors would love the opportunity to be notified be notified if we're making ordinance changes I can believe that's a requirement anyway and assuming that it's the same neighbors from the last time something was offered to this area they'll be here with bells on time to [25:42] Speaker G (unidentified): discuss pros and cons and well if we were doing i'm sorry to jump in if we were doing an ordinance change it wouldn't necessarily be in a butter mailing but there would be a notice in the paper [25:53] Speaker A (unidentified): about separate from a notification of review of this parcel if we were reviewing this contract rezone or any kind of application the butter would be notified but just the rezoning would [26:06] Speaker H (unidentified): would be just a public notice. As for that 40 foot frontage on Webster Street, assume that 's the frontage for that apartment building, I first incurred, if that's the word, came across that property when I was a youth in scouting, selling something to make some money. Popcorn. That was before the popcorn days. I'm dating myself interesting activities going on in that apartment but that apartment's been there for more than 50 53 years like at the time they've been standing for 50 years before that I can imagine that any non-conforming lots inside of NCA is because that was before potentially before zoning which was in the 30s or it might have been before one of our major rezoning projects i believe 87 might have been one of those years if i remember right so i don't think we can use a lot or even several in a zone as a reason to suggest that there's the an exception that we can parlay to other places but yeah I'd look forward to seeing some of the faces I would look forward to [27:38] Speaker A (unidentified): that debate particularly because parcels 17 21 and 25 well I understand that it's a side street not Webster Street from the notion of growing denser as we go downtown those are actually going the opposite direction and so there's this lake. So this is downtown. And this is Al Webster Street towards Blaise Floral. And these less dense lots are this little less dense oasis between East Ave. And then you have this street where they are again more dense. And so the notion of, you know, building on infrastructure that reduces costs and creates more density in places that would want it. while I'm sure the neighbors who will arrive with bells on would have different opinions, makes these parcels prime for us to revert back to the way we built things in the late 1800s and early 1900s. So that's a good debate that I look forward to having. [28:41] Speaker H (unidentified): And a phrase or a concept I've been using very recently when referring to East Avenue, from exit 80 down Lisbon to hang a right on East Avenue, go all the way to Russell hang a left basically almost semicircularly across the Veterans Memorial Bridge it's almost like a beltway yeah and there's the inside the beltway and outside the beltway this is right on the perimeter of outside the beltway nowhere things and more rural than urban even though it's suburban by nature there's a transition right there at East Avenue [29:22] Speaker A (unidentified): of noble street would disagree next [29:27] Speaker H (unidentified): street up noble yeah and disagree because it would disagree it's already more dense it's more dense because the lots were well somebody came in and when they developed noble street they maximized a lot they maximized like they did some of the old tenements that you could put a 15 person family in and now it's three apartments same sort of intensification [29:50] Speaker C (unidentified): is your hand up yes i want to just say first thank you to staff and to you for coming to us so early with this i really appreciate that we're not looking at something that's so far down the pike that we can't just give you our honest off-the-cuff right proof of concept so i think that's great i also love the leveraging of the existing infrastructure and feel like this fits IN WITH THE CHARACTER, EVEN IF IT DOESN'T HAVE THE RIGHT CIRCLE SIZE, AND MY ONE QUESTION IS, WOULD THIS BE A PUBLIC ROAD OR A PRIVATE ROAD THAT PEOPLE WOULD MAINTAIN? [30:29] Speaker I (unidentified): THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION. MINE TOO. I THINK IT WOULD BE A PRIVATE. IT HAS TO BE A PRIVATE. HOA TYPE ROAD. [30:34] Speaker G (unidentified): IF THIS WERE A FRONTAGE RIGHT OF WAY, IT WOULD BE PRIVATE ROAD MAINTAINED BY AN HOA OR SOME GROUP, PRIVATE GROUP. [30:44] Speaker A (unidentified): EVERYBODY GOOD? DID YOU GET WHAT YOU NEEDED FROM US? [30:45] Speaker J (unidentified): in terms of input I feel like we've provided plenty generally in favor of increased density I think even this lot as is runs into a different zoning district at the very tip so like that's how close it is so to me it seems I know it makes a lot of sense to me but I would love to see an application before I actually stick to that decision in the public hearing yeah is there anyone [31:13] Speaker A (unidentified): anyone else other than mr. Marcotte what do I will end with mr. Marcotte I'm just curious [31:18] Speaker H (unidentified): if I find an address on that 209 Webster Street there's an apartment building there right so it's a single family to a single family okay so it's currently 75 feet wide. It would be 72 with the street or right of way. If it was a right of way, would that requirement be necessary for a 75-foot circle? [31:55] Speaker G (unidentified): If it, I think I'm following you. So currently 209 Webster is 112 feet. They would need that 40-foot right of way, which would reduce it to 72 feet. the actual right-of-way wouldn't need to meet any circle requirements but the new the new lot that is being created that at the very front that is would can still contain that single family home because that is technically a new lot it would need to meet that 75 foot requirement and it is shy it is shy by three feet [32:33] Speaker E (unidentified): i see you yep yeah you're good i see you if i can follow up the ordinance for frontage right-of-way states that the right-of-way area can't be used to meet frontage by the parent lot so that's the issue here did you say can't cannot be used yeah mr pine [32:56] Speaker D (unidentified): I think maybe I'm picking up on the same thing that member Marcotte is maybe bringing up is if the if the road was done under easement on the lot rather than as a separate parcel unto itself because it will be a private road that might be a way to make sure that everything is conforming and doesn't run into this but I don't know if that's that [33:19] Speaker B (unidentified): that doesn't give you the frontage that they need if you do a just a right-of-way would it [33:25] Speaker G (unidentified): i think i think the language that shelly was referring to is excludes more than just frontage i think that area within the right-of-way can't be used for any dimensional requirements [33:41] Speaker E (unidentified): that I don't think we allow an easement to a property that would service this many lots it has to be a frontage right-of-way got it so the frontage right-of-way was provision was provided added a few years back so that back lots could be developed prior to that we really didn't have a method for developing back lots and it allows up to six and for residential lots depending upon the width of the road so for one to two lots there's a certain standard for the right-of-way road for two you know three and four and then five and six there's three different standards so it's 40 feet for this one for this situation yes and seeking a waiver not for the [34:28] Speaker A (unidentified): lot but instead for the road would be more regularly 37 foot yeah and it would be easier CONSISTENTLY ACROSS OTHER FUTURE, IN TERMS OF PRECEDENT, THREE-FOOT WAIVER ON A 40-FOOT RIGHT-OF-WAY IS EASIER FOR THIS BOARD TO ASSIGN CONSISTENTLY, PARTICULARLY IN FOUR-LOT INSTANCES WHERE THIS COMES UP AGAIN AND SOMEBODY IS LOOKING FOR A WAIVER, WE DIDN'T WAIVE THE LOT, WE WAIVED THE FOOTAGE AND THE RIGHT-OF-WAY. SO MAYBE WHEN YOU ALL BRING IT TO US, YOU COULD HAVE SOME OF THOSE CONSIDERATIONS AND POKE AROUND ON THE OTHER SIDE. [35:06] Speaker E (unidentified): side of that coin yeah I mean that's an interesting question but it's pretty clear that there's no waiver standard within the frontage right away so that's not an option for staff to or the board to waive that but if we looked at [35:20] Speaker A (unidentified): ordinance fixes like we were discussing for the design district that might be [35:23] Speaker E (unidentified): one of the ways to look at fixing it I don't think our frontage right-of-way standard is broken it was added a couple of years ago and Public Works [35:38] Speaker A (unidentified): public works isn't maintaining it and 40 feet and this is just this is just me right but 40 feet when the average car is what eight feet wide and a fire truck wouldn't need to be too traversing against each other right a fire truck would go in a fire truck would come out so is 40 feet truly for a lot service of lots this size is a question I feel like is we could look at. Sure. [36:09] Speaker B (unidentified): You said the criteria was different for one and two and three and four. So what is [36:15] Speaker E (unidentified): it for one and two? Craig just brought it up. It's on the it's it's forty feet forty. Oh, it's still forty feet. Okay. Yeah. All right. And then and then the roadway width is different from that as you can see. So why [36:28] Speaker A (unidentified): Why is the right-of-way more significant than the width? What are we doing with the feet in between? [36:35] Speaker E (unidentified): So you need space on either side for, you know, clearing vegetation, for snow to stack, that sort of thing. Like there needs to be additional feet beyond the edge of pavement. [36:46] Speaker F (unidentified): So what you were suggesting is that we could just do a three-foot waiver. You could just do a three-foot waiver for the lot, sorry, the right-of-way size, like give them a 37. [36:56] Speaker A (unidentified): I think that was I just feel like it does deserve some inquiry the 26 feet outside a 14-foot travel lane feels like a Significance three. It's three. [37:08] Speaker D (unidentified): I Hadn't I had one little more thing to add on to my comment From what I remember of our discussion of planned unit developments. This would be a great application for that. Yeah [37:19] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah Now I'm done. That's great. Sure. Sure. I believe. Thank you ask about the planned unit developments in your ongoing conversation with staff afterwards and this would be a lovely test case for our purposes looking at those categories one to [37:34] Speaker H (unidentified): two three to four and five to six i think the chair touched on it difference between 40 right away and 14 for a minimum roadway width i'm looking at the three to four because this is three right and third 18 feet times 2 is 36 no reason why we couldn't make the right away 36 with 3 to 4 it feels like a lot and wanted to yeah we're naming the [38:00] Speaker A (unidentified): shoulders are 2 feet so we're looking at 18 plus 4 is 22 feet and now we're there's still 18 feet that are for clearing of vegetation and snow that is somehow going beyond the two feet of shoulder on both sides it's just when we're talking about design principles for sustainable design that incentivizes building the way we used to in places that make the most of our infrastructure and our resources this is the stuff we added on afterwards that makes that harder for property owners developers and even us assigning stuff and so i just i feel like there's a couple of things that we can say well let's look at that instead of the one place that's allowed yeah we certainly can and [38:43] Speaker E (unidentified): and we need to have Public Works weigh in on this. It may also have to do with site distances. I don't know why 40 was selected, but it certainly is a big improvement over a few years ago where you wouldn't be able to do any development there. So it is an improvement over what we had, for sure. [38:59] Speaker A (unidentified): And continuous improvement's awesome. Mr. Pine, last one of your last ones? [39:03] Speaker J (unidentified): Yes. Sure. Yeah, sure,, sure,. [39:05] Speaker D (unidentified): Well, everyone keeps bringing up such interesting ideas. Yeah, so maybe the formal request is that we could do a review of street right-of-way requirements for developments because I think you know in previous applications we've touched on sidewalks and making sure those are available but that's like not necessarily mentioned in here line of sight I think is important but also like you know line of sight onto a 25 mile an hour street where you know you can practically walk out into the middle and not get hit like you know having something so uniform regardless of street I think is a problem so a formal request to do that review sometime in [39:45] Speaker A (unidentified): the next six months that'd be great and your point on both public safety and Public Works not forsaken with us and so that'd be a wonderful conversation that representatives join us with and I do as somebody who has worked on things over a long period of time it is really easy for folks to forget how far we've already come and so duly recognized for the good work that's done and I think our ability to continue to do good work is also there [40:10] Speaker B (unidentified): Do you want to, still want a straw poll? Because I think that was a request on that. [40:17] Speaker G (unidentified): It was regarding, specifically regarding the Article 5 language about whether those requirements are practical or not. It sounds like the conversation is going in a different direction about potential ordinance or reviewing certain ordinance language. [40:33] Speaker B (unidentified): I just want to know if we want to do a straw poll or not. [40:38] Speaker A (unidentified): we heard from everybody except mr. Reedy about a willingness to see it if there was public notifications and even with that a desire to not consider the application from mr. Marcotte did you want to weigh in sir welcome I don't feel qualified at this moment you're doing great welcome to the team yeah so I 'm happy to do a straw poll but I did hear each person speak I think that's the summary of it no I think I think that's right and mr. Marcotte would you [41:09] Speaker H (unidentified): character categorize what I said alternatively some of this in some way to [41:30] Speaker G (unidentified): your future endeavors yeah okay I think that's I think we've gotten feedback back from every member that is that's sufficient for two hours i'm gonna move us on to other [41:42] Speaker A (unidentified): business item b thank you 're welcome to stay but you'd want to do so in a different scene okay thank you might find yourself representing on the forestry board item b is an appointment to a member to the forestry board history lesson again former member zoe lindstrom served both on the planning board and as our representative to the forestry board your packet has some information about that board and its service anybody currently on this board interested in serving on the forestry board as well I [42:18] Speaker F (unidentified): would be interested unless there's anybody else that has a burning desire [42:21] Speaker A (unidentified): to do so we'll just give that a second I was gonna not burning let's see that [42:30] Speaker J (unidentified): nominate it Hattie Bertels with Forrester Board yeah great any further [42:36] Speaker A (unidentified): discussion other than our deep gratitude for you stepping forward thanks so much great so we need a look do we need I was gonna do one either way yes why don't call the roll thank you Michael you absolutely can yeah and feel good about [42:58] Speaker D (unidentified): it too in the process please michael marcotte yes lucy bisson yes shanna cox yes amy smith yes myself alexander pine yes kevin ready yes well done yes i accept yes you missed me but yes [43:15] Speaker J (unidentified): oh i'm sorry it's probably not right and then darren gallant yes in no particular order i [43:21] Speaker A (unidentified): believe that was unanimous for the record thank you so much truly i know zoe enjoyed join her service on that board I hope that you do as well I appreciate you stepping forward for us not a problem yeah thank you we are looking for any other business as the board may want to present this evening yeah [43:43] Speaker C (unidentified): I would just wanted to present a quick or ask a quick question and follow up on the red shop conversation from a few nights ago in terms of how the data is going to be shared and distributed and also just have a general question about stewardship of the riverfront island master plan going forward and could you ask that question yes so my first question is on the on the red shop we had a great community conversation about three weeks ago and the city collected a bunch of data that I understand has been transcribed and is not put into report form yet and we were hoping to excuse me have it tonight so that we could understand the data that's one question is when will that be made available and [44:28] Speaker A (unidentified): we'll pause there and see if staff has any response you have an update on the sharing publicly and with the board of the data from the red shop [44:36] Speaker E (unidentified): conversation I do have an update that marketing has the information and is working to get it on the website so I'm sorry it didn't happen before tonight [44:44] Speaker A (unidentified): but it should be out soon can it be provided as minutes electronically to the board and then made public upon the communications department's ability to get it public i can ask about that yeah is it any different than like our minutes i can i did [45:01] Speaker B (unidentified): the transcription so i spent a couple hours at city hall and then a couple hours at home looking over the cards and transcribing them putting them into an excel spreadsheet and I can give you a little snapshot of what I found regarding where you start [45:22] Speaker A (unidentified): that I'm not sure that 's the question I think the question is about us being able to see it all in its entirety and about due diligence oh [45:28] Speaker B (unidentified): sure absolutely but I thought you might like to get a little snapshot ahead of [45:32] Speaker A (unidentified): time but that's up to you I'd love to I'd love to see it all at once not that I don't have great appreciation for both what you did and your memory but I that's fine i think some of this is a process question and a timeliness question which is what member smith's asking will you please verify and follow up by email either to me directly or to the board as a whole about the timeline for getting that made yes available and the second part of that question is if it is going to take some time to add it to the website if you can disperse the notes in whatever format you have while we're waiting for them to be made available [46:07] Speaker C (unidentified): okay I will find out about that yeah they'd be great I just wanted to ask for the raw data the actual transcription of what was on the on the cards thanks for doing that Lucy and then just the other question is because this is very timely and the last time we made a recommendation on this particular item it wasn't communicated to the Department of Economic Development so because I know that they're actively working on negotiation with the developer has that data been made available to economic development so that they can consider [46:39] Speaker E (unidentified): that along with their deliberations at this point in time the raw data has been given to marketing and economic development I don't know you know what economic development has done with that information yet okay thanks yeah part two [47:00] Speaker C (unidentified): is just in general the riverfront island master plan and long-term stewardship of this I would be curious to understand how like what mechanisms are in place for people beyond elected officials in the city to have long-term long-term stewardship responsibilities around something that's going to take so many years to complete I just don't know what vehicles exist for that mr. [47:34] Speaker D (unidentified): pine I'm just looking for clarity on your question there so are you looking for like internal process within the city for departments to reference the plan as [47:48] Speaker C (unidentified): they work on various sections of it no I'm curious about just given the amount of staff turnover and changing of the guard across the city and city council is there a mechanism where a group of community stakeholders could be involved in an ongoing stewardship conversation for that particular plan mr murkoff and [48:16] Speaker H (unidentified): you just triggered a few memories after the charrette, three weeks ago, I did a few Googlings, hotmail can be very informative at times when you have a library of 50,000 emails and a keyword that doesn't appear too often and I may not have the exact dates memorized, but it was like 2012, Dave Hattigo was here. this may have been before one or two charter changes now when this board had five-year terms and theoretically depending on ten years now you could be here like 14 years so there was longevity in one of those original discussions about the riverfront master plan this board was supposed to be that stakeholder no this now this board none we was I reread the language and it wasn't as pregnant as I had hoped, but it did remind me of the sentiment I had, and that was we were informed at the time that the board was pretty much almost the governing body. Of course, the council still has to approve things that we do, but they shouldn't be doing our job for us. We should be the steward of the riverfront. As a matter of fact, in those early years, we were discussing how we would use a lot of grant money we were getting from the federal government at the time. Laying out the amphitheater, cleaning up the vegetation in the canals, dealing with the bridges that we didn't know who owned them at the time. I even found that in my tenure on the finance committee, that bridge that we all love to walk across. That was originally proposed to fit the budget as pine wood, and when it came to us, I was known as one of the penny pinchers, and I looked right at Dave Hedegaard and Mr. Beaupont at the time, and I said, so why are we going with the less expensive version? This teak wood seems like it would have more longevity, we'd get a better buy for a buck, Of course, at the time, some people may remember this euphemism that Heather Hunter could find the money when she needed to, and she did. That's why it's made out of teak wood today, and that's why we haven't had to replace it 14 years, running at least, if it wasn't even earlier than 2012. Those are the things that the planning board did at the time. and what walk why now the council was stepping in and usurping some of what we thought we had my governance over I don't know I understand what some of the motivations may be but it's it's not good for the future of Lewiston just to try to turn a quick buck when you're having financial difficulties in other areas we need to look at that riverfront as a gem the island master plan as well another point which I believe is sort of different not separate same thing they do seem to sit there and sit there for years and decades and that's unfortunate but if we really put the right sort of investment and guidance in the end of these we can make something happen and not handcuff ourselves with something that we're gonna possibly regret there's a lot that we get today over the last four decades let's not continue to repeat it based on hurried up bad [52:10] Speaker A (unidentified): decision-making duly noted so your question was how can a group of citizens who aren't elected steward the plan and I would offer to you we are that we are appointed not elected i would agree with pretty much everything mr marcotte said this board does have the purview while we play secondary to city council and i think where city council comes in is tiffs and the economic development angle of it the land use and the ability for the riverfront island master plan which does include the island point in the read in the second revision is very integrated now yeah so I would offer that it is us should this board's membership or leadership change and that feel less prevalent as a priority for this board then just for those who are listening at home any group of citizens can ask for this to be a workshop item to come before this board and to raise this discussion if they feel we're not doing it at the appropriate interval so like any resident can certainly do that not just developers this board has the ability to request a workshop or to do this at any point as well and i would say we have done that at least once a year for the last three years of which we've been working on it pretty consistently and then the other item that i would put in this is welcome new member day every year when we do the capital improvement plan there is an opportunity to revisit the riverfront ISLAND MASTER PLAN AS WELL AS SOME OF THE OTHER KIND OF ONGOING PIECES OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT RELATIVE TO LAND USE PLANNING AS PART OF THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT BUDGET AS WELL SO THOSE ARE THE MECHANISMS AVAILABLE TO EVERYDAY FOLKS AS WELL AS THROUGH THIS BOARD MR. PINE JUST [53:57] Speaker D (unidentified): THINKING ABOUT THIS UM SINCE SO MANY OF OUR PLANS BOTH LIKE THE COMP PLAN RIVERFRONT ISLAND MASTER PLAN AND SOME OF THE OTHER SMALLER PLANS THAT WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON ARE so directly tied with the economic development department, I don't think we have anything on the books where we sort of have a once-a-year meeting with them. You know, we get that with public works when capital improvement budget time comes around because we're able to talk with the head of that department. I'm wondering if we should consider that for economic development just because the implementation of so much of the big stuff that we think about is so dependent on them. [54:39] Speaker A (unidentified): I would add the transformation plan and the design district to the list of things that you offered. I'd be very interested, I also am recognizing that some of the reorganization of the third floor of which this code and planning office and this planning board that is in service of the code and planning department has always worked in close proximity, if not in partnership with economic development whether it's the staff and or the work that we do and knowing that there's a community and an economic and me frankly not being completely clear on how that reorganization works and how it might reflect in the work that we do I would love to see at a date that you find make sense the opportunity to see that I would offer let me make this a different I would like to formally request that before this board ENTERS THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT AND BUDGETING PROCESS THAT KICKS OFF IN THE NEW YEAR, THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THAT CLARITY AND A BASELINE LEVEL SET FOR THIS BOARD, SOME OF WHOM HAVE NEW MEMBERS SINCE THE LAST TIME WE WENT THROUGH THAT PROCESS, IT WOULD JUST BE GREAT FOR US TO GO INTO CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLANNING AND THE BUDGET PROCESS AND UNDERSTANDING. [55:51] Speaker E (unidentified): CAN YOU, SO YOU FORMALLY REQUESTED, AND THEN THAT GOT VIGGED TO ME, I WASN'T CLEAR ON [55:57] Speaker A (unidentified): WHAT YOU JUST SAID. Yeah, can I formally request representation from economic development and community development for a short workshop conversation during the course of a normal planning board meeting for us to better understand how these three departments work together in a way that informs the upcoming capital improvement and budget process? I don't want us to receive the book, these two presentations in, and try to understand how economic development, community, and code and planning make sense of each other that feels like not a good use of time of staff or of this board and so i think there's a good opportunity to understand it in advance and i saw lots of [56:41] Speaker J (unidentified): nodding so that feels great for everybody thanks this conversation has me thinking there's three new members since i've been on the board i don't think we've talked about any of these plans so it might be a good time to bring them up again for and before we transition next year and changes and maybe it's more than once a year. [57:04] Speaker A (unidentified): I just yeah I would add I think we've always looked for an orient I've always wondered what an orientation would look like for this board like welcome you're welcome you're a new member and here's five of the plans that we most regularly reference where you can find them in their entirety you don't have to give them to us in a printed format but [57:21] Speaker J (unidentified): We have a great orientation, I'd say, but there's a lot. [57:25] Speaker A (unidentified): Oh, maybe it's just been a really long time since I've done it. [57:26] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, so Heidi and I did ours together, so it's great. [57:28] Speaker F (unidentified): Well, the orientation's very much- [57:30] Speaker A (unidentified): It might have improved a lot over those years, too. [57:32] Speaker F (unidentified): It's not focused on public works or economic development, so that piece, certainly, missed it. Yeah, it does miss it. But you guys do a great job on your portion. [57:40] Speaker A (unidentified): See, and it makes me wish that you'd oriented me. Mine was a while ago, and we didn't have much of an orientation back then, so it's great to hear that's coming along. Right, okay. Yeah, that wasn't critical. It was just my lived reality glad was improved [57:54] Speaker E (unidentified): So if I could go back for the minutes Darren you stated something about in your time in the board The board has not reviewed and you listed three documents. Could you specify those the riverfront master plan? [58:12] Speaker F (unidentified): Sorry comprehensive play on capital improvement plan and the riverfront [58:18] Speaker C (unidentified): and then Shannon added the transformation plan which is the most recent comp ish plan do you [58:26] Speaker E (unidentified): mean the tree streets transformation plan okay the other thing that I mentioned was the design [58:31] Speaker A (unidentified): district which we do base a lot of any of these sizable developments that we have seen in the downtown area the design district plan comes up a fair bit I think plans may be the wrong word [58:45] Speaker E (unidentified): because it's more like standards that we apply with yeah that's a standard i would say that's [58:49] Speaker A (unidentified): a different conversation but still part of the like here's the basic tools in your toolkit and [58:54] Speaker E (unidentified): how you know how to use them sure we do we certainly do talk about the design standards during the orientation lcip you guys do look at that once a year i guess where my question is GOING IS WHETHER THIS IS A REQUEST THAT YOU SPEND TIME AS A BOARD TOGETHER AT A MEETING REVIEWING SOME OF THESE PLANS. IF THAT'S THE CASE I WOULD SUGGEST NOT THE LCIP ARE GOING TO DO THAT IN TWO MONTHS ANYWAY. AND THEN I GUESS I WOULD BE LOOKING FOR GUIDANCE FOR WHAT YOU WANT ME TO PUT ON AGENDA SLASH PROVIDE TO YOU FOR INFORMATION FOR YOU TO DO THAT REVIEW. CAN I TAKE A STAB AT THAT? [59:35] Speaker A (unidentified): IN PARTNERSHIP WITH MY EARLIER REQUEST, I THINK IT WOULD BE VERY HANDY FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND OUR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FOLKS TO SAY, HI, HERE'S THE TOP THREE PLANS WE USE IN OUR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND HERE'S WHERE WE INTERSECT WITH THE PLANNING BOARD. SO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MIGHT GO FOR A TIF, LOOK FOR A DEVELOPMENT AND WE SEE THE APPLICATION AND WE SHOULD BE AWARE OF WHAT THEY MIGHT HAVE. I look to Lowell Square as a good example where there might have been conversations in economic development that lended itself to code and planning about how utilities are buried for example which is something somebody is you know leveraging their project so that they get an outcome that they want some of that is economic development leverage and some of that is code leverage and comes through in waivers or just a pretty part of the application we get to see but that intersectionality of those efforts I think is part of what would be really helpful for folks to understand and so I guess to be really clear a workshop with Joe Grokmal and John Blay where they both talk kind of briefly about their departments and how they see them intersecting with each other and us and they could either together or separately do a short overview of each of the plans that we have referenced and how that relates to the work of economic development and code and planning feels very helpful and very concrete hi here's this book it's 86 pages long here's how we use it we're trying to fill these spots we can't point to you on a map because NDA and business like it's fine we don't need all the details I understand but we use this every day and we're trying to actively development and in these three plans our biggest priority is the riverfront island master plan for example would be really helpful for us to understand and i think that i'll be skilled at doing it [1:01:25] Speaker D (unidentified): mr pine and then mr marcott yeah just to add on to that i think it would be great to be provided with links to the plans to the most current documents so that we can sort of educate ourselves ahead of time i agree that it would be good to have the heads of these two departments Talk about how they interface with the plan most senior staff most senior staff. Sorry How they interface with the plans But I also don't want them to just like tell us what the plans are and not really tell us about How they work with it? That's the important part so making sure we get pre-educated on what the plan is and then they can sort of tell us what parts of what we've Pre-educated ourselves on they work with the most then we can say but what about this or but what about that? [1:02:10] Speaker A (unidentified): I would hope the like home page for code and planning or the home page for economic slash community development would think Here are the links to the key plans like they should be in one spot. Yeah, if you go to [1:02:23] Speaker E (unidentified): The planning and code page and at the bottom on the left side There's there's a menu and the last Craig's gonna pull it up for you The last item on the menu are like plans and then there's a whole page of plans and you can click on them all so and then the riverfront one is highlighted separately but while [1:02:47] Speaker A (unidentified): Craig gets there Mr. Markov is next and then Ms. Smith [1:02:52] Speaker H (unidentified): I think it would be a really good idea to have the most senior come in and explain how they use these plans as tools I have most of the paper copies if I could find them wherever they're buried at home and what I remember about some of the last pages of some of these plans, I think the comp plan might be one of them, there's an appendix, a checklist for what you accomplish. Accomplish something, check it off, you put a date. I think that tool is in the back of the comp plan and even some of the other plans, goals, objectives, and what you actually accomplished over the period that you should be getting that plan accomplished before you have to write another plan, whether that's seven years later or 40 years later all [1:03:42] Speaker E (unidentified): right so this page of plans you can see has the riverfront plan and then the summer pain Park master plan at the top and then older plans below it and Craig if you want to just go back a page you can see the gray column on the left and so the third thing down is the design standards So you can see where that is. And then when you go further down, you see Lewiston Comprehensive Plan is right there. And then a little further down, we're going to have the, you know, the planning studies. So everything is available, I think, that we've talked about on our website on the planning [1:04:30] Speaker A (unidentified): page. What page is this? [1:04:32] Speaker E (unidentified): Except for the Tree Streets Transformation Plan, so that might be on economic development. This is planning and code enforcement. So if you go to the website click on departments planning and code enforcement That's the page you get to thank you. Yeah [1:04:45] Speaker D (unidentified): Mr. Murkoff. Did you have a question? No, okay. Great. No, I finished and then I coughed triggered [1:04:55] Speaker C (unidentified): I just want to say I appreciate this repository But I really look forward to an overview and lifting out the stuff that's actually being worked on actively like right now or that's gonna come across our radar in the next six to 18 months I'd like to [1:05:13] Speaker D (unidentified): just make a request I don't know how hard it is to change the webpage but maybe sorting out the plans between things that are active and still being used by the city and things that are just there for archival purposes I didn't know we had digitized versions of the 1964 plan I might just take a look at that for fun I hope we are not working off of that things have changed [1:05:34] Speaker J (unidentified): changed here since 1964 I'm guessing even just to have dates associated I don't know that's the [1:05:39] Speaker A (unidentified): year I graduated it's very current it's very current yep is there any other business this evening before we go to the reading of the minutes hearing none we're looking for a motion to adopt the August 24th 2026 draft minutes so moved thank you anyone else yes, thank you. That was Amy Smith with the second Lucy with the that's great any discussion [1:06:08] Speaker D (unidentified): You call the roll. Okay, Michael Marcotte. Yes, Darren Galan. Yes, Lucy Besson. Yes, Shana Cox, yes, Amy Smith. Yes myself Alexander pine. Yes, and Kevin ready. Yes [1:06:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Thanks. Is it ready? You're ready Thank you. Thank you [1:06:24] Speaker B (unidentified): Yeah motion to adjourn [1:06:27] Speaker A (unidentified): heard second so I think you all in favor that's great see everybody November 9th if you haven't already please vote really voting is open this week or on Tuesday of next week I would I would name if you are putting your stuff in for recycling you might want to hang on to your amendment procedure for ordinances of policies given that we thought it was important enough to ask for the first place yeah okay great not entirely sure that's what I heard but I love it