Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[1:03] Matthew LaChance: So we're going to get this started. If I could ask everybody that's here to make sure they sign in on the right-hand side. If you haven't, if you'd go over and just put down your name. Is it on?
Unfinished Business
[2:25] Matthew LaChance: Okay. I'll welcome everybody to the November 10th Hampton Planning Board meeting. We're a day early since the holidays tomorrow. We're gonna start by, since we are light on plenty board members, we're gonna have Chelsea stand in as a voting member for this meeting. It looks like we also have some visitors on zoom, so I will get to started by doing the administrative tasks. So we have minutes from our last regular meeting. Motion to approve, seconded. Any comments or questions? There are none. I'll start on my right. Yes, chair vote yes. Moving on to the minutes for the workshop meeting on the 21st, seconded. Starting with Amanda, yes. Chair vote yes. So we have before us no old business. The new business, we have one item, which is New England Waste Services in Maine. Can I stop.
[3:52] Mark Cormier: You real quick? We do need to vote on the 2027 planning board schedule. Oh yes, okay, the meeting dates and deadline dates. So everybody's seen that, is.
[4:09] Matthew LaChance: There motion to.
[4:12] John Swalec: Accept the 2027 planning board schedule, second. Any.
New Business
[4:19] Matthew LaChance: Commentary or questions? If not, starting down with Amanda, yes. Sure about Jess as well. Thank you. So now no old business, and under new business we have New England Waste Services of Maine major site plan conditional use application, and I'll open the public hearing for this. Does the town staff.
[4:43] Mark Cormier: Have any comments first? Wanda wanted me to let you know that all public notices have been met, and I don't have any comments beyond what's in your report as far as our zoning ordinance goes. They have met the requirements. They submitted their lighting specs based on what it encourage review, but I know that the applicant has a presentation to give tonight, and we can ask questions around.
[5:11] Matthew LaChance: That. Excellent. So with that, for the, since there's a lot of people here, we'll have the applicant come up and give their presentation, and then we will take comments from the public. We would ask the comments to stay under three minutes, and with that, if the applicant can come up, you can just make sure the microphone phone is on, all.
[5:44] Brian Purse: Right, my name is Brian Purse of Steven Mahar Engineers. I want to thank you all for having me here tonight. With me tonight is Wayne Board, Wayne Boyd of Newsme, he's the general manager of the Pine Tree Landfill and Juniper Rich Landfill. In addition to that, Zach Brandwine, attorney for representing Casella, is also here this evening. And as indicated tonight, I'm here to present major site plan and conditional use application for leachate transfer system upgrades at the Pine Tree Landfill in Hamden. Maine, I think the best way to start this off is with a with a site location plan looking up at the screen here, you see I-95 cutting through the upper third of the figure. Just below that there's a thick yellow line. That's the property line for Pine Tree Landfill in Hampden. The brownish area in the middle is the landfill area. To the right there is a circle that's the leachate storage tank that's on the facility, and there's one, there's actually two small buildings over to the right of that is the generator building and the scrubber building, known of which are not currently being used for their original intent. The area in the white and red hatch is the proposed area of development for leachate transfer. A little site history about Pine Tree Landfill. It is a 160 acre property. It's owned by New England Waste Systems of Maine. There is a 53 acre closed landfill facility. That landfill was closed in 2010. During its operations, it's important to note that as much as 31 million gallons per year were disposed of from that facility in the Bangor wastewater treatment. As far as leachate and groundwater collection at the site, there are both. There is also landfill leachate transport piping located around the perimeter of the facility. They all pump leachate to the 0.92 million gallon leachate storage tank that was on that figure I showed you before. From the storage tank, the leachate is pumped through the Herman sewer and to the Bangor wastewater treatment plant. This drawing shows an existing conditions of the area of development. It is not horribly clear on this television, but it was in your packet. What you see the gray road coming down is the paved road. To the right, the circle is the existing leachate tank. There is a bunch of below ground leachate and gas infrastructure associated with the landfill in this area. Area, and as indicated near the bottom there to the old landfill gas building and scrubber building. As far as the proposed project is concerned, the proposed project includes replacement of the existing leachate transport pipe and structures and replacement of the existing leachate loading rack. It also includes construction of transfer facilities for unloading of leachate from Juniper Ridge Landfill. And that is all shown here on the drawings that you had to review previously. If after my presentation you'd like me to walk through each item, I would be happy to do that. Included here once again in the proposed design is a transfer pad of approximately 1,200 square feet that is generally in the middle, a darker gray color there, are force mains associated with it, there is a loading rack to the southwest of the drawing, there will be a backup generator and an electrical shed, there will be leachate will be discharged into a transfer vault, then will flow to a transfer pump station. From there, it will be pumped through force mains to vaults and manholes and the existing leachate storage tank. The additional paved area for the project is about 12,800 square feet. And as indicated, there will be site lighting located just to the upper portion of the transfer pad on the drawings. The lighting details were included in the package. Why build this project, I guess, is a great idea to start us with. Well, this project will allow flexibility of disposal of leachate from Juniper Ridge Landfill at a high quality wastewater treatment facility, specifically Bangor Wastewater Treatment Plant. It's important also to understand that wastewater, Bangor Wastewater Treatment Plant does not currently allow tanker service to their facility, so you can't bring a tanker truck to Bangor and discharge it's not allowed this will also result in easier and safer loading a pine tree landfill leachate should off-site disposal be needed in the future it also provides infrastructure necessary for future pfas treatment plan for the site and why did we separate the leachate transfer and PFAS treatment projects. We separated them first of all because they can stand alone as individual projects, and timing is critical here. We'd like to be able to use the transfer facilities as quickly as we can. Having said that, we will be back before the planning board when the designs and permitting documents are completed for the PFAS treatment system associated with PTL Leachate, Pine Tree Landfill Leachate, and Juniper Ridge Landfill Leachate. as far as site plan and conditioning use requirements are concerned we considered several options when considering the location we were at the location we ended with minimized cuts and fills it also minimized large tree removal wetland impact stormwater flow the potential for erosion and the threat of air and water pollution as far as vehicle traffic is concerned hall routes would include 90 route 95 to colebrook road down emerson road and onto the facility access road we anticipate an average of 10 trucks per day with a maximum of approximately 35 trucks per day. No appreciable traffic increase is anticipated, and this is already an industrial area that these Lice trucks would be driving through. The existing roads and facilities are suitable for use for this application. It will provide safe operations, and it is actually less truck traffic, even when considering these Liche trucks, than when the facility was an active facility prior to 2010. As far as pedestrian use is concerned, as indicated previously, the haul routes includes Colebrook Road, Emerson Mill Road, and the Site Access Road. The area is industrial in nature without significant pedestrian traffic. The existing facilities will allow safe, but I will say limited, pedestrian traffic. Scenic views and character. The proposed transfer facility is located within industrial zone. Use of the leachate transfer system matches the existing landfill nature and nature of the transfer station. It is screened by trees, and actually it's screened by trees on two sides and by the landfill on the other. As indicated previously, the lighting will be minimized while maintaining safe operations of the transfer facility. As far as groundwater protection is concerned, the facility was designed in accordance with Chapter 401, which is the landfill design rules. They require redundant systems to prevent spills that could cause impact to groundwater. Should spills occur, news me will implement corrective actions quickly. Surface water protection. The facility systems are designed to minimize peak storm water flows. Proposed controls will prevent erosion and sedimentation, and the storm water conveyance is designed to withstand a 25-year design storm. As it pertains to environmental protection, the design includes no wetlands disturbance. There will be no work within critical wildlife habitats. Once again, redundant systems will prevent spills, and it will allow leachate to be conveyed safely to the Bangor Wastewater Treatment Plant. Site access allows emergency vehicle access. Public utility capacity. Both the Juniper Ridge Landfill and Pine Tree Landfill are designed to meet leachate storage requirements of Chapter 401 solid waste rules. Leachate storage volumes actually exceed those requirements given that Pine Tree Landfill is now closed. There is approximately 0.92 available gallons of storage at Pine Tree Landfill and 0.92 million gallons available at Juniper Ridge Landfill. Prior to expansion of the Juniper Ridge Landfill, the Juniper Ridge will be required to install another 0.92 million cubic yards of storage. Storage. Volume discharged to the wastewater treatment plant will be subject to permit limitations from Hamden Sewer and Bangor Wastewater Treatment Plant. During any CSO events, leachate disposal in the Bangor wastewater treatment system may be shut off. In that case, storage tanks will be used to store leachate, or leachate will be trucked off-site to other permitted disposal facilities. As far as odors and fumes are concerned, basically these are managed by keeping all of our structures closed. They're minimized by keeping all of our structures closed. In the case where there are vents, for instance, the transfer vault has a vent in it. That's more likely to have odors. Should it be odorous, a carbon filter will be installed on it to limit odors. As far as noise is concerned, it's not anticipated as an impact to this project. All the underground pumping system, all the pumping systems are underground, and you would hardly hear them, and the site is directly adjacent to the interstate, which provides its own noise and character. As far as fire safety is concerned, it would not be a concern with leachate, as leachate is certainly not flammable. And once again, lighting will be minimized, but enough to provide safe operations. Alright, permits required to construct include the major site and conditional use permits from the town of Hamden, a minor revision from the main DEP. That minor revision was submitted in early October, and it was accepted as complete on October 13, 2026, by the DEP. In addition to this, the town of Herman sewer permit will need to be updated, as will the Bangor wastewater discharge charge permit for the facility. That's all I have. Any
[21:23] Matthew LaChance: more comments from you?
[21:24] Mark Cormier: Amy, no, the only thing I would add, maybe we put a condition that we get proof of
[21:30] Brian Purse: permits that are needed once they're obtained. We did receive a letter of support from the Hermann sewer, the town of Hermann, for the project, and I did
[21:44] Mark Cormier: add, I told all the board members, but there are new public comments that you
[21:49] Matthew LaChance: haven't received yet in front of you tonight, and I'm correct this doesn't touch the town of Hamden
[21:55] Mark Cormier: sewer at all, correct? No, it did say Herman, which is correct. It goes through Herman sewer to Bangor. Hamden does not have sewer infrastructure here. Good, then you can have a seat, and we will
[22:06] Matthew LaChance: open it up to public comment for those people that would be opposed to it. What I'd ask for an orderly faction, if you can come up, state your name and where you're from, and we can start with anybody who'd like to come up to the mic.
[22:32] Eric Jarvi: Eric Jarvi, Hamden resident and Hamden Town Council member. Let me start by saying I have a PhD in toxicology, and quite frankly, PFAS is a challenge. It's a challenge in Maine, it's a challenge here, it's a challenge everywhere in this country. And more importantly, even measuring this family of compounds presents some serious challenges, because my specialty is actually analytical toxicology. But I'm here to speak primarily with two issues that have already arisen in this application based on town council. Number one, as a former trustee of the environmental trust fund, it was our assumption, and I think it's a correct assumption, that the environmental trust fund was established and currently exists because of the closure of this facility And council is uncertain of what this means by adding yet another component to what's going on at the Pine Tree Landfill that's unknown. We don't know the potential impact on that contractual closure in the environmental trust fund. Secondly, if you had the pleasure of listening to our town council meeting last night, we received a rather detailed description of an impaired stream that comes through Hamden. And while it is not impacted by this facility, one of the things that council was presented with was the significant impact of non permeable surfaces on surface water, and that's the challenge we're facing with the Sucker Brook stream and why it is impaired. We believe that the consideration of this expansion out here is also going to have a significant contribution to non-permeable surfaces. And while that might be controlled in this plan, it is something that has to be of concern because of what has happened on the Sucker Brook. Thank you. Thank you for getting the seats in the sign up
[24:33] Matthew LaChance: up to Eric. Is there sure come on up. I'm
[24:48] Bill Lippincott: Bill Lippincott. I live in Hamden. I'm a member of the town's environmental trust committee, but I'm speaking tonight as a private citizen. Because Hella in this application is proposing an upgrade of the current leachate transfer system for the Pine Tree Landfill, they would not be proposing this except that they are planning a major expansion of the Juniper Ridge Landfill, and they're required in the public benefit determination for that expansion to build a leachate treatment plant rather than build that plant at Juniper Ridge. They're proposing to truck all of that leachate to Hamden, build a PFAS treatment plant here, and send the leachate to the Vanguard Wastewater Treatment Facility. They say that this is could also be a standalone project capable of being permitted, constructed, operated without the PFAS treatment system. Fine. I have no problem with Casella upgrading that, but that's not why they're doing the upgrade. Since they're going to be investing all this money in the upgrade, they hope and expect you to then approve their next application, which will be to build a PFAS treatment plant in Hamden. And there are many problems and concerns I have with that. And I won't take a lot of time tonight, but I will bring up a few things. Build it, and they will come. Supposedly, this will just be for the contaminated leachate from Juniper Ridge and the pine tree landfill. Landfill. And when I say just, the JRL expansion is predicted to generate approximately 11 million gallons of contaminated leachate. Both landfills are right off I-95. However, there are many wastewater treatment plants in towns to the south and to the west of Hamden that will need to treat their waste for PFAS, and there are very few options for them currently. So expect that they will also want to truck their waste to Hamden. Think about the amount of truck traffic carrying this toxic waste through our town up Route 1A, Route 202, the Kennebec Road, the back Winterport Road, and other roads to get to the Pine Tree landfill, and the likelihood at some point there will be an accident and a spill. And there's no current law prohibiting out-of-state PFAS leachate from coming to Maine. Casella's Hawk Ridge facility in Unity has been routinely taking out-of-state leachate until they finally had to shut down because of massively contaminated soil around that facility. Casella has a history of pushing the limits as far as they can get away with. Pine Tree landfill was supposed to last 22 years. They ran out of space in a little over 10 years. That is your three minutes. I'm up to about, that's your three minutes. Yep. Okay, well, I will submit by writing the rest of my comments, but they were a history of pushing their limits. They did with Juniper Ridge landfill, and I believe they're looking to do it here, and please take consideration in this application. Thank you. Thank you. Please come on up. Hello.
[28:47] Ed Spencer: my name is Ed Spencer I'm from Old Town I live about two miles from Juniper Ridge for starters let me state that I think this decision is to be made by Hamden officials okay I'm not here to meddle in your business but I would like to point just want to point out the obvious that what you decide here impacts the broader region this leachate is concentrated poison not just pfast but many other hazardous substances in it pied tree landfill leachate has a higher pfast percentages than juniper ridges. So it's actually more concentrated, and it should be treated before release into the Penobscot River, because I don't think the Bangor wastewater treatment plant has any sort of PFAS removal in it now. Just trucking over 20 million gallons from Juniper Ridge across the greater Bangor area is incredibly dangerous, and it's doubtful that a spill could be cleaned up all the way. Casella could limit leachate production and thus truckloads, but to date they have made no attempt. They leave a giant, wide area exposed to precipitation that just makes more leachate. Other things it does, it sounds like this will be addressed in a permit, but does Bangor waste water treatment plant want this? How much money is going to be involved between the parties? And at some point there could be a liability issue from either national or local lawsuits as far as PFAS going into rivers. Be fast control, so whoever's writing up those agreements needs to be very aware and make sure that it is Casella that is responsible for the leachate. It's, and I think as Mr. Lipka mentioned, Casella has trucked leachate from New Hampshire, it's New Hampshire landfill, to Maine for disposal. So beware of becoming just a port to pour leachate from everywhere into our systems, into our water. I think that's pretty much it. I just noticed though, you know, I've been, my wife retired a couple months ago, so we've been doing some traveling, and I've traveled a lot across the country, and I'm gonna stop
[31:56] Matthew LaChance: you right there, your time is up. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Is there somebody else like to speak next? So you may, the only thing I'd ask, if you're gonna do that, could you finish that way? It's kind of one thought instead of having a bunch of people in between. You can use his time. So I like, sorry to be on the record, I needed on the microphone, but go ahead. So I'll
[32:46] Bill Lippincott: continue I left off what happened with pine tree was they were taking massive amounts of bypass from their benefit Biddeford incinerator more than they could possibly process and they're only allowed to take bypass to any anyway that 's the only way they could put bypass in pine tree and they every week they would just taken way more waste mostly from out of state and it would come to pine tree and pine tree as I say, filled up much faster. And with Juniper Ridge, the definition of main waste changed. So all of a sudden, massive amounts of out-of-state waste became, by definition, main waste. And that's one reason that Juniper Ridge was needing an expansion. They pushed the limits. So another consideration is how effective this leachate plant will be, and I refer to today's Bangor Daily News op-ed by John Krueger, who has expert experience of DEP and the State Environmental Testing Lab, about the difficulty of treating leachate to remove PFAS, and I understand the method Cassell is proposing has many problems. We're also learning about the release of hazardous air emissions from PFAS. So if you're transferring 11 million gallons of PFAS leachate to Hamden over time, there are likely to be serious air hazards involved. So I would just ask the planning board to be deliberate when considering this application and not consider any obligation to move their next application just because they're investing a considerable amount of money to improve the present leachate collection system. Justice Cedar Casella stated to the town that they do not plan to test for PFAS in Pine Tree Landfill's leachate despite previously high readings because they are not required to. They will do as little as they can get away. Their interests are not the town interests, so please proceed cautiously and listen to concerns of people around this project. Thank you. Good
[35:35] Grace Nichols: evening. My name is Grace Nichols. I'm an environmentalist. I live in Bangor, and I was an intern over at the Conservation Law Foundation, and they have submitted extensive comments, and I certainly support all of those, but I wanted to share just a couple of thoughts that I had reading the conditional use permit proposal. And so first, the proposal states that it is standalone conditional use permit proposal when it clearly is not. The only reason for constructing the leachate loading area and making other adjustments is to facilitate the treatment of leachate from Juniper Ridge Landfill at Pine Tree Landfill. If this body would find that leachate treatment facility is inadequate to rid the leachate of PFAS and other persistent organic pollutants, then there will be no reason for this facility. Therefore, this body should not make this decision at least until a proposal for the actual leachate treatment plant is considered. And then we get into sort of the problems with doing that. PFAS separation from leachate is a evolving field. The method Casella has said they will propose, though they haven't submitted it, is foam fractionation. This method can separate long-chain PFAS molecules, but not short-chain ones or the very longest-chain ones. Sadly, landfill leachate is characterized by short-chain PFAS molecules rather than long-chain ones. There's two other methods, reverse osmosis and nanofiltration, that are more effective, but they're very expensive. Casella is not considering doing those, right? I've included two peer-reviewed articles for you, so you'll get those in the email. Additionally, the LICHE treatment facility was originally located, to be located, at the Juniper Ridge landfill, which would remove the possibility of accidents during transport. But it would also mean that the conditional public benefit determination governing the proposed expansion of the Juniper Ridge landfill, which was the subject of much litigation, would no longer have to consider the leachate processing plant, which is now in your jurisdiction and endangering your portion of the watershed as well as the Penobscot River generally. And so, basically, they're evading review. They're afraid that the public benefit determination is going to be turned down because of this very difficult process of both separating and then degrading, which is this whole other difficult problem, the organic pollutants from the leachate. And so they're trying to shove it off on you so that then the public benefit determination allowing the expansion will take the most controversial aspect of it out. Right, they shouldn't be allowed to do it. Part of why they're doing that is to minimize indigenous input, and so I hope you won't let them do it, and you'll just say no, thank you. Thank you. Is
[38:51] Matthew LaChance: there anyone else that would like to speak opposed to it? Looks like we do have some viewers. Come on.
[39:08] Linda Swackhammer: Hi there, I'm Linda Swackhammer from Vesey. I live downstream from the Old Town leachate pipe that runs into the Penobscot River. I have questions, actually. Does this mean that there will be no more output at the Old Town sewer plant, the wastewater treatment? Is that, is this in addition to this Hamden proposal, in addition to what's already happening up in Old Town? Does anybody know, like, are they going to stop leachate dumping from the Old Town? Yeah, so this, that really isn't a question before us. I Was just curious because it seems like they say 10 to 35 tankers a day are going to go into this, and that is before the proposed expansion. So we'll have him come up and try to answer something. Thank you. I appreciate it, because that seems like an awful lot, and we're trying to reduce waste, get robust recycling, start composting, and talk about waste at the producer's level, you know, with all the packaging and such. And I think the tide is turning, that people are interested in doing that, and all this infrastructure, when people are looking to reduce waste, seems contrary. Is
[40:49] Matthew LaChance: there anybody else? Is there anyone online who would like to take a second and speak? Yes.
[41:05] Unidentified speaker (Scott Bay Water Keeper): I would, possible. Okay.
[41:07] Matthew LaChance: Could you state your name and where you're from, and then you can have your time? Yes, I'm Pete
[41:12] Unidentified speaker (Scott Bay Water Keeper): Nichols, executive director of Scott Bay Water Keeper, Scott Bay and Watershed Clean Water Advocacy Organization. The application in front of you tonight is much more than an equipment upgrade. The application is presented as an upgrade to the existing Pine Tree landfill leachate transfer system. In reality, it would facilitate the transfer of approximately 20.7 billion gallons of additional leachate from JRL to Pine Tree and eventually to the Bangor wastewater treatment plant. This is a significant expansion and should be evaluated as such. JRL's leachate is the dirtiest and most toxic in the state. I met with Magnora Wastewater recently, and I'm sure you know that they removed the authorization to accept hauled leachate or septage from its March 26 NPDES permit rule, and it states that they don't want to accept any leachate that's not pre-treated. While the additional leachate resulting from this project is not technically called waste, is an end run attempt to dump untreated leachate through the system and ultimately into the Penobscot River. The proposed JRL contribution to Pine Tree will average around 56,000 gallons per day. And the applicant has not demonstrated that the proposed arrangement is authorized under Bangor's applicable waste water permits and approvals. The board should require written confirmation from Maine DEP for approving this application. And developing this project at Pine Tree Landfill is an end run on treating this leachate. Adding this toxic leachate from JRL without any pretreatment is an assault on the Penobscot River, clean water in our communities, and we will act accordingly. So we're asking you to not approve this application tonight until the missing information is provided. Thank you very much for your time.
[43:35] Matthew LaChance: Is there anybody else online who would like to speak?
[43:44] Unidentified speaker (Conservation Law Foundation): Absolutely. Good evening. We're the Conservation Law Foundation, or CLF. I'm here tonight providing comments on behalf of CLF. CLF respectfully opposes the planning the application to for major site plan and conditional use approval for leachate system upgrades of Pine Tree Landfill. As we specified in written comments that were submitted by CLF and others, the application does not meet the Town of Hampton zoning ordinance standards, including and especially the major site plan objectives and the conditional use objectives. First, I think it's important here for the planning board to consider that NEWS application, as others have mentioned, is connected to the proposed expansion of Juniper Ridge Landfill located in Old Town in Alton. NEWS planning board application is the first step toward building the best treatment system at Pine Tree Landfill, which is required by Maine DPC as a prerequisite for NEWS games workplace expansion of Juniper Ridge. NEWSME has represented in its application that roughly 20.7 million pounds a year of toxic leachate will be transported from Juniper Ridge about 20 miles behind the landfill This leachate contains PFAS and other harmful chemicals and contaminants, all of which pose risk to human health and the environment, and none of which are treated by conventional wastewater treatment plants, including Rainforest, as explained in the written comments of CLF and others. While NEWSME has described this application as a standalone project separate from the fast treatment system, the board must consider the entire context here when it evaluates the merits of this application. This context Includes the impacts of leachate transport 20 miles from Juniper Ridge Pine Tree and it includes the plans for future pre-pass treatment system at Pine Tree Landfill. I'll just briefly specify as well while why using this application does not meet the town zoning ordinance and this pertains to the major site plan objectives and the conditional use objectives. We provided in detail the reasons why this application does not meet the objectives in our written comments but I'd just like to highlight a few points here. The application does not adequately address threats to air pollution water pollution pedestrian and vehicular safety hazardous substances and burdens to public utilities particularly burdens to wastewater treatment facilities including Bangor's which do not treat for PFAS and they don't treat for other non-conventional contaminants which are included in PCHE. While NewsMe referenced wastewater treatment plant permit limitations tonight in its presentation the Bangor wastewater treatment plant does not have limitations for PFAS or these other non-conventional pollutants. The application does not address safety risks that are associated with sending up to 35 8,000-gallon truckloads of leachate per day from Juniper Ridge, 20 miles to Pine Tree Landfill. These safety risks include traffic safety.
[46:55] Matthew LaChance: So that is actually your time. We appreciate your comments. Okay. Thank you very much. Is there anybody else that's here to speak opposed? Is there anybody who is neutral or anybody in favor of? Be welcome to speak as well if there's not would the applicant like to address some of the items brought up from the podium please there
[47:38] Brian Purse: certainly were a lot of a lot of comments there. I tried to write down as many as I could I hope I'll have the opportunity to provide written responses to some of those questions also if I wasn't able to write them down but at one many people here are talking about the risk of hauling leachate. What we have to understand is leachate is hauled from Juniper Ridge landfill regardless. Whether it's hauled to Hamden or Old Town or to Brewer, that's the question here. It will be hauled regardless. Casella wants to build this treatment system because it's the right thing to do. All right, it will allow for these both landfills to receive PFAS treatment for their leachate, which is a positive thing. Without building this, there will be no pretreatment of the leachate. There is no other facility. There is one other facility, Waste Management, a private facility that has pretreatment for their leachate. There is none of no other facilities in the state that provide pretreatment of leachate. Without building this, there won't be a facility. And I will say, both Pine Tree Landfill and Juniper Ridge Landfill do sample for PFAS in their leachate, and they have, and that's public information. Leachate is a non-hazardous liquid, and somebody said earlier that this is a way to get past regulations and skip a step that's absolutely not true regardless of the location whether the PFAS future PFAS treatment system is that Juniper Ridge landfill or at pine tree landfill it will require an amendment application from the state of Maine if
[50:13] Matthew LaChance: there's no more comments from the public, we'll close the public portion of the hearing and I guess perhaps the board has other questions. The one that I have, that since you just mentioned it, so what happens with it right now? You said there's
[50:28] Brian Purse: no pre-treatment at all at all. What happens with it? No pre-treatment, the leachate is trucked to Brewers wastewater treatment system and discharge, and prior to that it was trucked to Nine Dragons facility in Old Town and discharged with no pretreatment into the treatment system, through the treatment system and into the river.
[51:08] John Swalec: So I got a couple of questions. Somebody was worried about the amount of impervious soil. So I'm just curious on the different size in the pad from what we previously had to what we will have.
[51:24] Brian Purse: How many- 12,800 square feet.
[51:27] John Swalec: What is it 12,000? Okay. Yeah, but what was it previous? So what's the difference of the whole site from what we have now to what we like opposing? I don't know
[51:40] Brian Purse: I don't know. I didn't do the impervious of the whole site at this point because that was somebody had a concern. I was just curious on how much. I would suspect its acres, but I would hate to make a guess. If you like that number I can get it for you
[51:54] John Swalec: So the other thing is there's no PFAS going on anywhere right now, right?
[51:59] Brian Purse: Is that correct? There is one facility, Waste Management in Norwich Walk, has a pretreatment system for the leachate.
[52:05] John Swalec: As far as we're concerned on this project, foam fractionate. That's right. There's nothing coming from Juniper Ridge. There's nothing coming out of Pine Tree.
[52:15] Brian Purse: There's no pretreatment, correct.
[52:17] John Swalec: So if there was to be, is that another permit that has to be gone through before you can use that facility to transfer that, or is it automatically you're allowed?
[52:31] Brian Purse: No, the transfer is being covered under a minor amendment to the solid waste permit. Right. If we do a PFAS treatment system, that will be handled in a different process, separate permitting process from. So it's still got to go through another permitting process. Absolutely. Absolutely. And it's the same regardless whether we do the leachate pretreatment in Old Town or Hamden, that review process is exactly the same
[53:11] John Swalec: Through the DEB so back to a few other questions. Do we have any idea? Say Bangalore's capacity for what they'll take somebody's worried about out-of-state stuff being trucked in here so we must have an idea what we're using now what you plan on bringing in so we have an idea or that volume and then trying to make sure that we don't take more from outside of Maine in to go through this facility yeah I'm kind of curious on what those numbers would play out as far as the city of Bangalore and Herman because I know the town we're limited on our volume so I 'm confused on how much they can take I think the I think the
[54:09] Brian Purse: existing permit allows discharge of approximately 220 gallons a minute over it's about an eight or nine hour period each day the existing permit I
[54:22] John Swalec: would expect the any new permit to be simple with the existing permit and then the new permit is any of it coming from out of state leachate yeah no the proposal here is Juniper right but it was brought up so I just want to
[54:40] Brian Purse: absolutely try to get that there would be no clear it up and then there was the
[54:45] John Swalec: The Environmental Trust, and so I know they were closed. They're still operating because, I mean, they still haul stuff in and out of there all the time. So they never really shut down, in my mind.
[54:58] Brian Purse: They have a transfer operation. Right.
[55:00] John Swalec: Yeah. So they quit taking trash. Sure. But this facility has still been there a while running, so it hasn't really going to change that part of it. You're still going to take your leachate out that you have been. That's right. You're going to take some from Juniper Ridge too, that's right, and we're going to take it from
[55:17] Brian Purse: Juniper Ridge and when we when you unload the leachate from Juniper Ridge it mixes with the leachate from Pine Tree so there's no separating it then it all needs to be treated.
[55:28] John Swalec: Before it's discharged so in terms of the environmental trust how would that shouldn't.
[55:34] Brian Purse: Affect it at all should I don't know much about the environmental trust but I don't I don't anticipate it would it would affect that you.
[55:45] Mark Cormier: Have a legal representative do you not could they speak to that potentially I don't know if you.
[56:01] Matthew LaChance: Don't mind just stating your name yes absolutely.
[56:03] Zach Brandwein: My name is Zach Brandwein I'm counsel for the applicant in this matter and I just want to very quickly address that question there should be no implication for the environmental trust if there is that is a question for the town council I believe and not for the planning board on this application and so I would just suggest that 's not really before the board tonight and the other thing I would just note is there's a lot of discussion tonight and a lot of people concerned about possible future. Application for a PFAS treatment plan I think you've got to address the application that is in front of you for major site plan approval and conditional use approval and I think it would be a legal mistake to make a decision based on some future anticipated application the concerns of folks tonight and maybe there are concerns that you share that can be addressed if and when we come back before the board for site plan approval for a PFAS treatment plant it's just not appropriate from a legal. Perspective to address it in tonight's proceeding but again these concerns they can be raised if there is an application for a PFAS treatment plant that discussion can be had at that time it's just not.
[57:14] Matthew LaChance: Appropriate to conflate the two correct we are we are addressing just the application not the.
[57:20] John Swalec: Future but to the gentleman's point on the environmental trust so if we pass this and then for some strange reason that changes that outcome then it does have an effect on this I would I.
[57:34] Zach Brandwein: Think that has to be taken up between the town as a whole as a legal entity and the applicant and the parties to the trust it's it's just not a condition of it's not relevant to a condition of approval tonight on either the site plan side or the conditional use side I'm happy to address any other questions about that you probably don't want to hear from me I'm happy to turn it back over to Brian so you can ask him technical questions any other questions from the.
[57:58] Matthew LaChance: Board, okay. I do have one more, I have a clarification. You can sit down, thank you very much. So just for clarification, because the environmental impact of this does worry me, so I want to go backwards to something you said. So right now everything that would be coming to Hampden, it is currently impacting the environment worse because it's getting no pre-treatment, which it would be getting once it comes to Hampden. It would be treated, pre-treated before it goes in.
[58:24] Brian Purse: The Penobscot is that correct? That's so pre-treatment would be the PFAS treatment. So when we get through both stages, correct, you would be going through pretreatment prior to discharge to the Bangor facility or to another facility. You could also.
[58:46] Matthew LaChance: But for this application, so what you would be bringing in would be discharged by rural town?
[58:50] Brian Purse: It would be raw leachate as is the Pine Tree leachate and as was Pine Tree when it was open. Any.
[59:07] Matthew LaChance: Other questions for the applicant? If not, we can delivery. So currently we.
[59:12] John Swalec: Don't have to worry that there's out of state leachate coming in? No, the.
[59:21] Brian Purse: Request here is only for Juniper Rich landfill leachate. There.
[59:32] Matthew LaChance: Was.
[59:41] John Swalec: Some, they had to get the approval or something from. Yeah, I think it would be smart for.
[59:47] Mark Cormier: us to get confirmation from bangalore and dep as a condition i also noted that there could be some
[59:58] Matthew LaChance: Smell and I would prefer there be a condition that there be a carbon filter so that residents don't have to have a problem and then have it go through some process to try to get it addressed. Yeah, I agree.
[1:00:27] Unidentified speaker (Public commenter): So I moved to Hamden in 2004 and the Pine Tree landfill right there on the highway was open. I met Bill Lipping caught when he was spearheading that 2010 closure and I supported him, my family did financially, and also I remember all the complaints about that landfill during that time and that's.
[1:01:09] John Swalec: All I have to say. Other.
[1:01:22] Matthew LaChance: Comments from the board or questions? If.
[1:01:30] John Swalec: there's not is there a motion make a motion based on the findings and information presented the Hamden planning board votes to approve the major site plan and conditional use for the upgrades of the leachate transfer station system at the pine tree landfill tax map lot zero nine zero four six for the conditions of a carbon filter for odor DP approval and the approval from Bangalore wastewater water treatment plant second any
[1:02:02] Matthew LaChance: More discussion? Seeing none, start down with.
[1:02:06] John Swalec: Amanda? Yes. No. Yes, chair.
[1:02:14] Matthew LaChance: Votes yes. Appreciate everybody's comments tonight. I would encourage you if there is more action on this to make sure you come back and give comment feedback. Yes, Amy, do we have a report just
[1:02:52] Mark Cormier: that we will continue our workshop next week Wednesday at 6 to continue the Board of Appeals discussion and a new state mandate LD 337 around modular homes. So we will have a workshop next week in hopes that most of you can attend. Is
[1:03:15] Matthew LaChance: there any other new business or a motion to adjourn? Motion to adjourn. Second. All those in favor? Yes. In favor? Yes. Chair votes yes. Thank you. Good night.