← Back to MaineScanner

York Budget Committee Reviews Revenue Bonds and Climate Fund Proposals

2026-10-27 · 1h 51m · Source: Budget 10-27-2026 (Town of York (YouTube))
Speakers labeled via automated voice-based diarization + AI name-matching against the city's official roster. Automated transcription can still mis-hear a name during fast speech (e.g. a rapid roll-call vote) -- clear near-misses are auto-corrected, but this is not manually verified line-by-line. Treat names as a strong best guess, not an official record. Home addresses that residents give are left out of this page.
[9:37] Speaker A (unidentified): Yeah. All right. [9:44] Chair: We are live. Welcome everybody. Tonight is Tuesday, October 27th. We are here at the York Library. I hope everyone had the opportunity to stop and look at the moon on the way here because it was unbelievable. At the risk of being a nature nerd, I had to say it. Let's start with the Pledge of Allegiance. And Chris, do you want to lead us? does anyone have any edits to the september 2026 minutes i don't think we got them we were [10:38] Speaker C (unidentified): discussing it before yes sorry [10:54] Chair: sorry about that well we will approve the minutes then in november sounds good sorry i saved them and then didn't say i send them oh no worries easy enough okay do we have anyone here for public comment i [11:08] Speaker C (unidentified): know i was like oh this is a change no i was not [11:11] Chair: no great all right well we have several guest speakers tonight the first is i've asked wendy anderson our finance director to bring in our bond council if you'd like to come on up thank you so much hello [11:42] Richard Rannigan: hello i'd like to introduce to you richard rannigan from northeast municipal advisors he's our municipal advisor not bond council but we all are part of the working group team that helps to put bonds together and you had asked us to come by to speak about revenue bonds a little bit this evening dick is the expert and he'll he'll provide you the bulk of the information here but how we got here was there was a petition for an ordinance that collected the right amount of signatures to be able to be put on the ballot and so that's why we are here and i'll turn it over to you dick to explain all [12:25] Wendy Anderson: about revenue bonds and thank you wendy right wendy sent along to me the item that's potentially before the voters and actually before the vote is next week relative to an ordinance that would provide for or recommend for revenue producing facilities that when they're financed if they're financed that they'd be financed with revenue bonds and that would be revenue bonds instead of general obligation bonds it stopped me if i am too [13:09] Speaker A (unidentified): quick in explaining it or not explaining it enough yes if that's if the revenue bond if the if the if the purchase or what we're trying to purchase is going to produce revenue right is that what you mean right only if it can produce revenue they wanted to go by revenue bond as opposed to regular bond is that correct as opposed to general obligation [13:35] Wendy Anderson: bonds there are two types of bonds that municipalities generally can issue general obligation bonds which is the full faith and credit of the town so that you build a road you buy a fire truck you fix the seawall down it down at long sands or short sands wherever it might be and any other type of municipal operation those are financed with general obligation bonds in other words they're included in the tax rate so what you do just like the rest of your operating budget you have a line for debt service just like at home if you if you're unlucky enough to have a mortgage then that's part of your annual budget your monthly budget is to pay the mortgage in the case of municipalities is the line item called debt service Municipalities in York by its charter has the ability to issue bonds for various projects. State law also provides for the ability to issue something called revenue bonds. For those types of facilities that are revenue producing and that can be self-sustaining and the definition of self-sustaining is more than just breaking even by a dollar, but able to have a renewal and replacement fund a debt service fund debt service coverage of some multiple more than just what's owed that year those types of facilities can be financed with revenue bonds i will tell you that nobody no municipality in the state of maine issues revenue bonds but for one in the last my recollection last 20 years and that's portland when it issues revenue bonds for the jet port the reason why you don't issue revenue bonds is because you have the ability to issue general obligation bonds even for revenue producing facilities you may have a facility that is self-sustaining to 50% a 10% a 20% you issued general obligation bonds and the rest of it is made up from taxes. General obligation bonds inherently are not very risky and in the case of York even more so because it's rated triple A. In other words, they're gilt-edged bonds. You have plenty of room under state law to issue general obligation bonds until and unless that you start to bump up or get concerned about meeting the maximum that you're allowed to do under state law, which is 15% of the state equalized valuation, which translates into about $1.2 billion, and you have outstanding right now $56 million, it makes no sense to issue revenue bonds. We're in a 4% market right now for 20-year general obligation bonds. A tax-exempt revenue bond is more likely to be 5.5% to 6%. substantially higher and so it doesn't make sense again unless you're forced to issue revenue bonds to issue revenue bonds the ordinance that is proposed also talks about well maybe you could issue a hybrid bond some sort of combination general obligation and revenue bond there is no such thing to my knowledge i'd like to know who came up with that and have that discussion with that person or persons, but there's nothing provided in state law about some hybrid bond. You either have a general obligation bond or a revenue bond. I'll just go back for a second about revenue bonds. In the case of this community facility that may or may not go forward at some point, it would be likely that there may be some naming rights to that, the John Jones Memorial Community Center, or the Hannaford Community Center, or whatever it might be, and there'd be naming rights, like you would do to Gillette Stadium, for instance. It would then be very likely that those revenue bonds, if you issued revenue bonds for that facility, couldn't be done tax-exempt. They would have to be done taxable. Because you would be having a facility that looks like, walks like, talks like a commercial enterprise. And the IRS says, if you do that, then you've got to play in the same arena as private facilities and pay taxable bonds just like a taxable commute commercial loan now we've raised the interest rate on the bonds even further so if we're four percent for tax exempt then we go to five and a half for revenue bonds now we're at six and six and a half percent those are just relative numbers but it'll be substantially higher would that transfer [18:30] Speaker F (unidentified): to donation money as well like say I know you're using naming rights as an example but would that translate into you know if somebody wanted to donate a [18:39] Wendy Anderson: scoreboard or if that person then our group had their name attached to it yes that's what does it is having right there now there's a demand there is a de minimis rule that if someone donated a refrigerator and you slapped a tag on and it was donated by Mrs. Jones in the kitchen? Probably not. But we just issued some taxable general obligation bonds for the Augusta Civic Center the last couple of years. I think it's either Hancock Lumber or Hammond Lumber has their name now on the floor. So there's naming rights involved. And to be cautious, we issue taxable bonds versus tax exempt, not to run afoul of the IRS. They come in, do an audit and say, hey you got to transfer those over to become taxable bonds and you get into all the you can imagine the legal ramifications with that and the city owns that building the city of augusta owns the augusta civic center i do work for the cumberland county and back in 2012 or 14 the civic center the cross arena which has a naming right was renovated with 35 million dollars worth of bonds issued by the county the county owns that facility we were going to issue those as taxable but we spent because of the size of the issue we did spend quite a bit of legal work and money to allow us to issue tax exempt general obligation bonds there but a lot of the naming rights and so forth and the contracts of like disney coming back every year those had to be modified to be short term in nature to comply with some irs regs so we had to do spend a lot of money and able to be able to do that with a much smaller facility like the one you might be talking about here probably doesn't it's not worth it to go through that so just issue the taxable bonds in that case so when you look at the 15 cap that the state has on 15 of a set of the equalized valuation and again it's that 1.2 1.3 billion dollars you're only at 0.66 percent right now that 55 million that's outstanding so you have a lot of room there can you say what the cap percentage again the cap percentage is 15 percent there are some sub you're at 0.66 percent of 0.66 of one percent there are some sub categories within that 15 percent like it's seven and a half percent for schools it's three percent for water and sewer and so forth but overall it's 15 the entities in maine that issue revenue bonds are just that what i just mentioned water and sewer districts so the york water district in the york sewer district has the ability to issue revenue bonds they don't even issue them on their own they go to the main municipal bond bank and go under the guise of the bond bank there which there are general obligations of the bond bank and those rates are typically higher than a double a credit it and you're at a triple a level so i get into the weeds with that the bottom line is what you have in your charter and what you're doing is just exactly what all the other municipalities in maine do is to issue general obligation bonds because of the lowest cost bonds that you can [22:23] Speaker A (unidentified): an issue yes ma'am when would it be appropriate to use a revenue bond if you had a [22:33] Wendy Anderson: function or an operation at the town if for instance the york water district was disbanded and it became a department of the town and it wanted to issue a million dollars for a water line out on route one you could issue then revenue bonds for the for the York water department but even then it would be unlikely that you do that because you have plenty of room under your limit with the state so it wouldn't be anything that would come along to do that but in that example dick would that mean that the people [23:13] Speaker F (unidentified): that are directly benefiting from that new water line would be the revenue paying back the bond where it would be isolated to just the users that's actually a good [23:23] Wendy Anderson: good question you have to take a look at they're still going to set their rates to cover their operations and their debt service so inflows the revenue to wendy becomes part of the general fund revenues and what you do is you set that up as an enterprise fund and you account for it accounting for operations debt service bottom line how much are we raising in revenues we've got to raise water or sewer rates so you want to make it whole but you do it under the guise of being in the general operating budget so it is self-paying from the users right and that the revenues come in it's just not segregated into a separate entity or a tax ID number. It's part of the town. In Portland, the Riverside Golf Course is a municipal golf course. They set that up as an enterprise fund, and you can see on the financial statements that they spend a million dollars, they take in about a million dollars, and yet they do have capital improvements. So the fees that the golfers, such as myself, pay, the annual fees or daily fees covers the cost of not just operations but also debt service okay yeah dick can you speak [24:40] Richard Rannigan: to the fact that sometimes it's hard to get people to bid on these bonds well that's a whole different [24:47] Wendy Anderson: can of worms if you had a startup such as the community center i think it'd be very difficult even if you had projections with a feasibility study that it would going to be very much self-supporting that are you going to get a buyer of those bonds at what price on a startup it's just like any business for you go to the bank i got a startup and i think it's great i'm going to make a lot of widgets well yeah here's the rate if i want to even loan you the money at all so you're going to pay a penalty for that on a startup i think if you have a track record four or five years with a facility like that and then you want to issue some revenue bonds ones, yeah, there's going to be buyers, but again, at what price, because in the case of a community center, people have the ability not to go there. With the water and sewer, you can have some conservation, but basically you got to turn on the water and you got to flush the toilet. You can have some conservation. with that with an entertainment type of facility you'd go there by choice not by necessity and so they're harder to gauge on the long term is it going to be successful it's been successful for four or five years will it be successful for the next 15 years you don't know you do the feasibility studies you got to pay for those you gotta have the debt service reserve fund probably years is worth a debt service to make sure that you cover any shortfalls that might happen in a year [26:19] Speaker G (unidentified): so it becomes more expensive to do that i was curious about some of those other expenses right so as i had done some research on this and reading the warrant article i was trying to understand it didn't seem to me that there was any scenario in which i could imagine that a revenue bond would even be feasible right would certainly be a lot more cost in the interest rates as you outlined but I was trying to think through those unintended consequences of where do additional costs now where do we incur additional costs because of the requirements that this would put in place so one of those was the feasibility analysis you just mentioned the debt service reserve could you talk a little more like what would those costs look like do you have any [27:05] Wendy Anderson: perspective on how much that would be well the bond bank many of the issuers that go to the bond bank of small towns, and then these water and sewer districts. They require one year's worth of debt service to be set aside in the debt service reserve fund. So, if you were to have a $40 million facility, and your first year's debt service is, if you did it in 20 years, it'd be two million for principal, if it was paid down that way, and let's say $2 million more for interest, that's four million. and so you got to put four million dollars aside at the get-go just to have that set aside as a debt service reserve fund then you got to have maintenance and operations reserve funds you got to fill up all those pots to make sure that you're there for the times when you can't pay those bills [27:57] Speaker G (unidentified): whether it be debt service or operation costs whereas with a general obligation bond we don't [28:02] Wendy Anderson: have to do that you don't have to do it now good management says that you plan on that stuff but you don't set up debt service reserve funds because we know what the debt service is over the 20 years we set the tax rate the taxes come in pays off the debt service yeah and how much [28:19] Speaker G (unidentified): would a feasibility analysis cost if we had if we were required right even if it was a small amount of revenue the way that i'm reading it though somebody jump in even if it's a small amount of revenue that we know would never qualify for a revenue bond we would be required at any dollar [28:35] Wendy Anderson: amount to do this feasibility analysis it's so hard to say maybe staff could do it maybe you'd have to farm it out to an accounting firm it depends upon what the operation looks like and you could certainly spend 20 30 000 very quickly or staff time or a combination of the both yeah, I know that Wendy has been spending time around the whole ambulance situation And in running them, but yeah, I read all this keep track of it is you know is to Take a look at all that and what makes sense what doesn't make sense and bring that information back to the decision-makers so Outside feasibility study you're gonna spend that kind of money pretty quickly [29:20] Speaker H (unidentified): And you mentioned not potentially not being able to get it if even if it was like a self-sustaining facility but in the event that it's not even close to that if it's not even [29:31] Wendy Anderson: close to it you don't even you can't even sell the bonds because the real question is that if you sold the revenue laws and you had done the feasibility study and you all felt good about that and since we still want to do revenue bonds, then you have to stand back and say, if it fails, even one year, if it fails, are we going to walk away from those revenue bonds and get a big headline, York defaults on bonds? That quickly gets down to the bond market. And they say, what are they doing up there? [30:07] Speaker G (unidentified): Can that affect our credit rating? Absolutely. [30:09] Wendy Anderson: Well, not so much the credit rating. It's going to, well, I shouldn't say that. yes it is because certainly Standard & Poor's is gonna say what's going on but the bond market is gonna react and say maybe we don't want to buy even the general obligation bonds of that town because they're not managing that thing very well yeah so it's a black eye yeah absolutely major impacts on our ability to finance other it may not be an impact it may be but it's not certainly a plus [30:44] Speaker G (unidentified): oh absolutely significantly more expensive right that's unquestionably more expensive in all the [30:52] Wendy Anderson: ways and if you have more of these let's say we do something down at the beaches or something and we want to i don't know whatever it might be yeah or a parking garage or whatever and that does it but we do along with revenue bonds then i think you might have as the size of it grows on your balance sheet i think you have trouble with the rating agencies the other consideration that i [31:14] Speaker G (unidentified): was thinking about it was more around we'll say human behavior as a response to you know thinking about this as a financial lever and so i'm thinking okay great so if it's more expensive we know it doesn't make sense let's say for a given project well now does this actually disincent certain departments we've been talking a lot about how do we generate more revenue and what are different strategies that our schools or different departments could generate revenue and so if there's any disincentive towards that because then if there needs to be financing right it gets very confusing right then it could cause people to actually avoid the creative ideas that we've been trying to inspire around generating more revenue because then you know we [31:56] Wendy Anderson: could be subject to all of these other costs right yeah very good point a lot of municipalities take a look at and i know more recently than not that you've put parking meters down along the beach municipalities take a look at it and say you know are we getting what other municipalities are getting per hour for those can we increase those rates and so forth and you know there's an elasticity thing there with revenues that people will find some place else to park or whatnot so there's pluses and minuses to that but you might send end up with a whole parking garage or parking including meters fund so the money gets stuck a long time ago when I was the finance director for the city of Portland we were building parking garages that seemed left and right not one of them made any money so that 's why I come pretty adamantly and say it's very unlikely that you're gonna have any kind of enterprise here in New York that's going to qualify to be a [32:56] Speaker G (unidentified): revenue board and we if we ever did we can do it anyway it's already it's [33:04] Wendy Anderson: already in state well you have the ability under the revenue producing Finance Act to do it without this it's a management issue this is I think I think the way I read this is this is a tool that you're being that's being imposed on you versus a tool that you can use when you need to and I don't I don't think then that's a tool I think it's more of a hammer type of tool [33:31] Speaker G (unidentified): versus a lot of cost that's correct I had a procedural question I know I'm just firing on questions sorry there's there's a freight and Wendy you might be even better to opine on this too but it says revenue bond determination this is section five financing determination that it actually says that the budget committee shall establish revenue bonds like if it meets certain criteria that the budget committee shall establish revenue bonds as the sole funding method for the project now i don't think we as a budget committee don't have funding decision authority that's you do not if this passes it would have [34:14] Richard Rannigan: to be amended the attorney has already sounded in and said this isn't enforceable the way that it's written and work would have to come so more legal cost more legal yeah there's at least one [34:27] Wendy Anderson: citation in state law that doesn't is way off base in here too so there's mistakes within this document any [34:37] Chair: other questions this was very enlightening very well i wonder it went [34:41] Speaker A (unidentified): through the select board to get on the ballot and they voted it down that's correct then it ended up on the ballot and why that was a preference vote to be clear just like we put stuff on the island yeah and then there's a preference vote okay but did whoever put this on the ballot whoever requested it initially did they understand any of that they should i never received questions I wish that I had this maybe they didn't explain why it was all knows [35:14] Richard Rannigan: Why it was well it has to go on the ballot when you have a certain number of signatures [35:18] Speaker G (unidentified): They're required to put it forward. I see even if provisions don't meet state statute and aspects are not [35:26] Richard Rannigan: Legally in alignment. Well, I question that myself Why you know if this if this document is being presented this way and it's not legal does it have to go forward? I don't know how those decisions are made I was told specifically that this needs a lot of work if it did pass Because it refers to things like you just mentioned [35:46] Wendy Anderson: Your town council at Bernstein sure is well versed in this it does come up from time to time But I totally agree with you why put something in front of the voters that doesn't hold water But I think that's part of the process if that's what they want to put out there that they can put it out there and if it passes then you got to go fix it 's kind of a backwards way of doing [36:09] Speaker C (unidentified): it yeah clean up the mess later no [36:21] Speaker G (unidentified): I would just say and I know I know that we don't really have a vehicle for this and I know you know the town doesn't necessarily but I see just a lot of downside consequences in this and I think it's it's one of those that reads as like oh that's logical right so I can see a lot of people you know just trying to do the right thing and saying oh well that's a tool that they don't have let's you know consider that and so i really wish as a town we would put out a clear statement to voters i know there's information in the voter guide but i think as a town we need to explain to people you know we're doing it today but i'm not optimistic that our listeners are over a hundred we'll say that way so that would be very generous but i really [37:05] Chair: and 4 200 people have already voted right through absentee early which is really concerning [37:12] Wendy Anderson: very good so i really yeah i mean that was a missed opportunity probably good intent but doesn't make a lot of sense thank you for thank you thank you thank you thank you wendy thank [37:26] Speaker G (unidentified): thank you for sharing your expertise yes that's nice to meet you we've been hearing your name for years yes i'm sorry thank you this is nice to meet you we've been hearing your name for years [37:34] Speaker A (unidentified): thank you thank you very much thank you both all right next we're going to invite [37:39] Chair: the library up please if you can come up and introduce yourselves it's [37:51] Speaker I (unidentified): working thank you [38:30] Speaker A (unidentified): oh there we go ah there we go oh we can see it up there okay well the hundred or so who are watching from home [38:44] Speaker I (unidentified): just won't see it generous okay so I thought I would take the opportunity to do a urine review so you could see what your money funded what our money funded last year especially heading into the budget season so I'm gonna be focusing on a few areas here investments in technology and the facility itself the launch of new programs strengthening community partnerships fundraising and financial stewardship we had a lot of facility improvements this year we tackled several projects, including the replacement of the library's boiler, repairs to one of the retaining walls, the removal of a dozen dead ash trees, the completion of a teen room refresh, and the creation of a new space for tweens, and I'll speak more about the last two in just a minute. IT. WE UPDATED EQUIPMENT AND EXPANDED ACCESS TO DIGITAL LITERACY INITIATIVES AND OPPORTUNITIES. BEHIND THE SCENES WE UPGRADED OUR TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE BY REPLACING ALL OF THE BUILDING'S WI-FI ACCESS POINTS, UPDATING A SUBSET OF PUBLIC AND STAFF COMPUTERS AND IMPROVING NETWORK SECURITY BY SEPARATING STAFF AND PUBLIC INTERNET ACCESS. WE ALSO EXPLORED EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES with a program series on artificial intelligence, introducing patients to both the practical and the creative possibilities of AI. We completed a digital learning lab initiative, which was funded by a $10,000 grant from the American Library Association, Libraries Transforming Communities. The grant allowed us to purchase equipment and offer workshops in graphic design, robotics, coding, and podcasting for elementary age children, and we're now in the process of scaling those programs for all ages. We received a second $10,000 ALA grant to outfit the Wheeler Room with video conferencing capabilities. That has just happened. It's new enough that I haven't even been trained on it yet, but it's been installed. We launched Erin's Place in the Youth Services Department. Erin Fell was a local student who made no secret that the library was her favorite place. Gaming was a close second, so with an outpouring of gifts made by her family and her friends and community members in her memory, we carved out a fun space with comfy seating, fun carpeting, gaming PCs, laptops, a Nintendo Switch, a flat screen TV, and lots of board games too. and you'll see a version of that on the left if you haven't seen it in real life it's all the way back and to the left in the children's room for our teens we continued to focus on what they told us they wanted most which was a welcoming space to simply be themselves spend time with friends and engage at their own pace some highlights from this year included we completed the teen room refresh the teen room being directly opposite from here we got new carpeting furniture and technology all thanks to a generous grant from York wise and what you see on the screen is our ribbon cutting we hosted a prom closet where people donated gently used and often brand new with tags on prom dresses for those who otherwise not might not be able to afford them on their own or to go to prom 30 area teens found their gowns at the library we hosted creative programs like establishing indoor herb gardens and creating and hosting a life-size candy land game we started last fiscal year off with a brand new head of youth services who came to us from an emergency an emergency came to us from an elementary school teacher background her it was an emergency because we were without one for quite some time before we found her arrival marked the first time the department was fully staffed in nearly a year drawing on her school background we reached out to and worked with the schools to set expectations across the board meaning the same rules apply here and held an on their own open house to support middle school transitions. For the younger set, we had new weekly programs including Little Movers and Budding Builders, the creation of a maker's den for the younger kids for hands-on creativity and exploration. That's over in the craft area of the children's room. We've had record-breaking story times. You see one of them there on the left. And in the picture in the corner, lower corner, you will see our library of things for youth services they include things you can check out like board games puzzles stem kits and yodos which are not something I'd heard of until fairly recently but they're screen free audiobook devices that are hugely popular and these were funded by a grant from altruism of the seacoast summer reading last year got off to a fantastic start with our plant a seed read theme and a country fair complete with ski ball face painting photo ops and even baby goats beans and blueberry were the names of the goats that you see in the pictures they were a huge hit participation broke records we had over 700 people who registered across all age groups for adult programming those programs reflected our commitment to civic engagement lifelong learning and community wellness highlights included a reprise of last may's mental wellness month where we held a series of programs for example we partnered with cornerstone vna for healthy ways to manage stress with the main prevention network for a program on healthy teens for parents guardians caregivers and community members and thanks in part to the york rotary club we were able to create 300 mental health kits for teens and tweens which were then distributed at both the high and middle schools we held our third annual dan bancroft lecture series on civic engagement and leadership we hosted main journalist cullen woodard who is a pulitzer nominee who is known for among other things his books on regional cultures, going back to our founding fathers and how these cultures have shaped the political landscape through the centuries. We also launched a cookbook club, which has been very popular, where people will take recipes out of the same cookbook and then they'll all make whatever they're gonna make and they bring it in and it's kind of just a little, we do it for lunchtime, but that's been very popular. particular. The aforementioned AI program series touched on using it for graphic design, using chat bots, and also identifying its risks, benefits, and responsibilities. We introduced new membership benefits. I think most of you know the library is owned and governed by the York Public Library Association. Each year we have an annual membership appeal. some of you have probably received your mailing in your box already there are various levels of supporting membership and being a supporting member has its benefits it includes perks like decals special communications and depending on the level of giving there are sometimes free tickets to things most recently it launched we did this when we launched our annual lighthouses and legends donor appreciation event this year for the second year we actually added on we sold tickets to it as well so that turned into a fundraiser mini golf continues to be very successful this past year it was the third year and it had our highest attendance and revenue new a generous donation of seed money also afforded us the debut of more ypl merch we have water bottles bumper stickers t-shirts note cards and you may be surprised to learn that december marks the 25th anniversary of us being in this building so this past summer we launched to 25 years strong initiative to help pay for critical building maintenance ongoing stewardship building efficiency upgrades expanded programming and collections and for our endowment to help build long-term financial resilience we've been very fortunate to partner with a number of organizations see some of them there and to ensure our house is in good financial working order We have annual audits regularly. Our fiscal 26 audit is currently in progress. Our annual reports, financials, and 990 filings can all be found on our website. We have internal financial control processes and procedures in place. We have restricted endowments, and these can only be spent on certain things. For example, we have one that can only be spent on youth services. WE ALSO HAVE AN INVESTMENT FUND THAT FUNCTIONS AS OUR RESERVE AND TO BE USED FOR EMERGENCIES AND WE HAVE RAMPED UP OUR FUNDRAISING WITH THE 25 YEARS STRONG INITIATIVE. SINCE THIS WAS THE BUDGET COMMITTEE I THOUGHT IT WOULD BE FITTING TO SHOW A RETURN ON INVESTMENT. THIS CALCULATOR IS BASED ON ONE THAT THE MASS BOARD OF LIBRARY COMMISSIONERS CREATED AND which has been amended for use by states across the country. So for the last several years, we have averaged about 100,000 people coming through our doors each year. Last year, those people checked out over 78,000 books. They downloaded nearly 14,000 audio or eBooks. They booked our meeting rooms 425 times. Another 41,000 didn't have to buy a cup of coffee in order to use the Wi-Fi for as long as they wanted, except for that one early release day when the tidal wave of 160 kids, yes, we counted, overloaded our Wi-Fi. Another 4,900 have sat down at our computers, and we've had 16,000 attendees for our programs. And all of this comes up to an average retail value of over $2.5 million. dollars and this doesn't include things like databases and I have a happy thing here databases quiet study space we have downloadable magazines thousands of titles we have one-on-one technology help there are lots of things and that means that for every dollar York invested in its community it received a dollar and 79 cents in goods and services this was a comment that someone had made about the library we talk a lot in this town about wanting to preserve what makes your special the small town feel the local character the sense that neighbors still know each other the library is where that actually lives so thanks for investing in your library and for making it be the place for all to learn connect and belong so that's what i have for that i know typically this is the time when we it's been like an informal meet and greet and just kind of is there anything on the horizon that is unexpected no we're in the process of doing our budget we have a working But it hasn't gone through the vetting process yet of our Finance Committee, who will then forward it to the Board for their approval, who will then pass it on to you and the town. Do you have any questions I could answer hopefully i'm [52:17] Speaker J (unidentified): here at least twice a week. my fifth grader loves lisa's corner was it did i get the right space yes it's fantastic it's a great spot and it is it's vibrant it's colorful i'm seeing good behavior [52:32] Speaker I (unidentified): whichever yes okay so it's that school teacher that former school teacher who's now our head of youth services we set some boundaries and the kids abide by them so i love that value of [52:45] Speaker G (unidentified): services calculation that's so impactful just in being able to put numbers i remember seeing the numbers of people right last year in your reports of who comes through the door but really quantifying that value of services using a you know it sounds like a pretty widely used model it's quite a number and i think there's a lot that's not in there as you noted yeah [53:09] Chair: yeah thank you all right thanks thank you thank you all right at this point we would like to invite Taylor and the climate action committee to come on up to the table please make sure that you introduce yourselves and be helpful good [53:34] Taylor McGuire: evening thanks for having me I'm Taylor McGuire the environmental planner for the town good [53:40] Richard Rannigan: evening my name is Susan Covino and I'm a member of the climate Action Committee. [53:46] Taylor McGuire: So we're here to talk to you tonight about a recent proposal coming from the Climate Action Committee concerning some changes to the Sustainability Fund, or proposed changes to the Sustainability Fund. Can you put your microphone just a little closer? Because you're a little soft-spoken, I just want to make sure people can hear you. Thank you. So to give you some background and history on the Sustainability Fund, back in 2018, a one-time expenditure of $200,000 was voted in to create the fund. Since then, that fund has been used as the primary source for all of our climate action plan goals and accomplishments several projects also adjacent to give you a little bit of an idea of some of the projects that have covered from this fund prior to the climate action committee was the energy steering committee they worked on the led streetlight project which was implemented in 2020 20 and so far has saved taxpayers just over half a million dollars more recently we have just wrapped up a solar project on york village fire department it's estimated to save seven thousand four hundred dollars just this year alone and within going back to the net system cost that seven years it's estimated to provide over two hundred and ninety five thousand dollars in electric offset set to the town. So currently we are down to $21,632 in that fund. The way the fund functions is a little bit more like a grant. There's the select board policy for how they're going to expend it, and then there's also the application process. I see it functions more like a grant because that application requires a timeline, a budget, any kind of quotes, and then working DEEPLY WITH MY POSITION TO ENSURE THAT IT, YOU KNOW, ALL THE PARAMETERS ARE SORT OF COVERED BEFORE IT EVEN GETS PRESENTED TO THE SELECT BOARD FOR THEM TO DECIDE WHETHER TO EXPEND THOSE FUNDS. AGAIN, ONCE THAT 21,000 THAT WE'RE CURRENTLY DOWN TO IS USED UP, THAT'S IT. IT DOESN'T FUNCTION THE SAME WAY A COMMITTEE BUDGET OR ANOTHER TOWN REVOLVING FUND WOULD. AND SO OUR PROPOSAL IS TO CHANGE THAT. There are 142 goals or projects within the climate action plan that were voted in from the voters and without adequate resources, none of those projects are actually going to happen. So far all of the sustainability projects that have come out of my department have been solely funded from grants or the sustainability fund. So, we're proposing that this new FY2728, we would start with an amount of $200,000. And then as a result of funding certain projects, we would capture any saved revenue from those projects and put it back into the fund. Anything accrued from any prior fiscal year for those projects. So, for example, if we're saving the $7,400 this year from the fire department, that would then go back into the fund the following year. We don't foresee that making up the difference of any expended funds towards a project. Certainly a solar installation is going to cost significantly more than seven grand. But we are also saying that we should have a cap on that $200,000 to ensure that we're we're never going over the amount in that fund, just as kind of a trust with some of our taxpayers, that way they know that we're trying to be fiscally responsive with a lot of their tax dollars, but also ensuring that we're getting a monetary return. It's not just other benefits from these projects that we're looking to have, we're also looking for that monetary gain. [57:33] Chair: So there's an incentive for the projects to pay themselves back. Absolutely. [57:38] Speaker H (unidentified): But it's also just that first year? it's not like recurring years for the savings it's the first year savings no we're accumulative [57:47] Taylor McGuire: so any years prior we would put those savings towards the fund but then that's why there's that 200 cap so if far down the line for example you know five years from now if we don't have many other projects that are expending out we're still going to capture that solar for example and it's going to be that savings would be more than five years worth of the seven grand trying to do the math in my head explain it i didn't do that example well but we're trying to capture the savings from all the projects that we're [58:19] Speaker F (unidentified): spending the fund on so you'd like to use the savings to build that fund back up you're not planning on asking the taxpayers to bring that back to 200 right and so that's that's designed [58:32] Taylor McGuire: again the way the fund is currently set up we have to go to a vote every single time to ask for new expenditure so instead of doing that we're trying to come up with a way to structure this fund so that the fund builds itself back up we're not constantly having to come back to taxpayers to ask for more money especially when we're trying to focus on projects that will save them money in [58:50] Chair: the long term so when you say the savings I'm assuming you're looking at the net cost so after you we've paid for so like the lights for example you mentioned that we did we've got five hundred about five hundred thousand dollars in savings that's after the lights have been paid for is that correct yes okay just want to make sure [59:15] Taylor McGuire: we have already had a couple conversations with the town manager on how exactly that capture would work and we're still in various conversations with the finance director as well we wanted to present to you and receive your feedback and hear some discussion before we presented to the select board because our specialty here we want to make sure that we're funding climate projects, we don't know what is the best structure to move forward for the town. [59:40] Speaker F (unidentified): So that's one of my immediate concerns is, if your goal, and I'm not sure exactly what your committee charter dictates is your goal, but if all of a sudden you're motivated to do something that might not be the number one best thing you can do for the climate, but man, it's gonna help build that fund back up, all of a sudden you might be doing this instead of that. And I understand that what's really motivating the voters is the tax savings, like we all love the birds and the trees and all the things in town, but ultimately pushing the savings forward is what really is gonna get their attention. But then all of a sudden, with you guys as a committee, if you're letting this financial obligation to build the fund back up steer your motivation, then that seems counterproductive to a certain extent. [1:00:29] Taylor McGuire: Sure, you bring up a great point. So this would just be to change the structure of the fund and how our next fiscal year starts to make it more of a revolving fund. We would still be adhering to the sustainability fund policy itself, which is geared towards the goals in the climate action plan. It's not any superfluous projects outside of that or projects only aimed at a monetary goal. It's projects specifically that are covered in the climate action plan that were voted on and coming out of the climate action committee with all our different public engagement and support towards those climate projects. [1:01:03] Speaker G (unidentified): Of the 142 projects, do you have a ballpark as to how many would produce measurable savings if implemented? [1:01:15] Taylor McGuire: So there are 142, I should say, projects and goals, action items. Some of them don't have great metrics on them. If you're reading the climate action plan, some of it just says improve this or conserve land, and that can get there are too many variables to be able to put that number on there okay do [1:01:41] Speaker H (unidentified): you know how you would be measuring you know the cost savings like how does that process happen [1:01:48] Taylor McGuire: yeah so for you mean moving forward or kind of some of the numbers that i came up with here [1:01:55] Speaker H (unidentified): well that just like if the idea is to sustain it like how do you decide the number that you save [1:02:01] Taylor McGuire: to put back in the fund sure so for example we've been looking at the past year of our electric bills for the fire station and coming up with what that average looks like what are we actually spending in kilowatt hour and then what is that current cost of kilowatt hour obviously is costs increase in the future that number is going to fluctuate and so it's it's just really trying to look at the cost that we would have saved as direct as we possibly can so I [1:02:31] Chair: guess that would is where my question came in from before so let's say that we spent I'm gonna throw totally fake numbers out there okay we spent a hundred thousand dollars on the solar at York Village fire and we 're still paying for that right so really the real cost of that solar panel is something like at the end of the life $130,000 of that solar panel because we've bonded it and it's going to be useful for 20 years right so we're Bond this might be under a 10 a 20-year Bond my question would be how would you calculate the savings if we're still paying for that item [1:03:10] Taylor McGuire: in a bond have you guys thought about that at all so that's why we want to start with the 200 000 it wouldn't be bonded at all so this current project we were I don't have the number off the top of my head it was 163 that was left in the fund and then the actual cost of this solar project was 70 all parts 79 80 000 and so it's there was money already in the fund and we just directly paid for it so we already own those panels any of the savings is just going well right now it's just not being spent by taxpayers we've just saved money but ideally we'd like it [1:03:45] Chair: to go back into the fund for more projects right now it's going back into the general fund or into the from via the operating budget of the department under which under whom is receiving right no not necessarily because if they've got less $200 less a month and their electric bill they're spending it on other things it's not so you know if the fire department is saving 200 bucks a month from CMP what we don't see is the we're that 200 we can't follow those $200 right and so it may seem like we're getting the savings but what ends up happening is then the fire department has a 2400 surplus at the end of the year because they didn't expect the electric bill to be that low and then that 2400 because it's unspent goes into the general fund yeah so those who just dictate it go back and right so i think this is a different path [1:04:36] Speaker G (unidentified): further future investment up to the cap yeah right and that was a suggestion from the [1:04:41] Taylor McGuire: town manager as well as sort of wait for you know the excess at the end of the year and then whatever's left not to obviously exceed whatever the project was if they just did really well that year but that would go back into the sustainability fund so i we're very open to how it would actually flow through the structure of it so if i heard you just right let me repeat [1:05:03] Chair: it so in my fake case of the hundred thousand dollar solar panels that you paid for in cash and we are saving $200 a month which at the end of the fiscal year comes to $2,400 but -oh the fire department actually spent those $2,400 does that mean that then you don't get that the it [1:05:23] Taylor McGuire: wouldn't go into the fund that was something suggested it's not my preference yeah I guess [1:05:30] Speaker H (unidentified): I would I would suggest being really concrete around how you're calculating that because I think it can probably vary like that's an example that you can pretty exactly calculate it but like i imagine with the other examples maybe there isn't as straightforward a way and that would be my concern is like the whole idea is that you're trying to fund this and that oops there's where did this go went to this and then like if it's not really clearly spelled out there's no obligation to then put it back in so it may not function the way you're i do think though there's [1:06:03] Speaker G (unidentified): an element of yeah the other side of it i think is it could help instill some discipline right around how we measure some of the results right in the return that's that's sort of where i'm [1:06:14] Richard Rannigan: coming from i have no finance background i'm an energy expert but not finance and i what i'm seeing is a positive out of this is our finance department and you know we make the decision based on perspective what we think the savings are going to be i'd like to see some clear as we had with the led street lights some clear this is how we're accounting for it 's laid out anyone one of you can look at it and say yep got it and i'm afraid otherwise it might be missing it'll just as you say go it goes into the rose or something you can't follow [1:06:56] Speaker H (unidentified): it yeah because that's been one of our like recurring issues of like what happened to the extra money that we never that was a cause you know like anything that we recognize the next year we've asked for like oh let's see the benefit but then like we talked about it great where's that money you don't you just [1:07:14] Chair: reinvest it into the department as opposed to reinvest it into the climate [1:07:17] Speaker G (unidentified): initiative I like the concept I do think yeah figuring out some of the accounting and the motor is gonna be a little tricky that I do think the devils in the details a little bit on that but yeah i overall i think the concept makes a lot of sense and i think the town will benefit a lot from continued investment and the clarity of what [1:07:39] Speaker A (unidentified): you all are trying to do you have a list right now of things that you have accomplished like that [1:07:45] Taylor McGuire: we can see and the cost i do have a memo i pardon me did it okay yeah oh and that list i mean it breaks down so the big ones that we put in there where the led street lights are significantly that's our most significant savings in our project that we've had so far and then it also covers the reason the sustainability fund was sort of invented it was put on some pressure from some students they really wanted to have dishwashers and reusable silverware in the cafeteria so that's how the whole push to create it happened so i want to [1:08:18] Chair: go back to my fire station question again so let's say we save twenty four hundred dollars the first year would your initiative take that twenty four hundred dollars and move it into the climate action fund or is that what you're imagining yes okay and then what happens in year two when it's twenty seven hundred dollars we would [1:08:39] Taylor McGuire: still love for that to go back into the fund okay with a cap though yeah I think [1:08:46] Chair: one of my curiosities would be does it because as a taxpayer I'm thinking well we're saving money but one could argue that okay now my $2,400 is just going to something else it's not actually being saved so one thing you might want to consider is there a sunset right like after five years or seven years like because we just expect that this is now how we do business right I realize you're looking for savings that will help to replenish and I think there's an important balance of what Courtney said which is getting the department head on board to be able to get to demonstrate the cost savings but to also give back to your fund so that might be something else to think about us like proportionally how might that work and maybe even talk to some department heads and see you know what are they what would they feel comfortable with and because I do think you know they're gonna bring some of these things they're going to sponsor them with you and want to be able to demonstrate those savings but then if the savings go to a hundred percent of the savings forever go into this one fund that might be less attractive to them let's say maybe a split the difference kind of deal [1:09:59] Speaker J (unidentified): after a certain amount or something like that i do like the idea that 200 000 is you know our fund so we're not looking for more than that ever but to everyone else's point i think yeah like a five-year, you know, 50%, 40, 30, 20, 10, done. It's probably something like that. [1:10:16] Chair: Yeah, because the other thing, too, about putting the cap on the $200,000 is that might inequitably hit certain projects, right? So let's say the fire department is the first one that does this, and then the police department put $100,000 of solar panels, and there's so much savings from all the other things that then the police department doesn't actually have to put their money in the fund because the fund is already at two hundred thousand dollars so I think that might be another thing you want to think about is like in five years what might it look like and will there always be room for that two hundred thousand dollars or will some of the savings be significant enough that there will be a cap and then those savings really just go back into the general fund so I think you may want to think ahead about how much of the money do you want to follow for how long do you want to follow it and what happens if there's a detour if [1:11:12] Taylor McGuire: that makes any sense yeah absolutely just to hear there were kind of several ideas that you bounced around I'd love to hear some further discussion from you all about whether you'd prefer you know just a sunset in five years let's say or you know the decrease of percentage 50% 40% 30% etc and what I mean what do you think of appeals or makes the most sense from a budget I think it would be [1:11:36] Chair: be really smart to put together an estimate of ten projects and model it [1:11:41] Speaker G (unidentified): out both ways because might be different types for different projects right it's hard you know not knowing all the different types of work it could be different types of revenue streams right or triggers so it might yeah be more [1:11:53] Chair: than one way to or a much higher ROI on a certain kind of project where another one might only just be you know qualitative and if it's down to 20,000 [1:12:02] Speaker F (unidentified): and there might need to be some more cash that gets set aside for them too. Who owns the solar panels on the roof of the fire station? The town. So you bought them? [1:12:15] Taylor McGuire: Outright from the sustainability fund. [1:12:17] Speaker F (unidentified): As a representative of the town and the town has owned them the whole time, it's not like you bought it and gifted it? [1:12:24] Taylor McGuire: I'm speaking directly to the project that just happened this past June on the village fire, the ones at the beach. which I think we own those as well, actually. [1:12:33] Speaker F (unidentified): The town, we as in the town. And so just as far as, I used to hate being this guy. Now I don't really mind being that guy, but as far as the ongoing maintenance, putting solar panels on a roof near the ocean, here you are, here's this wonderful thing. Give us the money, the savings that this is offering you and the taxpayers. By the way, you need to replace this piece. you know and then all of a sudden that goes back to being on the taxpayers dime when they're not necessarily like yes I understand that refunding the fund you know does save the taxpayers money in a certain instance but some of these bigger projects like you know they say LEDs last 20 years they don't when these need to start getting replaced it's you know where do the maintenance costs and I'm not asking for an answer now but I just I think that 's an important part of the discussion as well as some of these bigger projects how is the maintenance gonna get handled if you guys are you know because again it's the taxpayers like they want the cost savings you know they want the cost savings probably more than you do you know they want that going back to them or they want the money not being spent and so then saying okay we're going to take all of your realized savings on this and by the way the warranty expires in november you know is going to need to be addressed we are looking at this fund as [1:13:55] Taylor McGuire: maintenance for ongoing projects as well and that includes the panels that are on [1:14:00] Speaker H (unidentified): the elementary school arena that's great when you guys asked for the 200,000 that I'm assuming that calculated that in some way or how do you why cap it I guess like what it what if there are bigger projects or like you know it [1:14:18] Taylor McGuire: certainly doesn't need a cap I mean if you told me sky's the limit I could come up with lots of projects to do it's more an assurance to give the taxpayers that like you said we're not trying to take all of the savings we're hoping that many of the projects we do will add more money into the general fund and just kind of giving them an assurance that we're focused it's it's a small enough it's a large enough budget to do several projects [1:14:44] Richard Rannigan: but it's a small enough budget that we're not going it allows us also to be opportunistic if an opportunity comes along or a need comes along that we didn't anticipate it seems to you know the budget cycle is so blessed long to have access to those funds and don't forget we're advisors at the Climate Action Committee the Select Board is the ultimate decider of whether the project goes forward or not period but it does give us a certain amount of flexibility and I don't think it's an outlandish number because it's got some history here the high school kids wanted to have or all the students wanted to have proper dishes and silverware so that amount of money was set aside to do that so seems like it's in within the [1:15:36] Taylor McGuire: realm of reason part of the application as well for this for the funds the policy states that the select board can grant the full asking amount or reduce it if they see fit as well. [1:15:52] Chair: One thing that we've started our capital meetings and one of the things that I have continued to ask about is when we are making large purchases, it be a fire truck, it could be a mower, it could be something, what are the operational savings and how are those being taken into account and like the Parks and Rec Department a big fun surprise is considering robot mowers for their fields and so I'm not sure that necessarily actually saves it might say fossil fuels I'm not sure if it actually saves energy because you've got to get the energy from somewhere but one question i have continued to ask is like what does that do to the operations of the department and if there are initiatives like a mowing robot that you were to bring or the parks department were to bring to you i think also thinking about what are the not to necessarily capture to give back but to be really clear about savings in the people budget and the overhead of that specific line of business because like in the parks example the idea is that it actually the equipment is maybe more expensive but it means that there are three people who can do other jobs because they're not on a mower eight hours a day and so what kind of savings and what kind of opportunities could come our way if there are you know operational things that will change with these initiatives that could improve services and potentially lower costs in the long run for the taxpayer. [1:17:48] Taylor McGuire: I do think that's a little bit, too many variables are a little bit more intangible to try and capture those costs directly. But I mean, it's certainly part of a bigger conversation where from a sustainability side, we talk a lot about the cost, life cycle cost of the equipment. Again, how long are these panels actually running? What does it take to look like to dispose of them properly at their end of life? So that's certainly part of the conversation. Yeah, what so do you have you have an app that you mentioned you have an application? [1:18:17] Chair: Is that what how it works? So like I'm the fire chief. I want solar panels. What how who do I go to? [1:18:22] Taylor McGuire: What do I do? So anyone can submit this it's open to the public Again, it functions a little bit more like a grant a municipal grant you summarize your project budget timeline And then kind of write out your deliverables theoretically you would be working closely with me so that i can help point out some issues as i also do the all the lead grant writing for the town and then we present it to the select board and if they think that it's a good expenditure of the money then we move forward got it so the high [1:18:53] Chair: school for example could come could come to you and say we're seeing a lot of teslas in the parking lot we'd like to put in electric charging stations and if that were a project that the select board prioritized, then they could authorize money out of this fund in order to pay for those electric charging stations. [1:19:11] Taylor McGuire: Correct, yep. Anyone in the town of York can apply for this. The only stipulation is that whatever the project is has to have some wider benefit. Obviously it can't be an individual that wants to have an energy retrofit on your own personal home. That's not gonna benefit taxpayers as a whole. [1:19:34] Chair: if these actions don't get funded by the savings account how do they get funded [1:19:47] Taylor McGuire: well that's what we're asking for so to go up to 200,000 to start the fund off with the new fiscal year and then for it to be almost like a committee fund to have it be a revolving aspect where at the end of the year whatever's left can go back to the general fund and then we'd start over with that [1:20:03] Chair: 200 but you said at the beginning you have 142 action items that were voted in the climate action plan yes and 21 000 left and 21 000 left so if you weren't to get this fund what happens to number one on the 142 list if it's under 21 if it's over 21 000 it doesn't get done [1:20:24] Taylor McGuire: okay so whose budget does this belong in this is just i believe it's directly under the sustainability or under the select board it does not belong to any department as i mentioned before all of the projects that i've pushed forward have come from grant money and so it's been it's been a lot slower of progress in trying to accomplish those goals than i had hoped in starting this position because we don't have any dedicated funding source towards these climate action [1:20:54] Chair: plans right so if i'm the police chief and i think let's i'm we're in a good place to put solar panels on the police station I can either go to bat for that with the voters as a capital item right or I could come to this fund and say hey you've got money in the fund could you help fund our panels right so it would potentially be capital items that would go through the capital process that are then assigned to that department right so if it's at the police station it looks like a police capital item it isn't necessarily part of the climate action [1:21:29] Taylor McGuire: plan as a capital item. Correct. And that's the problem with a lot of these goals is they span so many different departments in so many different areas. And it goes to what Susan mentioned earlier. If something arises where, for example, there's a tax credit or a company has a big sale or something like that where we want to move, we have the money available in the sustainability fund, but it's not set aside in the capital budget. We still want to be able to seize that [1:21:57] Speaker C (unidentified): opportunity yeah do you have any sense of how other municipalities sort of situate initiatives like yours you know like where do they live in different [1:22:09] Taylor McGuire: towns you know that Kittery has a fund and it does live in their planning department okay Portland has a fund they have their own sustainability department that it lives in from towns that I've seen across Maine it's hard to do a one-to-one comparison because it's they seem to structure their sustainability and environmental efforts differently throughout different departments i'd fall under planning so [1:22:33] Chair: so if we were really serious about these 142 items and the town decided that this two hundred thousand dollars is not necessarily enough there could be a separate budget under or part of the planning department could add a hundred or two hundred thousand dollars into their budget a year and then have that money come out of the planning budget is what you're saying [1:23:01] Taylor McGuire: there are other municipalities are potentially doing yeah i just in general the way environmental funds work in other municipalities is completely different i don't know anyone that has the same structure that we do and i think that's because frankly it's an inefficient structure to getting things done. [1:23:19] Chair: I think that's the point I'm trying to make. Yeah, me too. [1:23:22] Speaker C (unidentified): Thank you for making it. I was like, this seems like a lot of runaround for you just to do like bullet point number three or whatever. You know, it feels like it shouldn't be this hard. [1:23:31] Chair: We have 142 action items that were voted on by the town in the climate action plan, and there's been no money dedicated to it. So it doesn't seem like we're very serious if we're not putting money in the budget, in the operations budget, which is repeating every year to be able to reach these goals so I commend you for coming to us with the fund and I think it's a bigger conversation of why is there not a budget for these for these items in the you know in the town budget somewhere even if we start small right like maybe it's $20,000 this year and it's $30,000 next year at least it would be something and that's I mean [1:24:15] Taylor McGuire: that's really our ultimate goal here. We're not firmly attached to this idea of the sustainability fund. We're just trying to accomplish those goals in the climate action plan. So if we decide that this is not a great idea and we're just gonna use up that remaining 21,000 and then sort of let the sustainability fund itself die a little death there, then as long as we're adding something to the operational budget for it, we're happy. [1:24:40] Speaker G (unidentified): How many overall projects have you been able to fund out of that $200,000 so far? And then how much outside grant money have you been able to secure? Estimates, trying to understand. [1:24:54] Taylor McGuire: I believe since its inception there have been six projects. I do know that there were four applications last year that did not get funded. And, you know, I'm not going to speak for the select board on that, But I think one of the hesitancies and approving projects for it is because once the money's gone, it's gone So there's so much more pressure in deciding. Is this a good expenditure for these funds or you know Since it's not gonna the funds not gonna polish next year. We don't have any kind of capturing method It's just better to say no as a safe [1:25:28] Chair: How much of the funds are you using for matching? [1:25:31] Taylor McGuire: Right now we haven't had any matching grants at all grant money that was the other I forgot to address that I've had rough number I think it's a hundred and I've gotten almost half a million dollars in grants [1:25:51] Speaker H (unidentified): since I've started Wow congratulations thank you this is what I think we've heard repeatedly that you are super helpful in all of these ways and almost consulting to the different departments in a really helpful way so I was wondering about your role in like how often do you consult on any of these projects that we're doing and like maybe applying some of the money to like make current projects that we're doing more climate friendly or you know like kind of be like incentivize the projects that are needed to be more like have matching or even your consulting expertise on how to go about doing those things like would seem really helpful [1:26:44] Taylor McGuire: yeah both myself and all the committees that i am staff liaison for we try to do our best to butt our heads into places and try to make suggestions so right now with trash automation the recycling committee is doing a lot of work around that yeah another Roy Sieber another member of our climate action committee he is also on the committee for the community center official name of that but to try and make it be a net-zero building as much as we can yeah when the when the town [1:27:18] Richard Rannigan: hall was renovated and expanded we had one of our members was attending all of their meetings as well trying to bring to bear the expertise and the information that person had about our climate action plan so we're doing our best that's great [1:27:36] Speaker H (unidentified): and we hear that's i think that's what we wanted you guys to come because we keep hearing about all the ways in which you're impacting and all these good ways and it was good to hear [1:27:44] Speaker C (unidentified): directly from you i also feel like the fact that we're talking about this in the context of like the planning department budget like this has been a space that you know they're self-funding We've raised concerns before about having like really cheap permits because we don't want to bring in too much revenue This seems like a really good use. Oh, yeah extra revenue You know to have like some budget set aside You know within the planning department because you know, they are running like net zero, right? [1:28:12] Chair: Yeah, like what are them like if it's new construction would apply yeah, right the details yeah [1:28:24] Speaker F (unidentified): code and planning aren't one in the same oh that's true yeah they're just like [1:28:28] Speaker C (unidentified): come together any [1:28:34] Chair: other questions thank [1:28:37] Richard Rannigan: you for coming yeah thank you so much for having us thank you for your feedback really [1:28:40] Chair: appreciate it thank you thank you all right who went first last month all right All right, well, would you like to go first, Chris, since you sent your email before Adam did? [1:28:59] Speaker A (unidentified): All right, so the September school liaison report, we met on the 14th, there was Mike, myself, Rick, and Meg. The approved budget information is all there. Student enrollment to date is 14.55. At 25% of the year, 16% is spent, very much in line with other years prior years there's a new athletic director at the high school david mcguckin did mike was going to meet him did you meet him open to open to school consolidation we really don't have any updates it's basically what we talked about last month they there were some ideas about the cost of a two of a three school option as opposed to a two school so we talked about that for just a little bit and really some of these thoughts were more in the community about there being a disadvantage to the two school plan for the wide range of students and ages in both buildings no room to expand the high school and middle school without major costs upcoming and little flexibility for unknown requirements future ai might bring into the mix still unknown when they might be moving students up to the high school still having a question about the buildings if we were when that happens but that's all part of the consolidation plan so then I just mentioned the capital projects that were completed the science rooms are done the there were a couple of the HVAC and the windows that are going to be for next year and the vest fields being worked on by parks and rec for now so that they'll be ready in the spring [1:30:52] Speaker J (unidentified): to be worked up jumping quickly that was completed this past week oh good i haven't i tried to get up there but there was a ton of soccer going on so i left them alone but the vest fields are done they did them in three days the trail was thrilled with the big and the construction and says there's leftover money to maybe now be able to do some of the dugout work and things like that So I'm really thankful that everyone worked together sensibly to get this done in the fall when you're supposed to get it done. Fronted the money, so to speak, so that we didn't let bureaucracy get in the way of the kids, so I'm really thrilled about all of that. [1:31:36] Speaker A (unidentified): And then Mike, you can talk about the other questions we had that I put in here, just like the cheerleading and the idea that we don't have those things. [1:31:44] Speaker J (unidentified): That was one of the reasons I wanted to possibly meet with the athletic director is just there's a lot of things going on in the town, a lot of questions, and just would love to get his perspective on what he's looking for going forward, transportation, et cetera. Youth cheerleading is taking off. There's huge interest. They're fundraising to try to get at the high school. So what does that look like? How does that get incorporated if possible? you know, what are they looking for to get it into their budget? Is it on their radar, et cetera? So hopefully we'll be able to have some conversations about that. [1:32:20] Speaker A (unidentified): Okay, and again, some of this was just repetitive from last month as to what the priorities are with capital and such. The capital plan has not been updated since last month. No funds from the reserve accounts have been utilized. To date, contract negotiations have started. with the bargaining units and the auditor's briefing for fy25 is on the business office website at this point and that's pretty much the wrap okay any questions that i might help be able to answer or mike i [1:33:09] Chair: just want to add that the school presented their capital to their committee, to the school committee last Wednesday. Neil, the new head of facilities, just was such a breath of fresh air. I know he'll be presenting to us, but I did sit through a lot of that, and all of the capital that they are presenting this year is in preparation for school consolidation and are things that need to be done that are not that are many of which have been on the table for a while delayed projects so we'll be seeing more of that in January great thanks I was just [1:33:55] Speaker G (unidentified): noticing too on that I think this capital in the attachment I think this [1:34:00] Speaker A (unidentified): is the old capital plan yes it wasn't updated from last month have them remove [1:34:05] Speaker G (unidentified): it please yeah I would I would remove it until the new one is approved and okay. Because it's confusing, there's so many versions that are out there that. [1:34:17] Chair: And this looks like a legal version and it's not. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, that'd be helpful. All right. [1:34:31] Speaker F (unidentified): Okay, thanks. You're welcome. Adam, are you up? I suppose I am. [1:34:40] Speaker C (unidentified): Adam, our warrior. I have not been able to make the liaison meetings mostly. We're talking about changing the day. So Adam is our hero. [1:34:47] Speaker F (unidentified): So yes Wendy and I and nobody else met last week no and it is you know all in all status quo with the town you know there isn't anything that is too far out of whack at this point there's some miscellaneous revenue starting to pour in which looks like it's on the revenue side of I think it looks like something more, but we were just down in the negatives last year due to having to refund things, and it's really nothing to write home about. Parking ticket revenue is up. It's been up. You know, I'd rather have it come in through meter funds than ticket revenue myself, but, you know, it is up. It is coming in. What that shows is that the system is working. You know, it's just a positive sign. Rural roads comes in once a year, And so that's why that's so far down now. It's a one-time payment. One of the things that did jump out to me, and we'll transition to the other one, as far as revenue goes, I mean, that's really all the outliers for me. But if we transfer over to expenditures, the one that jumped out to me is that York Ambulance funding is down for this year. We're at 8.3%, whereas last year we were significantly higher that is timing of a payment we've prepaid that you know and it just it hadn't posted by the time when this report was generated you know Wendy is accounting for some of the things that are funded by code fees a little bit differently this year so we should see less peaks and valleys and some of the funds you know some of the money that's that's going to the to the assessor's office and funding GIS is getting moved in on a monthly basis now. Read through my report. Then also next month we'll see a good bump. The tax payments weren't due until September 25th this year. So we don't have a very good working number on the taxes that were coming in as far as property tax goes, but next month we should see a substantial bump in that. Any questions? Okay. Easy with the town stuff this time of year. Yeah. It doesn't come off the rails yet. [1:37:27] Chair: All right, let's move on to, I sent everybody the FY28. I just changed the dates. I didn't change anything else. I only changed the file name to review this narrative that we had from last year. We did make a couple of small changes during our April and May meetings that are incorporated in here, but just wanted to give us a last chance to make any other changes. I will say that in the capital planning process, Courtney and I were very, and Melissa, very happy to see a consistent cover sheet on every project for the capital. So maybe we started a trend here, very exciting. But I didn't have any other changes. [1:38:24] Speaker G (unidentified): I was trying to think back, I think it facilitated some really good dialogue last year. Did we have, going back to your question actually, on operational savings, I guess I'm just trying to think if there's any way to incorporate a question around any operational impacts HACKS BASED ON LARGE PROJECTS THAT MAY HAVE BEEN FUNDED, BUT I'M NOT SURE THAT IS [1:38:55] Chair: PROBABLY MORE CAPITAL RELATED. MAYBE WE ASK ABOUT, DO YOU HAVE ANY CAPITAL ITEMS THAT WILL HAVE AN IMPACT ON YOUR OPERATIONS BUDGET? [1:39:03] Speaker G (unidentified): IN THE FUTURE, BUT IT MIGHT NOT BE FY. [1:39:07] Speaker F (unidentified): ARE WE CREATING FUTURE OBLIGATIONS? [1:39:10] Speaker G (unidentified): more savings yeah so and i think that's where you know that was a really good conversation around the you know the robot mower as you refer to it right which is you know they're going to be saving theoretically 60 hours per week right and so that's a really meaningful saving so just might [1:39:29] Speaker H (unidentified): be a good way to bring that to the forefront i'd also wonder about the question of any environmental market factors like actually asking have you worked directly with the climate action Commission as one of the it's funny include any relevant history that would be helpful for us to know including direct you know consultation with the [1:39:49] Speaker F (unidentified): climate action I always wonder I want to ask what if it's not approved what if your budgets not approved yeah what do you do yeah so I was gonna say I [1:40:02] Speaker J (unidentified): don't want it I don't want to speak for you I feel like you've raised this concerned too in the past of like i feel like we're getting to the point where almost the entire budget increases salary and benefits so i almost feel like do we want to ask them like what percentage of your budget increases salary and benefits and theoretically operationally is your budget actually down because i felt like last year we saw a ton of line items cut to zero yeah and that can't happen again so to speak unless it's actually literally reduced not just capped, you know, I don't know how easy or hard it is for them to calculate that. I don't want to, you know, I figured it would be, but, that's just sort of some of the things I'm thinking about along Adam's line of what are you going to do when it doesn't pass? Like, what are you going to do? Yeah. It does simplify it. [1:40:48] Speaker F (unidentified): And what in your department is impacted if it doesn't pass? I mean, is it somebody's salary or is that a, you know, a service or, yeah. [1:40:57] Speaker J (unidentified): Or FTE, right? Like what's, what's happening? Christmas party. Yeah. [1:41:01] Speaker C (unidentified): Yeah. Yeah. Or we don't get plowing or something. Something that nobody wants to happen. [1:41:06] Speaker H (unidentified): I guess the only issue with that question is there's no holding anybody to that question. You know, like it doesn't, it's kind of out of our control and there's so many factors that go into it that they could theoretically say something and. [1:41:20] Speaker F (unidentified): It's still worth asking though, still worth initiating the conversation, you know. [1:41:23] Speaker H (unidentified): I just wanna like make people aware that theoretically this is what would happen. not it's not in any way a commitment or just because they say that doesn't mean they have to do to do that not that exact thing for sure yeah you know like i think it's yeah but i like intention but it's sometimes for example the whole confusion around what happens if the school and like whose decision is it to sell a school or not sell school and these things being tied to [1:41:58] Speaker C (unidentified): just creates confusion hypothetical conversations versus like these are the numbers and this is what [1:42:04] Speaker G (unidentified): we're talking about yeah i have a question just maybe separate from the narrative actually but i was thinking back to you know some of the some of the contracts that we have we are getting a very simple list by department but the information is not consistent across those and we don't have any insight on, like, what was the contract last year versus what it's this year. No historical trending or change. What's the term of the contract? [1:42:33] Speaker H (unidentified): How often is it negotiated? [1:42:35] Speaker G (unidentified): I feel like that's an area that, and just what's the general purpose? Do we have a, you know, the cleaning service was a conversation last year, right? Of six different cleaning service contracts. so i felt like that was one area where it almost doesn't make sense having it department by department i almost want to see a consolidated contracts list with departments named of [1:43:00] Speaker C (unidentified): course yeah with the relevant department but over time i agree it's hard to parcel out like how much are we spending on janitorial as a town across all the things or whatever yeah right yeah and [1:43:13] Speaker H (unidentified): length of contract like have we been contracting with people for 25 years or is this a new contract like and i really want to know how often it's negotiated because yeah when is it when the [1:43:23] Speaker G (unidentified): contract spikes by 40 or like you know that they don't have any of that no and it's such a huge [1:43:29] Speaker C (unidentified): part of the budgets it's just like this one line it's like contracts and lots of digits you're just like wow that's a lot of things you know it's nice to have a little bit of fine grain detail [1:43:39] Speaker H (unidentified): tail there i agree and it seems like there could be opportunities for combining those things i agree at the contract level when you put them all in one list it's possible that they would notice [1:43:48] Speaker C (unidentified): that would be noticed yeah so yeah i think operationally it gets complicated right but like there might be something that pops out as obvious like oh hey i could go talk to this department and we could get the same person servicing our copier or whatever it is you know but if you don't ever see it you don't see the opportunity you know maybe there isn't but maybe there is, you know, just by organizing an Excel spreadsheet differently, sorting a column. [1:44:13] Speaker G (unidentified): Yeah, a particular department may need a service that we might not even need a new contract. They might just be able to get that. [1:44:19] Chair: Right, like we tried with Logically with the school. Yeah. [1:44:23] Speaker G (unidentified): That one didn't work, but it was a good attempt. Yeah. [1:44:31] Chair: All right. I will incorporate those couple extra questions. I'll clean it up in the morning when my brain is clear and I will ask Wendy about a consistent format around contracts and see if she is able to extract more of that data. It might actually be easier for her to just do a big extraction rather than going department [1:44:53] Speaker C (unidentified): by department. That's right. Can we just have an Excel sheet? [Speaker I (unidentified): Not printed actually.] I just want an Excel sheet. Just want to nerd out on my Excel. I would love that. [1:45:04] Speaker G (unidentified): Someday. if we can get to the digital budgeting process. [1:45:07] Speaker F (unidentified): I've never seen you so excited. Oh my gosh. [1:45:10] Speaker C (unidentified): Even if it's read only. I won't change anything. [1:45:14] Speaker H (unidentified): Do you want me to make you a new one? [1:45:16] Speaker C (unidentified): Yes,. Do we need a new theme? [1:45:21] Chair: Okay, good. Any other, I just wanted to also throw out there, I didn't resend it out, but were there any last thoughts about the calendar and how it was done last year and if there's anything that we want to change yeah [1:45:36] Speaker J (unidentified): well it's my first year but i thought it went really well and we seemed very organized and i liked we had built-in sort of opportunities to meet or not meet so generally i thought it went well i liked having the schools i like the [1:45:50] Speaker G (unidentified): concentration of the town and the schools i do think we should bring back the 15 minutes at the beginning to like talk and think through the last meeting but other than that i think it went as much [1:46:06] Speaker H (unidentified): as possible getting the stuff ahead of time yeah oh yeah that's just yes you know because when you get it ahead of time and then like you review it and then get a new handout right when you walk in and i know that can't be helped in all cases but if at all possible yeah
Unfinished Business
[1:46:23] Chair: i think it is unfair of a department not saying that this happens to hand us a budget and expect I don't expect us to be able to review it in person. Yeah, I know we had some challenges with some of those things last year, but I think we've been getting a little bit better every year. We have, yeah. All right, so the last item on the old business is around the joint select board meeting. I was asked to bring back to the committee what kinds of things we would like to add to that agenda. I think I just heard that climate action funding is one of the things that just mm-hmm I would have added to the list tonight there isn't anything on it you know we've just always met with the select board and we're just trying to make sure that we have a specific agenda a couple of agenda items so that we're we're not just looking at each other. [1:47:24] Speaker C (unidentified): There's always things to talk about, so. [1:47:27] Speaker G (unidentified): Overall capital strategy. There's already a lot of asks coming in and just thinking about how we collectively prioritize and make decisions. Like we had a lot of surprises in that right at the 11th hour last year. [1:47:39] Speaker J (unidentified): Yeah, especially around the schools. [1:47:46] Speaker A (unidentified): Do we have a date for that? No. [1:47:49] Speaker H (unidentified): I wonder if we could brainstorm like joint initiatives or like goals or intentions going into the budget season together of like what's important as an entire group and see if we could actually make some targets for the upcoming budget season just to sort of see if we're all on the same page of what we're all doing like it'd be interesting to have that conversation ambulance [1:48:20] Speaker F (unidentified): could be one of those things [1:48:21] Speaker A (unidentified): i think [1:48:27] Speaker G (unidentified): it's probably enough yeah those are four really big topics yeah [1:48:34] Speaker C (unidentified): great i feel like too just as having a sense of they have like a you know the money at the end of the year that they will sometimes allocate towards particular projects and just getting like a sense of if they're thinking about that at all right because that sometimes takes stuff off the capital table like late in the game which is okay but if there's any like preview insight into what they're thinking about that would be so [1:49:00] Chair: funding of capital projects with yeah contingency or I have like [1:49:07] Speaker C (unidentified): no words today yes the things that are left over there's like leftover money sometimes yeah fund balance yeah is what I'm looking for that is the word there [1:49:22] Chair: it is you guys okay so any other items that we want to talk about so next month we have the water district coming that is the week of Thanksgiving so hopefully we'll be able to keep our meeting pretty short and if I am able to schedule a meeting with the select board I will let everybody know as soon as possible so you can get on your calendar are the tour dates like it all getting [1:49:51] Speaker H (unidentified): solidified too that's a great question my calendar never works because I need [1:49:54] Chair: to know ahead like way ahead of time yeah and so what I have talked about with the school committee chair and the superintendent is to focus specifically on the capital items for this year so doing one visit where we go to any of the facilities that are going to require an upgrade or a change so visit village specifically to look at the refrigerators visit you know the high school specifically to look at the cafeteria visit the middle school to specifically look at the windows if that's what we need to do so rather than been doing a very long and time-intensive school tour really focusing it in on because we spent a lot of time yeah school tours last year and not a whole lot has changed but making sure that we get to see the science wings the science wing and celebrate that and then have the other targeted areas so probably just one afternoon as opposed to two so i will our hope was to do that after they presented the capital which is happening next week and the week after so I would say before December yeah they are in contract [1:51:09] Speaker H (unidentified): negotiations now too yeah it's hard to accommodate so during the day it's a lot [1:51:20] Speaker A (unidentified): yeah all right capital meeting this week right that's the first day of [1:51:29] Chair: school I believe no that's Tuesday that's Tuesday all right friends thank you I will we will go ahead and adjourn it is that clock is not right it is 843 it is not 847 I make a motion to adjourn